ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 12 พ.ค. 2024
- Watch a fighter pilot react to Top Gun Maverick, the sequel to Top Gun. In these Top Gun Maverick clips, we see everything from training in the FA18 Super Hornet, to fighter pilots experiencing g-LOC, dogfights with a fifth generation fighter, and the impossible Top Gun Maverick bombing scene. Watch as Alex Bowman, Ex-US Navy Fighter Pilot and Aviator Instructor takes a look at these Top Gun Maverick flight scenes to tell us how realistic they are!
00:00 - Intro
00:38 - Maverick VS. Rooster
03:40 - Briefing Room
05:11 - Bombing Run Training
08:01 - Final Mission
11:40 - F-14A Tomcat VS. Fifth Generation Fighter
13:48 - Final Thoughts
Want to find out more about Alex Bowman? Make sure to check out his TH-cam channel ( / alexbowman_ventures ) and his Instagram (@atbowman)!
#IGN #Movies #TopGun - บันเทิง
Like in our first video, a MASSIVE thank you to Alex Bowman for lending his expertise to this video! Want to learn more about fighter pilot aviation? Check out Alex on his social channels! - Jesse
1) th-cam.com/users/AlexBowman_Ventures
2) instagram.com/atbowman/?hl=en
We should all just admit we like jet prawn
Thank you for your honest but not douchey commentating! Amazing. And thank you for your service. Most importantly, thanks for being a badass fighter pilot!
Alex Bowman...The NASCAR driver??
Dude has just about the best call sign 😂👏
He swipe right or left?
“Smoke in the air, swipe right swipe right!!!”
It could have been "grinder"
His back seat man is call sign Grinder😅
cant be taken serious with that name 😂
But was the volleyball scene accurate??? 🤔
They have to bring in a volleyball expert next
Hahahaha 🤣🤣🤣👍
🤣
It's football in this one
@@Yo_DynamoJoe are you some volleyball expert?
$25 says he’s been called “Grinder” by all his buddies!
He definitely had some time with the Marines 😂
Just because real fighter pilots can’t do this stuff doesn’t mean Tom Cruises can’t do it. Tom is a true American hero who never loses.
In movies 🎉😂
It's not a Top Gun movie without the legendary Grumman F-14 Tomcat.
More like obsolete. THE F15 is still our best fighter and came along with the F14 but its still our best air superiority fighter. 105 kills to no losses.
12:30 I've seen comments by other fighter pilots who mentioned Rooster actually messed up in the starting sequence for the F14. The reason the ejectable seats didn't work was not they were faulty, but Rooster didn't arm them before they took off (IIRC apparently you need to remove a pin somewhere to arm the seats, and Rooster never did that, most likely because he didn't know about it).
there are a bunch of pins to pull on a 14 seat.
Jeez people... it's a movie.
@@howboutusingyourhead7992 and this is just a comment Jeez LOL
@@howboutusingyourhead7992
Go watch a cartoon.
@@howboutusingyourhead7992Alot of the people watching this are gonna be enthusiasts, so attention to detail is not just “meh”
Don’t know if it’s accurate but the sound effect they used for the flares deploying is probably the coolest sound in the movie for me
It's accurate. Sounds like a machine gun. They're ballistically deployed.
Much better than the gun sounds...
that fancy briefing room was for the audience to understand the mission outline, they would be totally confused if it was just a dry erasable board.
The real deal is much lower tech and not as flashy. A few white boards and maybe a projector if you wanna get fancy.
If anybody wants an extended look at what fighter pilots think of the movie, check out C.W. Leimone - he recently concluded his reaction series and it’s worth a watch.
At the end of it the seem pretty tired of doing the reaction video.
Yeah I’ve seen it. They like the movie but it feels like they spend the whole time shitting on it instead of enjoying the fantasy of the story 😂
@@christiannevarez6590 thats the point isnt it? Its called "Mover ruins movies" for a reason
@@christiannevarez6590 To be fair they'd already heaped on the praise when did their initial review. Mover can't Ruin the Movie without excessive nitpicking after all.
