Ahhhh….trans women are, and are not the same as other cisgender women, just like all cisgendered women are and are not the same as other women. Women bare similarities, and differences, amongst each other.
You asked us for help to help the community…there is a young trans woman in London who has just kicked off her clothing design startup and sold out the initial inventory in just a few hours. She’s currently working on putting together a new order to her manufacturing partner as well as working on new designs. I don’t know if she’s ready for an article (or anything) as she is also struggling with major trauma from ending a VERY public relationship and yet I think that something positive would benefit her at the same time drawing public attention to positivity in our community. Everyone loves an underdog story,right? I thought that as one of our reps to GLAAD you might be interested.
its so stupid to be like "i'm exposing how gullible they are" - like dude, have you ever considered that other people just really don't care enough to try and dissect another person's identity and just want to show them respect in their interactions instead??
While I was pretty sure he's trolling, I saw him being ridiculed by the content creators that regularly mock "cringe" trans people and didn't want to be a part of that group.
@@FoxGameCZ honestly! Someone tells me something about themselves usually my response is "okay cool (shares fact about myself in response)" not "thaaat sounds suspicious" unless it really is suspicious
Didn't prove anything at all. Just showed everyone how to waste 5 months of your life was all he did. No hormones, no surgeries, no IPL/laser/electrolysis not even a razer to his body hair lmao nothing but lipstick and clothes. Sad he spent 5 months copying us and didn't even learn anything about what being trans is. How do you do that lol.
Fr pretending to be happier and living your best life and getting surprised when people are supportive is wild. He wasn’t hurting anybody it was a productive and happy life.
Yes he did actually. That anybody can be an infiltrator in the 🏳️⚧️ community and yes destroy what trans of the past has worked for with our rights. Im in the beginning of Samantha video.
I guess he’s trying to prove we didn’t know he was lying but like… okay? So he lied about being someone else and pretended to be happy, and then think it’s a dunk cos people were nice to him? Like, I think his point is that any man could do this and be accepted as a woman but like… no, not really, actual trans women are already not accepted. What undue privileges did he get from doing this? He literally describes experiencing bigotry too, so like… You pretended to be a gender minority and received the “privilege” of being accosted in a bathroom and getting some supportive comments? Even the false narrative doesn’t show anything concerning 😂
Literally, thank you so much. Like I love when they want to point their ,,stupidity" which is just kindness and then laugh at it like dude when was the last time someone told you they love you😂
well not necessarily. Obviously, voice does not determine what someone's gender is. However we can acknowledge that men and women are typically associated with high/low voices. So this comment doesn't make any sense to me because how would he be pretending to be a man if his voice was light? Men typically have deeper voices. I pointed this out in my og comment because I found it funny that despite all the pretending he was doing (which we all knew was bs) his voice was actually true to himself.
Tbh I believe this is exactly what these type of ppl want when they do sh*t like this. Trans lives need to be protected ASAP. As a trans man who struggles with depression, I'm so deeply sorry for your loss
As someone who detransitioned before(I've been back on hormones and out as myself for a while now dw), there's a decent chance it's this. Don't get me wrong, he was definitely fishing for attention, but I think he got scared about actually having to live this way, and even moreso, scared of how much he wished he could
As a trans woman who doesn't really pass that well this really hurts. It's not our fault we can't afford to pass. If i could i would love to pass perfectly well but i can't. This is just cruel and it's fuel on the fire of transphobia that is already a raging wildfire.
I looked at your videos. Not only are you gorgeous, you are way prettier than this bio female, full stop. I dont know if that offends you or compliments you, but take it for what its worth. You definitely strike me as a girly girl.
You are so pretty!! Womans are all pretty and we dont need cosmetic work to look our best!! I know it must be hard for you but remember that no woman are the same and we are all pretty! ❤
The reason people took him at face value is because it’s become dangerous to come out, especially as trans again. People have been fired, kicked out of families, homeless, broken up with and even d!ed because of it. We need community and support. It takes so much courage to come out! Why risk any of that, if it wasn’t true???
To answer your question: A terminal lack of talent, skill, or interesting qualities to get attention or success from, making him have to rely on the lowest of the low bait possible (a "shocking" coming out story that wasn't real) to get into any headlines again.
Because of horrible people like the big right wing influencers and the way them and conservatives push anything to make trans people and LGBTQA people in general look either not real, predators, or victims of SA as kids. They literally hate trans people so much they risk their lives. I dont know what he thinks he proved anyway literally the video I watched before this was a woman who faked cancer for 4 years. That doesn't mean all cancer is fake. It means a scum bag lied. I could wake up tomorrow and claim any thing I wanted unless it undeniable I was lying most people aren't going to demand proof and you can't "prove" your trans anyway, its not a medical condition like the other woman faked but I was just using that as an example that just because one person lies about something they are or an illness or disablity doesn't mean every single person is. Thousands of people a year try to fake disablity to get a check, doesn't mean millions aren't legit disabled. They think they're sooooooo smart but all they proved is hes an idiot and most people don't ask a load of personal questions when you tell them something very personal like being LGBTQA, having a loved one die, getting a tragic illness ect
As a cis-man, we don't claim him. The only thing he exposed and proved is that he's just a lowbrow troll and a wannabe grifter. As for Halloween, I dress like it's 'Halloween' everyday so I'll be dressing as my regular self and watching some Horror movies.
I mean, idk if he really is 1 of y'all. It's kinda weird that he "pretended" to be trans for 6 months to own the libs. Is it really a joke or a cry for help?
