Why India Is Afraid Of Its History
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 25 ก.ค. 2023
- Textbook sections about Mahatma Gandhi, the Mughal Empire and the theory of evolution were only some of those the Indian government has removed from students’ textbooks in 2023.
The recent deletions aren’t an isolated event. Rewriting history has been a major priority of Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Hindu nationalist party - and the impacts have been felt way beyond textbooks.
#India #NCERT #BJP
Subscribe for more videos: ajplus.co/subscribe
Follow us on Instagram: / ajplus
Like us on Facebook: / ajplusenglish
Follow us on Twitter: / ajplus
we should not remove history but add history of india like gupta empire, mauryan, chera chola pandya and indus valley civilization.
@@lordvold9486 lol aryan invasion and migration both has been disproved with current dna testing across india. Aryan invasion theory is myth to divide india and take credit of vedic work done by us.
@@lordvold9486not Dravadian but Old Tamil
@@iniyanprabhakaran lmao
Kartik! You have just proved yourself wrong. Had it not been taught how would you have known about the Gupta empire, Chola, Cheras!! It was always taught. You were sleeping 😴 then and now the WA university forwards have made you feel they were not taught.. This is called mind bending.. History as a subject is taught to General students from Class VI to X only. Everything from Ancient India to Mediaeval India to Modern India has to be taught to students of Age 11 to 16, including like you who were sleeping during History classes.. Just check the books - it was all taught.
To those who are interested in History it is taught in greater detail after X.
*What is there to learn about the Indus valley civilization. In fact you can't decipher their language boi.*
Those who don't learn about history are doomed to repeat it.
What are you getting at?
Considering India contributed 2.5m soldiers to fighting the axis (Germany and Japan), that’s an utterly ignorant comment to make.
@@naxalite115yes under the British rule which you forget to mention. Also Muslim were among the soldiers as. Get your facts straight.
@@GoodOne4All of course under British rule, but the fact remains it was a VOLUNTEER army, not conscripts. Of course Muslims were in the army, but the vast vast majority were Sikhs and Marathi’s. Know your history.
150 years history doesn't really mean shit, India have more than 10,000 years history, so there are better things to learn than some bs
@@Nexus-fe1yz As an "Indian" person myself and with some level of education. India was never "United" as a whole untill the British took over the subcontinent. Get your facts straight. The two empires that held the most territory from the "Indian subcontinent" was the Mauryan and than the Mughals. You do know "India" was invaded countless times by different empires/kingdoms whenever India would fight and weaken the region another external force came to the region. Hell it's even in the "Indian DNA", hence why you find signature of African, West Asian, East Asian and Central Asian (Arayan). Get your facts straight or keep continue to each your nonsense like laadoo and Paneer.
We want to learn our own histrory not invaders history
who are the invaders?
@@laithmughrabi8990 see you don't know about invaders...🤭🤭🤭
@@sradhandas5174
The invaders did more for India in 600 years than sanatanis have in 6000
Not they didn't abdul 😂💀@@syedahmed8650
@@syedahmed8650so u r proud of how they destroyed 1000s of temples, and used the same material to build mosques and erase indic religions.
Thanku for solidifying my belief of "never trust muzzzzlims"
I'm a muslim and a history enthusiast, however i must say that I've studied the ncert history books and it is definitely over-focused on mughal empire and delhi sultanate, and eventhough i love to read about the mughals, there has to be enough representation of the other diverse empires that existed in india. So if they remove part of mughal history and replace it with ahoms or cholas, then although i might feel slightly upset (due to the political aspect) as a muslim, as a history enthusiast I'll be happy that other empires are finally getting representation.
bro you're indian first then a muslim..
and also those muslim rulers were not natives but they were bunch of invaders who destroyed thousands of historical places..and forcefully converted millions of peoples into islam.
Some sensible guy
the thing is there's no reliable historical evidence of Indian history that was written before Mughal empire besides some snippets and imaginary stories written by indians who didn't even live during that age.
That's true
❤
100 % lindus😂😂
‘Those who do not learn history are doomed to repeat it.’
We remember the butchery 😂 don’t worry about us
@@Aries659that's why you guys pee in your dhoti and are trying to remove it 🤗 but you know. Scars stay ;)
@@Aries659full support this channel is fully bhadkau and anti bjp content
@@Seeta-and-Parvati-are-my-fwb ola hu uber
@@praveenshukla472 Jai Chutiya Ram
Ganpati bappa..... Chutiyaaa.
He said Well respected historian n showed Romila thappar...my foot... She is shoeleacker of leftist...😂😂😂😂
Doesn't negate the fact that what she said is true.
@@hostile_usermanipulation or twisting of facts
@@hostile_userthen why was she wrong about the existence of Saraswati river?
@@hostile_userlol she btw claimed that Buddhist tale was there under so called babri masjid ,when asked for evidence she was mum ,😂later ASI dig happened and hindu architecture was found by archaeological department,
read her books first dumbo ,she puts just claims which have no evidence
@@hostile_userwhat true commie stories for Muslim appeasement
Im not in favour of scrapping out histories including that of mughal leaders but NCERT is overly focused on Mughal era, India has a rich history so that part should be added
Chola, pandya, pallvas, ahom , Sungh, katikey , rajputana, maratha, list is endless.
How about the Saka dynasty?
@@4TengrisSakeJust because you have not heard these names doesn’t mean it’s not Indian history 😅
Those history are also added if you read ncert book correctly but why muslim leaders are overly because when the came to india they ruled over most amount of indian land that they are seen important honestly british is seen more important by ncert cause when they came to india they also dominated indian land
@@ayushpatel1245histories of all these empires are there in the textbook and I have read about them as am an humanities passout, the thing that these empires are not talked about so significantly is because they did not have an impact of whole Indian history as a whole they were just concentrated on one part or the another no less than that and no MORE than that, on the other hand Mughals or the Afghans they came from outside which also has a geopolitical or international significance and they ruled whole of India and just a PART unlike chola , ahoms or whatever
How many paragraphs will you find about North East India??
They have 0 like their brain
Fact - The guy who built the Taj Mahal was arrested and jailed by his own son after a brutal internecine struggle. The guy who comissioned the Taj Mahal bankrupted his Mughal Empire and his son jailed him for this wasted resources.
You forgot to mention 60% Tax was imposed on Farmers during that era, to build the Taj Mahal, Causing a Great Mass Starvation in those days.
You forgot to mention he also killed his brother and sent the decapitated head to his imprisoned father
@@hindurashtra63 this is not true ,there is no source for this
So, when will RSS Hindutva demolish the Taj Mahal 😮😮😮😮
Why should we Indians be embarrassed when it was Indians that built the Taj Mahal 😂
@@IndianStreetShittersPajeetThen why all the labourers hands were cut as to not replicate the architecture. You need hands and arms to make a building not just your mind.
@@IndianStreetShittersPajeet Yeah Mughals and the entire muslim world has such great architects that they couldn't make a single architecture in their Parental land of Uzbekistan but miraculously learned this after coming to India. 😆😆 Pure joke. Converting Ancient Iranian monuments, Christian Churches and Indian Temples, that was what they were only good at.
