ไม่สามารถเล่นวิดีโอนี้
ขออภัยในความไม่สะดวก
Speakers Shootout: YAMAHA NS1000 vs TANNOY BERKELEY - 1 of 3 comparison
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 19 ส.ค. 2022
- Hi-Res Audio recorded at 24bit/96kHz with dedicated X-Y microphone, for best results listen through a good pair of headphones or IEMs. Consider giving a thumbs up and subscribing to my channel if you enjoy this type of content.
- Specifications:
YAMAHA NS1000 - 3 way, 3 driver loudspeaker system, infinite baffle
Frequency Response: 40Hz to 20kHz
Sensitivity: 90dB
Impedance: 8Ω
Power Handling: 100W
Crossover Frequency: 500, 6000Hz
Bass: 1 x 300mm cone
Midrange: 1 x 88mm beryllium dome
Tweeter: 1 x 30mm beryllium dome
TANNOY BERKELEY - 2 way, dual concentric loudspeaker system, ducted port
Frequency Response: 35Hz to 20kHz
Sensitivity: 91dB
Impedance: 8Ω
Power Handling: 85W
Crossover Frequency: 1000Hz
Full Range: 1 x 15" HPD 385A
- Source: #Denafrip Ares DAC & #DigiOne Signature Allo Audio streamer
- Amplifier: Luxman L580
- Music: Pink Floyd - Money
![If you can't hear this then you're not an audiophile [See description for link to followup video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/48PxwspDvrE/mqdefault.jpg)
Tannoys for me, thanks for making the comparison.
👍🏼
What vintage tannoys do better than nearly every other speaker is bring you into the performance and an interesting mate and lifelike way. This won't be able to be conveyed on a recording but the nuances in the midrange are pretty incredible and the way the dual concentric with alnico makes all the frequencys arrive at exactly the same time and place just can't be achieved with a standard 2 way or 3 way.
I have never heard NS-1000 sound like this. I have had many pairs and none of them sounds anything like this. I compared whith my own video recordings and it is a big difference.
Your Tannoys does sounds just like mine thou!
The crossovers in my NS1000 have been recapped with Jantzen Superior Z-caps. I went looking for your videos but could not find any available.
@@vintagehifilover😂
Hi-Res Audio recorded at 24bit/96kHz with dedicated X-Y microphone, for best results listen through a good pair of headphones or IEMs. Consider giving a thumbs up and subscribing to my channel if you enjoy this type of content.
- Specifications:
YAMAHA NS1000 - 3 way, 3 driver loudspeaker system, infinite baffle
Frequency Response: 40Hz to 20kHz
Sensitivity: 90dB
Impedance: 8Ω
Power Handling: 100W
Crossover Frequency: 500, 6000Hz
Bass: 1 x 300mm cone
Midrange: 1 x 88mm beryllium dome
Tweeter: 1 x 30mm beryllium dome
TANNOY BERKELEY - 2 way, dual concentric loudspeaker system, ducted port
Frequency Response: 35Hz to 20kHz
Sensitivity: 91dB
Impedance: 8Ω
Power Handling: 85W
Crossover Frequency: 1000Hz
Full Range: 1 x 15" HPD 385A
- Source: #Denafrip Ares DAC & #DigiOne Signature Allo Audio streamer
- Amplifier: Luxman L580
- Music: Pink Floyd - Money
The Yamaha's seem a little ''muffled'' while the Tannoy's seem a little ''higher'' pitch. Sound the same on 3 of 3 comparaison with Sade. (Tannoy Arden listener here )
Thanks for the feeback
Yamaha's by a mile. Where is the midrange and bass on the Tannoys? The treble is the big difference. Agree the treble sounds better on the Tannoys, but nothing else. I think I would find the Tannoys fatiguing. Great video though. Fun to compare, I'm inspired to record some of my own.
Thanks for sharing your opinion
For whatever reason, the soundstage on the Tannoys is dramatically wider than the Yamaha. On the Tannoys the vocals sound as though they emanate from well to the right of the right speaker! Everything is a lot more centralised with the NS1000, perhaps too centralised. I prefer the Tannoy soundstage but, on the other hand, I prefer the punchiness (but not the harshness....a little too bright for me) of the NS1000's.
I love my Berkleys and listening to my studio mixes on those, but do my studio mixing on Yamahas.
That's an interesting perspective you've offered there Trevor. It got me thinking about the different qualities of both speakers. Thank you
Prefer the Tannoy sound, they sound more open and airier where the Yamaha sound more enlcosed and boxed in but also more meaty.
I guess a bit like headphones enclosed or open backed, both can be very good but have their trade off's
I prefer the thinner but more open and spacial sounding Tannoy's.
