Yes the track did appear on the 1992 version of the single "There Is A Light That Never Goes Out" but it first appeared as a B-side in 1987. Both on the 12" and Cassette versions of the single "I Started Something I Couldn't Finish". The audio used for this vid was originally sourced from the Japanese 1987 CD release "Stop Me/The Smiths" before it was remastered, wonderfully, by '50 Pound Note'.
Hell yeah. Its too bad he so often gets overlooked both in the band and in terms of bass prowess in general. The bass on Bigmouth Strikes Again is another absolutely killer example.
This guitar track.has been in my head for 15 years and I barely have listened to it in 15 if ever, it's insane how it just keeps coming back and staying
I know. I love it. He's like a child with headphones who can't hear a word of what he's singing but it doesn't matter because he's enjoying himself. And Marr. I simply cannot express how fucking ingenious he is and Andy's bass playing... And Joyce of course. It's all just... Somehow... perfect...
Mayor Of Simpleton I personally feel Joyce gets too much stick when actually he serves the music perfectly, as I drummer I can tell you it's simplistic, and boring to play, but it serves the song first
Andy Rouke is clearly the most under-rated bassist! His playing has funk, Motown, Jamaican cues with his creative driving force fill-ins makes him an impeccable bassist! He is as awesome as Johny Mar.
The outro on this track is hands down my favourite piece of music of all time. Its like some perfect marriage of 80's Jingle Jangle/Folksy Guitar and some exotic rhythm section from Latin America. It makes me want to cruise in some kind of relic from the 50's down a highway in Florida. In a Floral Shirt. Wearing shades. On repeat forever.
Love the way that Morriss*y sings the title of the song differently each time, he does it normally at first then more heartfelt and then like a sneer, like he has a different persona each time, great stuff
You can spend 100 years crafting a song about life, love and death then the smiths will write a song about how some girls mothers are bigger than other girls mothers and their song will be better than yours. Greatest band of all time.
3:02 for The Smiths officiandos. This line wasn't on the version on the great Queen is dead album but Morrissey added it here allowing Johnny to weave his magic
@@obsi_diana on the shop floor there’s a calendar as obvious as snow as if we didn’t know. That’s the line Morrissey added to enable Johnny to riff. It’s in the book ‘songs that saved your life’ by Simon Goddard
@@fan-done1856 He only says it in this version. Not the actual released version. But i wish he did cos then that means the song would have been longer which it needed to be longer. It wasn't enough. Its beautiful 😭
Saw them live. Billy Bragg opened. I was twenty something and thinking this moment is as good as it will ever get. Thanks for posting this video and taking me back to less greyer days. I love that they added another verse in this live recording. -Dan
Their greatest song ever....play in on repeat a few times in the morning and it will be in your head for the week....the bass and guitar tone are out of this world.
Wow - good taste indeed! - that hypnotic, trancelike interweaving of four distinct voices is captured so perfectly on this recording - pure transcendence. I have paused in my life to mourn the passing of Andy Rourke and to remember what made The Smiths so uniquely gratifying to me.
One of marrs best riffs wasted on morrisseys perhaps deliberately lazy and annoying song, towards the end of the band. Some egos are bigger than others
The Smiths were my favorite band when I was around sixteen (you can have an educated guess how many friends I had at the time by that fact). Have not listened to them for a while. Today my statistics professor used this song as the opener for an exercise where we had to correlate the weight and height of women. Stupid exercise but now I cant stop listening to that song again. One of the greatest bands in the world.
How brilliant is that extra line? So funny, thanks for sharing that. I like learning new things about The Smiths! Embarrassing that I just realized I own that book, I've just unpacked it from storage! I must add that citing your sources is great because there are many "fans" who make shit up so to speak, now Wikipedia is full of errors! Thanks again!
É como se Morrissey soubesse que essa seria a primeira e última vez em que a banda tocaria essa canção num show. Acabou registrando uma interpretação espetacular, inesquecível, eterna.
