He might have a role sharing with Martinez who does tend to get injured as well. If he’s not having to run up and down the flanks he might have less injuries.
Its taken too long but most united fans agree with you on Rashford. Some are still blindly loyal to him, to the detriment of the team. I've said for years he's not the guy. Club backed him with superstar salary and status, but playing so many games with a passenger has held us back massively. Until he's finally replaced, our attack will remain limp.
Imagine if we use his salary and have players like salah instead,who gives 100% regardless of who he played under,that's a real superstar and I hate Liverpool
@@miloveshredding41 completely agree. He's treated like some untouchable star player, it shouldn’t be this difficult to get him to perform. English media make it worse. Big drama when he was on the bench recently because he'd scored in the previous game against fucking Barnsley.
Aftter seeing the nature of Gyokres goals for Sporting, I think Rashford could do well as a 9 in this system. He was awful for Utd as a 9 because he invariably got isolated and played with his back to goal - which is a weakness. Gyokeres is always goal facing, running towards goal. Marcus has the speed and the finishing. If Amorin gets Utd playing in a similar manner - Rashford could shine. I would start off trying with Hojilund & Rashford as 9's. Bruno, Amad, Zirkzee & Mount as Inside Forwards.
Stop it,marcus doesnt have the same physicality, bro build like a stick and doesnt like to contest 50/50 areal duels like gyokres does,pls just stop@@freeindeed13
@@freeindeed13 yea abd when Ten hag gad no striker in his 1st season Rashford clearly said he did not want to play as a 9 so the question is jow much can man united get grom selling him
@@enchantedowl5731 yep, and immediately retire, since he will not be able to play more than 2 games in a row without injuries. Phil Jones career path 100%
You are spot on regarding Rashford. The Rashford sentiment must come to an end. He has not lived up to his potential and it’s quite unfortunate. It’s high time we move on from Rashford.
Happy to see that I'm not the only one screaming for ButtRash to get got! Last year, we could have gotten a substantial fee from PSG or RM. Now, no one will want him...period. Go sell cars since you can't score goals.
Hi Sam, I'm a Man United fan and a new subscriber since I last saw a couple of your recent videos paying tribute to Ruben Amorim. I'm hugely impressed by your content, full of honesty and integrity with huge doses of humility. Nothing click-baity, or irrationally emotional... you're up there with some of the best, content wise.Keep up the good work. If I may add further, perhaps you need to change your background or where you record your content, it's about time to make the next step up. Many thanks & Good Luck...
Luke Shaw needs to go. The fact he made himself available for England after not playing for months and then came back to be injured again for this season start is INSANE. I don’t care how good he is or can be his time is up we need to move on.
Predictions based on next few windows - January - Antony out, In the summer - Shaw out, Maguire out, Erikson out, lindorf out Casemiro kept around to rotate with mainoo for a final year, his influence during the week will benefit the youth development. Kone to break through Casemiro leaves following year a legend 😁 rashford, dalot and Bruno all leaving too.
thats astute agree with it all word for word. be sad if bruno goes hes player with amorim and sporting dna . amorim doesnt allow long passes , diagonal balls, shots outside box. wants to outrun work, counter, and attack. thats brunos best style and natural style its how he played when first joining united. if he doesnt succeed it wont affect amorim long term and maybe be better for club and proper rebuild bottoming out no massive contract like sporting. bruno is key to winning and leading short term hes been band aid eth finishes season without bruno united could be in relegation its that toxic the chemistry . cant wait for change hope bruno succeeds he is natural to the style im benfica fan but watched sporting plenty. i think casemiro, licha make great captains only alternative to bruno imo who plays better when not captain and just cares about production .
Completely agree with all your picks, Rashford's body language tells me he's not bothered any more. Shaw is an expensive bed blocker and Casemiro just isn't young anymore
We will have to move around 9 players. Casemiro, Shaw, Linderluf, Anthony, Mount, Evans Erikson, Rashford, & Maguire. May be not all at once, but the sooner, the better.
Ragnick's "open heart surgery" still needed. Shaw could be back-up for left sided in a back three. A very expensive back up. Selling Rashy would free up and generate the funds for buying players from Sporting, particularly a certain Swedish CF if Hojlund does not kick on.
“Back-Up for left sided in a three”? The biggest problem for Shaw is that he needs to be available to be a backup which he is barely available… So it would be pointless
@@tygittens6424 That's why it would be expensive. Exactly as I said. The OP did not see how Shaw would fit into Amorim's system. I was merely pointing out an expensive alternative.
@@ABiggles fair enough bro but this is why INEOS needs to be shrewd in the market…or slowly integrating a youth player into the squad… I was keen on us getting Anselmino when we linked with him before he went to Chelsea as we could’ve signed and then either slowly integrate into the squad at a later stage or sent him on loan to get experience.
Just came across the channel, great stuff! Casemiro I think has a chance to stay as a rotational veteran/someone to bring stability in the locker room. He might not have the same fitness as he did in the past but neither did players like Luis Neto, Joao Pereira and Antunes. From the outside looking in, it feels like some players don't have the motivation to put in effort like others and someone like Casemiro who generally tries his best (even if it's not a good enough performance for united) is valued highly for Amorim. Yeah 100% agree with Luke Shaw. The thing about St. Juste is that there is a lot of depth, I don't think that the players you mentioned are above him in the order when he's fully fit though. I think most people who watch the portuguese league will generally say that St. Juste is, arguably, one of the best CBs in the league. The problem is that he's rarely fully fit. Shaw could stay in a rotational LCB position like when Matheus Reis got adapted to that spot but I am not sure Shaw would want to do that. Rashford is a complicated one. Theoretically he could play any of the three forward roles but given his supposed talent, he's just not making enough to justify it. I guess a good comp for this scenario would be Trincão. The difference is that, even when Trincão was not at the level that we had seen in his breakout season at Braga for Sporting, he was still, at the very least, putting in a lot of effort to be involved in matches in other ways. Thankfully, Trincão now is prospering and with Rashford, we haven't really seen it yet. As a controversial take, I don't think any of the CBs are good enough to play in Amorim's system aside from maybe Leny Yoro? We'll see. I think there will be a lot of youngsters who play in the first 2-3 matches that people might not expect (excluding ones who have already debuted for the first team like Kobbie Mainoo, Garnacho etc.)
