Fasting while undergoing menstruation or post natal bleeding? by Dr Zakir Naik
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ต.ค. 2024
- Fasting while undergoing menstruation or post natal bleeding?
Dr Zakir Naik: As far as the woman who are undergoing menstrual cycles or post-natal bleeding according to our beloved Prophet Muhammad (saws), its mentioned in Sahih Bukhari, also in Sahih Muslim that it is forbidden for a woman to fast who is bleeding due to menstrual cycle or post-natal bleeding.
So it is not optional, it is forbidden. And the reason is because when the blood flows out in a lady, in a woman, she loses a lot of blood and on top of that if she fasts it will not be good for her health. So Allah (swt), it is His Mercy that he has exempted them and made it compulsory not to fast otherwise it may be damaging for her health. And Allah (swt) does not want to overburden any of the human beings. So that's the reason they are exempted from fasting and even in the middle of the day if the menstruation begins, they have to break their fast. Even if it begins a few minutes before sunset, they have to break the fast but they have to compensate later on. But if they are undergoing the menstrual period and if the period stops just before Fajr even if they did not have a bath, they can start their fast. But if it ends even a few minutes after Fajr, they cannot fast. They have to break their fast but they have to compensate it later on
MashAllah MashAllah Allah forbid women from fasting in menstruation is for her health SubhanAllah Allah is so raheem and kareem
how does he memories all those page numbers from the quran so adorable
Mimi Cilla He been Practicing Islam his whole life my cousin can do the samething
Hanif Abdullah dont lie, its pretty hard to memorize all this unless
@@zai4booc not at all many people have memorized the Quran with translation
Ma sha Allah
Mimi Cilla Allah gave him this memory Masha’Allah. If you struggle to work hard for a certain goal in path of Allah. Definitely Allah blesses that person , because he is Allah is most Kind & merciful & generous !
Subhanallah I really like these sessions of Dr Zakir naik they answer all the question that I was not clear about
Great great Dr zakir naik.. We need more zakir naik for this world
Trueee..we all should try..
Sir Zakir Naik u r great MashAllah
May Allah Almighty protect u and gv u best state of health
Ameen
MashaAllah i get my answer google realy sucks sometime gives so many miltiple answers.
But whenever i found my question answered by Dr.zakir i accept it without any doubt.
Such a good information u gave . Jazzakallah
i love the answers ☺ Mashallah
Can anyone tell .i have really doubts ., normally my periods are of 7 days but this time it stopped a day before and i m not sure to take ghussal as i have doubt wheather I'll be having spotting on last day or not .should i fast in sahoor and take ghussal in the day .will my fast be acceptable.or should i have a bath and fast .
Thanks for such information...
JAZAKALLAH Zakir Sahib❤
MashaaAllah..thank you sheikh zakir..👌👌
I am suffering continue bleeding 🩸 long then my periods can I have fast with this situation
Thank you for the information... Allah SWT always bless you. Ameen
Jezakallah Dr Zakir Allah protect you
Thank you for the information.
How can I help my mother and father...for if they have commit any sins in the past..please let me know..maybe by feeding the poor or giving charity
Aferose Ayabarreno pray for them
So i my period flow syoped earlier and i thought it was ove so i took ghusl and fasted but later i find out i was still spotting blood,have i sinned ?
MashaAllah ... and JazakaAllah ul khair :)
After child miscarriage bleeding already passed 40 days still spotting can I fast 😢
Aww oh god thanks I was wondering if it’s ok for me to not keep it because of it
thanks a lot sheikh
aslm bhai zakir if meens stop before 7 day but only little bit brown likage come can fasting our must wait 7 days
i have same question...because namaz cant be performed if that brown color still comes but can we fast? who will answer plzni need to know
what happens if my menstruation stop yesterday and then I fast today then i had an spotting in the middle of the day, do I need to break my fasting?
As I know if you complete 7 days then you can fast
Why didn’t they write down the reference of the hadith. I cannot find the hadith anywhere where it says that it is forbidden to fast during menses. I cant find other articles referencing hadiths that say this either. Please if you know reply to my comment.
It's written in the Qur'an my friend... More stronger reference than Hadith....
I have spotting for 3 to 8 or 10 days before my periods begin. This spotting is attached to my period i.e my period start as soon as the spotting gets over. So will that spotting be considered as part of my period? Can I offer Salah during my spotting? If I include spotting to my period than whole process last for sometime around 15 to 16 days. What should I do in this condition?
