Thanks everyone who voted us to revisit this. Really enjoyed going back to the movie and hope you guys enjoyed the breakdown. If you enjoyed this video then please subscribe to the channel th-cam.com/channels/q3hT5JPPKy87JGbDls_5BQ.html *Check out our BEST new videos below* *Agatha All Along Episode 7* - th-cam.com/video/bkcth_3zw8o/w-d-xo.html *Venom 3 Ending Explained* - th-cam.com/video/Bv4LSaNmgaU/w-d-xo.html *Penguin Episode 5* - th-cam.com/video/EtB0Brb_0Lc/w-d-xo.html *Smile 2 Ending Explained* - th-cam.com/video/v_OCIthvjzc/w-d-xo.html *Alien Romulus* - th-cam.com/video/g5iolGIag0M/w-d-xo.html
I'm Astonished nobody questioned that part Where Haley Jo is riding in a car with Bruce It must have looked like Haley jo was riding a self driving car
Whenever i watch this I cant help but think of that nate bargatze bit: “we just thought his wife wasn’t talking to him for like a year. That made more sense to us than him possibly being dead”
Toni Collette's acting in the scene where Cole is telling her about her mother saying she's proud of her is absolutely phenomenal. That scene tears me up every time. It's so genuine.
@@richardboss2892 one of the more underrated actors i can think of. Because she's known for her horror films and her TV series, she's been kind of typecast. Its not fair to her because she's shown the range. I really like her in 'Nightmare Alley', its a very subdued role but she makes you immediately buy-in to the type of person her character is. It's all very natural
When the film was released no one had a clue. There was no social media to reveal the ending, thank God. It was a genuine revelation and a brilliant one at that. We have become desensitised to ‘reveals and twists’ but at the time we were genuinely gobsmacked
yeah! I remember seeing it in the theater and jaws dropping. I think it's also because of how focused we were to see this child saying something so chilling. We were hanging on his words, missing the bigger picture. Amazing
I know Haley and Toni were rightly Oscar nominated for their roles, but I felt Bruce should've been as well. Classic film. Can't believe it's 25 years now.
Agreed. It's a totally different role than what he was used to at that time. Considering he had to do the movie to fulfill a legal issue with Disney, it's one or his best roles.
look at what was nominated over him and only one was actually remembered after the ceremony: one a typical feel-good story, one a political story, one a racism story, and one just because it’s a Woody Allen movie 🙄 he got screwed out of a nomination because of usual Oscar shenanigans
Haley did something on the bus going to the girls wake. They go by a cemetery, he looks out the window, then sits back so what he sees won't see him. No words, perfection.
This movie and The Others had the most astonishing unforeseen plot twists at the end. They both surprised the hell out of me, and they are two of my all time favorite movies. I love when they are so well written that you can't see what's coming.
Both are similar to some Are you Afraid of the Dark episodes One about a teen who doesn’t know he is dead and only can talk to his sister, his mom ignores him and the other about a boy playing with some kids who say the old man is haunting them when in reality the old man is alive and the kids are dead.
i agree my two favourite horror movies because in both i didnt guess the outcome. The scene with the girl in the communion dress with the puppet in The Others still haunts me to this day.
This is my favorite kind of horror movie because it’s not actually about the horror. It’s about the characters the story and the family drama. The horror aspect is the icing on the cake.
I was so blown away by the ending, I had to immediately rewatch it, and some things made more sense. Like when they were at little girl's house after funeral, or before, not sure, and they walked upstairs, I said " why doesn't anybody there think it's weird for this unknown man to be going up their stairs!?".
Yes! And I thought it was weird when Willis and the Collette are on the couch facing each other and Osmet comes in the door. I thought it was weird that they never spoke to each other. BUT, NOPE -DIDN'T FIGURE IT OUT!!
I remember seeing this at the theaters, and the audience was hooked. Very few movies have the audience react to the same things at the same time. The theater exploded with the revelation at the end🎉... I Enjoy these breakdowns of past movies. Brings back a lot of memories.
I watched it in the cinema too. When I finally realised the twist, I let out an audible gasp and everyone around me laughed. I guess I was last to get it. 😂
I was one of those that didn’t figure it out until the end. The shock of it still stays with me. Thank you for your video. I’ll need to watch this classic again with a new perspective!
It’s the most hackneyed ghost story twist that there is. I really hoped that this wouldn’t be the case when I first heard that this movie existed. But it was, again.
It freaks me out even more as an adult, realizing he was shot in the back of his head with no entry wound from the front. That wasn't self-inflicted, accidental or not. Gunshot wounds to the very back of the head are almost always murder.
@@chrystie_bowie I thought gunshot wounds mushroom outward? My thought was that the boy might have shot himself in the mouth, and the bullet came out the back of his head creating a large hole.
I recently rewatched this movie a week ago and one thing I did notice was that when Cole came home from school and saw Dr. Malcolm sitting across from his mom, he didn’t acknowledge Malcom’s presence. Instead he stayed silent and only spoke very quietly when answering questions so his mom wouldn’t hear.
The brilliance of this twist is that all of the clues are there, yet many people ignore them for various reasons. I recently rewatched it, and it holds up well even with knowing the twist.
I watched this movie for the first time on a flight 2 days ago! I already knew the twist but was shocked by how good Haley Joel Osmont was in this movie. What an impressive performance
I watched this in the cinema with my sister. Later, I had a boyfriend who hadn’t seen it, and I definitely wanted to watch it again, and it had gone to video. So, we went down to Blockbuster, and at check out, the lady said, “What an amazing twist!” I was so pissed because that little remark would ruin the experience! So, he asked me about the “twist” that he would now be looking for. I said, “Well, we are supposed to accept the premise that a disturbed child can actually see dead people and he has a child psychologist on his case that starts to buy into it.” So, that was the twist that he was looking for and afterwards he thanked me for not spoiling the movie.
Seriously whoever doesn't like this movie has absolutely no imagination! Excellent breakdown again Paul! I loved it! Osmett looks so different now. His parody of VP Candidate Vance is spot on! The kid still is great! I'd love to see a breakdown of Signs someday. That was wild casting Phoenix and Gibson together.
I am really adept at predicting how a film is going to develop and end. However, I literally got whiplash from the plot twist in this film. Truely gobsmacked at the end.
My grandpa had a HUGE salt shaker that he always used. It’s the only thing I wanted after his passing. I’m forever grateful to my mom for getting it for me.
This film and Signs are my 2 favorite M Night pictures. And yes, the first time I watched it, I had no idea he was dead the whole time. I do remember thinking some of the scenes felt off, but I probably just figured it was the directors odd way of doing the scenes; since I’d never seen one of his movies before.
@@manart6506So do I. Not all of his movies are great, but his style is interesting and unlike anything else in mainstream Hollywood, which I appreciate.
Another good movie with a plot twist is, The Other. It came out in around 1970. It's about two twin boys. My mom read the book. She said it was very disturbing. It's in a similar genre as The Others and the Sixth Sense. Good twist at the end.
It was too on the nose. It's the only criticism of the film I would make. She should have been dressed in black, but maybe bright red lipstick or a red brooch.