That depends on Casemiro. How he practices and his role in the squad outside the pitch. Amorim likes to keep players that know the club and its spirit that are experienced and can bench and come on whenever he has assignment for them.
I think that under Amorim all players will do better, even those 3, however, that doesn't mean that it'll be enough. I hope he can pull some good performances here and there from them so they can have at least somewhere decent to move on in the summer. Aside from Shaw because of being injured all the time, the other two can have key roles in the right team, with the right system in the right league. The Shaw thing reminded me of Pato, he struggled a lot but then got an incredible doctor that figured out that his problem was actually some minor muscles that atrophied, later with physical therapy targeting them he got a lot more fit, but his time had passed.
I think these three players make up a lot of fan favs, however I totally agree with you. How much money will be freed up taking these 3 off the payroll.
Its up to the coach to decide what his visions are and who fits into his system. Every successful person has that decision to make, so the decision solely lies with Ruben.
I 💯 agree with Shaw, Rashford, Mount and Casemiro. Marcus isn’t producing so i’ll cash in right now if i was man utd… Shaw too as well, Mount same as Shaw can’t stay fit
Hell, i can give you about 10 names that have no future under Ruben. Lindelof, Malacia, Evans, Maguire, Shaw, Casemiro, Eriksen, Rashford, Antony and Zirkzee.
@MrKajjaGG don't worry about Evans. He is still a United fan. His wife works for Man Utd media. He will be around. Would not be surprised if Evans went into coaching after retirement.
Amorims ability to move players on will be crucial to his success as manager ETH failed to clear out the dead wood and it cost him ,the new boss will need to stamp his authority on the team and needs to be backed by ineos or he'll go the same way as his predecessor.
I bet you must be sad Amorim is leaving and I understand that. But you seem at peace with his decision and you have no bitterness over it. And I happen to agree with you on your thoughts 💯. The players will need to be physically and mentally fit to play in what will be a 3-4-3 or 3-4-2-1 formation and the first two aren’t physically fit for that formation and Rashford is neither physically or mentally fit for that system. And I am not certain Bruno will suit this system either being honest. An excellent video. Good luck to Sporting
I think there needs to be a clear out of all the senior players left. There is a broken culture in this club and I can make no other conclusion other than it is down to the leaders in the dressing room. We have had a myriad of managers come and go and none of them could get this team motivated to play more than 1 match in 3. Bring in hungry, young and emerging players to fill the gaps. I would rather watch us play like Chelsea each week than play like we do now.
I agree with you; Rashford most fits in the Striker role (if at all). Garnacho, even though young, is not suited for the 10 role and also is not suited for the left wing-back role as he is inferior defensively. So, Garnacho might also not fit into the new manager's plans. On the opposite side, Amad and Antony might be perfectly suited for the 10 or right-wing-back roles as they run up and down and are better defensively. - Keep up the content! You got a new sub, looking forward to more videos from you.
It's interesting to hear your views on which United players may not have a future under Amorim. Just a quick note; Amorim is coming to United as Head Coach, not the Manager. So it will not be his job to move unwanted players on, there is a team of Sporting/Football/ Technical Directors that are responsible for player recruitment and selling players. Having made that general comment I don't disagree with the players that you have marked down as potentially not wanted. The problem that I see with Casemiro and Shaw (I would add Maguire to my list) is getting them out of the door and finding another team that would buy them. United have had major problems disposing of unwanted players and I can't see it being solved anytime soon. Casemiro is definitely too slow for the CM role and Shaw would have the same issue at LWB, but I could see Luke Shaw as a backup Left-sided CB for when Martinez needs a rest or is injured. I agree that Rashford is going to struggle to fit into an Amorim line-up, it would be best for all concerned if he moved on and refound some of his hunger elsewhere.
@@verbalkint98 Apology accepted👍👍 PS If you don't have the education to construct a sentence with a clear, precise meaning, I suggest you go back to kindergarten and, while there, learn some manners.
Before I watch this, from what I can tell about Ruben Amorim is players who jog back or don’t track back at all will leave the club. So Rashford and Antony for me I can see
You can say that about rashford but not Anthony. As bad as Anthony has been going forward he has never shirked his defensive duties. I can honestly see him as one of the wing backs due to his work rate but who knows we will see soon enough
Antony is a hard worker, unfortunately he's also got terrible decision making, power, technique, has a petulant temperament and always does embarrassing shit.
If we can get rid of Shaw (I don’t miss him anymore), McGuire and Casemiro soon, we can have the money to buy a younger and more dependable Left Wing back in the long term.
I have to say i agree with all 3. Rashford is pretty slack off the ball and cheats alot in the press. I think Amorim will not tolerate it. Love your content
Cheat alot is an understatement, he never press these days,it's okay to not press if you're producing goals everygame,but his stats is below average for over 2 seasons now and you still see fans making excuse for him while earning more than most prem players.
I prefer to cheer on the team that the manager puts forward. He sees the players every day and he knows each guy needs a different approach and how he fits in with his team mates. That is what fans should be doing they are not personally involved with the players either on their meantallity or their ability and how they work with the other players. Fans should do what they are good at that is singing on the players making funnies and getting right behind the team. Anything else they do not know enough to warrant team selection and who should go and who shouldn`t. you aint good enough for that. However the fans do course problems by keeping on the backs of players and managers let the committee do that if they cannot get ride of the committee.
