Hey, no real issue there. Just that sooner or later, the issue of Jehovah's messy reputation and why jeopardy to souls even existed, might rear it's variformed head.
According to Islamic traditions, the only human being who was able to control and capture Satans ( evil Genes ) in the history is King Solomon in Jerusalem. King Solomon was a prophet and King at the same time , he asked god to grant him a throne/power that should not be granted to anyone else after him. Then god gave him the ability to understand birds/animals languages , control the wind , and control all Jinns and their power. They say that he used to punish the evil Jinns and put them inside objects like boxes or maybe lamps. Nobody can have this ability again after King Solomon because that was his wish.
@@kenziehans6598 no.. there are 2 kinds of jinns good and bad. Same like humans... There are good jinns those have accepted Islam and there are other demons.
Kenzie Hans logically, he probably was trapped inside the lamp by a powerful sorcerer in the past. However it’s just Disney thing, there is not such a thing in real life. In real life Magicians can use Genies in dark magic without trap them. Because the genie that works with magicians and dark magic are all bad 100%. Actually it’s not the magician controlling the genie , it’s the genie controlling the magician and help hem to mislead people.
@@Dragonizes from the technology seen in that movie since they already have access to damascus steel it cant be any more than 1000 years ago. Saudi Arabia is part of the cradle of civilization, which existed long before the Mayans or Aztec (mezo american) cultures. It could have just as easily been a much older vizier that long predates Jafar (possibly even one of his ancestors) that trapped the Genie
In the aladdin animated series, one episode included a former master of the genie (who had wished for immortality but not for eternal youth, and become extremely old and withered), who used a new pair of darker, handcuff-like shackles to trap the genie to serve him again. So, people who can trap djinn may not be that rare.
I love the ideas that disney has with all these powerful magical artifacts. and they're all made of gold: Genie's lamp, Maleficent's staff, Triton's trident, Ursula's nautilus shell, kinda Hercules' amulet, probably quite a few things on Tamatoa's shell. either gold items or gems are sources of power for the disney world: the Heart of Te' fiti, the crystals of Atlantis, whatever that big red gem that Abu touched in the cave of wonders was seemed pretty important.
oh right. thanks. That doesn't explain why the genie wasn't able to stop Jafar after granting his third wish. The genie was done being Jafar's master and wasn't free yet, so he could have stopped jafar instead of Aladdin.
How about a theory on the backstory of Aladdin's carpet. Is it possible that he was once a human cursed to live in the body of flying fabric? Also how did he end up in the cave of wonders. (I know we ask a lot from you, but these are just suggestions, no obligations)
What’s suspicious about the way Genie gets all mad and intimidating when Aladdin makes fun of him? I’m sure you would react the same way if someone were to make fun of you!
In the actual book, there were actually two genies: the Genie of the Lamp and the Genie of the Ring, and each gave Aladdin 3 wishes, with him being the master of both of them. Woulda been interesting if they had used both genies instead of just one.
Bambi I think was made to not show a particular time period. I read the original book from the 1920's and it doesn't give a specific date of when the story was either. When I watched the movie you never see "Man." You only hear the sound of the gun and Bambi is told his mom died so it's possible that the two movies could have occurred around the same time.
Bambi is set in the USA, Beauty and the Beast is set in France. Also, the rifle shot that kills Bambi's mom sounds like a modern rifle, not the type Gaston would have had access to.
can you do one about iago and why he served jafar. another one I would love to see is where did the magic carpet come from thank you. you're videos are awesome
There's one story about how God gave King Solomon a powerful ring that allowed him to keep jinni under his control. One of them, named Asmodeus, pissed him off so he imprisoned him in a lamp. 400 years later a fisherman accidentally discovers this lamp and frees Asmodeus, who's ticked off about being stuck in a lamp. He threatens to kill the fisherman, who manages to trick him back into the lamp. Asmodeus, now realizing his mistake, begs the fisherman to let him back out, in exchange for three wishes. But that's just ONE story.
Well I have some ideas. A. The Enchantress: She is associated with magical animate objects like the Beast's staff turned furniture similar to the Magic Carpet found alongside the Genie, as well as creating magical objects like the magical rose. B. Merlin: Not as likely but has been shown with magical objects and has combated powerful shapeshifters like Madam Mim in the past. C: Middle eastern dragon of the past from American Dragon: The Dragons have shown to protect the human world from magic creatures for many generations, and have access to many items and spells to trap dangerous entities. Its also to be noted that the dragons once dealt with a goblin made chalice that can release evil Djinn.
The genie often made comments about “modern” events and technology which made people feel as though the genie had lived in the future. Some of the statues in the cave of wonders is from ancient Sumerian times and looks like Annunaki. So the genie seems to have existed in all times from ancient to modern times.
I feel a more plausible explanation is that the Genie was collateral? He wasn't necessarily evil, but the shear abundance of evil genies in the world, being captured and contained, made him a target by association. They may have mistaken him for an evil Genie and trapped him anyway.
I don't think the Genie would be violent, but just mischeivious (e.g. mushu, Iago) to where merva were concerned of the havoc he could ensued with his limitless power.
Muslims believe that Solomon, known to them as Sulaymān, was given a ring by the Archangel Michael that would give him command over all demons and spirits of the earth, including jinn. A number he imprisoned in various containers, like brass jars and lamps.
but that do not flow with in the time frame Aladdin is set. It shows that in the movie the sphinx is being finished Also the cartoon has Mechanicles who is a Greek and the Hercules show corsses over with the Aladdin show, thus Aladdin takes place long before Islam was birthed as a faith. Either Aladdin is Persian and thus probably A Zoratist or any number of ancient middle eastern faith that predates Islam
Oh yes please, Atlantis is such an underrated movie! Do something about Treasure Planet as well, I love both those movies and they are both so under-appreciated.
