Regarding language, why is it that Some people on social media especially Pakistanis gatekeep Urdu a lot? They make it a point to correct people’s pronunciation and while doing so they sometimes go overboard as well. Its just a language not god’s word. People bring their regional dialects and mannerisms in very language they speak, be it hindi or english and nobody is up in arms about wrong adayegi but with Urdu people take such offence. Why?
This happens when the language is not your mother tongue and you speak it because it has a "prestige" status in your society. Urdu is the mother tongue of merely around 9% of the Pakistani population but it has the reputation of being a marker of the educated class. The same happens with the English language in India and Pakistan. People here lose their minds being pedantic over the misuse of English, while the real native English speakers not only don't bother but themselves commit a lot of errors. Not to mention the wide variety of English accents in the UK, some of them being hardly comprehensible.
REgarding the language, it was basically Bhojpuri, not really Hindi. The dialogue you referred to was the mother asking the mother in law --Kya ab auraton ki pasand ka khana banega? It is delicious irony -- the person who cooks asking the matriarch if it is even possible to take women's choices into consideration
every rural language of UP isn't Bhojpuri 😂 Only the very eastern part of UP and the western Bihar speak Bhojpuri. UP is linguistically very diverse. It has avadhi (your hanuman chalisa, kabir ke dohay and ramcharitmanas ramayan are in this language), braj bhasha, bundelkhandi etc etc. All these languages are much older than the standard Hindi/Urdu with a lot of rich literature of their own.
Aamir Khan is never against vulgar or abusive language , he says it should go organic with script , watch delhi belly , it is abusive and vulgar but it flows with screenplay.
One correction.. you said it’s a Netflix original movie. It’s actually not. It was released in theatres long before it appeared on Netflix. For Indian audiences , the language is perfectly familiar.
Sir, you are absolutely correct , Actually shooting started during covid , so , onthe first day cinematpgrapher got covid positive. so, for some days ,another cinematographer shot the film
Yar finally the views are coming. Am so happy to see the numbers. This channel and these two boys deserve more reach. They are the perfect mix of junk and healthy consumption. Support and love from Sydney ❤
Please move out of this misconception that a lot of Indians watch those age old in house Pakistani love dramas, there is an audience for that but very very less, nowhere near what you are thinking, maybe at most 1cr, vast majority of us today have no idea about Pakistani content
Tum logo ko kitni bar bola jay hum south side walo ko Pakistanis drama story culture kuch samaz nhi ata.....survey kar lo koi v nhi dekhta yha Pakistanis drama ....hindi belt region me specially muslim aur kuch non muslim dekhte honge dramo ko.... Indian web series dekhna jyda pasand krte hai.... Ek bar tum apne dramao ko paid subscription karo fir btana india se kitne log dekh rhe hai ya world wide???
@@TheMusbatShow ye kya tha fir India me bahut pasand kiya jata hai????are India me 28 states and 8 uts hai....Hindi belt region pure india ko represent nhi krta.
@@vbe_bGS dobara dekho show yehi kaha hai k pakistani directors ye kehtay hain lekin itna no hai nahin. Moun se jhaag nikalay baghair dekhogay tou samajh ayegi
@@TheMusbatShow 10 bar v dekh lene se bat badal nhi jati....thoda research kre...her video me yhi aap logo ko kehna hai...ek video me Indian election ke bare bahut sare false batein ki thi....Indian tv serial me koi gay sex ya normal sex scene nhi dikhya jata ....web series me dikhya jata hai jo ott platform pe ata hai...(recommended 18+,16+etc krke)
Just watched "Laapataa ladies". The movie is Simply Superb. The scene between Deepak & Phool in the farm just took it to the next level. He is so vulnerable in that scene and yet he goes ahead with it. The Overall narrative & storyline is so good. This movie is much much better than the big budget South Indian movies and their remakes which have no sense in them - just big loud music, over the top action & tons of over acting. No nuance at all. It is high time that audiences start valuing & supporting quality cinema over big budget loud movies with over the top acting.
