Superb nuance in feeling. In nature, the wind, crackling electricity, waves... In the young woman, her chest rising and falling with breath, sadness in her eyes. Very sweet, even with the unhappy end.
That was stunning. All I could do was sit and stare at my screen holding my breath. Incredibly realistic. I thoroughly enjoyed the entire experience of this short film.
Despite what happens to the woman at the end, this was so delicately told. I love the expressions on the woman's face, I almost know what she's thinking... very beautiful film.
I loved how you showed her feelings with simply face expressions but still kept it mysterious so you can imagine what happened for yourself :) Great job!
For those of you who don't see a story line, it only shows your shallowness. This is THE story... life, and death. It is the only thing we ALL have in common. It is obvious, also, how very much alive she felt before death, filled with human emotion. Beautifully done.
Beautiful and haunting. And all the while, I was asking her why aren't you going home? THANK YOU for this film for which I have no explanation. And that's the true beauty of it. Merci! Merci! Sallie
Agree... which parent would want to live on without their child... It's hard, cruel and very very heart breaking indeed... That smile on her face before the waves hit her... Just shows how a parent would feel. The child is everything for a good parent.
très éprouvant pour moi ce film... ça me rappelle carrément mon enfance, dans mon pays, avec les cyclones... et quand elle sort seule, dehors, le cyclone grondant, j'ai eu froid moi aussi. Bravo.
It always puzzles me how people can dislike a movie like this, it`s obviously took a long time to make, and is made with a lot of passion, by people at the top of their profession (switching to another channel is more easy than pressing the small dislike button) Great upload, tnx for sharing !!!
You succeeded in creating the ambience. Her struggle to not let go of the summer is clear and even moved to the last dot of light (lampost) there was in the darkness. However, autumn coloured leaves would have blown right off that tree in such a storm. Excellent job.
Wow...(pardon that I don't speak French), I am very impressed. Beautiful world, sad world. You've really done a great job conveying loneliness and loss, desolation, and an appreciation of the beauty in the severity of isolation. I love the details of the world as it goes by her...bravi! Encore! Encore!
Wow, this is so good. I showed my teacher this after school and left before he got to finish it.... I think he might have enjoyed it though. I know I did! It's so deep.... There's no words to really express how well this video is....
Amazing, this video is life compressed into 5 minutes. Alone,wandering through the storm we are helpless... until death finally takes us. Maybe i'm just overthinking it.
Absolutely breathtaking. The sea during the tempest was stunning. Wonderful work. So much temperature in the colours, and the music was well made too! 5/5
great mood, loved it. the breathing was great animation....the wide shot where she is at the end of the pier is very dramatic, great impact. touching film! my compliments to the music too.
I really didn't get just one particular feeling from this movie. And the last view of the tree was just beautiful, wish I could have that as my desktop.
![[LIVE] นาทีนี้ต้องพี่ทนาย | ทนายแก้ว vs ทนายไพศาล | #คุยให้เด็กมันฟัง EP.47 (02/11/67)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/HmquaO-PL_M/mqdefault.jpg)
Watching it 10 years later and it still gives me goosebumps.
I remember when I saw this in 2006 - 2007, omg, a long time ago...but it's still amazing...
Antonio avendaño I also remember seeing this on youtube way back in 06. Its kinda
Almost 10 years for you now. :)
Still watching and listening to this after 15 years...
16 years later and i still think about this film often.
that was the best animation i ever saw in my lfie
Superb nuance in feeling. In nature, the wind, crackling electricity, waves... In the young woman, her chest rising and falling with breath, sadness in her eyes. Very sweet, even with the unhappy end.
I watch this film at least once a week, and it moves me everytime! Thank you.
Loneliness, Despair, Relief, and finally Peace... these were the emotions I perceived as the film developed. Super! Continuez comme ça.
That was stunning. All I could do was sit and stare at my screen holding my breath. Incredibly realistic. I thoroughly enjoyed the entire experience of this short film.
The best short film I have ever seen.
