Q&A: What is 'Hanafi', 'Maliki', 'Shafi', etc.? - Dr. Shabir Ally
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 19 มิ.ย. 2024
- Q&A: What do the terms Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi, etc mean? Are these sects of Islam? Dr. Shabir explains.
Please subscribe to the show! Click "Subscribe" above.
![แฟนแนวใด๋ - ยูริ โตเกียวมิวสิค [ SyncVersion ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Fm8oDwos2uc/mqdefault.jpg)
I'm an Agnostic Atheist but I really enjoy and appreciate Dr. Shabir Ally's talks.
I'm even thinking of financially supporting his organization because of his scholarly approach
and efforts to bring Islam into the 21st. century.
Seldom Seen jajak Allah swt khair my brother!!
You deserve to go to heaven without a doubt.
Arman brother with all respect but its not correct to say such things because only Allah swt knows who deserves paradise. its important to know these things because even words can bring you out of islam. assalamu alaykum brother
Hadis Mustafi brother listen knowledge has three parts,
Knowing
learning and
realising.
Perhaps what you are failing to realise is how easy islam is as a religion,its the most easiest easy religion of all religions.its also very simple and makes absolute perfect sense every time.
And maybe you do not know that god Almighty Allah swt can absolutely forgive anybody and everybody if he wishes.even if it is the worst of sinner.....jajak Allah.
Plus through your opinion it seems you either follow the classical islamic way,or believe in academical islamic knowledge which is shariya a little too much,
Do you know there are other three sources of islamic knowledge?
Arman brother i just gave you a nasiha thats all. it doesnt even matter wich madhhab i follow or you because its a clear rule that its up to Allah teala who deserves paradise. there are words and actions that can put you out of islam and thats a fact. if you wish that guy good than do it the islamic way and say "may Allah guide you"
Seldom Seen I know he is great isn't he? And it is so wonderful to see his daughter with him!
Great topic, jazaakum Allahu khayr
Excellent as always, a family dedicated for Islamic cause, MashaAllah
This guy is one of the best teachers I've ever witnessed. The explanation was plain and simple. Good job
What a wonderful explanation.
Thank you for this video! It was very helpful!
SUBHANALLAH very well explained in short words but detail info. Jazak Allah khair👍😊May Allah swt reward u for ur effort.
MASHA'ALLAH good informative program...keep up the good work
highly informative videos....nice channel...God bless you all~
Maa sha ALLAH Dr. Shabbir !
Came to this video by reading a book about Salah al-Din. Thanks for your explanations.
I like how they handed over the paper at the end of the video like a professional news broadcast would lol
1:45 made a mistake naming Imam Malik Ibn Anas. Said the opposite! Anas Ibn Malik was a companion of the Prophet (Peace be upon him)
well elaborated
Thank you for answering my question. Especially the second part of the answer was very interesting. To bad Dr. Shabir, may Allah (swt) bless him, did not go in to the Salafi/wahabi school. I understand this is a sensitive issue.
Again I thank you for answering my question. I look forward to post some new questions!
Salaheddine020 Salado is a manhaj...u can be Salado hanafi
Tazboy salado?
Salaheddine020
Wahabbi that took root in late 19th century at a place where the Muslims in that regions were still practising the traditions from the day of Jahaliah does not count. Wahabbi should not be discussed as if it is worthy to be discussed on par with Hanafi, Maliki, Hanbali Madhab
Mandy A Abdul Wahab was a great reviver of the sunnah of the prophet and brought back tawheed to the land of Arabia please do not disrespect him
@@Hassan-mr5pv z8
I heard someone from one of my relatives say Hanafi school of thought I never really understood it until I grew up pretty much.
It is true. Being a Hanafi, one must know all basics which themselves are very huge. Other Thought of School (Maslak) it is not the case.
@@hannanpakthini7221 From the little that I have learned from Hanafi school of thought ( which is nothing in comparison to it's principles ) I do appreciate their academic and critical thinking approach instead of just taking in what is read literal and run with it although many may not understand it. This in regards to ahadiths mainly.
Regards from Los Angeles.