You are way off about Rashford.... he's more suited to Amorim's system than Garnacho tbh. Rashford is a 9/10...he's made the mistake of trying to be a winger that he never was. he fits in like a glove into the positions behind the striker in Amorim's 3-4-3. none of the attacking players in United's squad can play in the wing position for Amorim's 3-4-3. Dalot and Mazrawi will be the wing players. Bruno, Mount, Garnacho and Marcus will be the options for the 2 behind the striker. in fact I think Mount and Bruno behind Rashford with Ugarte and Mainoo in midfield will be United's best team under Amorim. We shall see.
@RobertGithinji-e5u It's more efficient to make the most of what we have mate.... the Anti Rashford Fanbase really is a disgrace... too many tactical and managerial changes to expect consistency from any of our attackers. Rashford is our best. Would be foolish to sell.
@@rohitrevankar7674 if we sell trashford for 40 mill....it's pure profit.... he'll have given back to his boyhood club and maybe he can get structure and consistency elsewhere....the fact that Madrid can sell Ronaldo an actual goat but you think that an average winger at the wrong side of 20 is worth keeping is y this club fell off
First out of the door should be Maguire. He has never been good enough. Massive wages (£10M per year) And not picked by EtH or RvN. He's too slow, both mentally and physically, too old (31) and too immobile to play Amorim ball.
Rashford will score playing more centrally and I see him fitting to this role as the No 10 that’s support the striker, he scored 30 goals playing centrally for ETH and when Rasmus was sign, Marcus was completely mismanaged and his lack of goals leads to his poor form and poor performance showcasing frustration all game
@@uruwahjoshua8321 the season you're talking about he scored 17 goals from the left and 11 through the middle. 2 goals from the right. His poor form is because he's an inconsistent player. Always has been.
I agree that Casemiro and Shaw won't have a future, however I think they don't have one under any manager, not just Amorim. Pretty obvious picks. Rashford is spot on, he doesn't have the discipline, work rate or football intelligence to do that.
I agree with you But and it is a big But will the owners of this Club allow him to do this. I bet other Managers of this bunch tried to do it but it seems to me got nowhere. I do hope that your Club does not suffer on Amorin's departure and I hope you find some one to carry on in the same vain. I am a United supporter for more years that I can Remember but I feel that he has made a MISTAKE in taking up the position (I do hope I am wrong). To me he is Leaving a Club where Players give everything on the pitch and not stroll around. It will be interesting to see how he gets this Bunch playing, just like Ten Hag attempted to do. To me every Man United fan is looking forward to him coming in the same way there were looking forward to Ten Hag, Ollie Etc. but look what happened. As for me I will reserve my judgement when he proves he can handle not only the Premier League but the exsiting Players.
On the field, yeah Case might be surplus but his experience could help in the dressing room. The kind of bollocking he gave Garnacho is what these young pkayers whove achieved nothing of note need.
I hate Luke Shaw and Rashford playing in United. They are never united genes. Only English ppl likes 'em. Rashford is the biggest fraud in my P.O.V, seconding Antony. I want Antony, Rashford, Luke Shaw, Maguire, Lindelof, Mount, Casemiro and even Bruno to be sold. Maguire can still be useful in CB position but slow. Bruno also can be useful.
It's not controversial, Rashford needs to go but because he's lazy, he knows he ain't getting 350k anywhere else. So, he is holding down his contract and will leave on a free.
mount could play with Ugarte in midfield , united need pressing , determination and workrate in that middle and that could be the perfect partnership (just dont know how long mount can stay fit for ) and agree with Rashford , he needs to be sold in the summer , possibly loaned in January
I don't think Luke Shaw fits into that system and I think Casemiro will be too lazy today's football goes faster than when he started even though he has played in Portugal and Spain it hurts to say it like that a Brazilian who has moved to Norway in 1994 and I don't think so either Christian Eriksen Harry Mac wire And Viktor Lindløv And Anthony Rashford And Evans But I look forward to discussing this with you with kind regards from Peter Magnus and I wish you a really nice day have a good time long we need midfielders who can cover large spaces And I think we have that in the reserve team.
Rashford was our top scorer in Ten Hag's first season, but since signing Hojlund, Ten Hag COMPLETELY changed Rashford's role, forcing him to stay wide in a role not suited to him, mismanaging him ever since. Rashford will play as either the striker or as one of the 10s in Amorim's system, and I am certain he will score goals when played more centrally. Also, fans haven't talked about him as a young player for YEARS now 😂 you only ever hear that from people saying we shouldn't do it anymore 😅
But fans like you still making excuse for him,his best season, most of his goal came when he played on the left side,never a no 10,never a no 9,what changed? His attitude stinks,the amount of money he earned he should be producing world class numbers,he's not even producing "ok" number these days and yet you still find excuse,embarrassing
Real machos wear Benfica shirts Sam, you know that. But I agree with you about Luke Shaw, he should be the first to go and that brings a bonus to the club: less things leaked to the press from inside the dressing room.
Cr7 was toxic. We went from a team that finished 2nd before he came back. To not qualifying for Europe. Cr7 had a bad effect on the attitude of younger players who looked up to him. We should have let him go to shitty.
