Watch: A penalty for a foul committed outside the field!!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 7 ก.ย. 2024
- Who got a red card this weekend? Watch Instant Replay as MLSsoccer.com's Simon Borg brings you the most controversial and talked-about plays from Week 29 of the 2017 MLS regular season.
Atlanta United vs. Montreal Impact 0:07
New York City FC vs. Houston Dynamo 1:04
Columbus Crew vs. New York Red Bulls 2:29
New England Revolution vs. Toronto FC 3:54
Minnesota United vs FC Dallas 4:42
Real Salt Lake vs. Seattle Sounders 6:04
Portland Timbers vs. Orlando City 7:33
Sporting Kansas City vs. LA Galaxy 9:02
Subscribe to our channel for more soccer content: www.youtube.com...
- Follow us on Twitter: / mls
- Like us on Facebook: / mls
- Follow us on Instagram: / mls
For more information about MLS, go to the league's official website: www.MLSsoccer.com
Judging whether a player is on or offsides based on shadows? Lets not go down that route
Big Banner holy shit u have 11 million subs
Why not use all the information available?
Shadow position is not information that can be used to decide a persons position. Shadow is based on the height and angle from the sun, so tell me how shadow can tell u if a person that is side by side with another person show the position when the shadow is different depending on the person?
Ascion Blade , did you even bother to read what i wrote?
Ascion Blade I assume you have no argument against me. No point in talking to you then I guess
Borg puts in more effort to pronounce names properly rather than focusing on calling plays properly.
Two players clearly hit shoulder to shoulder --> "Looks like a push in the back. Should have been a PK"
Player has his hand on the back of the player --> "He had position."
As consistent as the refereeing...
But he shouldered behind him making a foul dumbass
great call, I agree, bias commentary
That was not from behind moron. Maybe that's how you like it?
ROFLMAO! The calls were 100% CORRECT! You and 79 people who liked your comment don't belong anywhere close to commenting on football!
What a joke, no Mention of all the red bull fouls, but mentions Higuaín's kick of the ball. Shame Borg, shame.
Your funny. The Red Bulls always gets calls. They are a bunch of cry babies.
They always get calls now because it was brought forward that they were previously handed the shorter stick in every call by referees.
When people complain about plays not being in the video it’s because they aren’t pointed out on social media.
“.... and I agree”
Lol, said every two seconds
6:38- Has to be a red card because his studs are up, aggressive and if the player didn't jump out the way, he could have been seriously injured
I know. It's fucking ridiculous that this guy doesn't know this, yet can create content for a channel as important as this one.
yeah its yellow or red, that slide wasn't targeting the ball. He was targeting the player.
@@zyadalzahrani971 actually it was..😂
The direction his feet were pointing wasn’t even at the ball, it was at the legs of the player.
I’m American and I’m ashamed of how bad mls players are
Facts. All our good players are from other countries
4:03 the NE vs TOR offside decision is an interesting one b/c he was _pushed_ into an offside position by the NE player.
If MLS isn't scripted, I am Santa Claus
no silly, with that name youre jesus
lemon you don’t dare call Zlatan silly.
Lol
Where’s the video with the 2 straight red in ATL UTD vs New England game. I want to see what you have to say about those. Also the ATL vs Galaxy reds as well
I'm stunned you didn't dive into the ATL-LA Galaxy match. The two red cards-one for each side. I thought Jermaine Jones's was warranted for that gratuitous KICK OUT on Tito Villalba. And I think the Brandon Vazquez red should've only been a yellow. He was going for the ball.
‘It’s a ruthless challenge’ the guy head butted his arm
Cavbucky Plays exactly
08:45 Victor Giro's red card could have been avoided if the referee prevented attackers from being in the wall. There were 5 defenders in the wall. From law 13 "Where three or more defending team players form a ‘wall’, all attacking team players must remain at least 1 m (1 yd) from the ‘wall’ until the ball is in play."
this video is from 5 years ago. That law wasn't in place in 2017.