Why do people keep calling her the 'step' mom? There is never any indication she's not the parent, and her being the parent makes more sense. Is it just because people don't like to acknowledge that parents do this, and so adding in the step makes them feel better?
btw, some people have said that the scenes showing the meals not being finished and the book open part way also indicate business not being finished. something is incomplete.
Expertly done! This movie is one of the most harrowing, bittersweet, sad, clever and impressive films I’ve ever seen and I indeed didn’t catch the clue until the very end. You can never beat that first viewing and as far as emotional investment went, I was in over my head.
I was 21 when this film came out. My mate was one of the few people who had the Internet at home. I'd heard there was a twist and so I asked him to check out what it was. He went on those early spoiler sites (no way as good as heavy spoilers) and told me "he's dead." I spent the whole film thinking the kid was dead. I was shocked as anyone else in the cinema when I worked out it was Bruce. 😂😮😅
I am totally blind. I lost my vision about 10 years after this movie came out and I am so so so grateful to the powers that be that I was able to visually see this movie. It is a masterpiece.
I was lucky enough o watch this as a teenager in a whim group decision, without even know the genre of the movie. I thought I was watching a Drama at first. Love this movie and what an amazing twist.
I must have seen 10 breakdowns of this film after watching multiple times and I still learned some new things in this video. Very nice attention to detail! Man, I wonder how M Night’s career would have been if he hadn’t been painted into the corner of having “twists” all the time.
True story: went to this movie with a friend on opening night (we were 14). We were a few minutes late and ran full sprint into the theater, but accidentally went to the wrong screen for an earlier showing. We literally watched the VERY end when it's revealed that Bruce is a ghost, then the credits rolled and we realized what happened. We still made it to the right screen right as the trailers were ending and it dawned on us after the first scene with Donnie Wahlberg that we'd completely spoiled a twist ending for ourselves.
It's funny that you mention this twist along with Darth Vader being Luke Skywalker's father. Both were spoiled for me before I saw either movie. In May, 1980, my older sister and her then- boyfriend (now ex-husband) got to see an earlier screening of "The Empire Strikes Back" before my younger sisters and I did. Her boyfriend had a car and we younger siblings couldn't drive so we had to wait to get a ride to the theater from our working mother. They told us the twist before we had a chance to see the movie. I don't remember which of them blurted it out, but I resented it then and I still think it was mean-spirited now. Then when "The Sixth Sense" came out in '99, my then fiancé and I were walking into the movie theatre and someone coming out from an earlier screening walked by us and said, "Oh my God! I can't believe that he was dead the whole time!" I wanted to run after them and scream, "Shut up! Shut Up! SHUT UP!!!!" while smacking them. I didn't...barely. I asked my now husband if he had heard what they said. He hadn't. I sat through the movie fuming. They were both good movies, but I would have preferred to have been able to enjoy them without prior knowledge being dumped on me without my asking for it. I'm very careful about not spoiling movies, shows, and books for other people.
The scene with Lynn and Cole at the end makes me sob like a baby every time. It's what I wish I could hear from my mom. That she's proud of me. I was lucky enough to see this in the theater when it came out, before it was spoiled for me. It really was a twist NO ONE saw coming.
My 13 year old and I just watched this for our first time ever. (I know, I'm 25 years too late to the party.) Holy smokes, incredible movie! Haley Joel Osment is the best child actor I've ever seen. (I know he is still an actor.)
Two things I wanted to add that you touched on: 1. Cole’s Father glasses: I thought it symbolizes his gift beforehand, that he’s able to “see” clearly whereas the glass that used to be there acts as a barrier for others. 2. The first play that Malcolm goes to see that has Tommy as the lead, he mentions a boy that can “speak to the animals”, another point to his ability. And the last play with King Arthur, also served as a metaphor for him accepting his destiny.
Your first point made me wonder if the divorces of Cole’s parents and the first boy who shot Malcolm were due to raising difficult children who were acting strange and terrified all the time.
Never before nor since have I been so emotionally moved by a film, in the middle of what is now my fifth decade of of life. Breathtaking is the scope and persistence of these emotions over many re-screenings in a way no other film has, before or since. Much of my family was still alive in 1999, and as each has moved on I cannot help but relive all over again Cole and Malcom's journey. It is a painful but beautiful, poignant experience I am sure many of you share. 🏆
Truly one of the best movies ever made in my opinion! We all know Shyamalan has had made some stinkers since, but he will always be one of my favorite directors because THIS is what he’s capable of. Hats off to every single cast and crew member of this film
I saw this in a theater and when Toni Collette sits with Bruce Willis, I knew he wasn't there- and I knew that a mother would not normally let her son hang out with a man, a stranger, unsupervised. In my theater seat, I turned to my BF thinking he had seen it, too, but he was looking at the screen. I looked around me at others in their seats and didn't see anyone excited like I was. LOL. The end of the film didn't surprise me, but it was still worth watching, and I've watched it a lot since. Thank you for this vid. My favorite color is red and I never noticed the connection in this film to the paranormal. I'm not sure I connected Cole's red-penned free associating journal with that, I just thought he used red to express anger, but now I see it. Stuttering Stanley set the fire that killed his teacher, and the dead teacher tells Cole about his former stutter and his setting the fire that killed people at the school, but why does Cole seem out of character in the class scene when he is taunting his teacher? Was a ghost present then? Was Cole possessed? I've never been able to figure that one out.
Love to see all the clues in a row. There’s one in the beginning I think, the very first time the kid sees Malcolm across the street and acts very anxious. When Malcolm starts to follow him, he’s clearly trying to get away from him, ending up in the church. That wouldn’t be normal behaviour if Malcolm had just been a regular guy across the street. (I apologize if it’s in there, have to finish watching later)
Nah, seems like he was fortunate enough to be someone who felt a calling to his career -- he's genuinely trying to help a troubled child because he feels like he must, not like he has to -- he wants to help Cole because of his own interior motivations, not due to external motivations such as having to make a mortgage payment or disappointing a coworker or angering a boss.
@@MizzyLQ Yep, but sometimes a job sucks so much one finds oneself having idle daydreams of dying in one's sleep so one doesn't have to go in to work -- Malcolm luckily didn't have a job like that.
Is the teacher Stanley Cunningham redeemed? 14:19 When Cole and his teacher are talking before the play, I got the impression that the teacher gave Cole the lead to make up for calling him a freak. The teacher, of course, was shocked and disturbed that Cole knew that he'd been bullied in school because he had a stammer, with kids calling him "Stuttering Stanly" I've had a lot of conversations with people who condemned the teacher for lashing out against Cole, but considering how wrong footed the teacher was by Cole's revelation, and having a kid calling him "Stuttering Stanly (likely in the very same room he'd been called "Stuttering Stanly" as a child. In the very next scene Cole is seen in what may or may not be a principles office. But honestly I don't think Cole was in trouble for calling his teacher names. I think the teacher felt horrible about lashing out as he did, and to me that greatly redeems him. We don't know how much time has passed since the "Stuttering Stanly" incident. I think the casting for the play was not not long after, and to make it up to Cole, he gave him the lead. Stanly was shunned and bullied as a child, and I think the teacher could see that Cole was shunned and bullied, and yea, he saw that Cole was the "weird" kid. He also saw that the actor kid was a bully to Cole, and so assigned the role of 'village idiot" to that kid. If you think about it, and make a lot of assumptions that are not based on much from the film, we see that Stanly was quite a good teacher.
