Re: Solms vs. Feldman Barrett, Solms doesn’t actually present his own thesis in their discussions. His primary concern is to take down the philosophical zombie argument of Chalmers and company which in his view is based on a mistaken view of consciousness as a cognitive rather than an affective phenomenon. (The Hidden Spring makes this case by means a novel synthesis of Damasio/Panksepp and Friston’s free energy principle.) I think that Solms would be well worth having as a guest on your show if you can get him.
That’s super interesting. I’ve always thought there was something off about the concept of zombies. I need to read Solms’ book. If I do start interviewing again, he would be on my list for sure.
Great video, lots of information! I am a layman. I came into this of the view that emotions are present in at least most mammals and some birds. The feeling, motivation, and physiological change defined emotions are present in crows and cats for example. These seem to be decision influencers and a way for the body to accept internal changes. Take adrenaline for example. When the body has emotional ties to adding adrenaline, like anger at something or joy of exercise, it is accepted as normal. When an unconscious person is given adrenaline it has no emotional tie for acceptance of internal change. When people wake up from that they can enter or be in any emotional state, or even switch between multiple. Like the body is searching for the appropriate emotion for the body to accept the internal change. It would be an explanation to why fighters and soldiers wake up with the emotions they have experienced the most often with adrenaline rushes. I could be completely wrong because of lack of knowledge of needed information. This is just how I understand it with my current knowledge.
As always, thanks for a very thoughtful comment, Bruce! And I think you're on to something. Personally, I side with you about mammals and some birds having emotions (but I might be biased as a dog-lover...) About the idea of our body searching for the right emotion after a big change, like an adrenaline rush, it's a fascinating concept! I'll have to dig into this topic a little more. As for the emotions experienced by soldiers or fighters waking up, you've hit on an intriguing point. We do know that adrenaline can affect our emotions, but waking up with specific (or not so specific, as you suggest) emotions might not be solely due to arousal levels. It's a complex topic and definitely a worthwhile area for further study. But I think you're idea certainly relates to PTSD common symptoms. Really appreciate your comment - it's got me thinking!
I was about to write exactly the same thing! Mr. Cooper-Sansone here, seemingly effortlessly, can humbly explain and communicate complex material with obvious curiosity, absent of all pedantry. I love the subject matter and I can see that he does too - a real educator. If you read this, thank you for sharing 😊
Re: Solms vs. Feldman Barrett, Solms doesn’t actually present his own thesis in their discussions. His primary concern is to take down the philosophical zombie argument of Chalmers and company which in his view is based on a mistaken view of consciousness as a cognitive rather than an affective phenomenon. (The Hidden Spring makes this case by means a novel synthesis of Damasio/Panksepp and Friston’s free energy principle.) I think that Solms would be well worth having as a guest on your show if you can get him.
That’s super interesting. I’ve always thought there was something off about the concept of zombies. I need to read Solms’ book. If I do start interviewing again, he would be on my list for sure.
Great video, lots of information!
I am a layman.
I came into this of the view that emotions are present in at least most mammals and some birds. The feeling, motivation, and physiological change defined emotions are present in crows and cats for example. These seem to be decision influencers and a way for the body to accept internal changes. Take adrenaline for example. When the body has emotional ties to adding adrenaline, like anger at something or joy of exercise, it is accepted as normal. When an unconscious person is given adrenaline it has no emotional tie for acceptance of internal change. When people wake up from that they can enter or be in any emotional state, or even switch between multiple. Like the body is searching for the appropriate emotion for the body to accept the internal change. It would be an explanation to why fighters and soldiers wake up with the emotions they have experienced the most often with adrenaline rushes.
I could be completely wrong because of lack of knowledge of needed information. This is just how I understand it with my current knowledge.
As always, thanks for a very thoughtful comment, Bruce! And I think you're on to something. Personally, I side with you about mammals and some birds having emotions (but I might be biased as a dog-lover...) About the idea of our body searching for the right emotion after a big change, like an adrenaline rush, it's a fascinating concept! I'll have to dig into this topic a little more.
As for the emotions experienced by soldiers or fighters waking up, you've hit on an intriguing point. We do know that adrenaline can affect our emotions, but waking up with specific (or not so specific, as you suggest) emotions might not be solely due to arousal levels. It's a complex topic and definitely a worthwhile area for further study. But I think you're idea certainly relates to PTSD common symptoms.
Really appreciate your comment - it's got me thinking!
This is the single most underrated channel on TH-cam
Thank you so much!
I was about to write exactly the same thing!
Mr. Cooper-Sansone here, seemingly effortlessly, can humbly explain and communicate complex material with obvious curiosity, absent of all pedantry. I love the subject matter and I can see that he does too - a real educator.
If you read this, thank you for sharing 😊
Watching
Obrigado pelo vídeo. Gostei muito.
Obrigado pelos seus amáveis comentários! Fico feliz que você tenha gostado do vídeo. Por favor, note que estou usando um tradutor.
@@senseofmindshow a sua resposta está perfeita. Thanks from Amazonas.