Dragon Ball GT VS Super (Artstyles)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 ก.ย. 2024
- An in-depth look into the art-styles of Gt and Super discussing everything from the drawing style to the colors used in an episode.
So which is your favorite style, Gt or Super let me know in the comments.
Also sorry for taking this long to upload this video took a lot of work
to make.
►Instagram: / d.bz_arts
►Credits: Music by Shunsuke Kikuchi
Goku got a tan in gt. He went to the beach for a bit you know
he trained with black Uub at sunny time for years it makes sense
He trained in Africa under the sun for years with uub
@@vladimirlong7125 In Africa 😂
Hahaha Africa lmao
Toriyama colored him tan long before GT.
I miss when the Super Saiyan hair moved like actual hair in Z and GT
Dude ssj hair moves in z and gt not in super
Tremain Dzuimo ssj is super saiyan i think you got confused xD
@@justaguywithagoodphoto4801 I said super saiyan hair moves in GT and super bro :)
Tremain Dzuimo i think he didn’t watch the MUI fight >\>
@@treemane0 I had fixed it, I had meant to put "Hair moves in Z and GT" I'm aware that it doesn't move consistently in super
Man I love GT's artstyle that much more now
@PKD Orion no their bodies look like sticks
@PKD Orion
Look at 16:24 and tell me Vegeta doesn't look like a kid in Super. He looks like a different character, and he's supposed to look older than he does in Z. While in the right in Z you see how much more powerful and threatening he looks. That's why they went with another style entirely for the DBS Broly movie.
@PKD Orion Yeah I don't follow the series anymore as Super didn't hold me. I find studying the art style of Z more interesting these days since I draw as a hobby. And I can always watch the older episodes.
I like the art in GT better. Their promo art and opening and closing art is crazy. In some cases looks better than Z. I also like the GT art in that japanese intro for that horrible psone game,"Final Bout."
I think dragon ball gt it's more faithful to toriyama art style back then
Your Super Saiyan 5 picture takes me back, and also is that a perfect example of what the art style should be.
@@LuminesBreezer-- lmao all I see is white
@@alexsao1105 Get your eyes checked because I see a SSJ5 too.
super only looked decent in the last 2 arcs. n only looked consistently decent in the tournament of power. it baffles me that so many ppl were able to enjoy the stiff, off model, pasty looking art and animation of super for years to get to that point. it took a little to get used to dbs broly look but the animation was amazing n the quality that this amazing franchise DESERVES.
Super really pissed me off with it's animation and character designs. Pure trash
It had a rough start at the beginning of Dragon Ball Super with a major controversy about the drawing artwork from Dragon Ball Super Battle of Gods (episode #5) and Resurrection 'F ' arc in episode 24 or 25 I think where Goku (as Super Saiyan Blue) fought against Golden Frieza/Freeza. But as time went by, the artwork grows phenomenally well during the Champa arc, Goku Black/Zamasu arc, Tournament of Power arc, and Dragon Ball Super Broly film. I used to draw Dragon Ball characters back in the early 2000s (2002-2003) during my late childhood/preteen years when I was in middle school at that time.
I basically agree. The Battle of Gods arc was a retell, the Resurrection F arc was a retell, the U6 vs U7 Tournament was kind of boring, except for SSJB Kaio. And then we get to the Goku Black arc, which kind of turned things around for the Series, but of course was still flawed. The T.O.P arc I mainly loved for the animation. There were so many fights and episodes with beautiful art and animation, but yeah, there were many boring, and annoying episodes. Honestly, I don't give a flying shit about Ribrianne.
@@ThatGuyErazo always hating the show are you guys morrons or something ?
They don't have budget and time when they make a show.The movie was high quality because of all money that they got later for show and sponsor Dragon ball heroes. Bruh you guys need to stop look at animation and enjoy the show
@@medul10alpha31 oh no, I enjoyed the show, in fact, wish for the best from it. I never said I hated it, so I'd ask you stop assuming shit. My problem with the anime was the reproduction of the Battle of Gods and Resurrection of Frieza, even though we've all, I should hope, already seen the films. One thing Super did better in the Resurrection F arc than the movie, was showing Vegeta and Goku training with Whis, which we barely got to see in the movie. As for the U6 vs U7 Tournament, was it really necessary? Power Scaling was bad, the Universe Introduction could've been much better, and the animation overall just passed. Like I said, I really enjoyed the Goku Black arc and Tournament of Power arc, given the animation improved heavily, and the story for the Goku Black arc was at least plausible. As for the Tournament of power arc, it was simply Fan Service, with beautiful animation and art. My only complaint was, as I said, Ribrianne.
gogeta has a fantastic jaw line
CHAD MAN JAW LINE.
can we just agree that goku vs buu was the best looking goku we ever got?