As a regular viewer, I suggest if you could start an alternative series of film reviews along with current affairs, it can be a huge hit in Pakistan. But Ali Bhai please don't create a separate channel for that :p.
I have personally met a few young Pakistani fellows. Trust me they are damn good storytellers. Bas unki kahaniya typical love story lolo pocho kuchi ku nhi hai... If u know u know, Pakistani TV serials which are currently popular in India, Its just a phase which eventually will pass. But I think its high time they should think beyond love stories. I loved Parizaad. And trust me Parizaad is just tip of the iceberg. Isse bhi ache ache bana sakte hai , par wo freedom nhi hai unke paas banane ki. Wai thakeli love stories ladkiyan aur auntiyan dekhti hai, eventually wo bhi bore ho jaengi. Humare yaha ekta kapoor 90s are early 2000s dominate karti this, Afghanistan me take kahani ghar ghar ki chalta that, Pakistan me bhi dekhte the. Par ab koi bhaaw nhi daalta. Soon the TV shit shows will go, OTT quality shows will get transferred to TV. Pakistani TV industry will have to match that. 25Million views is nothing if u simply talk about stats. U will have to give chance to young film makers with risky storytelling
2-2:50 crore jo bhi views aata hai wo bhi jyada indian Muslims dekhte hein aur aapne 3.5 rating de diya to kya baat hai, aapse bada koi best film review kon kar sakta hai. Aap dono ka jawab nii😊
I am yet to see the film, but after seeing your review, I am really tempted. And of course, everyone is talking good about this movie. And in the team, Aamir Khan, Kiran Rao, I trust. Great reaction/review.
Sir, a small request - plz be mindful of spoilers for those who are yet to see it 🙂 Or give us the timestamps of when spoilers are discussed, so we can skip those parts.
These people should watch “Delhi belly “ movie which was also Amir khan production. Its script was full of vulgarity and abuse . Vulgarity and abuse in the script should be organically not forced . Normal people in our society does all kinds of stuff including abuse , so if you are making film on common people you should include these things in movie .
مووی اچھی تھی میسج بھی تگڑا تا لیکن مثبت ness مجھے ضرورت سے زیادہ لگی، اسٹارٹ میں جو مسئلہ ہوا سو ہوا لیکن اس کے بعد سب شانتی، گھر کے افراد بھی ہر لحاظ سے تعاون کرنے والے، لڑکا اور اس کے دوست بھی خاندانی، ڈھابے والی انٹی بھی وومن امپاورمنٹ کی علمبردار، کام کرنے والا لڑکا، بھکاری، ریلوے افیسر حتی کہ پورا ریلوے اسٹیشن مکمل محفوظ اور تعاون سے بھرپور، پولیس والا بھی کرپٹ ہونے کے باوجود ہیرو صفت... مجھے فلم کم اور مثبت شو زیادہ لگا۔۔۔
Sir, love your conversations on films and music. Ho sake to amazon prime ka series "Jubilee" dekhiye aur accha lage to show me baat bhi kijiye. Love and respect from West Bengal India
Aako humhare bhojpuri aur ghar aur cultural geet jo movie me use hote h wo bhi sunane chaiye. Me khud rajashthani hu but Wo to bhojpuri ya up bihar ke gaano ki image aesi bana di h ,,warana aapko unme bhi bahut pyaare aur ache geet milege
Sorry to make demands on you. But please try to talk about Gangs of Wasseypur in one of your videos, if you can. Great Show. Big admirer of Ali Aftab. Thanks
It's sad very sad n funny that you guys are admiring mediocre films like Pathan n jawan that had an average ham actor .why It's clear Momin supporting Momins. If you lover of art, do review on films like Sam bahdur, Article 370,Veer Sarvarkar, 12fail, Mujib. A sane sawal. Waiting for jawab. Adaab
The discussion on dialect and language had me facepalming so hard!! Literally no one here in India had a problem understanding the dialect used in this film! Wish you had a better idea about how the Indian audience looks at films and how language was one of the best things about this particular film. Sad!