I'm happy you are enjoying it! This video I made a few weeks ago may not seem like an Atlantis video, but trust me it is! Check it out here: th-cam.com/video/v9x9T_WZm_M/w-d-xo.html Thanks for watching!
Good theory. Who really knows though. From what we know we have no idea who or what would have been motivated to trap Genie. This is a good idea though that it was due to the recklessness or cruelty of his past. In many stories genies are portrayed as troublemakers and tricksters. Perhaps that's why he was trapped. It could have very well been the Moroovians. We've seen other Genies in Sofia the First and they are confined to their lamps for misbehavior. It makes sense then that genies are locked in lamps, not as an unfair curse but as a punishment (perhaps in the hopes that they will someday become good).
10,000 years the Genie says. So go back 10,000 years from Aladdin. Who was around back then that could do that? Or was it just another master that wasn't his first. Also, Jinns were caught by people back then according to things like the books of wisdom and Jewish/Muslim folktales. So who knows. Example: " Asmodeus, king of demons, was one day, according to the classical Rabbis, captured by Benaiah using the ring, and was forced to remain in Solomon's service."
Pretty sure it was Solomon who sealed the Genie in the lamp. According to legend, a genie displeased Solomon somehow, probably granted him a wish exactly as worded rather than the way Solomon intended for it to be interpreted, and Solomon responded by sealing the genie away.
Allow me to explain this in some detail. There are 2 episodes that go into this in some detail and I suggest you look them up or go watch them. They are The Genie Hunt and The Hunted. Where it goes into some detail about the genies first master and the one who created him.
I read that there is going to be a live-action movie that is supposed to be an origin story for the Genie; I believe it's meant to be released before or after the live-action Aladdin(most likely after, given we're getting info for Aladdin before Genie's story).
The Jinn that are Shayaton can’t change. The very word comes from Shayton,Satan because they serve him. The Jinn who don’t go around the world only to be controlled by Solomon.
My thoughts were always Merlin did it. He has the ability to travel to any point in time, has a long life span as well as the good will and power to trap/punish a that isn't human and cause mischievous trouble.
There's actually one more genie in Aladdin's tale. It's the Djinn of the ring. She is far weaker than the lamb genie yet she is also powerful enough for some wishes.
Cool theory, but one thing that bugs me is that if Genie was cursed, how do we explain Jafar’s lamp appearing out of now where? Aside from Jafar being slightly more powerful than the Genie they’re both the same. Maybe the prison of a Genie is magical manifestation of a failsafe. Because the Djinn are so powerful, there needs to be a way to control them. Not only does the lamp work as a prison, but in Jafar’s case it also proved to be a dangerous weakness. Which only Genie knew about. So, maybe the lamp simply comes into existence as a way to control a Djinn as well destroy a Djinn if there was a need to do so.
While your theory has some logic, there is a more likely answer that comes straight from the Aladdin TV series. There is a species known as the 'Mukhtar', whom Genie describes as living only for enslaving genies. Given Genie's immense fear of them (A fear I that is too strong to be just from hearing stories of them), I would say that Genie was probably imprisoned by such a creature.
Maybe it was moui who trapped the genie , he's immortal so i believe he'd be around to see him and trapped him with the power of the gods , from his exhaustion he probably dropped it in the sea resulting in tamatoa finding it and resulting in his immense size , and I know tamatoa was around for mouis origins but maybe moui was a part of an incarnation cycle also resulting in his parents throwing him a way as he wasn't deemed"the chosen one"
Remember Tamatoa isn't a giant crab. He's a dark being around since near the beginning who happens to have that form. He's also either a demigod or Moanna's culture's version of a demon.
Well the most common myth is that King Solomon was able to command them using their True Names. Matter of fact as I recall the Djinn found in a bottle by a fisherman said that he'd been imprisoned by King Solomon. This is also the first tale specifying 3 wishes (In the original Aladdin story, the Djinn just granted any wish the bearer of the lamp made, until Aladdin accidentally offended it by ordering it to steal a Roc's egg).
My theory is that one of the Genie's masters simply wished for the Genie to be bound to the lamp as a means of control, to be banished or summoned at the whim of his Master.
3:56 a dangerous moth fairy that brings darkness to the world? doesn't that sound like the moth man or a flying 'thing' that's been seen when theirs a volcano eruption or tsunami? and this moth fairy was trapped in a spirit world. cant our moth man thing been trapped in the spirit realm and now released? we are in the end times anyways. sorry! just a thought
Actually, there is a way! There is an Arabian story in which a young man outwits a genie (the one from Aladdin!) and in the end gets him so mad, that he traps him in a lamp. I forget exactly how. (Beyond is Edited) AND the genie from the original story is actually evil! So his time in the lamp might have made the genie change his ways.
well here is another question why was aladan the only one who could enter the cave of wonders and why was the gennie placed in the cave of wonders in the first place.
He even though he was a petty thief, he was doing it to survive and helped out others in need. He never stole for greed. He wasnt in the best of circumstances but he was a human of great potential and character.
Great idea - with just one problem - geography. The Meru, from what I understand, existed in what would later become Latin America. I do not think that they would be operating on or near the Arabian Peninsula. And even if the Genie’s havoc was originally in what would later become Latin America (thereby causing him to run in with the Meru) - how would the lamp have gotten all the way from Meruvia (later to be Avalon) to Agraba (which is clearly in Arabia)? You need to find some way to answer this question in order for your idea to work.
The Genie was trapped for AT LEAST 10,000 years..."10,000 years will give you such a crick in the neck" meaning either he has been trapped in total of 10,000 years or hasn't HAD a master for 10,000 years meaning he's older. Also check out if you haven't heard of the theory that Tamotoa was the genies last master. 😄😘
Do you know Solomon? Or in Quran we know him as Prophet Sulaiman? He had an strong army of genie, i think he is the closest person that could mastering the genie, capture it in objects and King Solomon also wellknown as the King that created the big Palace with the help of Genie.
