Bruckner: 4. Sinfonie (Fassung 1878/80) ∙ hr-Sinfonieorchester ∙ Eliahu Inbal
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 13 พ.ค. 2024
- Anton Bruckner:
4. Sinfonie (Fassung 1878/80) ∙
»Romantische«
(Auftritt) 00:00 ∙
I. Bewegt, nicht zu schnell 00:43 ∙
II. Andante quasi Allegretto 18:40 ∙
III. Scherzo. Bewegt - Trio. Nicht zu schnell. Keinesfalls schleppend. - Scherzo 33:56 ∙
IV. Finale. Bewegt, doch nicht zu schnell 45:10 ∙
hr-Sinfonieorchester - Frankfurt Radio Symphony ∙
Eliahu Inbal, Dirigent ∙
Alte Oper Frankfurt, 25. November 2016 ∙
Website: www.hr-sinfonieorchester.de ∙
Facebook: / hrsinfonieorchester - เพลง
Ich bin gegen die Abschaffung der Rundfunkgebühren, weil durch diese so wunderbare Musiker, wie das hr-Sinfonieorchester, finanziert werden.
Mit diesen guten Mikrofonen hört man sogar das Rascheln des Publikums. Wie schön, dass unser Rundfunkbeitrag für so großartige Orchester verwendet wird!
Bruckner’s symphonies will quench and moisturize your parched soul
I am grateful to God for being alive and healthy enough to be able to hear and enjoy such magnificent piece of music!
@Max E thanks!
tas re vivido
Yes! He’s amazing god and this person this person is blessed to be able to do this
Merveilleuse interprétation
Ce que j’aime avec cette symphonie c’est que tous les mouvements sont fantastiques
Le chef et l’orchestre (et la prise de son ) a la hauteur .
Un grand plaisir , merci!
I've been there in "Alte Oper Frankfurt" 2016. Performance and sound was incredibly good. It's a little bit ashaming, what the folks gave as a "thank you" to Inbal and the musicians. Later I met two of the musiscians in the metro and gave my best "Thanks to you", I was able to give. I asked, why the public was so ignorant, the answer: "They didn't know it." "What, really? It.s a famous work!" "No, not for the normal people. They only give big applause to the famous works!" It's sad, but true. For me it was a wonderful (h)ear experience!!! The orchestra is really gorgeous.
The people were just pacing themselves...LOL
Bruckner says
「My Symphonies are beautiful like the flowers of roses , and immeasurable , unfathomable and invincible , and are full of admiration and deep impression 」
From
Tokyo of the Land of the Rising Sun 🇯🇵
What a splendid, superb assembly of great musicians! Wow! This 4th is almost like a horn concerto. Hats off to the great 1st horn! They're all the best.
Your right
Really, Bruckner is the best of all symphonist s. Excellent recording and conducting. This is my most favourite piece of music
Finding this channel was like when Indiana Jones found the Ark of the covenant.
Jeff Duke totally agree with!
I totally agree also. Being a classical music nut discovering TH-cam was like discovering the Great Library at Alexandria...intact.
great music
Agreed, but will it also eventually become lost in a warehouse belonging to the United States Government Services Administration?
The applause doesn't do justice. This is actually one of the best performance of Bruckner No. 4 I've ever heard. Kudos to them
Yes. Read my comment above!
this is an absolute brilliant and beautiful performance of the 4th! Magnificent...still the greatest is Gunter Wand with NDR in 1990 th-cam.com/video/ziXfdU6iTp4/w-d-xo.html
That's one thing I notice about the audience featured in this channel's videos: the applause is rather underwhelming, even when it's a particularly spectacular ending.
@Max E I like to hope you are correct. Seems to me the German & Dutch audiences are VERY subdued in their appreciation of some very great codas.
@Max E Very well. Just that when I used to attend L.A. Philharmonic programs in the Mehta & Giulini days, we were unafraid to get off our butts when when a great finish brought us near to tears. Maybe Europe is spoiled.
I. Bewegt, nicht zu schnell ∙ 00:43
II. Andante quasi Allegretto ∙18:40
III. Scherzo. Bewegt - Trio. Nicht zu schnell. Keinesfalls schleppend. - Scherzo ∙33:56
IV. Finale. Bewegt, doch nicht zu schnell ∙ 45:10
Gott erhalte uns unsere wunderbaren Rundfunksinfonieorchester !!!
