*There is a important reason companies don't let their idols sing live all the time, cause it can damage their voice* Voice is smth that needs to be preserved ans saved for the best moments, idols most of the times sings live in concerts and performances as they should ofc, aespa also does that. It's just they r too good already. They don't always need to sing live.
@@yeonhee1767what about groups who always sing live since years ? 😂😂😂😂 stop making excuse. Most of lipsync groups is because they can’t sing. Aespa can sing but SM are just scared (they let exo sing live since day 1…). If you stan untalented groups it’s not our problem, but many groups slay each stage with live vocals and We all should praise them
@@Sullyoonaaaaa im not making excuses, i know facts that you don't, im a sm fan since 2018. and one thing that sm artists know how to sing live, they actually put that standard in kpop. In music bank stuffs they don't really sing live, the company doesn't let that happen either. And it's good for them. but they do sing live, watch their concerts you'll know.
AESPA deserves an apology. I blame SM because it was so last minute and there was hardly promotion or hype about Aespa at Coachella, but they did very well and clearly they have the talent to prove they deserved that stage.
@@butterflai_their boring ass fuck not good enough for BP Level and nobody know who are they😂 nugu girl grup sudenly appear and the agency even say "aespa is the first girl grup who invite in main stage cochella"😂😂 very embarrassing..in fact nobody know them 🤣😂🤣...BP always on another level their present always bring hype and every body know who they are..
@@ranisa6567It's true that æspa GG was the first to perform on the main stage, because previously BP perform on the SAHARA stage, and that was a different stage. Don't tell me you don't know about that?😂😂😂 Very embarrassing
As a Blink and a MY I am so sorry. Some psychotic blinks make the fandom look so bad and now all of a sudden they are praising aespa as a reason to hate on Le Sserafim. I won’t forget the hate and hateful reels that went around flaming Aespa during that time. I love aespa they have some of the absolute best vocals in Kpop. I wish I could hear them sing the Tetris song in person, i would die happy.
After hearing only Giselle’s back soundtrack in this part, so heavenly and mesmerizing I will NEVER skip black mamba and definitely always appreciate such a magical song.
@@ranisa6567because they were 1 year old when they performed at Coachella, and I don't think it was boring, because I was there at that time are you there too?
Because SM post that time , Aespa is the first girl group that perform Coachella main stage.. and their stage presence is not good enough That's why were criticize that time
뭐가 어찌됐건 살아보니깐 사람들은 어떤식으로든 까내리는 특성을 가지고 있음. 이래나 저래나 욕먹고 잘하나 못하나 싫어 하는 사람들 계속 싫어함 평생 남 욕하고 까내리고 사람이라는 게 본성이 어쩔 수 없음 나는 그냥 뭐가 됐건 저렇게 열심히 해주고, 노력을 해서 저 자리에 갔을테니 응원해주고 싶음.(그리고 한 가지 말하고 싶은 거: 지금 욕하는 분들 회사나 다른 일 할때도 완벽하게 하면 인정, 근데 완벽하지도 않으면서 남 까내리는 거 본인한테 쪽팔리지도 않으세요?)
각 케이팝 그룹은 자신의 이야기를 가지고,연수생 일 동안 많은 어려움을 겪고. 사람이 진정으로 케이팝을 사랑한다면 그/그녀는 상관없이 그/그녀의 마음에 드는 것이 무엇인지,각 케이팝 그룹을 감사하지해야합니다... 그건 그렇고,나는 당신에게 당신의 인생에서 최고의 소원.😊🥰
aespa were more close to being a 1 year group and lsrfm is closer to being a 2 year group when they performed at coachella. giselle is also the main rapper who only trained for 10 months, singing better than other groups' main vocalist. aespa's black mamba choreography is harder than lsrfm's choreo too. aespa was also performing live yet preparing for coachella. hybe should invest on vocal and rap training rather than buying awards
@@이승-c7d 그리고 ar보다 잘불렀다기보단 ar보다 크게 불렀다는게 좀 더 정확한 표현입니다. 자신있거나 부르고 싶은 부분은 ar보다 소리를 크게 내어 라이브소리 비중을 키우고, 자신없는부분은 안부르거나 라이브소리 비중을 줄여 ar소리 위주로 나오게 되는거지요. 자신없는부분에서 라이브를 작게하면 피치가 나가더라도 ar에 묻히거나 적당히 섞여 피치가 덜 나가게 보이게 됩니다.