In the question about who can seal a genie? An answer can also be found in the Arabian Nights tale (a thousand and one nights to be precise). There is another tale that is almost similar to Aladdin which in this case is a fisherman who happens to drag a sealed jar with his fishing net from the bottom of a lake. The seal on the jar has the king's seal in it, and when the curious fisherman pried the jar open, lo and behold a smoke oozed out of the jar and formed a terrifying figure which is a genie. According to the genie himself that King Solomon who was blessed by God trapped him in there. The genie however was not giving any wishes to the fisherman, rather he would kill the poor man and be off. The fisherman had to trick the genie back into the jar and bargain for some wishes. It's an interesting bit from the Arabian Nights tale. There are other genies who were servants of Kings and apparently they can be controlled by the king in most cases.
Great theory, but in the Aladdin tv show we actually meet the genie binders, a group of people that do exactly what the name implies.... In fact we meet the very same one that binds Genie
In real life, there are people who have the knowledge to control the jin upon their will but it comes with a price. Once free they haunt the person and his family forever.
An extra caveat: this might also be related to how Jeannie, the female version from the sixties series I Dream Of Jeannie, was also created, though it tells differently. The Mauro could closely be related to people in the Arab peninsula, who possessed these magical abilities to control the jinn, though it's just a theory. Great work pointing this out.
I think the clip of him saying "phenomenal cosmic power" while he's all big, red, and threatening looking should have been included again when theorizing if he had once been a wicked Djin,
I’m not that knowledgeable of Djinn lore, but I could work it out by analogy. In mythology and folklore demons (which are somewhat similar to Djinns) are usually deceived into complying with the protagonist, which sometimes gets them sealed into various artifacts. I believe any human that is cunning enough might have bound the Genie to the lamp, pretty much like Aladdin gets himself out of the Cave of Wonders without wasting a wish. It would be pretty cool if the first master was a pseudo-Aladdin, wouldn’t it? Then again, in occultism it is believed that King Solomon used to control demons. I know people are arguing about this statement in comments below, so I’ll be clear: it’s not part of my beliefs. I’m merely speculating about a fictional subject, in the context of lore and fantasy. While King Solomon might have never left Israel, it is likely that successive owners of the lamp used to travel and somewhat got the lamp in the Cave of Wonders.
I always thought the the same being who cursed Beast was the one who created the lamp. Knowing that humans would most likely wish to be "the most powerful in the univers," she came up with a clever lesson. That wish would then create the catch 22 and swift justice that the lamp carries out. Genie was once a normal man who made that wish, just like the genie before him? 🤔 Question is, who was the first genie??
I had a theory that the Genie from Aladdin was not a real Genie. I was thinking it may of been a fey or shape shifting fairy cursed to force whomever has the lamp. It would explain why the genie doesn't need to have the lamp rubbed in order to leave it, why when he considered getting out of the cave that was a wish, but once he pointed it out it no longer counted. But since Aladdin agreed "no more freebies" when he was drowning he didn't need verbal confirmation to use up a wish. Additionally, it explains why Jafar can control the genie just by having the lamp, even though he still has a contract with Aladdin. Also, if you want to go sequels, It explains why not only why removing Aladdin's clothing suddenly no longer made him a Prince (Father was a king of thieves) which logically shouldn't work since it was Made clear that Genies are more powerful. and in Return of Jafar, When the genie fought with Jafar, he had no chance. Though freed he was still a genie....allegedly. Being taken out so easily indicates that perhaps he was another kind of magical creature.
There's always a chance he was a good genie which was causing problems for an evil force. If Genie was the good force's trump card, you better believe they'd try and find a way to get rid of him.
I know the original version of Aladdin am Arab and I know who are the jinn it's not like what most of you think and the answer is النبي سلميان عليه السلام
I'm actually reading the book "1001 nights" and in the story called "The Fisherman" a fisherman founds a bronze cup and when he breaks a seal on the cup a Genie emerges from it and he explains that Salomon the great prophet of God imprisoned him because he was an evil spirit that rebel from God and he didn't obey Salomon, so he was forced to pull the throne of him but he still wasn't obedient, so Salomon imprisoned him in the cup with a Seal for 4 centuries. Sorry for my English, I'm Mexican :P
Hey Issac! I've been watching your video of Kion's disappearance in The Lion King 2. Which gave me an excellent idea for a sequel. WHERE WAS SARABI IN BOTH THE LION KING 2 AND THE LION GUARD????????
Wotso Videos Simple answer really. She died of old age. She was an adult at the start of the first movie and we she's still alive when Simba returns as an adult to end Scar's reign. Which is going through a period of drought and famine so bad that remaining at pride rock is a death sentence. Not to mention that Scar seems to get furious when his authority is challenged or compared to Mufasa.
When the film came out there was a magazine tie in that had an interview with Genie and he revealed he used to be human until some guys asked him to look into a lamp and that's how he became a genie.
I’m pretty sure that there are multiple genies/jinns I think your theory is correct but I don’t think that that specific genie was tied down I think that there were many people who wanted to be a genie and wished so and got everything that came with it hence the vicious cycle of genies
Your leaps of logic are so energetic it would mage the gummi bears proud. A reasonable effort, but we really have far to little information to begin to form a proper theory.
Luce Kidlets I've been wondering why nobody has mentioned the black cauldron yet, I want to know more about who the evil king that was trapped in the cauldron, and the full story of the horned king, but yeah Atlantis would be cool.
