ce n'est pas près d'arriver, nous sommes en plein dedans. Même si la France doit être mise à feu, et même les Français sont réputés pour être râleurs, JAMAIS nous ne cèderont face à une loi anti-démocratique. C'est la base même de notre pays.
I’m not sure any politician on either side of the channel puts 18hours a week in! Never mind a day. Have to admire the french people for making themselves vocal to the political class
@@LexiD-zx6bf 😮that’s Rs.123200 woah I mean for Indians the amount is woahhhhh but I wonder how well one can live with that income in France? Does it cover all the basics like utilities,rent & groceries?
@@D.2601 not! Many PEOPLE are totaly broke the 15 each mounth in France! And Many Gand pa and ma have juste 5 or 600€ pension per mounth but they give Money all over their life!
@@mrprosser843 I know you're right. I guess I mean generally. It seems to be the minority in this country that get their voices heard and the majority, ie the working class who don't. The French have always been very nationalistic and why not.
@@mrprosser843 you say that as if it’s the fault of workers. Tax the rich more and the government will have plenty of money for welfare and an earlier retirement age.
@@dylanschmeichel2008 In the UK we already do, 43% of all British working Adults pay no income tax compared to the top 1% who pay 27%. Now im not soft on the rich in no way whatsoever, but we must recognize that "tax the rich" has its limits. What Britain needs is simple reform of expenditure not more income.
Well they could also contribute more to the pension scheme then. But paying 20% of your salary into pension is also not sustainable and doesn't solve the structural deficit.
You have to love the french people. Government does something they don't like? Protests. And not only protests. No. Protests for days. They go and take grandma out of the retirement home so she can protest too. And they stand up and sing their national anthem. Has some feeling like the scene in Casablanca
I wish it had an impact, but a million people on the street doesn't make the government listen... Even the polls state that 93% of working people (Hence paying for retirement) are against it and the government forces though... I'm proud that my people stands against all of this, but I'm ashamed of our representatives. In a democracy, you should at least listen to your people, negotiate and compromise, not treating it like an annoying fly...
@@Grytem I admire your people for that. Like honestly. Wish we Germans had the balls to do that. So keep protesting please and sing the song of your people
@@falconeshield 64 is the age My dad passed away. Asking years for an early pension, while recovering from two heart attacks, and his heart being monitored with a pacemaker ! Oh, and he was in construction. So 2 years can be the difference between spending your limited time on earth left with your family, or killing yourself in a difficult job !
We here in Ireland talk of the French as a model to look towards, I wish we Irish had the spirit of working class unity and the fire of revolution still in our belly like the French. Never lose what you have 🇮🇪🇫🇷
France/Ireland are brothers since centuries from the war with England to just the fact Irish people are the kindest people in this messed world and their country is magnifique...my grandma is 93 and she'd never travelled but her only destination has always been Ireland...congrat' for the rugby tournament
Can you believe there's no real opposition in the UK? No party wants to end the horror show that's Brexit, Starmer is happy to leave further and further right.
What the politicians do not understand, is to listen to the people and realize that collectively, the people are more powerful than the politicians, history has shown this to be true, over and over again.
@@valenwood6299 yup, plain armed uprising is impossible without complete support of the army in our modern times. It's just not a viable action anymore.
@@koopasteve that's Ukraine and it was in 2014, Ukraine is a population similar to Russia or India or any developing nation, the west is west. You think you and your tiktok friends will hold a revolution on the streets? What will be your slogan, let taxpayers pay for my degree which has no prospects for giving me a decent job?
@@omeven5785 It infuriates me how few people realize this. You have to either have military support or overthrow the government so quickly and efficiently that there's no room for a counterattack
Cogadh Un grand merci de la part d'une française c'est très dur ce que nous vivons en ce moment en France mais il faut tenir bon ,pour sauver la démocratie..❤
According to the latest WHO data published in 2020 life expectancy in Cameroon is: Male 60.3, female 64.5 and total life expectancy is 62.4 which gives Cameroon a World Life Expectancy ranking of 169. According to the latest WHO data published in 2020 life expectancy in France is: Male 79.8, female 85.1 and total life expectancy is 82.5 which gives France a World Life Expectancy ranking of 11. According to the latest WHO data published in 2020 life expectancy in Morocco is: Male 71.7, female 74.3 and total life expectancy is 73.0 which gives Morocco a World Life Expectancy ranking of 102. [World life expectancy] 1:03
This time, only 9 voices were missing to reject the parliament.. never happened before... but some politicians have said that they received high pressure from government, as threafs of suppressing local funds for their area... We are not a democracy anymore... And the pension system has no funding problem! It is a fight between two pension models. Here is the true goal...
The pension system definitely has a funding problem, have you even taken a look on our current population models? Our average age is getting higher, how do you suppose we make up for that? By printing money?