RIP Andy,,, my oldest dream about a band get together just disappeared with your death!! you may Rest In Peace!!! what amazing music you played!!! it just been over 35 years of dreaming your music!!
I hate how Rourke is spoken about as if he’s some underdog bassist that people are just coming to realize. These men are the masters of their instruments and they all found each other to make this for us
Not into the Smiths but discovered this recording maybe a year ago, listened to it 200 times since and I'm now convinced it's one of the most perfect performances I've ever seen. Thanks for the enlightenment 🙌
@@tmantonytv1166 And that was one of the things that made that decade so great. You could actually rebel and be heard! You didn't need to conform and become an existential zombie obsessed with looking happy and perfect all the time! Now,if you don't comform,or fit in,your voice will just be ignored.
@@chivoloks28 Fair point. But consider the role of music & art at hastening change and acceptance of differences . . . 1950's, Del-Vikings, Muscle Shoals Records, etc.
johnny is a guitar player that every time you hear him you say to yourself this is incredible no matter what song he plays you just cant help but noticing how great he is
To people who think Morrissey's lyrics are a little silly & a crime to put over a guitar rift like this are really missing the point. It's the "high brow-ness" & utter elegance of the guitar rift lifting up & elevating a throw away, fleeting, "low brow-ness" observation that "some girls are bigger than others" & taking that observation from the small into the infinite. That rift allows meaning, space & time to come out of the mundane lyrics, to magnify them & ponder them as a universe itself. It's truly a beautiful thing.
Yes the track did appear on the 1992 version of the single "There Is A Light That Never Goes Out" but it first appeared as a B-side in 1987. Both on the 12" and Cassette versions of the single "I Started Something I Couldn't Finish". The audio used for this vid was originally sourced from the Japanese 1987 CD release "Stop Me/The Smiths" before it was remastered, wonderfully, by '50 Pound Note'.
do you mean they have the whole gig professionelly recorded??!
@@lucalone if you search up for their last smiths gig you can find the full gig. audio is very good but video is the same like here
@@lucalone Rejected soundboard?
it was a b side, with 3 other live songs...can't remember the Single [know meat is murder also]...56 clumsy and shy, from 1983 and I...
@@joes2525 the full concert is remastered?
Can we just talk about Andy's bass? Absolutely wonderful.
yes
Hell yeah. Its too bad he so often gets overlooked both in the band and in terms of bass prowess in general. The bass on Bigmouth Strikes Again is another absolutely killer example.
? It sounds nothing like a John Taylor riff.
Pazazu The Girl Afraid riff though. That one hits hard too hehe
Nobody cares about Joyce hehe
This is my favorite guitar work of anyone, anywhere, anytime.
Amen... Just unreal!!
jam 3 the Layla sessions
Or I'll be a liar
Hear, hear
You have incredibly good taste.
Rest in peace. Andy Rourke, your bassline is just pure genius
💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖
it's at the same level than the guitar riff, both together make this song fantastic
RIP to the absolute best bass player of all time ❤❤❤
AR BMF
The Marr intro, unreal, what an artist. Could listen to the first minute 100 times. Audio quality is top notch too.
I could listen to it 104 times
What does he sings at 3:00 - 3:15
MIQUEIAS ALVARO “On the shop floor, there’s a calendar, as obvious as snow / As if we didn’t know...”
Probably listened to it 200
Just uploaded a guitar cover of this on my channel check it out!
Johnny Marr should have asked the government to build him a 60ft statue for writing this riff. Fucking astounding.
* And they should have called it: "Some statues are bigger than others".
Or we should do that instead of him...He deserves that.
i doubt statues are his style
69Phuket morrissey would probably like a statue of himself
Why it’s basic chords ffs not difficult playing at all
Marr's guitar compositions are out of this world
And a bass too. What a great bass player. Andy Rourke 🖤🖤🌹🌹
RIP 😢
@@altarseni4553Nobody asked
Easily my favourite smiths song the guitar rift is unreal n my faveourite lyric "send me the pillow the one that you dream on and il send you mine"
Love girl afraid too.