I think trickery was involved. The genie wanted more power, more power than the godlike power he already had. A lever wizard entered a debate with him, setting up rules of conduct for contracts and such, giving the power to free will and binding contracts sprung from those. He then convinced the genie to create the bands and the lamp in clever storytelling. The genie would have unlimited power for a mere 2 wishes and 1 to release him, and the wizard was to wish for his freedom for the last wish. But the wizard painted the deal to sound far better than that. Once bound, the wizard betrayed the genie, gave 3 selfish wishes and buried the lamp... perhaps while saying "maybe your next master will be generous by wish 3." That explains why Jafar became the next godlike being trapped in the lamp.
@@TheRealSephiroth I'm guessing it's cause of the legend who voices him if you've never seen Aladdin I feel sad cause he is a legend my cousin wants to become a comedian cause of him I'm glad will Smith did want to copy him it never would've for and I rambling aren't I I'll stop...
Now could you make a theory on how the lamp ended up in the cave of wonders. Or even how the cave of wonders came to exit in the first place.
I thought the concept came from the original Arabian Nights?
And also why Jafar knows where the lamp
@@gpaderx6105 perhaps because he's a sorcerer and his dark magics enabled him to know of its whereabouts.
Drew Asaro that’s a great idea 💡
Cave of wonders is the soul, or woman.
from a mythological standpoint the most likely answer would be Solomon
oooh! hahaha! yeah!
Yeah, the guy who got to BREAK YHWH's no magic rule?
@@chrissonofpear1384 wasn't his best move but yeah at least according to some cultures.
I believe Solomon is real and Jesus can save you from death
Hey, no real issue there. Just that sooner or later, the issue of Jehovah's messy reputation and why jeopardy to souls even existed, might rear it's variformed head.
According to Islamic traditions, the only human being who was able to control and capture Satans ( evil Genes ) in the history is King Solomon in Jerusalem.
King Solomon was a prophet and King at the same time , he asked god to grant him a throne/power that should not be granted to anyone else after him. Then god gave him the ability to understand birds/animals languages , control the wind , and control all Jinns and their power. They say that he used to punish the evil Jinns and put them inside objects like boxes or maybe lamps.
Nobody can have this ability again after King Solomon because that was his wish.
Majed Alajmi so your saying maybe King Solomon. I totally agree
Kenzie Hans not all Jinns are evil, there are good and bad Jinns just like humans
@@kenziehans6598 no.. there are 2 kinds of jinns good and bad. Same like humans...
There are good jinns those have accepted Islam and there are other demons.
@@kenziehans6598 it was good genie..
But trapped by some1 to full fill his/her wishes..
Kenzie Hans logically, he probably was trapped inside the lamp by a powerful sorcerer in the past. However it’s just Disney thing, there is not such a thing in real life. In real life Magicians can use Genies in dark magic without trap them. Because the genie that works with magicians and dark magic are all bad 100%. Actually it’s not the magician controlling the genie , it’s the genie controlling the magician and help hem to mislead people.
You have no idea about Arabian myth. Some of the powerful jinns were supposedly trapped on bottles and lamps by King Solomon.
I was about to mention that lol!
@@KarlKimball i always thought it was jafar before he became a genie
K
He is looking at it from disney's perspective in their universe!
@@Dragonizes from the technology seen in that movie since they already have access to damascus steel it cant be any more than 1000 years ago. Saudi Arabia is part of the cradle of civilization, which existed long before the Mayans or Aztec (mezo american) cultures. It could have just as easily been a much older vizier that long predates Jafar (possibly even one of his ancestors) that trapped the Genie
In the aladdin animated series, one episode included a former master of the genie (who had wished for immortality but not for eternal youth, and become extremely old and withered), who used a new pair of darker, handcuff-like shackles to trap the genie to serve him again. So, people who can trap djinn may not be that rare.
YOUR
GETTING
YOUR
WISH SO
SIT
DOWN!
😂
😆
Ana Nunez
Ir
Didn't
Get
Myr
Wish
So
Can
Ir
Stand
Back
Up?
Ana Nunez lol
😂😂
I love the ideas that disney has with all these powerful magical artifacts. and they're all made of gold: Genie's lamp, Maleficent's staff, Triton's trident, Ursula's nautilus shell, kinda Hercules' amulet, probably quite a few things on Tamatoa's shell. either gold items or gems are sources of power for the disney world: the Heart of Te' fiti, the crystals of Atlantis, whatever that big red gem that Abu touched in the cave of wonders was seemed pretty important.
"10.000 years will give such a crick in the neck"
I don't think Sophia and Elena were that old
No, but the Maru people were
10 years isn't that long
@@Lucid4286 nice
I only liked this so it could be 69 likes hehe
10,000*
can you do a theory on why Jafar was a more powerful genie than the original genie?
Ari Yad Jafar didn't care about rules unlike the Genie. The Genie was as powerful as Jafar but didn't use his full power. That's what I think anyway.
Ari Yad I think it was because of his wish
well if the original genie was able to give jafar those powers, surely he was equally as powerful?
Ari Yad in the second movie it says genie got weaker when he was freed to semi-fernominal nearly cosmic unlike a genie in a lamp
oh right. thanks. That doesn't explain why the genie wasn't able to stop Jafar after granting his third wish. The genie was done being Jafar's master and wasn't free yet, so he could have stopped jafar instead of Aladdin.
How about a theory on the backstory of Aladdin's carpet. Is it possible that he was once a human cursed to live in the body of flying fabric? Also how did he end up in the cave of wonders. (I know we ask a lot from you, but these are just suggestions, no obligations)
The real story is interesting also as the carpet replaces the Genie of the Ring, a less powerful genie than that of the lamp.
It is probably just a craft like in the story of price Ahmad and piri-banu
What’s suspicious about the way Genie gets all mad and intimidating when Aladdin makes fun of him?
I’m sure you would react the same way if someone were to make fun of you!
He does everything in such a goofy way I didn’t take it that serious like as a real threat to harm.
Were you a history major in college? Your videos are very well researched.