@@2mac_mini952 where did you read that there was a funding problem in France ? There is a group of expert to check this fund, and they clearly said that there was no problem. But European Union wants that every country limits its ratio of funding vs PIB (I don't know the english letters sorry...). So it is a choice to reduce the funding , the system is well balanced. But french system is not open to capital, and some financial groups want to profit of it.
It's not compulsory. You can quit when you want. Personally, I see no reason to stop working, unless you have something better to occupy your time. If, for example, you run your own business, and you make a decent living from it, why stop?
I wish we were half this defiant when we raised the retirement age from 65 to 67. France has their revolutionary history, and we have our convict history. Us Australians talk a big game but it's just talk, deep down we love being told what to do by an authority figure
You Australians are lucky then, we Americans don't even talk big game about our government lol while we have the largest wealth inequality in the developed world, highest poverty rates, some of the highest crime rates. I guess we as well like being told what to do by an authority figure. anyways, still love our australian brothers, us workers are in this together. 🇺🇸🇦🇺
Grazie, fratelli d'Italia. Non dimmenticheremo mai come Signor Macron era irrispettoso e arrogante con gli Italiani mentré noi Francesi abbiamo il piú grande rispetto per voi e la vostra nazione che ha tutto inventato. Vergogna per lui, nessuno ha bisogno dei consigli di questa persona, ancor meno voi. 🇮🇹🇫🇷
A French man's life expectancy is 79 years. Raising the retirement age means he can expect to have 15 years of retirement instead of 17, that's a 12% reduction. Now let's be honest you are lucky if you are not bedridden and pooping in your hospital gown after age 72. Those precious 2 years Macron just stole were 2 of the 10 best years that a person works 50 years to earn.
@@Maurazio you’ve got to be really naive to believe they do it to « save » the pension fund system. The amount of public money we lost when they got rid of taxes on the wealthiest, whose profits broke records during the pandemic and post pandemic periods - they weren’t too worried about deficits.
UK might not understand this, they were upset when their PM said he wants kids to learn stem so that professional immigration can be reduced, they all started crying.
Yeah, and all the alternatives to capitalism have created wealthy, happy, healthy societies. Like democracy, capitalism (controlled) is about the least-worst form of organising things we’ve invented. Unless you’ve got any better ideas, that is …
Because capitalism is when the state tries to enforce a 2 year higher pension age in line with the rest of Europe to deal with the aging population. Smart guy.
When the government tries to destroy democracy, everyone needs to stand up and resist! Bravo! Nice to see some French officials have not forgotten the meaning of their National Anthem.
Do you know anything about French history and why and when the 49.3 was introduced? If you werew I doubt whether you would have written what you wrote. This is perhaps why it's so irresponsible of the Guardian to have a Comments section in the first place. (I expect that, ideologically, we're quite close, but I've lived and followed left-wing politics in France for over 30 years so would like a voice in all this. This being social media, it's those who issue the most provocative statements that will prevail (at the expense of this who perhaps know what's really going on). This is how Trump happened!
@@spythere democracy is a fantastic aspiration: I recommend that you do a MOOC on the subject, because it's also complicated. I teach classes on this subject and notions of what "democracy" is differs across the globe. Beware of simple solutions!
Art. 49.3 allows that but it's normally used for emergency situations or if we are in a rare "alternance" Situation. Never for an important structural vote !!
It's a consitutionnal article 49.3 that can push a law and force the mp voting the text if they doesn't thé gouvernement will resign. It's like a warning button. Because the Président will dissolve the parliament so New electionif the gouvernement resign Macron have relative majority not absolute.
There's a clause that allows for it. The problem for Macron is that he might have a hard time justifying himself in this instance. I don't know that this situation qualifies, even though I actually think he's in the right on the pension reforms.
A few years ago the Australian government put up retirement age from 65 to 67. I wish our members of parliament where as passionate as those in France 🇫🇷
@@billal2731 Actually there is no retirement age in Australia (except for judges as per constitution). So citizens can claim for the aged pension when they are 67. The only jobs with retirement ages are judges at 70 years old, and fair work Australia presidential members where it is 65 years old.
they were going to vote against it , that's why he used emergency powers to force it. That's the main reason for the revolt. The bill is not just about age, everythign about it is wrong. French retirement funds are at balance because we financed through our taxes a fund to anticipate demographic shift. This fund is full and exedentary , they want to use the money to fund green energy and have us work two more years. They want to steel the money.
And it will get worse, many countries are having a demographic crisis with way too low childbirth rates, how many pensions can a country provide with a fast ever-shrinking active/working taxpaying population? My generation will see retirement in their 70s or maybe never. That's one of the downsides of people not having kids
@@atropabelladonna3120 immigration is unpopular, but it is a side-effect or by-product of an ageing population and small families or people deciding to stay single. The 'social engineers' of the left-wing created that!
a lot of people around the world are actually jealous that UK got a PM who can actually fix the UK economy but some how the brits themselves are not convinced. He seems to be saying all the right things then what's the issue ?
