ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 เม.ย. 2024
- Laurence Tribe joins MSNBC’s Lawrence O’Donnell to discuss his reaction to the Supreme Court’s arguments on Donald Trump’s claim of presidential immunity and the “shameful performance by the court basically buying the very time that Trump wanted.”
» Subscribe to MSNBC: / msnbc
Download our new MSNBC app for the latest breaking news and daily headlines at a glance: www.msnbc.com/information/dow...
Follow MSNBC Show Blogs
MaddowBlog: www.msnbc.com/maddowblog
ReidOut Blog: www.msnbc.com/reidoutblog
MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House, The ReidOut, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and Alex Wagner who brings her breadth of reporting experience to MSNBC primetime. Watch “Alex Wagner Tonight” Tuesday through Friday at 9pm Eastern.
Connect with MSNBC Online
Visit msnbc.com: www.msnbc.com/
Subscribe to the MSNBC Daily Newsletter: link.msnbc.com/join/5ck/msnbc...
Find MSNBC on Facebook: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Twitter: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Instagram: / msnbc
#SCOTUS #Trump #immunity
![[柴犬ASMR]曼玉Manyu&小白Bai 毛发护理Spa asmr](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/0TsXQ7z2Dh4/mqdefault.jpg)
Laurence Tribe is exactly right, all of this is shameless and embarassing.
He is too polite.
Why don’t they switch the question from
Political Opponent to SCOTUS ?
Not embarrassing. Dangerous.
He’s been wrong the whole time.
@@zdwadesays the constitutional law expert. 🤔
SCOTUS which has historically been the bastion of the Constitution has lost credibility. The mental gymnastics left me nauseated
Me too. The refusal to hear "facts," was egregious. There was zero case law discussed, but rather, nothing but hypotheticals and suppositions.
There you go, thanks Mitch.
For me, they lost all credibility when 3 of them lied under oath about their position re. Roe v. Wade during their confirmation hearings. Chief Justice Roberts lost his, far as I'm concerned, when he sat in on the Senate's dereliction of Constitutional duty (blocking evidence for Trump's impeachment) without comment, & Justice Thomas apparently never had any.
These Supreme Court Justices MUST BE HELD ACCOUNTABLE. Remove the lifetime appointment and hold these corrupt Republican justices accountable. This is so unacceptable.
SCOTUS decision
Maybe we should think about the issue in a different perspective:
Maybe we don’t need to worry about Supreme Court declaring there is immunity …!!!
Think about it …
The Supreme Court rules that absolutely immunity exists …. according to trump‘s lawyer, that means that a sitting president can order seal team 6 , to take out a corrupt political opponent…
That’s just great!!🎉🎉
That means Biden can legally order that a corrupt multiply indicted former presidential narcissistic psychopath be taken out…
Problems solved !!!
Which ever way SCOTUS decides on this issue, US wins.
By the way, Biden could take advantage of the decision, to take care of a couple of greedy, corrupt, political hacks masquerading as Supreme Court justices !!!
Look forward to Karma coming back to investigate Thomas, and,
also who paid off Kavanaugh’s personal bills he owed before his appointment.
Only to you commies.
@@MaryReese-oy8is Take your meds
The SHOE SEEMS TO GET REAL TIGHT WHEN ITS ON THE OTHER FOOT.!
How is Clarence Thomas STILL a SC justice ? He should have been dismissed years ago !!
Dismissed and brought up on bribery charges
Should have never been appointed to begin with.
If AG Garland would be true to is oath of office he could indict Ginni for treason. which requires Thomas to resign.
Unfortunately, there's no mechanism in place to dismiss a SC justice. That needs to change.
These Supreme Court Judges should not have a life time term but a 15 to 20 year term.
VOTE BLUE. Let's fix this corruption. Pass ethics rules for ALL justices. We've had enough of this BS.
YES!!!
Voting will not be enough.
If Biden is re-elected, which seems more and more likely, and the Congress is Democrat expansion can be possible.
Yea that’s worked out so far……
Reform reform reform
SCOTUS shouldn’t be for a lifetime, everyone 8 years and out
Thomas, Alito and Gorsuch should be lifetime in jail. Add to that a ten year sentence for Roberts.