For me the best looking artstyle was at the end of frieza saga like in this video th-cam.com/video/Upda92YBZgU/w-d-xo.html
And yamamuro's artstyle for movie 8
eh, still prefer SSJ4.
No, I like the simple artstyle in Goku Vs Frieza
Debatable.
I couldn’t blame anybody for preferring the Saiyan Saga Goku or the Frieza Saga near the SSJ transformation or the character style near the end of Cell or the characters at the end of Z/Buu.
I think they’re all really great depictions of the characters throughout time. Even though they change so dramatically, I never really felt like the overall art changed. It’s… hard to explain, but I guess what I mean is that every version of the characters in Z feel like they are just older versions of the exact same characters. I don’t feel like this way about Super. I feel like they aren’t the same characters any more.
Nah I prefer buu saga Goku
Ah Katsuyoshi Nakatsuru... Such a fantastic artist. I will always be an admirer of his for creating that iconic SS4 form. His style added so much bulk to the characters, just gives a good impression of the training these characters go through. Besides that, he just gave such great art direction of DB. Certainly did a superb job of imitating Toriyama's peak DB years... Wish he had some more prominent roles again in DBS, though I hear he's been busy with Digimon.
The Buu ark, everyone looked their best accept piccolo, piccolo looked brilliant in the cell saga
I believe that art style during the Android and Cell arc are good, characters are well proportioned, during the Buu arc and beyond the characters gradually "shrunk". I remember Mr Satan in the Cell games being tall and his body proportioned right but in the Buu arc, GT and the following shows Mr Satan's head is now larger than his now lanky body.
i think thata to add to his comedic affect
Because Hercule grew old dude
Mr. Satan and Majin Buu used to be about twice Goku's size. Now they're only a little taller.
I prefer the Namek and Cell saga's art style the most.
@@treemane0 that's not a good excuse ti make him look that much different after only a 5 year time skip
Awesome vid, your like the only one who's discussing Dragon Ball like this.
Thank you, I definitely plan to continue to
being an animator and artist myself, it's also where they were in that period of time with how production was handled, gt was traditionally drawn on cels and painted by hand and then scanned into software for editing where as super is pretty much entirely drawn in software packages aside from pencil key frames. if you notice on line art the quality is cleaner on super, mostly lacking the variation in thickness. this is where gt has the advantage in which there's a smooth organic line quality where the key animators talent really shines through.
traditional animation has a far better aesthetic due to the more painstaking process but is more artistic.
digital frame animation, has the advantage of having smoother animation with inbetween assisted frame generation. however there is more animation today, closing the gap between the art styles of old and the quality of animation of the modern day.
In my opinion they need to get back to incorporating original traditional methods with new methods because super looks extra digitized and sprite like......
@@cmuney101 I 110% agree with you, when Super comes back the guys at Toei should add a grain/color filter so it looks like it could have been on TV in the 90s
Gt artstyle is dope af
I like dbz and gt Animations much better and then supers
Definitely agree
I prefer the art from Z better, but the animation in Late Super completely dogshits on GT and Super. Regardless of the age of DBZ, the Tournament of Power was generally a feast for the eyes.
Disagreed 🖕🖕🖕🖕
@@prabalkamra7763 yeah
@@ThatGuyErazo I mean I agree with you
GT was very well drawn. Super is so hit and miss
GT got the best art style than Super without a doubt
GT honestly SLAPS
I really can't stand the giant irises for Ultra Instinct. Not sure if that was from Toriyama or Yamamuro.
it looked like a tarsier
He looks like a "How to Draw Anime" parody of himself.
Compare it to another form with pupils like SSJ4. The irises at least twice the size.
@@Studio_OZKai He looks cute tho. Like some sparkling Chibi Goku, its hilarious.
Thats why most of the new forms are whack, because they all have that disney princess look to them.
When Vegeta got his "Powerup" in the tournament of power I called it "Moe Blue Vegeta"
GT's art shits on 90% of Super.
DBS only looked good towards the tournament of power
I actually really like the style I’m G it was much more Symmetrical and for someone that’s has a little OCD when it comes to drawing that’s good I always loved drawing the late dragon ball z to GT art style
So the majority of the DB fans like GTs art style, the artists should've continue that style, imagine watching SSJG Goku in GTs art style 🤩
Deserves so much more views and subs, great editing, good narration and great pace. You earned a sub :D. Keep up the good work!