Love how vindicating this is, when Xiumin said vocals are more important than singing everyone got offended, when aespa sang live everyone glossed over it and started criticising them for something out of their control, choose, stable vocals which means you have to preserve your energy, or a whole lot of choreo with no substance, this is fun, anyways, last I checked, idols are experienced and enjoyed for their singing more than anything, appreciate aespa.
We all know they ate when it comes to live vocals, the people didn't just like their lack of stage presence. And i thought myself too that SM did not invest on their stage production. Well, there is still next time. I'm sure it'll be better than their last performance.
aespa's concept is about defeating black mamba, i don't think they need to sexy expressions, cute expressions or smiley expressions that much. i think their charisma is enough but newer stans focus only on excessive expressions that don't match the song. just see lee hyori's performances, the epitome of charisma
And these girls were just debuted then. I know you cannot compare new groups to BP but what about this literal rookies singing their lungs out?? If they still want to defend lsrfm then they are just deaf..😵💫
Their performance cannot be compared to bp but it is insane for a rookie group to sing like this, their vocals are on the NEXT LEVEL, they just need a little more stage presence. I am sure if they performed this time they would have definitely bought a DRAMA
Lia who is getting hate for her vocal because she can't just hit a high note is better than her vocal Because its so stable and clear Why the work is not fair?
카리나 머리 돌리는 거 진짜 잘함 어떻게 저렇지.. 그리고 라이브 잘하고 못하고로 까인다기 보다도 라이브 할 수 있는데 안 시키니까 소속사가 욕 먹는게 대부분임. 에스파가 잘못한게 아니라. 소속사도 그렇고 그냥 라이브를 안 시키는 요즘 음방 시스템도 그렇고 아주 맘에 안 듦.
애초에 라이브 실력으로만 까면 상관없음 근데 꼭 외모나 비하성 짙은 말들로 까니까 웃긴 거지 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 여태 라이브 논란됐던 3, 4세대 아이돌들 다 여돌임 남돌들은 조금이라도 까면 팬들이 애들이 긴장해서 그런거다 뭐다 이런 말들 나오고 여돌은 시녀짓 해줄 팬들도 거의 없어서 까판되는거고 하여튼 그냥 죄다 웃김
It's an upbeat song, how does it not fit the Coachella vibe?💀 Every type of music genre has been performed in the festival. Like Lana Del freaking Rey headlined this year🤣 so I don't see why this particular song or their setlist doesn't fit the "vibe" lmao. For the boring part, I can agree on that, SM pulled the trigger too soon for a Coachella set. But also this was in their rookie years iirc so they were heavily in their AI Era so their vibes were more aloof and muted. They have grown in stage presence since then, which makes me want to see them have another go at Coachella as they're more established performers compared to here.
so what is coachella vibes? all i know is since the beginning, coachella is about all kind of genres. pop, rnb, rock, ballad, country, edm, even traditional music from foreign countries were performed every year at coachella. you do realized that there are probably about hundred if not more singers every year, right? it was all day festival for more than a week, with multiple stages right? stop projecting you own belief if you don't know what coachella is 🤣🤣
I wish SM would allow them to sing live more often. Their vocals are insane
*There is a important reason companies don't let their idols sing live all the time, cause it can damage their voice*
Voice is smth that needs to be preserved ans saved for the best moments, idols most of the times sings live in concerts and performances as they should ofc, aespa also does that. It's just they r too good already. They don't always need to sing live.