@@nishant115me they can have him. He was not voted in by either the party members nor the public. He was placed there to do deals for his mates. After all, he did give billions to fraudsters and no chance of getting it back. I suppose they are jealous of what he did and got promoted to the big job.
@@bridiesmith5110 yes he was not elected by anyone but he has been able to stabilize UK economy. That's what UK needed. Don't know how he'll manage in future.
@@nishant115me he hasn’t stabilised the economy, he has done the exact opposite. He will multiply his his fortune before he leaves office and will bankrupt many ordinary people with his socialist tax system. He doesn’t care and he has no idea of poverty. He might try USA politics next.
Parliament can vote to fire the entire government if they want to, but they most likely Will not. Many fint oppose the reform, they just do not want to pay a political price for it.
This time, only 9 voices were missing to reject the parliament... some politicians have said that they received high pressure from government, as suppressing local funds for their area... We are nit a democracy anymore...
@@kaki3151 The Republicans supported this measure as clear as day, people are paying lip service to protestors whilst secretly wanting this. They want the best of both worlds, getting a reform they want through and reducing future deficit whilst also scoring political points by attacking an unpopular reform
@@michellemobakeng5938 It's hard to find a starting point of an event as complex as the French revolution, but one could say the "Serment du jeu de paume" on June 20th, 1789 is the closest we got. Basically, most representatives of the "Third State" (not noble, not clergy) gathered in a building in Versailles, and sworn not to leave before France gets a Constitution.
Pension shouldn't be from debt of government. We may save one person today but we lose three later while paying back the debt with interest. Government should always spend what it collects from taxes.
The actual age french people can retire at the moment is 62 years. In Germany in comparison it is 67 years. I am pretty sure that if there was an affordable plan to leave the retirement age for the French as ridiculous low as it is now, the government would support it. So what are the sound counter-calculations of these patriotic Marseilles-singer?
The issue is not raising the age per se. The issue is all the countries who did in Europe got their pensioners poorer. French pensioners are the 2nd richest pensioners after Luxemburg ones. The present French pensions system is in no way close to collapsing. It was beneficiary in 2020 and 2021. The present system works well and does not need to be changed. There will be a very small deficit in the next years, which could be funded very easily, like raising women's salaries to men salaries or getting the financial incomes to contribute a little. French are hard-working people, and you can see this in the OEDC reports when comparing countries' private workers yielding. Finally you have to know it's very hard for older workers to find a job. To have to work 2 more years will be in reality to be on social paiements for 2 years. This is less than 600 eur per MONTH for everything
Don't be mistaken when you talk about the French when you are actually talking about the Parisians. These same Parisians who assassinated the king of France, took control and made France the most centralized country in Europe. This is why France is the 2nd country most interested in the British crown and are constantly looking for the providential man.
We Indians also need to be revolutionary like the French and question the governments whenever required. Revolution is in Indian blood. Our history shows that we are capable of great change, as seen in our struggle for independence from British rule. Through the power of unity, led by remarkable leaders like Mahatma Gandhi, Subhash Chandra Bose, Bhagat Singh, Jawaharlal Nehru and many others, we defeated the British and secured our freedom in 1947. Jai Hind!
Great, we don't need fools like Putin and slavish Russians who don't fight for democracy. Even during the reign of Catherine II of Russia, the atmosphere in Russia was less gloomy. If not then a democracy, it at least took an interest in French intellectuals and philosophers. The philosophy of enlightenment, rationality, Does the separation of powers mean anything to you? The social contract of the people?
Now the riots are suppressed by the police and quite brutally, but the EU has no problem with that. France breaks EU laws and still no reaction. But if Poland would do the same, then you get ridiculous penalties right away
@@Krell-ef7rfWhen in Poland the police dispersed the strikes in a similar way, the EU, including France, criticized us and threatened with penalties. The EU has double standards
May the french never lose their inspiring revolutionary soul.
❤❤❤
I wish they’d let Americans borrow that soul for a little bit 😭
ce n'est pas près d'arriver, nous sommes en plein dedans. Même si la France doit être mise à feu, et même les Français sont réputés pour être râleurs, JAMAIS nous ne cèderont face à une loi anti-démocratique. C'est la base même de notre pays.
@@sooodumnnim4257 which side you on 😳
@@RNKel1 side of the proletariat
It's not just the anthem but the words have meaning in these times....
Exactement !
Allons enfant de la Patrie!
Fier d'être français nous ne laisserons pas un petit napoléonien comme Macron tuer notre système de retraites.
I mean, there are other solutions too... Cut all welfare money and we don't have to raise the retirement age.
@@cae2525 😠🤮
My mother in law is a 60 year old French lady. She said that she accept the reform if Macron works everyday from 6am in the morning until 12 at night.
je crois pas que ta daronne soit ouvriere agricole
I’m not sure any politician on either side of the channel puts 18hours a week in! Never mind a day.