@@PreMal2023the hands cutting part was deemed as fake a fabricated
@@zaihussain9069 Indian Hindus paid Jajiya tax to Muslims rulers and that's how with help of Hindu Labours and Hindu tax payer money, the taj mahal was built.
The main issue is that large parts of the history in Indian school books is based on the false propaganda stories of the British. Nobody says that the Mughal history should be erased but there is no need to go into great detail about every Mughal king considering the fact that the Mughals most of the time only ruled large parts of North India. This is why a chapter was reduced. If you have to go to this detail regarding Mughal history then you also have to include more chapters about the great Chola, Chalukya, Vijayanagar and Maratha Empires.
The mughal Empire at its height ruled all but the southern tip of India.
@@balargus319
The Mughals were only able to keep large parts of India for less than 10 years. Later they were defeated by the southern Maratha Empire and lost almost all their territories. Most of its existence the Mughals were a north India based dynasty. It does not make sense to give the Mughals more importance than the Gupta, Chola and Vijayanagar Empires
@@balargus319no noby ever ruled all of india and Marathas who defeated mugals had bigger empire then mugals and mugal kings who remained were mere vassals
@@balargus319it lasted like 10 years
@@AKumar-co7oe Even in its collapse, the Mughal Empire basically set the context for the Rise of the East India Company.
Thank you.Kashi,Central Vista,Mahakal temple ,Puri Bhubaneswar and the list is endless.
What's problem.
Ye project india nhi karega to ka pakistan Or oic karega kya.
And the list is not complete yet
Rubbish!
@@ayushpatel1245 Itihas todke project karenge?Please read and read 51A(f) of the constitution,UNESCO declaration of 1972 and Amsterdam declaration on heritage.Pehla padho baad me criticise karna.
what about apj abdul kalam roads,apj abdul kalam Island....no one will speak about it...if u read ur looters,people will forget ur golden eras,atrocities they did.
Yes India should be a Hindu rashtra my ancestors are the Cholas
Well east part of india should be buddhist majority and Hinduism is also imported Idea from outside, maybe eastern europe or Australia ...😂
@@heythere4218 'Hinduism' is not a single religion. It's just what The west perceives it to be. There are various schools of thought that have all the rights to be called a religion on their own. And no, they were not imported by the West. There is nothing similar to Trika Shaivism, Advaita Vedanta, or Patanjali Yogashastra in the West.
@@heythere4218yeah eastern Europe and Australia are definitely Hindu lmao
Yes, I’m a Dravidian residing in central India and I agree with you
@@heythere4218 My son Hinduism is older than your shitty religion and much older than when your ancestors would be fighting in tribe.
Producer/Editor is Chinese and Everyone else is Muslim... What can we expect ? 😂😂😂
not surprising at all.
Really, that's your defence.
@@tam4959ur life is delusion
@akshay: have happy neighbours before you go across the town. Is ur IQ that bad?
😮😂😂😂😂
Please also make a video about what is written about Hindus in Pakistani textbooks
They will never 😂😂
After all they are Victim Carders
Oh .... they never will... too afraid ...
Pakistan is almost on the brink of failure because of military dictatorship, radical Islam and corruption. Do you want India to end up like that? Radicalism of any kind will destroy a country. BJP is trying to turn India into a radical Hindu country.
The truth ?
@@Xyz-ju7vc Too afraid of what exactly ? cow worshippers who we ruled for 800years Lol
I would much rather learn more about shivaji maharaj and maharana pratap than propaganda glorifying Islamic invaders
Instead of removing history we should represent every sort of history no matter what culture, there are many histories of kingdoms that are lost throughout the history of India & the world in general.
As an American, first time?
Students in india already have to study 4 books for their Social Science exams (History part 1, History part 2, Civics/Political Science, Economics). It's just too inhumane to make them study so much for one exam. I personally didn't like it during my school days. I found it very difficult to balance with other subjects like Science (Again, divided into Biology, chemistry, and physics), Mathematics, Computer Science, Physical Education, Language 1 (English), Language 2 (Mostly Hindi), Language 3 (Sanskrit/Regional language like Kannada, etc.)
Students are made to study so much and an awful lot of it turns out to be useless. They just use route learning and pass the exam, and then forget everything. Therefore, the syllabus must be reduced.
Reducing science and maths is actually bad, because the topics in those books are important and already very concise.
Reducing language content is also bad because it might render students with less knowledge about either English (which is the very reason for the IT boom in India), or their mother tongue (which will cause a big trouble with all the state governments. People would bycott central government schools and join state government schools which teach primarily in regional language).
Reducing physical education/computer science is not possible because they already have so little time. Students hardly get time to play. There's about one PE class a week!
That only leaves us with Social Science. Of the 3 sub divisions; History, Political Science, Economics... History has 2 books! So it makes sense to remove some content from history. Now, what can we remove from history, the one paragraph about the Chola Empire, or one of the many chapters about the Mughals?
I generally do not like the moves by our government, but this is indeed a thoughtful one. It deserves appreciations. The media will definitely portray it as anti Muslim, but it is not. Muslims in India are not Mughals! There is a whole chapter about the Delhi Sultanate (who were Muslim conquerors) which isn't removed. Going by the logic of this video, that Delhi Sultanate chapter should have been removed. But it wasn't, thus proving this video wrong.
If UK can get away by not teaching students about their Colonial atrocities, why can't India reduce the number of chapters dedicated to Mughals in school textbooks? The Mughal dynasty had a series of chapters completely dedicated to them, their architecture, etc. On the other hand other great empires like Cholas had just one paragraph! That's unacceptable. Clearly, that book was biased towards the Mughals. This could have been done due to various political reasons, but it needs to stop now as it is no longer needed.
Brother trust me you have no idea about Indian history.. Just try to answer a question. Why Hindus are still 81% percent of Indian population even after the Islamic rule of 500 years and British Christian rule of 200 years? You will only find the correct answer in Indian history. The Modi government is going to bring them out.
bro the indian history was maniplulated after the british rule taj mahal was tejo mahal and many hindu temples were destroyed. this kind of true history is not thought. Let me give you the example of ram mandir Its is not the history that is being removed it is the false history that is being removed
Yes doing that is called removing muslim history in this video
Time for Indians with dignity and self respect to learn & spread their real history
😂love the way u think man, ur a teen in the TH-cam comments, stop talking like what u say actually matters, 😂😂ngl I love how most Indians comment, it’s just so funny 😂
@@moharshad6882 You and anti Hindu cretins like you cannot cover up the truth about Indian Hindu history with your lies..in this information age.
@@moharshad6882 real history😂😂😂,as if the history which goes against hindutwa ideology is story.
@@imranhasan4109 lol says a converted muslim , you aren't a real one 🤣🤣
@@moharshad6882same like isl@mic p@rasites wh¡mpering 'free pottistine' on every video 😂
this video is the perfect example of why people support modi and bjp..