Is it just me or mls make up there own rules
lol
The foul was in the box and so was the ball the player would’ve got to the ball if it hadn’t been a foul
13 for Dallas wasnt offsides and he couldnt get out of the way yes he was behind but when the shot came the goalie was prepared but couldn't do anything
8:50 is not a red card. Barely touches him and the other player takes a Italy/Portugal level dive.
If you take into account player appeals on the call you make or might make, like the one you referenced on the David Villa penalty shoutout. Then, you are basically incentivizing embellishment. Do you understand how that is bad?
The moving ball case was fine. The player clearly placed his hand on the ball to stop it, meaning the restart was unambiguous to everyone, and he gained no advantage from the tiny bit of remaining movement on the ball. At that point, the incredibly small amount of movement remaining is trifling and doesn't violate any of the reasons why that part of the rules exists in the first place. The rules clearly state that referees should avoid calling trifling offenses, and that would have absolutely qualified as one.
Thank you. If you nitpick every single thing in the game, you're the kind of referee everyone would hate, because you'd be stopping the game, and pulling everything back every thirty seconds. Technically, one in every eight throw-ins is a foul throw, but they don't get noticed. I can't remember the last time a keeper held onto the ball for longer than six seconds and had an indirect free-kick awarded against them. There are some things that you just let go, for the flow of the game, and so that people know you're not a complete douche who wants to be the center of attention.
In 7:47 the defender grabs the attacker's hand but the attacker looks like he dived. Plus wouldn't it be red because the guy who tackled the attacker was the last man who he got past the defender in minuet 7:53
When the ref goes blind
You can’t even touch a soccer player without him screaming that his leg is broken
In Spain, yes, but not everywhere. My pal once introduced me to his mate from Barcelona. I shook his hand, and he immediately fell to the ground and started grabbing his face. Just a natural reaction, I guess. Once he remembered that he was not playing a football match, and that he was standing in his friend's garden at a barbecue, surrounded by scores of people who were staring at him in disbelief, he got up rather quickly with an embarrassed look on his face.
That was the silhouette of Mcbeans arm
I think McBean should've seen red
DozyProductions it's only fair since Besler did
There's already to many stops for VR
The Red Bull against Columbus thing was a clear penalty.
FIFA's rules nowadays takes intention into consideration.
The defenders intention was clearly to stop the Red Bull's player from reaching the ball.
The defender started the tackle inside the box and even though he hit the other player outside of the box, the ball was inside the box and if the attacker hadn't been tackled, he would have been able to go for the ball.
So, tackle started in the box, hit the player outside the box yet by doing this, prevented player from reaching the ball which was in the box.
Penalty.
When ur favourite team isn’t included😭😭😭
Arboleda was sent off against RSL for the exact same foul on Plata
Roldán was grabbing his arm and he was shaking him off
Damn, the intro must’ve been the guy with Eminem flowing within him.
You missed the non-stationary free kick by LA that led to a Yellow on Ike Opara and a goal against SKC.
"ball to hand" lol yeah right
The penalty outside the box that was called started inside the goal box. In the law book it mentions that if a defender
starts holding an attacker outside the box but continues inside the box then the referee must give a penalty.
That's just not true. Show me the law that states that. You're completely wrong. If you're running into the box, but you're just outside it when I start grabbing your arm, then you fall inside the box, that's not a penalty - it's a free kick.
And I agree
Finally a 'ref' i agree with. You should once review Belgium pro league soccer refs they are absolutely terrible. All blind af.
I was at the Portland- Orlando game
I don’t understand these things, I feel like I see way different things then he says. I always feel like he’s wrong.
lance cardon HE IS WRONG
Yeah, he's completely wrong. Just because he creates content for this channel doesn't make him right. I've been watching football for nearly thirty years, and I'm actually embarrassed for you that he is the best you guys can get.
