The meaning of words is understood by everyone Ghalib ka ishara jo lafzo mein bayan nahi kiya jaa sakta Jab hum kuchh nahi the to Khuda the Hamari ego ahankar hume us khuda se door karti hai Sar katna Bhav Jub ego mar jaati hai to sab me wo allah hi hai Nahi to jab tak main ghalib tha To yehi chinta thi ki ye hota to Kya hota Wo hota to kya hota Wake up guys Allah ram god waheguru is same As we say to water Pani. Jal. Aab. Neer. Water ❤
Thank u Sir for recommending 🙏. Ur command over Hindi English and Urdu language is amazing and what a mesmerizing way of decoding shayari of the Legend called Ghalib 👏👏
Your explanations are nuanced and multifaceted and truly wonderful to hear. Its also great how you combine English and Urdu. I am just getting to know these couplets so appreciate your work.
Brillant!!! Sir please please please upload more ghalib's ghazal. Will be eagerly waiting for another ghalib's masterpiece explained by you. You are amazing. Love the way you explain. I have watched almost all yt videos but your explanation stands out. Waiting for more ghazals!!❤❤
Thank you for this explanation. Kindly explain "ye na thi hamari qismat ki visal-e-yar hota" Specially the sher " hue mar ke ham jo rusvā hue kyuuñ na ġharq-e-dariyā ".
Sir you are doing an amazing job. I don't know if my words would have any influence but if you see this, i just want to say please continue this. It's a humble request from your admirer.
Khuda aur banda do mukhtlif makhlooq nhi janab...makhlooq sirf hum hain ya aur b hain khuda sirf Rab hai jo makhlooq ka paida kerne wala hai....baat soch samaj k kiya kerain.
جناب پہلے شعر کا ایک تیسرا مطلب بھی ہو سکتا ہے۔ غالب شکایت کرتے ہیں کہ انسان کی تخلیق بیکار ہے اور غیر منطقی ہے کیونکہ نہ انسان پیدا ہوتا نہ گناہ کرتا نہ جہنم میں جاتا جبکہ خدا کی اپنی حیثیت میں ان تمام چیزوں سے کوئ فرق نہیں پڑتا۔ اور جبکہ یہ پورا معاملہ غیر منطقی ہے تو خدا کا وجود بھی منطقی ہے اس کا کیا ثبوت ہے؟ تو اس شعر میں ایک اشارہ خدا کے وجود پر سوال کی طرف بھی ہو سکتا ہے۔ اور شاید یہ مطلب سب سے گہرا ہے۔
That is an interesting take and I can see how one can extrapolate this from the shayr, but this is not something that I saw in any of the scholarly interpretations that I have read. Also, while Ghalib has questioned the traditional & dogmatic ways of the religion frequently, he has always been considered to be a deeply committed believer in God. So, while he can cast a skeptical eye towards the ways of God, would he ever actually question the existence of God? I don't know. But the purpose of poetry is to provoke thoughts & ideas, that's what exactly this nayaab shayr seems to have done. Thank you for watching the video and sharing your views.
@@sukhanvari8360 thanks for the acknowledgment. Yes I know that no one has interpreted this as I have. But there is a very thin line separating advanced level mysticism and atheism. Because you question the creator in mysticism. And as Ghalib in another shair says یہ مسائل تصوف یہ تیرا بیان غالب تجھے ہم ولی سمجھتے جو نہ بادہ خوار ہوتا
The meaning of words is understood by everyone
Ghalib ka ishara jo lafzo mein bayan nahi kiya jaa sakta
Jab hum kuchh nahi the to Khuda the
Hamari ego ahankar hume us khuda se door karti hai
Sar katna Bhav
Jub ego mar jaati hai to sab me wo allah hi hai
Nahi to jab tak main ghalib tha
To yehi chinta thi ki ye hota to Kya hota
Wo hota to kya hota
Wake up guys
Allah ram god waheguru is same
As we say to water
Pani. Jal. Aab. Neer. Water ❤
Kitni dilkash hai Aapki sukhanwari...saari baatain...fizool hon jaisd
Jaise
निःशब्द हूँ..... क्या उत्कृष्ट व्याख्या की हैं आपने इन दार्शनिक गज़लों का।युहीं इन दार्शनिक ग़ज़लों से जान पहचान हमलोगों का कराते रहे....बहुत बहुत आभार🙏
आपकी उदार प्रशंसा के लिए आपका कृतज्ञ रहूंगा. धन्यवाद.
speechless 😶👏👏👏👏
Thank u Sir for recommending 🙏. Ur command over Hindi English and Urdu language is amazing and what a mesmerizing way of decoding shayari of the Legend called Ghalib 👏👏
Very kind words! Many thanks and I am glad you liked it.