I'd go with 13 years (and 13 Justices -- one per circuit), then one justice gets replaced each year.
Great idea. It will never work. The term limits are baked into the constitution
@@fred_derf that's not a bad shout
@@fred_derf Too long
These justices forever be remembered by history as the court who allowed democracy to die. Their great grandchildren will learn how they had the most important job in the country, and they let our country down.
The Dems also share blame. Pelosi should have gaveled in impeachment proceedings right after they certified the election and Garland should have indicted Trump the moment he was confirmed. Treat the insurrection like the emergency it was rather than the political opportunity they thought it was.
This is going to be taught in world history for many decades. The world is watching. All the sane people hope that democracy will prevail.
Not just allowing injustice, they are complicit!!!
Agree with Tribe 100% this Court Performance is Shameful!! Absolutely Shameful!!
Why is the Government not pointing out that in 44 previous presidencies this has not been an issue? 🤦♀️
That came up a couple times during arguments.
I dont know. Is it?
@@thesaw9988 Ask stupid questions, get stupid answers. No President has ever asked for or NEEDED immunity from prosecution for 88 felonies before. Trump is "special".
Exactly my thoughts!!!
Justice Jackson alluded to it as well. She actually made the point that NONE of this has ever been issue previously and she is 100% accurate
Wow we the people really need to start protesting the CORRUPTION of the SCOTUS!!!
I thought so too, cos now they are acting with impunity, they don't even care ,they are daring us with these rulings,
This is a landmark ruling that WILL change history forever. SCOTUS isn't being rational enough to understand the repercussions of immunity for future presidents. If this is given. . . the rioting will begin. The orange grump (blowhard and sore loser) is not a king. He needs to be put in his place - in prison.
And start protesting at their homes again right?
Unfortunately wont help. They are in the position of power , do not need our vote have no worries of being removed.
These things need to be prevented . It was predictable .
Only hope is vote blue across the board even if some Republicans seem ok and against Trump because they put these Justices on the bench and they did it intentionally and others are asleep😴or 🙉🙈like Cheney. Happy she woke up but why did she not see the train coming ? Many of us saw the danger long ago.
A justified impeachment instead of the idiotic impeachments maga has tried against biden
I am a lawyer in Australia and have been watching what’s happening in the US since Jan 6 . How D Trump can be a presidential candidate again despite the myriad of legal issues he currently faces is simply beyond me. I am very nervous about where the bastion of western liberal democracy (USA) is currently heading ..
America is not any where close to being western liberal democracy. Liberals are part of the American Citizens and they may even outnumber the Center and center right. But since the vast Majority of them are centered in just a few states political that have little power. Also America is not and never was a Democracy. That like every other form of Goverment was debated and rejected when America was being born. America is a Constitutional Republic. The American Goverment only has Authority that is expressly granted in the body and text of the Constitution. All other authority is reserved to the States. This is why many do not understand America. All guidelines rules laws about who can and can not run for President are also set out in the US Constitution,. Unlike the Federal Judges and SC Justices that are granted Lifetime Appointments in the Constitution When FDR was in his 3rd tern the Constitution was Amended to limit the number of Terms to two.
Until the amendment's ratification, the president had not been subject to term limits, but both George Washington and Thomas Jefferson (the first and third presidents) decided not to serve a third term, establishing the two-term tradition.
Ma’am, I am afraid here in the USA, watching my country move from a democracy towards a dictatorship. I thought we were better than this, all the checks and balances are failing and now SCOTUS.
Because there is no crime thus far! The dems are scraping the bottom of the barrel for evidence but have found little to none . It’s all about hate for Trump but they idolize the demented piece of flesh inhabiting the White House.
SCOTUS has completely lost any sense of credibility, which is just awful.
There is presidential immunity. obama used it in 2009.
Clearly points out the need for reform...
13 justices
Term limits
@@charlie-obrien Well, Biden had control of the senate and congress in 2020 but they just focused on trump. So what will it take to reform?