Salaam 🇲🇽🤝☪️☝🏼
Jazakumullahu khairan
love shabir aly huge respect for him love him from india
Islam warns against the formation of a clergy explicitly (and warns against all forms of monopoly generally), which leaves the religion to be interpreted by people. While people present their views on the correct interpretation it is typically people who have a knowledge base on the topic who end up gaining respect on discussing the issues. For example, political chat shows on tv will usually have a panel of experts who have knowledge on the field they are discussing/debating. In the same manner different interpretations from islamic scholars and philosophers have been debated throughout the centuries. Islamic scholars gravitate to other scholars who have stronger arguments etc thus forming schools of thought. All the different schools of thought are valid provided if they follow certain basic criteria. There were hundreds of schools of thought in history - but with debate they whittled down to those which were intellectually consistent with the holy texts.
Ni zal it is essential that one consults a scholar to get a better understanding of the way of Deen and that's how the schools of thought came about. If you try to be like the Salafi people of today who say follow Quran and Sunnah strictly and when you ask them which books of Hadith, they only accept Sahih Al-Bukhari and some accept Sahih Al-Muslim. It's like the other books of Hadith don't exist to them or all contain 'da'eef' Hadith which is wrong. The schools of thought sifted through the Hadith to help people have a structure to their lives as they had the capability to decipher the Ahadith.
The Google Translate Shuyookh of today go around denouncing Imam Abu Hanifah, Imam Malik et al. and call them deluded and say that what they did was bid'ah. Na uzubillah min zalik. Most of these guys don't even know the dua'a to enter the toilet or how to do tayamum in the case of lack of water or other circumstances.
they have believe only sahi bhukhari and Quran and still not following properly , first you should follow the shariyat rules and regulations , that you don't know, imam bhukhari rehmatullah alahi he knew 1 lakh sahi hadith and 1 lakh jaif hadith ..
in his life he wrote 9082 hadith , still 90918 sahi hadith pending , few hadith coded by kandyani , Huzur Muhammed sallahu alahi wasallam said , kandyani are majusi and and their dalil can't be accepted and few things you know we don't know complete sunnah of Huzur Muhammed sallahu alahi wasallam.. people blindly following hadith without seeing raabi ....
As a Hanafi scholar myself, I have no problem reading my salaah behind a Shafi'i imam than a Shia. At least the schools of thought don't believe the angel Jibra'eel took a wrong turn our rubbish like that.
Assalamulaikum. No Muslim believes that. If a shia says he believes that then he can say what he wants but he is no muslim. I am shia and we are warned about the exaggerator. In fact Imam Ali warned against it.
taaj howell wa alaykumusalaam the aforementioned is what was taught in the religious studies class and I always thought it was a strange philosophy.
@@Kofi_Mensahs_BurnerAccount it is. I would say please learn more about the actual shia school of thought. There are many old hadith from both sunni and shia that say things that are obviously not true from people who are obviously not reputable.
taaj howell quick question? Do you condemn Abu Bakr, Umar ibn Khattab and A'isha radiyalaho anhum?
@@Kofi_Mensahs_BurnerAccount I condemn no wife of my prophet AS. And the prophet had his own words on those who align themselves against Ali AS.
Can we let him speak in the listening assignments his voice is very clear
SO my did told me malaki formed when people thought who should be the next khalifa, some people wanted it to be from quraish, and some people said no it should be Ali, and Some thought it can be anyone. Those who said it should be ali later on became shia, the ones who wanted it to be from quraish are sunni, and then the ones who said it can be anyone were maliki/Ibadi
Dr Shabir is real scholar who stand for truth and an example of what the so called alim is supposed to be
1:47 His name was Malik ibn Anas.
not Anas ibn Malik
He is human being...
May be it was a slip of the tongue
@@shaikziyad9866 May be
Imam Malik ibn Anas is the son of Anas ibn Malik and Anas ibn Malik was a comrade of prophet Muhammad PBUH
@@namaloom7061 anyone with beard is Mullanah .... let's look at the lives of these iman did they do any atrocities? Did they commit shirk or innovations? Prophet had a turban not blue kufi . Most these schokars are just knoweldge and no heart 💔 and some sufis are all heart ♥ and no logic .... you need both ... as you have both fear of punishment and displeasing allah and future regret and also hope of allah 🙏 that he will overlook your sins and multiple your good rewards and by his mercy give you eternal life .