Yeah this shit gave me PTSD. My ex boyfriend and I at first had like an amazing relationship but then he broke up with me after a year he just ghosted me over text one day and locked me out of the apartment I was living in with him and had all my stuff on the front porch. Later on I found out from his friend he only dated me so he could "See what it was like" and he told him "It felt gay" so he instead of talking to me and having a conversation ghosted me and wouldn't talk to me on anything. Then he went and bashed on me on instagram because I "Led him on that I wasn't trans" we literally met on Grindr and he knew I was trans from the start. He then went on this whole thing about how all trans women should die or get mental help because we are sick. After telling me he was left leaning in his family. That shit traumatized me and I haven't dated since 😊🫶🏻👍🏻
I’m tired of people using groups of individuals as a “SOCIAL EXPERIMENT" from this “Josh” individual; and going all the way back to earlier this year with Nikocado Avocado, THEY NEED TO STOP IT!!!
I'm a cis woman that doesn't wear make up, I don't wear dresses, my feet are big, so I wear mens sneakers...so according to this guys tiktoks I am a trans man now? 😂😂😂 He is ridiculous. Totally missed the point of gender identity and doesn't understand the difference between gender expression. If someone wants to dress as the traditional definition of the opposite gender that doesn't make them Trans. Being Trans is what makes them trans. His ignorance is embarrassing.
Jokes on you. Maybe don’t believe every person who claims they are trans and ask yourself, are they doing it for money, fame, or more commonly attention? Honestly the solution is to gate keep being trans.
I always love your videos, Samantha. Transgender people are completely valid. You are a valid, beautiful woman. The world needs more open-minded and open hearted women like you.
@@ねこ男の子 a trans man is still a type of man though. A Trans woman is a type of woman. I think the only reason there’d be an issue with referring to a trans woman as just a woman is if you are assuming that woman automatically means cis.
@@ねこ男の子 a trans man is still a type of man though, just like a cis man is a type of man, or a gay man, tall man, strong man. They're all just adjectives to describe the type of man you are or someone else is.
@luvley-f3n he literally did it for attention and cus he's closeted vro he's still parading around in dresses despite it being a "stunt" face ot he's just a closeted crossdresser lol 😂
I know it's literally wild like some people can't take rejection. I get being upset about a break up, but pretending to be trans for clicks over it? That's is too far.
I get trans women and trans people in general... come in all shapes and sizes but this was the most low effort and the stupidest atempt to be provocative... don't know what pisses me the most off... his atempt at ridicule or the lack off effort... he had 5 months to actually perfect his ''ruse''... instead we got this patetich excuse. Good video Samantha... slay
It is actually problematic to use the word autogynephylia as if it is an actual fetish. It legitimizes the concept as an actual paraphilia that was later attributed to transfeminine folk, and not as it actually is: A term invented to describe the transgender condition as a paraphilia. The term itself should not be used, as the term doesn't exist in the land of ideas where it just describes a fetish of imagining oneself as a women. It is a description of trans women as male fetishists, and it has always been used that way. Even if some people have a fetish of viewing themselves as women, that would not be autogynephilia, as autogynephilia is a failed description of the trans woman, not a fetish.
Yeah for a lot of the people who have a fetish of viewing themselves as women, honestly it's not really genuine. It's mostly like a really specific humiliation kink. And then the way the word was coined and defined doesn't really work. They're kind of the opposite of attracted to themselves as women. They're attracted to being a target for misogyny and emasculation and ridicule. If they don't look attractive as women, that's better for them. That gets them going more. The hurt is more so the masochism can deepen. If a person isn't into it for the humiliation angle, honestly they're probably actually a repressed trans person and this is their shadow escaping.
There have been follow up studies done and they found out that if autogynophelia were a fetish, it's one that most women, trans _and cis_ have! "I feel turned on when I feel like I look attractive and desirable!" Well duh!?! Welcome to being human. Men have it too. Are we going to call it autoandrophelia? The demonization of normal human behavior when you attach it to a trans person is maddening.
Samantha, you are literally advocating for human rights by advocating for trans rights!! thank you for making these videos because its helping us grow and advance as a people! trans rights are good for everyone!! allow people more room to be themselves!!
"any biological man putting on makeup is pulling a stunt" is a fun line to listen to while I do my makeup before work lmao Call me "Stunt Double", cause I'm putting mascara on BOTH eyes~ (also, I'm not taking criticism from a guy who thinks a woman is "someone born with a uterus who wears lipstick every day", that's a TINY group of people, what about... all the other women?)
I live in Chicago and know Monica Beverly Hillz like… an acquaintance I see out once in awhile. I never felt like it was my business to ask her about this like before Josh revealed it was all a stunt but I heard some rumors at the time that he was faking it all and he had like come out to her as trans or something and then had some sort of panic attack leading to all of the fake death/disappearance stories
Which ones? Because certain people are bothered by certain T people. And the other certain people are bothered by the other certain T people. This happens to every group. Some T people are bothered by other T people.
@@SSGLGamesVlogsThis is useless, referring to a queer group of people as “which ones?” only reinforces that straight people see queer people as a hierarchy ranked upon pretty privilege, status and how in line they are with their societal constructs/beliefs and value non-conforming queer people as the lowest, which extremely sadly is black trans youth. Maybe you should stick to your star wars and planes, the grown ups are talking xo.
@@SSGLGamesVlogsGeneralization is something people do who hate a certain group of people. Like this guy hating all trans people just because they're trans
Expressing femme doesn't make you trans anyone can dress feminine and have make up having a gender identity that diverges from the one you were assigned at birth does glad to see that person got to experience gender expression different from those reinforced by the gender binary and patriarchy haha that just goes to show it's always good to explore and experiment with new aesthetics
Can you do a video about Richard O'Brien? He wrote the Rocky Horror Show. He's nonbinary, and a few years ago he said in an interview that "trans women can never be natural women." Was that internalized transphobia or something else? I'm a cis woman and his words kinda devastated me because I never imagined he'd say something like that. He was one of the reasons I became a supporter of the trans community, so that remark disappointed me.