@@TheMusbatShow You did consider it as one of the weaknesses of the film. The point is, it is one of the strongest aspects of the film. The target audience has no problem understanding what’s being said on screen. You called the film linear and simple, and I know in a non- negative way, but it’s the simplicity and innocence of the film that has people falling in love with it. In the times of shitfest like Pathan, Jawaan, Heeramandi, etc., this film is a much needed breath of fresh air. And it’s not just my opinion, ask anyone here and they’ll tell you the same thing.
Hey , about language its not hindi nor urdu , its mix of bhojpuri and bundelkhandi of central india The dielect and language is beautiful ❤️ And the audience which watches Asur series don't watch Pakistani turki drama . Only north indian muslim who has less income and backward with their thinking . Large urdu speaking population of north india muslim watches Pakistani dramas . Urdu is not from Pakistan ita from delhi and u.p . Pakistani culture is arabi and turki thats why you feel alienation. Bandar kya jane adraq ka swaad. Sabke liye nahi hoti ye chiz.
According to Divergence Theory in linguistics, the birthplace of the language can be identified by the multiplicity of accents of that language spoken there, explaining the presence of numerous accents of Urdu spoken in Indopk, and the variance of accents in places like Lahore.
You can either resist the revolution or be part of it. For latter
www.patreon.com/aliaftab_saeed &
0325 6555592 Easy Paisa / Jazz Cash / Raast
Heera Mandi ka bola thha uska baaja bjaye script h nhi Mahal khde kr diye
Bramayugam and Anweshippin kandethum hindi dubbed movie review
Regarding language, why is it that Some people on social media especially Pakistanis gatekeep Urdu a lot? They make it a point to correct people’s pronunciation and while doing so they sometimes go overboard as well. Its just a language not god’s word. People bring their regional dialects and mannerisms in very language they speak, be it hindi or english and nobody is up in arms about wrong adayegi but with Urdu people take such offence. Why?
This happens when the language is not your mother tongue and you speak it because it has a "prestige" status in your society.
Urdu is the mother tongue of merely around 9% of the Pakistani population but it has the reputation of being a marker of the educated class.
The same happens with the English language in India and Pakistan. People here lose their minds being pedantic over the misuse of English, while the real native English speakers not only don't bother but themselves commit a lot of errors. Not to mention the wide variety of English accents in the UK, some of them being hardly comprehensible.
Right about Urdu ...yeh log sab languages ki taang todte hain!!!!
And they do it while they speak urdu with that heavy punjabi accent .
REgarding the language, it was basically Bhojpuri, not really Hindi. The dialogue you referred to was the mother asking the mother in law --Kya ab auraton ki pasand ka khana banega?
It is delicious irony -- the person who cooks asking the matriarch if it is even possible to take women's choices into consideration
It was not bhojpuri but Hindi with awadhi slang.
It is bundelkhandi and not awadhi and not bhojpuri.
every rural language of UP isn't Bhojpuri 😂 Only the very eastern part of UP and the western Bihar speak Bhojpuri. UP is linguistically very diverse. It has avadhi (your hanuman chalisa, kabir ke dohay and ramcharitmanas ramayan are in this language), braj bhasha, bundelkhandi etc etc.
All these languages are much older than the standard Hindi/Urdu with a lot of rich literature of their own.
@@nitishsaxena1372 i laughed out loud when they said its bhojpuri.
It's not bhojpuri, it's just Hindi with Bundelkhandi touch, that's removed far from Bhojpuri region
Indians from north can understand that language very well …
Aamir Khan is never against vulgar or abusive language , he says it should go organic with script , watch delhi belly , it is abusive and vulgar but it flows with screenplay.
One correction.. you said it’s a Netflix original movie. It’s actually not. It was released in theatres long before it appeared on Netflix. For Indian audiences , the language is perfectly familiar.
Not for all...
Sir, Aapne lagta hai "Delhi Belly" nahi dekhi. Aamir Khan production ki.😂😂😂
Just a minor point on Aamir Khan’s views on ‘vulgarity’, Delhi Belly was his production and it still has a huge fan following!