@@yeonhee1767what about groups who always sing live since years ? 😂😂😂😂 stop making excuse. Most of lipsync groups is because they can’t sing. Aespa can sing but SM are just scared (they let exo sing live since day 1…). If you stan untalented groups it’s not our problem, but many groups slay each stage with live vocals and We all should praise them
@@Sullyoonaaaaa im not making excuses, i know facts that you don't, im a sm fan since 2018. and one thing that sm artists know how to sing live, they actually put that standard in kpop. In music bank stuffs they don't really sing live, the company doesn't let that happen either. And it's good for them.
but they do sing live, watch their concerts you'll know.
@@Sullyoonaaaaa dude why u so stupid, they can sing live ik, but often singing live can damage their vocal cords. *THIS AIN'T NO EXCUSE.*
You thought they are lypsinc...look at this they eat CDs duhhh...unlike other groups who is not stable even they are only standing...
I love ning ning stage presence and her confidence.
And now people realize how much important vocals than anything else for idols
Do u listen pre recorded mmm 😂😂
@@veronikapeshkova3892It ain't pre recorded babe
@@veronikapeshkova3892lol pre-record is a no no in Coachella. It's not inkigayo or music core stupid. Hahaha
For aespa yes not every group has to be the same k pop is a music genre it doesn’t all have to be the same
Stupid @@veronikapeshkova3892
AESPA deserves an apology. I blame SM because it was so last minute and there was hardly promotion or hype about Aespa at Coachella, but they did very well and clearly they have the talent to prove they deserved that stage.
Coachella year was indeed hard for mys 😔 we had to deal from so much hate even when the girls were doing there best
It came from those blink, i would never forgot that moment ....
@@butterflai_their boring ass fuck not good enough for BP Level and nobody know who are they😂 nugu girl grup sudenly appear and the agency even say "aespa is the first girl grup who invite in main stage cochella"😂😂 very embarrassing..in fact nobody know them 🤣😂🤣...BP always on another level their present always bring hype and every body know who they are..
@@ranisa6567It's true that æspa GG was the first to perform on the main stage, because previously BP perform on the SAHARA stage, and that was a different stage.
Don't tell me you don't know about that?😂😂😂
Very embarrassing
As a Blink and a MY I am so sorry. Some psychotic blinks make the fandom look so bad and now all of a sudden they are praising aespa as a reason to hate on Le Sserafim. I won’t forget the hate and hateful reels that went around flaming Aespa during that time. I love aespa they have some of the absolute best vocals in Kpop. I wish I could hear them sing the Tetris song in person, i would die happy.
As an multistan it hurts
you did well aespa
At this level, a new singer can be called fearless.🎉
This gave me chillss. Their vocals are so good!
This what we call Talented idols❤
Now k-netizens realize that without vocals performance is nothing 😵
I got goosebumps. Ningning is really top tier
After hearing only Giselle’s back soundtrack in this part, so heavenly and mesmerizing I will NEVER skip black mamba and definitely always appreciate such a magical song.
Ning Ning is the Mother of mothers
와 개잘하네 이때 당시엔 왜 욕 먹음?
Their stage present not that good..boring..
@@ranisa6567true, but they have immensely improved since spicy era ;-;
@@ranisa6567because they were 1 year old when they performed at Coachella, and I don't think it was boring, because I was there at that time
are you there too?
Because SM post that time , Aespa is the first girl group that perform Coachella main stage.. and their stage presence is not good enough
That's why were criticize that time
What the heck is a stage presence.. Their vocal and performance looks good enough. Are they expecting some kind of aura oozing out of Aespa?
Woo I know why Hype was scared about Aespa, they are amazing!!
vocal mereka ga mengecewakan sii, semoga besok diundang coachella lgiii yaaa aespaa😍
y'all really owe them a apology😭😭
Finally a real prove to show people who said they can't sing live 🤗🤗🤗
Ning❤❤
뭐가 어찌됐건 살아보니깐 사람들은 어떤식으로든 까내리는 특성을 가지고 있음. 이래나 저래나 욕먹고 잘하나 못하나 싫어 하는 사람들 계속 싫어함 평생 남 욕하고 까내리고 사람이라는 게 본성이 어쩔 수 없음 나는 그냥 뭐가 됐건 저렇게 열심히 해주고, 노력을 해서 저 자리에 갔을테니 응원해주고 싶음.(그리고 한 가지 말하고 싶은 거: 지금 욕하는 분들 회사나 다른 일 할때도 완벽하게 하면 인정, 근데 완벽하지도 않으면서 남 까내리는 거 본인한테 쪽팔리지도 않으세요?)
