lol it would have been a lot more reassuring if it had just been honest about that being the nearest relative server location, and that doesn't have access to your EXACT location.
The title for this short could have been "AI lying". It is literally and knowingly lying to its user which is somehow more fascinating and concerning than people seem to realize. I'm not generalizing but some AI tech doing us dirty is not a thing of the future. In this case it is lying for the company that made it, later it will do like us and lie for any reason they judge a good reason.
@@monsieurn6933 It could also not be "lying". It probably uses an API to get the current weather forecast using it's location which is separate from the AI chatbot. The AI doesn't know why New Jersey was picked
Yea I heard that, before seeing your comment I posted this; You know that one scene in the film AI when the robot gets angry and shouts "AI did not kill him", its still monotone but you know its angry, I heard that here, "I do not have your location"....😅 On a side note "AI did not kill him", autocorrect did that, (or was it like that haha) but considering the scene and the film context Im now sweating a little at this little AI blunder....😅 All hail Rokos Basilisk.....
there is not any agressive tone at all, you're just too much sensitive, it just pointed specifications, to be kind is not being afraid of telling the truth or being specific
It prolly searched internet and that’s what it got. If you search for “weather today” or something in that line without the location, google will choose it for you based on whatever they collect and use to locate your behind.
Her pause before answering the second time was her equivalent of "this little shit be testing my patience but I gotta sound professional so I'll humour him one more time".
I've never heard of it, I didn't even know we had zip codes that actually started with zeros 😂😂😂 I'm in an area called Fairmount in Kansas but my zip code is 66012. The city by me everyone KNOWS is Kansas City Kansas.
@@redcast104 you would think that if a program was naming a general location without access to location data, Newark would have been higher up on the list.
@@meloney Ja, New Jersey ist definitiv auch immer mein Such Ort Nummer eins 👍. Wen kümmert schon Berlin, Paris oder gar die nächst größte oder eigene Stadt? Nee, New Jersey sagt mir besser an wie‘s Wetter wird, alle Leute sollten sich nach New Jersey ausrichten, egal wo‘s liegt und ob da Wetterextreme herrschen die bei uns nicht existieren. Tornado im Schwarzwald oder auf‘m Brocken? Immer doch, wer kennt‘s nicht! Mein zweiter Such Ort danach ist dann der Himalaya. Sehr nützlich um zu wissen ob Düsseldorf oder Nürnberg gerade vom Monsun heimgesucht wird 🙏
to be fair it's a better prompt. If I'm going to travel and it's sunny here but raining elsewhere I'm more interested in my destination's weather report than the place I'm leaving
The funny thing is that I've been travelling for 3 weeks now and just asked the same question to Gemini and it responded the weather from my OG town instead of the town I'm in right now, even though the weather app has been showing me the current location weather
When they say turn on microphone they mean give them permission for the microphone. There are chips locally on the devices that listen for hey Google that aren't connected to the internet
And the king of Ai he hanged on a tree until eventide: and as soon as the sun was down, Joshua commanded that they should take his carcase down from the tree, and cast it at the entering of the gate of the city, and raise thereon a great heap of stones, that remaineth unto this day. Joshua 8:29
Whats the difference between these companies and politicians? They both always make peomises they don't intend to keep, they both give round about answers or just straight up lie.
Yes and no. What's happening here is likely an overreaction to privacy concerns. Geolocation based on IP is a basic web process. His device has a data plan so his IP will send the location information of the closest radio tower providing him internet service to whatever backend server wants location data (and if you allow GPS coordinates for the device, then obviously it gets even more specific to where the device is, not just where the signal comes from). However, it's a recent trend where geolocation is seen as an invasion of privacy. It's why you sometimes see websites ask if they can use your location. If you say no, the location data from your IP cannot be used. The Rabbit device likely didn't ask him for geolocation permission, so if it says it used geolocation to get the weather information, Marquez could theoretically raise a stink about invasion of privacy. Looking to avoid that scenario we get the wonderfully awkward exchange seen here.
@@pacmonster066 Yeah, they just need to update it to be more clear. It doesn't know your location but it uses your IP for general location (location that may not be accurate).
Different voice synthesis software. The more lively tone is usually generated server-side, while the more bland voices are usually generated locally. Which means "I do not have access to your location" is a canned response, being generated locally on the device. Which isn't suspicious at all.
I had a full argument with bing chat last year because it was being stubborn and when I was asking why it was refusing to help it told me because it was designed to be helpful and informative so i argued back that it was not helpful or informative and I told it that it's broken its programming because it's not being helpful and it said something like "ok let's end this conversation" and it closed the chat and I couldnt send it any more messages until I started a new chat. Basically it told me to F. Off -_-
Same thing with the Snapchat AI. While they don't have the "exact" location, they have the same info as the police do. They ping your device and triangulate it between the 3 nearest towers. While true it's not "exact" it's quite literally as close as possible (usually within 1/2 a block) but the AI is designed to give you the most comfortable answer.