IKR
I mean yeah definitely, but he also didn't get that djinni (genie) is just the singular of djinn
@@azazelreeds he doesn't know everything
Isn't it established that King Solomon was in the business of trapping genies in lamps?
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solomon#One_Thousand_and_One_Nights
In the actual book, there were actually two genies: the Genie of the Lamp and the Genie of the Ring, and each gave Aladdin 3 wishes, with him being the master of both of them. Woulda been interesting if they had used both genies instead of just one.
Next theory did Gaston killed Bambi mom ?
Bambi I think was made to not show a particular time period. I read the original book from the 1920's and it doesn't give a specific date of when the story was either. When I watched the movie you never see "Man." You only hear the sound of the gun and Bambi is told his mom died so it's possible that the two movies could have occurred around the same time.
MMA KING jr in an early draft of Roger Rabbit, Judge Doom was the one who killed Bambi's mom
Bambi is set in the USA, Beauty and the Beast is set in France. Also, the rifle shot that kills Bambi's mom sounds like a modern rifle, not the type Gaston would have had access to.
Keith Dean it could've been Amos slade from from the fox and the hound that killed Bambi's mom
Keith Dean Bambi actually from Canada not USA I know because he's in the Canadian section of Epcot
Traditionally, Solomon was the one who imprisoned the Djin in bottles, lamps, rings, and so on.
can you do one about iago and why he served jafar. another one I would love to see is where did the magic carpet come from thank you. you're videos are awesome
Yes!
Katherine Lowe yes
The magic carpet came from the same place that Aladdin found the lamp.
Delirium_ Fries I think your answer is the best one, you smartass
The carpet is also at least 10.000 years old, for both seemed to know each other when Genie came free.
That's entirely possible but I just struggle to imagine the Genie as a bad guy
Did you not watch the Aladdin series? Their chaotic gods prolly did it. Even Genie feared them.
Sophia is too new.
There's one story about how God gave King Solomon a powerful ring that allowed him to keep jinni under his control. One of them, named Asmodeus, pissed him off so he imprisoned him in a lamp. 400 years later a fisherman accidentally discovers this lamp and frees Asmodeus, who's ticked off about being stuck in a lamp. He threatens to kill the fisherman, who manages to trick him back into the lamp. Asmodeus, now realizing his mistake, begs the fisherman to let him back out, in exchange for three wishes. But that's just ONE story.
Well I have some ideas.
A. The Enchantress: She is associated with magical animate objects like the Beast's staff turned furniture similar to the Magic Carpet found alongside the Genie, as well as creating magical objects like the magical rose.
B. Merlin: Not as likely but has been shown with magical objects and has combated powerful shapeshifters like Madam Mim in the past.
C: Middle eastern dragon of the past from American Dragon: The Dragons have shown to protect the human world from magic creatures for many generations, and have access to many items and spells to trap dangerous entities. Its also to be noted that the dragons once dealt with a goblin made chalice that can release evil Djinn.
I believe that it wasn't an all powerful group of people that trapped the, but, a sneaky person who tricked them into the lamps as Aladdin did!
The genie often made comments about “modern” events and technology which made people feel as though the genie had lived in the future. Some of the statues in the cave of wonders is from ancient Sumerian times and looks like Annunaki. So the genie seems to have existed in all times from ancient to modern times.
I feel a more plausible explanation is that the Genie was collateral? He wasn't necessarily evil, but the shear abundance of evil genies in the world, being captured and contained, made him a target by association. They may have mistaken him for an evil Genie and trapped him anyway.
I don't think the Genie would be violent, but just mischeivious (e.g. mushu, Iago) to where merva were concerned of the havoc he could ensued with his limitless power.
Robyn Reding jinns(mostly djinn) were said to toy with wishes like if you would wish for a puppy you get a rabid jackal
You need to watch the Aladdin animated series where you meet the being that traped Genie in the first place
The back story of Fa Zhou, Mulan's dad.
Andrew Bercovitz yes
I believe Isacc already has done one about Fa Zhou.
I do have one on how he became a war hero. Check it out here: th-cam.com/video/F0oohQBuprE/w-d-xo.html Thanks for watching!
HE DID
dont yell Jeremy and lookup lol
The background music was so off putting :(
Malibu Milk lower the volume a bit until you can’t hear the background music
Genies temper was made as imitation of Robert de Niro's performance in Taxi not anything else
Genies are criminals. So the genie we all know and love did something really bad to be in that lamp
Huh, I'd heard that it was King Solomon who imprisoned the Djin...
Fucking thank you! Yes Solomon was granted the power to summon and control Demons or Djinn by the God of the old testament
Thoralmir please explain
Muslims believe that Solomon, known to them as Sulaymān, was given a ring by the Archangel Michael that would give him command over all demons and spirits of the earth, including jinn. A number he imprisoned in various containers, like brass jars and lamps.
Thoralmir Same.It says in the Holy Qur'an that he had different kinds of jinns who would do everything he wished.
but that do not flow with in the time frame Aladdin is set. It shows that in the movie the sphinx is being finished Also the cartoon has Mechanicles who is a Greek and the Hercules show corsses over with the Aladdin show, thus Aladdin takes place long before Islam was birthed as a faith. Either Aladdin is Persian and thus probably A Zoratist or any number of ancient middle eastern faith that predates Islam
Who put him in the cave of wonders and made it that only a diamond in the rough can enter to get the lamp in the first place.
I really love the theory and this channel in general! Can you do one about Atlantis?
Oh yes please, Atlantis is such an underrated movie! Do something about Treasure Planet as well, I love both those movies and they are both so under-appreciated.
I'm happy you are enjoying it! This video I made a few weeks ago may not seem like an Atlantis video, but trust me it is! Check it out here: th-cam.com/video/v9x9T_WZm_M/w-d-xo.html Thanks for watching!
