How is everyone doing? Rian wants back in! Please no. Would you want to see Rian direct a Mandalorian episode? If you got something out of this video please give it a "Like". Consider subscribing. And sharing is wonderful. Cheers Crazies!
Yup. I am not gonna lie 3 quarters into the movie and I was laughing my ass off AT the movie. I was thankful that they didn't throw me out but when you see ridiculous story like TLJ you just have to pull the Joker out. After the movie I went with my mate for a couple of cold ones and we were just laughing at the movie: "A 40 year franchise just went down the toilet" and we laughed some more...
I feel you.....I didn't even have fun getting drunk afterwards. I left the cinema and I didn't talk at all for the first 15 min. I just couldn't believe it. It was like someone just hit me in the face multiple times with a jack-hammer. I just felt empty.
Personally I felt quite good. For the first time since Revenge of The Sith I did care about what was going on. In The Force Awakens I didn’t because it was just the same as a new hope but with more superficial characters. But I was ready to forgive this movie as it leaded to The Last Jedi where all the characters grew somehow. But The Rise of Skywalker threw it all away and The Last Jedi is the only one of the sequel trilogy who tried to make things right by correcting JJ Abrams’ errors. Rogue One was okay as an action movie but the characters were very weakly defined.
@@FunZies. I mean many people accused EP7 for plagiarism, so as Ruin recreated the iconic Hoth scene of EP5, he wanted to make clear, that it is different. But he did not put work into it, so this is the result.
I mean it doesn’t even make sense I am assuming he meant this planet was a giant salt flat but needless to say salt flats are the same as table salt and I don’t advise you Try to taste salt from one
@@mala6238 Even the bit where the rebel has the binocular device and sees the walkers and the camera pans from the legs to the upper bodies, and then outward revealing the whole fleet. That was ripped off in Last Jedi.
I used to work in a restaurant than I started bringing people the wrong orders and tell them I subverted their expectations and than I got fired I didn't know all our customers were racist
Remember this is the director that refused for us to see how Luke would react to Han's death. It is a sad day when a stranger had a more emotional act to an original's death than his best friend.
A Luke scene where he's doing whatever and is hit with the feeling of Han's death through the force would have been such a nice touch. I should stop reading these comments because I'm only gonna keep getting more disappointed.
That wasn't only a Rian Johnson thing. JJ also didn't understand the friendship of the OT's main characters. Remember, after Han's death in The Force Awakens, Leia walked right past Chewie to hug Rey. That's what happens when you get writers and directors who don't understand the characters.
@@verindictus3639 JJ made other huge mistakes, too, such as not bringing Harrison, Mark, and Carrie back together on-screen and talking about the importance of having a prominent black character then making him a clown. So, admitting one mistake doesn't excuse JJ's bad decisions or lead me to think that he's better than Rian Johnson. Those two should both stay far away from Star Wars. Heck, Rian only ruined one franchise (Star Wars), JJ ruined two (Star Trek and Star Wars) and is on his way to really screwing up the DCEU now by hiring an American-hating writer for the American character Superman.
I feel like we shouldn't HAVE to explain why the guy who ruined Star Wars needs to stay away from Star Wars, but sadly, some people are a little too slow on the uptake...
Kathleen Kennedy ruïned star wars. Johnson helped her with that. They both clearly know nothing about star wars and are just trying to push their own agenda with this franchise. George may not be the best director but he did understand star wars since he litterly invented it. The biggest mistake the fans made was making George believe he wasn't good enough for his own creation therefore pushing him to sell it to Disney. Dave Filoni and Jon Favreau are in my opinion Star Wars last hope. Because without them Star Wars wouldn't be Star Wars anymore. But that's all my opinion ofcourse
It’s selfish to avoid a director a lot of Star Wars fans liked to stay away from Star Wars. If he wants to do an episode of Mandalorian, and you don’t want to watch it, fine, no one will force you. The fact is, as a film director, Rian Johnson has a lot of fan. He directed to great movies, like Looper and Knives Out, and two great episodes of Breaking Bad. He just released a movie you didn’t like, this doesn’t mean he has to stay away from Star Wars. The fans who liked his film deserve to get an episode of The Mandalorian directed by him. You don’t. Then don’t watch it and let us have our time of pleasure.
I remember leaving the cinema after TLJ. Me and my dad had seen it together, and whilst on the bus, we were silent. We were thinking about the crap we had just watched. Then, he looked at me and said, "It wasn't very good was it." I said, "Yeah."
The milking scene was supposed to show how Luke survived the island, and it displayed him as a hermit. Anyways, the scene is less than a minute and has no effect on the plot, so I don't see what the big deal is.
@@justoons2949 The scene also shows how far his character has fallen as a living legend/hero which is a HUGE plot point in the last jedi (THE DUDE IS LITERALLY THE LAST JEDI). people don't like that, which surely you acknowledge as being at least a little fair. plus with the way it's framed and acted it just plain looks goofy. idk what else to tell ya.
For some reason, I'm reminded of a story Kevin Smith tells on one of his stage shows, about directing Bruce Willis in something, and Bruce asks Kevin what lens he's using for the shot, and Kevin says something like, "A close up..." and Bruce repeats, "What lens are you using for the shot?" Kevin turns and asks the camera guy, and then gives Bruce the answer. Bruce responds, "And why don't you know that?"
You make some excellent points here. Most people aren't aware of what 'direction' or 'cinematography' actually mean. They think if there's a pretty image in a movie, that's good cinematography. It's actually defined as the art of telling a story using camera and lighting. This means camera placement/movement/focus/framing, use of suitable color and light, etc. in order to make not a picture, but cinema - moving images that convey a sense of what's going on, both atmospherically and narratively. In other words, to tell a story. What those people are admiring is the set/costume/prop design, mostly.
Any director that says "I stand by EVERY choice" after they make a film is either a fool or lying. Even Scorsese constantly questions whether he made the right choices or not. Rian is no Scorsese. For one, Scorsese is a 78 year old man and Rian is 3 toddlers in a suit.
@@GameOver-vh7py well he kinda is, prequels just prove that he couldnt really direct a movie and wrtite a script on his own without a shit load of people fixing it, like in the OT. He was a guy with vision and great ideas, but he needed all those great actors and directors to make Star Wars work. Prequels only prove that to be right
@@thanos_6.0 but that’s even worse : he recognized that he messed up but he didn’t change anything, because the next day he says : « It was designed to be that way and you can’t undo that. »
It is volunteer to show that Finn doesn’t understand why Rose kisses him and that it isn’t a dumb romance like everyone thought. But you will just ignore this detail only to complain about this very rigorous and precise directing style.
I almost walked out of the theater when Rose pulled a “gotcha” moment by crashing her pointless ski speeder into Finn. Instead I remained seated to witness the dumbest scene in all of Star Wars.
There are only two logical ways this scene should have ended. 1. Finn and Rose both die in the crash when she crashed her speeder into his. 2. The First Order soldiers - who were just getting orders to kill everyone a.k.a no prisoners - take one minute to open a lock on the battle-walkers and have a couple Stormtroopers shoot Rose and Finn, who are lying dazed and defenseless right next to them. And even if for some absurd reason they survive and the First Order just ignores them, they would STILL be dead, because they were good four or five KILOMETERS away from their base and Finn had to dragg a injured person behind him, through a SALT FIELD. By the time he managed to return the battle should be long over, with them being left behind on Krayt to be hunted down and killed by their enemies.
