This is by FAR the best list you have ever, ever ,ever came up with(of course all the others were good too). If you ever get a chance, try Diagaliv by RD Cheers!
this list reminds me of the good old fragrance days when i used to watch yr videos and i was eager to try the unknown , still is to this day a soul fulfilling lists to me
Just purchased Leather Oud a few days ago, and definitely full bottle worthy, definitely can't wait to see how it wears during the winter & fall. I wore it the other day (I don't wear scents according to season), and it was great! 1 spray behind the neck & was set all day. Definitely love the Dior house.
With all them dislikes along with the likes...Robes has become the most successful reviewer. I can honestly say you have done what you are supposed to do.
Marc, Very nice lineup. I've been a subscriber to your channel for a good while now, and have enjoy your informative fragrance reviews,first impressions etc etc! You mentioned chergui being reformulated and I must say this subject is very confusing when it comes to this house. I heard chergui was reformulated in 2015, but from what I understand all serge lutens bottles that were pre 2010 releases were reformulated sometime around that year, indicated by the change from palace logo to the new SL logo. Your bottle of chergui in your lineup has the palace logo showing your bottle to be vintage. If I'm correct, then the change in 2015 would be a 2nd reformulation if chergui. Please share any insights on this, if you've any. Stay fragrant! Warm regards. A2 !
Because SL changed the logo does not mean all his older releases were reformulated. We throw the word around WAY too much in the fragrance community. I heard Chergui was reformulated and the juice does not look as dark as mine however I have never confirmed if Chergui has received multiple reformulations. So sorry I have no insider knowledge on Chergui. All I know is I love the scent and no talks of reformulation would stop me from buying another bottle. Reformulation= scare people away from trying great scents imo. Hope this clarifies or helps a little.
Marc, Thanks for responding. You're correct in pointing out that logo change is not necessarily a change with juice in bottle. But as we've seen with fragrances such as Dior,L'artisan,YSL and even creed, external changes with products can be an indicator that a change has with juice. Makes no sense for stores Who offer SL to charge a higher price for a 50ML bottle with the older logo, and offer it in 75ML with new SL logo, unless the juice in 50ML is possibly original. But hey I'm still learning as a collector. Thanks for responding. Best. A2 !
I think you should go do something worth in your life not put dislike before even see the video , or leave something useful and appreciate the time they put on these videos . if you dont like him just dont watch it , unsubscribe to his channel .
De rien.On sent vraiment l'expertise et la passion dans tes vidéos. Ce sont des parfums à forte personnalité qui ne plairont peut être pas à tout le monde mais c'est indéniable que ce sont des chefs-d'oeuvres au point de vue artistique. Thumbs up!
Just because its for Winter 2016 doesn't mean these scents are going to be obsolete or anything so I am not sure why people are complaining. These juices will be just as good for Winter 2017 because its not like they magically won't work for 2017.
The rest of the faithful subscribers should start hitting the thumbs up button instead of just watching his hard work and moving on..while the haters faithfully click on each and every one of his videos to hit the thumbs down button. Fragrance Com, we have to do better.
And just give him "fake" likes? Then you guys are no better than the haters. Just watch it if you want or avoid it if you don't. You don't need to "have his back" or "cheer for him". Why do you care? Stop being so "positive" about this whole thing.
Claudio Nunez No! But obviously, everyone who is enjoying his videos do not hit the like button. My comment was directed towards those viewers and Marks true followers. Lol Enjoy your day.
I don't think anyone would like my scents. I'm too crazy into some big bold scents. I love leather, tobacco, incense, plum, mint, oud, cedar, saffron, cloves and I could go on and on...
You should maybe start researching/testing those colognes earlier in the year of 2016... so when the winter of 2016 hits, this video would make more sense.
All these kids hitting the dislike, can't get more immature than wasting your own time to go out of your way and dislike somebody's videos that you don't even know on a free video platform.
This is by FAR the best list you have ever, ever ,ever came up with(of course all the others were good too). If you ever get a chance, try Diagaliv by RD
Cheers!
thank you and I'll give it a try because I have not yet
this list reminds me of the good old fragrance days when i used to watch yr videos and i was eager to try the unknown , still is to this day a soul fulfilling lists to me
Another amazing top 20 niche winter review excellent choices and quality delivered by the fragrance guru himself
Just purchased Leather Oud a few days ago, and definitely full bottle worthy, definitely can't wait to see how it wears during the winter & fall. I wore it the other day (I don't wear scents according to season), and it was great! 1 spray behind the neck & was set all day. Definitely love the Dior house.
Awesome list Marc! This gives me time to hunt for the ones I have never tried in preparation for next winter!! They all sound interesting!
Thank you for stopping by Oz
SDV is stunning and has a surprising amount of depth. Great list buddy!
With all them dislikes along with the likes...Robes has become the most successful reviewer. I can honestly say you have done what you are supposed to do.
I am the most hated and loved reviewer on the tube. I guess it makes an interesting comment section.
I was hoping Feve delicieuse would be in there somewhere? I know you have it.
imo it just disappointed me after all the build up about its sweet notes
the drydown is amazing though
Marc,
Very nice lineup. I've been a subscriber to your channel for a good while now, and have enjoy your informative fragrance reviews,first impressions etc etc!
