@@Animexxkyubii sadly no as id get a 2nd copy strike if I did so, I spent 2 weeks redesigning a demon slayer fight scene only to get a strike, very disheartening.
This is real nice, i would love if you were to upload a full version somewhere else, maybe even redesign other parts of the anime sound. You might upload the clips somewhere else and add their link the description
Honestly i think that the redesign was really lit but it was too chaotic like the lines which she is saying gets mixed up with the bg sound and makes the viewers a bit confused on what to focus the bg sound or the voice acting I think that's why anime made the bg sound high when she stopped talking and low when she was talking Well that was only my opinion
I agree but I think I like the rework because of it. Its so chaotic and violent which matches what is going on at the screen. Yes it doesn't sound as solemn and noble but it draws on passion and strength instead.
if you take into account the physics then the sound effects are way more better. when quetz descends with ultimo tope patada she is cutting the atmosphere so the resistance that air have is what give us that magnificent sound, and the voice of her that diminish in the end is because she is literally burning the air so almost no sound apart from the friction can be heard.
I mean, wouldn't you agree that the original seriously "lacks" sound, like the initial take off is there but then it goes pure silent It really doesn't fit You could have shown me his/her redesign and I would have believed it was the real anime as it doesn't obstruct her voice lines and really sells out her noble phantasm's power but it's ur opinion if you like it or not
@@DarkFoxes I guess its a personal preference thing. I'm not sure how to describe it, but I guess I just prefer the impact sound in the original. I feel they made a little too much noise going on at the impact. I prefer the original cause it sounds, to me anyway, like a louder, harder and sharper roar of an impact. With this they seemed to add a bit more noise (I guess you could call it a bit more 'roaring?' noise than before) That partly drowns out/slightly mutes that original sound and feels like it lessens the sharpness of the original which I liked. I'm really not sure if I'm explaining it well. I guess its a case of 'less is better' for me, in this particular case anyway. I do think the additions they made on the fall are nice, but the impact just doesn't have the same feel to me. I understand that the redesign might be more realistic, and I'm no sound designer, but it just doesn't sound as nice to my ears. And when I brought this up with my friend group they all seem to agree.
God saw what you will but this Np was the most awesome! The scale, the power! and its a nice touch that tiamat instant puts up ashield when she sees her coming lol
Imo, redesigned one seems more accurate as there are more harsh wind breaking bashing noises and the harsher post-effect noise as she hits her target. It might sound more unpleasant to ears but hey it is what it is in nature😁 Nice work there, props to your effort.
Babylonia's animation is on par with Ufotable's. I mean, even if you want to talk about Cloverworks FGO's sound effect, it sounded really good. If FGO were made by Ufotable, most of the fights wouldn't have the characters fight using physical attributes, rather than they generically shoot energy blasts and didn't move at all. Beside that, I also believes that there is high chances that Ufotable would pulverize the story into nothingness and only focuses in the aspect of animation. Cloverworks also have really good CGI, though they're not the same level of that of Ufotable, atleast we didn't get that nightmarish early Titan Shifters CGI in S4 of Attack On Titan.
@@markoantonijevic9683 UBW and HF. Hell rider vs saber alter being a massive fight scene ruins Shirou vs kirei, the actual grand final fight of heavens feel and stay night in general. Even 9LBW got totally sidelined all to make that one fight scene look as good as possible.
I think the reason why they made the nuke sound weaker in Quetz's original noble phantasm version is so that you can clearly hear Quetz more clearly. After all it would detract quite significantly from the scene given what a noble phantasm is, the manifestation of the legend associated with the hero to be drowned out by other sounds wouldn't sound as good. Not to mention having to balance out all the other sounds going on so that you can make out distinct sounds and what is going on exactly in the scene can be a bit of a nightmare I can imagine especially if a sound or sounds is of narrative importance. Anyway I'll have to still go with the original, good attempt though.
redesigns focus only on sfx not voice lines, wouldn't be a *sound* redesign if I equalised both Voice and sound Besides, these scenes I remake are not fit for such sfx in terms of scenario as animes that actually do these sorts of stuff do a great job at making sure chrs say thier voice lines before sfx impact which is what makes them so epic
If I were animating a sprite series, I'd ask if you'd like to help with the sound design. It's a shame this scene doesn't last longer, I'm having multiple eargasms everytime.
Personally, I think they're about the same quality. While the 2nd one sounds cleaner, it has a serious tuning problem in the sense that how do you set it up? Do you make it sound good on full systems and TVs miss it or tune it to sound epic on what 75% of people consume media on and destroy sound system users house? At least this is the exact opposite of the problem Apocrypha had. Apocrypha had way too much clipping and that ruined all the audio for me. Those fights would be awesome to see audio redone on before fine tuning ones like this which already sounded big just not necessarily your idea of big. And just to reiterate I'm not trying to diminish your efforts this edit is amazing and if it wasn't side by side I wouldn't know this wasn't from a high budget studio.
