Im a huge pearl jam and obviously love the original...but this is so different it cant be compared they are both good in different ways...this version is so so good
wow. aaron's voice- sometimes soothing, sometimes so full of pain, and he usually chooses to cover songs with great fucking lyrics and feeling and he always does them justice. 2002- the end of the golden era of alternative rock
After this song came out and the media blew up BS between him and eddy? I saw Arron in concert and guess who his guest was to do this duet with 2 guitars??!! Eddie vedder!!! THAT was f-ing awesome....once in a lifetime performance and THEY BOTH killed it!
I'm not sure this occurred? I'm also not sure the media blew anything up? Great cover. Had this on my desktops in college. Burned to a DVD. These guys are on different planets as far as culture relevance. Both great, in some ways. Not sure about the hard Republican stance, at its ignorant points, or switching genres entirely, but there are people who believe in him
I remember when this CD came out. I was in Myrtle Beach, South Carolina 2001 Beach week. Family values tour 2001 Album. Too bad we can't get this on I-tunes
Hey-hey, oh Sheets of empty canvas, untouched sheets of clay Laid spread out before me, as her body once did, mmm All five horizons revolved around her soul, as the earth to the sun, yeah Now the air I tasted and breathed has taken a turn Mmh, and all I taught her was everything Mmh, how quick the sun can drop away And now my bitter hands cradle broken glass Of what was everything All the pictures had all been washed in black Tattooed everything I take a walk outside, I'm surrounded by some kids at play, ooh I can feel their laughter, oh, so why do I sear? Mmh, and twistin' thoughts that spin 'round my head I'm spinning, oh-oh-oh, I'm spinning How quick the sun can, drop away And now my bitter hands cradle broken glass Of what was everything All the pictures had all been washed in black Tattooed everything All the love gone bad, turned my world to black Tattooed all I see, all that I am All I'll be, yeah Uh-huh Uh-huh, no I know someday you'll have a beautiful life I know you'll be a star in somebody else's sky But why, why, why can't it be Oh, can't it be mine? Hm-hm, no yeah, yeah no We, we belong, we belong together, together We, we belong, we belong together, yeah
Well, it isn't as good as Eddie Veddar, but then it wasn't his heartbreak. I do love his music. I saw him in California, it was supposed to be the whole band "stained" but only he showed. We didn't miss the rest.
@lounzer No he can't, however, there is no other artist that could have pulled it off. Aaron Lewis and Staind are the end of the best era for rock music.
I think the pearl Jam jockies need to chill...you are obviously too arrogant to listen to or appreciate anyone but them sing their songs so why bother clicking on it. he did a great rendition and I prefer his voice to Eddies *my bad *
As a big fan of Pearl Jam since they first album. I appreciate what Aaron lewis do. But I think no one can sing this song better then Eddie. It's so flat and I can't feel any emotion. I know it's hard to cover a song from a band who has fanatic fans. But I'm back to the rules of youtube. Shut up and listen.
Everyone has their own opinion, and that's fine, and I try not to judge... But I can't even comprehend people saying that this is better than the original. I am fighting urges to throw petty insults at people who think Aaron's voice is better than Eddie's... but I won't. Enjoy your opinions!
![Chris Cornell - "Nothing Compares 2 U" (Prince Cover) [Live @ SiriusXM] | Lithium](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/IuUDRU9-HRk/mqdefault.jpg)
Please don’t ever take this video down, I’ve been coming back to it for over a decade.
I discovered this version about 5 years ago and I absolutely love this version over the original
I used to blast my voice out to this on many drives back and forth between Jersey and Virginia 2009-10ish. Can’t agree with a comment more
Yessssss.
My thoughts exactly bro! Over a damn decade! Still great 🤘
Thats cuz its better than the pearl jam original, by far
Alcohol always brings me here.
Couldn't have fucking said it better..lol.
@@aaronlane5800 Oddly enough tonight I'm here sober. And really soon since the last time...
Guilty as hell right now man. Cheers mate
Fack me confronting 😂
love Pearl jam. but Aaron Lewis did Black unbelievable. one of the Best cover I ever heard. & the end when he sings it sends chills down my spine
He just does it all better period :D
literally one of the greatest covers of any song ever
@@iDTecKt ñññññpñ lo ñ pollo ññpñ ññ por p PP pm P
I prefer his personally. But give credit to pearl jam as the creators
I agree. I love this so much
This is one of the best covers ever.
