With all due respect Father, you crack me up. Your the absolute best and your work has to be sweet insense to heaven.My prayers will continue. Without your work, where would the true church be?
Thanks again Fr Cekada for all that you do for us. It's interesting that so many quoted by Salza say that he couldn't even get their beliefs right, let alone a refutation.
I wouldn't waste my time with Protestant literature On the other hand having just recieved my copy of a truly great and logical analysis of the Vatican II heretical assembly ' Work of Human Hands" a book every Catholic should own. I have found myself applauding and jumping up in down in my self imposed catacomb after reading passages in the book and repeating to myself "thats true . thats true'. I for myself have believed for years that the Holy Ghost has removed the scales from the eyes of some , in order to wake up and save the many , your book is one of his instruments . I pray that the Holy Ghost gives you a full recovery from your illness. Baruch 4:25
The conception, planning and execution of the thoroughly researched topic by video presentation... admirable! Fr. Cekada was and remains (because of video) a rock solid gift to Holy Mother Church. Please pray 3 Hail Marys for the repose of his soul ❤️
Excellent. Flawlessly logical. Unfortunately it will have little effect on most in the R&R camp who wish to rationalize their position because acceptance of the truth would cause them to make painful decisions in their life. Loss of parishioners, friends, subscribers? Sedevacantism will eventually be accepted by all true Catholics as the apostasy at the top gets so overt that even the most pertinacious R&R believer will be forced to swallow their pride and believe the truth.
@John The logical conclusion is Fr Cekada for pope. I reckon, we should, like so many other sedes, organise a conclave and, since the 'flawless logistics' of a pop piece on youtube outweigh thousands of years of revelation and 2000 years inclusive of Church authority, raise Fr Cekada to the Chair of Peter.
@@soniamartin2007 I’d have been all-for that. If such a thing had happened, perhaps people could take Rome seriously, once again. As it is, under Frank Bergoglio? Pagan dumpster fire.
@@soniamartin2007 It is my hope that all of the valid Sede bishops get together to call a conclave. We desperately need a Pope, because we are a scattered flock.
THANK GOD for the consummate research and erudite publications of Fr. Cekada - as well as Bp. Sanborn - against the errors of Modernists and Heretics in Trad clothing...
You remind me so much and even sound similar to my dear Confessor Fr. John A. Hardon, S/J who was my Confessor and Spiritual Director of my Apostolate of Heralds of Divine Love that I began with an assistant Ann in NY in 1973. I used to take my children to St. Loyola Church in NYC to go to Confessions each month for many years. He gave my daughter, Laura first Holy Communion and arranged the Confirmations for them and another dear family who were wonderful friends. We miss him so much. He said Mass like an Angel. So gentle and kind and holy was this man of God. We were very blessed to have known him. My Laura is 48 now. She was 7 when He gave her her First Holy Communion. God bless. I love the Latin Mass, but can't get to one where I live now in New Jersey and health problems as well. But I love my Faith as I am an convert from the Anglican faith at the age of 20 after 8 months of private instructions. My sister also became Catholic + So much I could relate. And the love of Our Lady is such a gift to us; to have such a wonderful Spiritual Mother - Jesus our Savior gave us everything! Even His wonderful, pure Mother Mary to be our Mother. I keep praying for the Church. I remember that vision the Pope had about satan telling the Lord Jesus...give me 100 years to destroy the Church! That was 1876. He has been busy, but the gates of hell shall not..prevail. Amen.
Saw something at novusordowatch that clued me in: we love you and are praying for you: your creativity and intelligence, gentleness and sense of humor bespeak a great deal of suffering risen above: We Love You.
I have question. Is it really Catholic to spend all one's energy on trashing the Catholic Church? That is what Mario Derksen does ( www.trueorfalsepope.com/p/sedevacantist-watch.html )
I hope to hear you soon on Francis Watch. We miss you! I continue offering my prayers and life contradictions to All Mighty God for the speeding of your revovery! God Bless You!
Great video Father, an English SSPX seminarian claimed the book was "good" I refereed him (verbally) to your video's. Amoris Latittia was what maybe 250 pages but this is 700 pages of junk (Salza & Cisco's book, not your video).