@@carlocalingasan998
You might recall, he was dealing with the pandemic and the effects of a thwarted insurrection.
Besides there was still Sens Manchin and Sinema to handle.
@@charlie-obrien Ah you are saying he is not good enough to handle too many issues at the same time?
"Justices" delaying are Justices denying. This bunch is truly disgusting.
Yes, if by bunch you mean the conservatives.
Well at least some them continually appear to be totally corrupt. We will know who when the decision comes down.
Agree 💯 truly disgusting
Absolutely. Agreed.
Why is a delay so upsetting to you, if they have to go back to lower courts to hash out the legal issues so they are following the law? I do not u def stand. We all want ourselves and our loved ones to have every effort to make sure the law is followed if we are in a court situation, yet you seem upset if it happens in this case?
Why hasn't Clarence been recused: his wife was involved in this case?
Who is going to make him?
Donald J Trump,🎉🎉
The Teflon Don,
The Next President of US 2024,
I love all of this😂😂
@@kaypakaipa8559...
the biggest loser 👏
BUT HER TEXT MESSAGES😭😭😭
I agree they all in cahoots with one another
The fact that NO justice member, nor elected official in the past 240+ years ever THOUGHT that this would/could ever need to be spelled out, says EVERYTHING you need to know about Trump. And the fact that the Supreme Court’s answer wasn’t immediate and concise, says EVERYTHING you need to know about the inadequacy and partisanship in our highest court.
Thank you Professor Tribe for stating the obvious this has gone on long enough! SMH
Tribe...a lawyer knowingly lying to get paid by MSNBC...
They should be ASHAMED, a total disgrace.
Money grabbers feel no shame, ask DJT.
Pointless to say they should be ashamed. They know no shame, therefore they don't know that they should be.
Shame requires self-awareness which is in very short supply in today's GoP
As ashamed as the demon possessed Joe Biden is on the World stage?
So what?
Are there any patriots that gonna do anything? Other than hope.
Your plan: give up when the cheaters don't stop.
Remembrance day: Am I a joke to you?
What a joke of a “supreme” court
What a Joke "Bidens America" and the World is Laughing ...Smile at the Gas Pump and Market Fool ...
Well said Professor Tribe!
Four justices have shown that they don't belong on the court
They already showed their true colors by accepting the case and waiting untill the last possible day to schedule a hearing. I doubt they are going to actually rule in Trump's favor but they are pushing a narrative that it is a broad question that needs to be narrowed down in the lower courts before they can address it. In other words, delay Trump's trial.
These guys are going to be a real stain on our history.
They don't care - they're praying for the rapture.
They don't care, they believe they have the final say, and they have no checks and balances,that need to hapoen, the reason we must vote to change things,else it is over.
They are a strain right NOW.
Our history may soon be over. Wake up, America!
hm. There was a large stain to that to start with.
Justice Jackson showing her brilliance to being on the US Supreme Court.
The MOST qualified on paper AND professionally. She proved It
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
I So Agree!!
Fantastic appointment- this can’t make up however for the horrible choice of Garland.
@@johnnycashlesscomedy8616Have you read any of his decisions from his days on the bench? Maybe you should.
Is that sarcasm? Hard to tell sometimes
When can we close down this inferior court & replace them with honorable justices
❤ Lawrence O'Donnell your program is so informative and intelligent.
Thank you, Lawrence and bless you!!!!❤
I am so glad that justice Jackson is there to do right by citizens!!!
Thank you Amen 🙏
She can't do it alone. She needs 4 allies on the Court. A minority opinion is just that: only an opinion. VOTE BLUE like our lives depend on it, because they do.
The MOST QUALIFIED
However, Justice Jackson needs to have an actual Majority to dismiss this RIDICULOUS Case. Moreover, there is the "Rule Of Four" (It Takes FOUR JUSTICES To Decide To Hear A Case Before The SCOTUS). Those Four Justices Should Be REMOVED IMMEDIATELY. This MCCONNELL Constructed SHAM OF A SCOTUS Is Simply SHAMEFUL
What’s that? Let corrupt career politicians get away with crimes and then allow those same criminals get away with it?