The only flaw in Citizen Kane is in the plot...a journalist tries to find out the meaning of Kane's last word, "Rosebud", but we're clearly shown Kane is alone when he died so how could anyone know his last word?
Ruin Johnson: I won't have my directing ability questioned by a robot! Robothead : I'm not questioning your directing ability, Ruin Johnson. I'm denying its existence.
I’ve been watching Star Wars my whole life and I will never ever forget how angry and embarrassed I was for being a Star Wars fan after watching each other the sequel movies.
Yeah. "You have 1 minute to make up a fanstory for Star Wars set 30 years in the future from Return of the Jedi." I bet 90% of what anyone wanting complete the task would come up with, would be better than the Disney films, yet they shoot this....and The rise of Palpatine and TFA. Write 100 plots, run them through 100 fans and see what floats on paper and shoot one of the best ones, not the worst ones. And use a good director, you can afford it. How could a studio fail such simple tasks? Disney should sell the rights to Star Wars.
When I finally watched this movie, I was amazed at how bad it looked. I couldn't put my finger on it, but it was just bad. It looked almost cartoonish or something. You explained it really well.
Same here. I really disliked the looks and cut of many scenes. Now I understand that the choices and hence the material was crap when entering the cutting room. I think the writing was mediocre and then they went into filming, totally overwhelmed by all the stuff they had to manage. Many of the stupid mistakes and bad choices just seem very rushed. No time to do it better? Knowing the american approach to health and job performance, i guess Rian was just drugged away. to not feel his anxiety for the ongoing fuckup. A present director should have taken corrective action at some point. Take another year to work out the movie before you bury a feckin' franchise...
It’s laughable to see how many people don’t even know how to write « Rian Johnson » properly ! Good to know that Last Jedi haters never learnt to write.
The moment Disney decided to not go with Lucas' plans for eps 7, 8 and 9, it was all over. What does the creator of Star Wars know about Star Wars anyway? Such arrogance from Mickey.
I wouldn't worry tbh, in 40 years the CGI will wither away and then the story will have to stand on its own. When that happens people will realize that it's shit, it's a very bad story.
He does deserve to be called out for handling the story terribly. But he and everyone else who worked on the film do not deserve to be harassed or threatened over it.
Before the knife disappeared, the vanishing knife is seen travelling the path over Rey's lower torso... That's a disembowelling shot right there and even with cauterisation the floor should have been a slip and slide of Rey's entrails if that guy was serious about killing Rey.
It is absolutely criminal that after 40 years of excellence, it took spectacle (Bladerunner 2049) and a gimmick (1917) for the Academy to recognize Roger Deakins’s work. Barton Fink, Thunderheart, 1984, True Grit, Fargo, Sicario, O Brother, Shawshank, Rango - every last one of them looked, felt, and did something very different and very interesting.
In that scene with Rey practicing with the lightsabre on the rock there's an above shot but with no reflection of the light from the sabre off its wet surface. That part stuck out like dogs balls to me but no one else seemed to notice it.
Finally a good take on Rian as a bad director and poor cinematography of The Last Jedi. Way too much talk is spent on the writing and themes which tricks people into thinking the other aspects are not as bad. They are. Thanks, Robot Head.
I just noticed when Rey stabs one of the guards at 11:55 the guy she stabs is behind another guard. This vital info is hidden from us because they failed at blocking the scene, well on top of everything else wrong with this fight scene.
I am literally forbidden from watching Robot Head in my own bed at night when my wife is laying next to me.. because I laugh so much that even when i am trying to not make a sound I shake the bed so much she freaks the fuck out. And that is the best way I can think of to say how great this channel is!! Especially when he's kicking Rian Johnson over and over in a dark alley in the early morning light. Fan-Fucking-Tastic!!!
I'll just put this out there: I recently watched _Knives Out,_ which was written and directed by Johnson, and it was a very capably told and directed movie. It's hard to imagine that the same person who made this movie is the same person who put together the mess that was _Last Jedi._
That's what I don't understand, because Knives Out genuinely a good film imo, but how the fuck did the same director do such a bad job on The Last Jedi
Rian Johnson is an amazing director: i'm amazed he still has a career in the film industry; i'm amazed that he actually gets paid for the shit he makes and i'm over come with amazement that he thinks he is good enough to direct an episode of the Mandalorian, because i don't think he could direct traffic in a parking lot!
@@edgarjacksby1402 it doesnt change the fact that tlj was trash because of him and his poor directing. His other movies may be decent or good, but we are talking specifically about SW here
What I've learned from all this is that the best films have creative teams with a lot of checks and balances. No one person should have full, uncontested creative authority.
I can rewatch episodes 1-6 no problem at all. Granted they’re far from perfect and many parts throughout I don’t like, but overall I can sit through each episode and enjoy myself. I have tried a few times, and there is absolutely NO doubt that I CANNOT ever sit through another watching of episode 7,8 or 9. I get maybe 30-45min into each episode and I just can’t take it anymore. The setting, the characters, the acting, the plot, the overall tone and feel of these movies is just tasteless, uninteresting, boring, and just BAD!!!
Say about the prequels what you want, but they had an original story that contributed to the bigger Story, didn't disrespect legacy characters in disgusting way and the main character wasn't a Mary Sue. I mean it's so ironic. I bet all my money that when Disney bought Star Wars and first discussed the future ST, one main topic at the start was "how do we avoid such a backlash like during the prequels" (I personally always loved the prequels). And here we 3 Films later, with a backlash 10 times huger then during the prequels and hardcore prequel haters stating that this dumpster fire, Disney calls a triology, is worse then the prequels. Ironic
Agree. The ROS is even worse, it took me three tries to actually watch it to completion (my wife got it as a present on DVD): I'd just fall asleep at about 1/3 in.
Robot Head: "Rian do you really understand camera angles, direction of actors, and general ideas of people's standards of a future classic movie?" Rian Johnson: "I'm about to classically subvert Robot Head's expectations!"
*Rian tries to get into the Studio* Jon Favreu: „We just gotta load up Tony's old Hulkbuster armor, a prototype for Cap's new shield and the Meg..me..megin... Thor's magic belt.“
Have you seen Star Wars Theory's Video showing an old Interview of George Lucas? He there shares his plans for the sequels that he had in mind before selling to Disney. Would love to hear your opinion on that 👌🏻
Kathleen: Rian writes "amazingly fierce & independent women"... Us: Only if your "definition" means forcing female characters down our throat with bad writing doing all the shoving.
I love Roger Deakins point about cinematography. Everyone orgasms all over Twitter about how pretty the last Jedi is. But that’s not actually cinematography. Just because it looks nice doesn’t excuse poor direction.
Thank you for this. You are doing the Force's work. Rian wants to be remembered? Allright, we'll make his Legacy a legacy of failure, just like he did to Luke.
@@drhypno6317 i agree. For example the cgi in the OT was really good for its time but you cant say it holds up anymore. But the fans remember it for its story and characters not for its fights (altho i still liked the space battles in ROTJ)
David Fincher once said “There are a hundred ways to shoot a scene but when it comes down to it there are only 2 and one of them is wrong” for Rian the only 2 options are dolly in or out. 🤡
His directing worked great for movies like knives out. Constant twists and turns, no real plot to follow, it’s just a movie on its own. But when there’s an already established series with a way of storytelling and we have 6/7 movies to see how characters act and react to situations, he’s an awful option.