Bruckner ci porta via dalla terra verso altre dimensioni. La sua musica ha qualcosa di mistico, segno di una forte fede che io purtroppo non riesco a trovare!
Yes you are right his music is fantastic 🎉
2024/4/28高齡88歲的Eliahu Inbal(殷巴爾)將在台北的國家音樂廳指揮台北市立交響樂團(TSO)演出布魯克納第4號交響曲,令人盛情以待...
Göttlich,
wenn ein Werk und seine Umsetzung so gelingen wie in dieser Aufführung ❤️✨
Ich habe Tränen der Freude geweint über dieses Meisterwerk und seine gelungene Interpretation !
Danke! Danke! Danke !!!
Ich weiß kaum, wie ich meine Freude❤️ ausdrücken soll, - denn es ist ein Gottesgeschenk ✝️✝️✝️
Incredible conducting. I have never heard this orchestra sound better.
Lieber Gott,
ich glaube, dass Du mit diesem Meisterwerk Bruckners,
dem Dirigenten Eliahu Inbal
und den hervorragenden Musikern des Orchesters eine riesige Freude hast !
Danke für dieses wahrhaftig überirdische musikalisch-klangliche Erlebnis ❤❤❤
Vergelt‘s Gott tausendmal ✨✨✨🙏 !
✨✨✨🕯✨✨✨
A towering, epic reading, spectacularly paragraphed and phrased - lofty grandeur all the way, the
absolute beauty of the unattainable and the untouchable. Golden magnificence.
What a pleasure it is to listen to this ochestra's performance of Bruckner 4th symphony. Bravo Cheers...
The final pages of this wonderful score are like an ascent to Heaven and the doors opening to let you in. What a magnificent ending!
Well explained!!
Yes very some people just don’t make eny sense
The whole last movement seems a struggle between darkness and light--I think it's the most remarkable thing ever: such a kaleidoscope of emotions.
Ich liebe deine Beiträge zu sehen! Es ist immer eine große Freude, diesen Kanal zu öffnen und zu sehen, dass Sie Ihre Zuhörer nicht vergessen, denn jeden Monat etwas Neues und von außergewöhnlicher Qualität hat. Danke.
Last 3 minutes is a goosebump overload. Best ending to any symphony ever.
YES!!!!!! #8 is also pretty dang good too...but, this one is the best!
Stairway to Heaven!
I can’t wait tell the ending
You obviously haven't heard Mahler's 2nd, 3rd, 8th endings.
@@TC.....Mahler‘s endings aren’t bad either.
The horn solo in the beginning was so nice and smooth. The camera should have been focused at the horn player to capture the entrance moment, when the whole world rotates around that player.
May I thank the administration of this very fine Orchestra for this wonderful, wonderful performance. In London here I am denied all visits to concerts, and I am suffering as a result. But I have the great consolation of seeing and moreover hearing this utterly superb orchestra in the Bruckner 4th. Your wonderful concerts on TH-cam are a great help in these times. Thank you.
I totally agree with you. This orchestra is one of the finest in Europe and this performance of this magnificent symphony has to be one of the finest interpretations . Kudos all round to the orchestra ( what a 1st horn!! ) and Maestro Inbal.
@@BritinIsrael Thank you Mr. Clive... this orchestra is just totally outstanding. Why I ask myself have we not heard of their brilliance before? I cannot wait to get out to Frankfurt to hear them for myself... we are so lucky here to have wonderful performances by them... I agree with you about the first horn!!
Una magnifica sinfonia, ottimamente interpretata da un bravissimo direttore d'orchestra.
Simply the best performance I ever heard. What a richness of sound and colour!
This symphony has one of the best endings ever written!
Yes; magnificent!
yes it certainly does...moves me every time I hear the coda! Otherworldly!
@@markwalton2968 Is there a specific hour/minute/second mark when the "coda " begins...? Thank you--
@@richrol58 Yes 1:03:02 the beginning of the greatest ending of any symphony. Pure Heaven.
Bruckner's 5th and 8th also have exceptional endings. Bruckner had a knack for writings codas.
Bruckner is amazing
Majestätische Aufführung dieser majestätischen Sinfonie. Die seidigen Töne aller Streicher und die milden Töne aller Holzbläser sind besonders eindrucksvoll. Das ist Bruckner!
Wow. Inbal is a great conductor, especially in Bruckner. Kudos.
