Which Removal Should You Play in Commander? The Complete Guide
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 13 ต.ค. 2024
- We break down EVERYTHING you need to know about removal in Commander in one video! Do you know the seven qualities of removal spells?
Buy some amazing cards from Card Kingdom and use this link so they know we sent you!
www.cardkingdom...
Sign up for whatnot using our link and get $15 to spend on whatever you want! whatnot.com/in...
Buy awesome sleeves from Dragon Shield and SAVE 5% using code "nerds" at checkout: dragonshield.c...
Follow us on Moxfield!
www.moxfield.c...
Consider Supporting us via Patreon!
/ nitpickingnerds
Come join our Discord community!
/ discord
Want to send us something cool? We'll open it on stream! Send to:
Mia Largo
PO Box 29372
100 Hartford Ave,
Providence, RI 02909
Mia and Beezy give off Jessie and James vibes
OH… MY…. GODSSS…. You are correct!
Mia is serving with the make up! 💅
Murder may not be the most efficient removal spell but there's an awful lot of fun to be had in slapping it onto the table and saying "I murder [name of creature that needs to be removed]. Very easy way to snap your fingers and get rid of problem creatures like Krenko, Mob Boss.
I hear he can double your goblins!
umm okay Mia, AMAZING MAKEUP GIRL! love it.
One thing I love about reprieve is that it also gets around "This spell cannot be countered" effects like that on Koma or Last March of the Ents
Part 3 Jotaro? Part 4 Jotaro? Part 5 Jotaro!?
*DESIRE TO KNOW MORE INTENSIFIES*
Could you imagine the goldfish podcast hearing 15 removal 💀😅
Curious where you would put “repeatability” or if it would be its own category? Cards like “Attrition” that can be used for removal again and again as opposed to most which are single use.
Have not viewed but i know im on the high side. 5 board wipes, as assymetrical as possible, 10-12 spot removal flexible or modal preferred.
Most games i play go 10 turns, and ill never see all of these cards every game but i need to see SOME of them.
Special shoutout to Skyclave Apparition, the real MVP.
When talking about average mana value, are people referring to with lands or without lands. Why does Moxfield list both? I'm confused. I would think it's without lands ...?
Why would you include lands 💀😭
Ummm… yes? It won’t count cards that are ONLY lands when calculating average mana value, but it will include MDFC cards that are lands on the back.
I prefer to swing with a massive creature remove the player
*Cries in serra’s emissary*
Unga bunga
I will preface this with, I value being kind of a hipster with card choices at times. I'm a big fan of Carrionette in my Kels, Fight Fixer deck, I let everyone know what it does when I play it, I tell them when I sac it. And hilariously, people STILL forget and tap out, without fail. It will happen, and some very problematic creature has just been exiled. It's also not counterable by things like Stubborn Denial and An Offer you Can't Refuse.
Wooo! Chillsynth! Great music
Based Jotaro enjoyer
Given the long history of "Orcish Librarian," a low price point below $1 for over 20 years likely indicates significant attrition and market neglect.
Attrition: Many copies would have been lost or damaged over time, especially for a card that isn't widely played.
Low Demand: A sustained low price suggests that collectors and players haven't prioritized this card, leading to fewer copies being maintained in good condition.
Considering these factors, it's plausible to refine the estimate. Instead of thousands, the total number of existing foil copies might be closer to a few hundred or possibly less than 1,000.
18:33 so I'm wondering, in commander, like with Pick Your Poison, is it really a three for one when you spend a card and each opponent only loses one card each? Feels more like a one for one to me, since everyone loses exactly 1 card. And if this is the case, I normally want more than a three for one for my spells in commander...
You know people play Krosan Grip solely due to their critical removal spell getting countered “that one time,” right?
*
I played Legacy during the days of CounterTop (both on the side playing it and while playing GBw - now “Abzan” - Loam). During this time, I was adamant that if you were playing green and didn’t have K-Grip in your sideboard, you were wrong for two reasons: they couldn’t Top in responseAND because it was 3 mana, which is significantly less common that one or two mana value cards; they would have to already have a 3-drop on top of their library. And to this day, I stand by that assessment. But no one’s playing CounterTop in Commander. Not only that, the Top is the least important part of the combos it goes with in Commander. Just blow up the Citadel or the Mystic Forge or whatever.
I sit 7-9 but I try to make sure they can hit anything
Awesome vid!
All of the... You should play all of them. Jk. One of my favorite classics goes to vindicate
15 removal is a lot!
All fun and games until a blue player negates and counterspells my removals 😢
Mia goated fr Jotaro gang 💪
All of it.
Slay Mia!
Push
First
1st!
Counter spells are not removal no matter how much you mangle your definitions
I guess??? It’s interaction it just has a timing restriction
Someone plays sheoldred, you remove it off the stack with counterspell, sounds like removal to me
Dissipate, now tell me that’s not removal.
Also, force of will is card disadvantage. Definitely agree with you @NickAIsup