Thank you very much for the positive feedback and the sub😃
OMG YESSS! I loveee these art videos sm! Keep doing what you do👍
I definitely will😁
The DBS Broly artstyle is my favorite
DB super’s art style looks so generic and plasticy, I feel like it got better in the future saga and universal tournament saga. And the colors are so basic and not as dynamic and vibrant as GT and Z, DBS broly struck a balance where it looks familiar but new, it’s like the character designs of the early DBZ manga and the simplicity of DBS. But also leaving its mark as a unique style, I would be so happy is Season 2 of DBS has that style
The Broly movie was so colorful tho Wdym?
The best color was the bright yellows for the hair and the dark Browns for the skin tone
Yeah i missed the rich yellows for the hair especially in super
What I'm talking about was only displayed for the original super saiyan on namek and no other
@@atomicpressure5112 Sorry what I meant was that I miss seeing those rich yellows from Z and wish it would return to super👍
Yeah they evolve past that now
Same here dude!
GT art style always looked slightly off to me. I’ve never been able to pin point why it was. This helps explain why
GT style is how Dragon Ball MUST look like.
Hellllllll no I like z
DBS: Broly?
Shintani is the best
Color tone wise I agree. I’m happy they went back to more traditional tones with dbs broly
@@apparatus2808 Nah, the characters look round and flat, like they don't even lift, the only one that looks good is Broly.
I really enjoyed the art style when the dbz yo special came out, it was like the best of z remastered
I don't why they didn't go with that artstyle for super! It's a pity they didn't
@@forgottenrelics1197 thats what pissed me off about Super the most when it came out
@@realamericannegro977 yeah the artstyle is an important thing. A poor choice but at least we are in the right direction now
A lot of people bashed on Yamamuro for unfaithful designs and shading, but if you analyzed it closely, his designs are faithful to Toriyama and Nakatsuru designs back in Buu and GT era. I always find he based on Toriyama's modern designs, yet tweaking it by adding traits that was found from Buu and GT era, creating both new yet nostalgic designs.
GT looks so much better than Super. Super would have been better with different animation and music, though I still enjoyed it, I was just happy to see new Dragon Ball episodes coming out weekly, and part of Toriyama's Canon at that.
Great video, I always wondered about these kinds of things in Dragon Ball and thank you for covering stuff like this and keep up the great work
Hey no problem and thank you👍
videos like this are very interesting, i think a vid about toriyamas vs nakatsuru vs yamamuro vs shintani artstyles and maybe a vid about movie art. sorry for the rambling lol keep it up
That sounds like a great idea! Although comparing them in one video would be quite long😁 but yes I should definitely do a vid just on the new movie artstyle alone I think it would be very interesting and thanks for your support.
ForgottenRelics JW yeah man no problem i think it would be super cool and i’m really excited for more stuff from you
I always had the idea that GT Goku looked more brownish because he kinda tanned while training with Uub. If I recall he went to his home town and it was a very sunny place.
the color palette in GT anime looks like most of the time it's sunset or after sunset
When super hit the tournament of power that’s when it got good
I recently came across this channel and I love your artist comparisons dude, very informative. Subscribed.
Thanks! I really do appreciate the support😃
As for the DBS 130/131 episode with Takahashi as key animator, you can either think of the meme of Takahashi saying to Yamamuro that he "uses the character sheets.. THE OLD ONES!" or the meme was REAL and Takahashi did indeed stay with original sheets on his own.
vegeta got such a triangular face in the super reference, he looks like a girl almost, he looks like how a friend would draw him, starting with a heart to make the face
The one thing better about gt vs super better art style still somewhat kept the original style intact
This! I feel when they brought super broly in they brought in more original styles and color tones
Yamamuro's art direction aged poorly and this is direct evidence.
Can you do a comparison between OG naruto, shippuden and boruto styles? I know you don't do much Naruto videos but It'd be really cool if you did
Imagine super with the gt art style
It would be suck
@@chief5604 still look better then what it did before.
@@chief5604 You know it would look better, you're just being biased.
@@TheFracturedfuture wanna know who's bias? Look in the mirror 🤭
@@chief5604 DBZ and GT were hand drawn that's why it looks better, that's not an opinion but a fact, hand drawn is always going to looks better than digital art, that's why hand drawn is more expensive.