Bruckner hat schon immer gezeigt, dass er ein ganz Grosser ist. Ein ganz ganz genialer Komponist. Ich bin stolz aus seinem Land zu kommen. Bravo Anton Bruckner👏🏻👌🏻👍🏿
Bin auch aus seinem Land und kann dies alles nur vollinhaltlich teilen!
eu sou da rua Áustria no Brasil acho esta música plana sem dinâmica, chata e com frases muito batidas, falta criatividade.
Why did you do a dark thumbs up emoji?
@@nicoqueiroz8637😅😅😅😅
Es gibt natürlich auch Deppen hier.@@nicoqueiroz8637
Damn, that guy nailed the opening horn solo.
Barletta Francesco Roma.Bruno Walter grande direttore del secolo scorso soleva dire di Bruckner che nella sua musica aveva trovato DIO! Al contrario di Mahler il quale avendolo cercato falli' sempre anche scrivendo musica altrettanto bella.L'orchestra di Francoforte e il direttore Imbal sono eccezionali. Grazie grazie mille.Bravi a tutti, soprattutto agli ottoni. Veramente avete suonato divinamente!!!!😊😊😊😊😊😊❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️👍👍👍
Gran Maestro Eliahu Inbal ! Extraordinaria orquesta ! Que versión !
Ich sollte mir unbedingt mal eine derartig schöne Aufführung in einem Konzertsaal anhören! Besuchte schon viele Jazz und Rock Konzerte, aber mit dem alter kam erst das Gehör für die "wirklich schöne Musik"! 👌🏼
Yes you are right
I want to as well
Wow, love how Inbal interprets the strings in the coda!!! That is a beautiful interpretation I have yet to hear and I listen to lots and lots of Bruckner.
I cannot agree more with you. Maybe it's this particular revision of this great symphony but the sound of the strings accompanying the brass in the final pages has never sounded so magnificent. Kudos to this wonderful orchestra and Maestro Inbal for giving us a unique performance. I have lost count of the number of times i return to this recording.
Me too. I just wrote the same, a year later! And I had not scene your comment. We must both be right.
I think it is achieved by the leader and some others playing the notes on the beats as accented quavers [?} rather than the continual semiquavers, if my eyes do not deceive me from the glimpses of bowing we get.
As palavras não vem fáceis para elogiar esta sinfonia. Final enriquecido com um suave toque melancólico, evocando sentimentos que transcendem a razão. Glorioso!
I like this because this makes sense and some peeps don’t and you can tell what is happening by the music 🎵
In this performance,
all is full of far superior splendor amazing
Nice opening horn solo!
Cette symphonie de Bruckner mérite bien son surnom de "romantique" . Très expressive et emprunte de thèmes cycliques, elle est ainsi une des plus populaires et sans doute la plus facile d'accès de l'univers de ce grand compositeur germanique.
.L'orchestre et son chef sont ici remarquables mais je ne peux m'empêcher d'avoir une pensée plus particulière pour les instrumentistes à vent notamment les cuivres !
Großes Lob an die Tontechniker. Da kommt kaum eine CD-Aufnahme ran an die Klangqualität. Als ob man direkt im Publikum sitzen würde. Das Orchester und Dirigent freilich „spielen“ auch virtuost! Eine phänomenale Aufnahme.
Sehr ausdrucksstark. Wagnerisch und trotzdem leicht.
Wunderbar !
There is some music that lies beyond criticism, and this symphony is a prime example; it is magnificent and emotionally and spiritually transcendent, realized here in a truly great performance.
@@conw_y If I have to read one more comment like this under a classical music recording I will kill myself.
Yes it ‘tis
Not really. It's full of unfinished melodies and cut motifs (trait of romantic music in general as composers tried to mimic Beethoven but couldn't). Next, there are plenty of cliches you can instantly recognize Viennese school from. It's far from emotional. I actually like it because of coldness and calculated composition. The truth is, it's too long. Whole material could be fitted into 45 minutes easily. Especially later parts are unnecessary, at 47:49 it should have ended. I would be giving you a medal if you can point at anything new past this point. 4th part sucks in general, it's like Bruckner tried to present four or five different endings of symphony one after each other for listeners to choose the one they like most. Also, its sound is overcrowded with brass section making listening a tiring experience. Next, separation between parts is unclear, all of them sounding kinda lethargic. Next, it's just not good enough. Bruckner tries to milk a few motifs in as many ways as he can never actually developing a theme or finishing even single melody. I can't hear music moving anywhere. Of course in major it's down to calculated structure of symphony. I hate places such as this at 25:32 when orchestra and audience are put in rehearsal mode.