Dear Father Cekada, please pray for conversion of my family and final perseverance. I could just imagine all wonderful saints greeting you, with joy at your work defending Holy Mother Church. Except an old saint in back... When room clears, he comes up and says, Real rough arguing against tax lawyer. You snap back: please to meet you Saint Jerome. I miss you, Father Cekada
Good form Father! You made the PROPER refutation. You identified the "paper swamp" and didnt stoop to refuted 700 pages of drivel which would have given the book a facade of credibility. Well done.
Father Cekada, I love your facial expressions when you look at Bergogglio...Your expressions confirm humorously what you are saying and thinking in reference to this G.Berg. We can't miss it!
By all means pray and fast for the Holy Souls, but I seriously doubt that a rare champion of the Catholic faith, such as Fr Cekada, will be among them.
Because sedevacantism is untenable. Read what the Catholic encyclopedia says about the mark of Apostlicity. Read The Catholic Controversy by St. Francis de Sales.
Hope you get better soon! Is there any way for a sedevacantist to properly become a priest? Or are we only left with those who were previously named priests?
When was the judgment that there is no more Pope (sedevacant) was done? Who did it? How do we know sedevacant is the right position to hold? If I want to join the true Catholic Church where I should go? Thanks for the answer in advance
A heretic cannot be a member of the Catholic Church. For more information read www.traditionalmass.org/issues/ , novusordowatch.org/start-here/, novusordowatch.org/now-what/ , www.truerestoration.org/ For mass try www.traditionalmass.org/locations/ or www.ecclesia.luxvera.org/Directory-USA.html or gspav.org/missions.htm
How embarrassing for those who saw this pathetic book as a way to justify remaining in the SSPX! S&S thoroughly deserve to have this tripe pulled apart and tossed in the bin. Great work, Father! Our prayers and thoughts are with you every day. May God bless you heaps.
Have not been able to follow your limited, vaig overview of the book. I have personally known Mark piverunis for 30 plus years and have seen him twist and change truth to fit what he needs at time. I have lost all respect for him. Thanks
I own a copy of Karl Marx's "Das Kapital" (three volumes), Chairman Moa's Little Red book "The thoughts of Chairman Moa", and Hitler's "Mein Kamf" (1930s edition). The worst is Chairman Moa's. Thanks for the sence of humour. Rev Cekade RIP.
The worst is Chairman Moa's book because it is unreadable and contradictory. I have thought often that Francis is a Moaist because he too want perpetual revolution.
Some reason I never liked father jakato with the minimal amount of exposure that I had to him a few years ago but since his passing I decided to kind of go back and watch some of his videos and the more I watched the more I feel he has some of the most entertaining and educational Catholic videos on the internet may he rest in peace
This rebuttal wasn't convincing. Firstly. The fact that sedevacantists now put forward a second argument - that these popes were never popes to begin with, doesn't invalidate any criticism against the argument that these popes lost their office, especially since the question is not only of practical but also of academic concern. Have sedevacantists now conceded Salza's & Siscoe's points on that matter?
No -- for which, see the first part of my video Stuck in a Rut. But it's an "angels-on-the-head-of-a-pin" argument unrelated to our current position. And remember, you argue with the sedevacantists you HAVE rather than with the sedevacantists you WISH you had -- assuming you'd wish to have sedevacantists at all, of course! : )
@@WorkofHumanHands This maybe your argument, but I hear the CMRI argue loss of office, as well as Bishop Sanborn in an interview stated he believed John 23 lost office after he was elected, So I think it was completely fair for them to address that argument in the book . They also address the other argument (never was Pope) as well as many other arguments .
To have a pope you need more than just an election... The candidate for papacy has conditions to meet that were elaborated prior to Vatican II... and those are the followings: not be a child, not be a woman, not be a heretic, an idolater, or schismatic... he must be a practicing Catholic in his beliefs and every day life...and must have the intention of guiding the people in the Truth taught by Christ and promulgated by his apostles and Fathers of the Church... We cannot say that this is the case for Mr Bergogglio.. who was a heretic and practicing idolatry when he was archbishop in Argentine....promulgating homosexuality....cult with Jews....and with communists....This man does not hold the papacy - it's power....
Did you sedes hear that ? You no longer hold the position that these Popes lost office due to heresy. And there for Salza waists time in addressing that argument. , so just dismiss the whole book . Only thing is ...I would have to object because, , apparently the sedes never got the memo that they don’t hold that position any longer because I hear that position every time I engage in discussion with a sede . I also hear the position of cum ex , but I’m confused , because Fr Cekada stated publicly that can’t be used to support sedevacantism either . And I read an artical from bishop Sanborn were he slso states that cum ex can’t be used . So all you sedes better stop using these arguments. And John Salza better stop addressing arguments you guys apparently don’t use “any longer “.
