A reminder that the news arm of the BBC has unaddressed institutional transphobia. You probably know all about this but here are some links if you need a refresher: . Council of Geeks has videos on the issue, here is one: th-cam.com/video/skh81N5lcYY/w-d-xo.html . Shaun has done several videos, here is the latest: th-cam.com/video/3F7GW7Ro4OQ/w-d-xo.html . Laura Kate Dale's speech outside the BBC: th-cam.com/video/hBjGnWkwAjI/w-d-xo.html
The first regeneration is so last minute and abrupt - and we know now Tenth Planet wasn't originally intended to be a regeneration story - that you can't help wondering that Hartnell blotted his copybook badly on location for the Smugglers and became so unforgivable that the BBC felt it had no alternative. They had contemplated changing Hartnell before during Celestial Toymaker but had ridden it out in the theory of "better the devil you know." Hartnell had even planned ahead for vacation breaks further along in season 4. You'd think such a momentous decision as changing the lead of such an important show would have been the results of many months careful planning, instead of being so abrupt.
I still maintain that power is one of the absolute best depictions of the Daleks in the show, with its only serious competition being Dalek (2005). I go back and forward on which story gets the daleks right the most, but both are sensational portrayals.
The thing about the Doctor sending troops to stall for time against the Daleks is something I always found interesting. Obviously, he values life. But the reason he might have been less tact about it was because all of this could have been prevented if they just listened to either him or their own common sense. Think about it. You're gonna immediately put these "Daleks" to work when you have no idea where they came from? I get that the colony was struggling, but that ain't a criticism. It's genius. It's how people are like in real life. They only see what they want. I love your take on the Cybermen too because you put them into words that I couldn't. They are Fuastian in that way. Like how I consider the Daleks to be so warped in their thinking like some lovecraftian horror, scaled down to our level. We'll never be on the same page and that to me, is terrifying because who knows what else is out there? How different are they in terms of psychology? "Why do Human beings kill human beings?" This is my favorite Dalek Line, ever. I'm glad someone took the time to make a video about it. You pretty much summed up my thoughts on what I think about regarding them.
interesting! i love the original animation so much more than the 'improved' one... i do not understand why everyone loves the 2nd one more. i rly love the nonverbal communication the doccy does with the recorder. Troughton with the recorder is my favourite thing he does. It is on a level with Jodie's face scrunches
You've got to remember but will never understand there wasnt alot to watch on a TV back then only media other than TV Newspapers or radio no repeats no video no dvd streaming NADA
Hey hey hey, i don't remember giving consent to Battles in Fandom being played and advertised...btw Ben here has been on 3 times already, An Awful Lot of Running A Doctor Who Podcast is available whenever you get your pods. Also what a great use of the Jack Reeves jumpscare
I was in such a manic state when doing Battles in Fandom that I have fully forgotten the weird stuff that came out my mouth (bar my correct "Rock" related suggestion)
Power is great, I personally prefer Evil though, it has stronger characters and The humanised Daleks are an amazing concept. I see the Cybermen as a representation of a flaw in many political philosophies, including Capitalism and Communism - That everything is a resource, including human lives and that they should be 'spent' in the most efficient and effective way possible. Not the biggest fan of the revivals interpretation of being only care about conversion, and are ultimately robots that use a brain as a CPU - It feels like they took a surface level interpretation of Spare Parts and never really deviated from it. The writers should dare to make them more then a worse version of the Borg.
A reminder that the news arm of the BBC has unaddressed institutional transphobia. You probably know all about this but here are some links if you need a refresher:
. Council of Geeks has videos on the issue, here is one: th-cam.com/video/skh81N5lcYY/w-d-xo.html
. Shaun has done several videos, here is the latest: th-cam.com/video/3F7GW7Ro4OQ/w-d-xo.html
. Laura Kate Dale's speech outside the BBC: th-cam.com/video/hBjGnWkwAjI/w-d-xo.html
That remix of the theme tune SLAPS!
This is quite possibly my favourite DW video essay I've seen. Consider me subscribed!