@@AxiamWolfe "Excessive nitpicking" sums it up nicely. That one just went on and on... Took longer than the bloody movie :D
The taking off in the tomcat part was included because in WW2 an American pilot stole an enemy plane, after crashing his and flew it back to a friendly air base. The reason for the accuracies in the movie is down to Tom. He played a large part in all aspects of this movie while it was being made.
And the ejection scene was a bit of a call back to the Right Stuff and Yeager's ejection.
But, he should have used flaps.
thought it was more a play on the mig25 defection into Japan. where the CIA and their cohorts of engineers took the entire plane apart and took samples of everything. they played down its importance in its abilities but what they secretly wanted was the materials that were being used for mach3 travel. particularly the canopy. they drilled holes through it.
They also needed a justification in the script to have Maverick and Rooster flying an F-14 in a near death situation, to recall the death of Rooster's father, with Maverick saving his son on the same plane his father died in.
Sure, because Tom was a fighter pilot so knows all about it.🤣
I’m real life this movie is over after Maverick ejects doing Mach 10. Dude just walked into a restaurant like he didn’t just get shot out of an airplane at 7000 MPH.
Look up how much thinner the air is at 150,000ft vs 10,000ft
He didn't necessarily eject at that speed. The plane could have decelerated. As others have said the air is thinner up there, the plane could have an ejection pod, not to mention his pressure suit.
@@AnP865 As others have NO FREAKING IDEA what they are talking about. He is dead when that plane explodes.
That call sign goes hard 😂
Callsign “Tinder” 😂
Hes just that hot
Better than Grinder hahahahaha
We all know why his callsign is tinder. 😂 it's 1 of 2 scenarios.
He was probably always on it and swiping on people.
Would have liked to hear your take on the Fifth Gen scenes and the evade maneuver. Great commentary.
1:10 ...and, as it turns out, it was indeed a former Blue Angels pilot that flew the maneuver for the stunt.
Thank you for your Service Alex
Great video. The F/A -18 is a darling plan. Thank you for your time in the service. Fly safe.
TY for this one Alex…I really appreciated your candid, honest, and fair expert opinion on this…TY for your insights here- well done…And TY fir your Service to our Country
This was fantastic! Thank you Alex!
The briefing room with the white board blew my mind...I would have never guessed that.
That’s true “military grade”
1:38 - “Hard Deck my -, we nailed that -!” ~Maverick, later in the locker room
"He got you, didn't he?"
Great review! Love our Naval Aviators! Thank you for your service Sir. Semper Fidelis!
The flipped bird was originally done by the Duke in Vietnam. He was that close.
My favorite explanation for this is in Ace combat where the Maverick F14 is just way better than the regular F14
Still not a word from anyone about Maverick dropping a GBU on the target in his heroic training demonstration with the Master Arm off and the A/G light out.
It's just a movie, the best action movie in years!
🇮🇹HAI ASSOLUTAMENTE RAGIONE🙂👍
Outstanding video, thanks for sharing! 👍
You probably wouldn't be surprised at the amount of people who disagree with you with absolute certainty in many other video comment sections. LOL. The internet is an entertaining place. And thank you for your service.
Only move missing is the "Split Throttle" incident in the F-14. Would have loved to hear him break that down
For sure. I've seen it tried in DCS and the Tomcat stalls.
He flew specially F-18 and to be able to do a split throttle, you need space between the 2 engines (F-15, F-14, Flanker) in order to have a major differential thrust
AWESOME... do another one with Alex Bowman and his opinion on the F-14D (new upgraded tomcats). Would love to hear his opinion on those.
Why are there so many people triggered by this video? Some people are just curious about the actual realism of the movie and understand the movie is just entertainment. Doesn't mean people would also like to know what it's like in real life
Dry erase boards are remarkable!
"It's not the plane, it's the pilot."
famous last words...