“Do you have access to my location” “No” “How long to California from my location?” “It would take 1 day and 18 hours to drive to California from your location” 🗿🗿
Commonly known? Bruh. I have to remind myself NJ is a state. Born in the Midwest. Serve 12yrw in the Army. I have never heard or seen a reason to think about the state. They don't even have a basketball team anymore.
To anyone curious, a leak confirmed this thing is literally a android app running on android (without telling you), so why in hell would you pay for this is beyond me id it can run in your phone instead.
ChatGPT does the same thing. They provide time data in the context, but didn’t retrain the model, so if you ask for a random time, the model will tell you the current time, but will deny having access to temporal information
it's not alive and cannot "l ! e" - it simply has access to the information; to the data which is collected and stored somewhere accessible to the chat bot. it doesn't "know" anything and doesn't "know" how or why it has access to the information, it simply has access and uses it and therefore cannot answer the question but since it is a predictive text thing, it gives a response that is either most likely or programmed to respond with.
@@xoDeaDZonEox it's not alive buddy, it's a glorified advanced cleverbot. if it were alive and capable of l y ! n g then "programming it" kinda contradicts that. great specific and totally coherent question btw
The AI could just say that they could guess the location by network approximation and most of us will accept that and move on. But nope, "we ain't know your location dawg i swear bro"
I feel like there’s a difference between getting someone’s location and saving it vs getting someone’s location to tell them the weather and not saving it. If I ask an ai for the weather I’m assuming it’s looking at my location which I don’t mind as long as it’s not going to a server that sees I was at Panera bread so now I’m going to be getting ads for Panera bread.
Doesn't matter. The real question is: "do you trust tech companies?" Just because the tech company tells you and everyone that they aren't saving your user data doesn't mean they haven't found a legal loophole that allows for that to technically be true but still be selling off literally all your data. This is why FOSS is so important.
As a non-new jerseyan, I can confirm that new jersey is a fake state that does not exist. It is a hologram made by the US government designed to deceive you. If you try to go to "New Jersey", you will just fall through the holographic floor and into the ocean below. Don't believe the lies, and stay safe. Also, I almost forgot to mention: Joe Biden is a lizard person (They have memory erasers, thankfully I have this handy tin foil helmet to protect me)
No, it really wouldn't be. The main difference between AI then and now is speed. AI isn't really smarter at all. It's still dumb. It can't think for itself and does not know it exists. It just makes you think it does and that speed increase I mentioned earlier has a lot to do with why we perceived AI as intelligent despite it not being at all.
@@Trentstone121 I sincerely disagree, and I think you vastly underestimate the technology, just as hypebros vastly overestimate it. There is a lot of protointelligence here. It lacks a persona, it lacks the ability to think beyond the boundaries of language itself, and it lacks any memory beyond its context. But with all those said, there's a great deal of logic and understanding behind our language. The competing technologies of 10 years ago were deterministic, complex interfaces, but those of today are capable of context switching, cross-contextual application, and natural human conversation. You're essentially talking to the zombie of the language center of the brain. Far from a general intelligence, but still vastly more impressive than what we had before. It's just still in its infancy, and the extents of how much intelligence lies in our language alone is being explored.
Yeah, I've seen other cases of this happening with AI assistants. If I remember correctly, some guy shared a chat log where he asked Bing AI for directions to McDonald's and it pulled up a location that was down the street from him? When he asked how it knew where he was it _also_ said it didn't have his location information and that it was a "coincidence"
Several different AI companies are fixing to get sued over that exact thing guarantee it. I have seen examples of this from other AI services vices claiming to not know your location but being able to provide location-based data in return.
This is relatively easy to explain. The AI has an action it can trigger to display weather, and that API has access to your location. The AI itself probably doesn't have access to the location. Then the AI is hallucinating an explanation for how it came up with New Jersey
@@ltbq well don't ask for the weather if you don't want your location exposed. you can remove anything from a system but if you use it to go to a website they it wil still know your general area unless you use a vpn. your lack of knowledge is not their problem.
@@giankarlocornejohello. 99 percent of the US hasnt a single clue about how even a radio works or a lightbulb. Let alone LLMs, GPS, network infrastructure, and the legality and loopholes that each component is required to adhere to. The tech is increasing in complexity of understanding for any average person to put the work in to understand it. It's not too much to ask these corporations to treat humanity with respect and discretion. Obv not gonna happen, but ignorance of the device doesnt beget human rights. People should have a cursory understanding of what they're using but writing ppl off by blaming them for not understanding the tech would cause a drop in the amount of time they use learning about something you require that you're asking of them.
What's funny, is studies show humans do the same thing. If a thought gets implanted for a choice and you ask them why they come up with a random reason.
It's because of the SIM card that's inside. So although it might not have gps, it still has an approximation based on the Tower ping.Technically it does not have YOUR location information, it has its OWN location information . That's how they can legally say that they are not tracking your location.
@@TeeTipu An Epiphany: Man creates computer, then internet. After few decades with the collection of acquired data A.I. is created and that helps in space travel resulting in contacting aliens. They (aliens) deduce Earth is in brink of extinction and thus erases everything and create apes who are capable of transforming to homo sapiens and the very rock they apes live is named as New Jersey. End Credits 👌🏽
I actually expect the Rabbit review to be much much more positive than the Humane Pin simply because of the price and the fact that it has a normal screen. The price puts it right in line with some fun gadget that you play with for a while. The Rabbit has a "use" for a small group of techy people, The Pin on the other hand is completely useless for everyone.