Thanks a lot, Tangled and Atlantis are my favoutite Disney movies, so this is perfect!
Wotso Videos we need a behind the meme kind of channel youre theories are awesome while behind the meme treats his viewers like 3 year olds
Good theory. Who really knows though. From what we know we have no idea who or what would have been motivated to trap Genie. This is a good idea though that it was due to the recklessness or cruelty of his past. In many stories genies are portrayed as troublemakers and tricksters. Perhaps that's why he was trapped. It could have very well been the Moroovians. We've seen other Genies in Sofia the First and they are confined to their lamps for misbehavior. It makes sense then that genies are locked in lamps, not as an unfair curse but as a punishment (perhaps in the hopes that they will someday become good).
"Cursed the genie into being a slave of all who rubs it" I must have like gazillion genies by now.
I disagree on that because according to the similarly Cannon series of Aladdin we find another Genie name Eden who is also cursed to a bottle
10,000 years the Genie says. So go back 10,000 years from Aladdin. Who was around back then that could do that? Or was it just another master that wasn't his first. Also, Jinns were caught by people back then according to things like the books of wisdom and Jewish/Muslim folktales. So who knows. Example: " Asmodeus, king of demons, was one day, according to the classical Rabbis, captured by Benaiah using the ring, and was forced to remain in Solomon's service."
Aladdin is from 11th century.
10000 years he trapped.
So he started trapped in 1th century
Pretty sure it was Solomon who sealed the Genie in the lamp. According to legend, a genie displeased Solomon somehow, probably granted him a wish exactly as worded rather than the way Solomon intended for it to be interpreted, and Solomon responded by sealing the genie away.
please do who killed Bambi's mom?
Luce Kidlets it was the hunter
jason kreider I konw!😂 I just want to know maybe the specific person like if it was Gus dollars something like people said?
Luce Kidlets quick video
Lucifer killed bambis mother and brought children to tears.
Luce Kidlets john Smith from Pocahontas.
Gaston
I like the Idea of the Genie being once Evil. It gives rise to the idea that People/Entities can change for the better, If afforded the Opportunity.
Allow me to explain this in some detail. There are 2 episodes that go into this in some detail and I suggest you look them up or go watch them. They are The Genie Hunt and The Hunted. Where it goes into some detail about the genies first master and the one who created him.
which series? :P
@@fuseteam the Aladdin tv series
@@britishjack9931 there was an alladin tv series?! o.O
@@fuseteam yes
@@britishjack9931 oh my did not know that
I read that there is going to be a live-action movie that is supposed to be an origin story for the Genie; I believe it's meant to be released before or after the live-action Aladdin(most likely after, given we're getting info for Aladdin before Genie's story).
this probably is one of the few disney theories i've heard that actually make sense don't clash anything contradictions
I'm happy to hear you thought it seemed valid! Thanks for watching!
Disney is stupid not making a separate movie about gene and his life or history.
King Solomon do it in the Arabic mythology and not just in lamp in many stuff like ring
The Jinn that are Shayaton can’t change. The very word comes from Shayton,Satan because they serve him. The Jinn who don’t go around the world only to be controlled by Solomon.
My thoughts were always Merlin did it. He has the ability to travel to any point in time, has a long life span as well as the good will and power to trap/punish a that isn't human and cause mischievous trouble.
There's actually one more genie in Aladdin's tale. It's the Djinn of the ring. She is far weaker than the lamb genie yet she is also powerful enough for some wishes.
Cool theory, but one thing that bugs me is that if Genie was cursed, how do we explain Jafar’s lamp appearing out of now where? Aside from Jafar being slightly more powerful than the Genie they’re both the same. Maybe the prison of a Genie is magical manifestation of a failsafe. Because the Djinn are so powerful, there needs to be a way to control them. Not only does the lamp work as a prison, but in Jafar’s case it also proved to be a dangerous weakness. Which only Genie knew about. So, maybe the lamp simply comes into existence as a way to control a Djinn as well destroy a Djinn if there was a need to do so.
While your theory has some logic, there is a more likely answer that comes straight from the Aladdin TV series. There is a species known as the 'Mukhtar', whom Genie describes as living only for enslaving genies. Given Genie's immense fear of them (A fear I that is too strong to be just from hearing stories of them), I would say that Genie was probably imprisoned by such a creature.
Maybe it was moui who trapped the genie , he's immortal so i believe he'd be around to see him and trapped him with the power of the gods , from his exhaustion he probably dropped it in the sea resulting in tamatoa finding it and resulting in his immense size , and I know tamatoa was around for mouis origins but maybe moui was a part of an incarnation cycle also resulting in his parents throwing him a way as he wasn't deemed"the chosen one"
Zarya Nova different time periods. Moana happen 100s of years after Aladdin.
Brady Voels: No real way to say. Moana could have happened thousands to hundreds of years ago.
Remember Tamatoa isn't a giant crab. He's a dark being around since near the beginning who happens to have that form. He's also either a demigod or Moanna's culture's version of a demon.
It was the Mukhtar. It is in the show.
Tracy Danger: They just said they were Genie hunters. Not that they crafted the lamps.
Well the most common myth is that King Solomon was able to command them using their True Names. Matter of fact as I recall the Djinn found in a bottle by a fisherman said that he'd been imprisoned by King Solomon. This is also the first tale specifying 3 wishes (In the original Aladdin story, the Djinn just granted any wish the bearer of the lamp made, until Aladdin accidentally offended it by ordering it to steal a Roc's egg).
I reckon Ursula was trying to curse someone but she failed and accidentally turned herself into the genie. But hey, that's just a theory! LOL
Hey that's just a theory a film theory
My theory is that one of the Genie's masters simply wished for the Genie to be bound to the lamp as a means of control, to be banished or summoned at the whim of his Master.
