Dr. Moynihan ~ you must realize that the myth of the "great society" has not lifted the masses out of poverty ~ instead it's made more people more poor. It's not that Conservatives lack charity. Clearly, the US gives a lot. It's that individualism matters too ~ we face the Judge on our own ~ individually.
Refreshing to hear a cleric say what many of us our feeling, that the Church needs to stand up and say that what is going on, in many respects, is WRONG. Period. I think Archbishop Vigano is spot on about what he says. Great video, thank you.
Thank you and I think Vigano is right on....for they are always ridiculed before God strikes. Discredited and persecuted. Those who have the courage to speak up....Remember the flood.
Seems like Vigano and Father Murr have a good understanding of the Holy Spirit and the gifts of knowledge, understanding, fortitude and wisdom. There IS a unity involved.
"He's seeing a lot of different parts of the same whole." You nailed it, Father. Vigano nailed it. And he is a huge part of why I took an interest in Catholicism, and why I'm a new convert. God bless, y'all. #RedPill
I just love learning the back stories of how the church was ruptured. You guys are so enlightening. Thank you for championing the real good guys. I can see how Our Lord sends us quiet saints to keep us afloat while the ship rides a tidal wave of evil. You give us hope. ❤️🙏
After taking the Ignatian Exercises, I think listening to your stories is proof positive of how God is manager extraordinaire of his church. Although at times things seem hopeless, He is there for us saying “be still and know that I am God.” Pray & fast always..sometimes use words.❤️🙏
A really great conversation and thank you both. I, too, find myself in agreement with you both. Unity is critical, and as Catholics we are first and foremost united in Christ, by living our personal lives united in Christ and by grace, Christ in us. I say then we continue to pray for Pope Francis and trust in God's providence. Until there is a change, until we have a great Holy Father (as Our Lady has promised and stated so well by Fr. Murr), the unfortunate reality is the sheep are already scattered. Find comfort and trust in what we know for certain- Christ- and the traditional Latin mass of our fathers, and their fathers before them and all the saints. This is reality.
Robert Moynihan has been around the Vatican for decades, involved with the publication, Variety Ivanovo, so he’s so knowledgeable. I appreciate that he introduced us to Abso. Vigano with his book, Finding Vigano. How wonderful that it was Vigano who finally outed the evil Theodore McCarrick who’d abused likely thousands of young men, particularly young seminarians. What psychological damage this monster imposed on so many innocent well intentioned holy young men. James Hroen differed PYSD for all that McCarrick put him through. He is the root of the spread of priestly sexual abuse. The pope first sent McCarrich to give the Church in China to the Communists. Moynihan is a great problem solvers, knows so many people and so much about what ails the Church at the Vatican...
Thank you immensely Dr. Moynihan for that awesome Quotation by St. Vincent of Lerins. I will try to find it on his book "The Commonitory of St. Vincent of Lerins" My God bless all your exemplary works for our King Of Kings Jesus Christ.
Dr. Moynihan, I finally got the content of your quote "In dubious questions Freedom; in certain questions, Unity; but in all questions Charity......beautiful! But not by St. Vincent of Lerins. Nevertheless, I immensely thank you as in searching this quotation, I read the whole extraordinary book, (only 129 pages)The Commonitory of St. Vincent of Lerins. The last chapters very adapted to today's Catholic Church, dough written over 1000 yeas ago. Almighty God bless abundantly you Dr. Moynihan and jovial Fr. Murr.
Dr. Moynihan, I made an egregious error this morning during the Live Chat, attributing a quote of Archbishop Vigano to his Homily from the Feast of the Ascension. As you know, the quote was the Archbishop's, however, it was from the interview with Arkady Mamontov - not his homily. In keeping with the 200 character limit in the Live Chat, I deleted a sentence and failed to edit my edit.
May I humbly suggest that next time you have communication glitches and air time to fill, the prayer to Saint-Michael and a Hail Mary to banish the gremlins. 🙏🏻
Robert, we all want unity, but don't unite around deserting The One Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church. Hold onto the traditions passed on. Follow the Council of Trent. Pope Bergogulio is doing the smashing as did Vatican II. Restore tradition. It's the only way. Our Lady of Fatima, pray for us. 🙏
"IN ESSENTIALS UNITY, IN NON-ESSENTIALS LIBERTY, IN ALL THINGS CHARITY. On the Origin of the Sentence: "In necessariis unitas, in non-necessariis (or, dubiis) libertas, in utrisque (or, omnibus) caritas."
@@StarVoyagerMan I disagree as it doesn't make sense. "I think this is fine up until a certain point. And this is where, I think, Vigano impacted me an awful lot, which is true."
We are at the stage when because of the volume of the greatest sins ALMOST TOTAL power has been given to the devil. Recalling Pope Leo XIII had a vision and overheard a conversation between God and the devil, Satan! We have reached the climax of that power handed to Satan and through his minions (the freemasons who report to the AC Charles) has caused mankind's massacre of the unborn to be so great that these deaths exceed ALL THE WARS PUT TOGETHER....