(Don't know enough about Richard O'Brien, just commenting my thoughts.) I think it depends on the context. It's at best very poorly worded and misinformed, and at worst malicious. If he meant "natural woman" as in "cis woman," then it's technically true in the sense that trans women will never be cis. If he meant it in the sense of "trans women aren't 'real women,'" then yeah, that's transphobic on his part. But trans women *are* natural women (they wouldn't be transitioning if they didn't feel the need to be who they naturally are). Just because a trans woman isn't cis doesn't mean she's not a natural woman. (Enby here) 💜
no it wasn't really that people are just coming out as a women and look like a whole man and disrespected women.The whole ponit is that most people who are trans are just putting on outfits and calling them a women.People were not supposed accepted this its outrageous and disgusting how anyone can be called a women by putting on a outfit and some unprofessional makeup and most people accepted.This whole trans community is messed up i use to accept it but not anymore for disrespecting me.
@@shadesofcallum thats what u take out of my comment i made stop ignoring my facts that's all u people do ignore and ignore. and when i say u people don't act like u don't know look at ur pfp.
@ what the hell does my cartoon self portrait have to do with any of this?? what you said was basically that people call themselves trans but don’t pass and that’s apparently a problem. last i checked you weren’t the gender police so why do you care
I am not at all surprised. I had a feeling he was a chaser or closeted because it’s such a bizarre thing to do as “a social experiment.” Why else would it even occur to someone to do this “experiment.” Like that, anyways. I could see someone cis trying to see what the experience of living as a trans person was like just out of true curiosity, but not someone like this. I really wonder what they convinced themselves was going on at the beginning, and why it lasted 5 months specifically. Not 6 months? 5 months is such a random amount of time in a 12 month calendar system. I just feel so sad for people like that. I’d love to get the tea on that breakup directly from his ex! But she shouldn’t have to share anything unless she’d enjoy doing it. Why are bigots always so blatantly pathetic?! I don’t want to have to empathize at these hatemongers. At least they were such a clown and so nasty that there’s plenty to laugh and mock as well. But I just can’t help feeling sad for people like that. :/
Right? I remember this transphobe once on twitter had made a thread of videos of him dressing in women’s underwear in women’s section in attempt to make commentary on invasions of women’s spaces , like bro YOU are the one invading women’s spaces acting like a nut walking wearing a matching set over your clothes and ranting about trans women like what are you really doing
I think he probably wanted to do the “conservative grift” but also didn’t want the conservatives to see his dating history so if someone looked up “*his name* transgender” they’d be inundated with headlines and TH-cam videos about this and not his ex
Omg, this may very well be it! It's like when Taylor Swift started going to New York Jets games when people were criticizing her for her private jet use, so you would get "Taylor Swift at Jets game" results whenever you Googled "Taylor Swift jet" 😋😋
this is insane hahaha. Him putting on lipstic, a 5 dollar wig, and telling made-up stories claiming that's what it means to be trans. I'd be like me dressing in military uniform and claiming that's what it is being in the actual military
I mean I personally feel I was born a female but not a cis one 😂 but like I’ve always been a woman, I was just socialised forced into a puberty that changed me in ways I never wanted.
I think he tried to prove that, even without doing anything (except for a little bit of make up) if he just identifies as trans, the community would accept him. If he got accepted by the community, then i think his "social experiment" was successful.
Just... faking your death and doing a social experiment after your trans ex broke up with you needs to be like a movie plot or something. That's so wild
12:25 dude i rarely wear a dress and never wear makeup and most people think i'm a cis woman. i mean, I always look a bit sick and unattractive, but that's just the depressions.
For Halloween I have the house all to myself, so this year I’m being myself 😊 ❤️ I’ve always found, especially at uni/college, it’s kinda socially acceptable for guys to cross dress or wear a feminine outfit at Halloween. So, if u feel up to it don’t be afraid to be yourself. If u have male friends who will commit to the idea with you, it can make you feel more confident too. Even if people just think it’s a Halloween outfit, you will know what you’re doing and it can feel like a small personal step in your transition. If you’re unsure too it can be a helpful but less accurate experience of how it feels to wear clothing in public that aligns with your gender identity.
Wild take. The angry cis males that are losing it because most men never were taught/allowed to have feelings/like what they want clothing/hobby wise.(not condoning the shiteheads either way) and using their internal turmoil to attack what they fear is something "wrong" based on so many old ass ways. These boys need to learrrrn. I'm slowly fighting through it with sooo many family members that I can. oi. Love yah
Samantha! I AM SO RELIEVED to see youre doing well and still making amazing content!❤️ I heard from a mutual friend that your synthetic vagina was septic and rotting out of your body and it smelled so bad you couldnt leave the house for fear of offending others with the rotting flesh smell. Wishing you well and a fast recovery my friend!🥰 keep making great content girly!
As a trans woman who does wear a wig (but not makeup), I appreciate your words about our validity and our truth being internal. I love your videos and I appreciate you (and I love your hair) ❤
Last Halloween I was discharged after nearly dying , so this Halloween I'm celebrating 1 year of not dying 😂❤ and I moved into this flat in January after being homeless so i am also celebrating it being my first Halloween in my new home. However I was planning on dressing up as a "boy version" of mona the vampire so my cat could go as Fang again this year but sadly my moglet had to be put to sleep recently so I now don't have any idea what I'm going to be.... so I just got a mask and some sweets to give out and hope it's enough to just hand out sweets to local kids and watch hocus pocus (I watch it every Halloween) ❤
@@5-Volt oh I actually didn't know that. It's just that alot of transphobes and gender critical use that against trans people as if they are a monolith. My sincere apologies I was not aware.
@@prod.bykiddthe initial "study " didn't include transgender women and didn't have a control group. In follow up studies that were conducted by more ethical scientists using better procedures. Cisgender women were as likely to be diagnosed with AGP as transgender women. So AGP exists, but isn't proof of some pathology, it is just the R reality for some women.
@@prod.bykidd Most people on both the GC side & the TRA side misunderstand what AGP actually is. It's not a fetish. Aspects of it can be, but it's not one in & of itself.