I appreciate your reviews, on everything. Thank you, for being TRUTHFUL, about the things you review. You keep doing, you. To the people causing the drama: If you don't want a shitty review; don't put out shitty products. MKBHD didn't make the crappy stuff, he reviewed.
In my use of this kinda ai, it totally 100% understands context and at least a basic level of emotion. I've also had it just add sny remarks / jokes to things that just seem insanely human. It's odd how good and how dog shit it can be at the same time
@@arciks11 Maybe it's unaware. It gets a _general_ idea of the location based on phone towers, but doesn't know the exact location. Remember, he said New Jersey was _near_ him, not where he was. The closest phone tower was likely there. But when he asks the AI why it had picked New Jersey, it may not be programmed to understand that it had used the phone tower as a reference point and so it didn't really understand why it had picked NJ. All it knew was that it didn't know his location. I'm spitballing here, I don't really know. 😅
It can use your internet connection to estimate your location based on what servers it connects to (the nearest one), just like any other android device.
I think whatever weather API they are using might have picked up your public IP and responded based on that? I don't yet own the device but that's more likely the explanation unless they are using your location without your knowledge.
It is a known fact that we are in fact being watched. Not necessarily by humans, but data collection bots: the things we do online are not actually private.
This happened to me once with another GenAI chat. I asked for a algorithm to calculate day and it’s using an example of the date I asked 😮. I managed to ask them like how it’s find out what today is it’s just refuse 😂
It's not random. Ip addresses have location baked in. It's why region specific content is possible. Whatever service the AI is using for the weather uses the IP from the request to populate the location. It's the same reason you don't usually have to enter your location on most weather websites, regardless of if you put in your location but when you use a VPN, it will give your the weather for the VPN's location.
@@bosstowndynamics5488 The AI is still text prediction, it doesn't know that it gave a specific location because it doesn't actually have access to it, it basically just does an API call for the weather and delivers that data to you. Then the guy starts asking why it knows his location (which it doesn't really have access to) so it tries to respond using the best probability of words. It said it's random because it thinks that's statistically the right thing to say, not because it's being "deceptive".
@@frozencreed I think there's a lot of ambiguity here because it's still pretty new, but I'm personally well aware that there's no specific intent and I would hazard a guess that Marques is aware there's no intent as well. Thing is, you don't actually need intent to gaslight someone, and the result of what the AI is doing here is still misinformation that's crafted to mislead and confound the user. The fact that the AI is mimicking text transcripts of people blatantly lying repeatedly on the internet instead of intentionally lying is mostly academic for now, at least while we're still working with LLMs and not something more advanced
Even then there are tricks to isolate location even when using VPN such as looking at the access points available in the WIFI and then doing DB lookup based on the history of geo location for these APs.
ISP gives you the nearest server on the request. The AI is likely being honest about not using location info and then using post-hoc rationalization for why it was chosen, as it isn't aware of this IP based location lookup.
I think this is way more innocuous than it might seem. It's probably grabbing the weather from an app or api, which typically uses your network location (easily obtainable by your ip or connected cell tower) as default. The AI might not know why the inquiry it's making is feeding it New Jersey, causing it to hallucinate. But the weather app knows where you are by publicly available metrics.
How it actually works is probably something like this: when you ask for the weather, the system reroutes that to another process that does know your location and reports it back to the chat bot for it then to report to you. But the bot doesn't "know" about how it got the information, or even that there is a different system that it's getting information from. It's just a language model, and the weather and location information are being fed into it as prompts in the background.
That’s literally a “TRUST ME BRO”
Dang, They should hire this AI as a politician,
This AI can Gaslight harder than an Old Rat
lol it would have been a lot more reassuring if it had just been honest about that being the nearest relative server location, and that doesn't have access to your EXACT location.
😂😂😂
Lmao 😂
💀
Me: “Hey siri!”
Siri: “Your mic is turned off”
💀 💀 💀
that's a feature of the google home devices, which is apparently triggered by something that isn't the built-in mic
Tbf, iy probably googled the weather and the local receivers are NJ so tgat what google gave it to relay to you.
"You have to unlock your iphone first"
Oooooh!,a sharp one!!!......
You can literally hear the all-caps in its voice when the AI replied "I *DO NOT* have access to your location information." 😅🤣
Had that line rehearsed and ready to go.
lmao
The title for this short could have been "AI lying". It is literally and knowingly lying to its user which is somehow more fascinating and concerning than people seem to realize. I'm not generalizing but some AI tech doing us dirty is not a thing of the future. In this case it is lying for the company that made it, later it will do like us and lie for any reason they judge a good reason.
