Since polls are gone just tell me which ones better here! RIP POLLS 😭 (Also I'm an idiot and put the nose back on wrong while dusting/cleaning the 2018 set)
Ryan: "The 2007 model had some shortcomings as far as the strength of the build, as you've seen throughout the review" *Doesn't break anything on the set, not even the top wing* Also Ryan: Breaks the 2018 model whenever he picks it up
Missing context. He held the 2018 by its weak spot before he said it was its weak spot. The only pieces that broke off the 2018 model were the pieces he wasn’t supposed to hold by; the reason he held it by them a few times was the muscle memory from holding the 2007 model that way. He was able to flip the 2018 model 360 by the fin and it didn’t break. He didn’t “break” the older model because he was a lot more cautious with it, and if he lifted by the fin it was a centimeter at most. You can hold the 2018 model by the rear easily and comfortably too, the best way to hold the ship. If you swooshed the old model like he did with the new model the fin would be jeopardized and the weakly set pieces within the holding compartment would be flying around inside. The new model is objectively more sturdy. Don’t believe me? Try a drop test
Lego: "Should the imperial landing craft remake keep the huge missiles, bomb dropping feature, detachable hull, and wing mechanism? Also Lego: "Nah, just throw on some stud shooters and make a ramp that minifigures can't use, kids love that stuff"
The wing mechanism trade off isn’t a loss in value, for reasons stated in the video. Agreeably the ballistae in the older model are much cooler and more functional than the new stud shooters. That said its green accent “buttons” don’t flow with the set nearly as well as the perfectly blended black/red shooters on the cockpit in the newer version. And the black spheres intertwined with the white blocks around it is a huge hit/miss appearance wise, while again the stud shooters are seamless and easily removable if you so choose. Ballistae gets points for the ability for stormtroopers to use them as base defense weapons on the drop off. Also figures can use the ramp on the new model, I’m not sure what you mean by saying otherwise.
@@SageSea1 the new one looks ugly af dude. tons of cracks in the ships that shouldnt be there, worse proportions, worse minifigs, worse playability. It's trash compared to the old one.
Hey Ryan! I don’t mean to be “that guy” but, the long sloped white pieces on the nose of the 2018 landing craft are upside down. You put them to where they are sloped on the top, their supposed to be sloped on the bottom. Sorry again.
the old one had that feel the the AT-OT and Dropship lego set did, and i loved that those two sets were the only ones that had that feel of having 2 vehicles kind of act like they transformed (at least in star wars)
Not sure if you noticed but you put together the nose of the 2018 version wrong, if you look up an image you’ll realize that it is suppose to be flat. However you have put 4 pieces upside down resulting in the nose to slant downward after the windshield. But great video :)
MandR: the 2018 model is more stable making it win. Me: how many times did the 2018 model break (2), and how many times did the 2007 one break (0) Hmmmmmmmm each like is an F for the 2007 imperial landing craft.
Missing context. He held the 2018 by its weak spot before he said it was its weak spot. The only pieces that broke off the 2018 model were the pieces he wasn’t supposed to hold by; the reason he held it by them a few times was the muscle memory from holding the 2007 model that way. He was able to flip the 2018 model 360 by the fin and it didn’t break. He didn’t “break” the older model because he was a lot more cautious with it, and if he lifted by the fin it was a centimeter at most. You can hold the 2018 model by the rear easily and comfortably too, the best way to hold the ship. If you swooshed the old model like he did with the new model the fin would be jeopardized and the weakly set pieces within the holding compartment would be flying around inside. The new model is objectively more sturdy. Don’t believe me? Try a drop test
I don’t completely agree with the 2018 one being more accurate mainly because of the wings feature. In the movies and shows the wings go down seamlessly but on the 2018 one they go down in sections and not seamlessly like the 2007 one. Also I believe that the playability of the 2007 one far surpasses the 2018 one because of how many features it has, it has the beautifully integrated giant spring loaded shooter, a feature to drop bombs, and a feature to literally make it a DROP ship by letting you DROP the troop area. But hey this may just be my nostalgia talking, great vid keep up the good work!