This is probably the wrong takeaway from this video but "The Rock" would look great as a woman and would absolutely slay, I have zero doubts about that.
And isn't that the same guy who interviewed him a few months ago, trying to get him to admit it was a grift and claimed to know the whole thing was a lie? I'm POSITIVE it is
“I just think everyone’s trying to get something for free these days” literally expecting the man to and then to say this is so contradicting. Comments like this lead me to believe that they’re not being serious.
The Lux Perspective podcast drops this Thursday 🎉❤
Ahhhh….trans women are, and are not the same as other cisgender women, just like all cisgendered women are and are not the same as other women. Women bare similarities, and differences, amongst each other.
Name finally revealed!
You asked us for help to help the community…there is a young trans woman in London who has just kicked off her clothing design startup and sold out the initial inventory in just a few hours. She’s currently working on putting together a new order to her manufacturing partner as well as working on new designs. I don’t know if she’s ready for an article (or anything) as she is also struggling with major trauma from ending a VERY public relationship and yet I think that something positive would benefit her at the same time drawing public attention to positivity in our community. Everyone loves an underdog story,right? I thought that as one of our reps to GLAAD you might be interested.
💚💙❤️💜💛🧡
You are merriage material! 🥰😍😘
its so stupid to be like "i'm exposing how gullible they are" - like dude, have you ever considered that other people just really don't care enough to try and dissect another person's identity and just want to show them respect in their interactions instead??
While I was pretty sure he's trolling, I saw him being ridiculed by the content creators that regularly mock "cringe" trans people and didn't want to be a part of that group.
maybe because we don't go out there to try investigate who is "real transgender" and just let people be themselves
@@FoxGameCZ honestly! Someone tells me something about themselves usually my response is "okay cool (shares fact about myself in response)" not "thaaat sounds suspicious" unless it really is suspicious
Yeah he just proved we don’t really care how folks identify… like yeah, thats what we’ve been saying!
Frrr like you didn’t “trick” anyone we just have better shit to do💀
Faking being trans then being surprised when people accept you is wild. He DID NOT prove anything.
Didn't prove anything at all. Just showed everyone how to waste 5 months of your life was all he did. No hormones, no surgeries, no IPL/laser/electrolysis not even a razer to his body hair lmao nothing but lipstick and clothes. Sad he spent 5 months copying us and didn't even learn anything about what being trans is. How do you do that lol.
Fr pretending to be happier and living your best life and getting surprised when people are supportive is wild. He wasn’t hurting anybody it was a productive and happy life.
Yes he did actually. That anybody can be an infiltrator in the 🏳️⚧️ community and yes destroy what trans of the past has worked for with our rights.
Im in the beginning of Samantha video.
I guess he’s trying to prove we didn’t know he was lying but like… okay? So he lied about being someone else and pretended to be happy, and then think it’s a dunk cos people were nice to him? Like, I think his point is that any man could do this and be accepted as a woman but like… no, not really, actual trans women are already not accepted. What undue privileges did he get from doing this? He literally describes experiencing bigotry too, so like… You pretended to be a gender minority and received the “privilege” of being accosted in a bathroom and getting some supportive comments? Even the false narrative doesn’t show anything concerning 😂
Literally, thank you so much. Like I love when they want to point their ,,stupidity" which is just kindness and then laugh at it like dude when was the last time someone told you they love you😂
I really thought he was faking a voice.. then when he 'revealed' that is was a 'social experiment' and the voice stayed💀
Lmao so true
ngl I just heard a similar voice to JP and was like "Ok, well that's not an attempt."
And by his logic, isn't he pretending to be a man because his voice is light?
🤭
well not necessarily. Obviously, voice does not determine what someone's gender is. However we can acknowledge that men and women are typically associated with high/low voices. So this comment doesn't make any sense to me because how would he be pretending to be a man if his voice was light? Men typically have deeper voices. I pointed this out in my og comment because I found it funny that despite all the pretending he was doing (which we all knew was bs) his voice was actually true to himself.
So he took advantage of people's kindness and called them stupid. Who's the bad guy again?
Sounds like Nikocado
This proves that any perv can have access to female spaces by just putting on some make up. But when women point it out they are called terf
Nope. Just exposing foolishness.
@@bellejour559“kindness = foolishness“ to you?
Thank you !! I'm so sick of ANY celeb taking advantage 🙄 Doneeeee
My trans cousin took her own life. I don't wish that on anyone. I'd rather be gullible than hurt someone.
I sorry that happened ❤
Tbh I believe this is exactly what these type of ppl want when they do sh*t like this. Trans lives need to be protected ASAP. As a trans man who struggles with depression, I'm so deeply sorry for your loss
I'm so sorry for your loss.
As a doll myself, I think they were into it, got scared, and decided to call it a "social experiment" for clout. LOL
strong autogynephilia vibes from him
same maybe he's a chaser or maybe he is a repressor and actually trans himself 😂
I get the same vibes. He still talks in his "girl" voice lol
@Necrophyllis. 😂😂
As someone who detransitioned before(I've been back on hormones and out as myself for a while now dw), there's a decent chance it's this. Don't get me wrong, he was definitely fishing for attention, but I think he got scared about actually having to live this way, and even moreso, scared of how much he wished he could
The trans chaser to trans hater pipeline is…not a pipeline. It’s a circle. It’s a big ol circle. It’s a damn circular flow chart, okaaaaaay.
As a trans woman who doesn't really pass that well this really hurts. It's not our fault we can't afford to pass. If i could i would love to pass perfectly well but i can't. This is just cruel and it's fuel on the fire of transphobia that is already a raging wildfire.
I looked at your videos. Not only are you gorgeous, you are way prettier than this bio female, full stop. I dont know if that offends you or compliments you, but take it for what its worth. You definitely strike me as a girly girl.