각 케이팝 그룹은 자신의 이야기를 가지고,연수생 일 동안 많은 어려움을 겪고. 사람이 진정으로 케이팝을 사랑한다면 그/그녀는 상관없이 그/그녀의 마음에 드는 것이 무엇인지,각 케이팝 그룹을 감사하지해야합니다... 그건 그렇고,나는 당신에게 당신의 인생에서 최고의 소원.😊🥰
진짜 인정.. 지들이 손꾸락으로 싸지르는게 똥인지 된장인지 구분도 못하고 .. 어휴 과도하게 비난하는 너거들이 악플러라는거야 ㅠㅠ
@@hyencock 진짜 우리나라 네티즌 역겨움 악플로 몇사람 보내고도 정신을 못차려요 자기가 뱉은 말은 다 돌아온다는거 알았으면 좋겠네
진심 인정
조금 미끄러지니까 우르르 달려와서 끌어 내리는거 너무 역겨움.
사람들이 그렇게 좋아하는 블핑도 한참 활동할때 엄청 까였었음 이제는 세대가 바뀌니까 타겟이 바뀐거지 나중에는 다른그룹 깔듯 에스파보다 못하는 그룹은 많은데 유독 에스파한테만 잣대가 깐깐함
You deserve apology
they are the actual fearless
에스파가 까이는 이유: 실력 자체는 이렇게까지 까일정도 아니고 깔 생각도 없었지만 sm이 블랙핑크 내려치기하는 ㅂㅅ같은 언플해서 없던 안티도 만들어버림
결론: sm이 sm했다
애초에 저런 대형 콘서트도 안하고 갑자기 코첼라 보내기...
이게 ㄹㅇ임
자꾸 스엠 언플탓하면서 애들 까지 마셈ㅋㅋㅋ 막말로 언플은 스엠이 햇지 가만히 잇던 에스파가 무지성으로 개억까당하는데 언플때매 깐다는 뭣같은 포장 좀 작작해ㅋㅋ 그거때매 그칸다 할거면 비난이 아닌 비판을 하던가 별의별욕은 다해놓고 언플때문에 지들이 악플단다는걸 정당화시키네
@@njm6980 ㅇㅈ
@@njm6980 맞지... 언플 심해서 욕먹을 수 있음. 근데 왜 욕먹는 대상이 sm이 아니라 에스파임?
It was the first time they performed to a large crowd and they did a great job. Congrats Aespa.
aespa were more close to being a 1 year group and lsrfm is closer to being a 2 year group when they performed at coachella. giselle is also the main rapper who only trained for 10 months, singing better than other groups' main vocalist. aespa's black mamba choreography is harder than lsrfm's choreo too. aespa was also performing live yet preparing for coachella.
hybe should invest on vocal and rap training rather than buying awards
Who said that aespa messed up at Coachella they also slayed...🔥🔥
Aespa ha mejorado muchísimo desde su debut, eso me alegra
Aespa en coachella es otro nivel
SLAYYYY
전체적으로 보면 괜찮게 한거 같은데 안좋은 부분만 편집되어서 떠돌아다니더라
ㅎ ㅏ
안 좋은 부분이 ㅈ나 많은게 문젠데요? ㅋㅋ
@@sjjkdok8475 reading this comment after Le Seraphim Coachella made me giggle 🤭 what bad parts
I think this is their first real live perform. Look at how ning ning strugles, but i appreciate it, they make more lives, gud girls, mmmmm🎉🎉🎉
Some groups need to take notes...
I wish they redeemed their stage performance this 2025. They deserve all the love in the world ❤
ngl, aespa songs r really hard to cover 😂 so intense and i love it!!!
Love there vocals❤
Ningning stopped her high note/run since she had to be back, dance and get along with the others' move.