@@alicaramba7680so pretentious lmao
"Trying to be Beethoven"
Bruckner and his peers expanded the tradition of Beethoven and made it more colorful imo
One especially magical detail in the ending of the 1st movement - listen to the theme played by the violas (17:10) then taken up by the violins (17:40). It's a "preview" of the theme from the Trio of the 3rd movement (38:28)! 🤩
Thanks for pointing that out! There's lots of these cross-references in each Bruckner symphony, and it's nice each time one notices a new one :)
This theme also occurs in the Scherzo of Mahler's Resurrection Symphony 😳
See e.g. at 0:46 of th-cam.com/video/bBhy505-UnE/w-d-xo.html
Absolut ergreifend ❤❤❤
✝️✝️✝️🙏
The end is amazing it’s the best part! 😊🎉😊🎉
Прекрасное звучание,,спасибно за. Запись
0:42 begins | 18:42 2nd movement | 29:54 beginning of gentle wake up | 33:57 3rd movement | 45:10 4th movement
53:17 is just such an amazing moment😍
totally agree!
Superb piece of Bruchner, thanks.
Bruckner! He is sometimes confused with Bruch.
Simply wonderful, magnificent , transcends the physical senses
Just wonderful and beautiful performance and orchestra~!! Thank You All~!!!!!!
Großartig! Vielen Dank für diese Aufnahme. ❤️
I have to do this for school and I am very glad that I can listen to this because it’s amazing
Música que penetra na alma e nos deixa mais serenos. Maravilha!
Fabulous! Loved the slower buildup to the end. Bravo.
Listen to Celibidache and you'll faint...
@@richrol58 From boredom
Another wonderful recording from my favourite european orchestra.
It's hard for me to think of any performance of anything ever that is better than this.
This orchestra is impressing me more and more. I wish DG would give them a contract. Remember INBAL recorded a Mahler/DENON cycle with them - excellent Mahler.
Thanks for sharing that. I like Mahler. Going to check it out now that you mention. I find this recording to be really well done, therefore, naturally you got me interested. 😌✌🏻
Inbal recorded a Bruckner cycle with them as well. Years ago. On Warner.
Eine sehr gute Bruckner Darbietung!!!
With this symphony, for me, is that amazing, extraordinary crushed note the horn plays in the climax movement 3. It’s like the earth’s core has just opened up in slow motion
The first horn part in Bruckner's 4th is a dream part.In this wonderful performance ( and recording) i have never heard such brilliant individual instrumental playing . the closing pages never fail to make my hair stand on end . Only in this Inbal performance do you hear the beautiful repetetive strings backing the brass and wind instruments in those final glorious pages.
Really love the brisk tempo of the 4th movement. What a great orchestra!!! That hall is so fine. I adore my Bernstein/Vienna Phil. Mahler 5th recorded there.
Great Tempi! Great Conductor! Thanks!
Piękne wykonanie Wspanialej Symfonii!
I really love interpretation of Inbal. So much good tempi and rubati. Can't listen another Conductor interpretations.
Love it too, but imho, Celibidache's interpretation is above all the others.
Inbal is a modern master in the grand old tradition
Con todo mi afecto me sumo a los aplausos. Y muchas gracias hr-Sinfonieorchester.
2nd movement at 24:40 that theme with that unexpected joy and those little "jumps" always fill my soul with happiness!
To listening to Bruckner is to approach in the realm of God .
It is awesome; marvellous!!! Thank you so much All!
Impresionante versión de una de mis sinfonías preferidas de Bruckner. Desde el principio, hasta el apoteósico final, todo va maravillosamente, con unos solistas en estado de gracia y un conjunto que brilla como nunca. Esta es mi orquesta favorita, a la que tengo por una de las mejores del mundo, y aquí lo demuestra con creces. El director, preciso, de una gran expresividad. Excelente sonido, realización buena, se oyen los aplausos y se ve los saludos de los músicos, ¿qué más se puede pedir? Ah, claro: estar allí, en directo, alguna vez...
wonderful! thank you for sharing on you tube ⚘⚘⚘
Maravillosa interpretacion
Every time I hear the first movement of this glorious work, I envision rays of sun emerging from the glories of Heaven.
Bruckner: Hates hunting
Also Bruckner: Creates one of the best hunting musics there is 33:56
tolle aufführung beeindruckend schön.
even if I wouldn't be amazed by all of this piece, I would listen to this one hour of music. Just for the overwhelming coda. simply incredible.