I dismissed so many clues because I attributed it to atmosphere. I had to see this movie the following week just to be sure that the director played fair with the audience. He did. One of my favorite horror movies.
Every Sat I take my elderly Mum shopping, sweetest woman ever, happy to do it since my Dad died recently..... but it can be tough, the poor thing is lost without her Husband of 50years...... but is tough The one thing that has been making it easier the last few weeks is knowing there'll be a new Breakdown to watch when I get home, you are really helping me keep sane, thank you so much guys for the content...... and keeping me sane every Saturday evening🤪🙃🤣
Guessing this movie in the first 10 mins when I saw it with a friend is my claim to fame. When it cuts to a year later and he’s sitting on the park bench, I leaned over to my friend and whispered “I reckon he’s dead and the kid sees him too” my friend said “don’t be silly, just watch the movie” because I had this in my mind, I noticed in the restaurant scene that his wife didn’t actually interact with him and KNEW I was correct! Fortunately for my friend (and myself apparently) at the end after the reveal he turned to me and said angrily “you’re SO lucky I didn’t believe you!” 😂 I’m just glad I had a witness and I bothered to say something to them or no one would’ve ever believed I guessed it so quickly!
The poison is Pine Sol. A general purpose household cleaner here in the States. I think you meant to say that it's Malcolm's ring Anna drops at the end, not hers. She's still wearing hers.
Technically speaking, the label on the bottle was a made up brand. But let's face it, that bottle is pretty iconic. It's like using the iconic Coke bottle and slapping a different name on it ;-)
Great breakdown! This movie is a forever staple in my favorites list. The scene with Toni C during the bike rider accident also gets me every time. I too lost someone very close to me and I imagine they think the same thing. When he says, "everyday", I breakdown 😭🎥
I also noticed that Malcolm was reading Vincent's notes, but I always thought he was referring to Vincent's experiences to see if Cole had the same ones. I like how Shyamalan probably assumed that's what people would think if they noticed.
I rewatched this movie after listening to a podcast talking about it and good lord does it hold up. Definitely not scary but much more emotional for me. That car scene near the end made me cry.
Yeah even though the ghosts scared me in some cases due to their injuries, I never realized it was a horror movie when I watched it as a child. It was more emotional than jump-scary, which I like
@@monicarenee7949, exactly the same for me. I don’t watch many horror movies because I loathe gore with a violent hatred. I put up with a bit here, because the film was so gripping. Also finally satisfying.
I just watched this movie for the first time, but I already knew the twist. It still got me trying to figure out how everything worked. What a good film wish I watched it sooner.
Hey what year did ya get the SUPERMAN figurine? Was it around 93? I remember the 80s DC figures, way better than the MARVEL secret wars ones. The SUPERMAN one you have Paul is prob from the DEATH OF SUPERMAN run.
@@heavyspoilers That was a beautiful part of yourself to share with us. You have high emotional intelligence and I love your passion for film… and your snark ❤
I figured this out a few minutes into the movie. I turned to my then movie producer wife and said, "Boy, they sure didn't break the budget on wardrobe." She asked, "Huh? Why would you say that?" I told her, "Bruce Willis has been wearing the exact same clothes since the first scene." We turned to each other and said, "He's dead!" We spent the rest of the movie pointing things out to each other like, "Look, no one is actually talking directly to him." "Look, everyone is ignoring him."
Haha same. I argued with my mom at the time. I was like,”the kid sees dead people. Bruce Willis is literally wearing the same thing and no one is talking to him”.
My mom is very well read. She figured out the twist shortly after he was shot. It took me a bit longer. I figured it out when the boy says, "I see dead people." And the Bruce Willis character goes on to question him and the camera does a close up of him. Great film! I agree it's M. Night's best.
Excellent breakdown of this film. You brought up some things I missed. I love this film. I think it was fantastic although sometimes you talk too fast. Lol but a great analysis.
M. Night was in the movie as an homage to Hitchcock, who was literally in every film he ever made. Hitchcock realized audiences were too busy looking for him and weren't paying attention to the rest of the film. So he had to put himself in earlier and earlier in the story, and eventually he would just show up in the opening credits to get his cameo out of the way to begin with. It's one reason why M. Night started taking acting lessons and gave himself more prominent roles in his films--so he was part of the film and not just a cameo to look for.
Watching this for the 1st time, and in the theater, when his death was revealed, the whole audience had a audible " gasp ". Today's world, if I don't want to see a movie without knowing a spoiler, I avoid social media before seeing it. If this movie was released today, it wouldn't have seen as brilliant because of it would have been spoiled by the internet.
Went to the cinema twice too see this! Brilliant film! Haven't seen it for years! After your breakdown, I'm gonna watch it again this week. Keep up your great work! Love your channel!
I saw this movie in the theater. I figured out that Malcolm was dead right away. After being shot, he said it didn't hurt anymore. With all that blood, that had to be the moment he died. There was no way he recovered losing all that blood. Throughout the movie, Cole was the only person interacting with him. When Cole said "I see dead people", Malcolm asked how often do you see them? Cole looking at Malcolm says "All the time".
Also at the girls' funeral the boy asks Bruce's character "you're not leaving are you?" And he says "no", but in the very next scene when the kid enters the girl's room he's nowhere to be seen
Great analysis! Very deep and thought provoking. As a psychologist, I found it fascinating. I loved this movie and watching your break down of it really uncovered the many layers and made me want to rewatch it. Thanks!
I wonder if the people who don't like it had the twist revealed to them? Even if you haven't seen this movie, it's kind of hard not to know he's dead now. Kind of like the reveal of Darth Vader being Luke's father doesn't have the same impact.
I don't understand that mentality because the movie is still great without any twist, it just switches from "supernatural horror" to "emotional drama". Like, you could tell the same story entirely from Cole's perspective, with every twist laid out from the start, and it's still compelling and sweet. A young boy has been tormented his whole life by ghosts, but finally encounters a friendly ghost that worked with children when he was alive. The ghost tries to help him and they become friends and ultimately help each other. I love rewatching the movie just because their relationship is so nice (not to mention Cole's relationship with his mom), no twists required.
Thanks very much. I'm not stupid academically and have several degrees but I don't pick up on things on films, subtle clues or Easter eggs. I very rarely guess what's coming and alot of time I ask my husband to explain a film to me after we watch it together 😂 this channel is a life saver.
I always found it strange others didn’t guess the end going into it. The line is, "I see dead people." And you see him get shot at the start. The best part is Cole telling his mother that her mother came to see her dance in school and was proud of her every day. That whole exchange with Toni Collette's reaction is just beautiful.
Whether one gets the twist early on or later the true beauty of it was that it was a revelation to Malcolm. Particularly because despite his youth, Cole is so empathetic that he discerns that Malcolm isn't ready to be told this yet, and must work towards it to heal his own heart and soul. It seems that Malcolm is denying the depth of his own heartbreak and guilt which in part is what has him in His current state. It also prevents him from forgiving himself. The other obvious issue is how a intense love for his wife and feeling like he also failed and hurt her. Of course there is the theory that a ghost that lingers hoping to lessen the grief of those left behind is actually compounding and lengthening the time of grieving. The story "The Lovely Bones" also illustrates this.