The whole point of the movies was that Maverick was trying to prove that humans were better than drones. But in this impossible mission a drone would have worked perfect with no loss of life
Okay, but what are his thoughts about the fact that the entire mission was stolen from A New Hope?
May the 4th be with you
LOL. Alex - you are back on IGN. That is great.
All they would of had to do for dropping the laser guided bombs is after release just pull up and do an Immelmann and go back to the deck. You probably can do it before hitting the crest of the mountain where the SAMS are. At peak of the turn throw some chaff and flares out just in case. Then you are low and fast cause you punch it on the way down and you just go out the way you came in which has already proven to be a relatively safe ingress route. Or better yet take 6-7 of the tomahawks and take out the top of the mountain sam sites in addition to the runway/airbase. But it would not of been as exciting.
we tried it in dcs lol it was an absolute slaughter on that f14. zero chance that f14 would have survived past the suprise hit
It's nice to hear real fighter pilot's input about movies like this. Movies tend to take liberties and make some scenarios unrealistic.
6:50 isn't something like Auto-GCAS supposed to help prevent situations like that?
Sure that one popular clip it starts at 17000 ft, and the system engages only at 9000 ft, but still.
Quality commentary.
Cw lemoine has a great reaction with other naval aviators that where also Air Force pilots
Tony Scott did not make movies to be for the professionals He made it for the entertainment
And people base their opinions on perceptions on what they see in films. They are so simple minded so as to actually believe these things to be true.
Thank you for your reaction !
Thank you, Lieutenant! o7
@6:50 what about GCAS or some sort of auto-leveling system to take over while the pilot is unconscious?
the Grim Reaper & Sidewinder YT channels have tried dogfighting a 5th Gen fighter with a Tomcat in DCS. The Tomcat lasts about 5 seconds in ALL SCENARIOS !!
Wait.... Share with us how ya got "Tinder" as a call sign? A big part of this story is missing.
Nice video! The F-14 is a kino aircraft, but people don't realize how many hornet pilots in the 80s and 90s would eat Tomcats everyday for lunch in simulated dogfights.
could you comment on the crazy 5th gen fighter move to get behind mav?
The biggest problem with the combat scenes is near the end when the pilots are trying to avoid all those missiles. Every one of those missiles has a proximity fuse and would explode near the planes instead of missing. It makes for a great movie, but not very accurate.
And they throw out 1000's of peices of sharp shrapnel designed to shred whatever gets in the way.
@@rinzler9775 sure, but going at that speed it would not damage the aircraft.
🤣 who cares!!!!
@@seyumaiayami3536 The missiles are designed with said proximity fuse to damage the aircraft in the event of a near miss when they explode and shoot sharpened and jagged metal in all directions right next to the jet
@@seyumaiayami3536 The missile is going faster than the aircraft, the shrapnel 100% damages it and can easily take it down.
Did you not watch the actual movie? Maverick did not want to train them using a hard deck due to the nature of the mission.
That wouldn't be his call
@@bayanon7532almost nothing Mav did was supposed to be his call 😅
@@shaunward3711
Buzzing the tower? Nope.
Well what about the racing the Jets sitting on a Ninja 😂. Vrommm 4:58 leaving the time stamp have no idea what it means lol love you all 💝. Thanks for your services aviators awesome 😎
Your call sign is "Tinder"?
Whats your wizzo's name? Grinder?
It’s all counts down to camaraderie, whether you are in a factory, working your heck out, or on a jet plane
Is that VFA-106 in the backround?
Awesome commentary.
Dont sleep on the Pete "Maverick" Mitchell factor...
2:55 only guy I've heard saying that the difference isn't huge between Top Gun students and instructors. Every other pilot I've heard says the difference it is indeed huge. Like, if being a Top Gun pilot is a big thing, imagine being a Top Gun instructor... So on my inexperience and other pilots online, I'll say the difference must be dramatic
Except he's talking about the difference between Top Gun graduates and an instructor. Bit of a difference there.