You are so pretty!! Womans are all pretty and we dont need cosmetic work to look our best!! I know it must be hard for you but remember that no woman are the same and we are all pretty! ❤
damn this celeb rly caught leftists red-handed at being kind and accepting
He did this every single day in his personal life for FIVE months? That is just weird.
FR
Same, I couldn’t pretend to do that just for a social experiment. I feel like some part of him enjoyed it
I feel like he did it only when posting.
@@SilverQuartz13yeah but he posted nearly every day, and was out in public a lot when he posted
The reason people took him at face value is because it’s become dangerous to come out, especially as trans again. People have been fired, kicked out of families, homeless, broken up with and even d!ed because of it. We need community and support. It takes so much courage to come out! Why risk any of that, if it wasn’t true???
To answer your question: A terminal lack of talent, skill, or interesting qualities to get attention or success from, making him have to rely on the lowest of the low bait possible (a "shocking" coming out story that wasn't real) to get into any headlines again.
Because of horrible people like the big right wing influencers and the way them and conservatives push anything to make trans people and LGBTQA people in general look either not real, predators, or victims of SA as kids. They literally hate trans people so much they risk their lives. I dont know what he thinks he proved anyway literally the video I watched before this was a woman who faked cancer for 4 years. That doesn't mean all cancer is fake. It means a scum bag lied. I could wake up tomorrow and claim any thing I wanted unless it undeniable I was lying most people aren't going to demand proof and you can't "prove" your trans anyway, its not a medical condition like the other woman faked but I was just using that as an example that just because one person lies about something they are or an illness or disablity doesn't mean every single person is. Thousands of people a year try to fake disablity to get a check, doesn't mean millions aren't legit disabled. They think they're sooooooo smart but all they proved is hes an idiot and most people don't ask a load of personal questions when you tell them something very personal like being LGBTQA, having a loved one die, getting a tragic illness ect
Also, there were definitely people who were sus from the beginning.
As a cis-man, we don't claim him. The only thing he exposed and proved is that he's just a lowbrow troll and a wannabe grifter. As for Halloween, I dress like it's 'Halloween' everyday so I'll be dressing as my regular self and watching some Horror movies.
I mean, idk if he really is 1 of y'all. It's kinda weird that he "pretended" to be trans for 6 months to own the libs. Is it really a joke or a cry for help?
To say makeup is "womenface" is to say makeup is an intrinsic aspect of being a women. Just as blackness is intrinsic in being black.
Yeah that tripped me up like trans women will have "womenface" without makeup like it's just their face wdym ??
Seriously! This is driving me nuts
Are you stupid? 💀💀
I am a woman and I rarely wear makeup. Thank you for your point 😊
So true
Being trans isn't a choice, people don't choose to be in the wrong body
He did choose to be in the wrong body because he was born a man trying to cosplay a women
My.
Mom thinks it's just people not accepting themselves for who they are
Right! The only choice they have is to either actively transition or live with their gender dysphoria untreated.
Fr! That’s how I understood it when I learnt about trans people online as a kid like how do grown adults not understand something so simple
@@namjoonie936cause people are dumb and ignorant and you should just accept it and ignore it
Yeah this shit gave me PTSD. My ex boyfriend and I at first had like an amazing relationship but then he broke up with me after a year he just ghosted me over text one day and locked me out of the apartment I was living in with him and had all my stuff on the front porch. Later on I found out from his friend he only dated me so he could "See what it was like" and he told him "It felt gay" so he instead of talking to me and having a conversation ghosted me and wouldn't talk to me on anything. Then he went and bashed on me on instagram because I "Led him on that I wasn't trans" we literally met on Grindr and he knew I was trans from the start. He then went on this whole thing about how all trans women should die or get mental help because we are sick. After telling me he was left leaning in his family. That shit traumatized me and I haven't dated since 😊🫶🏻👍🏻
Thats horrible. I hope you find happiness. 🙂
So sorry that happened to you
@@Lonesomefate Thank u I hope so
That's awful. I'm so sorry. I hope you're doing well
😢I am sad for you after a year living together for a year why break up.
As you said no secrets 😢
I’m tired of people using groups of individuals as a “SOCIAL EXPERIMENT" from this “Josh” individual; and going all the way back to earlier this year with Nikocado Avocado, THEY NEED TO STOP IT!!!
I'm a cis woman that doesn't wear make up, I don't wear dresses, my feet are big, so I wear mens sneakers...so according to this guys tiktoks I am a trans man now? 😂😂😂 He is ridiculous. Totally missed the point of gender identity and doesn't understand the difference between gender expression. If someone wants to dress as the traditional definition of the opposite gender that doesn't make them Trans. Being Trans is what makes them trans. His ignorance is embarrassing.
Exactly, it's stupid.
I swear bigots always say, makeup and clothes don't change your gender but turn around and act like makeup and clothes is all there is to gender. 😂
@Necrophyllis. Lol exactly!
Me and my boyfriend are going as James and Jessie from Pokemon I just finished sewing the costumes 😸
that's awesome
@ineophobe thanks 😸
I love this!!! Iconic really
Girl I remember this Monica BH drama from back in the day omg , every soul could clock
im so upset that i defended this dude against transphobes online. like why lie bruh
Jokes on you. Maybe don’t believe every person who claims they are trans and ask yourself, are they doing it for money, fame, or more commonly attention?
Honestly the solution is to gate keep being trans.
It’s always worth defending against bigotry - worst case it’s still teaching by example and making the world better.
@@NeonJ1 That is the worst idea i've ever heard, because how would you prove that in cases other than this one where he admitted to it?
@ imagine this guy not admitting it, and people still believed him. Then ppl calling him out as being sus were getting cancelled because of it
Regardless of whether some idiot is faking. Calling out bigotry is never a bad action
I always love your videos, Samantha. Transgender people are completely valid. You are a valid, beautiful woman. The world needs more open-minded and open hearted women like you.
Trans woman. That is what she is and that is valid and beautiful. Samantha knows and thats okay. I'm a trans man. Not a man.