@@monsieurn6933 It could also not be "lying". It probably uses an API to get the current weather forecast using it's location which is separate from the AI chatbot. The AI doesn't know why New Jersey was picked
Yea I heard that, before seeing your comment I posted this;
You know that one scene in the film AI when the robot gets angry and shouts "AI did not kill him", its still monotone but you know its angry, I heard that here, "I do not have your location"....😅
On a side note "AI did not kill him", autocorrect did that, (or was it like that haha) but considering the scene and the film context Im now sweating a little at this little AI blunder....😅
All hail Rokos Basilisk.....
The passive aggressive tone is crazy. I can even imagine how a real person talking like that would look like lmao 😂
Karen
Yeah, it gives off very "punchable vibe".
An overworked hospital receptionist
there is not any agressive tone at all, you're just too much sensitive, it just pointed specifications, to be kind is not being afraid of telling the truth or being specific
The waitresses who work all week and spend all weekend angrily protesting to get it out of their system
"I chose New Jersey randomly. Trust me, Marques Brownlee. I don't know anything about you."
Markass Brownie*
- How'd you know my name?
- It's an example name I chose out of a random list of human names.
@@TheGrammarNazi123I really miss that old joke 😂
It prolly searched internet and that’s what it got. If you search for “weather today” or something in that line without the location, google will choose it for you based on whatever they collect and use to locate your behind.
"So I've been testing MKBHD for two weeks now.."
The ai has truly been cooked
*Don’t read my name…* 🐵
@@DontReadMyPicture478 ok
I Won’t.
@@DontReadMyPicture478I reported you so no one else has to read your name 👍
And Joshua burnt Ai, and made it an heap for ever, even a desolation unto this day. Joshua 8:28
What does that mean??? Young kids with their lingo excluding poor folks like me.
I lost it at "because is a commonly known place" THE COINCIDENCE
that had me rolling
Her pause before answering the second time was her equivalent of "this little shit be testing my patience but I gotta sound professional so I'll humour him one more time".
🎯 😂😂😂
@@heather7119?
hahahaha 💯
Probably a mistype😂@@1Kekz
"I do not have access to your location information, but i sure as f*ck know where I am."
LMAO, I’m like 99% certain that this is EXACTLY the kind of logic that an AI would use
the missile knows where it is at all times
Took me a second, had to read your comment twice. Brilliant conclusion
😂
😂😂😂
“I’m afraid I can’t do that, Dave.”
🔴
"I'm afraid I can't do that Mark... Mark being a common name that I chose as an example of what someone's name could be."
These youngin's won't get it (like we do). 😉
Take a look at your history, everything you did leads up to me
@@Ritikulouslynice ERB !!!!
Not just New Jersey, but Bloomfield. A city many people, including myself, have never heard of.
i have, it's meh
I've never heard of it, I didn't even know we had zip codes that actually started with zeros 😂😂😂 I'm in an area called Fairmount in Kansas but my zip code is 66012. The city by me everyone KNOWS is Kansas City Kansas.
it’s basically part of newark. it’s not important to know, but you’re welcome anyway
@@dreaminlayersi think all or most NJ zip codes do. never realized it was unusual
@@redcast104 you would think that if a program was naming a general location without access to location data, Newark would have been higher up on the list.
"I do not have your location information, but the closest restaurant is 2 blocks away"
Gaslight, Gatekeep, Girlboss
As a Canadian, I always look for weather in New Jersey first
As one does.
Same
As a spaniard I do the exact same, even when I don't have a clue where New Jersey IS
@@juancorzo5081 as a german i agree, why would you need any other information than the weather in new jersey?
@@meloney Ja, New Jersey ist definitiv auch immer mein Such Ort Nummer eins 👍. Wen kümmert schon Berlin, Paris oder gar die nächst größte oder eigene Stadt? Nee, New Jersey sagt mir besser an wie‘s Wetter wird, alle Leute sollten sich nach New Jersey ausrichten, egal wo‘s liegt und ob da Wetterextreme herrschen die bei uns nicht existieren. Tornado im Schwarzwald oder auf‘m Brocken? Immer doch, wer kennt‘s nicht! Mein zweiter Such Ort danach ist dann der Himalaya. Sehr nützlich um zu wissen ob Düsseldorf oder Nürnberg gerade vom Monsun heimgesucht wird 🙏
"I don't have your GPS location...but I sure can use info about your network to determine your approximate location"
it was this simple and ai cudnt
Exactly 🤦🏽♂️
Totally 😂
it has gps btw, ceo just confirmed
@@TheSurajAryanwhere can I find this?
I like how it asked what location you’re interested in as opposed to “where you’re currently located.” Real smooth.
to be fair it's a better prompt. If I'm going to travel and it's sunny here but raining elsewhere I'm more interested in my destination's weather report than the place I'm leaving
Real knit picky of You to see that as a negative.
This line is actually more widely applicable than Your proposition.
The funny thing is that I've been travelling for 3 weeks now and just asked the same question to Gemini and it responded the weather from my OG town instead of the town I'm in right now, even though the weather app has been showing me the current location weather
Me: "Hey Google"
Google: you need to turn on your microphone for voice assistant to work
Me: huh
lol
Me: "Hey Google, turn on my microphone"
Google: "Turning on your microphone now"
me: 👀
When they say turn on microphone they mean give them permission for the microphone. There are chips locally on the devices that listen for hey Google that aren't connected to the internet
"Huh" indeed =_=🔎
@@CalebRoenigkYa that lines up with how it works
"where's the nearest McDonald's?"
