Reaction on Kadi Aao Ni and Chadh Chadh Jana | Mai Dhai, Atif Aslam | Ram Sampath | Coke Studio
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 5 ธ.ค. 2021
- I found a strange similarity between these two songs, yet they are soo different! Listen and figure out yourself. Do you agree with my analysis?
Video edited by - Kritik Varshney
This is just a commentary video. All rights belong to the original creators of the song
#indianyoutuber #cokestudioreaction #youtubecreator #cokestudio - เพลง
I too used to take Atif Aslam's singing lightly but when Tajdar-e-Harm came out I felt like I was watching a miracle because such variations in a single song, those pronunciation of Persian and Arabic words and phrases, that confidence of singing, that just made me realise how underrated I had took him. Believe me like Arijit Singh he is a bestowed singer for whole of South Asia.
Yaar Ab maan hi lo ki Atif is one of best👍...
1:27 I don't agree that they've copied or taken an "Indian concept", Mai Dhai is from Tharparkar, Sindh. It is geographically and culturally very close to Rajasthan, the women there dress in bright coloured ghoonghats like both Mai Dhai and the lady in the CS India one. This is in no way a case of "copied" material when both songs are literally just showcasing their culture which are both similar, given that we have a shared history therefore many cultural similarities. On the other hand we have many such examples of where Bollywood has copied Pakistani songs lyric by lyric and tune by tune. This video however was not a very clever attempt of trying to frame CS Pakistan 😶
You r right
Not copied they are two different kind of genre .. just lyrics and vocals sounds rajasthani ..but composition is different..
She s malnourished pakstani she won't get it ..
Marwarri language is spoken in most areas of Sindh Pakistan mostly in "Thar" region which is very near to Indian border.
really, I'm rajasthani and this female singer is from rajasthan the best things is i understand this lyrics , why 1947 partition happen
@@sanataniarmy5340 mai dai ka bachpan Barmer me beeta hai
Pakistan has a large number of audience speaking this language and practicing the same culture. Especially in south panjab and north Sindh. These divided areas are once called Rajasthan. If you look at the timeline of coke studio pakistan on wikipedia there are many songs that use Marwari language. This is not stolen but it is one of Pakistani culture highlighted.
They recorded it atleast 2 months before the release..... It's 100 percent a coincidence
I don't write much, but you deserve to read this, I have had the same feelings about these songs, Indian coke studio sounds so discombobulated regarding the music arrangements, it almost feels like they're trying so hard, I don't know why, on the other hand CS Pakistan is just so well done regarding arrangements, every instrument has its own place complimenting the vocalisations.
P.S. The way you're feeling it, loved it.
I agree. They ruined it by mixing too much modern instruments. Its chaotic. They also ruined Kattey by mixing that rap by hard core. They are trying too hard to repeat the success of Choudhary by mame khan, and its resulting in such mess.
Thanks soo much for sharing.Really enjoyed alot❤️
You are honest in your reaction. And that is your strength.
Thumbs up 👍
Coke studio ka her content original hota hai, singers , songs ki list and rehearsals bht months pehle start ho jati hain, may b Koi leakage hoi ho aur jaldi mein Indian coke studio ne copy kr ke release kiya,.. Ye bat man'ne wali he nhi ke Pakistan coke ne inko copy kiya ho, jab ke indian coke studio ka concept he pakistan coke ki copy hai..
Bilkul
Beautiful reaction !!!!! please keep it on ...... I love the way you react!!!! You have great sense and knowledge about music 🎵🎶....loved it always!!!!
This is one of my favourite reaction channel.. Keep it up 👍🏼
Wow, you actually talked about Rohail's Harvard talk. This tells how much you love music.
U have genuine reaction videos, Super Like. Not like rest all other Reaction videos making fake spell bound faces. U have a proper reason, thinking and real analysis behind every song reaction.
Really enjoyed, keep doing it.
Good to see you appreciating the fine work. ❤️
Your love for music is next level, never seen so mush enthusiasm in any learner ♥️
Love From Pakistan ♥️
Appreciate your reviews ananya, thanks for sharing. I would recommend “kattey” to you because I believe that it highlights the fusion style and ram sampath’s thought, in a better way than “chadh chadh jana”. I get where you’re coming from in this review but I would encourage you to appreciate the difference between the underlying thought in both the presentations.