Idk why this generation deems trans as not enough. When we are enough. We're not the same and it's okay. This narrative just hurts us.
@@ねこ男の子 a trans man is still a type of man though. A Trans woman is a type of woman. I think the only reason there’d be an issue with referring to a trans woman as just a woman is if you are assuming that woman automatically means cis.
@@ねこ男の子 a trans man is still a type of man though, just like a cis man is a type of man, or a gay man, tall man, strong man. They're all just adjectives to describe the type of man you are or someone else is.
@@ねこ男の子 not the blair white ideology
Faking being trans cus he got dumped that's just sad I agree he needs helps
Love you Samantha x
thats not the reason he did that its disgusting u even think that
@luvley-f3n he literally did it for attention and cus he's closeted vro he's still parading around in dresses despite it being a "stunt" face ot he's just a closeted crossdresser lol 😂
I know it's literally wild like some people can't take rejection. I get being upset about a break up, but pretending to be trans for clicks over it? That's is too far.
I get trans women and trans people in general... come in all shapes and sizes but this was the most low effort and the stupidest atempt to be provocative... don't know what pisses me the most off... his atempt at ridicule or the lack off effort... he had 5 months to actually perfect his ''ruse''... instead we got this patetich excuse. Good video Samantha... slay
Him being with Monica Beverly Hills was NOT what I expected I’m gagggggedddd
poor monica 😭😭
I just realize how stunning her cheekbones look with that highlighter i love it, If anyone knows what highlighter she wears please spill!!!
It is actually problematic to use the word autogynephylia as if it is an actual fetish.
It legitimizes the concept as an actual paraphilia that was later attributed to transfeminine folk, and not as it actually is: A term invented to describe the transgender condition as a paraphilia.
The term itself should not be used, as the term doesn't exist in the land of ideas where it just describes a fetish of imagining oneself as a women. It is a description of trans women as male fetishists, and it has always been used that way.
Even if some people have a fetish of viewing themselves as women, that would not be autogynephilia, as autogynephilia is a failed description of the trans woman, not a fetish.
Thank you! That irked me too
Name a better word to use then.
Yeah for a lot of the people who have a fetish of viewing themselves as women, honestly it's not really genuine. It's mostly like a really specific humiliation kink. And then the way the word was coined and defined doesn't really work. They're kind of the opposite of attracted to themselves as women. They're attracted to being a target for misogyny and emasculation and ridicule. If they don't look attractive as women, that's better for them. That gets them going more. The hurt is more so the masochism can deepen.
If a person isn't into it for the humiliation angle, honestly they're probably actually a repressed trans person and this is their shadow escaping.
Sissy/crossdressing fetsh makes more sense to describe men like this, better terms to use, agree with your comment
There have been follow up studies done and they found out that if autogynophelia were a fetish, it's one that most women, trans _and cis_ have! "I feel turned on when I feel like I look attractive and desirable!" Well duh!?! Welcome to being human. Men have it too. Are we going to call it autoandrophelia?
The demonization of normal human behavior when you attach it to a trans person is maddening.
the “GOOFY” in the call-out TikTok is so satisfying 😩
I said this on Kat Blaque's video, "the cons want to be oppressed so bad".
Samantha, you are literally advocating for human rights by advocating for trans rights!! thank you for making these videos because its helping us grow and advance as a people! trans rights are good for everyone!! allow people more room to be themselves!!
I’m being the riddler from Batman Arkham knight for Halloween :3
"any biological man putting on makeup is pulling a stunt" is a fun line to listen to while I do my makeup before work lmao
Call me "Stunt Double", cause I'm putting mascara on BOTH eyes~
(also, I'm not taking criticism from a guy who thinks a woman is "someone born with a uterus who wears lipstick every day", that's a TINY group of people, what about... all the other women?)
I live in Chicago and know Monica Beverly Hillz like… an acquaintance I see out once in awhile. I never felt like it was my business to ask her about this like before Josh revealed it was all a stunt but I heard some rumors at the time that he was faking it all and he had like come out to her as trans or something and then had some sort of panic attack leading to all of the fake death/disappearance stories
Unsurprisingly, JK Rowling praised this guy on Twitter
YUCK.
I don't see why he is so bothered by trans people.
Which ones? Because certain people are bothered by certain T people. And the other certain people are bothered by the other certain T people.
This happens to every group. Some T people are bothered by other T people.
@@SSGLGamesVlogs But none of that was an explanation. It was just stating that bigotry exists. Lol.
@@thequeenofnod7338 Generalization is a problem.
@@SSGLGamesVlogsThis is useless, referring to a queer group of people as “which ones?” only reinforces that straight people see queer people as a hierarchy ranked upon pretty privilege, status and how in line they are with their societal constructs/beliefs and value non-conforming queer people as the lowest, which extremely sadly is black trans youth. Maybe you should stick to your star wars and planes, the grown ups are talking xo.
@@SSGLGamesVlogsGeneralization is something people do who hate a certain group of people. Like this guy hating all trans people just because they're trans
samantha I love ur videos, but come on, calling him a “celeb” is more than a stretch 😭😭😭
A "public figure" would've been more appropriate lmao
Here in Brazil we call people like him, random ex-participants of reality shows, "sub-celebs" 😅
@@Goingby20s yes 😂 subcelebridade
you know the saying ”the prettiest girls dress up as the weirdest things on halloween”, I feel like samantha would dress up as like idk a cicada
Expressing femme doesn't make you trans anyone can dress feminine and have make up having a gender identity that diverges from the one you were assigned at birth does glad to see that person got to experience gender expression different from those reinforced by the gender binary and patriarchy haha that just goes to show it's always good to explore and experiment with new aesthetics
We need to bring back “goofy”
Can you do a video about Richard O'Brien? He wrote the Rocky Horror Show. He's nonbinary, and a few years ago he said in an interview that "trans women can never be natural women." Was that internalized transphobia or something else? I'm a cis woman and his words kinda devastated me because I never imagined he'd say something like that. He was one of the reasons I became a supporter of the trans community, so that remark disappointed me.