Queens of choachella
Still the best I heard Aespa sang live, the greatest vocals ever....👍👍👍
Winter white mamba
윈터 거울속에~는 불렀고, 이끌어져버릴은 안부르고 ar소리만 들리네요. 그다음 환영인걸까 는 다시 부르기 시작.
즉 라이브 안해도 거의 라이브처럼 들리는 ar깔아놓고 그냥 라이브로 더블링 친거임.
네 알아내셔서 축하드립니다 이제 느그어머니 안부나 확인하러가세요
방구석 ㅈ문가등댱
그렇게보면 ar보다 잘부르는게 되는군데
@@이승-c7d 음원 ar과 라이브 ar은 다릅니다. 라이브처럼 들리게 일부로 깔끔하지 않게 ar녹음한거에요.
@@이승-c7d 그리고 ar보다 잘불렀다기보단 ar보다 크게 불렀다는게 좀 더 정확한 표현입니다.
자신있거나 부르고 싶은 부분은 ar보다 소리를 크게 내어 라이브소리 비중을 키우고, 자신없는부분은 안부르거나 라이브소리 비중을 줄여 ar소리 위주로 나오게 되는거지요.
자신없는부분에서 라이브를 작게하면 피치가 나가더라도 ar에 묻히거나 적당히 섞여 피치가 덜 나가게 보이게 됩니다.
Love how vindicating this is, when Xiumin said vocals are more important than singing everyone got offended, when aespa sang live everyone glossed over it and started criticising them for something out of their control, choose, stable vocals which means you have to preserve your energy, or a whole lot of choreo with no substance, this is fun, anyways, last I checked, idols are experienced and enjoyed for their singing more than anything, appreciate aespa.
읭 연차 별로 못 쌓은 거 치곤 괜찮은데? 못한다는 생각은 안 드는데 에스파는 유독 심하게 까이는 듯... 20대 초 어린 여자애들에게 대체 먼 억감정이 있어서 그런지 참
내말이; 스엠언플탓 지리게 하면서 지들이 무지성 개억까하는걸 정당화 시키는것도 구역질남
연예인이라는 이유로 무지성 억까 해도 된다는 멘탈 가진 것들 너무 많아 요즘…에휴 세상 요지경
@@njm6980 그러게요 언플 때문에 화났다고 악플을 달아도 되는건지ㅜㅜ; 분노표출의 방법은 다양한데 말이죠... 왜 본인의 품격을 떨어트리면서까지 싫어하는지 모르겠음.
실력파 빌드업 존나 치고 블핑 까다가 돌려받은거지 ㅋㅋ
@@tshd4B2ZNWS 결국 회사 잘못을 소속가수에게 화풀이한다 이말이군요...쩝
The best K-Pop live vocal performance in Coachella
Who’s here after le sserafim performance
👇
💀
Meeeee❤
Hybe girls could never
And people say aespa can't sing live!
Yess aespa
차라리 이젠 그룹형 많이 나왔으니까 제대로 라이브 가능한 가수 솔로로 나오면 좋겠다..다이어트도 적당히 시키고
Winter looks like a soloist
Yeah I don't know why they just gave her white outfit
@@btsismyoxyjin2013 u watch this video after a year 😭
@@shubham_gupta9 I did watch the performance before not this short🤣
@@btsismyoxyjin2013 🤣🤣🤣🫂
@@btsismyoxyjin2013 btw where are you from???
아니 이어폰 끼고 듣는데 "너를 만나고 싶어" 이 부분에서 어떤 분이 냅다 소리 지름 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
We all know they ate when it comes to live vocals, the people didn't just like their lack of stage presence. And i thought myself too that SM did not invest on their stage production. Well, there is still next time. I'm sure it'll be better than their last performance.
aespa's concept is about defeating black mamba, i don't think they need to sexy expressions, cute expressions or smiley expressions that much. i think their charisma is enough but newer stans focus only on excessive expressions that don't match the song. just see lee hyori's performances, the epitome of charisma
LIVE VOCAL ARE TOP-TIER. Argue with the wall if some of you not agree 👅
THE VOCAL 🔥
근데 무대 장악력이나 여유같은 부분에선 떨어지는게 사실이긴 한데 라이브 실력만 놓고 보면 평균 이상 아님? 음향 한 번 만지고 나가는 음방도 아니고 완전 쌩라이븐데 잘하는데?