I admire your journey, taste in music and above all, the fact that you are a fellow SGian (shreya ghoshal fan). Keep singing❤
Explained very beautifully ❤️
Ab jab aapko insta reels pr dekhta hoon to happy happy sa feel hota hai kyuki aap mere vision pr kaam kar ke paise bhi kama rhi ho but at the same time regret bhi hota hai kaash iti courage hoti meri bhi to mai bhi music se mera love share kr pata. Thank you for choosing music critic as a career 🎉❤
So Ma'am finally Atif Aslam made you cheerful ,even being a critic of his Singing you reacted to him.
Thats what Atif Aslam is
None of the songs is copied. Both have separate lyrics and entity. Yes, they may sound similar to the one who is not known to the language used in the song. They are purely folk (traditional) songs. Both songs are well reacted. Keep it up.
Would love to see your reaction on songs: Par Channa De....Uddi Ja.....Ishq Da Kukkar.......Dacchi Waaliya ...... Sawaal Kande Utte
It’s not about the song, it’s about the setting and dress up of the singers which is similar
@@unplugged_ananya Signature setting to coke studio Pakistan ki hai. Many other countries took inspiration from it. So yeah similar ho skti hai. Lakin koi copy bolay usay toh I think it's an insult to this show. I have been following the show from the first song they released and I was like this is the true music why do people follow bullshit music at that time? Then gradually the whole world started to recognise it and I am just so happy to see that.
@@unplugged_ananya if you talk about the setting and concepts then it is the Indian version that has copied the Pakistani variant as with everything in the past 40 years in the field of music. talking about the dress and how the woman is sitting , youtube is filled with hundreds of videos with such setting , that's folk/traditional.
Look at Mai Dhai's other videos from 12 years back , she is sitting like that in all of them.
you're obeservance is good facts are not.
@@unplugged_ananya please make a reaction on , choudhary by mame khan from cock studio india its good one which u feel good
@@unplugged_ananya please make a reaction on , choudhary by mame khan from cock studio india its good one which u feel good
I enjoy listening to your analysis
Ananya mein ne ist time ap k reactions ko suna ap bht smoothly explained krtin or bht acha explained krtin in detail ,ye bat mein ne akser note ki musicians producers Pakistan mein bhi achay hoty hein but i must say k hmary music ko understand or explained ap log zyada acha krty hein in detail or ye xheez dekh k bht acha lagta , ap log itna interest ly k sunty or dekhty, ap ka way of taking bht acha hai explain krny ka..
liked subscribed and pressed the bell icon, love from Pakistan, just cute reaction
Pakistan Coke studio has been promoting its folk music since its season 1 and that dates back to 2008
So its not the first song in which you are watching a traditional appearance....
In this song atif aslam blended his famous song julay julyame pan kal nadiya ....🎉
impressive reaction, well noticed
ये दोनों गानो का सबजेक्ट ही अलग है एक लव सोग है ओर दुसरा वीर रस का युध के समय का
Song or music ko smj kr suna jae to same reaction hota Hy jesy tuhara Hy, it's beautiful to listen this song with you. Love from Pakistan.
Bohat Acha Lga Apki Videos dekh k I'm from Pakistan❤ Or han Atif Aslam Acha Singer hai manlo😅
Hahaha point to b noted
I think everyone has kept his own choice
Starting music of the Mai Dai song paints the picture of chooolistan desert with line of camels walking across a setting sun in the background and khans badosh on the backs of those camel unaware of a women in the near by village singing the song.
i wish u have million followers 😍
Indian female singer voice beautiful
I don’t know the nuances of music but i love both the songs.
You are truly music lover
Your vocals ❤
Atif bhai ny hr tarh ka song gaa dia kamal kia kahin in k bare main
Wonderful defined well done
Love from North Pakistan
I love this video 😍🤞
Bewajah and Umran Langian are also marvellous.