Even if i get angry at BJP for their complacency and stupidity. These kinda videos makes me realise that still BJP is the one I am gonna vote for🥲
What has the bjp done to prevent this video from being made on TH-cam? 😂
@@TH-camGirliewhy should he prevent the video .
If this video makes you want to support the BJP, then you've been a Hindu fascist dog all along. Not sure what you're trying to prove?
TH-cam is an American platform
I don't think India need anyone to lecture about it's rich CIVILISATION and history.
India is chad ❤
India such beta retadrded wannabe chad lol
Laura...china aur usa ko dekh😂
@@saswatakrsarkar9759 chup re kangladeshi 😂
U can be when online. When you open mouth rest of the world runs away
Removing history from textbooks is wrong. If anything you should add more to history books rather than trying to eradicate it.
Not eradicating it. Compressed it so other empires would be included too. The mughals are still their just compressed a little.
For your information that history on the thumbnail cost the hand of 20000 innocent labours
Narrator : Tabish Talib
Producer : Mashaal Mir
Graphic Designer : Walid Hadid
Do i have to say anything even more??
Muslim : 2+2=4
Lindus: We are not agree with it.
@@imranhasan4109 pusslims at its cries again
@@imranhasan4109 come on muslims can't be that logical not in my lifetime i saw any Muslim smart from gray matter just a few and that to who are not practicing Muslims
@@darkheart8811 Yep. Most successful Indians are also south indians who are liberal.
@@yourdad602 i will support that point to some extent but as much as south indian civil people are successful i have seen people having same characteristics from other regions become successful as well it's the quality of character not the geographical location or culture
Invaders & predators. Can’t decide 😂 make in india 😅
Islam colonized india just like Britain did . The muslims erased the millenary Hindu culture and imposed their culture . Anti islamic colonialism isn't discrimination. Many minorities in islamic conquered lands live as second class citizens even tho that they are the indigenous people of those lands unlike their islamic colonizers.
Thsi is such a short sighted view .As a Matter of fact, India is enhancing its history to include all since it existence and not just last 300-400 years or last 75 years since independence. Get facts rights.
can you prove it?
@@momrazuddin381ya by including cholas ahoms and many other Indian dynasty to closur . Mughal history is overrated and too detailed.
I am glad some good decision taken by Modi
@@momrazuddin381Students in india already have to study 4 books for their Social Science exams (History part 1, History part 2, Civics/Political Science, Economics). It's just too inhumane to make them study so much for one exam. I personally didn't like it during my school days. I found it very difficult to balance with other subjects like Science (Again, divided into Biology, chemistry, and physics), Mathematics, Computer Science, Physical Education, Language 1 (English), Language 2 (Mostly Hindi), Language 3 (Sanskrit/Regional language like Kannada, etc.)
Students are made to study so much and an awful lot of it turns out to be useless. They just use route learning and pass the exam, and then forget everything. Therefore, the syllabus must be reduced.
Reducing science and maths is actually bad, because the topics in those books are important and already very concise.
Reducing language content is also bad because it might render students with less knowledge about either English (which is the very reason for the IT boom in India), or their mother tongue (which will cause a big trouble with all the state governments. People would bycott central government schools and join state government schools which teach primarily in regional language).
Reducing physical education/computer science is not possible because they already have so little time. Students hardly get time to play. There's about one PE class a week!
That only leaves us with Social Science. Of the 3 sub divisions; History, Political Science, Economics... History has 2 books! So it makes sense to remove some content from history. Now, what can we remove from history, the one paragraph about the Chola Empire, or one of the many chapters about the Mughals?
I generally do not like the moves by our government, but this is indeed a thoughtful one. It deserves appreciations. The media will definitely portray it as anti Muslim, but it is not. Muslims in India are not Mughals! There is a whole chapter about the Delhi Sultanate (who were Muslim conquerors) which isn't removed. Going by the logic of this video, that Delhi Sultanate chapter should have been removed. But it wasn't, thus proving this video wrong.
If UK can get away by not teaching students about their Colonial atrocities, why can't India reduce the number of chapters dedicated to Mughals in school textbooks? The Mughal dynasty had a series of chapters completely dedicated to them, their architecture, etc. On the other hand other great empires like Cholas had just one paragraph! That's unacceptable. Clearly, that book was biased towards the Mughals. This could have been done due to various political reasons, but it needs to stop now as it is no longer needed.
well respected historian of ancient India who doesn't even know Sanskrit🤣🤣. Just how much congress' agenda-friendly history books were, no one wants to talk.
😂😂😂yes ur the smartest guy in the world, this TH-camr who did some research is the dumb one
why do we pretend like this video itself is unbiased 😅
yeah it sa terrible video
Students in india already have to study 4 books for their Social Science exams (History part 1, History part 2, Civics/Political Science, Economics). It's just too inhumane to make them study so much for one exam. I personally didn't like it during my school days. I found it very difficult to balance with other subjects like Science (Again, divided into Biology, chemistry, and physics), Mathematics, Computer Science, Physical Education, Language 1 (English), Language 2 (Mostly Hindi), Language 3 (Sanskrit/Regional language like Kannada, etc.)
Students are made to study so much and an awful lot of it turns out to be useless. They just use route learning and pass the exam, and then forget everything. Therefore, the syllabus must be reduced.
Reducing science and maths is actually bad, because the topics in those books are important and already very concise.
Reducing language content is also bad because it might render students with less knowledge about either English (which is the very reason for the IT boom in India), or their mother tongue (which will cause a big trouble with all the state governments. People would bycott central government schools and join state government schools which teach primarily in regional language).
Reducing physical education/computer science is not possible because they already have so little time. Students hardly get time to play. There's about one PE class a week!
That only leaves us with Social Science. Of the 3 sub divisions; History, Political Science, Economics... History has 2 books! So it makes sense to remove some content from history. Now, what can we remove from history, the one paragraph about the Chola Empire, or one of the many chapters about the Mughals?
I generally do not like the moves by our government, but this is indeed a thoughtful one. It deserves appreciations. The media will definitely portray it as anti Muslim, but it is not. Muslims in India are not Mughals! There is a whole chapter about the Delhi Sultanate (who were Muslim conquerors) which isn't removed. Going by the logic of this video, that Delhi Sultanate chapter should have been removed. But it wasn't, thus proving this video wrong.
If UK can get away by not teaching students about their Colonial atrocities, why can't India reduce the number of chapters dedicated to Mughals in school textbooks? The Mughal dynasty had a series of chapters completely dedicated to them, their architecture, etc. On the other hand other great empires like Cholas had just one paragraph! That's unacceptable. Clearly, that book was biased towards the Mughals. This could have been done due to various political reasons, but it needs to stop now as it is no longer needed.
Now India show thier true history with British colonialism & islamic invasion of India.
Also adding more Ancient Indian history portion, when Native Hindus kingdom's time.