God, I love his voice. I don't care what he sings. He is just beautiful.
best voice in the fucking game. hands down
@@BradyIsAfagInHeat you ain't fucking lying I would pay for him to sing commercials
@@BradyIsAfagInHeatNice to see somebody that gets it sprinkled throughout life 😁
Both Eddie and Aaron are amazing on this song. No need to argue who's better, they're both epic.
lost count how many years and times i come back to this. Life is weird and wonderful.
“I take a walk outside, I’m surrounded by some kids at play”
Goosebumps every. Damn. Time
Im a huge pearl jam and obviously love the original...but this is so different it cant be compared they are both good in different ways...this version is so so good
we can all admit this is better than pearl jams version.
Try wrapping your brain around this concept: any artist that does a cover does it with total respect. Live music is always better
Still come back here all the time lol
Same here. Same. 🥹💕🎶
love this man's voice
best voice in music.
This is the best cover of ANY song EVER. Black is my favourite song of all time and he absolutely nailed it
wow. aaron's voice- sometimes soothing, sometimes so full of pain, and he usually chooses to cover songs with great fucking lyrics and feeling and he always does them justice. 2002- the end of the golden era of alternative rock
Aaron singing Black gives me all the feels. What a powerhouse voice & an incredible cover! ❤
After this song came out and the media blew up BS between him and eddy? I saw Arron in concert and guess who his guest was to do this duet with 2 guitars??!! Eddie vedder!!! THAT was f-ing awesome....once in a lifetime performance and THEY BOTH killed it!
I'm not sure this occurred? I'm also not sure the media blew anything up? Great cover. Had this on my desktops in college. Burned to a DVD. These guys are on different planets as far as culture relevance. Both great, in some ways. Not sure about the hard Republican stance, at its ignorant points, or switching genres entirely, but there are people who believe in him
@Logan Bunn I love the man's music. I couldn't care less how he votes at the ballot box. Simple as that.
Now that’s how you pay respect to the singer and band for making such a heartfelt relatable song, “when words fail, music speaks.”
Wish this was released on one of his albums. Love this cover
This is on Family Values '01. Along with a lot of other awesomeness!
@@jamiewright9270 thanks!
@@jamiewright9270 what's tgat
Whatever he sings I feel in my soul ♥️
Best song to deal with a broken heart
So true
Or looking back on lost lovers, family and friends. Dead or alive.
Shit yes
Best song ever written!!
I heard him on MTV Unplugged & went to Best Buy that night to buy his CD.
Thank u to the person who introduced me to this song I’m China. Been a favorite every since. U know who u are...
A touchstone performance for a certain generation. A fan appreciating the beauty for all of us. ❤
Probably the best individual performance of any song ever
That song made me shiver.
This is the only version of Black I like. Aaron Lewis gives me chills with his voice. So good!
Look up Black live from Beneroya hall. You’ll likely have a new favorite version
Great cover of a beautiful song
It’s rare a cover is better than the original. Impressive
LOL you mean like every single song by Bob Dylan?
Sorry, what I meant to say was EVERY SINGLE song by Bob Dylan.
Not big on covers, but Aaron really knocked this one out of the park.
Achei!!! Lembro bem dessa versão 😊 19/08/2024
Bueno this is a beautiful version, I love both versions. My favourite song by far.
Remember listening to this for the first time on a Family Values Tour cd mix
Haha saw a Family Values concert with Korn and The Deftones!
“Drop the Mic Awesome”
Still gives me chills and breaks me way tf down everytime I hear this version
Oh my fkin gawd this is so fkin good
2024 still the best cover ❤
All time great Cover my man!
Best song ever and best performance ever❤ Aaron is just amazing
I remember when this CD came out. I was in Myrtle Beach, South Carolina 2001 Beach week. Family values tour 2001 Album. Too bad we can't get this on I-tunes
Best version EVER! Beats Pearl Jam!
Epic song , gives me the chills
20 seconds in ghoosebumps all over🥰
I like eddies, but this is just as good or better!
Unreal ❤
Love this song and Aaron lewis! Love both versions also but yes I agree Aaron is more into the song, he's more soulful! :)
How can you say he's more into the song I think your comment is just dumb..
Fucking awesome cover!