You cannot avoid “open schism” when the pope is worshipping pagan idols. We cannot be one Church worshipping one God when the pope is worshipping a false god.
@@pavelrazamazov2672 After the ceremony in the Vatican Garden where he sat there while people offered latria to a false god, which is evil enough, he participated in a tree planting ceremony, shoveling the dirt himself, planting a tree with pagan tokens hanging from it. Then, he had the abomination processed into St. Peter’s Basilica, placed it over St. Peter’s bones, said prayers to it, and held some abomination of a Mass where he accepted an offering to it. You don’t nearly have the full story if you only saw the first ceremony in the Vatican Gardens. The pope fully participated in pagan worship, allowed altars to be set up to the abomination in various churches in Rome, and had prayers published to the Andean earth goddess by name, which I will not use here. I will ask again, how can we have unity in worship of the one true God as the one true Church, when we have a pope who worships idols? This is only the most grievous of his many sins, heresies and apostasies. This “pope” seeks unity at the expense of the faith and unites himself with pagans and heretics. Schism is the lesser evil when we have such a pope, and it is already upon us. We cannot be united in apostasy. We must call the pontiff back to the faith, and if he will not come, we must abandon him and hold to the gospel given us by the apostles and reject any new gospel, even if it should come to us from an angel. Such is the teaching of St. Paul. We live in a hard time when we must make a hard choice. We cannot be obedient to an apostate, even should he sit in the chair of Peter. The devil mocks us by forcing this choice upon us, this choice between obedience to the ancient faith, and to the man proclaimed by the Church as pontiff. The times are, indeed, evil.
@@pavelrazamazov2672 really "oh no Jesus I wasn't doing that I was just watching" I have no respect for any man sitting back and watching an assault or a rape or what ever and I am just a man I am not the Vicor of Christ who accepted being the head of the Church Jesus started to protect the Deposit of Faith .Pray for the Pope and all Church leaders
The end doesn't justify the means. Usery was forbidden by the Church. Then the church found out they were missing a bet and changed the law, so they could charge interest.
Fr Murr, you should view Jordon Peterson's interview with Joe Rogan... as he states that it is fascinating to see how the conversations make their own themes, and have an arc and conclusions. Your conversation was perfect, and had the theme it should have.... no need to try impose too much on them.
lI ove and appreciate these in depth conversations where there is never enough time to get to the bottom of things and to get round everything. But I do have one point of contention with you both, and respectfully ask, please excuse my frankness, why do you both continue to tiptoe round Bergoglio and all his blatant heresies - for, blatant they are, to believing Catholics! I think in your heart of hearts you know this too. E.g. the Creed itself gets us to declare that we reject the 'devil, and all his works, and all his empty promises.' The belief in Hell, and the belief in our freedom to go there if we want to, is a fundamental of our Faith. Bergoglio's manipulative game of saying, well, yes, it's there, but I believe it's empty, is a spiteful trick against simple Catholics! By saying this he first of all teases us and insults us by implying we are horrible uncaring people for thinking anyone would have to go to hell, and then he says this because he believes he himself is more generous than God!!! He puts himself above God by saying this. And no-one with a few brave exceptions, has the courage to call him out on it. I hope you are not upset by my thoughts, but, I think we should start airing these things, or we will never clear this up and many will be hurt and lost. Of course I've given you a 'like! The programmes is great and I really appreciate your insights, which are very enlightening. Thank you and bless you!
@@dlw3425 You are a fool! It is still Communist. Changing names of countries does not mean changing nature or Ideology! LOOK at what evil Genocide POOtin, is doing! He is like Stalin!
39:47 YES PLEASE ~ a regular show with Dr. Moynihan, Don Carlo & Abp Viganò: PRICELESS & much needed for the good of the faithful around the world 🙏
Dr. Moynihan ~ you must realize that the myth of the "great society" has not lifted the masses out of poverty ~ instead it's made more people more poor. It's not that Conservatives lack charity. Clearly, the US gives a lot. It's that individualism matters too ~ we face the Judge on our own ~ individually.
Amen to our Holy Catholic Church to stand up to the world order! God Bless Abp Vigano !
My life changed for the better because of Archbishop Viganò and my heart is filled with gratitude towards him! Big THANK YOU to both of you as well!
I agree with your comment.
Refreshing to hear a cleric say what many of us our feeling, that the Church needs to stand up and say that what is going on, in many respects, is WRONG. Period. I think Archbishop Vigano is spot on about what he says. Great video, thank you.
Thank you, gentleman. Fr. Murr. You laugh is contagious. Thank you for great discussions, Mr. Robert.
Thank you and I think Vigano is right on....for they are always ridiculed before God strikes. Discredited and persecuted. Those who have the courage to speak up....Remember the flood.
Seems like Vigano and Father Murr have a good understanding of the Holy Spirit and the gifts of knowledge, understanding, fortitude and wisdom. There IS a unity involved.