I absolutely love this movie! I can still remember how mind-blowing it was to realize that Malcolm was dead. I love your breakdown of the movie, and while I knew about the color red from someone else's analysis-along with some of the Easter eggs-you informed me of so much more! Bravo 👏
he couldv'e been, it it wern't for people and hollywood expecting him to always have a twist in his movies. it kinda limits his potential. i'm just glad he's doing low budget movies again.
My wife and I watched it, and liked it so much we has a friend come over to watch it. A little way into the movie, our friend said; "what's up with all the red?" My wife had only noticed the doorknob.
I appreciate this breakdown. I'm one of those people who would say I didn't like this movie. It was spoiled for me (by accident) before I had seen it, and that really tainted the experience. It felt heavy-handed and obvious when you know the twist ahead of time. Then with Shyamalan making undeniable stinkers afterward, I just felt like he always sucked. However, this does highlight hints and glimpses of genius that is there. I still see plot holes and find some moments too convenient for the sake of tricking the audience. That said, this reminded me of the heart and emotion the movie had. Although the twist was spoiled, I also cried during some of those moments you pointed out. Thank you! I'll be rewatching soon to give it another chance to change my opinion.
this movie has one of my favorite twists of all time, excited to see what I’ve missed! that moment of realization, oof, insane stuff I literally thought of “I am your father” too, you get me so bad
This movie is one of my all time favorites; I’ve watched it at least 25 times. But I never put it together that the red objects coincided with ghostly visits, that’s brilliant.
As you said, this is an outstanding film and what an opener to start your career by M. Knight, made a bit of a rod for his own back though starting so strong. luckily I saw this before the end reveal was spoiled and, no, I didn't see it coming, what a blood-chilling shock! I am also bought to tears throughout the film, it really tugs at your emotions, very effective story telling by Knight and the superb cast. I am generally not a fan of horror but this film is kind of honest with the horror side, not playing it for the sake of gore or jump-scares, shooting your popcorn across the room. A very careful path trod by the way the plot unfolds, as you say, signposting what is actually happening without tipping you off, M. Knight has never been better. Creepy and moving, well worth a watch, thanks for reminding me of this modern classic.
I remember seeing Haley Joel Osmont used to make me think of the line "I see dead people", but then it was quickly replaced with "Walker told me I have AIDS".
I've seen this film countless times, as well as much commentary about the film. One thing I am still not sure of: Did Cole know Malcolm was dead? Because while he was terrified of all of the ghosts at the beginning, he never seemed to fear Malcolm.
Cole did fear Malcolm when he first saw him. He started fast-walking to get away from Malcolm, then ran into the church to hide from him. He wasn't terrified, but he was scared. He didn't want to endure another encounter with a dead person. He didn't understand why he was seeing them, and some had physically hurt him.
Great vid as always. This has always been in my top 25 movies of ALL TIME. The writing, directing and acting were all brilliant. Toni Collete tears me up every time in the car scene, a testament to her acting ability.
Technically the guy in the back is not pointing it through Bruce Willis’s head. You can make the point but the video is pretty clear it’s pointing to the side of Bruce.
Thanks everyone who voted us to revisit this. Really enjoyed going back to the movie and hope you guys enjoyed the breakdown. If you enjoyed this video then please subscribe to the channel th-cam.com/channels/q3hT5JPPKy87JGbDls_5BQ.html
*Check out our BEST new videos below*
*Agatha All Along Episode 7* - th-cam.com/video/bkcth_3zw8o/w-d-xo.html
*Venom 3 Ending Explained* - th-cam.com/video/Bv4LSaNmgaU/w-d-xo.html
*Penguin Episode 5* - th-cam.com/video/EtB0Brb_0Lc/w-d-xo.html
*Smile 2 Ending Explained* - th-cam.com/video/v_OCIthvjzc/w-d-xo.html
*Alien Romulus* - th-cam.com/video/g5iolGIag0M/w-d-xo.html
lmao that camera was not aimed at him at all... REACH
Wait also you think he looked directly at the camera when he said “I see dead people” also??? Am I missing something?????
The red thing is a stretch surely!? There was red all through out the film regardless of ghosts, yes?
Your chair is also Red
I'm Astonished nobody questioned that part Where Haley Jo is riding in a car with Bruce
It must have looked like Haley jo was riding a self driving car
Whenever i watch this I cant help but think of that nate bargatze bit: “we just thought his wife wasn’t talking to him for like a year. That made more sense to us than him possibly being dead”
Loooooool
"This is a movie about marriage and about how hard marriage is. Even if you get shot, it's your fault."
Thought she was going to ask for a divorce at the dinner scene 😅
I love how the Chinese title was "He's a Ghost!"
@@ChunkyLover53😂😂😂
Toni Collette's acting in the scene where Cole is telling her about her mother saying she's proud of her is absolutely phenomenal. That scene tears me up every time. It's so genuine.
Wonderful acting, I agree
Me too. I cry like a baby during that scene every time.
@@richardboss2892 one of the more underrated actors i can think of. Because she's known for her horror films and her TV series, she's been kind of typecast. Its not fair to her because she's shown the range. I really like her in 'Nightmare Alley', its a very subdued role but she makes you immediately buy-in to the type of person her character is. It's all very natural
You're so right - Toni Collette is always superb!!
She's always been great in everything.
When the film was released no one had a clue. There was no social media to reveal the ending, thank God. It was a genuine revelation and a brilliant one at that. We have become desensitised to ‘reveals and twists’ but at the time we were genuinely gobsmacked
They all die on the perfect storm.
yeah! I remember seeing it in the theater and jaws dropping. I think it's also because of how focused we were to see this child saying something so chilling. We were hanging on his words, missing the bigger picture. Amazing
I went to a late night showing on new years. It was incredible!
I've enjoyed it twice as much since knowing the ending.
The good old days.
I know Haley and Toni were rightly Oscar nominated for their roles, but I felt Bruce should've been as well. Classic film. Can't believe it's 25 years now.
Agreed. It's a totally different role than what he was used to at that time. Considering he had to do the movie to fulfill a legal issue with Disney, it's one or his best roles.
look at what was nominated over him and only one was actually remembered after the ceremony: one a typical feel-good story, one a political story, one a racism story, and one just because it’s a Woody Allen movie 🙄
he got screwed out of a nomination because of usual Oscar shenanigans
Haley did something on the bus going to the girls wake. They go by a cemetery, he looks out the window, then sits back so what he sees won't see him. No words, perfection.
This movie and The Others had the most astonishing unforeseen plot twists at the end. They both surprised the hell out of me, and they are two of my all time favorite movies. I love when they are so well written that you can't see what's coming.
Agree! Love them both
Both are similar to some Are you Afraid of the Dark episodes
One about a teen who doesn’t know he is dead and only can talk to his sister, his mom ignores him and the other about a boy playing with some kids who say the old man is haunting them when in reality the old man is alive and the kids are dead.
The Tale of the Dream girl and the Tale of Old Man Cororan. Both very similar to 6th sense and the Others
i agree my two favourite horror movies because in both i didnt guess the outcome. The scene with the girl in the communion dress with the puppet in The Others still haunts me to this day.