Knives out was very entertaining yet very fking predictable. From the first 10 min I already predicted it was chris Evans. Because I know rian is a gotcha type of guy . Knives out had A HUGE STAR STUD CAST . I imagined the film without the HUGE names like.... CHRIS EVANS ... aka CAPTAIN AMERICA. Daniel Craig aka JAMES BOND 007 . And I imagined the film to be very boring........ yawn
@@valenwood6299 the surprise was not who is the killer but how did he kill. And if you guessed how and to what extent he was guilty, congratulations because this wasn't possible to predict.
@@filmdebating4915 its a fking murder mansion mystery. Fking family guy did a better job than rian Johnson. It's fking done before and always works because everyone loves a mansion murder mystery right ?
@@valenwood6299 did you guess how Ransom murdered Harlan ? No. This was the big surprise. Like Benoit Blanc said : a donut hole. Everything else lined up with what Benoit Blanc thought, except this donut hole. This is genius writing like we don't see very often. It was very refreshing to have such a clever murder mystery with a very unique tone which switches cinema genres in a very surprising way. I wish Rien Johnson was hired for more films, that man is a genius director and writer and anyone who say the contrary is a liar.
Very comprehensive and excellent work RH. Can't wait for your first tranche of pulp romance. Some suggested titles - _Rise of the Reylo Prince_ , _Fifty Shades of Ruin_ and _That's not a Moon Baby!_
Close ups are good at highlighting something important or fostering a claustrophobic feeling in the audience. Using them too much to say "this is important" only makes the audience feel that either nothing is important, everything is small, or both. The movie comes off as tiny in this epic setting. Everything in the movie feels like it's inconsequential. Sure, you can tell an inconsequential story in this setting, but there are payoffs in the film that should be huge and somehow feel like nothing at all. Luke dies in this film and it comes off like a wet fart because by that time the audience realizes that none of it matters. Which is exactly what happens when you put a nihilist in charge of a film like this.
11:32 the sword techniques are honestly abismal, with such dramatic movements and succh a wide stance she's waiting for someone with a polearm or even just fists to knock her over.
I remember enjoying TFA for the most part. I was looking forward to TLJ, but the trailers left a weird feeling in the back of my mind. I went in to see it with an open mind, had my 10 year old daughter with me. When Luke tossed the lightsaber over his shoulder I knew this was going to be bad. I hung in there giving the movie the benefit of the doubt until the Leia flying through space scene. My whole body literally cringed, catching my daughters attention, and I tried to show her that I was enjoying the movie but it was too late. Even she felt it at 10 years old, it was just bad bad bad. That Leia scene flying through space still makes me cringe to this day when I think about it.
I couldn't agree more Mr Astronagol... it is just so easy to get extra angry when driving, maybe because there is no room for error in a big box made of metal and metal. The Incredible Hulk brings into play a couple details from the comics, and of course, the abomination character, or if you wanna go by my nickname for him, "the spiky hulk".
I always think of “blocking” as only considering the outer silhouette of each charter in the shot. Basically not looking at the inner detail, but just the cut and profile of the character. If you think of Rian’s cinematographer in that light, taking every character as a silhouette, everything would look like a big bunch, with actors and robots all crowded together as a big mess. I’m not saying you can’t consider the inner detail of a character or object, it’s just while “blocking” this is all I consider when filming.
I will never forget when I was waiting in line to watch TLJ I saw the first crowd departing the theater and it looked like they were leaving a funeral. In a way it was. All those faces showed shock, bewilderment, and resigned. Those of us who were waiting were eager, laughing, and ready with anticipation. When I left the theater afterwards I was fking numb and so was the whole group I went with. Haven't seen TROS yet, and not going to bother with it.
I watched it at home with my father invited around who did nothing but tut and look bewildered the entire movie, ending with him saying "what a load of fucking rubbish". Sadly I didn't have the choice to walk out.
I watched the whole thing, but I went out for a loo break during the mary poppins scene, laughing my head off, and sharing baffled 'wtf' looks with the rest of the audience. The 'your mum' scene was the point of lost hope
@@flowinsounds My point of lost hope was when Luke confirmed that he did try to kill Kylo in his sleep. I pretty much tuned out of the movie at the point.
The throne room fight scene has absolutely no force powers whatsoever despite having TWO force users present, but hey, Kylo randomly stabs the ground for no reason (11:56) and features a vanishing weapon (14:39), so it's a goddamn masterpiece.
The first time I saw those guards in the throne room, and how they brandished their weapons and bust into "cool" poses when someone (I can't remember who) shouted at Snoke, I knew that any action we'd get from them would be trash. That one moment immediately undermines them. They're about as intimidating as that kid in high school who thought he could fight because he watched a lot of kung fu movies. It's nonsense. It's stuff like this that both distracts and detracts from the experience. (Incidentally, Gus Johnson does a video about this sort of thing, how everyone always cocks their gun when they "mean business," when, if they actually knew how to use it, there'd already be a round/shell in the chamber.) Point is, a real badass doesn't posture or pose. They don't need to; their power is in their presence. These walking lobsters scream of incompetence. They aren't even in range to engage. What's the point of taking a ready stance twenty feet away from the person you're guarding? The whole thing is just puerile and inept, and it was done at Johnson's direction. Contrast this with the Imperial guards we see in Return of the Jedi. They literally just. stand. there, and they still look more intimidating than anything else in the OT, save Vader, himself. Would you mess with them?
Knives out is a fantastic film, Rian's work on the Breaking Bad episodes he directed is awesome. Let him do stuff he's good at, keep him away from any star wars project though.
Oh that’s why the closeups made the whole movie feel like everything was cramped and small. It wasn’t a movie set in a GALAXY far far away, we were instead subjected to all these closeups that made the movie feel like a small room far far away lol
This is the first Star Wars movie I refused to watch. I heard from fans it was an atrocity and just couldn't subject myself to it. They were right! Great video Robot Head.
I was playing the vid in the background while doing some paperwork and I swear I thought it was a girl speaking in the beginning of the video, but it was apparently Roundhead Rian XD
My take on the bombing run, George uses WWII dog fight footage to model the X-Wing battles, Ruin ... WWII bombing run it is (but with malice not homage). Speaking as a pre digital era photographer, 100% with you on the sunset pics.
Disney needs to reign in Lucas Film if they ever hope to salvage anything about Star Wars. Part of that is making sure this man can't touch it ever again.
@@ArdaSReal Knives Out came out after TLJ and was pretty good, whether you liked TLJ or not. The fact is Rian Johnson is a good director who can make great movies.
After seeing the Last Jedi, I got a job at a movie theater and I would send patrons to the wrong theater to subvert their expectations. I figured if half the people I sent into the wrong theater liked the movie I chose for them, and the other half hated it, it showed how great I am and recommending movies.
So at 5:18, he forgot the first rule of shooting a scene. The rule of thirds. ANYTHING in the center of the shot is treated as insignificant to the viewer subconsciously. The space that people view the screen has meaning. Riding off into the sunset is always shot the same for a hero triumphant for a reason. Framing the scene correctly captures the movement and helps write the story. That is the job.
![[Live สด] การออกรางวัลสลากกินแบ่งรัฐบาล งวดวันที่ 16 พฤศจิกายน 2567](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wPd7VFfWHIA/mqdefault.jpg)
How is everyone doing? Rian wants back in! Please no. Would you want to see Rian direct a Mandalorian episode? If you got something out of this video please give it a "Like". Consider subscribing. And sharing is wonderful. Cheers Crazies!
Last Jedi was so bad I watched it on a plane and walked out
Bro! I missed your voice so much! So glad your back making more content!!! Can’t wait to see you rip apart 2021!