Dude awesome video! You are literally the only youtuber I’ve seen dive deep into the art and color tones of dragon ball. Toriyama’s original work of Goku gave him a brown tone. Sun wukong the monkey king traces far back to Hindu mythology. Notice in DBS super broly they give broly and his father a brown tone. They’ve always shown the saiyans as a tribal indigenous homosapien like species with many varying different shades of skin tones
How does this man only have about 100 subs !! He should have way more
this video is great, I love when peoople dive in the details
You have done another great video my guy with your videos and this one is no expectation
Thank you, your support keeps me motivated!
ForgottenRelics JW and I mean it my guy hope you can do a part 2 against Toyotaro vs youngjj
I like the GT art style better.
2008 yamamuro character sheet for Goku was awesome. Very close to what we ended up getting with the DBS Broly character sheet in terms of color.
I like how GT Vegeta has an actual forehead
Thanks for these videos. I prefer the GT, DBZ art style.
i just found this channel and i looove it
GT was fresh after DBZ and by the same animators. Of course it would still look great.
If I had to choose I'd pick DBZ over GT and Super animated series.
dbs broly has the best design we’ve ever seen imo. perfect balance between old db and new db.
Question, where do you find information of the animators using difference art sheet for the Super episode of SS3 in the Tournament of Power?
So ... does that mean Goku is able to say the word N sometimes?
He’s SUN ☀️ wukong of course! Lol
Post-GT Yamamuro is TRASH, thank GOD for Shintani.
Agreed!
Spitting facts
What about my boi Yuya takahashi
I am not at all fond of Shintani's drawings. I appreciate the versatility that they bring, and that's it. I'd take Z-Yamamuro back in a heartbeat.
@@ThisHandleSystemCanGetNicked Well, you have Takahashi who draws everything like Z-Yamamuro..
I always liked the tan Goku look.
Same man! Sun ☀️ Wukong is his name after all...
Dragon Ball GT had some fantastic art examples and some lazy examples, like hair on Goten and Gohan and sometimes Vegeta.
Good video it was really interesting
Thank you! Sorry if it was a little long though I hope you enjoyed it regardless
I actually like his tan color in GT
How bout this Vs. Saiyan / Namek / Very Early Z Movie Style Vs Buu saga / Late Z movies style
Yes! Thanks for the suggestions I love the early Z style as well as the buu arc so it would be quite fun to discuss :)
Super looks like pokemon art
I don’t know why but when Goku when UI he looks really dark is some places
i prefer the older styles too :^>
I like dragon ball super it’s really catching it’s footing
Great content as usual
👍
ForgottenRelics JW I can’t find content like this anywhere
ForgottenRelics JW so great job
17:42 I wanna see the artists challenge themselves... There isn't enough going on with the meta, lore or art anywyay so I wanna see what would happen to his SSJ3 hair if some was cut off... Would it go back to base form, without Goku's power, surging through the strands? Is it going to stay blonde, even when cut off since his physiology changed for the form??
This stuff is interesting and helps answer a lot of questions about the science of DBZ, without going all Man of Steel on us
Gt looks better
GT looks better than Super BUT Super actually looked awesome in the Universe Survival Arc. I would love the DBZ Designs but with Super Shading, colours and effects but GT designs wouls also work really well. That shiny look needs to die though. Or...DBS Broly look is really good too.
Great video
Thanks man!
I think the skin color for GT Goku would be to set him apart from original DB's Kid Goku and Kid Goten's design. With this weird logic take in mind, for the poster of Goku Jr. movie it could MAYBE be to set him apart from the Junior himself?
BTW, love your channel and your art!
i feel like its more accurate to say that GT is just darker in general. like the backgrounds are darker (thinking how movies r darker than tv shows)
Great video. Detail is important
Sure is and thanks!
ForgottenRelics JW I do have a quick question. With the future of hand drawn animation is looking darker each year, do you think that future animation technology would make it so that the computer draws out the anime for you using a mimicking art style program? I know expressions and exaggerated movements are what make hand made art unique but if a computer can read an anime frame by frame, could it one day replace hand. Anime’s could be drawn out quicker but probably lose it appeal maybe
@@black2785 Sounds kinda similar to adobe after effects, from what I remember you can basically use preset shapes and then set a path for it to follow and it will animate it. Of course I remember when I did it it still took alot of manual input from my side but no drawing of frame by frame was needed.
And if you had a 3d model I'm guessing I could probably do the same.