I think you could not be more wrong about Marcus Rashford, your arguments are so silly as well.. who cares how old he is and how much he is making?? Stick to football on it man... you mention Grealish for Southgate job and he's worse. Southgate is a fool, its why he got sacked.. You seem to base ur opinions on what other people do.. its so odd. So lets stick to football. the top scorer for Manchester United last season was Hojlund with 16, that's not just on Rashford, that's on ETH. HIs system requires rashford to play as a touchline winger and that's silly. I think Marcus in that inside forward role under Amorim could bring the best out of him again. It is a similar role to the one he played under Ole and ETH first season (he scored 30 goals, first United forward to do so since RVP). So I am just saying, it seems like you are just saying buzz words for Rashford and using irrelevant arguments when he is clearly on of our best players. Good video otherwise, just please educate yourself instead of saying silly arguments.
Inside forward for Rashford is perfect, his demeanor and work ethic and rate might scupper his progress. He works on that, he suits Amorim ball. Luke Shaw is Luke Shaw, hardly fit and available. Casemiro will do well, if he has adequate midfield cover and used sparingly. ten Hag ball was taxing on Casemiro, wide open spaces to cover, no set role and no help from around. He will be an asset in a structured squad.
@@captainchevrolet1694 I understand where your coming from, but if you’re rebuilding, money and age are huge factors for a team. Sticking to football though, Rashford hasn’t been great the last few seasons, Roy Keane, Gary Neville say the same. And I did say Amorim will give him a chance, I just don’t know if he’ll be able to impress if he doesn’t improve. That’s all I was saying
Rashford takes full seasons off regularly. You'll waste years wating for him to become a top player. United won't level up until we move on from this guy. How much more evidence do you need?
@ lmaoo wtf ru talking about?? Rashford is less than 10 goals away from 100 PL goals. Not many people can say that. He’s one of 6 United players to hit the 80 40 club (80 goals, 40 assists). And he’s had 2 less 20+ goal seasons since 18/19 than Messi. Takes multiple season off he says, jackass. Rashy only had seasons coincided with a major surgery and ETH playing him like a touchline winger. Please stop!
@@jakobpienaar5727 I also think Casemiro could fit an Amorim ball.. but yeah back to Rashy work ethic/rate, I think a more defined pressing structure will help. It worked under Ole and Jose until fatigue hit.. ETH was asking him to play hybrid pressing roles. That’s difficult by itself but then you don’t engage the fullbacks in the press and w winger is being asked to cover both the CB and the fullback while also being available for outlets. It gets draining Forsure.
Sell Rashford + Antony for Viktor_Gyokeres. Put Zirkzee on loan to Fenerbache. Swap Hoslund with Ohsimen who wants out of the middle of nowhere… Gyokeres Ohsimen Garnacho Bruno Mainoo Diallo Mazzy Martinez DeLigt Yoro
Luke Shaw is NOT controversial. I’d guess 80-90% of United fans have moved on from thinking of him as a player in this team.
He's NOT been fit and available for less than 50% of the games he could have played for UTD.
He might have a role sharing with Martinez who does tend to get injured as well. If he’s not having to run up and down the flanks he might have less injuries.
@@svnqt_ No he doesn't, he needs to go. He is everything wrong at Manutd, rewarding useless players needs to stop.
Other clubs would have gotten rid of Shaw like 3 years ago. He is never available, what is the point? Get rid of him please
First one we need to get rid of is the head of medical we got from arsenal
Its taken too long but most united fans agree with you on Rashford. Some are still blindly loyal to him, to the detriment of the team. I've said for years he's not the guy. Club backed him with superstar salary and status, but playing so many games with a passenger has held us back massively.
Until he's finally replaced, our attack will remain limp.
Imagine if we use his salary and have players like salah instead,who gives 100% regardless of who he played under,that's a real superstar and I hate Liverpool
@@miloveshredding41 completely agree. He's treated like some untouchable star player, it shouldn’t be this difficult to get him to perform. English media make it worse. Big drama when he was on the bench recently because he'd scored in the previous game against fucking Barnsley.
He’s not had a lb overlapping him for 2 years
M’bappe would look shit without a full back overlapping him 🤷♂️
@@wiretom Shame on you mate
@@wiretom 9 years in this team and aged 27 and you think he has an excuse of an overlapping leftback..... embarrassment
United fan here and totally agree with you! Especially on Rashford.
Aftter seeing the nature of Gyokres goals for Sporting, I think Rashford could do well as a 9 in this system. He was awful for Utd as a 9 because he invariably got isolated and played with his back to goal - which is a weakness. Gyokeres is always goal facing, running towards goal. Marcus has the speed and the finishing. If Amorin gets Utd playing in a similar manner - Rashford could shine. I would start off trying with Hojilund & Rashford as 9's. Bruno, Amad, Zirkzee & Mount as Inside Forwards.
Stop it,marcus doesnt have the same physicality, bro build like a stick and doesnt like to contest 50/50 areal duels like gyokres does,pls just stop@@freeindeed13
@@freeindeed131 problem Rashford doesn't want to play as a 9
@@obongo96 No he wants to play on the wing. The position no longer exists.
@@freeindeed13 yea abd when Ten hag gad no striker in his 1st season Rashford clearly said he did not want to play as a 9 so the question is jow much can man united get grom selling him
As a United fan I agree with all of these players. I don't think any of them will thrive in an Amorim system.
A fit shaw would be excellent at left centre back, but he is never fit so needs to go for that reason.
Who is buying him? Like for money and stuff... that he will want to go to. I doubt such club exists
He pretends to be injured. He's magically fit for finals and international tournaments.
He probably won't ever be sold, just gonna stay until his contract runs down and leave as a free agent
@@enchantedowl5731who is his guru? phil jones??
@@enchantedowl5731 yep, and immediately retire, since he will not be able to play more than 2 games in a row without injuries. Phil Jones career path 100%
You are spot on regarding Rashford. The Rashford sentiment must come to an end. He has not lived up to his potential and it’s quite unfortunate. It’s high time we move on from Rashford.