And al jazeera said, India remove history 😂
You earn money by moghol structure
@@rezwanulabedin7674you can earn loda in your amma by hindu architecture
Another Al Jazeera Islamist propaganda 😂😂😂
🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡
Another racist Indian laugh😅😂
Reminder:
Blowing someones candle won't make yours bigger
When someone tries to pull you down... They're already below you 😂
We Buddhist we respect all religions even though they destroyed temples University scriptures we still respect
But Muslim concerns about burning a koran in Sweden is called respect to religion
Well said
So much respect in Buddhist Myanmar!
Buddhists have massacred thousands of Muslim and Christian women and children in Burma.
you dont make sense what did u just say lmao
How come @AJ+ never makes a video on Pakistan, the only country formed on religious lines, and continuous to this day to persecute religious minorities or forcibly converting them into Islam?? Rather this channel have shown to have selective amnesia when it comes to showcase just Israel, another nation built on religious edifice, but disregards the fact that this religious community has had a troubled history, a difficult past!
AJ is run by Pakistanis and Pakistani Americans …FYI
Shut up you fascist 😂
They are loyal to Ummah
Is cow pissing in the comments mandatory for you Indians?
Are you high , Al Jazeera has made documentaries about drugs , terrorism , secessionist movements about Pakistan .
Irony India is afraid my foot may be viceversa😂😂
Traditional history textbooks tend to be heavily biased, often disproportionately emphasizing Muslim empires. Have you come across many chapters that delve into the history of North Indian empires such as the Ahoms, as well as Southern empires like Vijayanagara and Kakatiyas?
Ok, so a couple of things that this video doesn't mention! Majority of the history text books in the past only spoke about Islamic Rulers and rarely spoke about the empires/kingdoms of India. And the government wants to balance that, because india goes further back that the Abrahamic religions. But another thing they are trying to do is raise the confidence of Indians to say tht they are more that what their rulesr defined them (i.e British and Mughals). But I do think they have to show the good and the bad!
In terms of street names, many of the places with Muslim names have had a (not Hindu) but Sanskrit names and they want to change it back to originality. The government is definitely exagurrating the history, it is not against muslims but to raise national pride based on the past to push the nation forward.
And it is annoying they are removing that Ghandi's assasination story. There are pluses and downsided to what is going on with history text books, but not everything is about muslims (AJ+). I hope you cover all aspects of what is going on.
Why do you think they are removing the Gandhi ?
Are Muslim Indians not Indian? If so, why would erasing names associated with Muslims in India increase "national pride"?
@@skoosharamacuz muslim rulers purposefully changed original names in their efforts to islamize India.
@@skoosharamawe over read about Islamic invasion. Thank God bjp did something about it.
Mughal Mughal Mughal , only detail history we learned , better to learn diverse and long history of India. Rather stick with one
"to push the nation forward"
Are you sure it's about pushing the nation forward and not about solidifying Modi's power?
HINDU NATIONALIST BOTS ON THEIR WAY TO THE COMMENTS 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
💀💀 fr
They’re everywhere 😂😂😂
Bahi main keh Modi Jaise bhi rehne Do...
Wrna Yogi aayega TB kya hoga..😂😂
Asli naam se aao puncharputra.😂
the make way for them don't cry
Now i will vote for BJP😂😂
Western colonizers afraid
Looks like India is now heading for its downfall 😂
@@yasineren3629come to Kerala here we enjoy Beef curry….Type most loved dishes of Kerala Hindus beef will be in Top 5….So please update stereotypes…all Hindus are not Cow worshipers…many love to eat them too…😂😂
@@yasineren3629Yeah eat to your heart's content. Magar aayega toh ...... 😂
Tu apni mua bhi xhuva le 😊😅 kisi ko 🔔 fark nahi padta
These titles are so offensive. India is not afraid of our history. As a matter of fact we need to embrace our rich history which contains vedic knowledge.
As usual, tropes by Al jazoora
Those who do not learn history are doomed to repeat it...
Students in india already have to study 4 books for their Social Science exams (History part 1, History part 2, Civics/Political Science, Economics). It's just too inhumane to make them study so much for one exam. I personally didn't like it during my school days. I found it very difficult to balance with other subjects like Science (Again, divided into Biology, chemistry, and physics), Mathematics, Computer Science, Physical Education, Language 1 (English), Language 2 (Mostly Hindi), Language 3 (Sanskrit/Regional language like Kannada, etc.)
Students are made to study so much and an awful lot of it turns out to be useless. They just use route learning and pass the exam, and then forget everything. Therefore, the syllabus must be reduced.
Reducing science and maths is actually bad, because the topics in those books are important and already very concise.
Reducing language content is also bad because it might render students with less knowledge about either English (which is the very reason for the IT boom in India), or their mother tongue (which will cause a big trouble with all the state governments. People would bycott central government schools and join state government schools which teach primarily in regional language).
Reducing physical education/computer science is not possible because they already have so little time. Students hardly get time to play. There's about one PE class a week!
That only leaves us with Social Science. Of the 3 sub divisions; History, Political Science, Economics... History has 2 books! So it makes sense to remove some content from history. Now, what can we remove from history, the one paragraph about the Chola Empire, or one of the many chapters about the Mughals?
I generally do not like the moves by our government, but this is indeed a thoughtful one. It deserves appreciations. The media will definitely portray it as anti Muslim, but it is not. Muslims in India are not Mughals! There is a whole chapter about the Delhi Sultanate (who were Muslim conquerors) which isn't removed. Going by the logic of this video, that Delhi Sultanate chapter should have been removed. But it wasn't, thus proving this video wrong.
If UK can get away by not teaching students about their Colonial atrocities, why can't India reduce the number of chapters dedicated to Mughals in school textbooks? The Mughal dynasty had a series of chapters completely dedicated to them, their architecture, etc. On the other hand other great empires like Cholas had just one paragraph! That's unacceptable. Clearly, that book was biased towards the Mughals. This could have been done due to various political reasons, but it needs to stop now as it is no longer needed.
Mughal did not leave they where kicked out
‘Gujarat riots, during which a hindu mob killed 1000 muslims.’
Wow!! What a journalism😂🐷🧕
And what about the history that's beneath that mahal?
there's nothing beneath it. pn oak is an idi*t and the people who take him seriously are worse
😂😂😂😂what's app history under that mahal. Where have you been. OMG😂😂😂
We are not afraid of history we recorrecting the history of medical era
medical?
@@morwickchesterham3875 yes in India 🇮🇳 we had era that was known for great medical advancement. Hence it was called the medical era. Only when the British came did they steal our knowledge.
@@pajeetkumar1645Don't worry, the British did not steal everything. The ancient Indian medicine of eating cow-shit was kept from the British.
@@pajeetkumar1645 I googled it and got no results, did the Britishers remove it from Google too? 🤔
@@RxnClash well of course you know Google is controlled by the west.
Bro India has 6000 years of written history. We are just bringing our history before Mughal and British. 👍👍
If you have any manuscripts or artifacts from 6000 year old India, please inform the Archeological Survey of India.
not India but "Bharat" region.