We need to end lifetime appointments to the bench. They’re crooked individuals
16-18 years would be reasonable.
Only 10 year terms! 😠
You would still get partisan hacks nominated. I would prefer an independent non partisan body selecting judges, yes term limits are a good idea.
Wha wha wha. Keep crying. You wouldn’t be saying that if the Supreme Court was full of democrat anti Trump judges just like the judges in most of Trump’s bogus court cases are
I only heard all 9 highly articulate, intelligent, thoughtful judges. But then, I was listening without bias.
Shame on this supreme Court justice
I don't expect anything less than total BS from this current SCOTUS!
What a bunch of cowards! We need to throw away the rule of law because someone could be wrongly prosecuted? Are these judges even qualified to teach kindergartens about law?! A president should do the right thing no matter what consequences they might face. No patriot needs immunity from the justice their own country exercises.
They are all members of The Federalist Society cult, believe in a ruling king of their choosing. The society has been working on this for years, stacking the highest court for just this situation. They need to be exposed to all Americans and stopped
Cool. Now we can prosecute Obama for murdering thousands with drones, including women, children, and U.S. citizens.
Well you shouldn't prosecute anyone for anything in case they are innocent according to that logic. Ridiculous coming from a judge. How desperate are they to help Trump
@paulpease8254 Yep and they can be cowards all they want because its not going to stop us people from getting answers as to why any supreme court justice would go against the oath they swore to!At least 77 million of us are going to want to hear their answer! Voting blue to protect our women's rights and our Republic! Biden/Harris 2024!
The Supreme Court is in the process of 'throwing away the law', if POTUS is immune from all preosecution he then becomes 'The Law'. If Trump as president is immune from all prosecution then Biden is immune from all prosecution and can dispose of SCOTUS at will.
This is about the Supreme Court delaying for Trump. It's shameful. Day one it should have been thrown out.
The corrupt Supreme Court should have nev er taken this case, then they slow walked it a d it will not make a decision in a timely manner. Maybe they are afraid of the Trump maga bunch? They are CORRUPT COWARDS
It should never have been taken up by the Supreme Court in the first place.
@@CB-my5ue No it shouldn't have, agree. This is all so wrong.
@@windorsolarplease4314 It’s a loophole they’re pursuing.
Like most of the criminally-inclined.
IiKR the UnSupreme Court a total judicial embarrasment to America 🇺🇸 on a whole period 💯 SMH 🙄🙉
They should be impeached immediately.
Even if Dems win majority in both houses, Biden will never change the status quo. NEVER NO MATTER WHAT
Thank you, Professor Tribe and Mr. O'Donnell. Wise voices that can be heard by all people are necessary to heal this horrific insanity in our country.
Some of the Supreme Court Justices are riding Trump's CLOWN MAGA WAGON ... Good grief 🙄
The highest court in the USA with the most corrupt and lowest standards.
Clearance Thomas #1
It's truly incredulous that SCOTUS is even hearing this case. This should be a no-brainer for such "experienced judges."
Certainly no need for them to craft a ruling for the ages and take their sweet time doing it, especially when it means the man who wants to end democracy may never face accountability for his most consequential actions.
Guys like Tribe should be on the Supreme Court.
He butchered the right-wing stance on the Second Amendment in one of his books.
Jackson is absolutely 💯 right!!!! There is NOTHING to debate here!!!
Not so fast what a woman is ....
@@hushmoney2058 Not so fast what about MAGA's inability to exercise critical thinking skills..... Love whataboutism arguments. Logic fallacies full speed ahead!!!
1000% Correct!
@@hushmoney2058- Such an idiotic "question" was and is completely beneath Judge Jackson in the first place.
Can *you* define - correctly define- "woman" in this day and age? Okay then. Three, two, one, *Define* :
@@ellab8897 Can you define “immunity”?
SCOTUS IS DISGRACEFUL…I AM DISGUSTED WITH THEM !!!
They've killed my patriotism.
Vote Blue
I AM DISGUSTED WITH BIDENS AMERICA AND HIS BRAIN DEAD VOTERS THAT LOVE HIS WARS ....