He specifically points out the difference between instructors and graduates, people who have completed the program, would come down to time in the cockpit and not be as significant as the movie displays.
The problem CW pointed out is that these are supposed to be graduates ... but they act like they just started the program, reacting to training like they've never been there before
@@radiospines Yeah, there seems to be a misconception that these guys are completely new. That's not Top Gun though. These guys already are pilots. Top Gun is an additional training program for already established pilots, not new guys...
I'm just a lay man but when maverick does his breaking maneuver to get behind his opponent Ben dogfighting and then dives behind them to get a mill shot wouldn't that bleed off to much speed wouldn't the enemy plane be gone by the time he re engages ?
Don't lie. You'd swipe right on callsign Tinder.
YES
Really nice video!
Mav getting saved by plot armor is such a Tom Cruise thing. The Su-57s Autocannon would have shredded the F-14 to pieces, also terrain wouldn't have messed up the targeting, that makes zero sense.
The terrain would not mess up the radar, but fighting that low will do a number on the pilot.
My only problem with the F-14 scene it is Gun sound! It doesn’t sound like that also the SU-57 “Felon” love that name it Gun to doesn’t sound like that
They could have taken a raptor to fight against the felon. There's no way that an f14 could beat a felon. SU-57 is much better equipped, much faster, more stealthy and has much better maneuverability than the f14.
Can't forget that during that spiral, they had already floor morted, both on the hard deck and nearly on the real floor, in which Maverick should have been yelling knock it off or something
Ever seen a full-bird still flying - even for skunkworks?
Saw the Turkish air force , preform canopy to canopy of girne, northern Cyprus wow 😮
Maverick should be in the blue angles then
You look realy young. What time did you start flying? Or you took care of yourself?
No Naval Aviator would have a p51 in his garage. That’s an army air corps plane.
The guy that owns that P-51 is Tom Cruise, an actor.
Ward Carol who was a Top Gun instructor gave it a great review
Ward Carol wasn't a Top Gun instructor
What exactly are the "brakes" on a jet plane?
This is like Ace Combat the movie…I loved it!😂🤣😂🤣
Its missing unlimited missiles
My call sign will be : " Renaissance". lol!
5:05 def possible if u map the cannyon with computer in 3D , and tracking in digital canyon
He didn't say it wasn't impossible just that they don't use that tech. They use whiteboards because they are cheap and still plenty effective.
They don't have the PS5 graphics so they use a white board for missions unbelievable
Callsign: TINDER
EHARMONY: HOLD MY BEER 🍺😂
Thanks your service, first and foremost, Tinder, and this analysis. I'm curious what your thoughts are on BOB wearing corrective lenses flying a Navy fighter aircraft. I'm pretty sure that is unrealistic with Air Force aviators. Thanks again.
Go Falcons!
In the navy you CAN WEAR corrective lenses ALTHOUGH NOT EXACTLY THAT THIN FRAMED (THE GLASSES THE NAVY GIVES YOU ARE MUCH MUCH THICKER FRAMED) the sides(temples) are thick 'ole heavy duty bastids🤔🤷♂️🤨😠😡🤬👎👎..!!
They are navy, not Air Force
Great reaction video. The 5th gen Fighters we're only about 4 to 1 over the older ones. So there is a chance , tho slimmer , a Tomcat could prevail. Especially with less trained pilots as adversaries against Top Gunners. Maybe not F*cked but definitely in deep.
I’d trust professionals unless you’re somekind of lagendary ex professional air force pilot
5th generation fighters are not piloted by noobs you know , it's just Hollywood .
Man I’m bummed they didn’t cover the scene where maverick split the throttles to create asymmetrical thrust to out maneuver the 5th gen fighter. Really wanted to see what he woulda said about that one
Danger zone intensifies
It's a shame we never got the super tomcat..
with the tom cat f14. in top gun one the plane that the plp was in was the tom cat f14
F14 Tom cat is the one that they steal from an enemy airbase and fight with the 5th gen fighters, aka SU-57 felon. In real life, felon will easily decimate the tom cat within seconds and there's no way the tom cat can win.