I’ll tell you my opinion after I’ve watched it play out in your video.
Obi wan: before the dark times
Yo fuck Rian Johnson
I will never forget how i felt when i left the theater after seeing last jedi.
It was that good huh?
Edit: I was being sarcastic guys xd
Yup. I am not gonna lie 3 quarters into the movie and I was laughing my ass off AT the movie. I was thankful that they didn't throw me out but when you see ridiculous story like TLJ you just have to pull the Joker out.
After the movie I went with my mate for a couple of cold ones and we were just laughing at the movie: "A 40 year franchise just went down the toilet" and we laughed some more...
I feel you.....I didn't even have fun getting drunk afterwards. I left the cinema and I didn't talk at all for the first 15 min. I just couldn't believe it. It was like someone just hit me in the face multiple times with a jack-hammer. I just felt empty.
Personally I felt quite good. For the first time since Revenge of The Sith I did care about what was going on. In The Force Awakens I didn’t because it was just the same as a new hope but with more superficial characters. But I was ready to forgive this movie as it leaded to The Last Jedi where all the characters grew somehow. But The Rise of Skywalker threw it all away and The Last Jedi is the only one of the sequel trilogy who tried to make things right by correcting JJ Abrams’ errors. Rogue One was okay as an action movie but the characters were very weakly defined.
It was the worst I’ve ever felt after a film....and I’ve seen thousands
Don't forget the scene where that guy touches the ground, tastes it, and says it's salt just to let everyone know that it's salt.
It not Hoth guys, its not Hoth. Anyways, on Hoth...
That was _so weird._ I did wonder what the hell the director was thinking.
@@FunZies. I mean many people accused EP7 for plagiarism, so as Ruin recreated the iconic Hoth scene of EP5, he wanted to make clear, that it is different. But he did not put work into it, so this is the result.
I mean it doesn’t even make sense I am assuming he meant this planet was a giant salt flat but needless to say salt flats are the same as table salt and I don’t advise you Try to taste salt from one
@@mala6238 Even the bit where the rebel has the binocular device and sees the walkers and the camera pans from the legs to the upper bodies, and then outward revealing the whole fleet. That was ripped off in Last Jedi.
I used to work in a restaurant than I started bringing people the wrong orders and tell them I subverted their expectations and than I got fired
I didn't know all our customers were racist
under rated comment
hahaha top tier comment my guy
Best!
Manbabies! All of them!
They are just mad that they had their expectations subverted.
Whatever you feel about this film the "milk" scene was truly, viscerally the most revoltingly unnecessary thing ever committed to digital card.
Ruin Johnson kept that in the film, but he couldn't put in that deleted scene of Luke mourning Han?
@@Doomlovesearth2 it was too subtle and part of the legacy of the original films.... Ruin only understands vulgar and meaningless.
@@sarahjaneheckscher6737 Indeed. Ruin Johnson is a hack writer. His actions against Luke Skywalker cannot be forgiven.
Straight from the teat 😅
@@patrickmcglonejr8163 that was truly ducked up!
Robot Head could make 200 more videos criticizing this film and I would watch every single one.
So would I, this film deserves all of it.
Unless he makes a video that actually acknowledges the good parts, I'm not interested.
His hatred for this movie's practically blinded him.
@@edgarjacksby1402 Correct. He's just beating around the bush at this point.
I'd rather that than actually watch these piece-of-shit films, any day.
@@icemaster9728 He should, at the very least watch his "Breaking Down A Scene" video on Knives Out.
Or any of his other work, for that matter.
Remember this is the director that refused for us to see how Luke would react to Han's death. It is a sad day when a stranger had a more emotional act to an original's death than his best friend.
Or his in-law in Luke's case. Also not to mention his real best friend and his wife.
A Luke scene where he's doing whatever and is hit with the feeling of Han's death through the force would have been such a nice touch. I should stop reading these comments because I'm only gonna keep getting more disappointed.
That wasn't only a Rian Johnson thing. JJ also didn't understand the friendship of the OT's main characters. Remember, after Han's death in The Force Awakens, Leia walked right past Chewie to hug Rey. That's what happens when you get writers and directors who don't understand the characters.
@@G360LIVE, at least JJ did have the humility to admit that that was a mistake.... unlike a certain other director.
@@verindictus3639
JJ made other huge mistakes, too, such as not bringing Harrison, Mark, and Carrie back together on-screen and talking about the importance of having a prominent black character then making him a clown. So, admitting one mistake doesn't excuse JJ's bad decisions or lead me to think that he's better than Rian Johnson. Those two should both stay far away from Star Wars. Heck, Rian only ruined one franchise (Star Wars), JJ ruined two (Star Trek and Star Wars) and is on his way to really screwing up the DCEU now by hiring an American-hating writer for the American character Superman.
I feel like we shouldn't HAVE to explain why the guy who ruined Star Wars needs to stay away from Star Wars, but sadly, some people are a little too slow on the uptake...
Kathleen Kennedy ruïned star wars. Johnson helped her with that.
They both clearly know nothing about star wars and are just trying to push their own agenda with this franchise. George may not be the best director but he did understand star wars since he litterly invented it. The biggest mistake the fans made was making George believe he wasn't good enough for his own creation therefore pushing him to sell it to Disney. Dave Filoni and Jon Favreau are in my opinion Star Wars last hope. Because without them Star Wars wouldn't be Star Wars anymore. But that's all my opinion ofcourse
people are idiots
Now, now, let’s not absolve Bob Iger in his share of the blame here. Or Alan Horn
@@Arander92 yes I forgot his exitence. Atleast he allowed dave Filoni to make some actual good star wars content.
It’s selfish to avoid a director a lot of Star Wars fans liked to stay away from Star Wars. If he wants to do an episode of Mandalorian, and you don’t want to watch it, fine, no one will force you. The fact is, as a film director, Rian Johnson has a lot of fan. He directed to great movies, like Looper and Knives Out, and two great episodes of Breaking Bad. He just released a movie you didn’t like, this doesn’t mean he has to stay away from Star Wars. The fans who liked his film deserve to get an episode of The Mandalorian directed by him. You don’t. Then don’t watch it and let us have our time of pleasure.
I remember leaving the cinema after TLJ. Me and my dad had seen it together, and whilst on the bus, we were silent. We were thinking about the crap we had just watched. Then, he looked at me and said, "It wasn't very good was it." I said, "Yeah."
My experience was nearly the same, but with my Brother. I had even gone back alone(and sober), to see if I really saw, what I saw.
Those movies piss me off more than they made me happy that's not supposed to happen Ryan Johnson sucks ass
"Just have Chewie sit there"
Yeah that is all Rian told Chewie the whole film!
That and fuck around with porgs
At least the actor could roll his eyes, yawn, mouth insults and relax.
Rain: I think we just made a Star Wars movie!
Fans: *Unfortunately for you, history will not see it that way*
"Rain" lol
@@MyUsersDark it’s edited as well
You mean man babies haters, not fans.
No, he's right. He did make a Star Wars movie. Just like the Holiday Special is also a Star Wars movie.
Fans: No, Rian, you taking a dump on Hollywood Blvd. is not a Star Wars movie.
Mark Hamill while filming the milking scene: At least I'm getting $3 million for this nonsense.
I know this is old but DAMN that's not much.
The milking scene was supposed to show how Luke survived the island, and it displayed him as a hermit. Anyways, the scene is less than a minute and has no effect on the plot, so I don't see what the big deal is.
