Martin D28: Sitka vs Adirondack Spruce | Guitar Battles
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 ส.ค. 2024
- For our 20th Anniversary, we asked the Martin Custom Shop to build us some 'standards' with an Adirondack Spruce top and Adirondack Spruce bracings. Today, we'll be putting this D28 Adirondack next to the standard re-imagined Martin D28. Let us know in the comments which one you thought was best!
Martin D28 Adirondack TFOA 20th Anniversary LTD: www.tfoa.eu/en...
Martin D28 Reimagined: www.tfoa.eu/en...
"New Arrivals" every Friday @ 16:00! / New video every Sunday at 16:00!
Thank you very much for watching! If you like what you see please take a moment to like and share this video! Want more TFOA? Here are the places where you can find us!
Facebook: www.facebook.c...
Instagram: / thefellowshipofacoustics
Pinterest: / pins
Twitter: / tfoaguitars
Website: www.tfoa.eu/en/
Any feedback or other questions? Comment below or send us a message!
For the fingerstyle part with Coen's lighter touch I clearly preferred the Reimagined. But for strumming and a heavier touch the Adirondack brings more headroom, power and body.
Hello guys , in my opinion , the reimagined sounds way better than the adi 20th one… I would pick it without any hesitation ! Thanks for the review.
I would NOT say way better , but I agree it did sound better . I'd a chose the re-imagined to .
The accoustic fellows are back!!!
:D
I liked both of these, and I had to listen on headphones to hear the difference between these two D-28 models. For 600 less Euro, I'd probably take the Sitka topped D-28 as I liked it's tone. But, I don't lack for Adi topped Martin Dreads here at the house. I own a CS-Bluegrass-2016, and a D-18 Authentic 1939 Aged. Great video to celebrate your 20th Anniversary.
Oof, I remember having one of those CS Bluegrass'. That guitar packed a punch! Thanks for commenting :)
Happy 20th birthday guys! Great work.
What would I like to see? Ok, exactly this-
I'd like to see direct comparisons with Martin dreads and Faith Guitar dreads (Rosewood and Mahogany B&Sides). So, expensive v inexpensive.
Ditto different body shapes, expensive/inexpensive.
So we can see what we're getting for the money.
Thanks! Good one, sadly we don't have Faith in stock...
Finger-picking
Adi 0:28 Sitka 1:09
Strumming
Adi 1:51 Sikta 2:25
Yea I would say the Adi spruce hands down has more power to it and get up. Anyone that doesn’t hear that is have to question their reasoning. Is it because they don’t have an Adi top guitar or what? If I can save enough money up I’m going to get me one of those HD 28 Addies.
Agreed. And anyone saying Addy isn't warm is also wrong. Give it a year or so.
Great comparison! Side by side, the Adirondack was maybe a bit crisper to my ear. If not side by side, I'd probably never be able to tell the difference.
The adirondack (to me) sounds earthier, dryer, wilder (a bit like Australian bunya).
Nice idea!!! I prefer the sound of Adirondack in general. Rounder, more in the bass and treble. Everything I like ;) I've never been a fan of the very pronounced Martin mediums. For this, I have always preferred big Gibson, I don't very like small guitars (000). Here, the Adirondack seems to erase these mediums a bit. I really like.
Mids you mean? Martin isn't known for pronounced mids
@@el34glo59 That's the first time I've read that ;) On the contrary, the Martins have very pronounced mids. Even on their Dreadnoughts. Just compare an HD28 to a Hummingbird (despite being designed with woods that bring out the midrange) or, worse, to an SJ200. This is also why Martins generally sound louder than Gibsons. I've had 4 of them, including a J40 and an HD28V, logically designed to favour low frequencies. Their mediums were much more pronounced than on my Gibsons. It's very personal, but I prefer the V signature of Gibson guitars. That's one of the reasons why I like my SJ200TV so much. I've never found that sound anywhere else. Even with rival brands that have stolen the design and the woods.
Yes
Both are sounding very Good! ... and great to know: Martin wants a Martin ... :) ...
Well done boys!
Haha, yes he does! :p
Take your time with Adirondack!. Sometimes it takes some years, but then you blow the Sitkapspruce away! Customshop or not......
Exactly, it needs to loosen up!
Adi seemed a tad brighter and the Reimagined almost seemed to have a touch more bottom end to my ears. Cool comparison. They say Adis open up over the years and Im experiencing that with my Yairi right now (which is Adi topped).
True! Adirondack can open up quite a bit over time. Enjoy your guitar!🎸
Great playing cool speck great idea.
Thanks Ryan!
The Sitka sounds bassier to me
sitka has a voice, addy has a choir
Nicely put Bill! Sometimes you need a choir, sometimes you just want a voice ;)
0:27 Adirondack
1:09 Sitka
Anyone notice neither guitars have a strap button ?
Yes. These guitars are new, unused. The strap buttom comes with the guitar. It's up to you to insert it!
Eric is exactly right! :)
@@ericouicestmoimeme is the slot already there for the button or exactly what do you mean? Do I have to go drilling the hole for the button? If so yikes
@@R.L.Humpert Yes ! A hole is already drilled. All you have to do is insert the piece of plastic that comes with the guitar.
@@ericouicestmoimeme thanks bro
Sitka for me all day long. I’m biased from gigging my Sitka 1999 HD-28 for the last 23 years, but In this back to back the Sitka has more ‘tone’.
Is it possible to make the same video with the om28 (sitka vs adi)???
Possible for sure! If we still have an Adi OM28 that is ;)
Can you do a battle between the sitka and adi 000-18?
If we can, yes!
Adi top would open up more after 3 years or so
Addy
ADIRONDACK IS GENERAL END OF STORY!
General Adirondack! 🫡
I think the same player must play both guitars
We do in the newer video's :)
What are you playing man? I cannot hear your guitar sound.
You guys need to be more enthusiastic
Gotta live up to that TikTok life