There’s a great video of another pilot watching the ‘9 Gs’ scene…and just silently shaking his head
Another entertaining video Leagle Eagle's review of the movie with a JAG lawyer. Let's just say "Can you say death penalty, boys and girls?"
It’s called Hollywood! But thank you Alex for your expertise and service!
What a callsign
Areobatics an important part of fighter pilots ' training to develop air combat abilities in trainee fighter pilots, specially for dogfight scenarios.
Yes, it's unfair to compare Tomcat (F-14) with a 5th gen fighter jet, but in case of a dogfight between the two, result very much depends upon the skills and abilities of the fighter pilot that's flying the aircraft. In a BVR combat 5th gen fighter jet can easily shoot down Tomcat(F-14).
Is it really aerobatics or is it just flat out recklessness, because theyve almost killed themselves & other friendlies multiple times??
But like alex said, just stay in sight. doesnt have to go down the valley with him
They would not be in a dogfight in the first place. And the only operational 5th gen fighters can just get a helmet lock
Imagine having call sign ...Grinder 🤣🤣
But the nax speed of the f14 is 1544 mph and for the f18 it is only 1190 mph ...so on the paper f14 can just open after berner and fly away....
We all know how this guy got his call sign lmao dude must be swiping legend
Dave Berke help with a lot stuff and was top gun instructor
2:13 rooster's at 100ft, maverick pulls up and behind him, suddenly (2:17) rooster's at 8000ft 🙄 immediate lock 😆
Different scenes in the movie. Not from the same moment in the movie
Nope, it's the same scene
As per the “Cobra” maneuver Maverick uses where he goes over Rooster probably wouldn’t work in that particular jet and the move has no known use and has never been recorded in a dogfight it’s usually a jet show move but in a fight questionable if it would even work
To all the pilots that served, or is now serving. Thank you for your service. For those that are reacting to the MOVIE. C'mon!! It's a MOVIE!!! For ENTERTAINMENT ONLY!!! Not to be confused to replace actual Training or Flight School. After all, just imagine the possibility an a recruitment tool. Just like the recruitment rise after Top Gun. The actual pilots that flew the front seat admitted that they joined and wanted to be a fighter pilot upon seeing Top Gun. So relax and just enjoy,,,,The Movie.
how do you get that call sign lol
are all the jets close as far as instruments could you fly the f35 without additional training
Yes.
Source: prepar3d and not having any idea what I'm talking about.
The most unrealistic thing in Top Gun is his call sign Maverick. You don’t get cool call signs, they’re almost always something embarrassing about the pilot. If he requested the call sign Maverick he would’ve been hazed to the point where he would voluntarily leave the force
He probably left his wingman, Hollywood.
The expert is called “Tinder”! That’s cool...
You mean like insisting on being called Duke instead of Yankee like Cunningham did?
Just spit ballin here but a 5th gen’s advantage is stealth and long range, right? Once they’re a couple hundred feet away that goes away so wouldn’t attacking them unexpectedly make it possible?
5th Gen fighters like the F-22 and SU-57 have far more advanced flight control systems, and thrust vectoring. The F-14 is very big and heavy and lacks any of these advanced systems. In close in dogfights with guns only some fighters like the F-16 or Typhoon may be able to get kills on 5th gen aircraft, however when adding off bore axis missiles like AIM-9X to the 5th gen fighters it becomes very one sided.
Fifth generation fighters are also typically designed to be excellent at ACM, because the current belief is that when two fifth generation fighters meet it will be guns and IR missiles that will decide the fight. That being said they shouldn't give up their advantage by getting close to fourth generation fighter unless the situation requires it, like with the SU57s merge with the F-14 trying to figure out if it is friendly. Once they knew that the F-14 was hostile that third SU57 should've just engaged the F-14 from longer range.