So... heartfelt. And reading the comments can make your soul warmer.
Beautiful! The waves were great! The woman was beautiful!
Amazing. I loved everything: the colors, the animations, the music, the atmosphere...
Very, very, astounding.
Amazing what a story you can make of no dialogue.
Despite what happens to the woman at the end, this was so delicately told. I love the expressions on the woman's face, I almost know what she's thinking... very beautiful film.
Wow, the end made me get chills, that piano was beautiful, and the tree was amazing. Wow...
I love this kind of music. and I love the scene with the red tree.
So beautiful! And I really felt for the woman.
I loved how you showed her feelings with simply face expressions but still kept it mysterious so you can imagine what happened for yourself :)
Great job!
For those of you who don't see a story line, it only shows your shallowness. This is THE story... life, and death. It is the only thing we ALL have in common. It is obvious, also, how very much alive she felt before death, filled with human emotion. Beautifully done.
Nothing short than perfect. Perfect. Perfect.
I can't say anything...Sadness,beauty,pain...and a true hope of resurrection...what more?...
wonderful!!!
Ankhsnammon
this was great. ignore people who cant think hard enough to contemplate the real meaning of this. its beauty.
I love how this transcends animation. Its not the best graphics, but its given such an incredible feel that it really haunts you.
I can get the smell of rain on the ground. Amazing!
Beautiful, breath taking and extremely touching.
Great movie, it caught my mind and heart, shivers went sent through my spine and also i felt a sigh of happyness
I like this a lot
i like this a lot too
@@jamesmiIIer we like good thing
@@Nathan.Barnatt what if we... loved good thing
@@jamesmiIIer even better
absolutely beautiful. i love the sky.
WOW....this is pure magic! How beautiful, yet sad if you think about it...
Heartbreakingly beautiful....
Top Notch.
Beautiful and haunting. And all the while, I was asking her why aren't you going home?
THANK YOU for this film for which I have no explanation. And that's the true beauty of it.
Merci! Merci! Sallie
absolutely amazing. most realistic motion cgi i have ever seen.
Agree... which parent would want to live on without their child... It's hard, cruel and very very heart breaking indeed... That smile on her face before the waves hit her... Just shows how a parent would feel. The child is everything for a good parent.
This is astonishing from so much point of view even after watching it many times. I just wanted to say thank you for the creators.
Ideas can be grouped in many ways, some of them are brilliant and others are insignificant, and most of them are unnoticed.
very very powerful and rich of emotions. I loved colors and music...wonderful
What a beautiful break this gave me from the noise of daily life - real art. What a shame others have such shallow comments.
Really beautiful, no words are needed to tell the story, all the colors and sounds of the animation do that perfectly!
The story of life, we decided to stay no metter what...
Beautiful work!!
très éprouvant pour moi ce film... ça me rappelle carrément mon enfance, dans mon pays, avec les cyclones... et quand elle sort seule, dehors, le cyclone grondant, j'ai eu froid moi aussi. Bravo.
It always puzzles me how people can dislike a movie like this, it`s obviously took a long time to make, and is made with a lot of passion, by people at the top of their profession (switching to another channel is more easy than pressing the small dislike button) Great upload, tnx for sharing !!!
Pure emotion!!!! Fantastic!!!
Conmovedora historia, genial atmósfera de desolación y desencanto, pero hecha con sensibilidad y magistralmente realizada.
Ther's no word, what could describe what i feel during watching this movie. It's awesome and touches my heart so deep.
You did a really great job.
one word says it all....
Beautiful
Wow. That was quite impressive. I loved how everything moved so naturally. It added a real sense of realism.
the tree is amazing,the image look as noir atmosphere,yes it was a good experience.thanx
beautiful.. i love the warm colours of the tree
absolutely beautiful, the details are so life like.
The waves were amazing. I loved it.
I love the tree at the end. Bent, battered but not broken.
Nice. I like the contrast in reds and blues, darks and lights. Very vivid.