I super-love this man. So humorous. He truly has a brilliant, light soul. I pray he rests in Glory,
Rest In Peace Fr Cekada ☀️💛 You are sorely missed
This channel is gold!!! Fr. Cekada was a truly gifted man. Had me smiling and laughing throughout.
With all due respect Father, you crack me up. Your the absolute best and your work has to be sweet insense to heaven.My prayers will continue. Without your work, where would the true church be?
Thanks again Fr Cekada for all that you do for us. It's interesting that so many quoted by Salza say that he couldn't even get their beliefs right, let alone a refutation.
I wouldn't waste my time with Protestant literature On the other hand having just recieved my copy of a truly great and logical analysis of the Vatican II heretical assembly ' Work of Human Hands" a book every Catholic should own. I have found myself applauding and jumping up in down in my self imposed catacomb after reading passages in the book and repeating to myself "thats true . thats true'. I for myself have believed for years that the Holy Ghost has removed the scales from the eyes of some , in order to wake up and save the many , your book is one of his instruments . I pray that the Holy Ghost gives you a full recovery from your illness. Baruch 4:25
Father thanks again for another excellent video. By the way, you look great with no hair. Get well soon, you're in my prayers. The Church needs you.
Thanks. A colleague suggest I get a sphinx cat to match! : )
Haha! :-D
Those cats are creepy
The conception, planning and execution of the thoroughly researched topic by video presentation... admirable! Fr. Cekada was and remains (because of video) a rock solid gift to Holy Mother Church. Please pray 3 Hail Marys for the repose of his soul ❤️
Excellent. Flawlessly logical. Unfortunately it will have little effect on most in the R&R camp who wish to rationalize their position because acceptance of the truth would cause them to make painful decisions in their life. Loss of parishioners, friends, subscribers? Sedevacantism will eventually be accepted by all true Catholics as the apostasy at the top gets so overt that even the most pertinacious R&R believer will be forced to swallow their pride and believe the truth.
John Hixson I truly hope so.
@John The logical conclusion is Fr Cekada for pope. I reckon, we should, like so many other sedes, organise a conclave and, since the 'flawless logistics' of a pop piece on youtube outweigh thousands of years of revelation and 2000 years inclusive of Church authority, raise Fr Cekada to the Chair of Peter.
@@soniamartin2007 Bishop Sanborn for Pope. Fr Cekada to run the Holy Office. :)
@@soniamartin2007 I’d have been all-for that. If such a thing had happened, perhaps people could take Rome seriously, once again. As it is, under Frank Bergoglio? Pagan dumpster fire.
@@soniamartin2007 It is my hope that all of the valid Sede bishops get together to call a conclave. We desperately need a Pope, because we are a scattered flock.
Thank you for sharing this informative video Fr. Cekada. May God rest your soul in peace.Amen.
God bless all that you do, Father!! God grant you a speedy & complete recovery!!!
THANK GOD for the consummate research and erudite publications of Fr. Cekada - as well as Bp. Sanborn - against the errors of Modernists and Heretics in Trad clothing...
'Bp Sanborn and Fr Cekada' are gnostic 'quacks', in 'trad clothing.'
You remind me so much and even sound similar to my dear Confessor Fr. John A. Hardon, S/J who was my Confessor and Spiritual Director of my Apostolate of Heralds of Divine Love that I began with an assistant Ann in NY in 1973. I used to take my children to St. Loyola Church in NYC to go to Confessions each month for many years. He gave my daughter, Laura first Holy Communion and arranged the Confirmations for them and another dear family who were wonderful friends. We miss him so much. He said Mass like an Angel. So gentle and kind and holy was this man of God. We were very blessed to have known him. My Laura is 48 now. She was 7 when He gave her her First Holy Communion. God bless. I love the Latin Mass, but can't get to one where I live now in New Jersey and health problems as well. But I love my Faith as I am an convert from the Anglican faith at the age of 20 after 8 months of private instructions. My sister also became Catholic + So much I could relate. And the love of Our Lady is such a gift to us; to have such a wonderful Spiritual Mother - Jesus our Savior gave us everything! Even His wonderful, pure Mother Mary to be our Mother. I keep praying for the Church. I remember that vision the Pope had about satan telling the Lord Jesus...give me 100 years to destroy the Church! That was 1876. He has been busy, but the gates of hell shall not..prevail. Amen.