Thomas is the worst in that he should have recused himself; because his wife Ginni wanted Trump to win so much she even sent text messages to Meadows to help him and Trump try to succeed in their fake elector scheme.
I’m sorry you don’t believe in due process for ALL Americans.
It is now high time to consider abolishing life appointments for Supreme Court justices.
Such a knowledgeable and Honorable, Clear Thinking Scholar, Laurence Tribe, God Bless you and keep you healthy and strong, America needs your words of Justice and encouragement 🙏
I'm ashamed of SCOTUS moreso than ever...
Stay ashamed,
While we march to the WH,
Donald J Trump,🎉🎉
The Teflon Don,
The Next President of US 2024,
I love all of this😂😂
Me too very ashamed 🙉
Sweet blue tears😃
@@kaypakaipa8559 Why do you love a coward who left America like he treated his bankrupted businesses? I'll wait.
@@DarthSailorMoo 😂😂😂😂😂
- Why do I love a man who granted me a Green Passport after I graduated from college as a legal immigrant?
- Why do love a man who made the economy so great jobs everywhere I landed my first tech job right after graduation?
- why do i love a man who invested 100billion into HBCUs which i graduated from. This was 8fold higher investment compared to any other President!
- why do i love a man who gave me a great tax cut, which i did get, was juicy bcoz remember i had that great Tech job salary!
Donald J Trump,🎉🎉
The Teflon Don,
The Next President of US 2024,
I love all of this😂😂
The justices are providing aid and comfort to an insurrectionist.
FBI determined there was no insurrection. You're imagining things.
There was NO insurrection. Stupid comment of the day award to you. Following the other sheep doesn’t make you smart.
@@MattheasJTOVARICH 🤡 FUNNY 😂
@@MattheasJ The current legal position in the US is that Trump engaged in insurrection (Colorado Supreme Court ruling). The ruling was appealed to the US Supreme Court which did not not overturn this decision.
@@GBPDAYTRADER Careful with the double negatives; you might be misconstrued as trying to make this fool's point...but a lot of us watched said insurrection on live TV.
This has to be the most shameful Supreme court of all times
My god this was a very sad day for America 🇺🇸 😢
History will judge these Trump justices
What a terrible legacy.
If we are still around to see it.....
History will judge Biden for using the Court against a political Opponent ....What a terrible legacy.
How about We The People Remove the hacks that call themselves Judges but by their behavior proven to work for DJT and maga
@@karenpoteet751 Yes. Was going to say that we don't have that kind of time.
Not if Republicans continue to write or rewrite the history books.
This gaslighting of the American people is absolutely outrageous. And how these justices are not understanding that a dictator has no need for a Supreme Court and they are accommodating an argument that could put them in prison or have them murdered without consequence is beyond me.
They forget Biden under there argument could disband the sc with the powers they are giving him, just do a presidential order firing three or four of them for misconduct and seat his own justices, they are giving Biden that power, and if another part of Congress tries to stop him he could refer to the powers the sc gave him. The sc must be 100% sure trump is going to win as when he definitely loses Biden is going to come after them using this interpretation of the law.
Agree. With all of their so-called learning they appear rather ignorant to me. Partisan hacks!
It's ironic that the outcome of this debate affects them more than anyone else, even Trump.
YUP...sad
These are people with zero imagination & no ability to see past the noses on their own faces. If they had imagination, they might imagine what the majority of us think of them.
😮😮Thank you Professor Tribe!! Hoping Scotus is seeing this!!!
The best justice that money can buy. Utterly appalling.
Disband the Supreme Court and restructure it. Make sure that the new justices have no political affiliation and set a maximum term for their appointment
Agreed. The ‘Supreme’ Kangaroo Court In its current state is not fit for purpose.
Is it really possible to appoint Justices with no political affiliations? How do we get their....strip them of the vote?....c'est pas possible.
@@lennieismael7455 I see ONE political affiliation in particular that is MOST problematical: the one that's causing all the problems.
Supreme Court is shady shady shady.