You mentioned chergui being reformulated and I must say this subject is very confusing when it comes to this house. I heard chergui was reformulated in 2015, but from what I understand all serge lutens bottles that were pre 2010 releases were reformulated sometime around that year, indicated by the change from palace logo to the new SL logo.
Your bottle of chergui in your lineup has the palace logo showing your bottle to be vintage. If I'm correct, then the change in 2015 would be a 2nd reformulation if chergui. Please share any insights on this, if you've any. Stay fragrant!
Warm regards. A2 !
Because SL changed the logo does not mean all his older releases were reformulated. We throw the word around WAY too much in the fragrance community. I heard Chergui was reformulated and the juice does not look as dark as mine however I have never confirmed if Chergui has received multiple reformulations. So sorry I have no insider knowledge on Chergui. All I know is I love the scent and no talks of reformulation would stop me from buying another bottle. Reformulation= scare people away from trying great scents imo. Hope this clarifies or helps a little.
Marc,
Thanks for responding. You're correct in pointing out that logo change is not necessarily a change with juice in bottle. But as we've seen with fragrances such as Dior,L'artisan,YSL and even creed, external changes with products can be an indicator that a change has with juice. Makes no sense for stores Who offer SL to charge a higher price for a 50ML bottle with the older logo, and offer it in 75ML with new SL logo, unless the juice in 50ML is possibly original. But hey I'm still learning as a collector. Thanks for responding. Best. A2 !
Great fragrances!
Great hard work,you are the best in the game
Looking forward to the 2017 niche winter list ❄️
What's with all the dislikes? Sheesh.. who are those people?
crazy good list! can't believe SDV actually made it at no1 too!
Thank you.
thanks Marc for this great video , dont mind the haters they will just make you stronger ,peace
Ugh... I find all of you fanboys annoying. Yay! Let's cheer for him!
LAME.
fan boys and trolls are equal to me.
I think you should go do something worth in your life not put dislike before even see the video , or leave something useful and appreciate the time they put on these videos . if you dont like him just dont watch it , unsubscribe to his channel .
the big boy list.. Look at that smile.. Robes loves the niche winter bombs!
love winter because of it
Beautiful great video! How can you afford buying all these fragrances?
solid job that pays well. Kids go to school lol
Awesome mate.
Great picks!
merci
De rien.On sent vraiment l'expertise et la passion dans tes vidéos. Ce sont des parfums à forte personnalité qui ne plairont peut être pas à tout le monde mais c'est indéniable que ce sont des chefs-d'oeuvres au point de vue artistique. Thumbs up!
Just because its for Winter 2016 doesn't mean these scents are going to be obsolete or anything so I am not sure why people are complaining. These juices will be just as good for Winter 2017 because its not like they magically won't work for 2017.
Good video 👍
great comment
marc
What do you think of Lira casamorati
great scent, however if you are scared of unisex scents this will not be for you
nice list.
The rest of the faithful subscribers should start hitting the thumbs up button instead of just watching his hard work and moving on..while the haters faithfully click on each and every one of his videos to hit the thumbs down button. Fragrance Com, we have to do better.
And just give him "fake" likes? Then you guys are no better than the haters. Just watch it if you want or avoid it if you don't. You don't need to "have his back" or "cheer for him". Why do you care? Stop being so "positive" about this whole thing.
Claudio Nunez No! But obviously, everyone who is enjoying his videos do not hit the like button. My comment was directed towards those viewers and Marks true followers. Lol Enjoy your day.
Why not launching your own perfume? With the ingredients you like the most..?
I don't think anyone would like my scents. I'm too crazy into some big bold scents. I love leather, tobacco, incense, plum, mint, oud, cedar, saffron, cloves and I could go on and on...
You have to do these kind of lists before the season begins not after !
I've always been expecting a Tom Ford
TF makes great winter scents. Just too many to choose from in my collection
5 Stars ★★★★★
STILL need to try a few of those after all these years watching,
abrarem sounds interesting, really need to check it out.
you really do and thanks for the stars!
damn, marc. there's gotta be $6 g's sitting on that counter!
Strange, man love Cuir Beluga.... love leather oud !!!!
You should maybe start researching/testing those colognes earlier in the year of 2016... so when the winter of 2016 hits, this video would make more sense.
there's no research, it's my most worn for the season. If i do it before the season it would be accurate.
All these kids hitting the dislike, can't get more immature than wasting your own time to go out of your way and dislike somebody's videos that you don't even know on a free video platform.
people dont geht your Timing, lol.
they sure don't. I guess I should be like every other reviewer and make a list before the season
robes08 at First, it irritated me too, but it makes sense.
Mark,your good but you table too much
Epic man👍👌😁!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Winter is over.....
Spring-summer top 10 video would be more helpful at this moment
it's autumn and already entering winter in the other half of the globe :p
Musc ravageur is like catpiss but even worse...how can you like that hahaha...even if would be paid 1 million $ a day i would not wear it.
Dude....lol Leather Oud?? I mean you've sold me on the Memoir Man.....but Leather Oud?? Come on man that stuff is rotten ;D
rename the title, to 2017
I almost skipped this video just because of that. At least he could write 2016-2017
To long videos please keep it Moderate.