The first regeneration is so last minute and abrupt - and we know now Tenth Planet wasn't originally intended to be a
regeneration story - that you can't help wondering that Hartnell blotted his copybook badly on location for the Smugglers and became so unforgivable that the BBC felt it had no alternative. They had contemplated changing Hartnell before during Celestial Toymaker but had ridden it out in the theory of "better the devil you know." Hartnell had even planned ahead for vacation breaks further along in season 4. You'd think such a momentous decision as changing the lead of such an important show would have been the results of many months careful planning, instead of being so abrupt.
I still maintain that power is one of the absolute best depictions of the Daleks in the show, with its only serious competition being Dalek (2005). I go back and forward on which story gets the daleks right the most, but both are sensational portrayals.
The thing about the Doctor sending troops to stall for time against the Daleks is something I always found interesting. Obviously, he values life. But the reason he might have been less tact about it was because all of this could have been prevented if they just listened to either him or their own common sense. Think about it. You're gonna immediately put these "Daleks" to work when you have no idea where they came from? I get that the colony was struggling, but that ain't a criticism. It's genius. It's how people are like in real life. They only see what they want. I love your take on the Cybermen too because you put them into words that I couldn't. They are Fuastian in that way. Like how I consider the Daleks to be so warped in their thinking like some lovecraftian horror, scaled down to our level. We'll never be on the same page and that to me, is terrifying because who knows what else is out there? How different are they in terms of psychology?
"Why do Human beings kill human beings?" This is my favorite Dalek Line, ever. I'm glad someone took the time to make a video about it. You pretty much summed up my thoughts on what I think about regarding them.
I think this story is the first time we get a good look at the Dalek mutant after getting a small glimpse of one in The Daleks
The opening episode of trying to open the capsule reminded me of the Quatermass Experiment...though that may be a bit of a stretch, lol.
I'm glad someone decided to tackle one of the 60's stories
interesting!
i love the original animation so much more than the 'improved' one... i do not understand why everyone loves the 2nd one more.
i rly love the nonverbal communication the doccy does with the recorder. Troughton with the recorder is my favourite thing he does. It is on a level with Jodie's face scrunches
I'm glad I now have the context of this. 😃
@@johnsmith8906 omg how did u find me here
I'm subscribed. @@LucyliciousDoccyWho
@@johnsmith8906 how does that tell u about other people's videos I've commented on?
What do you mean? I'm subscribed to Vacuum of Comments and saw your comment.... @@LucyliciousDoccyWho
You've got to remember but will never understand there wasnt alot to watch on a TV back then only media other than TV Newspapers or radio no repeats no video no dvd streaming NADA
Hey hey hey, i don't remember giving consent to Battles in Fandom being played and advertised...btw Ben here has been on 3 times already, An Awful Lot of Running A Doctor Who Podcast is available whenever you get your pods.
Also what a great use of the Jack Reeves jumpscare
0:15 Asking the real questions fr fr.
Great video lad, really enjoyed it, so glad you could get it out!
I was in such a manic state when doing Battles in Fandom that I have fully forgotten the weird stuff that came out my mouth (bar my correct "Rock" related suggestion)
Ah, that defence. I blame being in a "manic state" for ...pretty much everything I create.
what IS with that volume jumpscare at the very end
Power is great, I personally prefer Evil though, it has stronger characters and The humanised Daleks are an amazing concept. I see the Cybermen as a representation of a flaw in many political philosophies, including Capitalism and Communism - That everything is a resource, including human lives and that they should be 'spent' in the most efficient and effective way possible. Not the biggest fan of the revivals interpretation of being only care about conversion, and are ultimately robots that use a brain as a CPU - It feels like they took a surface level interpretation of Spare Parts and never really deviated from it. The writers should dare to make them more then a worse version of the Borg.
Also, which version of POTD do you like best? The 2016 version or 2020 version?
Been a while since I've seen the 2016 version, haven't really compared them side by side. I think the 2020 version is the one on Iplayer
I had to go check my shelf as to which one I had, I didn't know they'd issued again, were there any significant changes? Mine is 2016