They give us these big trooper carriers and then never give us battle packs along with them. But woo 10 Clone Battle packs in 10 Years, that's equality
I think for sets like this that are designed to carry a few troopers, they should have one trooper to fill each space, and for most they should also come with at least one figure to fight them
have yet to find a comparison vid where the old set has won literally more than 1 category. it makes sense that the newer ones are better, but not really a point in comparing to find which one's better
It's worth noting that this ship was only seen in Episode IV beginning with the Special Edition, where it was digitally added. It did not exist in the original EP IV.
Looking at the two versions of the Landing Craft, I feel like a hybridized version of both sets would be interesting. Imagine the 2018 version with the launchers, bombs and detachable troop bay from the 2007 version. The shuttle would still retain the look of the 2018 version with the deployable loading ramp and adjustable wings. The minifigures should be four stormtroopers, two regular and sandtroopers as well as an Imperial Pilot to pilot the shuttle.
I enjoy the 2007 one for its play features but obviously I like the 2018 one for design and stability. I’m going to have to go with the 2007 one because I think that little kids would really enjoy the bombing run that you can do.
Don't you just love it how everyone hates the stud shooters because they're bulky and aren't too accurate, but somehow love the Technic shooters which are the size of a tank and fire massive black projectiles?
Ask manR: hi! I recently bought the ucs millennium falcon and it’s so big! I also don’t find 4 pieces. Do I need to use different bags like: bag number 3 if parts from bags 1 are missing?
I have the 2007 still a good ship. Clearly better playbility with the fact it drops bombs has shooters has a interior that can store weapons and can be a command post and cargo shuttle just like that. 2018 has stud shooters and a ramp........... You gotta remember the shuttle model from episode 4 looks very different from the one in star wars rebels the 2018 one is based off too. Also 2007 one doesn't break that easily since it never broke while you were holding it lol.
Since polls are gone just tell me which ones better here! RIP POLLS 😭 (Also I'm an idiot and put the nose back on wrong while dusting/cleaning the 2018 set)
Rip
The old one in my opinion cause of all the space for the minifigures
New one, but old one is close. Rip polls
2007 I think
2007 more troopers
Ryan: "The 2007 model had some shortcomings as far as the strength of the build, as you've seen throughout the review"
*Doesn't break anything on the set, not even the top wing*
Also Ryan: Breaks the 2018 model whenever he picks it up
I was waiting for someone to point that out
Missing context. He held the 2018 by its weak spot before he said it was its weak spot. The only pieces that broke off the 2018 model were the pieces he wasn’t supposed to hold by; the reason he held it by them a few times was the muscle memory from holding the 2007 model that way. He was able to flip the 2018 model 360 by the fin and it didn’t break. He didn’t “break” the older model because he was a lot more cautious with it, and if he lifted by the fin it was a centimeter at most. You can hold the 2018 model by the rear easily and comfortably too, the best way to hold the ship. If you swooshed the old model like he did with the new model the fin would be jeopardized and the weakly set pieces within the holding compartment would be flying around inside. The new model is objectively more sturdy. Don’t believe me? Try a drop test
I enjoy the 2007 minifigures because then the set is a pseudo battle pack
*pseudo
My sentiments exactly!
@@magisterrleth3129 *pseudo
@@witciu1 You're right. I get the u and the e mixed up so often my spell check doesn't even correct me anymore.
Wit Korcz you corrected someone correcting someone
Fun fact, this vehicle made its first appearance in the _Shadows of the Empire_ video game and was added to episode IV in a later special edition.
Are episodes 5 & 6 a joke to you?
@@SecureInMyHeadThis is not the same as the Lambda shuttle
Lego: "Should the imperial landing craft remake keep the huge missiles, bomb dropping feature, detachable hull, and wing mechanism?
Also Lego: "Nah, just throw on some stud shooters and make a ramp that minifigures can't use, kids love that stuff"
The wing mechanism trade off isn’t a loss in value, for reasons stated in the video. Agreeably the ballistae in the older model are much cooler and more functional than the new stud shooters. That said its green accent “buttons” don’t flow with the set nearly as well as the perfectly blended black/red shooters on the cockpit in the newer version. And the black spheres intertwined with the white blocks around it is a huge hit/miss appearance wise, while again the stud shooters are seamless and easily removable if you so choose. Ballistae gets points for the ability for stormtroopers to use them as base defense weapons on the drop off. Also figures can use the ramp on the new model, I’m not sure what you mean by saying otherwise.