So the redesign is you pumped up the explosion so that we couldn't hear what she was saying. I think the original was better since I could actually hear the dialogue which adds to the scene.
Original was better. In a powerful blast, there's the initial flash of the explosion, and brief lull, then the boom, original observed this, the rework didn't
light travels faster than sound that's real life 101,redesign focuses on intensity of power not realism (otherwise it'd just be pretty much the same thing so no point redesigning)
We glad its ain't real, because her power really bring absolute calamity,i wonder we hear this in real our ear will have sound problem or maybe deaf...
![หมานแต่ผัวเขา - แสตมป์ โตเกียวมิวสิค [ OFFICIAL MUSIC VIDEO ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/m0g1TSBJPgo/mqdefault.jpg)
![Fate/stay night [Heaven's Feel] II. lost butterfly - Clip #03 (dt.)](/img/n.gif)
Fate fans are requested to refrain from harassing other viewers opinions or I'm closing this video's comment section
I'd wager a guess there is no "full version" of the reworked version avaiable somewhere?
@@Animexxkyubii sadly no as id get a 2nd copy strike if I did so, I spent 2 weeks redesigning a demon slayer fight scene only to get a strike, very disheartening.
This is real nice, i would love if you were to upload a full version somewhere else, maybe even redesign other parts of the anime sound. You might upload the clips somewhere else and add their link the description
holy shit this is hella sick
I always felt the sound design for this NP in the anime was lacking. You are a godsend for this.
Best sound is when she was start jump from earth to outer space... That redesign sound was lit🔥
Honestly i think that the redesign was really lit but it was too chaotic like the lines which she is saying gets mixed up with the bg sound and makes the viewers a bit confused on what to focus the bg sound or the voice acting
I think that's why anime made the bg sound high when she stopped talking and low when she was talking
Well that was only my opinion
I agree but I think I like the rework because of it. Its so chaotic and violent which matches what is going on at the screen. Yes it doesn't sound as solemn and noble but it draws on passion and strength instead.
i totally agree cause they focused on making the bg as awesome as they can and they did a very great job
if you take into account the physics then the sound effects are way more better. when quetz descends with ultimo tope patada she is cutting the atmosphere so the resistance that air have is what give us that magnificent sound, and the voice of her that diminish in the end is because she is literally burning the air so almost no sound apart from the friction can be heard.
YaaaaaS Really Nice Impact Sound !! Pure ART by Sound So Perfect
That was an eargasm.
Hmm, I think I still prefer the original, but both are good.
I mean, wouldn't you agree that the original seriously "lacks" sound, like the initial take off is there but then it goes pure silent It really doesn't fit
You could have shown me his/her redesign and I would have believed it was the real anime as it doesn't obstruct her voice lines and really sells out her noble phantasm's power but it's ur opinion if you like it or not
@@DarkFoxes I guess its a personal preference thing. I'm not sure how to describe it, but I guess I just prefer the impact sound in the original.
I feel they made a little too much noise going on at the impact. I prefer the original cause it sounds, to me anyway, like a louder, harder and sharper roar of an impact. With this they seemed to add a bit more noise (I guess you could call it a bit more 'roaring?' noise than before) That partly drowns out/slightly mutes that original sound and feels like it lessens the sharpness of the original which I liked. I'm really not sure if I'm explaining it well. I guess its a case of 'less is better' for me, in this particular case anyway.
I do think the additions they made on the fall are nice, but the impact just doesn't have the same feel to me.
I understand that the redesign might be more realistic, and I'm no sound designer, but it just doesn't sound as nice to my ears. And when I brought this up with my friend group they all seem to agree.
@@stixusardarach2625 yh in the end it all down to preferences, the guy is a jojo fan so no wonder he like bass and subwoofers
@@DarkFoxes for the sake of making it sound like a nuke though the first one does hit closer than the edit.
The original is more real the redesigned is more cool
God saw what you will but this Np was the most awesome!
The scale, the power! and its a nice touch that tiamat instant puts up ashield when she sees her coming lol
Sorry for the anti-climactic cut but TH-cam won't let me upload more of the episode
can u upload it somewhere else?
@@aslief9808 possibly but however I do not recommended it due to copyright (I got permission to upload only specific segments)
😭 I was looking for the link but not,it's amazing
Imo, redesigned one seems more accurate as there are more harsh wind breaking bashing noises and the harsher post-effect noise as she hits her target. It might sound more unpleasant to ears but hey it is what it is in nature😁
Nice work there, props to your effort.
At least she went out with a bang (a big one xD)
The boom of her re-entry into the atmosphere will always be one of my fav sounds in anime
redesign made this part the way it should have sounded like, sucks that Ufotable didn't do it
Babylonia's animation is on par with Ufotable's. I mean, even if you want to talk about Cloverworks FGO's sound effect, it sounded really good. If FGO were made by Ufotable, most of the fights wouldn't have the characters fight using physical attributes, rather than they generically shoot energy blasts and didn't move at all. Beside that, I also believes that there is high chances that Ufotable would pulverize the story into nothingness and only focuses in the aspect of animation. Cloverworks also have really good CGI, though they're not the same level of that of Ufotable, atleast we didn't get that nightmarish early Titan Shifters CGI in S4 of Attack On Titan.