윈터는 이게 맞는데 냉정하게 닝닝은 그렇진않음
자기 평소 할줄아는거랑 명백하게 역량차가 너쿠 심함 아마 대형무대 보컬 모니터링이랑 멘탈 관리 둘다 실패한느낌.. 비슷한 환경에서 리허설 많이 시켰어야했는데 아쉽
에스파 노래는 개썅마이웨이 컨셉노랜데 저렇게 큰 해외콘서트는 호응도 유도하면서 해야될것 같은데 하면서 ㅈㄴ갈등됐을듯ㅋㅋ
윈터는 잘하는거 인정, 카리나는 평타침, 지젤 닝닝은 솔직히 개구린데…
그걸초월한상태로 무대를하는곳이 코첼라임 이런쉴드는 에스파만 더 욕먹일뿐
@@두룹-q5y 아니 그니까 그거 다 차치하고 딱 라이브만 놓고 봤을 땐 솔직히 타아이돌들에 비해 유달리 못하지도 잘하지도 않는 것 같은 평균적인 수준인 것 같은데 이렇게까지 영상 퍼나르면서 조리돌림 당할 수준이냐는거지..ㅋㅋㅋ 쉴드는 무슨 쉴드임ㅜ
Actually I can detect this is jbl serious beside aespa good vocal + good speaker 👽😎
Winter so stable
And these girls were just debuted then. I know you cannot compare new groups to BP but what about this literal rookies singing their lungs out?? If they still want to defend lsrfm then they are just deaf..😵💫
Their performance cannot be compared to bp but it is insane for a rookie group to sing like this, their vocals are on the NEXT LEVEL, they just need a little more stage presence. I am sure if they performed this time they would have definitely bought a DRAMA
@@Blink-o3j yeah
For a moment I thought she was Lisa
WinNing is Fire
Wings 😫
TVXQ de SM lo haria muuuy bien en coachella 😮
Lia who is getting hate for her vocal because she can't just hit a high note is better than her vocal
Because its so stable and clear
Why the work is not fair?
아이돌이 노래만 부르는 것도 아닌데 가수 취급 오지고 ㅋㅋㅋ 춤 못 추면 또 댄서 취급… 한숨 언제까지 아이돌한테 각박하게 굴래
가수가 노래를 안하고 춤도 전문댄서보다 못한데 노제가 아이돌데뷔했으면 지금쯤 몇백억씩 벌었겠네
Which company let idols sing live?
I expected ningning to have the upper hand in voice control. Nevertheless, I'm glad they did their best
Who's that screaming brutally😭
Mys 😭
갸잘한다
윈터 노래 개잘해 카리나 핵 이뻐
노래 제목이 뭐야 🫰☺️
카리나 머리 돌리는 거 진짜 잘함 어떻게 저렇지.. 그리고 라이브 잘하고 못하고로 까인다기 보다도 라이브 할 수 있는데 안 시키니까 소속사가 욕 먹는게 대부분임. 에스파가 잘못한게 아니라. 소속사도 그렇고 그냥 라이브를 안 시키는 요즘 음방 시스템도 그렇고 아주 맘에 안 듦.
블랙핑크가 데뷔2년차에 넘사였구나
거품 걷히니까 여실히 드러나네..
진짜 과하게 무슨 사이비 종교마냥
팬들이 오바떨긴했음 손짓 한번만 척 해도 무슨
막 천재라니 여유로운거 보라니 무대 장악했다고
난리 난리를 걔네는 걍 신천지임 신천지
ㄹㅇ
광신도들보다 악플러가 더 꼴불견ㅋㅋ
사이비종교마냥 팬들이 오바 떨었다기엔.. 걍 에스파 유튜브에서 존나 까이던거밖에 생각 안나는데 ㅋㅋㅋ
그정도 유난은 어느 아이돌이든 다 떨어요 에스파는 오히려 데뷔때부터 꾸준히 욕만 존나 먹었지
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ종내 웃기네 신천짘ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ하긴 맞지
@@user-uq4it9dk1b 사이비 종교마냥 슴빠들이 오바떨었던거 맞아. 이거뿐만아니라 평소에도 무슨 신마냥 찬양하는 꼴이 아주 꼴값이였음
연예인이 싫으면 보지 마세요...ㅠ 릴스에 계속 뜬다, 피드에 뜬다 그냥 스킵하고 관심 없음 누르세요... 왜 굳이 싫어하는 사람들한테 감정 쏟음?