Is The Others the one with Nicole Kidman? That was a GREAT movie! I was not expecting that ending at all!
This is my favorite kind of horror movie because it’s not actually about the horror. It’s about the characters the story and the family drama. The horror aspect is the icing on the cake.
I was so blown away by the ending, I had to immediately rewatch it, and some things made more sense. Like when they were at little girl's house after funeral, or before, not sure, and they walked upstairs, I said " why doesn't anybody there think it's weird for this unknown man to be going up their stairs!?".
Yes! And I thought it was weird when Willis and the Collette are on the couch facing each other and Osmet comes in the door. I thought it was weird that they never spoke to each other.
BUT, NOPE -DIDN'T FIGURE IT OUT!!
I remember seeing this at the theaters, and the audience was hooked. Very few movies have the audience react to the same things at the same time. The theater exploded with the revelation at the end🎉... I Enjoy these breakdowns of past movies. Brings back a lot of memories.
I watched it in the cinema too. When I finally realised the twist, I let out an audible gasp and everyone around me laughed. I guess I was last to get it. 😂
I was one of those that didn’t figure it out until the end. The shock of it still stays with me. Thank you for your video. I’ll need to watch this classic again with a new perspective!
It’s the most hackneyed ghost story twist that there is. I really hoped that this wouldn’t be the case when I first heard that this movie existed. But it was, again.
I also watched it blind and was so shocked at the reveal. The wife says something like 'why did you leave me' and that bit always makes me tear up.
That ghost of the kid who wants Cole to play with his Dad's gun and the reveal when the ghost turns away still freaks me out as well 😬
Got the chills again...remembering that part...
Man that scene got me when I was little. Scared the hell out of me
It freaks me out even more as an adult, realizing he was shot in the back of his head with no entry wound from the front. That wasn't self-inflicted, accidental or not. Gunshot wounds to the very back of the head are almost always murder.
@@chrystie_bowie concur...! more chills knowing that also...
@@chrystie_bowie I thought gunshot wounds mushroom outward? My thought was that the boy might have shot himself in the mouth, and the bullet came out the back of his head creating a large hole.
I recently rewatched this movie a week ago and one thing I did notice was that when Cole came home from school and saw Dr. Malcolm sitting across from his mom, he didn’t acknowledge Malcom’s presence. Instead he stayed silent and only spoke very quietly when answering questions so his mom wouldn’t hear.
The brilliance of this twist is that all of the clues are there, yet many people ignore them for various reasons. I recently rewatched it, and it holds up well even with knowing the twist.
'They only see what they want to see'
I watched this movie for the first time on a flight 2 days ago! I already knew the twist but was shocked by how good Haley Joel Osmont was in this movie. What an impressive performance
I watched this in the cinema with my sister. Later, I had a boyfriend who hadn’t seen it, and I definitely wanted to watch it again, and it had gone to video. So, we went down to Blockbuster, and at check out, the lady said, “What an amazing twist!” I was so pissed because that little remark would ruin the experience! So, he asked me about the “twist” that he would now be looking for. I said, “Well, we are supposed to accept the premise that a disturbed child can actually see dead people and he has a child psychologist on his case that starts to buy into it.” So, that was the twist that he was looking for and afterwards he thanked me for not spoiling the movie.
Seriously whoever doesn't like this movie has absolutely no imagination! Excellent breakdown again Paul! I loved it! Osmett looks so different now. His parody of VP Candidate Vance is spot on! The kid still is great! I'd love to see a breakdown of Signs someday. That was wild casting Phoenix and Gibson together.
Yeah Signs is definitely coming soon. They’re dropping the 4k this year and I’d love to talk about it
I do like the movie but I love other Shyamalan movies even more.
I am really adept at predicting how a film is going to develop and end. However, I literally got whiplash from the plot twist in this film. Truely gobsmacked at the end.
Definitely one of those movies that just totally hits all the emotional marks. You’re not the only one who cries every time during this movie 😭😭
Seriousssly, one of the best, most classic pieces of horror cinema ever.
Shit is so iconic.
My grandpa had a HUGE salt shaker that he always used. It’s the only thing I wanted after his passing. I’m forever grateful to my mom for getting it for me.
This film and Signs are my 2 favorite M Night pictures. And yes, the first time I watched it, I had no idea he was dead the whole time. I do remember thinking some of the scenes felt off, but I probably just figured it was the directors odd way of doing the scenes; since I’d never seen one of his movies before.
I love his style.
@@manart6506So do I. Not all of his movies are great, but his style is interesting and unlike anything else in mainstream Hollywood, which I appreciate.
Please do The Others next ❤
Yeah I definitely want to, got the 4k recently and it’s great
Omg that movie was So good!
That's a great film! Another one I figured out early in the film, but I love being right so. 😂
@ I did not catch it but I also was younger. I would figure out this twist out now lol it really got me though
Another good movie with a plot twist is, The Other. It came out in around 1970. It's about two twin boys. My mom read the book. She said it was very disturbing. It's in a similar genre as The Others and the Sixth Sense. Good twist at the end.
Haley Joel Osment in my opinion in a genius actor. Him in Pay it Forward!!! That movie makes me cry every single time
I forgot about that movie. Loved it. Haven't saw it in like 10 or so years
He was great in A.I with Judd law too
You should see his parody of JD Vance on jimmy Kimmel live the past few weeks.
That stepmom wore RED to her daughter's funeral. People shouldve been suspicious IMMEDIATELY.
I guess you could say it was a… red flag
Evil.
Stepmoms in red are THIGHT... 🤓
It was too on the nose. It's the only criticism of the film I would make. She should have been dressed in black, but maybe bright red lipstick or a red brooch.
Why do people keep calling her the 'step' mom? There is never any indication she's not the parent, and her being the parent makes more sense. Is it just because people don't like to acknowledge that parents do this, and so adding in the step makes them feel better?
btw, some people have said that the scenes showing the meals not being finished and the book open part way also indicate business not being finished. something is incomplete.
Expertly done! This movie is one of the most harrowing, bittersweet, sad, clever and impressive films I’ve ever seen and I indeed didn’t catch the clue until the very end. You can never beat that first viewing and as far as emotional investment went, I was in over my head.
I love these deep dives into classic films you do. You are one of the best movie channels on youtube.
Ey thank you
Agreed!
I hope he does shows I watch too like Severance. Him and Eric Voss are goats
Yes, I've watched loads of these deep dives, @heavyspoilers defo one of the best channels, keep em' coming!!!
@@heavyspoilers hope to see many more too 😊
I was 21 when this film came out. My mate was one of the few people who had the Internet at home. I'd heard there was a twist and so I asked him to check out what it was. He went on those early spoiler sites (no way as good as heavy spoilers) and told me "he's dead." I spent the whole film thinking the kid was dead. I was shocked as anyone else in the cinema when I worked out it was Bruce. 😂😮😅
I am totally blind. I lost my vision about 10 years after this movie came out and I am so so so grateful to the powers that be that I was able to visually see this movie. It is a masterpiece.
I was lucky enough o watch this as a teenager in a whim group decision, without even know the genre of the movie. I thought I was watching a Drama at first. Love this movie and what an amazing twist.