@@PakistaniMan.Still we doing better then u guys.
Allah not helping uhh
@@PakistaniMan. Bhikari first arrange food for yourselves😂
@@PakistaniMan. The nation may be made later but tge landmass was tge same have some brain 😂🕋💩💦💥
First one needs to understand what is the real Indian history n if it is taught in school textbooks. Only the you can decide which party wants the real history to be taught n which party doesn’t for vote bank politics. No one is innocent!
Who controls the past, controls the future.
Who controls the future, controls the past.
Now testify!!!
Got it wrong buddy, it's actually
Who controls the past controls the future.
who controls the present controls the past
Agree first congress controlled it, and now BJP is controlling it.
@@AnkitKumar-sn8hqwell said
according to your logic there is no truth anywhere. then remove entire social studies (anyways it is useless) . Just english, maths, science is enough.
We are not the people of creation. We are the people of evolution and Darwins theory should be added back ASAP
Its sad that Taj Mahal is all we have to display about our sculpture. Its a small building built on remains of a temple on one of the easiest rocks to carve. There are a lot of temples with far more intricate designs that remain over thousands of years with literally no maintenance. Never understood the hype about taj mahal. The woman died in her 13th childbirth and is t even butied there
Dude the Taj Mahal is the most well known building in India, what are these cow 🐮 temples you speak of ?
@@pajeetkumar1645You can do nothing but cry in your puncture shop and fck goats, mleccha pedo follower.
@@pajeetkumar1645 compare the Taj Mahal with Rajarajeshwar Temple in Tamil Nadu and the golden temple (a gurudwara) in Punjab and you will understand what he is saying.
Wow. Brainwashed enough?
Why USA😂 afraid its history go to Europe leave land to native American
No one seems to belabor the fact that India was a British creation and that there was no such thing as India before 1947.
Waiting for BJP funded IT Cell to raid the comments XD
Thise comment is now going to full nationalist person and suppressing thise propoganda
@@ramtripathi6569 LOL
@@friendofall1824 what's lol ?use burnol it safeguard your bum
Me too waiting for radicals
Yes we are BJP funded =
1.we are BJP funded because in BJP term we got free rashion.
2. Yes we are BJP funded because in BJP term farmers directly benifit from government monkey for farmers
3. Yes we are BJP funded because we got UPI system wher previous congress minister said thise technology are not possible in india . And he said baseless idea
4. Yes we're BJP funded because our muslim sisters had free from triple tlak
5. We are BJP funded because our fellow dalit got free home
Darwin evolution theory is still in class12th . It's removed from class 10 Science NCERT
Don't spread fake news , darwin theory is still there and we respect that, you can see the latest survey on how many percent of Religious people acceot Darwin theory
When you compress a spring too much, it rebounds with equal intensity if not higher..!!!
Thank you Modi for rewriting history. We cannot allow colonial mindset to diminish Hindu culture, achievements and glory.
What hindu culture your hindu culture is filth. Thanks to mughal and Muslims who gave some architecture, culture and history to india otherwise india didn't have anything to be proud of. 1 Taj mahal is greater than whole hindu history and culture.
"@@saqibkhan-te7ht The Taj Mahal is predicte to collapse under its own weight in the next 20 years. Nothing lasts forever. I think its symbolic to the state of Muslim Unmah today.
@@hindurashtra63 History is evident...Mushriks(Polytheists) always lost to Monotheists..And Once again Ummah will rise..Allahu-Akbar
@@timur6770 follower of ummah have not created anything of significance in last 500 years. Iran closed 50000 mosques. Saudis built a toilet where Mohammed was born. The end of Islam is near.
Hindus will save Hindustan for Hindus.
@@surudog4929 landhbhakht Lindus have Created "0".. Lindus have gifted the World " 0" 🤣🤣 Lindus Ka Atomic Bomb Was Created by ApJ Abdul Kalam..🤣🤣 Landh Bhakhats are Varaha 🐷 Like their God Vishnu..🙄
*People from Bharat* 🗿🇮🇳👍
Approved😌
We label them scammers.😅
@@user-zw4mz2gx5w and we label tham thief
@@user-zw4mz2gx5wim not a scammer. may i know where youre from, just so i know whom to avoid because your people clearly do'nt like us.
That being said, I am also sorry if you were scammed by someone.❤
God bless you❤
Give turkey back to the Greeks, give Kurds their land back and acknowledge the Armenian Genocide. 😂😂😂
The chapter is deleted because it is already repeated in earlier classes. Don’t spread disinformation!!!
Thanks for debunking fake news! 😄
We are hindu nation ans sanathan dharma is our 5000 yr or much older history and legacy...we gotto show that....Stating facts is not wrong...and detoning over glorification of mogul empires is a good thing..
india will never be hindu nation! it is for Muslims because Muslims have history there
😂😂😂😂
@@saswatakrsarkar9759cry hard
How can you infidels dare to explore your own history and culture without the permission of the superior Muslims, especially of the petty diadochis of the late Mughal emperors?🖕🤣
Why is ncert so focussed on teaching colonial history wether it be under the Mughals or the British? It's Indian history, shouldn't be about the history of the Indian people and not about the history of invaders? France was invaded and ruled for as many years by the British, the French don't focus their history and their identities on the Hundred Years war. It's called having a set of leaders who believe that their nation's history is a story worth telling.
Postcolonialism and forced Islamization of the culture through violence cannot be the key part of our identities anymore. We're not British and we're not Mughals. We're not Europeans and we're not Central Asians either. We're Indians. Those people were not from here. We have to teach the history of our people to our kids, let them teach their children theirs.
Based
India is proud to its Hinduism 🇮🇳🕉️🧡🤍💚🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
I recently went through new text books of ncert Darwin theory is still there but now instead of being a part of a different chapter it has a chapter of its own . Rest all is right .
History should be learnt as-is. History is never glorious or shameful. History is truth. Face it.
Students in india already have to study 4 books for their Social Science exams (History part 1, History part 2, Civics/Political Science, Economics). It's just too inhumane to make them study so much for one exam. I personally didn't like it during my school days. I found it very difficult to balance with other subjects like Science (Again, divided into Biology, chemistry, and physics), Mathematics, Computer Science, Physical Education, Language 1 (English), Language 2 (Mostly Hindi), Language 3 (Sanskrit/Regional language like Kannada, etc.)
Students are made to study so much and an awful lot of it turns out to be useless. They just use route learning and pass the exam, and then forget everything. Therefore, the syllabus must be reduced.
Reducing science and maths is actually bad, because the topics in those books are important and already very concise.
Reducing language content is also bad because it might render students with less knowledge about either English (which is the very reason for the IT boom in India), or their mother tongue (which will cause a big trouble with all the state governments. People would bycott central government schools and join state government schools which teach primarily in regional language).
Reducing physical education/computer science is not possible because they already have so little time. Students hardly get time to play. There's about one PE class a week!