@@justoons2949 What if we saw Luke taking a quick shit? Your sentence would still apply....
@@justoons2949 The scene also shows how far his character has fallen as a living legend/hero which is a HUGE plot point in the last jedi (THE DUDE IS LITERALLY THE LAST JEDI). people don't like that, which surely you acknowledge as being at least a little fair. plus with the way it's framed and acted it just plain looks goofy. idk what else to tell ya.
@@gmonkman A scene where Luke is taking a shit would be far more childish, nasty, and bizarre than the green alien milk scene.
For some reason, I'm reminded of a story Kevin Smith tells on one of his stage shows, about directing Bruce Willis in something, and Bruce asks Kevin what lens he's using for the shot, and Kevin says something like, "A close up..." and Bruce repeats, "What lens are you using for the shot?" Kevin turns and asks the camera guy, and then gives Bruce the answer. Bruce responds, "And why don't you know that?"
The expression on Mark Hamill’s face when he says “Cut” is worth a thousand words.
Yeah.. what's the emotion called the that is embarrassment, pain, and sadness? I am sure that is what he felt
@@sunofpeter2 Embarrassment, pain, and sadness combined? I believe that's what we in the business refer to as "cringe."
@@KingKayro87 I believe lam looking for a different word, let you know if I find it.
I feel bad for all the actors, especially john boyega. He seems so talented
Disney was all too eager to emasculate the charismatic black guy.
Rian: "Wait, you want Finn, the black man, to be a jedi and a hero, not some dumb comic relief?!
Hahaha haha hehe he hohooho ha! No."
They did him dirty and used him like a Jim Crow era comic relief
Where is he talented? Where is he charismatic? Didn't notice it.
Blame it on JJ Abrams who completely wasted him in The Rise of Skywalker. In The Last Jedi at least he had a character arc.
I was so happy to see that robot posted then..... I saw the title
You make some excellent points here. Most people aren't aware of what 'direction' or 'cinematography' actually mean. They think if there's a pretty image in a movie, that's good cinematography. It's actually defined as the art of telling a story using camera and lighting. This means camera placement/movement/focus/framing, use of suitable color and light, etc. in order to make not a picture, but cinema - moving images that convey a sense of what's going on, both atmospherically and narratively. In other words, to tell a story.
What those people are admiring is the set/costume/prop design, mostly.
Any director that says "I stand by EVERY choice" after they make a film is either a fool or lying.
Even Scorsese constantly questions whether he made the right choices or not. Rian is no Scorsese.
For one, Scorsese is a 78 year old man and Rian is 3 toddlers in a suit.
George Lucas about TPM : « It was designed to be that way and you can’t undo that ».
Are you saying Lucas is a fool ?
@@GameOver-vh7py well he kinda is, prequels just prove that he couldnt really direct a movie and wrtite a script on his own without a shit load of people fixing it, like in the OT. He was a guy with vision and great ideas, but he needed all those great actors and directors to make Star Wars work. Prequels only prove that to be right
Or maybe he knows that bashing a movie he made with a studio he is still planning on working with isn't very professional.
Even George Lucas stated that he w8nt to far in some ways with the Prequels. Not that I dislike them, I love them, but can understand why many don't
@@thanos_6.0 but that’s even worse : he recognized that he messed up but he didn’t change anything, because the next day he says : « It was designed to be that way and you can’t undo that. »
I never realized that Finn has a grossed-out look on his face when Rose kisses him.
I wonder if Rian put that in deliberately or Finn had no idea about it during the set.
Well it would be assault if it was reserved so it makes sense.
It is volunteer to show that Finn doesn’t understand why Rose kisses him and that it isn’t a dumb romance like everyone thought. But you will just ignore this detail only to complain about this very rigorous and precise directing style.
@@monsieurgentil2989 damn, im glad atleast 1 person enjoyed this movie
@@monsieurgentil2989 hello Rian Johnson
I sense a dark presences in the force
I hope it's not me this time.
I presence I've not felt since . . . 2017 . . .
no it's rian who took another dump
It’s Robothead.
It's Rian Johnson.
I almost walked out of the theater when Rose pulled a “gotcha” moment by crashing her pointless ski speeder into Finn. Instead I remained seated to witness the dumbest scene in all of Star Wars.
There are only two logical ways this scene should have ended.
1. Finn and Rose both die in the crash when she crashed her speeder into his.
2. The First Order soldiers - who were just getting orders to kill everyone a.k.a no prisoners - take one minute to open a lock on the battle-walkers and have a couple Stormtroopers shoot Rose and Finn, who are lying dazed and defenseless right next to them.
And even if for some absurd reason they survive and the First Order just ignores them, they would STILL be dead, because they were good four or five KILOMETERS away from their base and Finn had to dragg a injured person behind him, through a SALT FIELD.
By the time he managed to return the battle should be long over, with them being left behind on Krayt to be hunted down and killed by their enemies.
*Almost*
One of the dumbest moments in movies.
I’m a simple guy I see robot head making fun of last Jedi I click.
same
pure comedic gold
it is low-hanging fruit.
I want him to belittle something like The Birds or Citizen Cane.
G.O. you fucked up that, bzzzz zzzz, beep .
The only flaw in Citizen Kane is in the plot...a journalist tries to find out the meaning of Kane's last word, "Rosebud", but we're clearly shown Kane is alone when he died so how could anyone know his last word?
@@lucasoheyze4597 Cane. I'm a dolt.
Ruin Johnson: I won't have my directing ability questioned by a robot!
Robothead : I'm not questioning your directing ability, Ruin Johnson. I'm denying its existence.
For some reason, I heard this in HK-47's voice
Only a sith deals in absolutes.
Wrong franchise.... tyrion lannistar isn't in this.
Yeah, the guy who directed Knives out and Ozymandias from Breaking Bad obviously can’t direct.
Tyrion Lanister would be proud..👏👏👏
Interesting detail: Star Wars 1-6 were filmed like documentaries. Camera almost never moves and the characters are in the centre of the frame.
According to George, the story was being told by R2-D2 to species in the far future.
SW 1-3 filming is really bad.
Just characters walking from place A to place B and a series of shots/countershots.
@@Arkanthrall It is called less is more. too many closeups and crap like that really make a movie hard to follow I know from experience.
@@emberfist8347 This doesn't excuse Lucas for being lazy.
@@Arkanthrall Director's job isn't just camera work. Lucas was kinda busy crearing the story, characters and designs.
Rian: "I think we just made a Star Wars movie"
Umm, no, you made a crappy fanfic horror movie.
Rian, I think you're gay (and not in the good way).
*Disney giving him an entire Triology*:
*Angry Robot head noises intensify*
😐
At the same time, think of all the content we'd get from RH lol
Where did you get that super gay looking avatar face, it's almost as gay as my real face.
@@JeffreyAllanBackowski it’s an Apple Animoji btw. chill your Life
@@JeffreyAllanBackowski why do you offend people on the internet? Nothing better to do ???
I’ve been watching Star Wars my whole life and I will never ever forget how angry and embarrassed I was for being a Star Wars fan after watching each other the sequel movies.
"And who has a better story than Rian Johnson?"
"EVERYONE!"
I can totally picture that last part as shouted by Gary Oldman's character in Leon: The Professional.
Impressive, everything you just said was wrong.
William Seabrook Indeed, no one is a perfect writer.
Yeah. "You have 1 minute to make up a fanstory for Star Wars set 30 years in the future from Return of the Jedi." I bet 90% of what anyone wanting complete the task would come up with, would be better than the Disney films, yet they shoot this....and The rise of Palpatine and TFA.