We should have sold him in the last transfer window. His time is up!
Happy to see that I'm not the only one screaming for ButtRash to get got! Last year, we could have gotten a substantial fee from PSG or RM. Now, no one will want him...period. Go sell cars since you can't score goals.
Hi Sam, I'm a Man United fan and a new subscriber since I last saw a couple of your recent videos paying tribute to Ruben Amorim. I'm hugely impressed by your content, full of honesty and integrity with huge doses of humility. Nothing click-baity, or irrationally emotional... you're up there with some of the best, content wise.Keep up the good work. If I may add further, perhaps you need to change your background or where you record your content, it's about time to make the next step up. Many thanks & Good Luck...
@@by.othman Thank you the nice words! Hopefully the background will change, but unfortunately it won’t be for a while 💚
Luke Shaw needs to go. The fact he made himself available for England after not playing for months and then came back to be injured again for this season start is INSANE. I don’t care how good he is or can be his time is up we need to move on.
Agree with all three. Where have you been until now mate, you are very good at this 👍 subscribed.
Rashford needs to go his time is up now.....
Predictions based on next few windows -
January - Antony out,
In the summer - Shaw out, Maguire out, Erikson out, lindorf out
Casemiro kept around to rotate with mainoo for a final year, his influence during the week will benefit the youth development. Kone to break through
Casemiro leaves following year a legend 😁 rashford, dalot and Bruno all leaving too.
thats astute agree with it all word for word. be sad if bruno goes hes player with amorim and sporting dna . amorim doesnt allow long passes , diagonal balls, shots outside box. wants to outrun work, counter, and attack. thats brunos best style and natural style its how he played when first joining united. if he doesnt succeed it wont affect amorim long term and maybe be better for club and proper rebuild bottoming out no massive contract like sporting.
bruno is key to winning and leading short term hes been band aid eth finishes season without bruno united could be in relegation its that toxic the chemistry . cant wait for change hope bruno succeeds he is natural to the style im benfica fan but watched sporting plenty. i think casemiro, licha make great captains only alternative to bruno imo who plays better when not captain and just cares about production .
I agree 100% with you regarding Radhford.
Completely agree with all your picks, Rashford's body language tells me he's not bothered any more. Shaw is an expensive bed blocker and Casemiro just isn't young anymore
We will have to move around 9 players. Casemiro, Shaw, Linderluf, Anthony, Mount, Evans Erikson, Rashford, & Maguire. May be not all at once, but the sooner, the better.
Ragnick's "open heart surgery" still needed. Shaw could be back-up for left sided in a back three. A very expensive back up. Selling Rashy would free up and generate the funds for buying players from Sporting, particularly a certain Swedish CF if Hojlund does not kick on.
“Back-Up for left sided in a three”?
The biggest problem for Shaw is that he needs to be available to be a backup which he is barely available…
So it would be pointless
@@tygittens6424 That's why it would be expensive. Exactly as I said.
The OP did not see how Shaw would fit into Amorim's system. I was merely pointing out an expensive alternative.
@@ABiggles fair enough bro but this is why INEOS needs to be shrewd in the market…or slowly integrating a youth player into the squad…
I was keen on us getting Anselmino when we linked with him before he went to Chelsea as we could’ve signed and then either slowly integrate into the squad at a later stage or sent him on loan to get experience.
Hojlund needs time. Do you have any idea how much time it's needed for the system to click
@@nananou1687 Yes.
Fair comments. Like your views. Factual!!👌🏻
if Casemiro plays like he did against Leicester i think he will fit Amorim like a glove.
Just came across the channel, great stuff!
Casemiro I think has a chance to stay as a rotational veteran/someone to bring stability in the locker room. He might not have the same fitness as he did in the past but neither did players like Luis Neto, Joao Pereira and Antunes. From the outside looking in, it feels like some players don't have the motivation to put in effort like others and someone like Casemiro who generally tries his best (even if it's not a good enough performance for united) is valued highly for Amorim.
Yeah 100% agree with Luke Shaw. The thing about St. Juste is that there is a lot of depth, I don't think that the players you mentioned are above him in the order when he's fully fit though. I think most people who watch the portuguese league will generally say that St. Juste is, arguably, one of the best CBs in the league. The problem is that he's rarely fully fit. Shaw could stay in a rotational LCB position like when Matheus Reis got adapted to that spot but I am not sure Shaw would want to do that.
Rashford is a complicated one. Theoretically he could play any of the three forward roles but given his supposed talent, he's just not making enough to justify it. I guess a good comp for this scenario would be Trincão. The difference is that, even when Trincão was not at the level that we had seen in his breakout season at Braga for Sporting, he was still, at the very least, putting in a lot of effort to be involved in matches in other ways. Thankfully, Trincão now is prospering and with Rashford, we haven't really seen it yet.
As a controversial take, I don't think any of the CBs are good enough to play in Amorim's system aside from maybe Leny Yoro? We'll see. I think there will be a lot of youngsters who play in the first 2-3 matches that people might not expect (excluding ones who have already debuted for the first team like Kobbie Mainoo, Garnacho etc.)
Problem with Luke Shaw is A) nobody will buy him B) he could be someone Amorim likes at LCB. But as a United fan I'd be happy to lose him
That depends on Casemiro. How he practices and his role in the squad outside the pitch. Amorim likes to keep players that know the club and its spirit that are experienced and can bench and come on whenever he has assignment for them.
thanks for sharing, your channel will grow well and we are watching it
I think that under Amorim all players will do better, even those 3, however, that doesn't mean that it'll be enough. I hope he can pull some good performances here and there from them so they can have at least somewhere decent to move on in the summer. Aside from Shaw because of being injured all the time, the other two can have key roles in the right team, with the right system in the right league. The Shaw thing reminded me of Pato, he struggled a lot but then got an incredible doctor that figured out that his problem was actually some minor muscles that atrophied, later with physical therapy targeting them he got a lot more fit, but his time had passed.