Have to admire the french people for making themselves vocal to the political class
@@LexiD-zx6bf 😮that’s Rs.123200 woah I mean for Indians the amount is woahhhhh but I wonder how well one can live with that income in France? Does it cover all the basics like utilities,rent & groceries?
@@D.2601 not! Many PEOPLE are totaly broke the 15 each mounth in France!
And Many Gand pa and ma have juste 5 or 600€ pension per mounth but they give Money all over their life!
He's the president of one of the biggest and most important countries in europe. Do you really think that is workload isn't far beyond average?
The British working class people need to take note and stand up together like the French.
No we dont. If we retired at 62 our economy would collapse.
@@mrprosser843 I know you're right. I guess I mean generally. It seems to be the minority in this country that get their voices heard and the majority, ie the working class who don't. The French have always been very nationalistic and why not.
@@mrprosser843 you say that as if it’s the fault of workers. Tax the rich more and the government will have plenty of money for welfare and an earlier retirement age.
@@dylanschmeichel2008 In the UK we already do, 43% of all British working Adults pay no income tax compared to the top 1% who pay 27%. Now im not soft on the rich in no way whatsoever, but we must recognize that "tax the rich" has its limits. What Britain needs is simple reform of expenditure not more income.
@@dylanschmeichel2008 so the rich leaves france (like nowadays) and don't create any jobs for the france
The fact that workers have to work more in a time when productivity has never been higher. Absolute shame.
Avec une retraite à 900 euros par mois ou moins ? A
THIS !!! 🙏
Well they could also contribute more to the pension scheme then. But paying 20% of your salary into pension is also not sustainable and doesn't solve the structural deficit.
People aren’t having enough kids
But how else their bank accounts would look like this?
You have to love the french people. Government does something they don't like? Protests. And not only protests. No. Protests for days. They go and take grandma out of the retirement home so she can protest too. And they stand up and sing their national anthem. Has some feeling like the scene in Casablanca
They don’t protest for days. They protest once a week by dancing and burning garbages.
@@johnmurphy7674 always that one guy
@@johnmurphy7674 it's been 2 weeks now that protests are daily in most of big cities. Yes, it's "for days".
I wish it had an impact, but a million people on the street doesn't make the government listen... Even the polls state that 93% of working people (Hence paying for retirement) are against it and the government forces though... I'm proud that my people stands against all of this, but I'm ashamed of our representatives. In a democracy, you should at least listen to your people, negotiate and compromise, not treating it like an annoying fly...
@@Grytem I admire your people for that. Like honestly. Wish we Germans had the balls to do that. So keep protesting please and sing the song of your people
Life is too short and the billionaires want to work us all to death.
It's just 64 mgawd
@@barclas4422 Seulement 64 ans, aujourd'hui. Demain, 67 ans. Après-demain, 70 ans.
@@falconeshield 64 today 68 tomorrow
@@tastytoast4576 who’s going to pay for it?
@@falconeshield 64 is the age My dad passed away. Asking years for an early pension, while recovering from two heart attacks, and his heart being monitored with a pacemaker ! Oh, and he was in construction.
So 2 years can be the difference between spending your limited time on earth left with your family, or killing yourself in a difficult job !
Parliament needs to hold a vote of no confidence as per article 49.2 of the Constitution...
And put who in power, exactly? Marie le Pen? That's what you really want, isn't it
Macron probably has executive power to override that too.
They did and they failed.
@@souventudubanned not enough votes of course.
@@LordCoeCoe If only this would’ve happened in Pakistan.
This should happen all over the World, Power to the people
Monarchism is better
We here in Ireland talk of the French as a model to look towards, I wish we Irish had the spirit of working class unity and the fire of revolution still in our belly like the French. Never lose what you have 🇮🇪🇫🇷
Exactly, we respect our Celtic bretherin
Respect to Ireland from your Celtic brother (im from Brittany) ; )
love you guys
Vive la République d’Irlande!
France/Ireland are brothers since centuries from the war with England to just the fact Irish people are the kindest people in this messed world and their country is magnifique...my grandma is 93 and she'd never travelled but her only destination has always been Ireland...congrat' for the rugby tournament
Can you imagine the spineless Mp's here in the UK doing that? No, me neither.
No, because they are ok.
They're hypocrits
What about during the 2019 prorogation?
Because the UK is not a democracy. The Tories run this place, even if labour are in "power"
Can you believe there's no real opposition in the UK? No party wants to end the horror show that's Brexit, Starmer is happy to leave further and further right.
What the politicians do not understand, is to listen to the people and realize that collectively, the people are more powerful than the politicians, history has shown this to be true, over and over again.
No they are not . They have heat seeking missiles now . No more swords or muskets. Heat seeking missiles.
@@valenwood6299 yup, plain armed uprising is impossible without complete support of the army in our modern times. It's just not a viable action anymore.
How will the people revolt, on twitter ?