@@kenkaneki9138 no he is not his son and they are huge time gap between them
Looks like they are father and daughter.
They are
They are
Why is there music at the end??
@1:45 Correction: Malik Ibn Anas
But some exploit to achieve their goals
is it permissible for someone praying to Repeat Surah Al-Fatiha in one raka under the schools of Hanafi and Malik
Does it really matter?
In Hanafi jurisprudence when in congregation prayers we don't recite any verse. Only thr imam recites.
All thé Madhabs are correct. Those were thé true scholars of islam. Not thé so called scholars of today. Those scholars were very pious and Allaah accepted them, that is why their Madhabs are followed today. Those were thé pious and we say May Allah have mercy on them. We should not said what we dont know. No one needs to get to thé bottom of anything because thé best of people were thé companions, Ta'biin and Ta- Ta'biin and those Imaams of thé four schools falls into that. May Allaah guide us and save us from à loose tongue.
MashaALLAH
@b king salifis and jakir nayek are praising yajid
Allbyiu need is to just watch your own tonge
All 4 Imams are on HAQ (Correct)
These are Maslaks of Islam, Islam is a madhab.
hey im kinda confused over here. Im unaware of which sect im in and how do i find out.
Does it really matter? Follow Allah's guidance through Allah's only Book, The Quran, and you will be fine as a muslim!
@@ahmedakhan1 look im just being curious over here over what are they and which should i be with. And i do agree with you but take note we are seeing two different categorization over here and I'm still scratching my head over why people are fighting over it instead following the most basic fundamentals of islam first.
@@arafath_shxfin follow the one imam fiqh four of them who is nearly to your house masjid who actually following one of them fiqh it's good for you and your family the four imam is one sect and rest other sect actually they don't have knowledge of everything on sunnah it's reality and find the mosque around you one above i told ,however it is kilometres away from you
No more discussion about that matter
Hanifa was an afghan who studied in Iraq and arabia
There's no sects Islam only different thoughts in practicing
sounds like sects but with extra steps xd
@@MMOInformers it's called critical thinking. Use it !
@@MacMac1313 ?
@@MMOInformers yea kind of but you can follow anyone of these imam all four of them are correct
These 4 orthodox are not sects
So from which of those i have ti learn?? Pls answer
Follow the one with closest to Qur'an and Sunnah.
All are right. Follow what is common in your country.
Islam is not divided...they only collected all information on deen. And told what to do in islam. Because after muhammed the deen should b prsnt until now. So these imams studied and wrote laws. So that all can understand untill end. So anyone can follpw that 4 teaching.
how do you guys pronounce hanafi is it HANA-FI or ha-na-fi
Hana-fi.
shabbir ali reminds me of a brown quentin tarantino :)
Makenshi Critiques after reading your comment......!!!
yes
Mr Shabir always gives beats around the bush! I don’t know why ...? Can’t he keep it a little simple ?
why u dont tell another school of islam is jaffria who was the teacher of all 4 sunni imam his name Jafeer bin muhmmad bin Ali bin Hussain bin Ali a.s
Fyi, Imam Abu Hanifah was a student & disciple of Imam Zainulanideen ibn Imam Husain RA.
Bro the basic school of thought say if u have sahi hadith the leave my fatwa
That's not basic that is Imam Abu Hanifa "Sahih Hadith is my Madhab"
Why are we so divided?? It's not meant to be like this
There is no mazhab in Islam ... Islam is united not something divided by false imams.
You are not even dust of those great imams which u call false
Ijtihad which is independent reasoning is done by the scholars for practices in our deen if the ihtihad is right the scholar gets 2 rewards if it’s wrong they scholar still gets one reward. Ahlus Sunnah Wal Jammat believe in the 4 main madhabs of Imam Hanifa , Malik , Shafii, And Ahmed May Allah SWT have mercy on them all
When we go through the study of
Qur'an and Sunnat on the basis
Of
Munhajj salaf ,
It gives clear message to a wise person that
there is
Only one way to get paradise
And not many ways
So find it _________
All madhabs link back to one way
This guy shabir is West Indian
It always an Indian Muslim with Mashallah amazing knowledge
Yes, he's from Guyana, so what?