This coda is one of the best piece of music ever written ; ;
Excellent performance!
Wunderschön!!
Inbal and this orchestra have a really great past together. He made one the best Mahler cycles ever with them.
Quotenwagnerianer. He made one of the worst Berlioz cycles ever with them.
He also did a great Bruckner cycle, unfortunately of the original scores.
"Unfortunately"?! The original scores are, with the exception of the 8th Symphony, vastly superiour to all later iterations.
We're essentially talking about 1,2 and 4, apart from 8. I agree with you about 8,and 1, but I don't understand how anyone can prefer the original 3 and 4. They are embryos...
3 is vastly superiour in it's first two versions. The 3rd version is an abomination that he should never have wasted his precious time with. He should have worked on the 9th instead of further mutilating the 3rd.
By the way there is a reason why Bruckner did not destroy the original versions, like for example Brahms who would not publish anything until he was done with all revisions.
Bruckner considered his original versions to be just as valid as the revised versions.
Fantastic!
superb!
Aww it was a cute finale and a nice performance. Very difficult symphony
I love you
Johnny !!!
Excellent
O M G this is love
at first hearing.
Amazing Bravissimi!!!!
Ich grüße Euch aus der Ortenau (Schwarzwald).
Inbal’a 7th is legendary!
El principal de corno es muy bien!!
Great.
The chord progression in tge end ist just sooo wonderful! Does sb know the exact chords?
1) Although Bruckner would have analyzed the chords using 18th century European figured bass, I have chosen 20th century American jazz chord terminology, but with having to choose between function and enharmonic simplicity (I wasn't going to write down double flatted chords).
2) From the best that I can hear and in the key of Eb Major:
1:03:02 = Eb unison, Cb Major, Eb unison, Cb Major, Eb unison, Cb Major
1:03:30 = Ab Minor/Eb, Eb Major, F Diminished Minor/Eb, Eb Major
1:03:40 = Ab Minor, Eb Minor/Gb, Cb Major - Cb Major 7th, Eb Sus/Bb - Eb Minor/Bb
1:03:50 = Ab Minor 6th, Eb open fifth, add 2/Bb, Eb Minor/Bb - Eb open fifth, add 2/Bb, Ab Minor/Cb, Eb Sus/Bb - Eb Minor/Bb,
1:03:59 = F Diminished Minor/Cb, Eb open fifth, add 2/Bb, Ab Minor
1:04:09 = Eb unison, Cb Major, Eb unison, Eb Major, Eb unison, Cb Major
1:04:27 = Eb Unison, Fb Major (enharmonically becoming E Major)
1:04:36 = A Minor, G Major, C Major, B Major, E Major, Eb Major, Ab Minor, Gb Major, Cb Major, Bb Major, Ab Minor, Gb Major
1:05:03 = Fb Major
1:05:12 = Eb Major
3) Starting at 1:04:09 and particularly at 1:04:36 on through to the end, the strings play a triplet figure that increases the harmonic tension of each chord, in many instances by playing non-chord tones on the downbeats of the first of two successive triplets. These string triplets are something like what the dying Mozart referred to as "the fire" as he dictated his Requiem to Salieri in the film version of Amadeus.
It is a sequence of 14 simple major/minor triads (the most basic of all chords), but a very unusual sequence, and ending with the flattened supertonic (in this case F flat) which is a particularly unusual chord. And yet it all sounds so natural and inevitable. The context of the "scale" notes played by the strings may be an essential factor too.
Here B shows his unsurpassed mastery of harmony. In the ending of the 7th he goes on to show his mastery of something more (which doesn't have a technical name).
53:34 sembra un coro di voci umane
Wow what a great performance . Tempii perfect, very inspiring direction from Inbal, and an outstanding first horn player ( who has such an important role to play). And the recording is fantastic. Bruckner's symphonies should be an essential part of all concert planning. Let's have less Mozart, Schubert, Haydn and more more more Bruckner! His adagios must surely have been sent by SMS from Heaven.
That's it!
Great performance by a great orchestra. A bit too fast I think
Minimal conducting maximum sound,excellent performance.
Eliahu Inbal prooves to be not only made for Mahler, he is brilliant in Bruckner too.
And of course all credits for the orchestra which is my favourite TH-cam orchestra. Splendid, both musical and visual.
@@janmannee4391And all credits to the superb recording technicians.
A great performance! Inbal and the band are in fine form. What's with the lukewarm response from the audience? It does not get much better than this!