Wow 💞😌
Like your review. Love from sri lanka 🇱🇰 💐❤👌
This is sindhi song a folk song
My grandfather migrated from pilani rajishtan my father knew marwari and he love this song
Basically, a FOLK SONG, so there is no copying issue........I don't know the techniques used but what I noticed it was sung in three languages, started with MARVAR'I (Gujrati), then Atif blended in with URDU and ended with PUNJABI..............BLESS YOU for educating this old soul.
I think mam now you become atif fan
Thanks for reaction
Right kaha aap ne mene bhi yhi notis Kiya tha.🙏🙏👍✌️🕺🕺🕺🤘🎸🎻🎧❣️👋👋🤝🤝🏆🏆
Keep reacting to coke studio and other songs of Nescafé basement as well please, I mean at least I get learn something about music from each of your videos😊
Thank you
♥️
"Baanware" song from coke studio love from Pakistan
FOLKS ALWAYS ROOTS.... THEY ARE ROCK
I know you don't like atif aslam
But Apko Atif Aslam ki taarif karni chahiye tha...usne acha gya tha
Coke Studio Pakistan's song "Sakal Ban" by Muazim Ali and Rizwan also starts with high beats, but you will instantly fell for it.
Nice awesome ❤️
No doubt Atif is best and I am very big fan of him, but some time it is depends on the song that what kind of music will suit. 'Chad Chad Jana' is awesome song music is supporting the power of song. If you going to sing this song with soft music so maybe it will loos feel and actual meaning (story) behind.
Not a fan of your reaction as u said u don't appreciate Atif's singing. He is a phenomenal singer. All his songs are chartbusters. His singing style is unique. Each one has his own taste and preferences. May be you don't like him. That's ur personal opinion. But don't generalize ur opinions. Avoid expressing negative comments. Don't be biased while giving ur reaction. Atif is one of the best singers of Asia. He is an emotion. Love Atif❤ from India.
❤❤❤
I can see you performing in Coke Studio Pakistan soon
I think its unfair to say that its copied since both Indo-Pak share the same cultures as both singers were from Rajasthan
What Ram sampath did is really good. He tried to combine dnb (drum n bass) with folk music. Just because the tempo is high and the setting is matching doesn't mean doesn't have soul. Been listening to it for years vibe in my car or when I feel low energy.
I think Ram Sampath did a great job combining locked groove of a hi-nrg genre with metal like singing of the high pitched folk singer.
Both songs are completely different. I'll always place chadh chadh as one of the better songs of coke studio india.
Not every thing needs to be acoustic and have unnecessary dynamics. Chadh chadh jaana is all about power and experimentation.
Aap ne Atif ko discuss nii kiya, aaj tu aap uss se inspired lag rahi thiin..😁
Okay so coke studio pakistan songs are recorded months before going live so this very unlikely to be inspired so its merely a coincidence and rajhastani and sindhi folk is quite similar and so the getup.
Sister buhat elm hy apko mausiki ka love from Pakistan 🇵🇰🇵🇰
Biggest difference is that Pakistan coke studio version sounded like Rajasthani
Hi I really like the way of elaboration Ambwa talay needs your reaction and expert opinion
By the way u have great taste of songs..
very mature comment!
mai dhai is singer from thar sindh which connect sindh and rajhistan india. toh yeh type of singing 2no sides pe hai. kisi ne copy nahi kara
That indian song starting was more like “Power Puff Girls Music” 😂😂😂
ایشین آلات موسیقی میں کے چھوٹے سے چھوٹے ہر آلات موسیقی کے پیچھے کسی انسان کا ایک کرداری بیک گراونڈ ہوتا ہے جو اس پر جادو کا اثر رکھتا ہے جبکہ ان جدید آلات موسیقی کا ایسا کوئی انسانی بیک گراؤنڈ نہیں ہوتا جو انسانی طبیعت کو متاثر کرنے کی طاقت رکھے.محض مشین ہوتی ہے انسانی طبیعت کے بغیر.
Mam music is just not limited to one dimension rajasthan music culture is very rich . Even the song sung by mai dhai is also sung for the umarkot royal family which is now part of Pakistan and for batter understanding of song please do research about the song too. Coz i know everything was going over your head.
I will not do any research and will speak whatsoever i have to. Kindly unsubscribe if you have problem with that.