And what your describing sounds a little similar to an author note by Kishimoto(author of naruto) back in 2001
"Both the backgrounds and characters themselves are created in software as polygons and once the initial design and programming is done, any imaginable composition is possible. For action sequences, we use motion capture to create and manipulate the coolest poses we can come up with. It's all done on the computer, without using any paper or ink".
(might have to make a video on that note)
ForgottenRelics JW I am impressed of your knowledge
They need to ease up on the animators for DBS. I'd be happy with one eppie a month, that way you'll get top notch quality
It doesn't work this way, plus during ToP arc, they had mostly 3 to 6 weeks for episode
@@lewycraft if they had up to 6 weeks, then the animators are absolutely garbage. They need new talent.
@@dk7541 well, the best new talents are recently emerging in their Precure department so...
Ball,z,gt were ALL weekly. It's the issue of art style,passion.
the desings for the movie are simply the best
Og art style is always the goat🗿🔥
super looks like the modeled it after the plastic toys.
it's not just the colors, it's the lack of details and unfinished linework. it feels hella rushed.
Got was clean af
GT looks far better than Super.
Only exception is Super Broly.
Goku is older in GT. And everyone knows once you get older you get that "middle age spread" lol that's why his face is more round in GT. He was a grandfather.
Hey man, when you make videos do you write a script and read or do you speak naturaly?
Ik they dont rlly show dbs broly but that is the best art style for dragon ball by far, it shows earlier db which is best for the story
I am free to disagree right?
@@chief5604 ur free to but i wont be replying after this
@@zenic558 ok I disagree
Did anyone comment anything about GT artist
*drawing big noses for the characters*
even though i dont like gt, gt style is wayyyyyy better than yamamuro's super art
One thing, Goku got a darker tan in GT
17:35,Yuya Takahashi. Can't blame on him,those colors look bomb asf.
Tu Yong-Ce*
15:26 at least he doesn't look like a fossil anymore 😂😂😂
The reason Dragon ball GT had inconsistent color palettes for the characters is because it had artifacts that changed the original colors that were painted due to the way it was produced and the images you used in the video as reference were from different sources. Same with the Promotional materials
18:13 S.S-J.Blue.Grade.5
I miss when the Z fighters we're beefcakes lmao
I love the VS series and when will you upload the part 2 of young jijii vs toyotaro?
Thank you! I haven't started on part 2 yet as I would like to read some more of there material first but I will be working on a video discussing Tadayoshi Yamrous artwork which I think will be quite intresting 👍
Man, super’s artstyle sucks compared to z(cell-buu arc)
Which one? Yamamuro, top style or shintani
@@insertnamehere658 I'm not really sure who was in charge of the edgy artstyle.
Let me try.
-Imperfect Cell vs Merged Piccolo & Kami
-Perfect Cell vs USSJ Trunks
-SSJ2 Gohan vs Cell Juniors
-SSJ2 Son Goku vs Majin Vegeta
-Chou Gohan vs Majin Buu
-Chou Gohan vs Buutenks
-SSJ3 Son Goku vs Buuhan
-Non sloppy artstyle during Super Vegito vs Buuhan
-SSJ2 Son Goku vs Kid Buu & the rest of the fight until the death of Kid Buu is just gold.
@@oyametalicusII I personally think that while not as good as the z style. The shintani style is still pretty good and if we're talking about animation then ui omen goku vs jiren, mui goku vs jiren and every fight in the broly movie looks better than Z
@@insertnamehere658 In dbs Broly, not all of the drawings look nice. Maybe this is just a matter of preference whether or not the audience like the rounded manga artstyle or the edgy & crispy artstyle (FullPower Broly charging up vs Gogeta Blue), and I don't know if that's the intention(to combine both artstyles), but I really prefer consistency of the edgy ones.
DBZ Broly movie's story sucks but the artstyle was consistent and really looks splendid during the time.
DBS Universe Survival arc had few great artstyles, especially when Vegeta started the attack vs Jiren. What else, the beginning of the SSJ2 Goku vs SSJ2 Caulifla & SSJ Kale(controlled) part, Chou Gohan's Kamehameha to Toppo.
Those were the few ones I really like.
@@oyametalicusII a lot of people like the low detail shintani style. I do also like the top style
Loved the video
Thanks!
The biggest thing that I noticed in Gt is that the noses are much bigger compared to in Z and even the Yamamuro art style.
11:02 Look at how terribly-proportioned Bulma, Chi-Chi, 18, and Mr. Satan are in GT. It's horrific.
DBZ and GT color palettes and art style are superior in every aspect. Super looks like fisher price shiny toys, I can’t stand it.
I agree