That only leaves us with Social Science. Of the 3 sub divisions; History, Political Science, Economics... History has 2 books! So it makes sense to remove some content from history. Now, what can we remove from history, the one paragraph about the Chola Empire, or one of the many chapters about the Mughals?
I generally do not like the moves by our government, but this is indeed a thoughtful one. It deserves appreciations. The media will definitely portray it as anti Muslim, but it is not. Muslims in India are not Mughals! There is a whole chapter about the Delhi Sultanate (who were Muslim conquerors) which isn't removed. Going by the logic of this video, that Delhi Sultanate chapter should have been removed. But it wasn't, thus proving this video wrong.
If UK can get away by not teaching students about their Colonial atrocities, why can't India reduce the number of chapters dedicated to Mughals in school textbooks? The Mughal dynasty had a series of chapters completely dedicated to them, their architecture, etc. On the other hand other great empires like Cholas had just one paragraph! That's unacceptable. Clearly, that book was biased towards the Mughals. This could have been done due to various political reasons, but it needs to stop now as it is no longer needed.
Oh my god,how much one-sided and biased a video can be!!
This one beats them all!!!😂
so your pissed that its right??
india is craving its own beautiful history..not of foreign looters...as i said ..this is not ours
Erasing history is usual not a good sigh in a country. Come on there’s a lot of us here who love history we should be defending it we love it and we learn from it it’s enjoying and sad at the same time.
Ask the Germans to reinstall statues, and portraits of Hitler. Leave the Indians the hell alone.
erasing is not that common a practice, re-writing is common though. do you see US admits its genocide against the native Americans? the Japanese atrocities committed against its neighbors? the Brits, Dutch, Belgians' genocide and other inhumane acts against the Africans?
the west still does it today. the only difference is how they market it.
No one is erasing anything. You can still learn them in higher studies. They just reduce the weightage of medieval history ( mostly about muslim invaders and British occupation) from school curriculum and adding ancient and classical history which was not taught much before. Also medieval history is also very hectic so reducing its weightage is not wrong. There was a lot of unnecessary information before. If someone reads Indian school NCERT books they would know what I am saying.
That's okay. Aji Saka/Ajivaka history from Kali Serayu (the ancestor of Sundanese-Javanese), the fall of the Saka dynasty, and Sriwijaya-Cholamandala war were also removed from their history book.
That's why, Indonesian and Indian history are very different.
Our history book tell us that our ancestors (Saka-Yavana/Sunda-Java, Malaya-Kamboja-Champa/Malay moved to Yunan/Mekong-Irrawaddy river after the fall of Saka dynasty.
And tell us that Sriwijaya-Cholamandala is the reason why the relation between Southeast Asia and Nepal halted for several centuries. That's why we moved the center of agama Siwa-Buddha from India to Borobudur and Mount Semeru/Mahameru in Java.
Of course they want to remove this dark history from their book. That's the reason why the word 'Sanatan Dharma', not well known in Indonesia.
Indonesia is more familiar with the word tirta religion/agama tirta from the story of Purwacarita. Yes, with Aji Saka/Ajivaka as a unifying figure. Because he introduced:
1. Agama tirta (Kapitayan, Kejawen, Sunda Wiwitan religion)
2. The Saka calendar (still used by the Muslim Javanese and Balinese Hindus)
3. Aksara Aji Saka/aksara Hanacaraka/Javanese script
This is why there is no Saka Year commemoration in India as in Bali, Indonesia (Nyepi). To remember the role of Aji Saka/Ajivaka, Kali Serayu (birthplace of Aji Saka/Ajivaka) was made the name of one of the rivers in Central Java. This history is erased from India textbooks and that's okay since we have our own version.
Sorry but barbarian mughals are not my history
Of the 10000 ( or maybe more ) yr old history of India , Mughal period is just an episode but it occupied substantial length in our textbooks around 50 percent , so the ques before the govt was people should know about entire history and not a concocted and distorted history created by Marxist historians . This is the reason certain chapters have been removed .
10,000 year history? Are there any documentation or artifacts available about the lives of people who lived in those period? There are plenty of documentation and other artifacts available about the Mughal period because they are quite recent.
@@nabeelmohammedca absolutely, there is significant epigraphic evidences which have been found in harappa and mohenjodaroand other IVC archaelogical sites , i myself being a student of history has studied some sites in detail .
@@abhisheksharma1019 Are they 10,000 years old? The oldest civilization in the world is the Mesopotamian civilization carbon dated between 4000 BC - 3500 BC, the Indus Valley Civilization is carbon dated between 2500 BC - 1700 BC.
@@nabeelmohammedca Bhirrana, also Bhirdana and Birhana, (Hindi: भिरड़ाना; IAST: Bhirḍāna) is an archaeological site, located in a small village in the Fatehabad district of the north Indian state of Haryana. Bhirrana's earliest archaeological layers predates Indus Valley civilisation times, dating to the 8th-7th millennium BCE.
@@abhisheksharma1019 There were human settlements in India that are 9000 years old but these were not advanced human civilizations like those in Indus Valley. There are similar human settlements across the world which are much older but they were not advanced civilizations which had towns, buildings, markets, written language etc. There are in fact very few details available about the language used by the Indus Valley people. They are still trying to decipher their language.
You don't know the meaning of hindutva . What's you know about hindutva and hindutva is a core of our constitution fought in supreme court of india .
Hindutva is the concept of winning VOTES by targeting minorities wearing Chaddi and holding lathis!! They are spineless when Chinese occupied Indian territories lol... Send these chaddis to Indo China border to secure Arunachal Pradesh
Bro have you seen how many times this chapter has appeared.
Taj mahal is also built on a hindu temple.
Source?!
@@user-nl7gt4zx5p history
@@user-nl7gt4zx5p archeology
I only laugh whenever AL-JAZEERA lecture other country on religion and democracy ground😅
😂😂I can laugh harder watching Indian news, INDIA GREAT PAK AND CHINA BAD, INDIA NUMBER 1, INDIA SLAM PAK IN SUMMIT, PAK GUY WANTS TO JOIN INDIA SHOCKING😂😂😂 Indian news is so hypocritical
@@moharshad6882 india is indeed number one , when you compare to china and Pakistan, why there to laugh 😃
@@moharshad6882 also we have always slammed Pakistan and that is well written in history 😀
@@ItsAmitPrasad 😂😂India is number 1 r u serous? U know for indias population India is actually poor, for having the biggest population in the world yet it’s behind Germany in gdp, a country that’s way smaller and has a WAYYYY lesser population
@@ItsAmitPrasadalso 😂funny thing about Indian news, they for some reason aren’t interested about the bad things happening in India and are way more interested in that 1 Pakistani guy who wants to join India
They can lie to themselves, but the rest of us know the truth. All they're doing is showing their insecurities
Nd you're showing your lvde
why would we lie? Do you think we don't know your history? We are not insecure but frustrated with disgusting culture of youra
“The further a society drifts from the truth, the more it will hate those who speak it.”