Yeah spotting attached with the periods you can't do Salah,,,,
Jazak Allah 🌸
Salamualaikum Sheikh.
At the time of our beloved prophet S.W.S. , They use to trek for a long journey that is why the obligation it fasting has been lifted upon them. But this our times, we sit in buses comfortably to where we are going to, would that also exempt a person from fasting?
Yes it would. Comparing Arab women of that time to today, we as human beings have grown soft to adverse changes. For example, the Prophet used to not eat anything for days but is it possible for us today? In the end, only Allah knows best
Can I read Quran while I am in piurud
Can i start fasting if my period length prolonged i mean its my 10th day and its still flowing whether its abnormal if the period prolonging more than 10 days , in that case can i start fasting ? Plzzzzzzz reply
@Mah Herma so can we fast during our periods?
@@refadahmad5756 " it is forbidden for a woman to fast who is bleeding due to menstrual cycle or post-natal bleeding. " This is in the description.
That means you can not fast during periods
@@refadahmad5756 Don't tell the comments please people have very different opinions please tell a trusted guided adult
th-cam.com/video/mR7vsD8BEA0/w-d-xo.html
@@refadahmad5756 no, one cannot pray, how can fast?? It is forbidden to keep fast during menstruation but allow during pregnancy. Your matter is different. Getting bleeding above normal days of menstrruation comes under illness, you could avoid fast due illness and get treatment first, but salah is compulsory. And ask further from authentic person who know about it further.
He is stating that it is in Bukhari and in Muslim that it is forbidden for a women to fast who is in her menstruational cycle. But he does not say which hadith it is by number. Can anybody show me those hadiths in Bukhari or in Muslim which says that it is forbidden for a women to fast while in her period?
It is forbidden to fast or read quraan while you're in your period
@@annievibes8794 show ANY hadith that it is forbidden
But how can I know that my period stopped? It could just start flowing anytime unexpected
My solution to this is that when it is my last day (even with an irregular cycle I know the earliest day it might stop) I become very vigilant about changing the pads round about fajr during Ramadan. It's worked well so far. Hope this helps.
Yeah....i also face this problem😞
@@Ayesha0610 what if im taking ghusl and start fasting on day 8 while im done on 7th day of my period
But during fasting day 8 again bleeding what should I do eat or how
@@khalidseddiqy2171 then you have to break your fast by eating or drinking anything.....because your fast has already broken when you are bleeding again
You get a white discharge when your period is over but not brown and after Ghusul if you get a drop of blood smaller than a coin it is not considered as ur period
Thank you
So I can never fast for Ramadan I don't get to do Ramadan that's sad I'm sad now
U Are super dr Zakir naik sir
You are superb, great, intelligent dr zakir naik
Compensate later mean? Fast later?
Yes, it means the days you've missed during ramazan you have to fast for the same number of days later.
Can anyone answer this for me, what if you woke up for suhoor ate and then were fasting but then at zuhr time you saw that your period has begun what do you do?
You have to break the fast dear ❤
@@adibazaman-sujana948 Yes i understood that, thank you 😊💖
You got your period during the fast therefore you have to break it 🥰
Barakallah ..💖
Is it sin for a woman to fast but she doesn't know if it's going to accepted or not
Eg: it's her last day of her period she sees a bit of brownish or some blood after 12pm
If anyone knows plz reply
I also facing this
Thank u😊 Sir now my doubts are cleared..
Fasting has nothing to do with purity. If one is sick (for whatever reason, may include menstruation), s/he can miss/break the fast. But if s/he feels okay, s/he should be allowed to fast. Menstruation should not be classified as a different case. Read Al Quran.
Hi Sheik,
The sahih Hadith you mentioned that woman should not fast during menstrual cycle is not sahih , there is not Quranic verses indicating this , so please give a Quranic Text.
Our religion s. Amazing !
What happens if you don’t fast during the pregnancy and haven’t made up for it before next Ramadan?
You have to donate an amount of money to the poor
I want to ask something really important, as most of the people know that women’s cannot fast during mensuration. But it gets really hard sometimes to explain brother or even the other people like work colleagues that why we are not fasting. So is it obligatory for women to pretend that she is fasting during her menses. The thing is we fast for Allah and he knows the reasons that why aren’t we fasting. But what about people they judge and ask questions like why aren’t you fasting?? So what should we do in these kind of situations???
Please answer.....