Thanks for this video dear Fr Cekada, get well soon and may God bless you!
Saw something at novusordowatch that clued me in: we love you and are praying for you: your creativity and intelligence, gentleness and sense of humor bespeak a great deal of suffering risen above: We Love You.
I have question. Is it really Catholic to spend all one's energy on trashing the Catholic Church? That is what Mario Derksen does ( www.trueorfalsepope.com/p/sedevacantist-watch.html )
@@soniamartin2007 You don't know the difference between a bunch of heretics in sheeps' clothing and the Catholic Church? Sorry for you.
@@soniamartin2007 leave off, troll. Go commune with open heretic, Frankie B.
I've enjoyed reading Work of Human Hands. Hope all health worries disappear. God Bless.
RIP I know father Jenkins who I listen to attentively didn't care for Father Cakada style but it works for me.
Thank you Father Cekada.
Father- thank you for yet another most excellent treatise.
Great video. Bless you for posting it, Father.
Thank you very much, Father Cekada, for this important thoughts to defend the RCC.
Smiling SOOOOO big after watching this. God BLESSSSSS YOU FATHER.
I hope to hear you soon on Francis Watch. We miss you! I continue offering my prayers and life contradictions to All Mighty God for the speeding of your revovery! God Bless You!
Thanks again, we keep you in our prayers on a daily basis.
Fr. Cekada takes apart Salza and Siscoe's book: "True or False Pope"... Literally!
Great video Father, an English SSPX seminarian claimed the book was "good" I refereed him (verbally) to your video's. Amoris Latittia was what maybe 250 pages but this is 700 pages of junk (Salza & Cisco's book, not your video).
Excellent stuff as always. A modern great. Very best wishes from England.
I am an sspx faithful and you are right with regards to salza. He doesn't seem right to me.
Very good Video and refutation of the book. Will continue to pray for your recovery
Dear Father Cekada, please pray for conversion of my family and final perseverance.
I could just imagine all wonderful saints greeting you, with joy at your work defending Holy Mother Church.
Except an old saint in back... When room clears, he comes up and says, Real rough arguing against tax lawyer.
You snap back: please to meet you Saint Jerome.
I miss you, Father Cekada
Good form Father! You made the PROPER refutation. You identified the "paper swamp" and didnt stoop to refuted 700 pages of drivel which would have given the book a facade of credibility. Well done.
Well put. There are too many crazies getting too much notice for their stupidities. Catholics are better off spending their time on the holy authors.
Father Cekada, I love your facial expressions when you look at Bergogglio...Your expressions confirm humorously what you are saying and thinking in reference to this G.Berg. We can't miss it!
My goodness, I needed some laughs today. RIP father.
25:30 But guess what? We did! :D
Thank you, Rev. Anthony Cekada
Thanks, Albert!
Sedevacantist have abandoned their argument from Bellarmine's writings? Dimond used it in his debate against Cassman
I only spoke with Fr. Cekada once. Yet I miss him.
Let's pray and fast for Fr. so he will be released from purgatory. He will help the Church. His mission continues!
By all means pray and fast for the Holy Souls, but I seriously doubt that a rare champion of the Catholic faith, such as Fr Cekada, will be among them.
I am confused how sedevavantism does not cut short apostolic succession.
Because sedevacantism is untenable. Read what the Catholic encyclopedia says about the mark of Apostlicity. Read The Catholic Controversy by St. Francis de Sales.
Hope you get better soon! Is there any way for a sedevacantist to properly become a priest? Or are we only left with those who were previously named priests?
You can! There are 2 seminaries in America. CMRI's Mater Dei and Bp. Sanborn's Most Holy Trinity.
May god rest your soul Fr. Cekada.
When was the judgment that there is no more Pope (sedevacant) was done? Who did it? How do we know sedevacant is the right position to hold? If I want to join the true Catholic Church where I should go? Thanks for the answer in advance
A heretic cannot be a member of the Catholic Church. For more information read www.traditionalmass.org/issues/ , novusordowatch.org/start-here/, novusordowatch.org/now-what/ , www.truerestoration.org/
For mass try www.traditionalmass.org/locations/ or www.ecclesia.luxvera.org/Directory-USA.html or gspav.org/missions.htm
@@angelaa.4254 Commenting so I can find this info again. Good stuff!