😂indian history is not only about this . Indus civilization is much old . In ancient time indian scientists and mathematician contributed alot . They gave 0 to world and more numerical values. They gave formulas for astronomical calculation and medical procedures, surgeries were given by Indian sage . Even the equipment which doctors are using in surgeries were made by him before thousand years . All this information is present on sort of paper in Sanskrit which are still present in India
@@anonymous-zt9xw And many stories from the Arabian 1001nights are of Indian origin, when you read the prologue of the editions well.
Al Jazeera commenting about india democracy is like hitler commenting about Holo cast as bad
The histroy was erased by mugal and british. India is bringing back its ancient glory where these buildings were temples not a tomb or mosques.
Indian history has more important chapters than turcic-mongol over glorified narrative.
yes but the fact is that their rule had an massive influence over modern india
@@MUHAMMEDYASEEN-bp4gk yes I agree but the fact is that Islamic history in India is whitewashed and taught, I am not against Islamic history but the facts should be taught correctly.
@@Ayush_Vikram brother honestly i am not eve mad about the chapter bieng removed it carries no influence towards me i andi am happy i dont want to learn about the mughals because i hated that chapter but if you wanna teach facts lets see what kind of facts you want to learn and what do you mean islamic indian history is white washed in my opinion all history learned in school is white washed
the latest piece of propaganda from aljazeera, what else can we expect?
Reporting about the Hamas' hostages Israel? But, hey, they are dirty infidels, not a big deal for true Muslims.
"the theory of evolution were only some of those the Indian government has removed from students’ textbooks in 2023. " - This is a blatant lie. Is this what passes for journalism ??
Now we definitely vote for BJP
I had studied that chapter years back , and it was not that important
Its not that government is erasing it from whole country,its only removing from a kids books
Which is good
As for my time it was hard to write in exams
And even if any one is intrested they can still learn about it in online ir library
It was?
remind me of the japanese education, war world 2 only mentioned briefly in their history subject.
@@saladinseige5843Students in india already have to study 4 books for their Social Science exams (History part 1, History part 2, Civics/Political Science, Economics). It's just too inhumane to make them study so much for one exam. I personally didn't like it during my school days. I found it very difficult to balance with other subjects like Science (Again, divided into Biology, chemistry, and physics), Mathematics, Computer Science, Physical Education, Language 1 (English), Language 2 (Mostly Hindi), Language 3 (Sanskrit/Regional language like Kannada, etc.)
Students are made to study so much and an awful lot of it turns out to be useless. They just use route learning and pass the exam, and then forget everything. Therefore, the syllabus must be reduced.
Reducing science and maths is actually bad, because the topics in those books are important and already very concise.
Reducing language content is also bad because it might render students with less knowledge about either English (which is the very reason for the IT boom in India), or their mother tongue (which will cause a big trouble with all the state governments. People would bycott central government schools and join state government schools which teach primarily in regional language).
Reducing physical education/computer science is not possible because they already have so little time. Students hardly get time to play. There's about one PE class a week!
That only leaves us with Social Science. Of the 3 sub divisions; History, Political Science, Economics... History has 2 books! So it makes sense to remove some content from history. Now, what can we remove from history, the one paragraph about the Chola Empire, or one of the many chapters about the Mughals?
I generally do not like the moves by our government, but this is indeed a thoughtful one. It deserves appreciations. The media will definitely portray it as anti Muslim, but it is not. Muslims in India are not Mughals! There is a whole chapter about the Delhi Sultanate (who were Muslim conquerors) which isn't removed. Going by the logic of this video, that Delhi Sultanate chapter should have been removed. But it wasn't, thus proving this video wrong.
If UK can get away by not teaching students about their Colonial atrocities, why can't India reduce the number of chapters dedicated to Mughals in school textbooks? The Mughal dynasty had a series of chapters completely dedicated to them, their architecture, etc. On the other hand other great empires like Cholas had just one paragraph! That's unacceptable. Clearly, that book was biased towards the Mughals. This could have been done due to various political reasons, but it needs to stop now as it is no longer needed.
Taj Mahal should be demolished in order to build Shiva temple which had been there previously.
I really don't see any problem in Bharat/India being a Hindu Nation, being a Hindu nation doesn't mean eradicating other religions. Bharat/India is the land where Hinduism was found so what is the problem in that 🤔.America/Italy etc is a secular state but also a Christian country. Saudi Arabia is Muslim country, aren't they secular 🤔🤔
No problem for you, The Problem is for the West which uses Islamists for their Geo Politics. They want to see India become a weak and corrupt Islamic State like Pakistan, Syria and Egypt, So they can manipulate and use us as Cannon fodder for their Anti China and Anti Russia agenda.
The change of Urdu/Muslim names to Hindu-sounding (Sanskrit-derived?) ones reminds me of South Africa. In South Africa, several Afrikaans locations have been given new names in native “black” languages. Ditto in Canada, some street names and other locations have been given Indigenous names, especially if the original names are seen as having colonial overtones. It’s fine in places like those but when something similar is done against Muslim names in India, suddenly it’s bad?
You are comparing two very different things and calling them equivalent. This is false equivalence.
In Canada, the names of locations being English erases the fact that this land was originally indigenous. English names is a sign of colonialism. When an English name is changed to an Indigenous name, we are trying to be honest to our history that Canada was a colonial nation. Canada in the past did what India is doing now, erasing local culture, and putting different names instead. Canada is trying to fix its mistake, India is actually making this mistake.
It's not bad because it's against Muslim names, it's bad because it's erasing the local population's history and culture. How would you feel if the British returned to colonize India, and renamed all of your cities to English names? Would you be okay if New Delhi was renamed to St. John?
@@AppleCinnamonPie the Muslim dynasties that ruled India were all originally of foreign (mostly Central Asian) origin, it’s not as different as you think.
@@2345434a Everything is different if you go far enough back into history. The English were originally Germanic, the Korean were originally Chinese, etc. The local population in some areas of India has been Muslim for at least 800 years. That's long enough to justify their being an indigenous population.
@@AppleCinnamonPie and white people have been in Canada for several hundred years, even longer in South Africa, so why change all the place names?
@@AppleCinnamonPieso the population of Canada has to wait another 300 years to become indigenous?
Muslims were not from India just like British today's muslim believe the same thing and if you go through history you get to know how horrible Muslim invaders were .So everything is justified what is being done today .
Muslim empires were comparatively some of the most diverse and tolerant places in history, full of many different ethnicities and religions. For example, Jews were treated much better in Muslim nations than in Christian Europe. Also, Hindus fleeing persecution of the Portuguese Goa inquisition sought refuge in neighboring Muslim lands.
I'm sorry but, seeing this video as a Dutch History and Science enthusiast is very surprising. The video seems to be very biased with hidden implications at almost every sentence. I liked AJ but I'm seriously starting to doubt the truthfulness since in the first 40 seconds the amount of fallacies and assumptions is, quite frankly, astonishing. You start with a nice introduction to appeal to the viewers emotion, a Misleading Vividness, than you oversimplify the situation, not mentioning the reasons given for the removal of the chapter and than imply a conclusion with ad hominem fallacy, by assuming it's all because of Hindu nationalism.