The newer one kinda looks like it's transporting soap. :D
lol :)
So true
XD
I guess they have to keep the storm troopers clean somehow
@@zachduperron8543 So they live inside the soap
Without any nostalgia goggles at all (I have neither set) 2007 takes the cake. The foldout wings, missiles, and bombs are just so sick
The 2018 one is better design but i find its lack of minifigures disturbing
Battle droid commander Kerem I mean, they include the same amount of Minifigures. I just wish it included more sandtroopers.
The 2018 one has way to small wings in the back
Yeah thats what i mean we needed 2 more sandtroopers instead of obi wan and r2
Commando Droid you’re right that’s what I meant
I find it’s lack of interior disturbing.
The 2 dislikes(curently) on this video are from those 2 sandtroopers who couldnt make it into the new set
NecromanYT ftw it’s 14 now, and you have 14 likes, so..
@Filip Nikitovic and now it’s 32 so...
@@Archieretrowrld now it’s 93 so.......
Now it’s not 2 it’s 102
@@StealthyGumDrop now it’s 114 soooo
I honestly think the 2007 one is much better between minifigs and playability. The 2018 set really only looks better
The look of the 2018+the play abilities of the 2007(include the wing mechanism) and the perfect landing craft
I like the features of 2007 and the form of the 2018
The 2018 one looks really bad honestly
i got the 2007 one, still built too but my lord has time not been nice to him😂 the hinges just arent hinges anymore lmao
For the 2018 one kids can pretend that the stormtroopers captured r2-d2 and Obi-Wan so all 4 seats are filled
Get out of here with that sound logic 😂😂
Lol
@@MandRproductions that man is a user of dark magic.
How can they catch obi wan he will slice them in half😂
@@katesandoval9451is that before or after his back breaks
I love the older model. With a little imagination it’s not just a landing craft, but a dropship to drop off a command center!!
One thing weird about the new one is that the top hatches don't close fully. Everything just looks really odd because of that
I feel like the 2007 one is better.
It is
Doesn't look as nice but in every other category it's the old one
Minifigures yes
I have the 2007 one and didnt feel the need to get the new one.
Yes
It feels just like yesterday when the old one came out
I like the older one because it has a lot of room for minifigures but the newer one has a better design
The Imperial Pilot in the 2018 Landing Craft is from the 2014 Star Destroyer Microfighter. The 2018 pilot had the newer Imperial cap.
Always had a soft spot for the 2007 release and always wanted it looking at the catalogs back then
Next you could compare all the Lego at-st
You had the wrong cap for the imperial shuttle pilot. It’s supposed to be the same from the Krennic’s shuttle microfighter.
Honestly the 2018 one looks so weird especially in the cockpit. I genuinely think the older one is better even by today’s standards.
You’d be objectively wrong then. You are killing yourself looking for reasons to hate new lego
@@SageSea1 the new one looks ugly af dude. tons of cracks in the ships that shouldnt be there, worse proportions, worse minifigs, worse playability. It's trash compared to the old one.
@@wizardsmix7961 the old one isn't much nicer to look at either, though the playability and minifigure amount I agree with.
Hey Ryan! I don’t mean to be “that guy” but, the long sloped white pieces on the nose of the 2018 landing craft are upside down. You put them to where they are sloped on the top, their supposed to be sloped on the bottom. Sorry again.
Captain Vaughn yeah he noted that in the comments
I love the comparison videos
First time I saw these landers, they were featured in Rogue Squadron, then I saw them in Episode IV. They also day viewed in several games.