@@eclipsewaves is there an example of ufotable butchering the story to focus on animation?
@@markoantonijevic9683 UBW and HF.
Hell rider vs saber alter being a massive fight scene ruins Shirou vs kirei, the actual grand final fight of heavens feel and stay night in general. Even 9LBW got totally sidelined all to make that one fight scene look as good as possible.
@@r.k845 9LBW was so underwhelming in the HF adaptation.
.
Chills on chills holy crap
I think the reason why they made the nuke sound weaker in Quetz's original noble phantasm version is so that you can clearly hear Quetz more clearly.
After all it would detract quite significantly from the scene given what a noble phantasm is, the manifestation of the legend associated with the hero to be drowned out by other sounds wouldn't sound as good. Not to mention having to balance out all the other sounds going on so that you can make out distinct sounds and what is going on exactly in the scene can be a bit of a nightmare I can imagine especially if a sound or sounds is of narrative importance.
Anyway I'll have to still go with the original, good attempt though.
redesigns focus only on sfx not voice lines, wouldn't be a *sound* redesign if I equalised both Voice and sound
Besides, these scenes I remake are not fit for such sfx in terms of scenario as animes that actually do these sorts of stuff do a great job at making sure chrs say thier voice lines before sfx impact which is what makes them so epic
Both my eyes and ears are blessed
I love it
If I were animating a sprite series, I'd ask if you'd like to help with the sound design. It's a shame this scene doesn't last longer, I'm having multiple eargasms everytime.
Up her voice volume, she is The Goddess Quetzalcoatl. Like any god her voice should below through the sky.
Personally, I think they're about the same quality. While the 2nd one sounds cleaner, it has a serious tuning problem in the sense that how do you set it up? Do you make it sound good on full systems and TVs miss it or tune it to sound epic on what 75% of people consume media on and destroy sound system users house? At least this is the exact opposite of the problem Apocrypha had. Apocrypha had way too much clipping and that ruined all the audio for me. Those fights would be awesome to see audio redone on before fine tuning ones like this which already sounded big just not necessarily your idea of big. And just to reiterate I'm not trying to diminish your efforts this edit is amazing and if it wasn't side by side I wouldn't know this wasn't from a high budget studio.
Definitely sounds better but if lowering the volume a bit would make it perfect
Holy shitttttttt wtf did you just do to my earsss! Sheeesh
Your ears went extinct after it 😂
It sounds like Fire Force flames ❤️
So the redesign is you pumped up the explosion so that we couldn't hear what she was saying. I think the original was better since I could actually hear the dialogue which adds to the scene.
RIP ears. 😅
wearing a headset when I saw this. 🤣
fucking CHILLS
The Goosebumps 😂😂
fck! goosebumps
Damn that really sounds like a powerfull attack
Can you do this for castlevania. As much as I liked the adaptation, I felt as though some fight scenes were losing sound fx
"Copyright is the ultimate noble phantasm" - Oof lol
At first I was like, I really like the original. But then I was like, ok yea you made it way better lol
Favorite "Daga" in anime. I mean, bitch becomes, if I'm right, the freaking meteor that killed the dinosaurs!
I like them both
clearly heard a sound familiar from Fire Force :D but its so well implemented its crazy
enough to make a grown man cry :')
I missed the chance to break my ears on cinema
If only ufo had fire force sound effects
Good job, cuz. Considering she's becoming the bloody meteor that killed the dinosaurs.
Please do Pera De Sol next
Original was better. In a powerful blast, there's the initial flash of the explosion, and brief lull, then the boom, original observed this, the rework didn't
light travels faster than sound that's real life 101,redesign focuses on intensity of power not realism (otherwise it'd just be pretty much the same thing so no point redesigning)
Redesign just like "fire force" for me , but it's good
We glad its ain't real, because her power really bring absolute calamity,i wonder we hear this in real our ear will have sound problem or maybe deaf...
The redesign sounds more realistic to what's actually happening but the original plays well with the music
Pinche escenota me despeina los pelos de los webos 🥵
So when's the ringging on my ear going to stop?
İTS FUCKİGN AWESOME WTF
The redesign was amazing except you kinda can't hear her. tbf that's just an audio balancing problem that could be fixed
i mean they did that to not make the watchers go explode their ear drums
Flashbacks of gilgamesh enuma elish
The only thing getting nuked here are my ears
The redesign is definitely better 👍
oof
Menuda patada!
can you make more of this?
I am currently on a strike watch list so I have to be very careful at the moment but yes Iv redesigned Ishtar's NP
Original btr
Nah original sounds better.
How??
You made better sound effect than fuckin cloverworks
Thats just insane