Very very shady after all trump owns them 🎉
Someone needs to do a slim shady video featuring the questionable justices of SCOTUS.
@@charlesasmith7836 lost all faith in the justice system. There's only justice for the poor, brown and black folks. You get a free pass if you're rich and white and your name is Trump it seems. Just my opinion
@@Ketowski yup.
Not as shady as all the court cases Trump is facing. The Supreme Court sees that and is stepping in. You can stay mad about it
You’d think the justices would be embarrassed to speak at all🤬🤬🤬🤬
Thank You Lawrence✨🇺🇸✨
Some of the judges need to take their silly black robes off and put their clown suits on!
Indeed , SCOTUS AKA CLOWN 🤡 TOWN.
That's what they have under the robe
It is no longer the SCOTUS we once knew. It's now the SCOTFS - SC of the federalist society.
Follow the money.
And The Heritage Foundation.
The Federalist Society is just a legal organization. Anyone can join it.
SCOFFTUS
For those that don’t know, the Federalist Society claims that the Executive Branch can do NO harm. Not accountable for anything.
Bingo.
"How pathetic it's all gotten" ...
You can say THAT again!! 😨
Embarrassing is a light word Tribe.....
This is disturbing, shameful and corrupted
It's up to the American voters to settle this matter in November if the justice system fails.
IF ??😢
@@blanketeyblank5309 Yes, not if, but as...
This Supreme Court is taking us back to the 18th century
Seemingly the “good ole days” the leader of the Republican Party wants to go back to. Robber baron era.
Hitler had total immunity too
14th Century…before there was any democracy
Gosh I totally dislike this Supreme Court with a passion 👎👎😠
A President with imunity would take the US back to being run by George III.........
The fact is Trump reacts Without any consideration. We cannot have a man like this have full immunity!
Or any immunity.
Thank you,Professor Tribe. I hope SCOTUS is listening.
NO IMMUNITY FOR THE SUPREME COURT
SCOTUS? America says thumbs down to SCOTUS.
Not the case. They work on a lot of law items you are not aware of. You focus solely on Trump & an opposing party.
@@ChristerAxelsson1 Not aware that the God King Law was available to debate......
👎👎👎👎👎👎👎
This is MAGA country so.....
@@earlturner9136 Hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha... Only On Social Media....Hahahahahahahahahahha
I don’t care who you are, nobody can pardon themselves. That is truely ridiculous.
Lawrence you are an honorable man keep it up with the desk in Africa you can amagine how many kids you are helping just with a desk from you but means so , so , so much to kids just want to learn you are ANGEL mr. O'Donnell
Doesn’t SCOTUS realize that any promise Trump has made to them will never happen?
Good point, but it's fear of his supporters and also the kickbacks drying up.
He has something on them, maybe not all of them but enough to sway the rulings
They have jobs for life. They’re immune. They just don’t want to admit that they’re as financially and ideologically compromised as he is.
Trump will throw them under the bus when he no longer needs them. When he's a dictator he will be the judge and jury.
Vote Biden/Blue 2024!
@@massonman9099 They have secret service to protect them. Plus, the 3 older male justices should have nice nest eggs from all the money they've gotten already. They could retire comfortably. We can't be afraid of Trump's base. They are bullies. We need to stand up to bullies.
The Supreme Court, 3 Justices, 6 Political Hacks.
I thought Coney Barrett was thoughful and careful and contributed mightily. She may be the Court's only possible bridge between those who care about this nation and those who care only for what remains of their party and themselves.
It is not a court. It's criminal enterprise owned and operated by right wing turdocrats. There is nothing legitimate about it.
Scotus = 6 constitutionalists and 3 radical leftists
Wrong, Thomas= crook, Brett=Frat boy
“Presidents are not kings, and Plaintiff is not President,” Chutkan wrote of Trump. 6 Political Hacks can not act as Kings.
Birds of a feather flock together
nIt´s frightening, how quickly one of the oldest democracies of the world gets in an insecure situation. That one person is able to endanger a 250 year old, very well functioning political system. When I listen to DT every thought on the coming presidency becomes unreal on the background of the mental capacity, the average general knowledge and the social-emotional intelligence of DT. So weird and depressing
Some of those justices are engaged in the ongoing insurrection. Don't forget.