So was peepli live...
Sir, you are absolutely correct , Actually shooting started during covid , so , onthe first day cinematpgrapher got covid positive. so, for some days ,another cinematographer shot the film
Your review is excellent, addressing both the positive and negative aspects accurately.
Why all Pakistanis are doing Indian movies/series review nowdays and why no indian ever do anysuch thing for Pakistani content.
Jewar chori do dukh pana, chhota dukh chori bada dukh thana.
Yar finally the views are coming. Am so happy to see the numbers. This channel and these two boys deserve more reach. They are the perfect mix of junk and healthy consumption. Support and love from Sydney ❤
Please move out of this misconception that a lot of Indians watch those age old in house Pakistani love dramas, there is an audience for that but very very less, nowhere near what you are thinking, maybe at most 1cr, vast majority of us today have no idea about Pakistani content
Indian Muslim consume Pakistani Drama.
@@vinsin328No only backwards in them do.
My all friends watch pak drams
@@iramguard6985 All backward people who has not seen what is happening around globe waste their time in such shit.
@@vinsin328 not many people have watched pakistan drama
Thank you for reviewing Laapata Ladies. I was also one of the requesters for this. I think your USP is film review.
Tum logo ko kitni bar bola jay hum south side walo ko Pakistanis drama story culture kuch samaz nhi ata.....survey kar lo koi v nhi dekhta yha Pakistanis drama ....hindi belt region me specially muslim aur kuch non muslim dekhte honge dramo ko....
Indian web series dekhna jyda pasand krte hai....
Ek bar tum apne dramao ko paid subscription karo fir btana india se kitne log dekh rhe hai ya world wide???
Agar ap show dekh letay tou comment karnay se bach jatay. Hum ne b yehi kaha hai k nai dekhtay
@@TheMusbatShow ye kya tha fir India me bahut pasand kiya jata hai????are India me 28 states and 8 uts hai....Hindi belt region pure india ko represent nhi krta.
@@vbe_bGS dobara dekho show yehi kaha hai k pakistani directors ye kehtay hain lekin itna no hai nahin. Moun se jhaag nikalay baghair dekhogay tou samajh ayegi
@@TheMusbatShow 10 bar v dekh lene se bat badal nhi jati....thoda research kre...her video me yhi aap logo ko kehna hai...ek video me Indian election ke bare bahut sare false batein ki thi....Indian tv serial me koi gay sex ya normal sex scene nhi dikhya jata ....web series me dikhya jata hai jo ott platform pe ata hai...(recommended 18+,16+etc krke)
@@vbe_bGS uskay b haq main hi baat ki thi dobara video dekh lo uploaded hai. Kaan ya dimaagh check karwao
The best thing I like is the composure of you two gentlemen. I feel at peace listening to you both. Bahut badiya yaar. Keep it up.
نظامی سر کی اولاد کا صبر کا مقام ھے ہی اچھا
Just watched "Laapataa ladies". The movie is Simply Superb. The scene between Deepak & Phool in the farm just took it to the next level.
He is so vulnerable in that scene and yet he goes ahead with it.
The Overall narrative & storyline is so good.
This movie is much much better than the big budget South Indian movies and their remakes which have no sense in them - just big loud music, over the top action & tons of over acting. No nuance at all.
It is high time that audiences start valuing & supporting quality cinema over big budget loud movies with over the top acting.
a family man, with manoj bajpayee
Movie waa for indian audience. Period. Swanand kirkire sampat amir khan combo they are known for these kind of songs. English hindi mix.
Just for info Police role is done by our Honorable member of parliament 😅
Same Aamir khan ne Delly belly produce ki thi jisme gangs of wasseypur se bhi jyada galiya hai ,har dusri line Mai
As a regular viewer, I suggest if you could start an alternative series of film reviews along with current affairs, it can be a huge hit in Pakistan. But Ali Bhai please don't create a separate channel for that :p.