Este film es poesía, pura poesía. Imágenes y situaciones misteriosas, simples, intrigantes, sutiles y bellas. Felicitaciones. Ricardo, de Argentina
beautifully-made video with a lot of feeling and a poignant story line. hyper animated graphics, great lighting, clouds, sea, movement.
Very, Veeeeeery, nice. So subtle, like a soft embrace. Visually moving and the sounds and above all, the music... sublime.
great, i love the feeling and the atmosphere before a big storm..
Very strong! A great portrayal of a woman's strong will and ambition.
This touched my heart in a way i can not explain. Thank you.
Mothers love of her child. Great vid.
Definitely a great video. TH-cam should feature more cool stuff like this.
beautiful. i almost cried and believe me, that takes a lot.
Alot of great Idle work in many scenes. Keeps audience busy and attentive. Good job.
amazing!!! one of the best clips and soundtracks ever seen...
You succeeded in creating the ambience. Her struggle to not let go of the summer is clear and even moved to the last dot of light (lampost) there was in the darkness. However, autumn coloured leaves would have blown right off that tree in such a storm.
Excellent job.
Absolutely amazing. Incredible atmosphere and realism. Very sad and touching, beautifully done. Superb.
All together this video was excellent. Very poetic ending. The piano was brilliant, almost made me cry. Great job guys.
simly beautiful...and moving.
amazing. i loved it. absolutely loved it.
Amazing.
I like the tree in the end,
beautiful!!!
beautiful. That's the only word I have to describe this. Fantastic job!
I'm a teen too, and i found this video, well... flat out amazing!! So moving! And its very detailed. Who ever made this thing, wonderful!
Beautiful. Breathtaking.
OMG! The sound is perfect! The video is perfect! I felt Like being there!
wow. this IS a beautiful story.. i LOVE it.
very, very, VERY well done boys!!
so touching , a feeling that sometimes occurred in my mind . something helpless, desperate but a really amazing moment.
das ist nicht langweilig. es ist traurig und schön.
very very beautiful video.
Oh, and very nice details with the sun going behind the posts in the cemetery. It was very realistic!
i love it! i really like the thunder....i wish it would storm like that here today.
I love this video, honestly,
it has so much meaning to it,
it inspires me.
It totally captures the concept & emotion of the end of summer(life) & onset of winter(death). Am I reading too much into it?
Really peaceful and serene, love this so much
Amazing water effects. Great atmosphere.
Wow...(pardon that I don't speak French), I am very impressed. Beautiful world, sad world. You've really done a great job conveying loneliness and loss, desolation, and an appreciation of the beauty in the severity of isolation. I love the details of the world as it goes by her...bravi! Encore! Encore!
Fantastic animated, especially the weather and the environment!
Wow, this is so good. I showed my teacher this after school and left before he got to finish it.... I think he might have enjoyed it though. I know I did! It's so deep.... There's no words to really express how well this video is....
Amazing, this video is life compressed into 5 minutes. Alone,wandering through the storm we are helpless... until death finally takes us.
Maybe i'm just overthinking it.
I love the mood you created. Also the view of the sea at night, with the lighthouse, is superb.
Absolutely wonderful....
Just WOW is the best to say. Great Job, With the endscene and the music and all...perfect!!
Absolutely breathtaking. The sea during the tempest was stunning. Wonderful work. So much temperature in the colours, and the music was well made too! 5/5
the detail put into her clavicles when she breaths is amazing.
that is EXCELLENT work. it reminded me of when i lived on the gulf coast of florida.
great mood, loved it. the breathing was great animation....the wide shot where she is at the end of the pier is very dramatic, great impact. touching film! my compliments to the music too.
one of the most beautiful and powerful animations i've seen. lovely work
so sad!!!!!!!!!! yet beautiful...
I really didn't get just one particular feeling from this movie. And the last view of the tree was just beautiful, wish I could have that as my desktop.
slow, otherworldly and epic. i love it!
I think that it's really well done... I really like the colors of the tree, opposite with the colors of the stormy sky...
Beautiful 3D work. I am amazed at the rendering of the art