A song title by Dean Martin.
@GreigCooper You do know that Morrissey didn't write that line you like so much?
@@crose7412they never stated that
@@liljax3103 I didn't say they did, I asked a question.
I could listen to this guitar forever!
+thiago lima PURE POET
I am literally obsessed with this guitar track and sound. It's always in my head.
Same!
Same here
This guitar track.has been in my head for 15 years and I barely have listened to it in 15 if ever, it's insane how it just keeps coming back and staying
the isolated guitar is my alarm tone to wake up in the morning xD
Man... Been listening and playing it on guitar in some kind of repeat for about 4 months lol. Can't get enough. Never heard something so beautiful
It’s hard to believe this was the only time they played it live. It sounds incredible
The last gig :(
Just uploaded a guitar cover of this on my channel check it out!
No way!!
I can't believe the only performance of this song was recorded so well
@@adonaiyah2196 thank god it was, national treasure
What I love about Morrissey is that it always feels like he's singing to himself like no one is watching. And Johnny Marr is a god.
Zero performance anxiety, it's amazing to anyone shy like Morrissey. He got me out of my shyness.
I know. I love it. He's like a child with headphones who can't hear a word of what he's singing but it doesn't matter because he's enjoying himself. And Marr. I simply cannot express how fucking ingenious he is and Andy's bass playing... And Joyce of course. It's all just... Somehow... perfect...
Mayor Of Simpleton I personally feel Joyce gets too much stick when actually he serves the music perfectly, as I drummer I can tell you it's simplistic, and boring to play, but it serves the song first
He did a lot of walking. The 1st step out of the door is freedom.
& the other two ?
Andy Rouke is clearly the most under-rated bassist! His playing has funk, Motown, Jamaican cues with his creative driving force fill-ins makes him an impeccable bassist! He is as awesome as Johny Mar.
Marrs' riff is one of the most beautiful I've ever heard, always complimented by Rourkes solid bass lines. Another underrated bassist
Just uploaded a guitar cover of this on my channel check it out!
Johnny Marr
fucking wizard.
Yes!
+Boko Kotar uff
Boko Kotar i was just about to comment this
+Jamie
Stupid comparison.
Different genres.
Fucking GENIOUS!
That riff belongs in a museum!
How do you even write a song like this??? It twists and turns and jangles just right. Johhny Marr. Yes.
This song is beyond what is understandable
I read somewhere that he doesn't even know himself. He just picks up a guitar and out it comes.
Matteoj he did, he doesn't make riffs like this anymore
No one else really played guitar like mate. Always making melodic riffs and packing lots of notes in. It’s sounds great.
How I See It listen to Heroes del Silencio, Juan Valdivia composes beautiful arpeggios.
The fact that some people got to see this live… I’m envious
I just found out they played this song (one of my favourites) on the 12th of December 1986, that is the day I was born.
That is Amazing!!!
You and a million other people 😂
@@Anthony-dj4ndEeeeeeeee gross.
Some riffs are better than others...
haha right on :)
Igor Ryzhikov , riffs and quiffs.....The Smiffs...
Some comments are better than others
Yeah!
uhhh this riff is amazing, what are you talking about?
The outro on this track is hands down my favourite piece of music of all time. Its like some perfect marriage of 80's Jingle Jangle/Folksy Guitar and some exotic rhythm section from Latin America. It makes me want to cruise in some kind of relic from the 50's down a highway in Florida. In a Floral Shirt. Wearing shades. On repeat forever.
edgy
Sounds like Bert Jansch to me
Yeah, all my mates take the piss out of me when I play this. They like the instrumental but lyrics make them laugh.
your daft
absolutely, it's been stuck in my head since the past two months non stop and it's 3am and all i do is listen to this, fuck yeah
Thank you for the Smiths, for however long it lasted. So special.