I prefer the newer one but the old one is super nostalgic
Fr
Fr
rF
MandRproductions thanks I at first I was like what the heck then I noticed why I kept getting that comment lmao
the old one had that feel the the AT-OT and Dropship lego set did, and i loved that those two sets were the only ones that had that feel of having 2 vehicles kind of act like they transformed (at least in star wars)
I think the 2018 one would be great if it where $70 and had 4 Sandtroopers instead of Kenobi and r2 which really doesn’t go well with it
0:55 you built it rong on its nose
*wrong
Auto correct I hate it
On the new one
Oh no 🙃😂
auto correct doesnt correct it to the wrong spelling lol
Not sure if you noticed but you put together the nose of the 2018 version wrong, if you look up an image you’ll realize that it is suppose to be flat. However you have put 4 pieces upside down resulting in the nose to slant downward after the windshield. But great video :)
When you’re watching Just2good, and a Mandr productions video pops up
Awesome I was hoping this would happen soon 😃
Love the Videos Ryan! Keep on going!
MandR: the 2018 model is more stable making it win.
Me: how many times did the 2018 model break (2), and how many times did the 2007 one break (0) Hmmmmmmmm each like is an F for the 2007 imperial landing craft.
Missing context. He held the 2018 by its weak spot before he said it was its weak spot. The only pieces that broke off the 2018 model were the pieces he wasn’t supposed to hold by; the reason he held it by them a few times was the muscle memory from holding the 2007 model that way. He was able to flip the 2018 model 360 by the fin and it didn’t break. He didn’t “break” the older model because he was a lot more cautious with it, and if he lifted by the fin it was a centimeter at most. You can hold the 2018 model by the rear easily and comfortably too, the best way to hold the ship. If you swooshed the old model like he did with the new model the fin would be jeopardized and the weakly set pieces within the holding compartment would be flying around inside. The new model is objectively more sturdy. Don’t believe me? Try a drop test
I don’t completely agree with the 2018 one being more accurate mainly because of the wings feature. In the movies and shows the wings go down seamlessly but on the 2018 one they go down in sections and not seamlessly like the 2007 one. Also I believe that the playability of the 2007 one far surpasses the 2018 one because of how many features it has, it has the beautifully integrated giant spring loaded shooter, a feature to drop bombs, and a feature to literally make it a DROP ship by letting you DROP the troop area. But hey this may just be my nostalgia talking, great vid keep up the good work!
2:30 is it just me or does the stormtrooper on the far right look like he’s French?
Lol
Lol
Lol
He has a moustache after the printing rubbed off
I just got the 2018 one. It’s amazing
great video ryan
I keep gettin joe biden ads
"hELLo EvErYoNe..."
its better than getting trump ads
@o pensador pensativo thanks
Stop let’s not turn a Lego set review into this
@@yorgeesmorgee shut up
@David Dzurec shut up
I love how in the 2007 model you can turn the little knob and the wings will go down that is such a cool feature the 2018 model should have had
I prefer the old one because it has better interior space.
Love it when notifications finally work
2007's body (and some more wing detailing) and minifigs with 2018's cockpit would be the best combo for me personally.
9:16 I started shaking ;-;
bro I had completely forgotten about the new model
I didn’t even know about either before this video
2018 one: The pilot's hat is not the right one
They look clean. Did the 2018 version take a shower?
They give us these big trooper carriers and then never give us battle packs along with them. But woo 10 Clone Battle packs in 10 Years, that's equality
I wish that instead of totally changing the ship that they had just fixed up some of the problems of the 07 set
19 wiews 86 likes and 25 comments youtube is perfect
No it isn't perfect it's drunk
@@a.l.d.a.16 i didn't mean it like that i mean it as a joke
I remember building the old one and you had to be so precise with the technic piece placement it drive me insane
“These are not the droids your looking for.”
"These are not the droids we are looking for"
I think for sets like this that are designed to carry a few troopers, they should have one trooper to fill each space, and for most they should also come with at least one figure to fight them
I used to have the 2007 version. Really liked the building process but the design made it break so easily.
have yet to find a comparison vid where the old set has won literally more than 1 category. it makes sense that the newer ones are better, but not really a point in comparing to find which one's better
Try the clone turbo tank comparison
it’s hard to tell cause the newer one looks better but the old one has more stormtroopers
there is now a new beer from the smug brewery called traitorade because of Brady and Gronk becoming traitors
who cares
@@bennett4789 MandRproductions in a patriots fan
RYAN: (points at yellow piece) press these green pieces
ME: (visible confusion)
John Stevenson their lime green
It's a weird colour some people would see green others would say yellow
I’m color blind so i dunno what you’re talking about😂
Nice Video :)
Good job
You are the best i love you video’s
I remember buying this set and the helmet prints were way more detailed than they were supposed to be for some reason
2:24 is the stormtrooper 3rd one along is it a misprinted one?