지젤 얼굴 시선강탈하네
에스파 짱
애기들한테 왜이렇게 야박한지…. 아직 대뷔한지 얼마 안된 어린 여자애들인데 저정도면 대박 잘한거고 긴장해서 실수해도 그럴 수도 있지
데뷔한지 2년입니다. 블랙핑크도 2년차에 코첼라 무대 섰구요.
더이상 신인 타이틀은 오히려 욕입니다.
코시국이라서 관객있는 콘서트 경험이 없이 갑자기 큰 무대에 섰던 것이 패착이라면 패착이었죠... 윈터도 이 비슷한 언급한적 있습니다.
@@songsong- 2년이건 20년이건 사람이 긴장 할 수도 있지 도대체 지들이 무슨 상관인지 모르겠음 맘에 안들면 팬 안하면 되고 안 보면 되는거 아님?
@@이예정-i4j 맞아요 마음에 안들면 안보면 되는거에요.
근데 실력이 부족해서 마음에 안들면 안보면 끝이지만, 질타를 받는 이유는 겸손하지 못한 태도인 것 같네요.
ㅋㅋ 신천지수준으로 빨아주는애들이 여기있었네
그럼 가수를 하지말아야지 준비되고 데뷔하는거아님?
잘했는데ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
닝닝 열라 욕하더니
잘하네ㅋ
잘하는데 ?
SM이 YG한테 비주얼이나 춤은 비빌수 있으나 라이브는 못비비지
JYP:J무룩...
비주얼도 카리나 윈터 빼고 ...
@평백현 그 블핑이 모든그룹 쌈싸먹음
으악 오글거령
제왑 이제 기죽을 필요없음 엔믹스가 라이브 하나는 독보적이라고 생각함
ㅋ ㅋ? 뭔 개소리지
저렇게 이쁘면 노래도 잘하는건가?
댓글로 까는사람들 뭐가그렇게 잘났다고 열심히 활동하는데 까대는지 ㅋㅋ 본인못난거 티 팍팍 내는게 젤한심
사람들 무서운게 ㅋㅋ 어느 아이돌이든 제일 못한 라이브 영상에다가 이게 진짜 실력이지 거품 걷히니까 실력 드러난다~~이럼
@이방원 나얼이 아이돌이나고 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅋㅋ 제발 제에발 좀 맥락에 맞는 소리 좀 합시다
@이방원 나얼이 춤추냐?
@이방원 비교를 하려면 똑같이 ‘춤추면서’ 노래하는 사람 데리고 와야지 나얼 타령이누
@이방원 대가리 골빈걸 굳이 ㅠㅠ
@이방원 그렇게따지면 조용필,임영웅 그런사람도 아이돌이야 아ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
애초에 라이브 실력으로만 까면 상관없음 근데 꼭 외모나 비하성 짙은 말들로 까니까 웃긴 거지 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 여태 라이브 논란됐던 3, 4세대 아이돌들 다 여돌임 남돌들은 조금이라도 까면 팬들이 애들이 긴장해서 그런거다 뭐다 이런 말들 나오고 여돌은 시녀짓 해줄 팬들도 거의 없어서 까판되는거고 하여튼 그냥 죄다 웃김
윈터만 솔로데뷰하는걸로 ~*^^*
멤버들 다 이거 전무대랑 블맘까지 잘했음 닝닝이만 세비지때 긴장해서인지 무대 연달아 계속 고음해서 목소리가 떨린거지
@@그까이거뭐 jjang깨가 jjang깨가 하는거고 구냥 다 별론디 ㅋㅋㅋ 닝닝이는
@@닝닝-c5f 뭐래 지랄 하지마세요
@@닝닝-c5f 처나대지마 니는ㅋㅋ 이때다싶어서 선존나넘네
@@그까이거뭐 세비지아니고 넥레에요 세비지때는 무난하게 질햇어요
지젤 앞머리 보호좀 해줘라
님들 춤추면서 라이브하는게쉽지가않아요 요듬괴물신인들이많아서그렇지
ㅋㅋㅋ이게무슨
그걸 잘해야 아이돌을 하지 뭔 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
회사의 잘못된 언플탓에 에스파는 물어뜯기는게 좀 안쓰러울지경.. 회사에서 저런 큰 무대는 다른 무대 조금이라도 더 서보게 하고 내보내는게 조금더 나았을것같다는 생각에 아쉽기도 하다.. 그 이상 그 이하도 아님
뭔 언플때문에 까이는거래 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 진실을 있어보이는 사실로 덮지마라.