I had Tannoy SRM-12 Little RED, but they died. I loved them. But today i have a strange danish pyramid formed made of concrete speakers with a 8" bass, they sound incredible.
Interesting
Tannoy's for me too. The midrange difference is the most noticeable. Little sibilance with the Tannoy's. The phase difference is quite noticeable. Might just be how the Tannoy's throw the sound around. Have you tried inverting the polarity on them? Just a thought.
Thanks for the feeback, I might try that sometime
Tannoy always has this strange sound signature which sounds so exaggarated. I prefer Yamaha in this clip. How is your JBL project?
I love the Tannoy dual concentric sound, particularly the midrange. Having the two playing next to each other makes the NS1000 closed in while the Berkeley sound more open, better instrument separation IMO.
I'll have some details about the JBL soon, watch this space =^)
I think you have the instrument separation comment reversed, by a mile. The Yamahas has much better instrument separation and much more natural sound. The Tannoys sound more sparkly, but very bright, which side by side makes the Yamahas trebble sound muted, but I think it's much more accurate/natural and mids and bass sound excellent. Tannoys mids and bass sound horrible.
@@stevedevuono4115 I sense a Tannoy hater :D Never liked Tannoy myself. The further I go, the more I understand each one of us listens to music differently and at least in my circle, I do not have anyone who is looking for the same aspects in sound as I do. So it is not surprising the perception is opposite sometimes.
Need to swap left and right on the NS-1000's
👍🏼
please update your title to show if this is a Tannoy MK1 or MK2😁
Tannoy 😍
Yep
glad I have the berkeleys ;)
👍🏼:)
Tannoys for me :)
For me too :-)
I have the Berkeley and the Arden ( and a pair of JBL 101 Lancer. Tannoy just does it for me ❤
I've had both models as well at one time. I had to sell the Berkeley so that I could get the JBLs though.
Which speaker is better?
mk1 ?
Tannoy for me🙂
You've got it 👍🏼
I think the Yamaha sound veiled then when you switch to the Tannoy...such fuller sound and open...!!!🎶 Tannoy by 2 miles🤣thx
There might be some centering issue with Tannoy tweeters... I hear slight outerphase in the crossover point.
Huh?
Yamaha for me
👍🏼
My NS-1000's sound better than I'm hearing here. Those Tannoy's sound like they have fantastic dynamics. The treble sounds a bit unnaturally boosted and a bit smeared. A very engaging sound though. I'd love to find a pair near me and do my own shootout, but they seem relatively rare here.
They don't come up for sale very often, people tend to hang on to them.
ns-1000m sounds open and relaxing while tannoy sound is compressed . ??
👍🏼
l have been having a look at the plot for this speaker if it's correct, I would say to high peak between 2.2-3.5kHz and is an awful dip after this point to 1kHz of -1.5db.
looks like if you change the 3.3mF for a 2.7mF or 2.8mF copper film, like Jensen cap, with a 0.3-0.5 ohm non inductive resistor, inline and a inductor over the resistor of 0.5 mm gauge wire with 14 turns placed over the resistor and sold at both ends of the resistor but not capacitor! find some wire and just paint it with nail varnish, wrap it around your little finger and slide it over the resistor.
might be worth changing the 1.5mF as well for a 1.2mF give you more brighter top end extension.
have you tried blocking the ports with a sock one or both, could be beneficial in this case better mid-range and extended of the lower bass.
Sadly I'm not that savvy of skilled to do all of that but thanks though
@@vintagehifilover ok but somebody might
If accuracy is your quest and with good source, nothing comes close to NS1000Ms past and present included.
Hence why they are still very sought after speakers
@@vintagehifilover I got one that I picked up in NY in the 80s and two that in mint condition from Japan when I visited there along with a PC2002m amp.
@@RoyFJ65 I always wanted to try those amps but haven't had a chance yet. I did have a M2 which was very nice.
@@vintagehifilover I forgot to add that I also have an MX-1 amp that I picked up in the late 90’s they sound marvelous as well with the NS-1000Ms.
Not even close; Tannoys by a mile.
Yep, you got it ;-)
Tannoys obviously
👍🏼👍🏼
to all you that think the yamaha is better than Tannoy...your hearing is limited🤣
TANNOY DYNAMISM IS way better!!
You've got it 👍🏼
Tannoy buy far even though these cheap headphones plugged into my PC
Thanks 👍🏼
I've never understood Modern Dance
LOL
Tannoy
👍🏼
Tannoy.
Thanks 👍🏼
ma esiste solo questo disco?
I've chose this track as lots of people are very familiar with it
Брехня!
У ямахи не может быть такой звук!
Разве шо регуляторы вч и сч выкрутил в минус.
Controls are in their default position