They're doing it in this hearing, which they intentionally delayed in an obvious effort to violate the law. They really should have been arrested immediately upon announcing the unnecessary delay.
There was no insurrection and the FBI report states as much. You anti Trumpers are wearing your tin foil hats proudly now aren't you? LOL
Charge Clarence's wife for being the circuit board of an entire insurrection.
Wonder if he recuses himself from that? 🤔
IT'S NOT FAIR😭😭 WHY WONT THEY RECUSE😭😭
Much as I don't like her views, I find it troubling for people to be tarred with the views of their spouse, parents, children or other relatives.
@@andrewstevenson118
As long as a Qanon follower has the ear of a supreme court justice. I don't really care.
"I heard they were being shipped off to Guantanamo Bay for ☠️"
-the wife of a sitting supreme court judge
Why wasn’t she charged?
@@andrewstevenson118
I dont care as long as a Q follower has the ear of a supreme court justice.
"I heard that they were shipping them off to Guantanamo Bay"
-the Qanon wife of a supreme court justice hoping for "official acts" from the president.
Well spoken Mr Tribe 🤝👍🙌🙏
Justice Jackson is sounding the alarm without sounding the alarm!
This is truly an obscenity. This Court cannot keep proudly declaring their fitness and high morality regarding impartiality, and, *”We are not political. We follow the Law!”* - while conducting their affairs like this.
I can't explain it but when I listen to beer-swilling
justice Kavenaugh pontificating, it is creepy and
makes me shudder.
He's a sadly mediocre (or worse) person, who confuses his White Boy privilege with intellect.
Man.. they are not even trying anymore to pretend they are reasonable and just following the law.
Amen Justice Jackson
This tawdry showing from the Supreme Court brings to mind a collection of bobble heads. Not superior intellects. 🤡
I like the one that can define what a Woman is ...
We so badly need people like Professor Tribe and Judge Luttig, along with Professors Vance and McQuade on our Supreme Court.
Back in the day -- circa 1970's -- Tribe was on every Dem's shortlist for SCOTUS. They never got the chance, though but it might not have been that big of a loss: He was the Harvard debate coach at the time and he once sat in on our debate during a tournament, before we met his team in the next round. He spent at least a half-hour prepping them for us but they were still pretty awful, including the analysis he fed them. So I've never been very impressed by him. Still not. He was correct here, though.
Agree! Thanks
and Neal Katyal.
Not one of the guys on the present court if they stood on their tiptoes could touch the heels, of the people you mentioned.
Repugs have to get their nominees for judges from the Federalist Society.
Thank you Lawrence for having Tribe on this presentation! Thank you Justice Brown!! 💪💙🇺🇸😎🌊🗽
Bravo ❗️Professor Tribe‼️. Thank You Lawrence👌
its up to the voters to stand up to this corrupt foolishness and make sure trump never set foot in office again...VOTE
Hearing Alito say he didn’t want to address the facts of this case made me scream. Plus the fact that Thomas didn’t recuse is sickening.
to Alito, those facts get in the way of his thinking of how to save the orange stain, so they don't matter to him.
Remember during Trump's first impeachment when the Republican-controlled Senate voted not to review evidence before voting NOT to REMOVE Trump? They never held a trial, so violated the Constitution before voting not to remove. There was supposed to be a TRIAL but it never happened. The GOP can no longer face ANY facts about ANYTHING they've done for YEARS.
Thank God for MSNBC !
No doubt, at this point, that Alito is the court leaker
I was almost tearing my hair out listening to those men wasting our hard earned money and our nation's reasoning that justice be swift and fair.
I giv up on the system and just asume they are all corupt...after watching the pianist last night i thought its time to start looking for anplace to run to if this all turns out like the movie....at this point im starting to worry. This is not like the america we use to know.
Yes, it was sickening really.
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
I So Agree!!