6:44 you're a fool and so inconsistent; Player clearly avoids tackle for his own safety. Seattle player makes a dangerous tackle that does not make contact(two legged studs showing). But you have said in other videos contact is not nessarcery.... For the love of god can we get anyone else to do these videos
I can agree and I'm a sounders fan I thought we were lucky that wasn't a red Borg is so inconsistent!
Came to comment the same thing. Blatant card. Dude would have lost his legs going for that ball.
Y'all are retarded, Alonso made a phenomenal tackle and didn't come close to touching the eso player.
Grant Luce haha didn't come close? And doesn't matter. It's dangerous play.
How about becoming a referee to understand the differences in every play? How about that simple thing?
Best call?
And this why I only watch the prem
Mate, there's nothing better. It's God's league.
Yeah I watch the prem, bundes and santander leagues. Is that how you spell santander
MLS does not clickbait....
no mention of the elbow to the face in Atlanta, OK whatever. Also endangering the safety of a player isn't a red card offense or even a yellow. Careless, reckless, or excessive tackles are the only card able tackles.
Law 12: "A tackle or challenge that endangers the safety of an opponent or uses excessive force or brutality must be sanctioned as serious foul play."
Serious foul play is a sending off offense. Right there, quoted, "endangers the safety of a player."
4:25 if the contact is made outside of the box, it’s clearly not a penalty and it was shoulder to shoulder. It couldn’t have been more clear. This guy doesn’t know football rules.
Outside the field? where were they playing?
Wow, MLS is a joke. I don't know what is worse, the abysmal American refs or this joker commentating. Learn the rules of football please.
Eddie Gill There are no rules there are Laws of the Game.
Shoob MacGruber Ikr
You do it then
@@minermarcus wait, what???
Brandon Vazquez should not have been red-carded in the game against LA!!!
this is a good show just going thru the league checking the ref. Havent seen a show like this in any of the euro leagues. Is there a ranking of refs resulting from the reviews from this show
Video Review finally gets Baldomero Toledo accountable? Why does he even still work for MLS? He's been a bad ref since at LEAST 2011, and the fact that he is allowed to continue making poor decisions in MLS just shows how much of a joke refereeing in the US is. This video series simply highlights the need for a complete fresh start. Fire them all and re-hire the good ones and maybe we can get some respect for American Soccer back.
Daniel Ladishew i don't think there was ever respect for American soccer in the first place
Nice
Good video
I don't think I've seen a wash-out by an MLS referee. Don't MLS referees practice wash-outs or have I just missed the games where the sign has been used?
Far too many babies playing soccer. They are always looking for a foul even when they trip over their own feet. Falling down and grabbing the wrong leg is not a foul. Any player that falls to the ground like a Neymar and no foul should be red carded and thrown from that game and the following game.
I am albanian and mabye i dont know how the MLS teams work but why dont LA Galaxy play i
Ibrahimovic he can score a lot of goals for them.
LA Galaxy does play. This video isn't a round-up of all the goals from one week. It's a referee analysis video.
Revelian1982 i know but its my bad then
No worries, brother. It's all good.
There was no way that was a penalty for fc Dallas, he stepped on the ball and his sudden stop is what caused the collision
That doesn't matter. He still prevented him from playing the ball.
Well yeah the defender wasn't making an attempt to tackle him, that's part of the point.. the coming together was initiated by and was the fault of the fc dallas player, so I'm not sure how you could penalize someone for that...
Because players are allowed to stop. There is no rule that says "if you are running, you have to keep running so you don't get hit from behind". You are allowed to stop any time you want, and the impetus is on the other player to be in control of his body so that he can react to such a stop and not run a guy over like an out of control semi truck.
4:20 shouldnt be a pen. Player is not gonna get that ball.
That doesn't matter, the defender cleary went to push down the striker
The mls is just a shame of a league
Only in the mls
why does america have 3g pitches in the mls ffs. it should be natural grass, it's the first tier of american football ffsssssss
Because they need to invade a country that has nice grass that they can steal and use for themselves, and they need to concoct a false flag terror attack for that to happen. Give it time. I hear North Korea has some lovely grass.