팩트는 윈터빼고 무대성량 1도 못내는 나머지 멤버 보컬 성량이 문제여서 까이는건데 ㅋㅋㅋ
여태 무대 여럿했어도 그게 다 립싱크로 카바친거
요즘은 걍 여돌 까는게 유행인것 같어..
삐끗만 해도 살인자 마냥 달겨드네
노래불러야되니까 개 살살춤
그럼~ 노래안부를땐 빡세게라도 춰야지ㅋㅋ
닝닝 라이브가 좀,,,,ㅋ
그러게요 정말잘하네용^^ㅎㅎ 고음이 짝 올라가는게 크으 ㅎㅎ🥰 찌밥님도 인정하시군영!
@@nnn22_01 ㅋㅋ ㅋ ㅋ ㅋ님도 웃겨용
솔직히 점점 까는 정도가 지나친 거 같네요 솔직히 잘하지 않나요? 처음 저렇게 큰 무대 서보는 거일거고 그만큼 긴장도 몇배였을텐데, 그 중에 상반신 헤드 뱅잉 하는 춤까지 추면서 저렇게 빵빵한 노래까지 부르는데 좀 곱게 봐주면 안되나요?
Winter weren’t use the power to dance
난ᆢ 왜ᆢ 지젤 얼굴에서 정유라
얼굴이 보일까
에스파 보정을 얼마나 한거야 뮤비랑 완전다르네
@이윤서 ㅇㅈ 합니다
지들끼리 지랄을해라…
솔직히 에스파 실력 좋은 거 맞음 춤 추면서 노래 하기엔 좀 음정이 불안정하고 딸려서 그렇지 춤 안추고 노래만 부르면 잘 부르더만
They are good singers and talented but the song doesn't fit coachella vibes and the stage looks boring
Yeah...... And they were rookies at that time. Sm should have waited more.
It's an upbeat song, how does it not fit the Coachella vibe?💀 Every type of music genre has been performed in the festival. Like Lana Del freaking Rey headlined this year🤣 so I don't see why this particular song or their setlist doesn't fit the "vibe" lmao.
For the boring part, I can agree on that, SM pulled the trigger too soon for a Coachella set. But also this was in their rookie years iirc so they were heavily in their AI Era so their vibes were more aloof and muted. They have grown in stage presence since then, which makes me want to see them have another go at Coachella as they're more established performers compared to here.
@@Rozznessagreed
so what is coachella vibes? all i know is since the beginning, coachella is about all kind of genres. pop, rnb, rock, ballad, country, edm, even traditional music from foreign countries were performed every year at coachella. you do realized that there are probably about hundred if not more singers every year, right? it was all day festival for more than a week, with multiple stages right? stop projecting you own belief if you don't know what coachella is 🤣🤣
ar 모르면 닥ㅊ라 멀 잘하노 이젠!에엔 목소리 들어갔는데 삑사리 실화냐ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
Off topic but by this clip alone you can hear that Winter is the better vocalist
익룡좌 ㅋㅋ
지젤 비주얼 쩌는구만;;