I think these three players make up a lot of fan favs, however I totally agree with you. How much money will be freed up taking these 3 off the payroll.
i’m a man utd fan and i’m subscribing
Its up to the coach to decide what his visions are and who fits into his system.
Every successful person has that decision to make, so the decision solely lies with Ruben.
Hi, united fan here, only three more likely half the team, more than half, most not up to amorin standards, he will sort it out in time, let's hope
I 💯 agree with Shaw, Rashford, Mount and Casemiro. Marcus isn’t producing so i’ll cash in right now if i was man utd… Shaw too as well, Mount same as Shaw can’t stay fit
Hell, i can give you about 10 names that have no future under Ruben. Lindelof, Malacia, Evans, Maguire, Shaw, Casemiro, Eriksen, Rashford, Antony and Zirkzee.
Crazy that Evans is the only one I'm disappointed to see on that list even though he's 84 years old.
@MrKajjaGG don't worry about Evans. He is still a United fan. His wife works for Man Utd media. He will be around. Would not be surprised if Evans went into coaching after retirement.
Actually Shaw, Malacia, Casemiro, Rashford and Zirkzee could
Zirkzee could play behind the striker alongside Bruno.
@@overman2306 Amad would be perfect in that role tho.
Agreeing on all, although i love rashy
Amorims ability to move players on will be crucial to his success as manager ETH failed to clear out the dead wood and it cost him ,the new boss will need to stamp his authority on the team and needs to be backed by ineos or he'll go the same way as his predecessor.
I bet you must be sad Amorim is leaving and I understand that.
But you seem at peace with his decision and you have no bitterness over it.
And I happen to agree with you on your thoughts 💯.
The players will need to be physically and mentally fit to play in what will be a 3-4-3 or 3-4-2-1 formation and the first two aren’t physically fit for that formation and Rashford is neither physically or mentally fit for that system.
And I am not certain Bruno will suit this system either being honest.
An excellent video.
Good luck to Sporting
Casemiro is very good for the bench actually, but if we can sell him for a price we will
Do you have a tactic download for fm24 please ? Or could you list the player instructions please
I think there needs to be a clear out of all the senior players left. There is a broken culture in this club and I can make no other conclusion other than it is down to the leaders in the dressing room. We have had a myriad of managers come and go and none of them could get this team motivated to play more than 1 match in 3. Bring in hungry, young and emerging players to fill the gaps. I would rather watch us play like Chelsea each week than play like we do now.
I agree with you; Rashford most fits in the Striker role (if at all). Garnacho, even though young, is not suited for the 10 role and also is not suited for the left wing-back role as he is inferior defensively. So, Garnacho might also not fit into the new manager's plans. On the opposite side, Amad and Antony might be perfectly suited for the 10 or right-wing-back roles as they run up and down and are better defensively. - Keep up the content! You got a new sub, looking forward to more videos from you.
It's interesting to hear your views on which United players may not have a future under Amorim.
Just a quick note; Amorim is coming to United as Head Coach, not the Manager. So it will not be his job to move unwanted players on, there is a team of Sporting/Football/ Technical Directors that are responsible for player recruitment and selling players. Having made that general comment I don't disagree with the players that you have marked down as potentially not wanted. The problem that I see with Casemiro and Shaw (I would add Maguire to my list) is getting them out of the door and finding another team that would buy them. United have had major problems disposing of unwanted players and I can't see it being solved anytime soon. Casemiro is definitely too slow for the CM role and Shaw would have the same issue at LWB, but I could see Luke Shaw as a backup Left-sided CB for when Martinez needs a rest or is injured.
I agree that Rashford is going to struggle to fit into an Amorim line-up, it would be best for all concerned if he moved on and refound some of his hunger elsewhere.
He is head coach, he choses the team, not the sporting director. If he isnt being picked he will be sold
@@verbalkint98 I didn't say, "that it was the sporting director who chooses the team"??????
@@banditbaker1675 i never said you did. Im sorry your intellect cant take the meaning from my reply
@@verbalkint98 Apology accepted👍👍
PS If you don't have the education to construct a sentence with a clear, precise meaning, I suggest you go back to kindergarten and, while there, learn some manners.
Before I watch this, from what I can tell about Ruben Amorim is players who jog back or don’t track back at all will leave the club. So Rashford and Antony for me I can see
You can say that about rashford but not Anthony. As bad as Anthony has been going forward he has never shirked his defensive duties. I can honestly see him as one of the wing backs due to his work rate but who knows we will see soon enough
@@GeneralThunderboltexactly! Anthony is a hard worker!
Antony is a hard worker, unfortunately he's also got terrible decision making, power, technique, has a petulant temperament and always does embarrassing shit.
Bruno Shaw Maguire
i agree with all your choices
Rashford ,mount, Anthony.
Mount would fit like a glove in an Amorim system.
Like a different positions
@@Dmaj089 ridiculous
@@Dmaj089yes I agree mount will shine and most united fan don't see it
mount could play with Ugarte in midfield , united need pressing , determination and workrate in that middle
If we can get rid of Shaw (I don’t miss him anymore), McGuire and Casemiro soon, we can have the money to buy a younger and more dependable Left Wing back in the long term.
WE HAVE MOVED ON ON LUKE SHAW
I have to say i agree with all 3. Rashford is pretty slack off the ball and cheats alot in the press. I think Amorim will not tolerate it. Love your content
Cheat alot is an understatement, he never press these days,it's okay to not press if you're producing goals everygame,but his stats is below average for over 2 seasons now and you still see fans making excuse for him while earning more than most prem players.