I must have seen 10 breakdowns of this film after watching multiple times and I still learned some new things in this video. Very nice attention to detail! Man, I wonder how M Night’s career would have been if he hadn’t been painted into the corner of having “twists” all the time.
True story: went to this movie with a friend on opening night (we were 14). We were a few minutes late and ran full sprint into the theater, but accidentally went to the wrong screen for an earlier showing. We literally watched the VERY end when it's revealed that Bruce is a ghost, then the credits rolled and we realized what happened. We still made it to the right screen right as the trailers were ending and it dawned on us after the first scene with Donnie Wahlberg that we'd completely spoiled a twist ending for ourselves.
It's funny that you mention this twist along with Darth Vader being Luke Skywalker's father. Both were spoiled for me before I saw either movie. In May, 1980, my older sister and her then- boyfriend (now ex-husband) got to see an earlier screening of "The Empire Strikes Back" before my younger sisters and I did. Her boyfriend had a car and we younger siblings couldn't drive so we had to wait to get a ride to the theater from our working mother. They told us the twist before we had a chance to see the movie. I don't remember which of them blurted it out, but I resented it then and I still think it was mean-spirited now. Then when "The Sixth Sense" came out in '99, my then fiancé and I were walking into the movie theatre and someone coming out from an earlier screening walked by us and said, "Oh my God! I can't believe that he was dead the whole time!" I wanted to run after them and scream, "Shut up! Shut Up! SHUT UP!!!!" while smacking them. I didn't...barely. I asked my now husband if he had heard what they said. He hadn't. I sat through the movie fuming. They were both good movies, but I would have preferred to have been able to enjoy them without prior knowledge being dumped on me without my asking for it. I'm very careful about not spoiling movies, shows, and books for other people.
The scene with Lynn and Cole at the end makes me sob like a baby every time. It's what I wish I could hear from my mom. That she's proud of me. I was lucky enough to see this in the theater when it came out, before it was spoiled for me. It really was a twist NO ONE saw coming.
1999 didn't have to go so hard but became the golden year of modern cinema
being john malkovich
The Cider House Rules (so underrated.)
@@au_barbGross. It canonizes an abortionist. Ghoulish and satanic.
Galaxy Quest
I saw it in the theater and absolutely did not see the twist coming. Still a favorite.
My 13 year old and I just watched this for our first time ever. (I know, I'm 25 years too late to the party.) Holy smokes, incredible movie! Haley Joel Osment is the best child actor I've ever seen. (I know he is still an actor.)
Two things I wanted to add that you touched on:
1. Cole’s Father glasses: I thought it symbolizes his gift beforehand, that he’s able to “see” clearly whereas the glass that used to be there acts as a barrier for others.
2. The first play that Malcolm goes to see that has Tommy as the lead, he mentions a boy that can “speak to the animals”, another point to his ability. And the last play with King Arthur, also served as a metaphor for him accepting his destiny.
Your first point made me wonder if the divorces of Cole’s parents and the first boy who shot Malcolm were due to raising difficult children who were acting strange and terrified all the time.
Love that, really good pickups
@@Luneowlthat makes sense.
In every photo of Cole from when he is a baby there is an anomaly, a light star, from when he was an baby
youre really stretching now
Oooh!! I thought the red gem on the sword was significant, but u couldn't really piece out why. Just like the red door knob
Never before nor since have I been so emotionally moved by a film, in the middle of what is now my fifth decade of of life. Breathtaking is the scope and persistence of these emotions over many re-screenings in a way no other film has, before or since. Much of my family was still alive in 1999, and as each has moved on I cannot help but relive all over again Cole and Malcom's journey. It is a painful but beautiful, poignant experience I am sure many of you share. 🏆
When they first show Malcolm meeting with Cole, Cole is actually running scared from him and tried to hide from him in the church.
"I'm going to see you again, arent I?" I'm paraphrasing but obviously that was a hint as well.
Truly one of the best movies ever made in my opinion! We all know Shyamalan has had made some stinkers since, but he will always be one of my favorite directors because THIS is what he’s capable of. Hats off to every single cast and crew member of this film
So sad about Bruce Willis. Such a great actor. One of my favorite actors.
So glad you did this movie - such a landmark film. Thank you!!!
He was on fire during this time, I hope Bruce can live comfortably from this day on
😢 I was thinking the same thing. Also just rewatched “Death Becomes Her.” So sad for what Bruce and his family are going through and I wish him well.
I love this movie and Bruce Willis! It is one of the only movies I didn’t predict the twist. My sister and I - grown women!- gasped out loud!!
It’s a brilliant film and knowing the ending doesn’t matter. It’s incredibly rewatchable, fun, subtly scary and emotionally enveloping
I just watched this the other day and still cry at the scene in the car when he’s talking to his mother and opening up to her
I saw this in a theater and when Toni Collette sits with Bruce Willis, I knew he wasn't there- and I knew that a mother would not normally let her son hang out with a man, a stranger, unsupervised. In my theater seat, I turned to my BF thinking he had seen it, too, but he was looking at the screen. I looked around me at others in their seats and didn't see anyone excited like I was. LOL. The end of the film didn't surprise me, but it was still worth watching, and I've watched it a lot since.
Thank you for this vid. My favorite color is red and I never noticed the connection in this film to the paranormal. I'm not sure I connected Cole's red-penned free associating journal with that, I just thought he used red to express anger, but now I see it.
Stuttering Stanley set the fire that killed his teacher, and the dead teacher tells Cole about his former stutter and his setting the fire that killed people at the school, but why does Cole seem out of character in the class scene when he is taunting his teacher? Was a ghost present then? Was Cole possessed? I've never been able to figure that one out.
Love to see all the clues in a row. There’s one in the beginning I think, the very first time the kid sees Malcolm across the street and acts very anxious. When Malcolm starts to follow him, he’s clearly trying to get away from him, ending up in the church. That wouldn’t be normal behaviour if Malcolm had just been a regular guy across the street.
(I apologize if it’s in there, have to finish watching later)
Shymalan put everything he had into this film. It was fantastic.
Clearly he put everything into it, as evidenced by him having nothing left for any movie that followed
Hey! It's @@EnricoPallazo !
@@mattgilbert7347 STEEEEEEERIIIKE!!
@@EnricoPallazo Unbreakable and Split are very good films.
The Last Airbender is a masterpiece but this is almost as good.
The worst part is the dude died and still had to go to work.
Nah, seems like he was fortunate enough to be someone who felt a calling to his career -- he's genuinely trying to help a troubled child because he feels like he must, not like he has to -- he wants to help Cole because of his own interior motivations, not due to external motivations such as having to make a mortgage payment or disappointing a coworker or angering a boss.
@@MM-jf1meThat was a joke.
@@MizzyLQ
Yep, but sometimes a job sucks so much one finds oneself having idle daydreams of dying in one's sleep so one doesn't have to go in to work -- Malcolm luckily didn't have a job like that.
Is the teacher Stanley Cunningham redeemed?
14:19 When Cole and his teacher are talking before the play, I got the impression that the teacher gave Cole the lead to make up for calling him a freak.