I believe u could just explain the situation but before that u could says something like 'only if you knew the reason' but I would say you can just explain it to them there's nothing to be ashamed of as it is from Allah Subhana Wataalla. May Allah guide us all.
You can eat secretly and tell no one! Just act normal no one is gonna ask! But don't pretend to pray tho
Asalamu alaikum! You don't owe anyone an explanation. If they insist, just tell them that you're in a period(timeframe) when you cannot fast
Period blood is not a loss of your own blood but im glad they think that and let woman eat anyway because i get very hungry on my period and its the only time i cant tolerate being hungry. Like i can skip meals anyday but when im on my period i would get light headed if i dont eat.
You do lose a lot of iron during menstruation.
It's uterus lining but still there is loss of blood that's why women who have heavy flow get anemic due to loss of much iron. And also the body needs hydration at the time of month some can even faint due to dehydration it's not easy for everyone people like me have constant vomiting ,cramps, bloating and dehydration also some women can be vulnerable due to harmonal fluctuations .
Plzz can someone tell me tht is it haram to eat frount of ur dad while u are on ur periods in ramadan plzz someone tell me
No dear its oky even i eat in front of my brothers and they don't mind
It is not haram but have to be respectful because they are fasting. I will just eat in my room 😁
can we read quran in mobile in manturatioon while Ramadan...
please give reply to my question
maryam afreen we can read Quran but we can't touch the words
No that's haram .... Without wudu we can't touch Quran
@@attitudegirl7920 no its in correct we can recite from mobiles but cannot touch Quran in a book form
can I pray my namaz during brown discharge but no bleeding
heba khan can I pray and fast I’m having period from 1 months. It’s not normal period it’s like black blood and very little amount
heba khan thank you very much.. I’ll keep fasting from today .. pray for me.. from USA
@@shipasiddika6052 no u cant cuz its alittle blood
can i fast during my brown discharge. Its just a sport. No bleeding
Mashallah❤️
jazakallah doctr zakir naik,, I have 1 more doubt, I gav birth to my son in mnth of Ramadan befr 2 yrs, but stil I din fast which I missd,, I m trying my best, so in last he told dat we must finish those kalah fast befr next mmth of ramdan, but I cudnt, its past 2 yrs,, now what I shell do,, plz if any 1 knw the correct answer let me know
Now u can fast and compensate it. It's allowed. Better late than never
Dr Zahir Naik, I really appreciate you and respect you for all what you have done, but please tell me where it is mentioned that it is forbidding for a women to fast ? there isn't a single statement saying that. and Coran only gave the permission to break the fast to sick persons and traveling persons . So if she find her self sick the first few days she can break the fast but ones she is feeling well she has to fast.
From Hadith of the Prophet Muhammad SAW. He mentioned the hadith no. and if you still have a problem with that then salamualaikum
wa alaykom salam dear brother, Sunan Ibn Majah Book 7 Hadith 1667:
It was narrated from Anas bin Malik that a man from the tribe of Banu ‘Abdul-Ashhal, while (one narrator) ‘Ali bin Muhammad said (he was) a man from the tribe of Banu ‘Abdullah bin Ka’b, said:
“The cavalry of the Messenger of Allah (Peace be upon him) attacked us, so I came to the Messenger of Allah (Peace be upon him) while he was eating a meal. He said: ‘Come and eat.’ I said: ‘I am fasting.’ He said: ‘Sit down and I will tell you about fasting. Allah has relieved the traveler of half of the prayer, and He has relieved the traveler, the pregnant, and the nursing mothers of the duty to fast.’ By Allah, the Prophet (Peace be upon him) said them, both, or one of them, and now I feel so disappointed that I had not eaten of the food of the Messenger of Allah (Peace be upon him).”
Sunan an-Nasa'i 2274: خْبَرَنَا عُمَرُ بْنُ مُحَمَّدِ بْنِ الْحَسَنِ بْنِ التَّلِّ، قَالَ حَدَّثَنَا أَبِي قَالَ، حَدَّثَنَا سُفْيَانُ الثَّوْرِيُّ، عَنْ أَيُّوبَ، عَنْ أَبِي قِلاَبَةَ، عَنْ أَنَسٍ، عَنِ النَّبِيِّ صلى الله عليه وسلم قَالَ " إِنَّ اللَّهَ وَضَعَ عَنِ الْمُسَافِرِ نِصْفَ الصَّلاَةِ وَالصَّوْمَ وَعَنِ الْحُبْلَى وَالْمُرْضِعِ " .