Pyare bhai ye konsa tareeqa he baat karne ka, you should have suggested in a respectful manner. That's not the way 😐
Mam if you react on coke studio content your channel as grow as graas in spring😁
Aitf wale ❤lins Ka cover bnao ap ananiya jee Kisi din 🙈😍
Plz plz react to ajj jane ki zid na kro by Madam Fareeda khanum. Outstanding
@Ananya Dwivedi I am big fan of Coke Studio Pakistan, India and Bangla as well. I am agreeing with you about superiority of Pakistani Coke Studio. I want to recommend you to listen Coke Studio episodes Produced by Shantonu Moitra and Anupom Roy and also Episode of Papon. You will listen some excillently produced Bangla and Assamese Folk Songs. If you get chance, Please listen to Coke Studio Bangla as well. Than you may also praise all the coke studio Shows. Loving your reactions and explanation.
Another marwari song by coke studio ,,, bheero binjaro pai b reaction dijye ga...
Both of them belongs to same soil either it’s Rajasthan or its tharr they don’t see lines actually we all belongs to same soil 😊 jahan tak recording ki bat hai Pakistani coke studio has bestest audio engineer hein jo k ap Mehsoos kar rehi hein while listening!
I don't think its right to compare both..everyone has thier own taste.
Some might like slow beats and some fast
Hi Anaya,
a heartiest request if you can please react to Bayaan band's song Nahi Milta and Auj band's song Nawaazish. please i would highly appreciate that. thank you
Dear rajasthan culture depiction
Atif 👌👌👌
Madam, Rajhistani culture exists on both the sides of border. Therefore, their folklores and songs are similar. There is a possibility of a coincidence of playing the same song.
Madam dono song different h
Dono rajasthani language me h
I'm waiting for your next reaction video
Ishq da kukkar from coke studio kindly give reaction on it thx.
Assalam o Alikum
Sister.
I like Ur reaction on coke studio PK
Pls react on Sajjad Ali rone na Diya by coke studya
Wana see your Reaction on "GO" by coke Studio..
Ananya respect your amazing knowledge but working with folk musics I can tell you they don't understand raags and shrutis, they are not trained classically. A lot of them claim to be trained, but its mostly fake. Also Mai Dhai is singing Sindhi folk where as Bhanvari is singing Shekhavati folk.
Also these songs are roughly 80-100 year olds and exist on both sides of the border, because people on both sides are from Sindh and have the same stories and songs.
bring more reactions
pls pls
I don't know why I'm feeling but in my opinion your review is not correct, second song is very soft like hindi main bole to वियोग श्रृंगार रस so that's why lift up should be very slow, on other hand चढ़ चढ़ जाना is like in वीर रस or ओज गुण that's why starting is perfect as according to the octave of vocals,
You should think about that
Know you react magical gutarest song sung by gohar Mumtaz in pepsi betle of the band you love 💯 but u should react
No copy indian song this is real pakistani song
Ma'm ye rajistan ka folk song hai before partition same area tha folk song kisi ki malkiat nhi hoty chahy India ho ya Pakistan
Plzzzzzzzzzzzz mention that you are watching Coke studio Pakistan because Pakistan deserves appreciation....
Ananya can u plz react to a nescafe basement song ( na kaho👍👍👍
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
React to shikwa jawab e shikwa by Coke studio
Chadh Chadh Jana is an acquired taste... Not everyone's cup of tea...
Aatif Aslam ❤️
They meant to create tension with their drums, bassline and haunting melody. Music is about expressions not all drums need to be light and flurry. Dnb is a genre with dark energy, music is about expression. Not every song is supposed to make a listener feel happy that'll destroy the purpose of music which is expression. Different genres of music are present because there are a gazillion types of expression. If one only listens to songs that sound happy then half of genres like metal, many sub genres of electronic music, hard rock (lyrics are mostly dark), punk rock (heavy riffs and hard hitting drums througout), dubstep (definitely you should not listen to it) will end to exist.
Please increase your taste and awareness about music in genera. Develop your taste.
You maybe a very good and trained singer but your taste is very limited.
Music ki koi boundary nahi hai 🇵🇰