The teacher, of course, was shocked and disturbed that Cole knew that he'd been bullied in school because he had a stammer, with kids calling him "Stuttering Stanly"
I've had a lot of conversations with people who condemned the teacher for lashing out against Cole, but considering how wrong footed the teacher was by Cole's revelation, and having a kid calling him "Stuttering Stanly (likely in the very same room he'd been called "Stuttering Stanly" as a child.
In the very next scene Cole is seen in what may or may not be a principles office. But honestly I don't think Cole was in trouble for calling his teacher names. I think the teacher felt horrible about lashing out as he did, and to me that greatly redeems him.
We don't know how much time has passed since the "Stuttering Stanly" incident. I think the casting for the play was not not long after, and to make it up to Cole, he gave him the lead.
Stanly was shunned and bullied as a child, and I think the teacher could see that Cole was shunned and bullied, and yea, he saw that Cole was the "weird" kid.
He also saw that the actor kid was a bully to Cole, and so assigned the role of 'village idiot" to that kid.
If you think about it, and make a lot of assumptions that are not based on much from the film, we see that Stanly was quite a good teacher.
Yeah, I think Cole just shocked and startled the teacher more than anything.
I'd like to think the teacher ended up looking up the history of the place and found out they actually DID hang people in the courthouse.
When I saw this movie the first time, was so blown away I immediately gave it a second watching.
I did too
I dismissed so many clues because I attributed it to atmosphere. I had to see this movie the following week just to be sure that the director played fair with the audience. He did. One of my favorite horror movies.
Every Sat I take my elderly Mum shopping, sweetest woman ever, happy to do it since my Dad died recently..... but it can be tough, the poor thing is lost without her Husband of 50years...... but is tough
The one thing that has been making it easier the last few weeks is knowing there'll be a new Breakdown to watch when I get home, you are really helping me keep sane, thank you so much guys for the content...... and keeping me sane every Saturday evening🤪🙃🤣
❤
You being with your mother every Saturday is her weekly highlight. 😊
I didn't realize that M. Night got the idea for this movie from one of my favorite childhood tv shows! I have way more respect for the guy now
Guessing this movie in the first 10 mins when I saw it with a friend is my claim to fame. When it cuts to a year later and he’s sitting on the park bench, I leaned over to my friend and whispered “I reckon he’s dead and the kid sees him too” my friend said “don’t be silly, just watch the movie” because I had this in my mind, I noticed in the restaurant scene that his wife didn’t actually interact with him and KNEW I was correct! Fortunately for my friend (and myself apparently) at the end after the reveal he turned to me and said angrily “you’re SO lucky I didn’t believe you!” 😂 I’m just glad I had a witness and I bothered to say something to them or no one would’ve ever believed I guessed it so quickly!
The poison is Pine Sol. A general purpose household cleaner here in the States.
I think you meant to say that it's Malcolm's ring Anna drops at the end, not hers. She's still wearing hers.
Didn't he say "Pine cleaner"?
@@melindaluna3592sounded like pipe cleaner so I turned on the captions and that's what the captions thought he said too.
@@melindaluna3592
Ah, that's what he said -- I, too, heard "pipe cleaner" and was confused.
Technically speaking, the label on the bottle was a made up brand. But let's face it, that bottle is pretty iconic. It's like using the iconic Coke bottle and slapping a different name on it ;-)
Great breakdown! This movie is a forever staple in my favorites list. The scene with Toni C during the bike rider accident also gets me every time. I too lost someone very close to me and I imagine they think the same thing. When he says, "everyday", I breakdown 😭🎥
I also noticed that Malcolm was reading Vincent's notes, but I always thought he was referring to Vincent's experiences to see if Cole had the same ones. I like how Shyamalan probably assumed that's what people would think if they noticed.
I rewatched this movie after listening to a podcast talking about it and good lord does it hold up. Definitely not scary but much more emotional for me. That car scene near the end made me cry.
Yeah M Nights crazy good at making people cry in this one
Yeah even though the ghosts scared me in some cases due to their injuries, I never realized it was a horror movie when I watched it as a child. It was more emotional than jump-scary, which I like
@@monicarenee7949, exactly the same for me.
I don’t watch many horror movies because I loathe gore with a violent hatred. I put up with a bit here, because the film was so gripping. Also finally satisfying.
I would put it in the Suspense // Supernatural category . the Ghosts were Scary , but all Victims 🤔@@monicarenee7949
I just watched this movie for the first time, but I already knew the twist. It still got me trying to figure out how everything worked. What a good film wish I watched it sooner.
21:20 it's not weird, Paul. Makes total sense. Grandparents rule, glad Grandma Joan was a special person in your life
Thank you
Hey what year did ya get the SUPERMAN figurine?
Was it around 93?
I remember the 80s DC figures, way better than the MARVEL secret wars ones.
The SUPERMAN one you have Paul is prob from the DEATH OF SUPERMAN run.
@@heavyspoilers That was a beautiful part of yourself to share with us. You have high emotional intelligence and I love your passion for film… and your snark ❤
Just watched the film again for the umpthteenth time. It is a masterpiece of filmmaking and made me an M. Night Shyamalan fan for life.
I figured this out a few minutes into the movie. I turned to my then movie producer wife and said, "Boy, they sure didn't break the budget on wardrobe." She asked, "Huh? Why would you say that?" I told her, "Bruce Willis has been wearing the exact same clothes since the first scene." We turned to each other and said, "He's dead!" We spent the rest of the movie pointing things out to each other like, "Look, no one is actually talking directly to him." "Look, everyone is ignoring him."
Haha same. I argued with my mom at the time. I was like,”the kid sees dead people. Bruce Willis is literally wearing the same thing and no one is talking to him”.
Same! It was so obvious to me.
I cleaned theaters, saw the end before the beginning, sort of ruined the surprise 😂
I hope you still enjoyed it.
how inconsiderate to those seated nearby
My mom is very well read. She figured out the twist shortly after he was shot. It took me a bit longer. I figured it out when the boy says, "I see dead people." And the Bruce Willis character goes on to question him and the camera does a close up of him. Great film! I agree it's M. Night's best.
Excellent breakdown of this film. You brought up some things I missed. I love this film. I think it was fantastic although sometimes you talk too fast. Lol but a great analysis.
M. Night was in the movie as an homage to Hitchcock, who was literally in every film he ever made. Hitchcock realized audiences were too busy looking for him and weren't paying attention to the rest of the film. So he had to put himself in earlier and earlier in the story, and eventually he would just show up in the opening credits to get his cameo out of the way to begin with. It's one reason why M. Night started taking acting lessons and gave himself more prominent roles in his films--so he was part of the film and not just a cameo to look for.
Watching this for the 1st time, and in the theater, when his death was revealed, the whole audience had a audible " gasp ". Today's world, if I don't want to see a movie without knowing a spoiler, I avoid social media before seeing it. If this movie was released today, it wouldn't have seen as brilliant because of it would have been spoiled by the internet.
Haley recently did a skit clowning JD Vance. It was spot on. 😅 he also had a cameo on what we do in the shadows, hes great.
If you don't like this movie, then you don't like movies period. You can't say you enjoy any movie. Because this movie is purely gold.
“I see dead people” ranks 44th in AFI’s 2005 list of “100 Years…100 Movie Quotes”.
We're going to need a bigger boat
I'll be back
No, I am your father
Frankly my dear, I don't give a damn.
