Despite the fact that 18th Amnedment restored the federal parliamentary democratic spirit of the 1973 constution ,it was unable to disturb the preserved hegemonic position of Punjab which was frozen in perpetuity in the 1973 constution.Pakistan has to move towards consociational model of democracy in order to move forward.Tyranny of the majority enshrined in the 1973 constiution is harming the polity and society.
“Lack of ownership.” No. “Lack of responsibility for the fellow man.” The mind of a Muslim colonial is too narrow. The narrowness is ingrained because of the burden of history. Example. Men of Punjab never saw and felt the presence of Bengal. Looting and plundering the resources of Bengal for the benefit of the interest of West Pakistan never registered. No sense of responsibility towards East Pakistan. No idea of what constitutes freedom. No idea that freedom means responsibility. Having been enslaved for centuries, a colonial mind never bothered to stretch. Baluchistan offers one more example of the absence of responsibility Pakistan displays towards the people of Baluchistan. State rights. Federalism. Too complicated for a feeble mind of the Muslims. It’s not an accident that the feebleness of mind makes Pakistan a bankrupt state. “Absence of ownership?” No. Absence of intelligence is making Pakistan a playground for devils.
pakistan economic administrative problem has threee solutions 1- presidential system russian model 2- make new provinces on bases of ethnicityies and population 3- transfer the authority of direct taxation like income tax wealth tax to provinces and give a royalty money on their resources 4- Direct election of district mayor and tehsil mayor with all those collection of taxes like water tax property tax municipal tax and provincial financial commision award given to them
Mam you raised wonderful points especially regarding civil services👏👏👏
V good subject chosen. Appreciated from India.
Good effort to understand what our politicians think .
رہے مصطفی کمال تو۔۔ کم تعارف نہیں۔ مجبوری ہے
PIDE
کی گیسٹ کے لیے۔
موضوع سے ہٹ گئ محترمہ ۔
ان سے سندہ میں اکثر سوال کرتے ہیں کہ پی ایچ ڈی کا مقالہ کیا تھا۔ کبھی بھی نہیں بتاتیں۔
مصطفی کمال اپ کو تو نفیسہ شاہ کی جماعت سے یہی تو اختلاف ہے۔
اور درست ہے۔
Distribution of power to local elected bodies is done in maharashtra india before 1972, called Panchayat Raj,
This is actually democracy
you people should have a person from legal fraternity too.
دونوں مہمان اپنی اپنی جماعتوں کے رخشندہ ستارے ہیں۔ سندہ میں سب جانتے ہیں۔
نفیسہ شاہ بات یہ نہیں کہ اٹھارویں ترمیم خراب ہے۔ عام تاثر یہ ہے اور ہمارا یقین سندہ میں اس کے ثمرات حکمران جماعت نے سمیٹے ہیں۔
it was good if nafisa shah has communicate it in urdu
نفیسہ شاہ سیاسی سے زیادہ وسائل کا جھگڑا ہے۔
Despite the fact that 18th Amnedment restored the federal parliamentary democratic spirit of the 1973 constution ,it was unable to disturb the preserved hegemonic position of Punjab which was frozen in perpetuity in the 1973 constution.Pakistan has to move towards consociational model of democracy in order to move forward.Tyranny of the majority enshrined in the 1973 constiution is harming the polity and society.
bhae todaaa english meee likhe kee urdu mee smajhayee appp kyaa bolnaa chahrahee hain
“Lack of ownership.” No. “Lack of responsibility for the fellow man.” The mind of a Muslim colonial is too narrow. The narrowness is ingrained because of the burden of history. Example. Men of Punjab never saw and felt the presence of Bengal. Looting and plundering the resources of Bengal for the benefit of the interest of West Pakistan never registered. No sense of responsibility towards East Pakistan. No idea of what constitutes freedom. No idea that freedom means responsibility. Having been enslaved for centuries, a colonial mind never bothered to stretch. Baluchistan offers one more example of the absence of responsibility Pakistan displays towards the people of Baluchistan. State rights. Federalism. Too complicated for a feeble mind of the Muslims. It’s not an accident that the feebleness of mind makes Pakistan a bankrupt state. “Absence of ownership?” No. Absence of intelligence is making Pakistan a playground for devils.
pakistan economic administrative problem has threee solutions
1- presidential system russian model
2- make new provinces on bases of ethnicityies and population
3- transfer the authority of direct taxation like income tax wealth tax to provinces and give a royalty money on their
resources
4- Direct election of district mayor and tehsil mayor with all those collection of taxes like water tax property tax municipal tax and provincial financial commision award given to them
پائیڈ اپنی پالیسی خود بہتر سمجھیں ۔