Good vid but is this the start of a comb over
Bro 😭😭. I’ve got a few years left still
I prefer to cheer on the team that the manager puts forward. He sees the players every day and he knows each guy needs a different approach and how he fits in with his team mates. That is what fans should be doing they are not personally involved with the players either on their meantallity or their ability and how they work with the other players. Fans should do what they are good at that is singing on the players making funnies and getting right behind the team. Anything else they do not know enough to warrant team selection and who should go and who shouldn`t. you aint good enough for that. However the fans do course problems by keeping on the backs of players and managers let the committee do that if they cannot get ride of the committee.
Rashford and Dalot need to be added on this list.
You are way off about Rashford.... he's more suited to Amorim's system than Garnacho tbh. Rashford is a 9/10...he's made the mistake of trying to be a winger that he never was. he fits in like a glove into the positions behind the striker in Amorim's 3-4-3. none of the attacking players in United's squad can play in the wing position for Amorim's 3-4-3. Dalot and Mazrawi will be the wing players. Bruno, Mount, Garnacho and Marcus will be the options for the 2 behind the striker. in fact I think Mount and Bruno behind Rashford with Ugarte and Mainoo in midfield will be United's best team under Amorim. We shall see.
Sell him and make money you lame fund annoy me
@RobertGithinji-e5u It's more efficient to make the most of what we have mate.... the Anti Rashford Fanbase really is a disgrace... too many tactical and managerial changes to expect consistency from any of our attackers. Rashford is our best. Would be foolish to sell.
@@rohitrevankar7674 you are so lame....you want us to keep a bum aged 28 for his potential
@@rohitrevankar7674 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣💔 where do you get the confidence to type this
@@rohitrevankar7674 if we sell trashford for 40 mill....it's pure profit.... he'll have given back to his boyhood club and maybe he can get structure and consistency elsewhere....the fact that Madrid can sell Ronaldo an actual goat but you think that an average winger at the wrong side of 20 is worth keeping is y this club fell off
First out of the door should be Maguire. He has never been good enough. Massive wages (£10M per year) And not picked by EtH or RvN. He's too slow, both mentally and physically, too old (31) and too immobile to play Amorim ball.
Rashford will score playing more centrally and I see him fitting to this role as the No 10 that’s support the striker, he scored 30 goals playing centrally for ETH and when Rasmus was sign, Marcus was completely mismanaged and his lack of goals leads to his poor form and poor performance showcasing frustration all game
@@uruwahjoshua8321 the season you're talking about he scored 17 goals from the left and 11 through the middle. 2 goals from the right. His poor form is because he's an inconsistent player. Always has been.
Sorry Sporting CP fans
Its the other way round.. Amorim doesn't have a future under these players
I've been saying for years we need to sell Rashford ,he ability will never match up with the status he has in the team
I agree that Casemiro and Shaw won't have a future, however I think they don't have one under any manager, not just Amorim. Pretty obvious picks. Rashford is spot on, he doesn't have the discipline, work rate or football intelligence to do that.
Mount, Maguire, Evans definitely. Anthony might go too
Wb antony
Luke shaw can play center back too, especially un a back 3
Your opinion, of course.
Rashford: no speed, no stamina.
I agree with you But and it is a big But will the owners of this Club allow him to do this. I bet other Managers of this bunch tried to do it but it seems to me got nowhere. I do hope that your Club does not suffer on Amorin's departure and I hope you find some one to carry on in the same vain. I am a United supporter for more years that I can Remember but I feel that he has made a MISTAKE in taking up the position (I do hope I am wrong). To me he is Leaving a Club where Players give everything on the pitch and not stroll around. It will be interesting to see how he gets this Bunch playing, just like Ten Hag attempted to do. To me every Man United fan is looking forward to him coming in the same way there were looking forward to Ten Hag, Ollie Etc. but look what happened. As for me I will reserve my judgement when he proves he can handle not only the Premier League but the exsiting Players.
Marcus definitely would not fit a sporting-style new United. Time to go
I would probably put Anthony ahead of Rashford. Do u think he have a place in the new system that Amorim is playing?
Rashford have thrown managers under the bus since LVG. the guy NEEDS to go. had 1 good season during that period.
Who brainwashed you into believing this?
💯
@@Yehxo Rashfords performances. 300k a week should be very special player, not the one who struggles under many managers and see them getting sacked.
@ which many managers did he struggle under, I wanna see something😂😂
@@henkkas2698 Don't waste your time! This guy is either a troll or he's a FANBOY!
If he keep rashford, Shaw and bruno he is setting him self up to fail
just curious, are you a Sporting fan from England? that's pretty unusual
@@nickraoyj hello pal, my dad is Portuguese so I’ve grown up supporting Sporting since I was born 💚
His surname is Fonseca, a Portuguese name
@@SamFonsecaaParabens
On the field, yeah Case might be surplus but his experience could help in the dressing room. The kind of bollocking he gave Garnacho is what these young pkayers whove achieved nothing of note need.
Luke Shaw is 29 (12.7.1995).
I swear to God any R-word over here defending Rashford 🤬 Totenham mentality
I hate Luke Shaw and Rashford playing in United. They are never united genes. Only English ppl likes 'em. Rashford is the biggest fraud in my P.O.V, seconding Antony. I want Antony, Rashford, Luke Shaw, Maguire, Lindelof, Mount, Casemiro and even Bruno to be sold. Maguire can still be useful in CB position but slow. Bruno also can be useful.