Bro, you killed it with the 'red'. Excellent breakdown.
..an absolute perfect film and an indepth review covering everything and some more.
Love it @heavyspoilers 👍🏽💯💯💯
Went to the cinema twice too see this! Brilliant film! Haven't seen it for years! After your breakdown, I'm gonna watch it again this week. Keep up your great work! Love your channel!
Ooooooo, the Breakdown I didn’t know I needed. ✌🏽
Hope you enjoy it Toni, thank you 🙏
Thanks your host Paul, this is one of my favorite movies even though it’s been many years since I’ve seen it. My whole family loves it.
I saw this movie in the theater.
I figured out that Malcolm was dead right away.
After being shot, he said it didn't hurt anymore. With all that blood, that had to be the moment he died.
There was no way he recovered losing all that blood.
Throughout the movie, Cole was the only person interacting with him.
When Cole said "I see dead people",
Malcolm asked how often do you see them?
Cole looking at Malcolm says "All the time".
Also at the girls' funeral the boy asks Bruce's character "you're not leaving are you?" And he says "no", but in the very next scene when the kid enters the girl's room he's nowhere to be seen
Great analysis! Very deep and thought provoking. As a psychologist, I found it fascinating. I loved this movie and watching your break down of it really uncovered the many layers and made me want to rewatch it. Thanks!
I wonder if the people who don't like it had the twist revealed to them? Even if you haven't seen this movie, it's kind of hard not to know he's dead now. Kind of like the reveal of Darth Vader being Luke's father doesn't have the same impact.
I don't understand that mentality because the movie is still great without any twist, it just switches from "supernatural horror" to "emotional drama". Like, you could tell the same story entirely from Cole's perspective, with every twist laid out from the start, and it's still compelling and sweet.
A young boy has been tormented his whole life by ghosts, but finally encounters a friendly ghost that worked with children when he was alive. The ghost tries to help him and they become friends and ultimately help each other.
I love rewatching the movie just because their relationship is so nice (not to mention Cole's relationship with his mom), no twists required.
Thanks very much. I'm not stupid academically and have several degrees but I don't pick up on things on films, subtle clues or Easter eggs. I very rarely guess what's coming and alot of time I ask my husband to explain a film to me after we watch it together 😂 this channel is a life saver.
One of my favourite movies ever! Really enjoyed this one mate! 👍
I always found it strange others didn’t guess the end going into it. The line is, "I see dead people." And you see him get shot at the start. The best part is Cole telling his mother that her mother came to see her dance in school and was proud of her every day. That whole exchange with Toni Collette's reaction is just beautiful.
Whether one gets the twist early on or later the true beauty of it was that it was a revelation to Malcolm.
Particularly because despite his youth, Cole is so empathetic that he discerns that Malcolm isn't ready to be told this yet, and must work towards it to heal his own heart and soul. It seems that Malcolm is denying the depth of his own heartbreak and guilt which in part is what has him in His current state. It also prevents him from forgiving himself.
The other obvious issue is how a intense love for his wife and feeling like he also failed and hurt her.
Of course there is the theory that a ghost that lingers hoping to lessen the grief of those left behind is actually compounding and lengthening the time of grieving.
The story "The Lovely Bones" also illustrates this.
Just came across this channel in the past few weeks, and the content is great. Love the movie analysis . Keep it up 👍
Thank you
I absolutely love this movie! I can still remember how mind-blowing it was to realize that Malcolm was dead. I love your breakdown of the movie, and while I knew about the color red from someone else's analysis-along with some of the Easter eggs-you informed me of so much more! Bravo 👏
Back when Shyamalan was hailed as "the next Spielberg"
he couldv'e been, it it wern't for people and hollywood expecting him to always have a twist in his movies. it kinda limits his potential. i'm just glad he's doing low budget movies again.
It’s a shame he felt he HAD to have a twist in every movie. They’re good to have, but nobody should feel tied to a trope.
@@blipblop9094it wasn’t the twists, it was the boring rehashes and unoriginal movies
…and then he believed it and kept trying to garner as much attention as possible on his movies but made them boring or unwatchable
My wife and I watched it, and liked it so much we has a friend come over to watch it. A little way into the movie, our friend said; "what's up with all the red?" My wife had only noticed the doorknob.
I appreciate this breakdown. I'm one of those people who would say I didn't like this movie. It was spoiled for me (by accident) before I had seen it, and that really tainted the experience. It felt heavy-handed and obvious when you know the twist ahead of time. Then with Shyamalan making undeniable stinkers afterward, I just felt like he always sucked.
However, this does highlight hints and glimpses of genius that is there. I still see plot holes and find some moments too convenient for the sake of tricking the audience. That said, this reminded me of the heart and emotion the movie had. Although the twist was spoiled, I also cried during some of those moments you pointed out. Thank you! I'll be rewatching soon to give it another chance to change my opinion.
Ey thank you, always good to read a comment like that after posting one of these vids
this movie has one of my favorite twists of all time, excited to see what I’ve missed! that moment of realization, oof, insane stuff
I literally thought of “I am your father” too, you get me so bad
The Sixth Sense is my second favourite M. Night film just behind Unbreakable.
I love that movie too along with the signs
This movie is one of my all time favorites; I’ve watched it at least 25 times. But I never put it together that the red objects coincided with ghostly visits, that’s brilliant.
As you said, this is an outstanding film and what an opener to start your career by M. Knight, made a bit of a rod for his own back though starting so strong. luckily I saw this before the end reveal was spoiled and, no, I didn't see it coming, what a blood-chilling shock! I am also bought to tears throughout the film, it really tugs at your emotions, very effective story telling by Knight and the superb cast. I am generally not a fan of horror but this film is kind of honest with the horror side, not playing it for the sake of gore or jump-scares, shooting your popcorn across the room. A very careful path trod by the way the plot unfolds, as you say, signposting what is actually happening without tipping you off, M. Knight has never been better. Creepy and moving, well worth a watch, thanks for reminding me of this modern classic.
This was such an epic film thanks for sharing these missed details
I remember seeing Haley Joel Osmont used to make me think of the line "I see dead people", but then it was quickly replaced with "Walker told me I have AIDS".
At the time I only saw the movie because of Bruce Willis. Loved the movie ever since and still think its M Night best movie yet.
I've seen this film countless times, as well as much commentary about the film. One thing I am still not sure of: Did Cole know Malcolm was dead? Because while he was terrified of all of the ghosts at the beginning, he never seemed to fear Malcolm.
Cole did fear Malcolm when he first saw him. He started fast-walking to get away from Malcolm, then ran into the church to hide from him. He wasn't terrified, but he was scared. He didn't want to endure another encounter with a dead person. He didn't understand why he was seeing them, and some had physically hurt him.
he seemed to towards the beginning
Great vid as always.
This has always been in my top 25 movies of ALL TIME.
The writing, directing and acting were all brilliant. Toni Collete tears me up every time in the car scene, a testament to her acting ability.
Technically the guy in the back is not pointing it through Bruce Willis’s head. You can make the point but the video is pretty clear it’s pointing to the side of Bruce.
Great job on this, watched the whole thing
This was a different movie to watch at the time. Haley was great in it. For him to go as a young Forrest to this character. He was brilliant!