Awsome
Way of description is marvellous
Plz keep it on
Thank you. I appreciate the encouragement.
It's wonderful
PL continue it
Thank you very much :)
What an explanation. Truely amazing.
This is brilliant!!! Thank you sir !!
Thank you.
❤️❤️❤️
Eagerly waiting for you next one.
Thank you! :)
Waiting for the next one
Same here
Ghalib was atheist
mashaAllah, behtreen
Lab o lehja aur aap ki awaz dil main utarte chale jaate hn.Marhaba,👍
Your explanations are nuanced and multifaceted and truly wonderful to hear. Its also great how you combine English and Urdu. I am just getting to know these couplets so appreciate your work.
Thank you very much!
This is awsome
Thank you very much. Hope you had a chance to check out my other videos on Baazeecha-e-atfal and HazaaroN khwaaisheiN.
Very correctly and well explained sir...
Brillant!!!
Sir please please please upload more ghalib's ghazal. Will be eagerly waiting for another ghalib's masterpiece explained by you. You are amazing. Love the way you explain. I have watched almost all yt videos but your explanation stands out.
Waiting for more ghazals!!❤❤
Thank you very much for the appreciation and the kind words. :)
Goodevening Sir
Waiting for full ghazals please
Thank you. I will post full ghazals soon.
Thank you so much sir. You help me a lot ❣️😊
I think Yaha khuda sy murad Yaha Aik state hai
Thank you for this explanation.
Kindly explain "ye na thi hamari qismat ki visal-e-yar hota"
Specially the sher " hue mar ke ham jo rusvā hue kyuuñ na ġharq-e-dariyā ".
Sir you are doing an amazing job. I don't know if my words would have any influence but if you see this, i just want to say please continue this. It's a humble request from your admirer.
Thank you for these very kind words. Needed to take a break but I definitely plan to continue to series.
Khuda aur banda do mukhtlif makhlooq nhi janab...makhlooq sirf hum hain ya aur b hain khuda sirf Rab hai jo makhlooq ka paida kerne wala hai....baat soch samaj k kiya kerain.
جناب پہلے شعر کا ایک تیسرا مطلب بھی ہو سکتا ہے۔ غالب شکایت کرتے ہیں کہ انسان کی تخلیق بیکار ہے اور غیر منطقی ہے کیونکہ نہ انسان پیدا ہوتا نہ گناہ کرتا نہ جہنم میں جاتا جبکہ خدا کی اپنی حیثیت میں ان تمام چیزوں سے کوئ فرق نہیں پڑتا۔ اور جبکہ یہ پورا معاملہ غیر منطقی ہے تو خدا کا وجود بھی منطقی ہے اس کا کیا ثبوت ہے؟ تو اس شعر میں ایک اشارہ خدا کے وجود پر سوال کی طرف بھی ہو سکتا ہے۔ اور شاید یہ مطلب سب سے گہرا ہے۔
That is an interesting take and I can see how one can extrapolate this from the shayr, but this is not something that I saw in any of the scholarly interpretations that I have read. Also, while Ghalib has questioned the traditional & dogmatic ways of the religion frequently, he has always been considered to be a deeply committed believer in God. So, while he can cast a skeptical eye towards the ways of God, would he ever actually question the existence of God? I don't know. But the purpose of poetry is to provoke thoughts & ideas, that's what exactly this nayaab shayr seems to have done. Thank you for watching the video and sharing your views.
@@sukhanvari8360 thanks for the acknowledgment. Yes I know that no one has interpreted this as I have. But there is a very thin line separating advanced level mysticism and atheism. Because you question the creator in mysticism. And as Ghalib in another shair says
یہ مسائل تصوف یہ تیرا بیان غالب
تجھے ہم ولی سمجھتے جو نہ بادہ خوار ہوتا
Beautiful ... Beautiful explanation... 👏👏👏👌
Singing is really bad