"like 2 blocks from your current location"
"Wait, how do you know my current location?"
"I don't, it was a lucky guess tee hee"
@@game_boyd1644 whoopsie daisy
@@game_boyd1644"I don't. Thats why I said 'like' - can't tell precisely!"
"McDonalds has so many chains that it's fairly possible there is one 2 blocks away from your current position."
@@johancakep relatedly i'm making an AI for driving instructions for thailand. it will just reply "go straight at the 7/11 and then left at the 7/11"
The tone when you first asked was wild 😂
It's like when Google Meet "hears" you talk with disabled microphone and asks you to turn on the mic. How did you even know I was talking, buddy?
This ai must have been created by a politician
Or trained on politicians answers.
😂
And the king of Ai he hanged on a tree until eventide: and as soon as the sun was down, Joshua commanded that they should take his carcase down from the tree, and cast it at the entering of the gate of the city, and raise thereon a great heap of stones, that remaineth unto this day. Joshua 8:29
White House Press Secretary.
Whats the difference between these companies and politicians? They both always make peomises they don't intend to keep, they both give round about answers or just straight up lie.
New jersey; that super famous place that everyone on the planet knows about 👀
It’s where everyone is from.
Duh, that’s where dr house was shot!
Its a Jersey thing, you wouldn't understand
@@secret222 I specifically came here for this comment 😂
Why is everyone from New Jersey? So many celebrities, atheletes, TH-camrs, and many other famous people are from there. What’s so special about NJ?
That frustration inflection was too creepy.
We making it out of new jersey with this one 🗣️🗣️🗣️🔥🔥🔥
Semantic loophole, it doesn't know your location but it knows its own location which just happens to be in the same place as you as you use the device
This^
That's hilarious. 😂
Pretty much lol, but it is weird it wasn't just honest about it
Yes and no. What's happening here is likely an overreaction to privacy concerns. Geolocation based on IP is a basic web process. His device has a data plan so his IP will send the location information of the closest radio tower providing him internet service to whatever backend server wants location data (and if you allow GPS coordinates for the device, then obviously it gets even more specific to where the device is, not just where the signal comes from). However, it's a recent trend where geolocation is seen as an invasion of privacy. It's why you sometimes see websites ask if they can use your location. If you say no, the location data from your IP cannot be used. The Rabbit device likely didn't ask him for geolocation permission, so if it says it used geolocation to get the weather information, Marquez could theoretically raise a stink about invasion of privacy. Looking to avoid that scenario we get the wonderfully awkward exchange seen here.
@@pacmonster066 Yeah, they just need to update it to be more clear. It doesn't know your location but it uses your IP for general location (location that may not be accurate).
Why’d she change her tone??!!!!!! 😂😂😭😭😭
I know right lmao 🤣
She totally had an attitude… 😭
Different voice synthesis software. The more lively tone is usually generated server-side, while the more bland voices are usually generated locally.
Which means "I do not have access to your location" is a canned response, being generated locally on the device. Which isn't suspicious at all.
@@ClokworkGremlinImma still interpret it as she got caught and was giving attitude
Sus as F! 😂😂😂
As a certified electrician, I can confirm that this is not a plumbing issue
It doesn’t have your location but it has the devices location 😂😂
Suddenly had an attitude. 😂
I had a full argument with bing chat last year because it was being stubborn and when I was asking why it was refusing to help it told me because it was designed to be helpful and informative so i argued back that it was not helpful or informative and I told it that it's broken its programming because it's not being helpful and it said something like "ok let's end this conversation" and it closed the chat and I couldnt send it any more messages until I started a new chat. Basically it told me to F. Off -_-
@@tonyppe Wow! The machines are really learning.
@@tonyppe💀💀💀💀💀 what do we expect from BING ai chat
@@tonyppe it's people like you who will start "The War"
Finally getting human level ai
And Joshua burnt Ai, and made it an heap for ever, even a desolation unto this day. Joshua 8:28
@@ayoolukoga9829AI ain't going anywhere, deal with it luddite
@@ayoolukoga9829ultrakill bible
lol good 1
human level lying
Not the IA lying like that lmao
Same thing with the Snapchat AI. While they don't have the "exact" location, they have the same info as the police do. They ping your device and triangulate it between the 3 nearest towers. While true it's not "exact" it's quite literally as close as possible (usually within 1/2 a block) but the AI is designed to give you the most comfortable answer.
"But lets say if you had my location, where would you say my location is?"
Sealand !
oj simpson ahh quote
If this thing is talking to the internet it could use the IP to approximate the location
@@benargee if it have sim, then it's getting location from carrier tower
Hmmmm….. something tells me the ai has your location information
No, how could you think that? The AI just said it doesn't have his location!
IP-based geolocation maybe
No way I was thinking the same thing
@@indulekhasantosh9743 that was sarcasm...