Write 100 plots, run them through 100 fans and see what floats on paper and shoot one of the best ones, not the worst ones. And use a good director, you can afford it. How could a studio fail such simple tasks?
Disney should sell the rights to Star Wars.
Then fucking write one.
When I finally watched this movie, I was amazed at how bad it looked. I couldn't put my finger on it, but it was just bad. It looked almost cartoonish or something. You explained it really well.
Same here. I really disliked the looks and cut of many scenes. Now I understand that the choices and hence the material was crap when entering the cutting room.
I think the writing was mediocre and then they went into filming, totally overwhelmed by all the stuff they had to manage. Many of the stupid mistakes and bad choices just seem very rushed. No time to do it better?
Knowing the american approach to health and job performance, i guess Rian was just drugged away. to not feel his anxiety for the ongoing fuckup. A present director should have taken corrective action at some point. Take another year to work out the movie before you bury a feckin' franchise...
Well today just got better! I see Robot Head, I click.
Facts.
Truth
What a generic comment, i see x i click and today is better because of a youtube video, so unoriginal
@@ozy667 I hate generic comments lmao
NPC moment. You're no better than Rian shills.
A Robothead taking a dump on Roundhead Johnson video?!
Never clicked so fast in my life.
None of us have
A Robot-butthead indeed
@@monsieurgentil2989 why are you here child? lol
Always nice to see someone tearing into The Last Jedi.
It’s laughable to see how many people don’t even know how to write « Rian Johnson » properly ! Good to know that Last Jedi haters never learnt to write.
I love that there is so much disgust and scorn for Rian Johnson's handling of Star Wars. He deserves it. Terrible story and direction.
Your reading my mind
Oh yes. The way he handled Luke Skywalker was just terrible.
The moment Disney decided to not go with Lucas' plans for eps 7, 8 and 9, it was all over. What does the creator of Star Wars know about Star Wars anyway? Such arrogance from Mickey.
I wouldn't worry tbh, in 40 years the CGI will wither away and then the story will have to stand on its own. When that happens people will realize that it's shit, it's a very bad story.
He does deserve to be called out for handling the story terribly. But he and everyone else who worked on the film do not deserve to be harassed or threatened over it.
I think my friend said it best when he said “he can’t even spell his own name right never mind a Star Wars movie”
That throne room fight scene will not be forgotten on how terrible it is
I still don't want to who the hell designed those costumes you can't see out of them.
Rey is flat footed and keeps her weight on her heels.
Before the knife disappeared, the vanishing knife is seen travelling the path over Rey's lower torso... That's a disembowelling shot right there and even with cauterisation the floor should have been a slip and slide of Rey's entrails if that guy was serious about killing Rey.
It’s treason then.
Not as terrible as the fights in the prequels where every choreography is forced and we don’t feel the danger.
"Why rian johnson should stay away from star wars" *puts up a picture of episode 8*
'Nuff said!
Indeed!
"Why we should give Rian another chance"
puts up a picture of everything else he's done
It is absolutely criminal that after 40 years of excellence, it took spectacle (Bladerunner 2049) and a gimmick (1917) for the Academy to recognize Roger Deakins’s work.
Barton Fink, Thunderheart, 1984, True Grit, Fargo, Sicario, O Brother, Shawshank, Rango - every last one of them looked, felt, and did something very different and very interesting.
I forgot Deakins was involved with Fargo production; the entirety of that movie is etched into my mind.
In that scene with Rey practicing with the lightsabre on the rock there's an above shot but with no reflection of the light from the sabre off its wet surface. That part stuck out like dogs balls to me but no one else seemed to notice it.
Finally a good take on Rian as a bad director and poor cinematography of The Last Jedi. Way too much talk is spent on the writing and themes which tricks people into thinking the other aspects are not as bad. They are. Thanks, Robot Head.
That one scene in Star Wars unleashed where Vader orders the troopers to execute starkiller was more badass then the sequel trilogy combined
The last act of Revenge is better too
_Now _*_this_*_ is pod racing!_ is more badass than the Sequels.
Yo, actually the Imperial offcier ordered the execution. Vader was the one who saved him. What fucking game have you played, my dude?
I just noticed when Rey stabs one of the guards at 11:55 the guy she stabs is behind another guard. This vital info is hidden from us because they failed at blocking the scene, well on top of everything else wrong with this fight scene.
I am literally forbidden from watching Robot Head in my own bed at night when my wife is laying next to me.. because I laugh so much that even when i am trying to not make a sound I shake the bed so much she freaks the fuck out.
And that is the best way I can think of to say how great this channel is!! Especially when he's kicking Rian Johnson over and over in a dark alley in the early morning light.
Fan-Fucking-Tastic!!!
What if we just did an entire episode of mandalorian as a close up shot of mandos helmet....... so much emotional rang!!!!!
I'll just put this out there: I recently watched _Knives Out,_ which was written and directed by Johnson, and it was a very capably told and directed movie. It's hard to imagine that the same person who made this movie is the same person who put together the mess that was _Last Jedi._
That's what I don't understand, because Knives Out genuinely a good film imo, but how the fuck did the same director do such a bad job on The Last Jedi
@@ewanmcloughlin6875 It is a mystery.
@@ewanmcloughlin6875 Passion. He did not care about TLJ .
@@matthewdunk No he did not.
@@ariochiv Not mystery. He purposely made shitty divisive movie.
Rian Johnson is an amazing director: i'm amazed he still has a career in the film industry; i'm amazed that he actually gets paid for the shit he makes and i'm over come with amazement that he thinks he is good enough to direct an episode of the Mandalorian, because i don't think he could direct traffic in a parking lot!
One word ozymandias
@@CalIunn does Fly count too?
"You've heard of the close-up, but have you tried a _closer_ up?"
-Rian Johnson talking about his ExPeRTiSe
If they ever let him back, my last bit of hope for star wars will gone forever im sad
Missed opportunity to make a last hope refference.
Watch some of his other work, you'll be pleasantly surprised.
@@edgarjacksby1402 it doesnt change the fact that tlj was trash because of him and his poor directing. His other movies may be decent or good, but we are talking specifically about SW here
What I've learned from all this is that the best films have creative teams with a lot of checks and balances. No one person should have full, uncontested creative authority.
I had hoped history would have teached this lesson in many other contexts, never ends well.
Exactly. Apparently WB didn’t learn that when they let Patty Jenkins have full control of Wonder Woman 84
did they not learn from the prequel trilogy
Prequels are still better
@@ben3129 Oh no, they didn't learn from TFA. The prequels had good ideas that had poor execution.
I can rewatch episodes 1-6 no problem at all. Granted they’re far from perfect and many parts throughout I don’t like, but overall I can sit through each episode and enjoy myself.
I have tried a few times, and there is absolutely NO doubt that I CANNOT ever sit through another watching of episode 7,8 or 9. I get maybe 30-45min into each episode and I just can’t take it anymore. The setting, the characters, the acting, the plot, the overall tone and feel of these movies is just tasteless, uninteresting, boring, and just BAD!!!
Say about the prequels what you want, but they had an original story that contributed to the bigger Story, didn't disrespect legacy characters in disgusting way and the main character wasn't a Mary Sue.
I mean it's so ironic. I bet all my money that when Disney bought Star Wars and first discussed the future ST, one main topic at the start was "how do we avoid such a backlash like during the prequels" (I personally always loved the prequels). And here we 3 Films later, with a backlash 10 times huger then during the prequels and hardcore prequel haters stating that this dumpster fire, Disney calls a triology, is worse then the prequels.