The prophet never took a razor to their face and shaved their mustache.
Ahlehadees
Means
Ahle Sunnat waljamat
No no no this opinion is universal wrong
Boy they are very rude and rigid.
Which Sunni is most correct
all four.. eg if u learn under a hanafi teacher .. u proceed with wat u learn.. it’s gd to know abt other mazhab eg shafiee.. who raise the hand for takbir when praying at few places.. (the start of prayer.. before rukuk.. after rukuk.. n when raising up after the first tahiyat.. hanafi only raise for takbir at the start of prayer.. all mazhab hv legitimate reason as it was taken frm hadith.. all four mazhab follow the sunnah .. the oldest of these 4 is hanafi.. then maliki.. then shafiee.. then hambali.. maliki was a student of hanafi .. shafiee was a student of maliki.. n hambali was a student of shafiee.. there are/were more than 4 mazhab.. bt these 4 survived.. hanafi is big in india .. china.. maliki in africa n turkey (the maliki founder in fact stayed mostly in madinah.).. shafiee is big in southeast asia.. indonesia.. malaysia .. singapore.. hambali is big in saudi arabia..
@@SonOfCheepThrill jazak Allaah for cutshort explanation💖
@@arshnaaz6258 i’m glad it helps ... 😀
@@SonOfCheepThrill I were looking for this comment....thnx for explaining😊
@@Hana_30 no problem.. hope it benefits u in order to understand our deen.. hv a blessed ramadan .. 😀
Is she his daughter?
I want to know too same last name
Yes
Who is Maliki or Hanafi???????
Maliki are those who follow the teachings of Imam Malik Ibn Anas. Hanafi are those who follow the school of Imam Abu Hanifa.
Fiqh schools
Umayyad emirate scholars were Maliki and Ottomans empire scholars were Hanafi. I think you're not taught fiqh matters.
@@mohammedmuadh9567 Sorry. Jazakallah Khair for correcting me. So basically these are schools of thought.
@@sniperphoenix4040 yes. They derive rulings from Qur'an and sunnah. Qiyas and ijma come under this.
True way ahlusunna Hanfi shaf i Hanbali maliki
Why Muslim scholars refused to resolve issue of sectarian in Islam...bcoz all of them has their own opinions on islam... isn't it man made religion????
Hamdan Hamdan it’s not a man made religion Islam is from Allah. Prophet Muhammad (May Allah peace be upon him) has completed islam for us. Anyone that makes changes or bring stuff to it will get sin, innovation is MAJOR sin. sadly a lot of people have innovated in different stuff in the sects they believe. ISLAM SHOULD BE FOLLOWED JUST JUST THE WAY PROPHET MUHAMMAD SAW TAUGHT US. Period
What does wahabis follow? Salafi /hanfi??
We follow Our Prophet Muhammad (صلى الله عليه وسلم)and Sahaba.
Wahhabism is not a sect. It is a term to mock the people who follow the Qur'an and the Sunnah. Muhammad Ibn Abdul Wahhab was a Scholar who revived the teachings of Islam when people started practicing shirk!
I think they are Hanbali or you can say salafi. See what they have done to the Holy land. Now women can bath in bikinis in beaches. Putbil comes for program.
Inki sunein mohtarma ya aapko dekhen...gunah karo aur karwao...hadd hai
Islam has been divided into 73 sects, the reason is that Imam Ali (as), the most knowledgeable person in Islam after the Prophet (PBUH), was not allowed to succeed as the successor of the prophet Muhammad (PBUH). So only those who follow Imam Ali (as) and the Prophet's (PBUH) progeny (Fatima (as), Hasan (as) and Hussain (as)) are following the right path. Imam Hasan (as) and Hussain (as) are the door keepers of heaven. The Hadith reported by At-Tirmithi and which was narrated by Usaamah Ibn Zayd who said: “I knocked on the door of the Prophet sallallaahu `alayhi wa sallam ( may Allah exalt his mention ) for a need and he said: “These (Al-Hasan and Al-Husayn) are my sons and my daughter's sons. O Allah, I love them, so love them, and love whoever loves them."