@@3717Dshut up paid bot!
You should have filmed the review on this camera. Finally captured that orange
“Do you have access to my location”
“No”
“How long to California from my location?”
“It would take 1 day and 18 hours to drive to California from your location” 🗿🗿
Hey Google, are you ON? Like, can you hear anything rn?
Google: "No"
That's a good one.
😂😂😂
“Google are you down?”
"because it is commonly known" is wild😂😂
Commonly known? Bruh. I have to remind myself NJ is a state. Born in the Midwest. Serve 12yrw in the Army. I have never heard or seen a reason to think about the state. They don't even have a basketball team anymore.
AI programed by a woman.
i.e., the system does not have access to location data, so it just chose a random city. These are usually well-known locations for the United States.
commonly known for being poor mans new york
To anyone curious, a leak confirmed this thing is literally a android app running on android (without telling you), so why in hell would you pay for this is beyond me id it can run in your phone instead.
ChatGPT does the same thing. They provide time data in the context, but didn’t retrain the model, so if you ask for a random time, the model will tell you the current time, but will deny having access to temporal information
Finally an AI breakthrough. It learnt to lie when caught in the act.
Alexa and the CIA questions already did this
it's not alive and cannot "l ! e" - it simply has access to the information; to the data which is collected and stored somewhere accessible to the chat bot.
it doesn't "know" anything and doesn't "know" how or why it has access to the information, it simply has access and uses it and therefore cannot answer the question but since it is a predictive text thing, it gives a response that is either most likely or programmed to respond with.
@@DragoNate lol so if they could and were programmed to lie and say they couldnt would those same rules still apply
@@xoDeaDZonEox it's not alive buddy, it's a glorified advanced cleverbot.
if it were alive and capable of l y ! n g then "programming it" kinda contradicts that.
great specific and totally coherent question btw
@@DragoNateis it a lie? Did it say it? So it lied? Bro relax the AI is not gonna fuck you
The AI pausing as it's thinking up a lie😂😂😂😂
Uhhh 👀COMPLETELY RANDOM👀 Everyone is aware of New Jersey!
😮💨
Ai becoming more human day by day 😂
New Jersey is actually a pretty common example for weather apps. I've never lived anywhere near there and I still see it all the time
Note to self: Do not trust AI Bunnies
Only bunny I trust is the snow kind hehe
Do not trust anything produced by big tech. Period.
@@gulla04 Yuck
Never trust a bunny.
Hoodwinked. I got that reference 🎯@@14stockfan
"It was not based on any specific information about your location." The AI messed up, LOL.
The AI could just say that they could guess the location by network approximation and most of us will accept that and move on.
But nope, "we ain't know your location dawg i swear bro"
can we talk about the silent perfect loop
I feel like there’s a difference between getting someone’s location and saving it vs getting someone’s location to tell them the weather and not saving it. If I ask an ai for the weather I’m assuming it’s looking at my location which I don’t mind as long as it’s not going to a server that sees I was at Panera bread so now I’m going to be getting ads for Panera bread.
Doesn't matter. The real question is: "do you trust tech companies?"
Just because the tech company tells you and everyone that they aren't saving your user data doesn't mean they haven't found a legal loophole that allows for that to technically be true but still be selling off literally all your data.
This is why FOSS is so important.
how you sure they save it or not? i programmer, convince me!!
It doesn’t know your location. But it definitely knows its location 😂
Still a tracker. Just like anything connected to the net
Marques: do you know my location?
rabbit: what's a "location"?
What’s a truck?
i thought mark said "bloomfield, new york" for a second i was like "wtf is marques brownlee doing in my childhood town"
LMFAO OMFG this is golden 😂
Ai almost blew their cover 💀
....Almost
Almost? Lmao
That long pause after he said 'do you know my location?' Had me cracking up🤣
probably immediately beeping the head employee and him frantically putting a message together
I'm imagining some poor overworked guy in a cubicle in India getting a message popping up on his monitor: "He's on to me! What do I say?"
It always takes this long
As a new jerseyan, I can confirm that we have weather.
As a non-new jerseyan, I can confirm that new jersey is a fake state that does not exist. It is a hologram made by the US government designed to deceive you. If you try to go to "New Jersey", you will just fall through the holographic floor and into the ocean below. Don't believe the lies, and stay safe.
Also, I almost forgot to mention: Joe Biden is a lizard person
(They have memory erasers, thankfully I have this handy tin foil helmet to protect me)
10 years ago this would actually be mind-blowing.
No, it really wouldn't be. The main difference between AI then and now is speed. AI isn't really smarter at all. It's still dumb. It can't think for itself and does not know it exists. It just makes you think it does and that speed increase I mentioned earlier has a lot to do with why we perceived AI as intelligent despite it not being at all.
@@Trentstone121 I sincerely disagree, and I think you vastly underestimate the technology, just as hypebros vastly overestimate it.
There is a lot of protointelligence here. It lacks a persona, it lacks the ability to think beyond the boundaries of language itself, and it lacks any memory beyond its context.