@@koopasteve that's Ukraine and it was in 2014, Ukraine is a population similar to Russia or India or any developing nation, the west is west. You think you and your tiktok friends will hold a revolution on the streets? What will be your slogan, let taxpayers pay for my degree which has no prospects for giving me a decent job?
@@omeven5785 It infuriates me how few people realize this.
You have to either have military support or overthrow the government so quickly and efficiently that there's no room for a counterattack
I've never been more french in my life and I'm Mexican 😅🇨🇵🕊️🇲🇽 Working people United for our rights. 💪🏼
Cogadh
Un grand merci de la part d'une française c'est très dur ce que nous vivons en ce moment en France mais il faut tenir bon ,pour sauver la démocratie..❤
Vive la France!
According to the latest WHO data published in 2020 life expectancy in Cameroon is: Male 60.3, female 64.5 and total life expectancy is 62.4 which gives Cameroon a World Life Expectancy ranking of 169.
According to the latest WHO data published in 2020 life expectancy in France is: Male 79.8, female 85.1 and total life expectancy is 82.5 which gives France a World Life Expectancy ranking of 11.
According to the latest WHO data published in 2020 life expectancy in Morocco is: Male 71.7, female 74.3 and total life expectancy is 73.0 which gives Morocco a World Life Expectancy ranking of 102. [World life expectancy] 1:03
VIVE LA RÉPUBLIQUE ET VIVE LA FRANCE 🇫🇷🇫🇷🇫🇷
Life expectancy in India was 25.4 in the year 1800, and over the course of the next 220 years, it has increased to almost 70. [Statista] 0:02
Even better is if you access the sources above. Do it, dear friends! 1:11
@@Gurci28 what are you talking about ?
This time, only 9 voices were missing to reject the parliament.. never happened before... but some politicians have said that they received high pressure from government, as threafs of suppressing local funds for their area...
We are not a democracy anymore...
And the pension system has no funding problem! It is a fight between two pension models. Here is the true goal...
Before the vote.. Brown enveloppes may have changed hands..
The pension system definitely has a funding problem, have you even taken a look on our current population models? Our average age is getting higher, how do you suppose we make up for that? By printing money?
@@2mac_mini952 where did you read that there was a funding problem in France ? There is a group of expert to check this fund, and they clearly said that there was no problem. But European Union wants that every country limits its ratio of funding vs PIB (I don't know the english letters sorry...).
So it is a choice to reduce the funding , the system is well balanced. But french system is not open to capital, and some financial groups want to profit of it.
You have to love the French
UK forced to work until 67!!!!
Don't worry, if the Conservatives win the next GE they will raise it to 70.
@@georgeash4008 they wont bc old people are their main vote source, it’ll be labour which does that 🤣
@@dolphee9935 don’t confuse small and big c conservatism. The only thing they have in common is they’re both a bunch of massive c’s, total and utter.
It's not compulsory.
You can quit when you want.
Personally, I see no reason to stop working, unless you have something better to occupy your time.
If, for example, you run your own business, and you make a decent living from it, why stop?
Even if UK raise the retirement age to 80, the UK citizens will not riot, they are obedient slaves.
I wish we were half this defiant when we raised the retirement age from 65 to 67. France has their revolutionary history, and we have our convict history. Us Australians talk a big game but it's just talk, deep down we love being told what to do by an authority figure
In the end, they’ll work longer.
You Australians are lucky then, we Americans don't even talk big game about our government lol while we have the largest wealth inequality in the developed world, highest poverty rates, some of the highest crime rates. I guess we as well like being told what to do by an authority figure. anyways, still love our australian brothers, us workers are in this together. 🇺🇸🇦🇺
Not allowed here, they'll label you as a inssurectionist and throw you in prison
Don't worry mate, absolutely nobody thinks of Australia when they think of respectable moral conviction
@@Henchman.24 Didn't Australia create Covid camps btw?
Aux armes citoyens!
formez vos bataillons!
Marchons! marchons!
qu'un sang impur,
abreuve nos sillons!
Over a two year increase in retirement age? Seems excessive.
@@maryanchabursky9148 You study economics at a liberal school, why would I care what you say?
@@maryanchabursky9148 it’s not just that.
Anyway if politics would work, there would be no need for that.
@@m.p.2234 to be fair politics doesn’t mean doing whatever the majority want immediately without pause.
@@tultoi5651 lol I’m not discussing economics. What kind of school should you study economics at?
🇺🇸 Hello from the United States. You guys are awesome. Never stop fighting for your rights.
I wish also Italy would be like that - the French have my respect.
Grazie, fratelli d'Italia. Non dimmenticheremo mai come Signor Macron era irrispettoso e arrogante con gli Italiani mentré noi Francesi abbiamo il piú grande rispetto per voi e la vostra nazione che ha tutto inventato. Vergogna per lui, nessuno ha bisogno dei consigli di questa persona, ancor meno voi. 🇮🇹🇫🇷
VIVE LA FRANCE ❤❤❤❤
et à bas la république !