Great reviews ... your attention to detail and depth of review is tremendous ... and being 100 years old ... really appreciate your perspective ...
I never knew I wanted this.
Been waitin for this vid
I love how all 4 of the mouths on your old stormtroopers look different.
14:24
the storm trooper pointing the gun at r2-d2's head
I thought he was not the droid they were looking for?
They are, and I'm tired of pretending they're not!
I think the sides of the older landing craft is made better than the new one.
Only the most imperial of landing crafts for the Lord Ryan
Those 2008 stormtrooper helmets look like 👁👄👁
It's worth noting that this ship was only seen in Episode IV beginning with the Special Edition, where it was digitally added. It did not exist in the original EP IV.
Could you do a general grievous wheel bike comparison
Looking at the two versions of the Landing Craft, I feel like a hybridized version of both sets would be interesting.
Imagine the 2018 version with the launchers, bombs and detachable troop bay from the 2007 version.
The shuttle would still retain the look of the 2018 version with the deployable loading ramp and adjustable wings.
The minifigures should be four stormtroopers, two regular and sandtroopers as well as an Imperial Pilot to pilot the shuttle.
My OCD is nagging me, the wings on the 2007 version are backwards. The angled parts should be on the back of the wings not the front.
I enjoy the 2007 one for its play features but obviously I like the 2018 one for design and stability. I’m going to have to go with the 2007 one because I think that little kids would really enjoy the bombing run that you can do.
When are we getting UCS Gungan Sub?
Love comparison videos. Thanks for making more. The only bad thing is nostalgia stuff.
Me im quarintine: mandr video drops. me: target acquired
Don't you just love it how everyone hates the stud shooters because they're bulky and aren't too accurate, but somehow love the Technic shooters which are the size of a tank and fire massive black projectiles?
I could be wrong, but I think its the wrong pilot fig for the 2018. You have the microfighter star destroyer fig, not the pilot
I like your channel and you really make great content.Thank
That Sandtrooper at the end was ready to pop R2.
Ask manR: hi! I recently bought the ucs millennium falcon and it’s so big! I also don’t find 4 pieces. Do I need to use different bags like: bag number 3 if parts from bags 1 are missing?
Turn on captions at 10:17 and you’ll see…
what are you 8 ??
@@judebenson8227 what's wrong with it? just something weird that I found in the captions
Hey Mandr the 2018 imperial landing craft does have a place you can grip it right under the thrusters there is a tiled edge you can use to grab it.
I got the 2018 Landing shuttle and when I opened it all the figs were misprinted
Rip
Awesome comparison.
Even though the new one is visually designed better, I still think the old version is better in terms of play features.
Swooshability?!?! Whaaaa?!?!
Cool
You’re killing me with how the 2007 you put the folding wings backwards
Honestly the old one seems a little better, the design can be fixed with some extra plating. Also it’s only ~$80 used and complete on eBay
Plz do a review of 8098 clone turbo tank
Good video
AskMandR:Have u done drop tests w both of them, if not, can you do that. AskMandR:can u bring back the drop tests
You have the wrong hat for the pilot in the 2018 set
7:41 R.I.P bob we will never forget you
I have the 2007 still a good ship. Clearly better playbility with the fact it drops bombs has shooters has a interior that can store weapons and can be a command post and cargo shuttle just like that. 2018 has stud shooters and a ramp...........
You gotta remember the shuttle model from episode 4 looks very different from the one in star wars rebels the 2018 one is based off too. Also 2007 one doesn't break that easily since it never broke while you were holding it lol.
I almost have a hearth attack 9:16
The pilot has a different cap than the one in the set
I know