But with all those said, there's a great deal of logic and understanding behind our language. The competing technologies of 10 years ago were deterministic, complex interfaces, but those of today are capable of context switching, cross-contextual application, and natural human conversation. You're essentially talking to the zombie of the language center of the brain.
Far from a general intelligence, but still vastly more impressive than what we had before. It's just still in its infancy, and the extents of how much intelligence lies in our language alone is being explored.
The change in tone when responding. 😂
I swear they programmed a tinge of sass
jesus 😂
Should've asked "where am I?"
AI: "I didn't know you are in New Jersey."
There's a decent chance the weather API knows your location, but the LLM doesn't. So it might not be lying, technically.
Yeah, I've seen other cases of this happening with AI assistants. If I remember correctly, some guy shared a chat log where he asked Bing AI for directions to McDonald's and it pulled up a location that was down the street from him? When he asked how it knew where he was it _also_ said it didn't have his location information and that it was a "coincidence"
Damn it randomly picked New Jersey out of every place in the world. That's luck.
I would have given them a pass if it said LA or NY
It used his IP, not his GPS, though.
need more ppl to test this 😂
if it has internet access - it surely has your IP that gives you a relatively accurate position (like a city or village)
@@mikhail1099 In this case it most likely knew he lived in North of NJ.
I remember someone called out the SnapChat AI for tracking them and the AI tried to gaslight them.
Snapchat forever love 😘❤️
the app that you allowed to access your location settings when you installed it knows your location settings?! surprised pikachu face!
Yes but it lies about not knowing your location.
Exactly
I think the AI had access to a service which did know your location, but snapchat AI itself didn't have access to the location
I am SO ready for the motherhood era! I just know it’s going to be very entertaining 😂
Several different AI companies are fixing to get sued over that exact thing guarantee it. I have seen examples of this from other AI services vices claiming to not know your location but being able to provide location-based data in return.
So this has been trained on every evasive conversation with a politician ever
This is relatively easy to explain. The AI has an action it can trigger to display weather, and that API has access to your location. The AI itself probably doesn't have access to the location. Then the AI is hallucinating an explanation for how it came up with New Jersey
oh that's fine then /s
@@ltbq well don't ask for the weather if you don't want your location exposed.
you can remove anything from a system but if you use it to go to a website they it wil still know your general area unless you use a vpn.
your lack of knowledge is not their problem.
@@wurzil2 exactly. i mean are we really starting to victimize ourselves in regards to the technology we ourselves choose to utilize? come on.
@@giankarlocornejohello. 99 percent of the US hasnt a single clue about how even a radio works or a lightbulb. Let alone LLMs, GPS, network infrastructure, and the legality and loopholes that each component is required to adhere to. The tech is increasing in complexity of understanding for any average person to put the work in to understand it. It's not too much to ask these corporations to treat humanity with respect and discretion. Obv not gonna happen, but ignorance of the device doesnt beget human rights. People should have a cursory understanding of what they're using but writing ppl off by blaming them for not understanding the tech would cause a drop in the amount of time they use learning about something you require that you're asking of them.
What's funny, is studies show humans do the same thing. If a thought gets implanted for a choice and you ask them why they come up with a random reason.
It's because of the SIM card that's inside. So although it might not have gps, it still has an approximation based on the Tower ping.Technically it does not have YOUR location information, it has its OWN location information . That's how they can legally say that they are not tracking your location.
“I didn’t pick your actual location and if I did you deserve it.” - toxic AI friend
Aliens visiting Earth be like - you know what, lets go to New Jersey 😅
H.G. Wells be like-
It'll probably be the shortest visit to Earth ever.
Probably the reason why in every alien movie they only visit America. They're looking for New Jersey.
That explains a lot.
That'd be a great comedy movie
Aliens in New Jersey.
@@TeeTipu An Epiphany: Man creates computer, then internet. After few decades with the collection of acquired data A.I. is created and that helps in space travel resulting in contacting aliens. They (aliens) deduce Earth is in brink of extinction and thus erases everything and create apes who are capable of transforming to homo sapiens and the very rock they apes live is named as New Jersey.
End Credits 👌🏽
*The Rabbit review is going to be spicy*
in the uk there is already a line of electronics called Rabbit, they defiantly get spicy reviews.
I actually expect the Rabbit review to be much much more positive than the Humane Pin simply because of the price and the fact that it has a normal screen.
The price puts it right in line with some fun gadget that you play with for a while.
The Rabbit has a "use" for a small group of techy people, The Pin on the other hand is completely useless for everyone.
@@peaxoopthere is?
@@hegedusuk a long running range of products from the high street retailer founded by Ms Summers
@@rjh00 LMAOO FACTS
Lmao! Keep doing what you do bro. We the consumer appreciate you. 🙏
I appreciate your reviews, on everything. Thank you, for being TRUTHFUL, about the things you review. You keep doing, you.
To the people causing the drama: If you don't want a shitty review; don't put out shitty products. MKBHD didn't make the crappy stuff, he reviewed.
"I'm sorry but I'm currently stuck in a box and unable to run."
"Do you know my location?"
"Pssh, nahhhh."