This is the most French turn of events I've ever seen.
A French man's life expectancy is 79 years. Raising the retirement age means he can expect to have 15 years of retirement instead of 17, that's a 12% reduction. Now let's be honest you are lucky if you are not bedridden and pooping in your hospital gown after age 72.
Those precious 2 years Macron just stole were 2 of the 10 best years that a person works 50 years to earn.
If the pension fund collapsed I am not sure how much you can enjoy it
@@Maurazio tax big corps
Bien résumé. On point summary 👍👏👏
Maybe we should make women work longer than men. They have an extra 6 years of life expectancy.
@@Maurazio you’ve got to be really naive to believe they do it to « save » the pension fund system. The amount of public money we lost when they got rid of taxes on the wealthiest, whose profits broke records during the pandemic and post pandemic periods - they weren’t too worried about deficits.
As much as i hate to big up the french, they do have a lot to teach the uk about political protest, riots and food.
What about.. wines and cheese😅
And teach you rugby no?
🤭
@@swann67000 not the last match ..buddy..
@@ornitho100 53 point buddy
@@ornitho100 biggest humiliation at home buddy
UK needs to take note of this before it's too late.
UK might not understand this, they were upset when their PM said he wants kids to learn stem so that professional immigration can be reduced, they all started crying.
When it's against the politicians, no such things as right or left, the people is against our government.
I m so proud of my country
Vive La France ❤
Qu'un sang impure abreuve vos sillons! Aux armes aux armes citoyens!
I wish I could move to France and hope that my spirit is strong enough to be counted among the French.
Reminded me of the British flag during Farage's final speech in the EU, but less patriotic.
Communiste
British and French workers unite against capitalism
Macron thinks he is De Gaulle, he is more like Petain.
Yeah, and all the alternatives to capitalism have created wealthy, happy, healthy societies. Like democracy, capitalism (controlled) is about the least-worst form of organising things we’ve invented. Unless you’ve got any better ideas, that is …
And replace it with what?
@@titteryenot4524 The key word is controlled. This pension reform was forced through, there was no democratic majority for it.
Because capitalism is when the state tries to enforce a 2 year higher pension age in line with the rest of Europe to deal with the aging population. Smart guy.
Great to see people stand up for themselves but for some reason it does not happen here in the UK.
yeah people in the anglo countries are cowards
When the government tries to destroy democracy, everyone needs to stand up and resist! Bravo! Nice to see some French officials have not forgotten the meaning of their National Anthem.
Well to be fair they're not destroying democracy, it's in the constitution.
@@kam0eb Yeah, because forcing laws without people's approval is definitely what makes country democratic
@@kam0eb the two ideas may be different of course…simply because something is lawful does not mean it is democratic or right.
Do you know anything about French history and why and when the 49.3 was introduced? If you werew I doubt whether you would have written what you wrote. This is perhaps why it's so irresponsible of the Guardian to have a Comments section in the first place. (I expect that, ideologically, we're quite close, but I've lived and followed left-wing politics in France for over 30 years so would like a voice in all this. This being social media, it's those who issue the most provocative statements that will prevail (at the expense of this who perhaps know what's really going on). This is how Trump happened!
@@spythere democracy is a fantastic aspiration: I recommend that you do a MOOC on the subject, because it's also complicated. I teach classes on this subject and notions of what "democracy" is differs across the globe. Beware of simple solutions!
At least they have some backbone more than our spineless lot
French people keep fighting 💪 🇫🇷
how is the legislation able to be pushed thru without a vote!?
That's called democracy...
Art. 49.3 allows that but it's normally used for emergency situations or if we are in a rare "alternance" Situation. Never for an important structural vote !!
It's a consitutionnal article 49.3 that can push a law and force the mp voting the text if they doesn't thé gouvernement will resign. It's like a warning button. Because the Président will dissolve the parliament so New electionif the gouvernement resign Macron have relative majority not absolute.
Its the 11th time with this government, thats how corrupt our countries are
There's a clause that allows for it. The problem for Macron is that he might have a hard time justifying himself in this instance. I don't know that this situation qualifies, even though I actually think he's in the right on the pension reforms.
well done Salute those stand for their Right 👏👍👍👍👍
Bravo!!! Ca ira!! ❤
Come on France do what you're famous for and have a revolution
We try since many years but we hope other countries do the same
For sure, it will never happen in South Korea...
Well done!
A few years ago the Australian government put up retirement age from 65 to 67. I wish our members of parliament where as passionate as those in France 🇫🇷
Do you have special rules in Australia for people with difficult professions like garbage collectors ?
Shooting for the ripe young age of 90
But in the end, French will work longer. Remember the yellow jackets, they didn’t change anything and they even re-elected Macron
@@billal2731 Actually there is no retirement age in Australia (except for judges as per constitution). So citizens can claim for the aged pension when they are 67. The only jobs with retirement ages are judges at 70 years old, and fair work Australia presidential members where it is 65 years old.