This is Marr's song IMO, I'm truly a Morrissey guy I love his lyrics and this song is no exception but my god the guitar in this... its masterful.
True
Just uploaded a guitar cover of this on my channel check it out!
All the songs by the smiths are orchestrated around the guitar specifically Marr’s playing. Morrissey is just a talking head in this song
If you're here, know that you have an incredibly good taste.
If I could go back in time to any place at any moment in history this would be it
I was at this gig Brixton Academy,London December 1986 their final show.....my older brother lived in a squat down the road at the time. Happy days :)
I was there. Bought the cassette tape two days later at Camden Market, which turns out is the audio to this video.
yes definitely
me too
Yes. This is the greatest guitar riff in human history. Thanks Johnny.
This song is magical. I can't get enough of this version. I can honestly say that this is my favourite Smiths song, without pause.
Just uploaded a guitar cover of this on my channel check it out!
This is by far the best version of this song I have heard.
It's so magical how Johnny Marr milks the beginning.
He is a genius.
How great is Johnny Marr? Wow, so great to hear him play this beautiful tune with such clarity and precision. Entrancing playing!
RIP Andy Rourke
I love this song to death, but hearing a live version... my life has been changed for good.
Hope you're well ;)
@Jakojaj Yep. Thanks. X
@Jakojaj Yep. Jakojaj. Hanging on. Hope you too. ;)
The way Morrissey sings the line @2:26 cracks me up. Amazing performance by an unreal band.
These men literally write melodies from my soul
The joy this music gives me. Johnny Marr. I could hear this tune on a loop all day.
Thank god someone had the foresight to record this.
Soundsville International filmed this.
that bass though. ..man o man...
Beautiful melody (that guitar!) + fantastically absurd & funny lyrics = perfection!
Love the way that Morriss*y sings the title of the song differently each time, he does it normally at first then more heartfelt and then like a sneer, like he has a different persona each time, great stuff
This asterisk is so silly
Some bands are bigger than others...
Some band's labels are bigger than other band's labels.
Exactly
iyi dedin
iyi dedin kral
You can spend 100 years crafting a song about life, love and death then the smiths will write a song about how some girls mothers are bigger than other girls mothers and their song will be better than yours. Greatest band of all time.
sad? but true lmao
seriously tho the lyrics literally mean nothing deep. how can he make it sound like they supposed to? crazy.
@@tortimandi666 what's it saying? If her mom's fat she'll probably be in the future?!
Well put
Very well put.
I just bought the 12" of I Started Something, and I had no idea the B Side was this (the actual live version), I nearly fell over in sheer excitement!
I bought that record solely for the B side :)
3:02 for The Smiths officiandos. This line wasn't on the version on the great Queen is dead album but Morrissey added it here allowing Johnny to weave his magic
I couldn't understand what he said. Can someone help me please?
@@obsi_diana on the shop floor there’s a calendar as obvious as snow as if we didn’t know. That’s the line Morrissey added to enable Johnny to riff. It’s in the book ‘songs that saved your life’ by Simon Goddard
@@satjinder thank you! 💕
The Best Riff of the Smiths. Such an incredible nostalgic sense
Started listening to Smiths all over again..cant get that amazing almost hypnotic guitar riff out of my head..
"On the shopfloor
There's a calendar
As obvious as snow...
(As if we didn't know)"
A verse not on the album version but that makes it obvious “bigger”means “bigger tits”
perfeito né?!
To be able to write a riff that brings tears to people's eyes - amazing!
Imagine the Smiths reunite and Johnny comes out just like this.
My favourite Smiths guitar riff
spoombung riff or picking ??
shut up
@@kawavulcan8411 who cares? it's magical!
"On the shop floor
There’s a calendar
As obvious as snow
As if we didn’t know!"
This is my favorite part of this song!
I didn’t even know that was in the song!