(Don't know enough about Richard O'Brien, just commenting my thoughts.) I think it depends on the context. It's at best very poorly worded and misinformed, and at worst malicious.
If he meant "natural woman" as in "cis woman," then it's technically true in the sense that trans women will never be cis. If he meant it in the sense of "trans women aren't 'real women,'" then yeah, that's transphobic on his part.
But trans women *are* natural women (they wouldn't be transitioning if they didn't feel the need to be who they naturally are). Just because a trans woman isn't cis doesn't mean she's not a natural woman.
(Enby here) 💜
What does "nonbinary" even mean? Of course males can't be natural women, does it matter though?
Oof definitely some looking inward is needed for them.
I like trans women. They are not natural women. Truth doesn't have to equate hate. Blaire White will tell you in one second she is a man.
I genuinely have no idea how people are surprised Richard is a transphobe. Have they seen rocky horror?
Hi! Being a woman is more than European standards (dresses and makeup) and more than how we present ourselves to the world. Hope this helps :)
17:17 that giggle was cute lol
‘wait what? people who claim to accept others regardless of how they look ACCEPTED ME?! OUTRAGEOUS 😡’
no it wasn't really that people are just coming out as a women and look like a whole man and disrespected women.The whole ponit is that most people who are trans are just putting on outfits and calling them a women.People were not supposed accepted this its outrageous and disgusting how anyone can be called a women by putting on a outfit and some unprofessional makeup and most people accepted.This whole trans community is messed up i use to accept it but not anymore for disrespecting me.
@ im sorry you take the existence non-passing trans people as a personal attack against you??? and who the hell is ‘most people who are trans’
@@shadesofcallum thats what u take out of my comment i made stop ignoring my facts that's all u people do ignore and ignore. and when i say u people don't act like u don't know look at ur pfp.
@ what the hell does my cartoon self portrait have to do with any of this?? what you said was basically that people call themselves trans but don’t pass and that’s apparently a problem. last i checked you weren’t the gender police so why do you care
@@shadesofcallum keep avoiding and avoiding.
For Halloween, im going as trash, since trump thinks America is trash. 🤣🤣🤣
He was really expecting us to be mad. People I saw were just like “cool. I don’t think that this person really is trans but ok”
I am not at all surprised. I had a feeling he was a chaser or closeted because it’s such a bizarre thing to do as “a social experiment.” Why else would it even occur to someone to do this “experiment.” Like that, anyways.
I could see someone cis trying to see what the experience of living as a trans person was like just out of true curiosity, but not someone like this.
I really wonder what they convinced themselves was going on at the beginning, and why it lasted 5 months specifically. Not 6 months? 5 months is such a random amount of time in a 12 month calendar system.
I just feel so sad for people like that. I’d love to get the tea on that breakup directly from his ex! But she shouldn’t have to share anything unless she’d enjoy doing it.
Why are bigots always so blatantly pathetic?! I don’t want to have to empathize at these hatemongers. At least they were such a clown and so nasty that there’s plenty to laugh and mock as well. But I just can’t help feeling sad for people like that. :/
Right? I remember this transphobe once on twitter had made a thread of videos of him dressing in women’s underwear in women’s section in attempt to make commentary on invasions of women’s spaces , like bro YOU are the one invading women’s spaces acting like a nut walking wearing a matching set over your clothes and ranting about trans women like what are you really doing
I think he probably wanted to do the “conservative grift” but also didn’t want the conservatives to see his dating history so if someone looked up “*his name* transgender” they’d be inundated with headlines and TH-cam videos about this and not his ex
Omg, this may very well be it! It's like when Taylor Swift started going to New York Jets games when people were criticizing her for her private jet use, so you would get "Taylor Swift at Jets game" results whenever you Googled "Taylor Swift jet" 😋😋
Lol “I lied so that proves everyone is lying”
16:26 Mother, my round of applause is still going on! 👏🏼LET’S GOO!👏🏼
I'm being Leon Kennedy and my partner is being Luis Serra and my friend is being Ada Wong for Halloween!!
As a resident evil fan you guys are soo lucky my culture doesn't count halloween as a festival man 😭💖
this is insane hahaha. Him putting on lipstic, a 5 dollar wig, and telling made-up stories claiming that's what it means to be trans. I'd be like me dressing in military uniform and claiming that's what it is being in the actual military
I feel illegal being that early also happy Halloween everyone (i was on Beetlejuice themed drag show hour ago btw)
I'm being my Vampire:The Masquerade character for Halloween: a Gothic Vampire Doctor 🖤🧛♀️
that sounds amazing! love vtm 💕
omg i went as my club bouncer gangrel for Halloween too
*Chuckles in Toreador* ❤
thank you for talking about this. i love the necklace :)
Enjoyed the video!☺️ But I disagree w using the word autogynephilia at all to describe any person. It is a fake dyagnosis coined by a horrible person.
Love the straight hair look girl! I’m dressing up as Aizen from the anime Bleach 💜
He tried a Dylan type of revenue and failed thats it
Iswtg Dylan is the only trans person that gets this weird fan behavior from cons.
@@roxassora2706they hate her cuz they ain't her
Wow he dated a trans woman and faked his death after their breakup and then became so obsessed with trans women that he spent 5 months doing this…
I mean I personally feel I was born a female but not a cis one 😂 but like I’ve always been a woman, I was just socialised forced into a puberty that changed me in ways I never wanted.
Thats so gross of him. smh
I think he tried to prove that, even without doing anything (except for a little bit of make up) if he just identifies as trans, the community would accept him.
If he got accepted by the community, then i think his "social experiment" was successful.