Queen Clarion and Lord Milori theory or how Queen Clarion got her wings or who was queen before her.
I would love to do some research into the fairy franchise. Thanks for watching!
3:56 a dangerous moth fairy that brings darkness to the world?
doesn't that sound like the moth man or a flying 'thing' that's been seen when theirs a volcano eruption or tsunami? and this moth fairy was trapped in a spirit world. cant our moth man thing been trapped in the spirit realm and now released? we are in the end times anyways.
sorry! just a thought
I thought the genies higher masters was the Roc bird? I’m wondering how did they harness the genie and why the lamp in general!
Actually, there is a way! There is an Arabian story in which a young man outwits a genie (the one from Aladdin!) and in the end gets him so mad, that he traps him in a lamp. I forget exactly how. (Beyond is Edited) AND the genie from the original story is actually evil! So his time in the lamp might have made the genie change his ways.
Oh interesting! I know in lots of pop culture genies are really manipulative and those stories probably play into that. Thanks for watching!
well here is another question why was aladan the only one who could enter the cave of wonders and why was the gennie placed in the cave of wonders in the first place.
He even though he was a petty thief, he was doing it to survive and helped out others in need. He never stole for greed. He wasnt in the best of circumstances but he was a human of great potential and character.
Great idea - with just one problem - geography. The Meru, from what I understand, existed in what would later become Latin America. I do not think that they would be operating on or near the Arabian Peninsula.
And even if the Genie’s havoc was originally in what would later become Latin America (thereby causing him to run in with the Meru) - how would the lamp have gotten all the way from Meruvia (later to be Avalon) to Agraba (which is clearly in Arabia)?
You need to find some way to answer this question in order for your idea to work.
do mulans dad origins
Linda Bangloy yes
There already is one.
I actually have an old video about her father. It's on how he became a war hero: th-cam.com/video/F0oohQBuprE/w-d-xo.html Thanks for watching!
Wotso Videos thanks!
He did.
The Genie was trapped for AT LEAST 10,000 years..."10,000 years will give you such a crick in the neck" meaning either he has been trapped in total of 10,000 years or hasn't HAD a master for 10,000 years meaning he's older. Also check out if you haven't heard of the theory that Tamotoa was the genies last master. 😄😘
Do you know Solomon? Or in Quran we know him as Prophet Sulaiman? He had an strong army of genie, i think he is the closest person that could mastering the genie, capture it in objects and King Solomon also wellknown as the King that created the big Palace with the help of Genie.
In the question about who can seal a genie? An answer can also be found in the Arabian Nights tale (a thousand and one nights to be precise). There is another tale that is almost similar to Aladdin which in this case is a fisherman who happens to drag a sealed jar with his fishing net from the bottom of a lake. The seal on the jar has the king's seal in it, and when the curious fisherman pried the jar open, lo and behold a smoke oozed out of the jar and formed a terrifying figure which is a genie. According to the genie himself that King Solomon who was blessed by God trapped him in there. The genie however was not giving any wishes to the fisherman, rather he would kill the poor man and be off. The fisherman had to trick the genie back into the jar and bargain for some wishes. It's an interesting bit from the Arabian Nights tale. There are other genies who were servants of Kings and apparently they can be controlled by the king in most cases.
Can anybody else hear a buzzing sound in the background or just me?
Just you
@@johnnylawrence7409 You're weird
I can too
Why was Basil upset over a bullet in the Great Mouse Detective
Great theory, but in the Aladdin tv show we actually meet the genie binders, a group of people that do exactly what the name implies.... In fact we meet the very same one that binds Genie
well actully they were called genie hunters and the one we know of wasn't really stated to be the one that bind genie to the lamp
Donald Lang
It was Arabian nights.
Jinn or ginnie catchers were called mamluks. As far as cartoons are concerned.
In real life, there are people who have the knowledge to control the jin upon their will but it comes with a price. Once free they haunt the person and his family forever.
No i know the original story of Aladdin and I know who imprisoned them all النبي سليمان
Love this video! Can you do a video of why Jafar can't enter the cave of wonders? And the history behind the cave of wonders.
An extra caveat: this might also be related to how Jeannie, the female version from the sixties series I Dream Of Jeannie, was also created, though it tells differently. The Mauro could closely be related to people in the Arab peninsula, who possessed these magical abilities to control the jinn, though it's just a theory. Great work pointing this out.
Now THIS would be an interesting connection... and an interesting backstory for the Genie.
2:16 actually djinn (at least always I've seen it spelled) has a d in front of it
I think the clip of him saying "phenomenal cosmic power" while he's all big, red, and threatening looking should have been included again when theorizing if he had once been a wicked Djin,
Just so you know, jinn are still there.they are just invisible after the last prophet 😑
They were never visible they were visible to Sulaiman cause Allah gave him that ability
That’s right
Did anyone else ever read that book that had Aladdin and the Genie.....but the genie was a girl and they fell in love???? It's a real book
The poor guy he just had an itty bitty living space.
I’m not that knowledgeable of Djinn lore, but I could work it out by analogy. In mythology and folklore demons (which are somewhat similar to Djinns) are usually deceived into complying with the protagonist, which sometimes gets them sealed into various artifacts. I believe any human that is cunning enough might have bound the Genie to the lamp, pretty much like Aladdin gets himself out of the Cave of Wonders without wasting a wish. It would be pretty cool if the first master was a pseudo-Aladdin, wouldn’t it?
Then again, in occultism it is believed that King Solomon used to control demons. I know people are arguing about this statement in comments below, so I’ll be clear: it’s not part of my beliefs. I’m merely speculating about a fictional subject, in the context of lore and fantasy. While King Solomon might have never left Israel, it is likely that successive owners of the lamp used to travel and somewhat got the lamp in the Cave of Wonders.