@@fan-done1856 He only says it in this version. Not the actual released version. But i wish he did cos then that means the song would have been longer which it needed to be longer. It wasn't enough. Its beautiful 😭
@@slowedvintagemusic right?????
The intro and the outro by Johnny…..magnificent!
I could literally listen to that riff on loop for the rest of my life and never get bored with it. Majestic 👌
The Smiths are the reason why the 80s were, are and will forever be the best decade of all time.
The best guitar piece I've ever heard. And the bass....
Saw them live. Billy Bragg opened. I was twenty something and thinking this moment is as good as it will ever get. Thanks for posting this video and taking me back to less greyer days. I love that they added another verse in this live recording. -Dan
I'm twenty something and I have just discovered this band. I envy you for seeing them live!
man, you had it good 5 years ago. You have to see the globalist wet dream shit show we're living in nowadays 😢
unbelievable. i have loved this band since day 1, and i don't love them any less. this guitar playing honestly i just love it.
Their greatest song ever....play in on repeat a few times in the morning and it will be in your head for the week....the bass and guitar tone are out of this world.
can't think of a riff as good as this one in music history
The bassline is quality also...
Yes bless you always Andy,an incredible musician
This mix is so sublime, the guitar is coming through like an angels voice
man that guitar sound is heavenly
Como puede ser una banda tan pero tan inmensa. Gracias sres. SMITHS. Saludos desde Argentina.
Wow - good taste indeed! - that hypnotic, trancelike interweaving of four distinct voices is captured so perfectly on this recording - pure transcendence. I have paused in my life to mourn the passing of Andy Rourke and to remember what made The Smiths so uniquely gratifying to me.
fabulous work by Andy Rourke and Johnny Marr :)
"you are having incredibly good taste" - thanks, Morrissey.
lol he said that at the start
LightFromADeadStar Yes, yes he did.
A highly intelligent man Morrissey
Apparently he failed all his exams but I'd think he's very intelligent.
TheZooropaBaby he says "you have incredibly good taste"
THE BAND OF MY LIFE. ALWAYS. FOREVER & EVER.
Fun fact, this is the one and only time they ever played this song live
it`s a pitty, one of their best songs
This is sad. They shouldn't break up so soon 💔
One of marrs best riffs wasted on morrisseys perhaps deliberately lazy and annoying song, towards the end of the band. Some egos are bigger than others
@@b.sweeney4102 so true lmao, wtf are these lyrics the instrumental sounds so much cooler
@@b.sweeney4102 stop spouting nonsense.
I come here to fanboy over that riff
Must admit my favourite Smiths song-the outro truly sublime. Played it 1000 times n will play it 1000 more.
The Smiths were my favorite band when I was around sixteen (you can have an educated guess how many friends I had at the time by that fact). Have not listened to them for a while. Today my statistics professor used this song as the opener for an exercise where we had to correlate the weight and height of women. Stupid exercise but now I cant stop listening to that song again. One of the greatest bands in the world.
Some riffs are greater than others.
The Smiths at their best ! Can't get better than this ! This is superb !
The extra verse was brought out for this show do that Johnny could riff longer. According to a smiths biographer
Simon Moult that's true I read the same thing. Think it was Simon Goddard's book 'songs that saved my life'
What are the lyrics to that extra verse?
Bradley Smith On the shop floor, there's a calendar, as obvious as snow, as if we didn't know
How brilliant is that extra line? So funny, thanks for sharing that. I like learning new things about The Smiths! Embarrassing that I just realized I own that book, I've just unpacked it from storage! I must add that citing your sources is great because there are many "fans" who make shit up so to speak, now Wikipedia is full of errors! Thanks again!
@oscillatewildly6553
I think all the lines are wicked clever.
"You have incredibly good taste"
Worlds best guitarist, nobody comes close.
@@MrJonpac I may be wrong... but isn't it Knopffler?