First time I hear a cover that he’s done where the crowd shut tf up
My favorite cover ❤️❤️
This was on the off the wall tour! That whole album was awesome
Amazing, i feel that soul
Hey-hey, oh
Sheets of empty canvas, untouched sheets of clay
Laid spread out before me, as her body once did, mmm
All five horizons revolved around her soul, as the earth to the sun, yeah
Now the air I tasted and breathed has taken a turn
Mmh, and all I taught her was everything
Mmh, how quick the sun can drop away
And now my bitter hands cradle broken glass
Of what was everything
All the pictures had all been washed in black
Tattooed everything
I take a walk outside, I'm surrounded by some kids at play, ooh
I can feel their laughter, oh, so why do I sear?
Mmh, and twistin' thoughts that spin 'round my head
I'm spinning, oh-oh-oh, I'm spinning
How quick the sun can, drop away
And now my bitter hands cradle broken glass
Of what was everything
All the pictures had all been washed in black
Tattooed everything
All the love gone bad, turned my world to black
Tattooed all I see, all that I am
All I'll be, yeah
Uh-huh
Uh-huh, no
I know someday you'll have a beautiful life
I know you'll be a star in somebody else's sky
But why, why, why can't it be
Oh, can't it be mine?
Hm-hm, no yeah, yeah no
We, we belong, we belong together, together
We, we belong, we belong together, yeah
Holy shit dude
Well, it isn't as good as Eddie Veddar, but then it wasn't his heartbreak. I do love his music. I saw him in California, it was supposed to be the whole band "stained" but only he showed. We didn't miss the rest.
Love both versions
you r absolutely right man!! he did best than the original ;)
Arron lewis kills this song, much rather hear him than pearl jam...
MARK Napier not me eddie and pearl jam is the best.
I gotta say I like it better than original
Can you buy a high quality recording of this anywhere?
@TheCharismaticVoice needs to review this
Lovely cover !!!
aaron lewis deserves to cover this song. he's pretty much all that's left of the 90's.
All i taught her was… everything
amazing
I've been trying to find this song on Spotify.. but just can't ☹
So true!!!!!!
the view counts on this video are insulting.....
Great cover of a great song, simple as that.
Classic!
very nice
😍
sings vry wlllllllll
@lounzer No he can't, however, there is no other artist that could have pulled it off. Aaron Lewis and Staind are the end of the best era for rock music.
Does anyone realize he changed the lyrics at the beginning?
🤯🫠🥲 every. fking. time.
No sah!
Very Good job ...but Eddie 's (PJ) version is unbeatable...its (he) touch your soul, that he just do not ....but. very good job
Best shit ever...better than Eddie, no disrepect to Eddie
Cool 18: Jonah, Area 51, toys r us
I feel like this song was made for him 🥲
My leg weightz here they come
Black Live matters
letal
😊😊
Means Uncle Aaron
Whoa way better than Eddie could have ever sang that song , I mean blew Eddie out of the water
Doesn't even sniff at the quality of Eddie's voice.
No way this guy touches Eddie’s range. Also, Eddie’s tone is better imho.
It’s a cover 🤦♂️ but be fucking
nailed it
Of course Pearl Jam's version is better but Aaron Lewis does a great job covering such a difficult song.
!!!
Anyone know where can download audio of this
Better than Pearl Jam version.
I think the pearl Jam jockies need to chill...you are obviously too arrogant to listen to or appreciate anyone but them sing their songs so why bother clicking on it. he did a great rendition and I prefer his voice to Eddies *my bad *
+Crystal Ortiz eres un pendejo, por eso prefieres a esta mierda
Crystal Ortiz Aaron has such a strong voice! I thought this cover was bad ass!
watch the unplugged version. And yes Aaron's voice and style's like no other. Same can be said for Eddie's
it is good but it doesn't make me shiver like the original does :)
Its because there's no guitar solo and drums imagine if Aaron all that this would of been the greatest song ever made
As a big fan of Pearl Jam since they first album. I appreciate what Aaron lewis do. But I think no one can sing this song better then Eddie. It's so flat and I can't feel any emotion. I know it's hard to cover a song from a band who has fanatic fans. But I'm back to the rules of youtube. Shut up and listen.
You spelled Aaron’s name wrong
I don't care what anyone says this version is superior to Eddies IMO
Have you seen the unplugged version? This is a good cover, but the unplugged version is one of the best piece of music being played ever IMO.
Everyone has their own opinion, and that's fine, and I try not to judge... But I can't even comprehend people saying that this is better than the original. I am fighting urges to throw petty insults at people who think Aaron's voice is better than Eddie's... but I won't. Enjoy your opinions!
Why can Aaron never get the lyrics right when he covers other people’s songs? FFS
Aaron has a more soulful voice. sorry eddie fans.
Too bad he turned fascist
Lmao. NOT!