Calling him a “celebrity” in the title was VERY generous of you cause WHO IS THIS MAN????😂😂😂
Just... faking your death and doing a social experiment after your trans ex broke up with you needs to be like a movie plot or something. That's so wild
12:25 dude i rarely wear a dress and never wear makeup and most people think i'm a cis woman. i mean, I always look a bit sick and unattractive, but that's just the depressions.
And we are the insane ones 🙄
Yeah that's way crazier than cutting off your penis.
@@rfields4137it’s not just cutting it off there’s more than that also people can do whatever they want with there body
The next time I see one of those posts on Facebook asking about celebrity crushes, I'm just going to post a link to your TH-cam channel. 🥰😍💖
Girl, it's 10 minutes in! Why are you edging us about the reveal? Lol
For Halloween I have the house all to myself, so this year I’m being myself 😊 ❤️
I’ve always found, especially at uni/college, it’s kinda socially acceptable for guys to cross dress or wear a feminine outfit at Halloween. So, if u feel up to it don’t be afraid to be yourself. If u have male friends who will commit to the idea with you, it can make you feel more confident too. Even if people just think it’s a Halloween outfit, you will know what you’re doing and it can feel like a small personal step in your transition. If you’re unsure too it can be a helpful but less accurate experience of how it feels to wear clothing in public that aligns with your gender identity.
Lol. Josh sounds like a textbook narc
Thanks so much for this. Made my day
His rise to...where he is now, LOL
Wild take. The angry cis males that are losing it because most men never were taught/allowed to have feelings/like what they want clothing/hobby wise.(not condoning the shiteheads either way) and using their internal turmoil to attack what they fear is something "wrong" based on so many old ass ways. These boys need to learrrrn. I'm slowly fighting through it with sooo many family members that I can. oi. Love yah
Samantha! I AM SO RELIEVED to see youre doing well and still making amazing content!❤️ I heard from a mutual friend that your synthetic vagina was septic and rotting out of your body and it smelled so bad you couldnt leave the house for fear of offending others with the rotting flesh smell. Wishing you well and a fast recovery my friend!🥰 keep making great content girly!
I’m being a wonderful, sparkly ghostface for Halloween. 😉✨
im ganna be moth man :333
As a trans woman who does wear a wig (but not makeup), I appreciate your words about our validity and our truth being internal. I love your videos and I appreciate you (and I love your hair) ❤
Last Halloween I was discharged after nearly dying , so this Halloween I'm celebrating 1 year of not dying 😂❤ and I moved into this flat in January after being homeless so i am also celebrating it being my first Halloween in my new home.
However I was planning on dressing up as a "boy version" of mona the vampire so my cat could go as Fang again this year but sadly my moglet had to be put to sleep recently so I now don't have any idea what I'm going to be.... so I just got a mask and some sweets to give out and hope it's enough to just hand out sweets to local kids and watch hocus pocus (I watch it every Halloween) ❤
The only person spooking me is the IRS
Halloween is the best of all! Go all the way for Halloween or Samhain in my life! BTW you are my favorite Vlogger of all!
Can you make a video how you style your hair? It’s so smooth and shiny.
I wouldn’t give any credence to the concept of agp
First ever trick or treating ended with me throwing up nonstop 🙂
That TikTok video where the girl dumped all the dirt on him is the best TikTok video I have ever seen. Journalism at its finest.
Watch Kat Blaque’s video on this same topic. It was posted 3 days ago if anyone wants more info
I don't know if AGP is actually a real thing...
It's bs.
It's in the DSM-5 so... It's considered real to psychologists & some people identify as having it as well. Is their experience not valid?
@@5-Volt oh I actually didn't know that. It's just that alot of transphobes and gender critical use that against trans people as if they are a monolith. My sincere apologies I was not aware.
@@prod.bykiddthe initial "study " didn't include transgender women and didn't have a control group. In follow up studies that were conducted by more ethical scientists using better procedures. Cisgender women were as likely to be diagnosed with AGP as transgender women. So AGP exists, but isn't proof of some pathology, it is just the R
reality for some women.
@@prod.bykidd Most people on both the GC side & the TRA side misunderstand what AGP actually is. It's not a fetish. Aspects of it can be, but it's not one in & of itself.
Just found you today and love the video. Girl you are SO PRETTY!!! Thanks for covering this insane topic. Subscribed 😊
This is probably the wrong takeaway from this video but "The Rock" would look great as a woman and would absolutely slay, I have zero doubts about that.
"And his rise to.....where he is now" AHHHHHHHHH
8:11 the smirk you gave is 👩🏾🍳💋 …
I seen him on my ig like a month ago and I knew this was a mockery. And blocked it
I challenge any Hollywood movie to have an ending as incredible as this video 😂 thanks for bringing the tea on this one
I'm going to be bowsette for Halloween this year! as a trans-lady this is my first dress!
I'm actually working on my halloween costume as I watch this! I'm going as Lloyd Garmadon from ninjago because gender euphoria is weird
And isn't that the same guy who interviewed him a few months ago, trying to get him to admit it was a grift and claimed to know the whole thing was a lie? I'm POSITIVE it is
Yikes. Thats so embarassing for him. This "expiriment" will not age well.
Babe we have all had our hearts broken at sometime, but we learn too deal with it!
“I just think everyone’s trying to get something for free these days” literally expecting the man to and then to say this is so contradicting. Comments like this lead me to believe that they’re not being serious.
I caught that right away too…”everyone trying to get something for free” while literally trying to get something for free…epic fail Josh! Lol
I think to me it'd be from traditional ideas not necessarily a contradiction
Sometimes I really miss the nail clacking. Yay!!
not me getting called out for using Neutrogina wipes ;-;
very excited for halloween candy :>
Loved the plot twist at the end. Unrelated - you’re absolutely gorgeous Samantha ❤
NOT THE DAILYWIRE "AM I RACIST" AD ON THIS VID
So unrelated but give us an asmr video!!!!!! love the nail taps in the beginning
I was going to be SCP049 but the heat and humidity lately have been atrocious