@@Vampire_Nightshade well, in his style he is ths best, same Marr and many others
Woah woah woah brotha
Well paco de lucia ? Andres segovia? You re way too ignorant about guitar players my friend
"You have incredibly good taste"
I felt that, Moz :')
So did Jake!, LOL
É como se Morrissey soubesse que essa seria a primeira e última vez em que a banda tocaria essa canção num show. Acabou registrando uma interpretação espetacular, inesquecível, eterna.
Caraca não sabia q era a última,mas de fato, sensacional essa versão,escuto ela em vez da do disco
Sim, a despedida no auge... e cedo.
How does he even play that? Gosh, it's so Johnny fucking Marr thing, being absolutely unpredictable and wonderful.
I wish this song gets billion of views one day. Everybody need to listen this awesome guitar play.
Love the bass!!
Johnny Marr is a fucking genius. The music wizard who was sent from heaven to create such iconic riffs for us!
RIP Andy,,, my oldest dream about a band get together just disappeared with your death!! you may Rest In Peace!!! what amazing music you played!!! it just been over 35 years of dreaming your music!!
I absolutely love this band.Andy Rourke's bass lines are so amazing. Marr wow!!
One of the greatest guitarists alive...Johnny Marr!!!!
R.I.P ANDY ROURKE ..,,YOU LEGEND, SORELY UNDERATTED........
I hate how Rourke is spoken about as if he’s some underdog bassist that people are just coming to realize. These men are the masters of their instruments and they all found each other to make this for us
Not into the Smiths but discovered this recording maybe a year ago, listened to it 200 times since and I'm now convinced it's one of the most perfect performances I've ever seen. Thanks for the enlightenment 🙌
The best five minutes of my life! Over and over.
johnny marr is one of those artists that appears one in 100 years
Perfect song in every way. Lyrics are absolutely nuts but that is what makes it great. Drums, bass, guitar and lyrics all perfect
Please,tell me ,what's the meaning of those lyrics I'm kinda blurred !
@@mihaelanegritu1709 Some girls are bigger than others
@@VoIkov O.K.,now,if you want,tell me what's the meaning of those lyrics.
@Mihaela Negritu that some girls are, in fact, bigger than others
@@VoIkov You're redundant,already ! I regret ,i was asking you this question.
But,if this makes you happy...
Possibly the best smiths song played Live.
Johnny Marr is awesome on this song, thank you very much for sharing this important piece
such a stunning riff from Marr......awesome
Beautiful music from a beautiful band. Simply put, The Smiths have never and will never, be surpassed.
Some decades are better than others...
Oswaldo Lafee what, the smiths were rebelling against shit 80’s music
Unless you were a minority, maybe yes
HOW TRUE....I'VE STARTED TO SOUND LIKE MY FATHER....
@@tmantonytv1166 And that was one of the things that made that decade so great. You could actually rebel and be heard! You didn't need to conform and become an existential zombie obsessed with looking happy and perfect all the time! Now,if you don't comform,or fit in,your voice will just be ignored.
@@chivoloks28 Fair point. But consider the role of music & art at hastening change and acceptance of differences . . . 1950's, Del-Vikings, Muscle Shoals Records, etc.
Ciao Andy 🙏
johnny is a guitar player that every time you hear him you say to yourself this is incredible no matter what song he plays you just cant help but noticing how great he is
WOW! This is one of the Best Live Recordings of THe Smiths in their Heyday!!
sounds system here is sublime........you can hear everything clearly...........BEST VERSION !
To people who think Morrissey's lyrics are a little silly & a crime to put over a guitar rift like this are really missing the point.
It's the "high brow-ness" & utter elegance of the guitar rift lifting up & elevating a throw away, fleeting, "low brow-ness" observation that "some girls are bigger than others" & taking that observation from the small into the infinite. That rift allows meaning, space & time to come out of the mundane lyrics, to magnify them & ponder them as a universe itself. It's truly a beautiful thing.
This is one of the very few times that the TH-cams still work and not flagging down epic work for the the after world.