They think it’s American football or something ? Cuz they foul foul and foul
How is there so many pens in the MLS because in England there is hardly any
Because the referees are a bit more savvy when it comes to making the decision. They know, for the most part, when players are trying it on. Seems like in the MLS, they go completely-and-utterly by their interpretation of the laws of the game, which is fine in a sense, but following the laws this closely leads to a million more penalties.
Why so many penalty appeals
Joke of a league.
Why does the MLS manage their channel like theyre not actually a league
I know. Incredibly unprofessional content creator.
What a joke, this competition
Minute 5: 09 bullshit seriously keeper purposely does that.
*_USES AMERICAN FOOTBALL FIELD FOR A FOOTBALL GAME_*
I am curious, why dont the MLS have relegation, and promotion from the lower tier, like every other top division
There are a number of reasons:
1) Not enough teams.
2) They're trying to grow the sport and develop serious fan bases around the country. Were they to relegate a team, the fear is that that team would lose a lot of its following.
3) The stigma of relegation hurts the American psyche. It's considered something only losers would do, and Americans want to be amazing at everything.
And don't forget money. An incredible amount of money is needed by the original investors to start a new team, and if they know they could immediately go down at the end of the season, they would never agree to the risk. I agree though, relegation would be great. Bring up USL teams and let LA Galaxy play in some little sweat box, let a little USL club go play in those big parks. It'd be great.
roldan repping Pico Rivera
How does the mls make the wright-Phillips brothers look good
They ARE good. They're not amazing, but they're good. You're being unnecessarily harsh, I feel.
Revelian1982 have you seen the right Phillips brothers and you’re American
Is that a question followed by a statement or two questions? To save time, yes, I've seen the Wright-Phillips brothers play, and no, I'm thankfully not American.
Revelian1982 I’m so sorry and take back everything I say I’m so sorry I wasn’t civil about my disliking of the right-Phillips brothers, again sorry
It's okay, brother. You're entitled to your opinion. You don't need to apologize for anything. I just disagreed with you. That's all. Hey, for all I know, maybe you're right and I'm wrong. Take it easy.
MLF*
Smh that’s wat happened to me in my game.. and we lost 1-0 cuz that pen
You made some bad decisions
Really starting to like and care about mls. Am from Kenya where its all about the Premier league, la liga and our local premier league
You need to keep watching the Premier League, fam. Spanish League is just a bunch of diving, cheating bastards, who would rather win by getting opponents sent off than by outclassing them with the ball. Everyone hates the Spanish league now, because they've seen it for what it is. The Premier League is more entertaining, more competitive and more honourable.
6:35 no foul? Hahahahaha
Roldan is such a flopper...
Americans have obviously never seen English football
This guy doesn’t know what he’s talking about
Great calls by the refs. What a tough job!
If mls wants to be taken seriously in Europe why promote its own failures?
Because it's content that gets people talking. It's not all about brand protection.
MLS ref need more training
Americans and their soccer...ridiculous. So dependent on penalties since they can't shoot
USA at football or as they call it "soccer" and it's true I mean have you ever seen them get anywhere in the World Cup
Look, I'm all for the America-bashing, but you've got to get your facts straight. "Soccer" is an English term. It's an abbreviation of the word "Association". In England, there is more than one kind of football, so to differentiate between the codes, "Association Football" was given to what you and I call "football", hence the name "Football Association" or with FIFA, "Federation Internationale de Football Association". If you're going to pretend you're all high and mighty about football, this is a basic fact that you're going to need to get right, otherwise Americans (some of whom ARE actually quite knowledgeable) will rip you to shreds.