The Guardian of Truth, the problem is that each sect looks down at other sects and think that they are following the right religion. The question is why several sects and who is responsible for it? All the sects can join togather as brothers and sisters and help each other (morally and financially) towards perfection in stead of hating and killing each other? It is the enemies of Islam who are trying to divide us. We should be united, visit each others centre, and learn. My personal experience is that we can also learn to some extent from non-Muslims and therefore we should not close the doors of salvation. United we stand and divided we fall.
what about omer usman abubker redylhu anhom we follow all the sahba
Who are these we, and for those who follow the people mentioned, they have been black spots for Islam (read history, they were idol worshippers and had limited knowledge about Islam). No one can take the place of Imam Ali (as) after the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) and after him Imam Hasan (as) and Imam Hussain (as) and ending with Imam Al-Mahdi (as)
Hapana Taka please don't tell me you are referring to the Sahaba as idol-worshippers, I am getting the feeling that you're a shia
Shabir Ally You misunderstood The Qo'raan The Perfect Word of Allaah ❤❤❤ The Alknown. You follow self written hadith and books. Allaah ❤❤❤strictly forbidden us. This is SHIRK SHIRK SHIRK. No doubt about it.
Khadija Benassou wdym
There is always a wahabi trying to enforce their belief onto other :)
Ok SHOW ME COMPLETE DESCRIPTION OF BURIAL IN QURAN ....
WITHOUT TOUCHING HADITH OR FIQH
so if u dont follow hadiths, how do u know how to pray?
@@amairah_celeste
Read The Qoraan The Perfect Word of Allaah❤❤❤The Almighty with a open hart. Maybe you will understand the meaning of Salaat.
Barakallahu fi
Saffiyah ally, do you think that you are in hijab with attractive color with skin tight clothing ?...fear allah, don't make impression to other muslim women that, this is way of hijab Quran speaks about...if you don't find the way of clothing in quran go back to hadeeth of prophet peace be upon him
some men 😬😠
SALMAN SHAIK . So you had a very close look to see what she is wearing???? She is sitting in a chair but you exercised your X-ray vision????
SALMAN SHAIK what she is wearing is Fine. You’re just a perv
why are you studying her body and outfit so deeply? people like you need to learn hijab is also compulsary for men to lower their gaze.
He talk good but mistake he said that suni following suna of Muhammad saw .Muhammad saw all Muslim was united but now more 72 sect in suni and Shia . My view is only one jamaati which reflects the suna of Muhammad saw is jamaati Islam ahmadiya which is under one imam (Khalifa of this time)
No sect of Islam consider ahmadi as Muslim so you carry on believing that until you actually research
LMAO CARRY ON BELIEVING THAT MAY ALLAH GUIDE YOU TO THE RIGHT PATH
Nauoozu billaah. God dame Ahmedias are the most sinister in Islam.
Christus vincit. Christus regnat. Christus imperat.
it is haraam in islaam to talk with gair marham ... don't you know?
shes his daughter bro
Mufti Sameer Ali
Rizan Alvi at about 0:07 she seems to quickly say 'brother' shabbir?
The Guardian of Truth i thought it's said in islam 'when a (non-related) man and woman are alone together, shaytan is the third (being with them)', also it's makruh/haram to talk to the non-mahrams unless necessary.
Lebin Payne well maybe there have someone else behind the camera....ever thought about that??
How can we stop Islam? Source: th-cam.com/video/jYCDuBuDlgI/w-d-xo.html
follow shia ahlul bayt. just like our prophet said i leave you 2 things quran and ahlul bayt
Shia is not Muslim
Quran and sunnah. Even queen Elizabeth is from the lineage of Ahlu bayt as per news available on the Internet.
Look at the makeup on her face. shame.
Why? What is wrong with it? Are u blind alley mullah?
why are you looking at her face so deeply?
Sister Safiyyah Ally u should change your hijab. Sorry to say this. This is not hijab .
yes it is, you should lower your gaze.