"Allah has waived meaning half of the prayer and fasting for the traveler, and from pregnant women and the sick. "(Hanas)
with all my respect there is not a single statement mentioning that fasting is forbidding for women during menstruation. please check all the references. its better to stand corrected than to die ignoring. we brother and sisters shall share any fruitful information that may guide us to hidaya. if women feel sick during her period she can break the fast, but if not its better to fast wa Allaho a3lam!
dr zakir is one of our asset , we are proud of him masha Allah, but this information has been fed to us by mistake, we are human we all may commit mistakes. it is better to go back to coran and sunna and check it again.
Mash Allah
Anyone pls help me I just got my period and I was fasting what should I do now
Live Life you should hear this video as soon as you start your periods and you are fasting your fast will break straight away so there will be no longer fasting
Your fasting is broke but you dont break your fasting by eating or drinking immideatly wait for the time of iftar and break your fast..if you break your fast by waiting till the time of iftar you can compansate only one roje after ramadan..but if you break your fasting by eating or drinking even if you have periods then u will have to compansate 60 days roje nonstop..
when you start bleed ur fast automatically broke :) if u drink or not its up to you, but its automatically broke and you have to count that day with other period days.
@@sardarbasha1744 its wrong... period start fast automatically broke.
So smart
Oh I see if. We can fast. Then our fast s validate
i am fasting on my period. i've never seen a real proof that says otherwise.
Even I does but after this video I feel I shouldn't as its forbidden
@@dilkill371 Qur'an never says that woman can't fast on their period. it is just a debate of whether women shouldn't fast on the first or two days of their period because of heavy cramps. we're not dirty. blood doesn't affect fasting. when your nose bleed while you're fasting it doesn't break your fasting. it makes no sense.
@@crystallineleaf Very good point sister. I think there is a general problem, how scholars treat menstruating women. Menses should be seen as a hardship for women. To ease their situation and their struggle, they are free to fast or not to fast. As Allah says: "Ramaḍân is the month in which the Quran was revealed as a guide for humanity with clear proofs of guidance and the standard ˹to distinguish between right and wrong˺. So whoever is present this month, let them fast. But whoever is ill or on a journey, then ˹let them fast˺ an equal number of days ˹after Ramaḍân˺. Allah intends ease for you, not hardship, so that you may complete the prescribed period and proclaim the greatness of Allah for guiding you, and perhaps you will be grateful." 2:185
@@michaelw.881 that's exactly what i am talking about. thank you 🙏🏻
@@crystallineleaf well explained sister! JazakAllah
I literally had less than 3 hrs left
MashaAllah
A woman Can Pray & Fasting in The Periods.
Only -
No Sex in The Periods.
وَيَسْأَلُونَكَ عَنِ الْمَحِيضِ ۖ قُلْ هُوَ أَذًى فَاعْتَزِلُوا النِّسَاءَ فِي الْمَحِيضِ ۖ وَلَا تَقْرَبُوهُنَّ حَتَّىٰ يَطْهُرْنَ ۖ فَإِذَا تَطَهَّرْنَ فَأْتُوهُنَّ مِنْ حَيْثُ أَمَرَكُمُ اللَّهُ ۚ إِنَّ اللَّهَ يُحِبُّ التَّوَّابِينَ وَيُحِبُّ الْمُتَطَهِّرِينَ
&
They ask you about menstruation. Say,
"It is a discomfort So keep away from wives during menstruation
&
Do not approach [Sex]Them until They are pure.
Quran 2-222
I have period problem. Usually I get period after 2 months 3 months but once I get period it’s stay like 1 months sometimes 3 months. So can I fast and pray during period time thought it’s stay like 1 months ?
@@shipasiddika6052 go to your doctor it's not good
Aleeza Ahmad yeah I took my appointment
This is my 8day.I am fasting but still I have brown spots.I have continue my fast and salah or not.(I am using my son's I'd)
@@shipasiddika6052 if periods are extending upto 12 -15 days you can start praying and fasting as usual. But you must've consult your doctor as that could be harm for health
oo
fACTS
He is the new prophet, it seems, he is such a manipulator. I don’t understand why hes not wearing parda, and speaks in arabic,
u should not use the word prophet ...
prophet Mohd sallallahu alaihi wasallam.is the last prophet....u may use the word Islamic scholar
Joker spotted