It's not controversial, Rashford needs to go but because he's lazy, he knows he ain't getting 350k anywhere else. So, he is holding down his contract and will leave on a free.
mount could play with Ugarte in midfield , united need pressing , determination and workrate in that middle and that could be the perfect partnership (just dont know how long mount can stay fit for ) and agree with Rashford , he needs to be sold in the summer , possibly loaned in January
I don't think Luke Shaw fits into that system and I think Casemiro will be too lazy today's football goes faster than when he started even though he has played in Portugal and Spain it hurts to say it like that a Brazilian who has moved to Norway in 1994 and I don't think so either Christian Eriksen Harry Mac wire And Viktor Lindløv And Anthony Rashford And Evans But I look forward to discussing this with you with kind regards from Peter Magnus and I wish you a really nice day have a good time long we need midfielders who can cover large spaces And I think we have that in the reserve team.
Do you think Amorim would try to play Rashford at a number 9?
Ericsson should be the first to go .
More takes from a Sporting die hard fan
You should tell us about Amorim's players at Sporting man
Only three huh???? it better be more if he's serious about keeping his job for more than 2 years!!!!
Rashford was our top scorer in Ten Hag's first season, but since signing Hojlund, Ten Hag COMPLETELY changed Rashford's role, forcing him to stay wide in a role not suited to him, mismanaging him ever since.
Rashford will play as either the striker or as one of the 10s in Amorim's system, and I am certain he will score goals when played more centrally.
Also, fans haven't talked about him as a young player for YEARS now 😂 you only ever hear that from people saying we shouldn't do it anymore 😅
But fans like you still making excuse for him,his best season, most of his goal came when he played on the left side,never a no 10,never a no 9,what changed? His attitude stinks,the amount of money he earned he should be producing world class numbers,he's not even producing "ok" number these days and yet you still find excuse,embarrassing
Rashford will be top on the selling list. He wont play mid attacker as he cant head a ball to save his life.
Luke shaws only blemish is injury record but that guy is a top top player.on this one you are wrong
Tf u want us to keep him mate
Bro,casemiro is finished, he can't even run!
Keep Shaw as Martinez back up sell Case and Rashford
I think Rashford is too disruptive.
Real machos wear Benfica shirts Sam, you know that. But I agree with you about Luke Shaw, he should be the first to go and that brings a bonus to the club: less things leaked to the press from inside the dressing room.
i wouls casimero will be ok in a midfield 4
Complete rebuild. All deadwood out.
No future, bro! Casemiro, luck shaw, mount, maguire, lindelof, evans, ericksen ( older),Anthony!!!!! Amorim will have troubles with onana,because!
Cr7 was toxic. We went from a team that finished 2nd before he came back. To not qualifying for Europe.
Cr7 had a bad effect on the attitude of younger players who looked up to him. We should have let him go to shitty.
Not 3 but a lots. 😅
Rashford has lousy attitude and corresponding skills in finishing of late.
Only three?
You lack understanding of football
Nah, all pretty logical points.
I think you could not be more wrong about Marcus Rashford, your arguments are so silly as well.. who cares how old he is and how much he is making?? Stick to football on it man... you mention Grealish for Southgate job and he's worse. Southgate is a fool, its why he got sacked.. You seem to base ur opinions on what other people do.. its so odd. So lets stick to football.
the top scorer for Manchester United last season was Hojlund with 16, that's not just on Rashford, that's on ETH. HIs system requires rashford to play as a touchline winger and that's silly. I think Marcus in that inside forward role under Amorim could bring the best out of him again. It is a similar role to the one he played under Ole and ETH first season (he scored 30 goals, first United forward to do so since RVP).
So I am just saying, it seems like you are just saying buzz words for Rashford and using irrelevant arguments when he is clearly on of our best players. Good video otherwise, just please educate yourself instead of saying silly arguments.
Inside forward for Rashford is perfect, his demeanor and work ethic and rate might scupper his progress. He works on that, he suits Amorim ball. Luke Shaw is Luke Shaw, hardly fit and available. Casemiro will do well, if he has adequate midfield cover and used sparingly. ten Hag ball was taxing on Casemiro, wide open spaces to cover, no set role and no help from around. He will be an asset in a structured squad.
@@captainchevrolet1694 I understand where your coming from, but if you’re rebuilding, money and age are huge factors for a team. Sticking to football though, Rashford hasn’t been great the last few seasons, Roy Keane, Gary Neville say the same. And I did say Amorim will give him a chance, I just don’t know if he’ll be able to impress if he doesn’t improve. That’s all I was saying
Rashford takes full seasons off regularly. You'll waste years wating for him to become a top player. United won't level up until we move on from this guy. How much more evidence do you need?
@ lmaoo wtf ru talking about?? Rashford is less than 10 goals away from 100 PL goals. Not many people can say that. He’s one of 6 United players to hit the 80 40 club (80 goals, 40 assists). And he’s had 2 less 20+ goal seasons since 18/19 than Messi. Takes multiple season off he says, jackass. Rashy only had seasons coincided with a major surgery and ETH playing him like a touchline winger. Please stop!
@@jakobpienaar5727 I also think Casemiro could fit an Amorim ball.. but yeah back to Rashy work ethic/rate, I think a more defined pressing structure will help. It worked under Ole and Jose until fatigue hit.. ETH was asking him to play hybrid pressing roles. That’s difficult by itself but then you don’t engage the fullbacks in the press and w winger is being asked to cover both the CB and the fullback while also being available for outlets. It gets draining Forsure.
Sell Rashford + Antony for Viktor_Gyokeres. Put Zirkzee on loan to Fenerbache. Swap Hoslund with Ohsimen who wants out of the middle of nowhere…
Gyokeres Ohsimen
Garnacho Bruno Mainoo Diallo
Mazzy Martinez DeLigt Yoro
@@peacefullyforever not realistic
@ elaborate
@@peacefullyforeverso unrealistic 😂😂expectations
Marcus definitely would not fit a sporting-style new United. Time to go