Has to be the Worst Review of such a great movie
All India rank ka review karein
I have personally met a few young Pakistani fellows. Trust me they are damn good storytellers. Bas unki kahaniya typical love story lolo pocho kuchi ku nhi hai... If u know u know, Pakistani TV serials which are currently popular in India, Its just a phase which eventually will pass. But I think its high time they should think beyond love stories. I loved Parizaad. And trust me Parizaad is just tip of the iceberg. Isse bhi ache ache bana sakte hai , par wo freedom nhi hai unke paas banane ki. Wai thakeli love stories ladkiyan aur auntiyan dekhti hai, eventually wo bhi bore ho jaengi. Humare yaha ekta kapoor 90s are early 2000s dominate karti this, Afghanistan me take kahani ghar ghar ki chalta that, Pakistan me bhi dekhte the. Par ab koi bhaaw nhi daalta. Soon the TV shit shows will go, OTT quality shows will get transferred to TV. Pakistani TV industry will have to match that. 25Million views is nothing if u simply talk about stats. U will have to give chance to young film makers with risky storytelling
aisa lag rha hia jaiase in dono ko kuch samjh bhi hai movie ki ?
Sabse unique hota hai aapka review
Ek movie south indian hai name- PARKING
ek bar zaroor dekhiyega ❤❤
One of the best cinema 📽️🎥
I just wanted to appreciate whoever is writing the captions of your videos these days. They are so, so well written, and a joy to read! Well done 👏
Glad you enjoy it!
Review: 3 Body Problem (Sci-fi)
25:40 .. Gangs of Wasseypur exactly did this in its music with the language. It was wonderful
2-2:50 crore jo bhi views aata hai wo bhi jyada indian Muslims dekhte hein aur aapne 3.5 rating de diya to kya baat hai, aapse bada koi best film review kon kar sakta hai. Aap dono ka jawab nii😊
I am yet to see the film, but after seeing your review, I am really tempted. And of course, everyone is talking good about this movie. And in the team, Aamir Khan, Kiran Rao, I trust.
Great reaction/review.
Siyasat nichley darjay ka kaam.. Wah..
یہ ھے ہمارے میزبان اور ان کی سوچ
sarcasm thaa
Sir, a small request - plz be mindful of spoilers for those who are yet to see it 🙂
Or give us the timestamps of when spoilers are discussed, so we can skip those parts.
Thank you for the great recommendation. Loved the movie.
Aamir Khan has also made delhi belly
Every indian drama or webseries is very filmy and every new Era Pakistani film becomes drama.
Kaahe to se sajana ..and mora Piya mose bolat naahi ...are two songs with similar language you...and remind you...they are incredible
These people should watch “Delhi belly “ movie which was also Amir khan production. Its script was full of vulgarity and abuse . Vulgarity and abuse in the script should be organically not forced . Normal people in our society does all kinds of stuff including abuse , so if you are making film on common people you should include these things in movie .
If you want aamir's vulgar movie please watch "Delhi Belly" , not just dialogue and scene are vulgar but song also
it would have been interesting to have invited a khawateen for the movie criticism as well...
Aik episode record krny k baad Blazers pehn k musbatness reload ho jati?😅
It's a plagiarised from an older less known movie.
You guys are really good 👍, though i liked the movie very much
مووی اچھی تھی میسج بھی تگڑا تا لیکن مثبت ness مجھے ضرورت سے زیادہ لگی، اسٹارٹ میں جو مسئلہ ہوا سو ہوا لیکن اس کے بعد سب شانتی، گھر کے افراد بھی ہر لحاظ سے تعاون کرنے والے، لڑکا اور اس کے دوست بھی خاندانی، ڈھابے والی انٹی بھی وومن امپاورمنٹ کی علمبردار، کام کرنے والا لڑکا، بھکاری، ریلوے افیسر حتی کہ پورا ریلوے اسٹیشن مکمل محفوظ اور تعاون سے بھرپور، پولیس والا بھی کرپٹ ہونے کے باوجود ہیرو صفت...