Ironic
It’s subjective. Just a matter of taste.
@@thanos_6.0 I'll take the prequels over the sequels any day.
Agree. The ROS is even worse, it took me three tries to actually watch it to completion (my wife got it as a present on DVD): I'd just fall asleep at about 1/3 in.
@@thanos_6.0 And all their current projects revolve around prequels, and nothing from their own sequels LMAO
10:46
Wait, did the rock change shape in between shots? Great f*cking job Rian.
Lmfao
It's amazing how every time you re-watch TLJ, you discover more and more problems with it.
It's definitely a whole different rock entirely.
Well, I guess every movie where a slight mistake in continuity is terrible now.
God, you people are so damn petty
Robot Head: "Rian do you really understand camera angles, direction of actors, and general ideas of people's standards of a future classic movie?"
Rian Johnson: "I'm about to classically subvert Robot Head's expectations!"
The Last Jedi is amazing and you are all insane.
@@monsieurgentil2989 there's things called opinions, back off..
@@monsieurgentil2989 No, were all just real star wars fans while you’re a faux fan.
*Rian tries to get into the Studio*
Jon Favreu: „We just gotta load up Tony's old Hulkbuster armor, a prototype for Cap's new shield and the Meg..me..megin... Thor's magic belt.“
1:01
This is one of my most least favorite scenes out of the entire sequel trilogy. It SCREAMS *Disney was here!*
Have you seen Star Wars Theory's Video showing an old Interview of George Lucas? He there shares his plans for the sequels that he had in mind before selling to Disney. Would love to hear your opinion on that 👌🏻
Kathleen: Rian writes "amazingly fierce & independent women"...
Us: Only if your "definition" means forcing female characters down our throat with bad writing doing all the shoving.
True man we all love Ahsoka, Padme and Leia wich are characters I consider strong and independent. But these characters werent shoved down our throat.
@@draymondshouldntwear2333 my point exactly👌. You just described good writing vs. incompetence. Leia>Holdo.
I love Roger Deakins point about cinematography. Everyone orgasms all over Twitter about how pretty the last Jedi is. But that’s not actually cinematography. Just because it looks nice doesn’t excuse poor direction.
Thank you for this. You are doing the Force's work.
Rian wants to be remembered?
Allright, we'll make his Legacy a legacy of failure, just like he did to Luke.
Yup, and it will be, in 40 years the cgi will look like shit, because at the end of the day it's the story that's timeless.
@@drhypno6317 i agree. For example the cgi in the OT was really good for its time but you cant say it holds up anymore. But the fans remember it for its story and characters not for its fights (altho i still liked the space battles in ROTJ)
@@drhypno6317 ya but most stuff he directs has zero cgi and great stories so he’s gonna be remembered pretty well
David Fincher once said “There are a hundred ways to shoot a scene but when it comes down to it there are only 2 and one of them is wrong” for Rian the only 2 options are dolly in or out. 🤡
Alfred Hitchcock once said "There are a hundred ways to shoot a scene, and none of them involve milking weird alien manatee tiddies."
Or once again not having the lead character do anything
Disney lost $ BILLIONS by mistreating and killing off Luke Skywalker
Hard to believe Disney approved of that.
@@adelanicole7517 Rian Johnson and Kathleen Kennedy do not understand real Star Wars
There is nothing good about the way Luke was handled in TLJ.
@@adelanicole7517 THEY KILLED OFF HAN SOLO!?!?
@@ricobarth In a really shitty way as well.
The intro is hilarious 😂
His directing worked great for movies like knives out. Constant twists and turns, no real plot to follow, it’s just a movie on its own. But when there’s an already established series with a way of storytelling and we have 6/7 movies to see how characters act and react to situations, he’s an awful option.
Knives out was very entertaining yet very fking predictable. From the first 10 min I already predicted it was chris Evans. Because I know rian is a gotcha type of guy . Knives out had A HUGE STAR STUD CAST . I imagined the film without the HUGE names like.... CHRIS EVANS ... aka CAPTAIN AMERICA. Daniel Craig aka JAMES BOND 007 . And I imagined the film to be very boring........ yawn
@@valenwood6299 the surprise was not who is the killer but how did he kill. And if you guessed how and to what extent he was guilty, congratulations because this wasn't possible to predict.
@@filmdebating4915 wtf are you even talking about !?!?!?!?!
@@filmdebating4915 its a fking murder mansion mystery. Fking family guy did a better job than rian Johnson. It's fking done before and always works because everyone loves a mansion murder mystery right ?
@@valenwood6299 did you guess how Ransom murdered Harlan ? No. This was the big surprise. Like Benoit Blanc said : a donut hole. Everything else lined up with what Benoit Blanc thought, except this donut hole. This is genius writing like we don't see very often. It was very refreshing to have such a clever murder mystery with a very unique tone which switches cinema genres in a very surprising way. I wish Rien Johnson was hired for more films, that man is a genius director and writer and anyone who say the contrary is a liar.
“Why fire should stay away from gasoline”
This has the be the best dunk on Roundhead Johnson on the internet
Can't help hearing "Yakkity Sax" in my head watching Rian's SW.
"The kid swinging the broomstick in the backyard" literally made me cry laughing. It's so true.
Just the therapy I needed!!!
Very comprehensive and excellent work RH. Can't wait for your first tranche of pulp romance. Some suggested titles - _Rise of the Reylo Prince_ , _Fifty Shades of Ruin_ and _That's not a Moon Baby!_
Close ups are good at highlighting something important or fostering a claustrophobic feeling in the audience. Using them too much to say "this is important" only makes the audience feel that either nothing is important, everything is small, or both. The movie comes off as tiny in this epic setting. Everything in the movie feels like it's inconsequential. Sure, you can tell an inconsequential story in this setting, but there are payoffs in the film that should be huge and somehow feel like nothing at all. Luke dies in this film and it comes off like a wet fart because by that time the audience realizes that none of it matters.
Which is exactly what happens when you put a nihilist in charge of a film like this.
One lesson that can be learned from this movie, ironically, is the power of subtlety.
Rian: I think we just made a Star Wars movie!
Fans: Everything of what you just said was wrong
I’m a fan and I consider his movie as a Star Wars movie. Thus YOU are wrong.
Indeed.
@@monsieurgentil2989 opinions. look up the definition and buzz off
Thank you Robot Head. I am so sick of fans defending the direction of this film.
I knew that this episode would come out sooner or later, and you did not disappoint
11:32 the sword techniques are honestly abismal, with such dramatic movements and succh a wide stance she's waiting for someone with a polearm or even just fists to knock her over.
The fact that we had to watch Luke milk an alien is a crime in itself
The Last Jedi is a clear example of why Rian Johnson should stay away from Star Wars. FOREVER.
"I hate you with the dark fire of a million exploding neutron stars"
Jack "Critical Drinker" Taylor, to The Last Jedi
I remember enjoying TFA for the most part. I was looking forward to TLJ, but the trailers left a weird feeling in the back of my mind. I went in to see it with an open mind, had my 10 year old daughter with me. When Luke tossed the lightsaber over his shoulder I knew this was going to be bad. I hung in there giving the movie the benefit of the doubt until the Leia flying through space scene. My whole body literally cringed, catching my daughters attention, and I tried to show her that I was enjoying the movie but it was too late. Even she felt it at 10 years old, it was just bad bad bad. That Leia scene flying through space still makes me cringe to this day when I think about it.