Why would a Supreme Court Justice actually lead the defendant's lawyer ?? The Justices need to be looked into, partisanship is one thing but this is blatantly bias beyond all sanity. Why would a president of the United States need immunity from acts of war ?? And why would a Supreme Court Justice actually lead the defendant's lawyer ???
@@treuthconductor8979 the pianist?
Justice Jackson is spot on correct.
I think Judge Chutken should tell the parties that the clock is running this delay is giving both side plenty of time to prepare, including for any impact that the SCOTUS decision will have on the proceedings. In other words, when SCOTUS makes up their mind, we're off and running.
Its insane to ask a question---whether a president has immunity from criminal prosecution----which has never been asked in more than two centuries. The very notiion that a citizen----our chief citizen---would be beyond the reach of the laws applicable to every other citizen is contrary to the very notion of "equal justiice under law." The threat of prosecution is a major impediment to unchecked executive power. We have gone completely through the looking glass.
Really embarrasing. Can thisJUDGES sleep well at nite or think the future of America with the likes of Trump
They can sleep in their free motor homes or luxury suites they get for saving traitor trump.
As long as they get their lavish perks they are fine with unethical behavior.
Six of them have no shame nor conscience.
I think those justices are literally traitors to their country.
The Dem ones ...
They have certainly betrayed the Constitution.
@@hushmoney2058Dunce
Yes they are❗️
ReTHUGpublican justices
Can't stand Kavanaugh and Thomas. How could they call themselves Justice? Even a dog on the street would laugh.
Thanks Prof. Tribe!
WOW! The fact that this nonsense is even being brought before the Supreme Court is disappointing and a huge embarrassment for America.
When I went to law school, I held the Supreme Court in the highest regard. Now I am embarrassed as an American citizen and attorney by this political and corrupt showing by our last form of checks and balance for our governmental system. And they have a life tenure!!!! Shame, shame, shame. Devoid of conscience, honor and integrity!!!!
SCOTUS decision
Maybe we should think about the issue in a different perspective:
Maybe we don’t need to worry about Supreme Court declaring there is immunity …!!!
Think about it …
The Supreme Court rules that absolutely immunity exists …. according to trump‘s lawyer, that means that a sitting president can order seal team 6 , to take out a corrupt political opponent…
That’s just great!!🎉🎉
That means Biden can legally order that a corrupt multiply indicted former presidential narcissistic psychopath be taken out…
Problems solved !!!
Which ever way SCOTUS decides on this issue, US wins.
By the way, Biden could take advantage of the decision, to take care of a couple of greedy, corrupt, political hacks masquerading as Supreme Court justices !!!
Well stated. I totally agree
Listen to every word of this question and answer session. It showed, without a doubt Scott’s is a group of highly intelligent, very articulate, and detail oriented serious minded professionals. I am proud of ALL of them for their detailed and varied, in depth questions.
@@MalibuBarbie-kk5gc and do you also believe trump won the 2020 election?
What do you want? For Trump to go to prison for wanting to better America? The impeachments the CoVID were not enough for you? You want him in jail. Ridiculous that you hold the Democratic party to any level.
This was worth hearing again. Thank you for having credible guests Mr. O'Donnell. Thank you MSNBC. Lawrence Tribe is brilliant and has a broad perspective on these issues.
This all is so disgusting 🤮. And how WE THE PEOPLE can fix this? How can we get these corrupt judges out of there? Seriously, is there something that can be done? 🤦♂️
There MUST be term limits and the ability to remove justices from the Supreme Court when they are found to be corrupt
I so agree.
How did the Supreme Court get so unjust.? The American people have rights and they are all being stripped.
Three Trump appointees, after Mitch McConnell blocked President Obama's last pick so Trump would have a shot at a fully dysfunctional majority, which he got. So here we are.
Some Justices putting their religious beliefs over the law. Remember the three Trump appointed said they Roe v. Wade was already decided. Then they flipped their stand.
What do you expect from judges who perjured themselves to get their position.
@@saintcain no evidence of any perjury. careful what you accuse people of when they have a nice team of expensive lawyers.
@@MalibuBarbie-kk5gc lol.
They need impeached 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
“never thought of that til just now” can this lawyer have the most horrible things happen to him now?