مجھے فلم کم اور مثبت شو زیادہ لگا۔۔۔
Sir, love your conversations on films and music. Ho sake to amazon prime ka series "Jubilee" dekhiye aur accha lage to show me baat bhi kijiye.
Love and respect from West Bengal India
Gullak Review
coming week
Aako humhare bhojpuri aur ghar aur cultural geet jo movie me use hote h wo bhi sunane chaiye. Me khud rajashthani hu but Wo to bhojpuri ya up bihar ke gaano ki image aesi bana di h ,,warana aapko unme bhi bahut pyaare aur ache geet milege
Thanks God ,there was not a single vulgar word in it۔
Please review on Tumbhad ...one of the master peace of Marathi cinema, it's available in Hindi dubbed.
Please do a review of "gullak" series.
Review: Late night with the Devil (Horror)
Enjoy the film janab....it one of a kind! Kante churi kyuun nikaali😮😮😮😮😮.
Please review Srikanth
Sir please review on "PREMALU" movie this is my favourite movie.... this is malyalam movie hindi dubbed is available...
Love you from India🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Sorry to make demands on you. But please try to talk about Gangs of Wasseypur in one of your videos, if you can. Great Show. Big admirer of Ali Aftab. Thanks
Haye Pak simper.
+1 I subscribed to this channel because they discussed GOW.
Woh gullak wala nahi hai
I started with very Positive intent your Podcast but you were not focus on topic.., jumping from one point to another point
Review on premalu and thanks later me
It's sad very sad n funny that you guys are admiring mediocre films like Pathan n jawan that had an average ham actor .why
It's clear Momin supporting Momins.
If you lover of art, do review on films like Sam bahdur, Article 370,Veer Sarvarkar, 12fail, Mujib.
A sane sawal.
Waiting for jawab.
Adaab
Mene tou Jawan dekhi hi nai hui
Mazza aya
Musbat
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Love ❤
First
The discussion on dialect and language had me facepalming so hard!! Literally no one here in India had a problem understanding the dialect used in this film! Wish you had a better idea about how the Indian audience looks at films and how language was one of the best things about this particular film. Sad!
We didn't discuss it in a negative context
@@TheMusbatShow You did consider it as one of the weaknesses of the film. The point is, it is one of the strongest aspects of the film. The target audience has no problem understanding what’s being said on screen. You called the film linear and simple, and I know in a non- negative way, but it’s the simplicity and innocence of the film that has people falling in love with it. In the times of shitfest like Pathan, Jawaan, Heeramandi, etc., this film is a much needed breath of fresh air. And it’s not just my opinion, ask anyone here and they’ll tell you the same thing.
@@xenarocs watch again. We did not
Kahani jis illaqay main set hogi zabaan tou wahin ki istemaal hogi chahay koi b ho
@@TheMusbatShow that’s what I’m saying
Recommendation- Madgaon Express
Hey , about language its not hindi nor urdu , its mix of bhojpuri and bundelkhandi of central india
The dielect and language is beautiful ❤️
And the audience which watches Asur series don't watch Pakistani turki drama .
Only north indian muslim who has less income and backward with their thinking . Large urdu speaking population of north india muslim watches Pakistani dramas .
Urdu is not from Pakistan ita from delhi and u.p .
Pakistani culture is arabi and turki thats why you feel alienation.
Bandar kya jane adraq ka swaad. Sabke liye nahi hoti ye chiz.
First time 8k views within 24 hours. Congrats u guys, ali ab smaj jao views ki cheez py aty hin
Accha bolte ho aap log aap panchayat web series par bhi analysis karo
I eagerly wait for your reviews of Indian content.
Movie was simply beautiful....your review was good too...
According to Divergence Theory in linguistics, the birthplace of the language can be identified by the multiplicity of accents of that language spoken there, explaining the presence of numerous accents of Urdu spoken in Indopk, and the variance of accents in places like Lahore.
❤❤❤ Nice ❤❤❤
Musbat ❤🎉
Kana Yaari was perhaps the first balochi pop song and was the prime example of new tunes
100/100 review! Zabardast
Like | Share | Subscribe