As for getting anywhere in the World Cup, you need to make sure you're not going to end up eating your words one day, because our precious little England has only won in once, and that was with two goals in the final that shouldn't have been allowed. I don't know how old you are, but there was a time when English people would take the piss out of the Spanish and the French for not ever winning a World Cup, yet look at them now, with one and two wins respectively. My point is that time changes a lot of things, and when you look at the USA, and how football, and the public's interest in football, is increasing at an exponential rate, if you couple that with the investment in infrastructure that will now be happening with the awarding of the Canusamex World Cup in 2026, then it's a recipe for eventual success.
I just don't want you to end up looking like a bit of an idiot if the USA DOES win the World Cup in the next twenty years, because I for one won't be surprised at all, should that happen.
You should be a refree
Did you mean that literally because if you did the you don't know what you're saying
This guys far too dramatic
MLS referees honestly don't know the rules
Is this..... Clickbait?!
why can't we have MLF refs in the laliga
What is wrong with This referee’s
Thats why mls sucks they dont have professional refs
is this official MLS ? im european ... just asking... because if it is than its shitier than i taught.
This is why mls sucks. People trying to make it so technical
Fifa has destroyed the game...
My Sunday league is better than this 😂
hi
Love this show!
Never this thing is complete trash. They don't know what they talk about
MLS is so bad compared to the premier league
British vs Englash football or "soccer" British wins by miles
Wtf is American football(soccer) all they do is look for penalties, that is bad.
who cares if his HAND IS IN A natural position im english if it touches his hand its handball
Handling the ball involves a deliberate act of a player making contact with the ball with the hand or arm.
The following must be considered:
the movement of the hand towards the ball (not the ball towards the hand)
the distance between the opponent and the ball (unexpected ball)
*the position of the hand does not necessarily mean that there is an offence*
A hand ball is a hand ball no matter what. It's the classic rules of football real football
Simon borg is clearly anti Seattle, but I’m shocked he vouched for Alonso. He is right that he won the ball clearly. Then he goes back to his selective viewing with the elbow to the face. Yes, it should have been a yellow, but they did not give a yellow. Also, a much lighter contact resulted in a yellow for Leerdam only moments earlier. And the fact it wasn’t even given as a foul in favor of Seattle is atrocious. Stop with the yelling Borg, it’s so annoying. Or don’t, I don’t care. You’re the reason I watch less and less of these videos.
Oh and there was nothing special about that Red Bulls/Crew penalty. The player was in the field of play and got dragged out. No shit that’s a penalty.
Bro this is his opinion. Relax fool. Go make your own videos if you want to make opinions
Alex Canas there is nothing opinion about the fact that he neglected to actually acknowledge what was controversial, that is just poor analysis.
Donovan is right, Alex. When it comes to absolute basics around the laws of the game, it's ISN'T about opinions. It's about facts. And this Borg person is demonstrating a lack of knowledge and an inconsistency that means he really shouldn't be making these videos.
Start at 2:30...... attacking player is tripped up outside the field of play at 3:30. Right?
According to Law 12: FOULS OFF THE PITCH (when the ball is still in play)
"When there is a foul OUTSIDE the field of play, a free kick is awarded on the boundary line nearest to the location of the foul. And if it's within the penalty area of the offending team, then it's a penalty".
OK Great. The ball was still in play when the foul occurred, as it was still on the pitch.......
But the foul at 3:00 was not within the penalty area as both opponents were off the pitch when the foul occurred.. If they were off the pitch when defending penalty area, how can the restart be a penalty kick? The penalty mark isn't even on or near the boundary line.
Did the ref get it wrong or is the announcer wrong about the restart area.
IMO the ref and the announcer can not both be right....Thanks
I think the foul was actually that at the end of the slide, the defender used his hand to grab the lower leg of the attacker. That was the trip. This happened outside the field of play. The ball, being in play, means it is a foul. A foul outside the field of play is considered to have happened at the boundary line closest to the foul. In this case, that point on the boundary line is where they just crossed, and that boundary line is part of the penalty area. Therefore, the foul is considered to have happened inside the penalty area. This is why it's a penalty kick.
lmao this is why the MLS is a joke. I mean many of these are very poor calls by the referee, and would never happen in Europe