Journalists should never assume, only state facts. But this factual information with a bunch of loaded words which lead to biased implied conclusion.
🤣😂India removed Darwinian Evolution , LOL, when , source WATSAPP UNIVERSITY or Trust be bro.............
ya sure, last time i checked about people who were ones pushing for two nation system culminating into partition of india were both Islamist and hindu right, both from overwhelmingly upper castes landlords. Didn't the true ideals of secularism and tolerance lost meaning after successful implementation of two nation theory.
Who would have guessed that islamic radicalism and separatist sentiments among muslims in northwestern provinces and kashmir will invite hindu radicalism.
Students in india already have to study 4 books for their Social Science exams (History part 1, History part 2, Civics/Political Science, Economics). Its just too inhumane to make them study so much for one exam. I personally didn't like it during my school days. I found it very difficult to balance with other subjects like Science (Again, divided into Biology, chemistry, and physics), Mathematics, Computer Science, Physical Education, Language 1 (English), Language 2 (Mostly Hindi), Language 3 (Sanskrit/Regional language like Kannada, etc.)
Students are made to study so much and a awful lot of it turns out to be useless. They just use route learning and pass the exam, and then forget everything. Therefore, the syllabus must be reduced.
Reducing science and maths is actually bad, because the topics in those books are important and already very concise.
Reducing language content is also bad because it might render students with less knowledge about either English (which is the very reason for the IT boom in India), or their mother tongue (which will cause a big trouble with all the state governments. People would bycott central government schools and join state government schools which teach primarily in regional language).
Reducing physical education/computer science is not possible because they already hqve so less time. Students hardly get time to play. Theres about one PE class a week!
That only leaves us with Social Science. Of the 3 sub divisions; History, Political Science, Economic... History has 2 books! So it makes sene to remove some content from history. Now, what can we remove from history, the one paragraph about Chola Empire, or one of the many chapters about the Mughals?
I generally do not like the moves by our government, but this is indeed a thoughtful one. It deserves appreciations. The media will definitely portray it as anti Muslim, but it is not. Muslims in India are not Mughals! There is a whole chapter about the Delhi Sultanate (who were Muslim conquerors) which isn't removed. Going by the logic of this video, that Delhi Sultanate chapter should have been removed. But it wasn't, thus proving this video wrong.
If UK can get away by not teaching students about their Colonial atrocities, why can't India reduce the number of chapters dedicated to Mughals in school textbooks? Mughal dynasty had a series of chapters completely dedicated to them, their architecture, etc. On the other hand other great empires like Cholas had just one paragraph! That's unacceptable. Clearly, that book was biased towards Mughals. This could have been done due to various political reasons, but it needs to stop now as it is no longer needed.
Damn 😂 bro, u wrote a full essay, my guy don’t try so hard in messaging under TH-cam videos just to prove a point or something, firstly no one ganna read all that secondly it doesn’t change anything, focus in school, focus in your life, leave this news thing, u change nothing to to
I read it. You are factually incorrect!!!@@moharshad6882
Claim the Mughals as yourself.
I never understood this rejection of the delhi sultanate and the mughals as their empire by the muslims. To my knowledge a majority of their rulers were very tolerent of hindus and promoted cultural integration.
Just for trivia I'm asking does AJ+ stand for Al Jazeera? Sounds like someone crying for muslims.😂
Don't forget Chinese army took akshai chin from India in 1962😂😂😂
@@mashkar2062 93k yaad dilaun kya
Oh whats that lindu? keep crying
@@hah5663 we are not cry this aj+ is crying 😅
@@ayushpatel1245 crying by exposing your sad corrupt country?
the problem is that india is not a homogenous population and its minorities are in the millions, so this type of oppression will only lead to disaster in the long run. instead india should try to promote multiculturalism like America and Britain or the Ottoman and Mughal empires.
What India is doing is good but thise video is only propoganda I'm 12th class students I learning history I know what is deleted and what's not
Joke of the year ?
@@ribamariyam321 homogenous 🤔what that mean ? Indian population is indian yes ofcourse some community comes from Saudi Arabia that's another matter . And we are proud to be indian . And what government did is right 👍
@@ramtripathi6569 bhai ye converted nhi smjhenge 😂😂 sirf inko India ki image khrab krni aati h . Bhagwan ne moka Diya n mujhe not exaggerating I'll put a full stop to this crap .
@@ramtripathi6569 nd till now government has done nothing to make us proud. Being a hindu girl I want to make chuslims realise what their ancestors has done to us . Bhgwan sahayta kre
Why native Americans afraid of their history
During Partition, M population got two new countries. What did Hindus get?
Why don’t you give independence to Muslim Kashmir, Christian nagaland, Manipur and north east india, secular south india and so on. After giving them independence, you can make a filth hindutva nation
During partition Pakistan Pakistan and Bangladesh were one country Bangladesh later became independent. India is way larger then both of them combined anyways,has more resources and population
This is why I laugh when people are worried about the transformational impacts of AI and other advanced technologies: the world has had the internet for 30 years, and we (humans) still fight the same ridiculous ethnic and religious battles as that of our ancestors. From India, to the Middle East, to Europe, and America - people, if think, will never truly change. New iPhone, same ideology.
Fair, but the rise of AI in the wrong hands makes things worse. AI, like the internet before it, is just a tool. A tool that humanity will take time to best utilize. But till it does, it provides unruly elements a tool to create a narrative of hate, create fake stories to support that narrative, and a way to spread it to the far corners of the world.
It will be a dark comedy to watch World War 3 start because a teenager in his bedroom made a deepfake.
LoL! Good point but the world has had technologies and their transformative impacts for centuries. just to name a few remember lights bulbs, telephones, Airplanes and all the quantum technologies ( the basis of our 21st century tech revolutions) and we still fought two world wars and so many wars for what not all over the world! Human and the culture, this biology, outlasts all our technology. You want to change it, probably would take lot many things and centuries not just technology mate :)
You bet the world will run out of chaos. But nope. Even between lovers who promised to love one another forever will most prolly have to face chaos. Even between blood related family member face chaos
Satan is real pitting us mankind against each other.
Development since 18th century since two world War were there. Do having iphone make any difference????
they should also teach british schools how last mughal emperor bahadur shah children were killed infort of entire delhi crowd in red fort by east india company
We are not afraid of history we learn from history ,accept our mistakes
I'm from India and this video from Islamist perspective With all lies coated to the core
Please make videos on Christians of Manipur and India 🙏
The issue is not about religion. It's more than that. It started with a caste related issue
Also Hindu of Bulchistan and Pakistan...😂
@@mrkeshav736
I agree, we need to see more state of affairs of minorities in every country - be it Muslims & Dalits in India, Christians & Hindus in Pakistan or middle east, various other indigenous populations across the world, women, transgenders, Romanis, etc.
Why are you bagging like a Pakistani?
Do not bag