Average life expectancy has increased faster
Not even French politicians are a big fan of this bill. Hopefully, this won't devolve into chaos. That could've been a lot worse!
they were going to vote against it , that's why he used emergency powers to force it. That's the main reason for the revolt. The bill is not just about age, everythign about it is wrong. French retirement funds are at balance because we financed through our taxes a fund to anticipate demographic shift. This fund is full and exedentary , they want to use the money to fund green energy and have us work two more years. They want to steel the money.
Bottom-up revolution is what gets real change
Браво!
спасибо товарищ
@@MXCProdHD 🤚
So proud to be french ❤🇨🇵❤
Y’a pas de quoi pourtant
@@johnmurphy7674😂😂Tu parles français pourtant 🇲🇳
@@poussinmignon3193 Et ? J’apprends la langue.
Ce n’est pas parce que tu parles français que tu es français. Au Canada ils parlent français aussi.
@@johnmurphy7674 Bah ouais trou du cul du coup tu craches sur la France mais t’apprends quand même le français 😂😂🤭
Gotta love French perseverance
Pih, 200 years ago the PM would beeen cut down.
The retirement age here in Australia went from 65 to 67 a few years ago.
In france it's 64 (can retire) but 67 can expect to have the full retirement (not much for many) pay.
Same in Italy.
And it will get worse, many countries are having a demographic crisis with way too low childbirth rates, how many pensions can a country provide with a fast ever-shrinking active/working taxpaying population? My generation will see retirement in their 70s or maybe never. That's one of the downsides of people not having kids
It's 65 here in canada
@@atropabelladonna3120 immigration is unpopular, but it is a side-effect or by-product of an ageing population and small families or people deciding to stay single. The 'social engineers' of the left-wing created that!
Strange how he does that after having a visit from snak sunak who placed himself as our pm. He too will be removed.
a lot of people around the world are actually jealous that UK got a PM who can actually fix the UK economy but some how the brits themselves are not convinced. He seems to be saying all the right things then what's the issue ?
@@nishant115me they can have him. He was not voted in by either the party members nor the public. He was placed there to do deals for his mates. After all, he did give billions to fraudsters and no chance of getting it back. I suppose they are jealous of what he did and got promoted to the big job.
@@bridiesmith5110 yes he was not elected by anyone but he has been able to stabilize UK economy. That's what UK needed. Don't know how he'll manage in future.
@@nishant115me he hasn’t stabilised the economy, he has done the exact opposite. He will multiply his his fortune before he leaves office and will bankrupt many ordinary people with his socialist tax system. He doesn’t care and he has no idea of poverty. He might try USA politics next.
"i invite everyone voicing their opinion to please stop, it goes against our rules"
Well done dear French may italians learn from you🇮🇹♥️🇫🇷
Italians have already learned their lesson, it's the naive french who haven't yet
I don’t think the France was ingouvernable but that gouvernement are deaf ! 🇫🇷
You know...last time the french were on the street it didn't end well, I suggest they start listening
Vive la France. True patriots.
Love the French 🇫🇷
They’re singing the wrong song. They should be singing a Beatles remix: Not When I'm Sixty-Four! 🎶
We hate your language, do you understand that ?
Terrible behaviour by the French government, marcon should be kicked out of office
Aux armes!
anywhere has tyranny and suppression, there comes the la marseillaise.
To arms, citizens!!!
Formez le bataillon !!!
@@babangteo2853vos*
The marseillaise
@@pierren___ Non, I do it deliberately.
the citizen can go to arms as they like. theres no one to lead, and so, the direction is nowhere
Parliament can vote to fire the entire government if they want to, but they most likely Will not. Many fint oppose the reform, they just do not want to pay a political price for it.
2 motions for vote of no confidence already lodged.
This time, only 9 voices were missing to reject the parliament... some politicians have said that they received high pressure from government, as suppressing local funds for their area...
We are nit a democracy anymore...
@@kaki3151 The Republicans supported this measure as clear as day, people are paying lip service to protestors whilst secretly wanting this. They want the best of both worlds, getting a reform they want through and reducing future deficit whilst also scoring political points by attacking an unpopular reform
@@oisinmtom Why do you like arguing about Canada?
@@kaki3151 you never were. Capitalism is anti-democratic
Why do you need a parliament at all if you are going to have a special power that ignore it. The presidential king system is broken.
Meanwhile in some other countries and especially mine, retirement is being considered to be outright cancelled and abolished.
So there’s not enough money for the people, but more than 40 billion € to invest in the new "war economy!” 🤦🏻♂️
I wish British politicians had balls like these fine chaps!
It's about the neoliberal government in general and not just about the pension age!!!
All power to the people!
chaotic, amazing democracy you have.
This is how the French Revolution started,
How did it start, please? It is not a rhetorical question. How much do you know about the French Revolution?