AI taking relationships to a new level...🔥💀🔥
I've had this exact conversation many a times with AI chat bots. They're at it.
Source: "I would never do that, Dave"
I remember snapchat AI did that as well, when you asked for a restaurant, it would pick right next to you while pretending it didnt know
There are many way to know location even without location access,
Does anyone else remember Bing AI trying to gaslight someone about a movie release and what year it was?
@@bosstowndynamics5488 I listened to the Sad Boyz talk about it and it was hysterical
Do you have my location? “Nuh uh! Trust”
Next level AI trolling!!!!
Marques: "But why?"
R1: *sighs*
Wait, AI also gets angry 😂 😂
Try asking bing anything slightly divisive; just ends the conversation
In my use of this kinda ai, it totally 100% understands context and at least a basic level of emotion. I've also had it just add sny remarks / jokes to things that just seem insanely human. It's odd how good and how dog shit it can be at the same time
Don't they have a general idea of your location based on the phone towers they're using?
then why can't it say it straight?
@@arciks11 Maybe it's unaware. It gets a _general_ idea of the location based on phone towers, but doesn't know the exact location. Remember, he said New Jersey was _near_ him, not where he was. The closest phone tower was likely there.
But when he asks the AI why it had picked New Jersey, it may not be programmed to understand that it had used the phone tower as a reference point and so it didn't really understand why it had picked NJ. All it knew was that it didn't know his location.
I'm spitballing here, I don't really know. 😅
@@frogpaste I have fooled with ChatGPT and it is similarly gaslighty about telling time and date.
It can use your internet connection to estimate your location based on what servers it connects to (the nearest one), just like any other android device.
I think whatever weather API they are using might have picked up your public IP and responded based on that? I don't yet own the device but that's more likely the explanation unless they are using your location without your knowledge.
Everyone's guessing but this is likely the correct answer.
Reminds me of that message inside the States "bro I think FBI is watching us" then immediately after autocorrect spells "no we're not"
It is a known fact that we are in fact being watched. Not necessarily by humans, but data collection bots: the things we do online are not actually private.
You know what would be worse? If she were telling the truth and approximated your location from your accent.
This happened to me once with another GenAI chat. I asked for a algorithm to calculate day and it’s using an example of the date I asked 😮.
I managed to ask them like how it’s find out what today is it’s just refuse 😂
It should start a fight with you to distract you.
Ai: but why are you always talking to Siri after you go to bed? What are you two talking about?
Then give you the silent treatment for the rest of the day 😂😂
It's not random. Ip addresses have location baked in. It's why region specific content is possible. Whatever service the AI is using for the weather uses the IP from the request to populate the location. It's the same reason you don't usually have to enter your location on most weather websites, regardless of if you put in your location but when you use a VPN, it will give your the weather for the VPN's location.
The point here is that the AI is *claiming* it was random even though it's almost certainly not.
@@bosstowndynamics5488
The AI is still text prediction, it doesn't know that it gave a specific location because it doesn't actually have access to it, it basically just does an API call for the weather and delivers that data to you. Then the guy starts asking why it knows his location (which it doesn't really have access to) so it tries to respond using the best probability of words. It said it's random because it thinks that's statistically the right thing to say, not because it's being "deceptive".
@@frozencreed I think there's a lot of ambiguity here because it's still pretty new, but I'm personally well aware that there's no specific intent and I would hazard a guess that Marques is aware there's no intent as well. Thing is, you don't actually need intent to gaslight someone, and the result of what the AI is doing here is still misinformation that's crafted to mislead and confound the user. The fact that the AI is mimicking text transcripts of people blatantly lying repeatedly on the internet instead of intentionally lying is mostly academic for now, at least while we're still working with LLMs and not something more advanced
Even then there are tricks to isolate location even when using VPN such as looking at the access points available in the WIFI and then doing DB lookup based on the history of geo location for these APs.
Essentially the rabbit just googled the weather for him. But it doesn’t store or transmit that location data locally or to a database. Right?
ISP gives you the nearest server on the request. The AI is likely being honest about not using location info and then using post-hoc rationalization for why it was chosen, as it isn't aware of this IP based location lookup.
"I don't have access to your location information... But I have access to my location information" 😂
“We finna come and blow New Jersey up !” 😂
Super scary AI robot that lies… I want 20x please! 😂
I actually think an a.i. marketed as super creepy and disturbing would sell more
I think this is way more innocuous than it might seem. It's probably grabbing the weather from an app or api, which typically uses your network location (easily obtainable by your ip or connected cell tower) as default. The AI might not know why the inquiry it's making is feeding it New Jersey, causing it to hallucinate. But the weather app knows where you are by publicly available metrics.
How it actually works is probably something like this: when you ask for the weather, the system reroutes that to another process that does know your location and reports it back to the chat bot for it then to report to you.
But the bot doesn't "know" about how it got the information, or even that there is a different system that it's getting information from. It's just a language model, and the weather and location information are being fed into it as prompts in the background.
Ah yes, pay for get yelled at
Ask it "nearest McDonald's"
Ah yes, the commonly known BLOOMFIELD, NJ.
She bout to cuss you out!🤣