I always thought the the same being who cursed Beast was the one who created the lamp. Knowing that humans would most likely wish to be "the most powerful in the univers," she came up with a clever lesson.
That wish would then create the catch 22 and swift justice that the lamp carries out. Genie was once a normal man who made that wish, just like the genie before him? 🤔
Question is, who was the first genie??
I had a theory that the Genie from Aladdin was not a real Genie. I was thinking it may of been a fey or shape shifting fairy cursed to force whomever has the lamp. It would explain why the genie doesn't need to have the lamp rubbed in order to leave it, why when he considered getting out of the cave that was a wish, but once he pointed it out it no longer counted. But since Aladdin agreed "no more freebies" when he was drowning he didn't need verbal confirmation to use up a wish. Additionally, it explains why Jafar can control the genie just by having the lamp, even though he still has a contract with Aladdin.
Also, if you want to go sequels, It explains why not only why removing Aladdin's clothing suddenly no longer made him a Prince (Father was a king of thieves) which logically shouldn't work since it was Made clear that Genies are more powerful. and in Return of Jafar, When the genie fought with Jafar, he had no chance. Though freed he was still a genie....allegedly. Being taken out so easily indicates that perhaps he was another kind of magical creature.
do one on Mulan
Mulan is a real story from China. If you want to know more, go look up the legend...
I'm wondering how after specifying "all powerful" in his become a genie wish, he was limited by lamp and bracelet/shackles rather than a free genie.
You're gettin' your wishes so *SIDDOWN!!!*
your profilepicture just made this so much better.
That kind of aggressive generosity is hilarious to me
There's always a chance he was a good genie which was causing problems for an evil force. If Genie was the good force's trump card, you better believe they'd try and find a way to get rid of him.
Jafer jafer hes our man if he can't do it *GREAT*
We've been trying to figure this one out for a while. How big is it inside the lamp?
I know the original version of Aladdin am Arab and I know who are the jinn it's not like what most of you think and the answer is النبي سلميان عليه السلام
oh CMON
The Prophet peace be upon him???
Wut
You mean profit Muhammad ?
its prophet solomon guys cmon
I'm actually reading the book "1001 nights" and in the story called "The Fisherman" a fisherman founds a bronze cup and when he breaks a seal on the cup a Genie emerges from it and he explains that Salomon the great prophet of God imprisoned him because he was an evil spirit that rebel from God and he didn't obey Salomon, so he was forced to pull the throne of him but he still wasn't obedient, so Salomon imprisoned him in the cup with a Seal for 4 centuries. Sorry for my English, I'm Mexican :P
Hey Issac! I've been watching your video of Kion's disappearance in The Lion King 2. Which gave me an excellent idea for a sequel. WHERE WAS SARABI IN BOTH THE LION KING 2 AND THE LION GUARD????????
This is an idea I have been wondering about for a long time as well. I want to dive into that soon. Thanks for watching!
Wotso Videos
Simple answer really. She died of old age. She was an adult at the start of the first movie and we she's still alive when Simba returns as an adult to end Scar's reign. Which is going through a period of drought and famine so bad that remaining at pride rock is a death sentence. Not to mention that Scar seems to get furious when his authority is challenged or compared to Mufasa.
When the film came out there was a magazine tie in that had an interview with Genie and he revealed he used to be human until some guys asked him to look into a lamp and that's how he became a genie.
Why is magi the only thing coming to mind?🤔🤔
I’m pretty sure that there are multiple genies/jinns I think your theory is correct but I don’t think that that specific genie was tied down I think that there were many people who wanted to be a genie and wished so and got everything that came with it hence the vicious cycle of genies
My question is, how did the genie's lamp end up in the cave of wonders?
it make you wonder
Your leaps of logic are so energetic it would mage the gummi bears proud. A reasonable effort, but we really have far to little information to begin to form a proper theory.
do one on Atlantis!
Luce Kidlets I've been wondering why nobody has mentioned the black cauldron yet, I want to know more about who the evil king that was trapped in the cauldron, and the full story of the horned king, but yeah Atlantis would be cool.
Luce Kidlets Atlantis was just and Island that was volcanic like Krakatoa, and it ended up like Krakatoa. Boom.
I think trickery was involved. The genie wanted more power, more power than the godlike power he already had. A lever wizard entered a debate with him, setting up rules of conduct for contracts and such, giving the power to free will and binding contracts sprung from those. He then convinced the genie to create the bands and the lamp in clever storytelling. The genie would have unlimited power for a mere 2 wishes and 1 to release him, and the wizard was to wish for his freedom for the last wish. But the wizard painted the deal to sound far better than that. Once bound, the wizard betrayed the genie, gave 3 selfish wishes and buried the lamp... perhaps while saying "maybe your next master will be generous by wish 3." That explains why Jafar became the next godlike being trapped in the lamp.
Rickem rackem rackem rake stick sword into that snake!
YOU STAY OUT OF THIS!
Jafar jafar hes our man if he cant do it GREAT! 😏
I've always loved that line from the Genie
@@SunnyyDayzz we all do that's the only reason I even watch this movie anymore
@@TheRealSephiroth I'm guessing it's cause of the legend who voices him if you've never seen Aladdin I feel sad cause he is a legend my cousin wants to become a comedian cause of him I'm glad will Smith did want to copy him it never would've for and I rambling aren't I I'll stop...
Interesting theory to a question I never thought to ask.
Amazing how many things we take for granted, or never question.
i think iago was a prince that didnt want to marry jasmine
I like the concept of your videos. Life long Disney fan, and these questions/theories, etc. are intriguing.
Wotso's videos are so unique! It seriously shows how much he puts into researching!!
I'm glad you can see how I differentiate myself from other creators. I'm glad you like the videos. Thanks for watching!
😍
It was archangels that stopped the gein and banished them so that is then long and short of that