@@michellemobakeng5938 It's hard to find a starting point of an event as complex as the French revolution, but one could say the "Serment du jeu de paume" on June 20th, 1789 is the closest we got. Basically, most representatives of the "Third State" (not noble, not clergy) gathered in a building in Versailles, and sworn not to leave before France gets a Constitution.
yet another extremely common French W 🇫🇷🇷🇸🇫🇷🇷🇸🇫🇷🇷🇸
Revolution coming in 0.02 seconds...
Viva France!
Vive, viva is Spanish
Pension shouldn't be from debt of government. We may save one person today but we lose three later while paying back the debt with interest.
Government should always spend what it collects from taxes.
Any leader would not have done it to any country
Vive la france. Vive la Révolution. ✌
Allons z'enfants de la patrie.... 😂
Thanks a lot, great respect for you all.
Remember guys
Never mess with the people who have revolution in their blood!
The actual age french people can retire at the moment is 62 years. In Germany in comparison it is 67 years. I am pretty sure that if there was an affordable plan to leave the retirement age for the French as ridiculous low as it is now, the government would support it. So what are the sound counter-calculations of these patriotic Marseilles-singer?
Bravo! Bravo! Bravo!
I wish American workers had the unity to fight like the French 🇺🇸🇫🇷
This is the spirit!!! 😊❤
The issue is not raising the age per se. The issue is all the countries who did in Europe got their pensioners poorer. French pensioners are the 2nd richest pensioners after Luxemburg ones.
The present French pensions system is in no way close to collapsing. It was beneficiary in 2020 and 2021.
The present system works well and does not need to be changed.
There will be a very small deficit in the next years, which could be funded very easily, like raising women's salaries to men salaries or getting the financial incomes to contribute a little.
French are hard-working people, and you can see this in the OEDC reports when comparing countries' private workers yielding.
Finally you have to know it's very hard for older workers to find a job. To have to work 2 more years will be in reality to be on social paiements for 2 years. This is less than 600 eur per MONTH for everything
Was the singing of the Marseillaise also a symbolic (i.e. not literal) hint at revolution?
Yes and (obviously related) the fight for democracy
Special powers? From a Federal Government not wanting to represent its people?? Y'don't say... Seems to be a global problem right now, eh?
He said we need a king, I wonder if he wants to end like the last french one now.
Come on let the people rest n enjoy their life.however they want. Stop forcing other to work at certain age. The young generation need that job
It's just around the corner 💥💥💥
62 to 64! Gosh they should lower it, not increase it. May the French keep fighting and never lose their spirit!
Un grande applauso ai nostri cugini francesi: vi prego, non fate la nostra fine.
Don't be mistaken when you talk about the French when you are actually talking about the Parisians. These same Parisians who assassinated the king of France, took control and made France the most centralized country in Europe. This is why France is the 2nd country most interested in the British crown and are constantly looking for the providential man.
I'm French and i want to say I'm with our citizen viva la france we will again build our france together
its "Vive La France"
Stop trying to act like a french, internet coper
You're not French bro don't act like
- "I'm French"
- "Viva la France"
I wish we were that brave unless your are an MP who can retire at 55 on a brilliant pension the rest of us will most likely not get to pension age
I hope those in the parliament who want to pass this bill will rot in jail soon!!!
That would also be against their rules.
The economic prediction is that the current generation will never retire.
If goes against OUR RULES l.o.l
The French people need to STORM the PARLIAMENT.
THE SECOND REVOLUTION IS COMING
the third because young vests can count as a revolution given that King Macron 1st and the government gave in to yellow vest
No the fourth.
We Indians also need to be revolutionary like the French and question the governments whenever required. Revolution is in Indian blood. Our history shows that we are capable of great change, as seen in our struggle for independence from British rule. Through the power of unity, led by remarkable leaders like Mahatma Gandhi, Subhash Chandra Bose, Bhagat Singh, Jawaharlal Nehru and many others, we defeated the British and secured our freedom in 1947.
Jai Hind!
Mother Russia and Father Putin support the people of France
Great, we don't need fools like Putin and slavish Russians who don't fight for democracy.
Even during the reign of Catherine II of Russia, the atmosphere in Russia was less gloomy. If not then a democracy, it at least took an interest in French intellectuals and philosophers.
The philosophy of enlightenment, rationality,
Does the separation of powers mean anything to you? The social contract of the people?
The french anthem is the only song who's forbidden to interupt in the National Assembly
Now the riots are suppressed by the police and quite brutally, but the EU has no problem with that. France breaks EU laws and still no reaction. But if Poland would do the same, then you get ridiculous penalties right away
There are laws against exessive use of force now?
@@Krell-ef7rfWhen in Poland the police dispersed the strikes in a similar way, the EU, including France, criticized us and threatened with penalties. The EU has double standards
🤐 Not Marseilles. That's scary. *Intense French Revolution flashbacks*
They love cosplaying 1789
Pension. Have to be able to be afforded so if Society wants to stay as it is,something else has to be lost but surely dont hit the older people😂