Oh bloody hell no. I don’t want him to do that! He’s gonna kill it again!
This man takes all my feeling about the sequel movies and puts it perfectly into amazing videos.
I couldn't agree more Mr Astronagol... it is just so easy to get extra angry when driving, maybe because there is no room for error in a big box made of metal and metal. The Incredible Hulk brings into play a couple details from the comics, and of course, the abomination character, or if you wanna go by my nickname for him, "the spiky hulk".
@@MrWinstonABailey um what???
It’s treason then.
Yeah, the sequel movies suck don't they?
Doomlovesearth2 well, Rise Of Skywalker sucks and wastes the potential of the sequels.
I always think of “blocking” as only considering the outer silhouette of each charter in the shot. Basically not looking at the inner detail, but just the cut and profile of the character. If you think of Rian’s cinematographer in that light, taking every character as a silhouette, everything would look like a big bunch, with actors and robots all crowded together as a big mess.
I’m not saying you can’t consider the inner detail of a character or object, it’s just while “blocking” this is all I consider when filming.
I will never forget when I was waiting in line to watch TLJ I saw the first crowd departing the theater and it looked like they were leaving a funeral. In a way it was. All those faces showed shock, bewilderment, and resigned. Those of us who were waiting were eager, laughing, and ready with anticipation. When I left the theater afterwards I was fking numb and so was the whole group I went with.
Haven't seen TROS yet, and not going to bother with it.
Rian reminds me of an actual bobble head that's come to life.
His head subverts my expectations when looking at it.
Never seen Adam Schiff before have you?
@@theunknowncommenter725 hahaha unfortunately. Add him to the list!
George Clooney is more of a human bobble head than rian Johnson.
Just keep him away from Star Wars.
Atleast I die knowing I walked out of the cinema with this movie... during the casino scenes.
Glad to meet you! I walked on the “milking” scene. I just couldn’t take any more after that.
I watched it at home with my father invited around who did nothing but tut and look bewildered the entire movie, ending with him saying "what a load of fucking rubbish". Sadly I didn't have the choice to walk out.
I left as the movie cuts away as Luke should be mourn for Han's death.
I watched the whole thing, but I went out for a loo break during the mary poppins scene, laughing my head off, and sharing baffled 'wtf' looks with the rest of the audience. The 'your mum' scene was the point of lost hope
@@flowinsounds My point of lost hope was when Luke confirmed that he did try to kill Kylo in his sleep. I pretty much tuned out of the movie at the point.
Boredom is subjective. You found this movie boring, this is your opinion, it doesn’t mean everyone will find the movie boring.
The throne room fight scene has absolutely no force powers whatsoever despite having TWO force users present, but hey, Kylo randomly stabs the ground for no reason (11:56) and features a vanishing weapon (14:39), so it's a goddamn masterpiece.
The first time I saw those guards in the throne room, and how they brandished their weapons and bust into "cool" poses when someone (I can't remember who) shouted at Snoke, I knew that any action we'd get from them would be trash. That one moment immediately undermines them. They're about as intimidating as that kid in high school who thought he could fight because he watched a lot of kung fu movies.
It's nonsense. It's stuff like this that both distracts and detracts from the experience. (Incidentally, Gus Johnson does a video about this sort of thing, how everyone always cocks their gun when they "mean business," when, if they actually knew how to use it, there'd already be a round/shell in the chamber.) Point is, a real badass doesn't posture or pose. They don't need to; their power is in their presence. These walking lobsters scream of incompetence. They aren't even in range to engage. What's the point of taking a ready stance twenty feet away from the person you're guarding? The whole thing is just puerile and inept, and it was done at Johnson's direction.
Contrast this with the Imperial guards we see in Return of the Jedi. They literally just. stand. there, and they still look more intimidating than anything else in the OT, save Vader, himself. Would you mess with them?
as a very incompetent person, this gives me hope i can get a really high paying job that im way under qualified for
Knives out is a fantastic film, Rian's work on the Breaking Bad episodes he directed is awesome. Let him do stuff he's good at, keep him away from any star wars project though.
Let the man direct a Star War.
If he's not writing it, will you watch it maybe?
@@edgarjacksby1402 that would certainly be an improvement
@@finleypetit5197 As long as Rian Johnson doesn't touch the script, I would be willing to allow him to direct.
@@edgarjacksby1402 no, he doesn’t need to be involved
Oh that’s why the closeups made the whole movie feel like everything was cramped and small. It wasn’t a movie set in a GALAXY far far away, we were instead subjected to all these closeups that made the movie feel like a small room far far away lol
This is the first Star Wars movie I refused to watch. I heard from fans it was an atrocity and just couldn't subject myself to it. They were right! Great video Robot Head.
I pirate it. And i m feeling that Disney owns me a money.
So you can’t form your own opinion and rely on you tubers to do so for you? Lol
@@guyred2083 you see where he said they were right? That implies he eventually saw it for himself. Reading comprehension bud lol
You made the right choice. TLJ is fucking garbage.
Man, you just gave me a WHOLE BUNCH of new reasons to hate TLJ. You're doing god's work.
It’s treason then.
@@monsieurgentil2989 its common sense lol
There's a difference between "new reasons" and just nitpicks.
This video highlighted at least two new problems with TLJ that I haven't otherwise noticed.
Get a hobby, my word.
I remember leaving the theater thinking. Well that's definitely a movie.
I still feel dumb because I brought my sister and brother to see last Jedi for their first Star Wars experience ( it still haunts me to this day)
I was playing the vid in the background while doing some paperwork and I swear I thought it was a girl speaking in the beginning of the video, but it was apparently Roundhead Rian XD
My take on the bombing run, George uses WWII dog fight footage to model the X-Wing battles, Ruin ... WWII bombing run it is (but with malice not homage).
Speaking as a pre digital era photographer, 100% with you on the sunset pics.
Disney needs to reign in Lucas Film if they ever hope to salvage anything about Star Wars. Part of that is making sure this man can't touch it ever again.
Rian Johnson should never be allowed to even unfold a director’s chair.
Watch Knives Out then we’ll talk.
@@monsieurgentil2989 watch the Last jedi than we wont need to talk
@@ArdaSReal Knives Out came out after TLJ and was pretty good, whether you liked TLJ or not.
The fact is Rian Johnson is a good director who can make great movies.
@@monsieurgentil2989 i guess, but i dont Like his personality and his directing in this öne was horrible
@@ArdaSReal 😂😂😂 Keep telling that to yourself 😂😂😂
Have a nice day man.
Drinking game idea: every time the word “close-up” is uttered, take a shot. It’s super fun, and you totally won’t di-
Wow, you even managed to type in a hyphen before you keeled over?
After seeing the Last Jedi, I got a job at a movie theater and I would send patrons to the wrong theater to subvert their expectations. I figured if half the people I sent into the wrong theater liked the movie I chose for them, and the other half hated it, it showed how great I am and recommending movies.
Perfect 👍
You are confusing art and industry.
Now that I think of it, had Mark Hamill held out, that could have FORCED it to be a better movie.
Had Mark Hamill held out they would have wrote him out. Disney doesn't give a shit.
Yeah, most likely.
So at 5:18, he forgot the first rule of shooting a scene. The rule of thirds. ANYTHING in the center of the shot is treated as insignificant to the viewer subconsciously. The space that people view the screen has meaning. Riding off into the sunset is always shot the same for a hero triumphant for a reason. Framing the scene correctly captures the movement and helps write the story. That is the job.