We sure miss you, Father Cekada! RIP
debate the most holy family monastery on baptism of desire
How embarrassing for those who saw this pathetic book as a way to justify remaining in the SSPX!
S&S thoroughly deserve to have this tripe pulled apart and tossed in the bin.
Great work, Father! Our prayers and thoughts are with you every day. May God bless you heaps.
It's R&R... I don't think you know very much about what you're talking about.
Unless he's referring to the authors...
Funny enough, Salza and Siscoe now condemn SSPX as just as bad as Sedevacantism lmao
Thank you very much for a sound and catholic doctrine.
Adam Weishof ???
Allan.
Have not been able to follow your limited, vaig overview of the book. I have personally known Mark piverunis for 30 plus years and have seen him twist and change truth to fit what he needs at time. I have lost all respect for him. Thanks
Acts 9 V4-6"Saul, Saul (Francis, FRANCIS) why do you persecute Me?"
I own a copy of Karl Marx's "Das Kapital" (three volumes), Chairman Moa's Little Red book "The thoughts of Chairman Moa", and Hitler's "Mein Kamf" (1930s edition). The worst is Chairman Moa's. Thanks for the sence of humour. Rev Cekade RIP.
The worst is Chairman Moa's book because it is unreadable and contradictory. I have thought often that Francis is a Moaist because he too want perpetual revolution.
What shall we do? Im afraid but convinced this priest was right and most of us have been duped.
Some reason I never liked father jakato with the minimal amount of exposure that I had to him a few years ago but since his passing I decided to kind of go back and watch some of his videos and the more I watched the more I feel he has some of the most entertaining and educational Catholic videos on the internet may he rest in peace
Where are sedevacantist Churches in USA?
This rebuttal wasn't convincing. Firstly. The fact that sedevacantists now put forward a second argument - that these popes were never popes to begin with, doesn't invalidate any criticism against the argument that these popes lost their office, especially since the question is not only of practical but also of academic concern. Have sedevacantists now conceded Salza's & Siscoe's points on that matter?
No -- for which, see the first part of my video Stuck in a Rut. But it's an "angels-on-the-head-of-a-pin" argument unrelated to our current position. And remember, you argue with the sedevacantists you HAVE rather than with the sedevacantists you WISH you had -- assuming you'd wish to have sedevacantists at all, of course! : )
@@WorkofHumanHands This maybe your argument, but I hear the CMRI argue loss of office, as well as Bishop Sanborn in an interview stated he believed John 23 lost office after he was elected, So I think it was completely fair for them to address that argument in the book . They also address the other argument (never was Pope) as well as many other arguments .
To have a pope you need more than just an election... The candidate for papacy has conditions to meet that were elaborated prior to Vatican II... and those are the followings: not be a child, not be a woman, not be a heretic, an idolater, or schismatic... he must be a practicing Catholic in his beliefs and every day life...and must have the intention of guiding the people in the Truth taught by Christ and promulgated by his apostles and Fathers of the Church... We cannot say that this is the case for Mr Bergogglio.. who was a heretic and practicing idolatry when he was archbishop in Argentine....promulgating homosexuality....cult with Jews....and with communists....This man does not hold the papacy - it's power....
We need this video in spanish
Has anyone ever told you that you sound a LOT like Mulcahy from M.A.S.H?
No - but someone once told me my sermon delivery sounded like Bob Newhart.
What an honor. Haha
@@DropDStandard11 he sounds EXACTLY like Fr. Mulcahy! Wow! Lol! Thank you for pointing this out? I *thought* he sounded awfully familiar!
Did you sedes hear that ? You no longer hold the position that these Popes lost office due to heresy. And there for Salza waists time in addressing that argument. , so just dismiss the whole book . Only thing is ...I would have to object because, , apparently the sedes never got the memo that they don’t hold that position any longer because I hear that position every time I engage in discussion with a sede .
I also hear the position of cum ex , but I’m confused , because Fr Cekada stated publicly that can’t be used to support sedevacantism either . And I read an artical from bishop Sanborn were he slso states that cum ex can’t be used . So all you sedes better stop using these arguments. And John Salza better stop addressing arguments you guys apparently don’t use “any longer “.
SSPX reviwere: I read every page.😂😂😂😂😂 I have never ever seen that in a review. Sounds like 5th grader talking to teacher on horrendous homework