"He's seeing a lot of different parts of the same whole."
You nailed it, Father.
Vigano nailed it.
And he is a huge part of why I took an interest in Catholicism, and why I'm a new convert.
God bless, y'all.
#RedPill
Thank you both, I truly enjoyed your talk! God Bless 🙏
I just love learning the back stories of how the church was ruptured. You guys are so enlightening. Thank you for championing the real good guys. I can see how Our Lord sends us quiet saints to keep us afloat while the ship rides a tidal wave of evil. You give us hope. ❤️🙏
After taking the Ignatian Exercises, I think listening to your stories is proof positive of how God is manager extraordinaire of his church. Although at times things seem hopeless, He is there for us saying “be still and know that I am God.” Pray & fast always..sometimes use words.❤️🙏
A really great conversation and thank you both. I, too, find myself in agreement with you both. Unity is critical, and as Catholics we are first and foremost united in Christ, by living our personal lives united in Christ and by grace, Christ in us. I say then we continue to pray for Pope Francis and trust in God's providence. Until there is a change, until we have a great Holy Father (as Our Lady has promised and stated so well by Fr. Murr), the unfortunate reality is the sheep are already scattered. Find comfort and trust in what we know for certain- Christ- and the traditional Latin mass of our fathers, and their fathers before them and all the saints. This is reality.
I definitely enjoyed you both - Thank you!
Discussions with Fr Murr are always excellent
Robert Moynihan has been around the Vatican for decades, involved with the publication, Variety Ivanovo, so he’s so knowledgeable. I appreciate that he introduced us to Abso. Vigano with his book, Finding Vigano. How wonderful that it was Vigano who finally outed the evil Theodore McCarrick who’d abused likely thousands of young men, particularly young seminarians. What psychological damage this monster imposed on so many innocent well intentioned holy young men. James Hroen differed PYSD for all that McCarrick put him through. He is the root of the spread of priestly sexual abuse. The pope first sent McCarrich to give the Church in China to the Communists. Moynihan is a great problem solvers, knows so many people and so much about what ails the Church at the Vatican...
Outstanding program. Looking forward to future installments.
Please lord, give AB vigano the strength to appear on a podcast, ....Fr Murr " I never bought into the world" love that quote snap....
Thank you immensely Dr. Moynihan for that awesome Quotation by St. Vincent of Lerins.
I will try to find it on his book "The Commonitory of St. Vincent of Lerins"
My God bless all your exemplary works for our King Of Kings Jesus Christ.
Great conversation
Rise Up Ohhh Men and Women of God and Defend Holy Mother Church and Our Country 🙏☝️ Viva Cristo Rey
Our de facto supreme pontiff.
Dr. Moynihan, I finally got the content of your quote "In dubious questions Freedom; in certain questions, Unity; but in all questions Charity......beautiful! But not by St. Vincent of Lerins.
Nevertheless, I immensely thank you as in searching this quotation, I read the whole extraordinary book, (only 129 pages)The Commonitory of St. Vincent of Lerins. The last chapters very adapted to today's Catholic Church, dough written over 1000 yeas ago.
Almighty God bless abundantly you Dr. Moynihan and jovial Fr. Murr.
Dr. Moynihan, I made an egregious error this morning during the Live Chat, attributing a quote of Archbishop Vigano to his Homily from the Feast of the Ascension. As you know, the quote was the Archbishop's, however, it was from the interview with Arkady Mamontov - not his homily. In keeping with the 200 character limit in the Live Chat, I deleted a sentence and failed to edit my edit.
May I humbly suggest that next time you have communication glitches and air time to fill, the prayer to Saint-Michael and a Hail Mary to banish the gremlins. 🙏🏻
We need Vigano for pope!!!!
I agree it is all one. Even faithful Catholics favor this philosophy of politics over church.
Why is it that my book with the title of murder in the 33rd° is written by Charles Moore and the speaker on the show is called Carlo Murr?
Hi Fr. Murr🙏🏼❤️
Too many untimely deaths! God help us.
Robert, we all want unity, but don't unite around deserting The One Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church. Hold onto the traditions passed on. Follow the Council of Trent. Pope Bergogulio is doing the smashing as did Vatican II. Restore tradition. It's the only way.
Our Lady of Fatima, pray for us. 🙏
"IN ESSENTIALS UNITY, IN NON-ESSENTIALS LIBERTY, IN ALL THINGS CHARITY.
On the Origin of the Sentence: "In necessariis unitas, in non-necessariis (or, dubiis) libertas, in utrisque (or, omnibus) caritas."
Archbishop Vigano would make a great Pope!
For the rest of the opinion of Don Carlo Muir , I AGREE WITH
Did Father Murr really use the expression "his truth" at the 17:28 mark?
He said "which is true" regarding Vigano's remarks.
@@StarVoyagerMan I disagree as it doesn't make sense. "I think this is fine up until a certain point. And this is where, I think, Vigano impacted me an awful lot, which is true."
We are at the stage when because of the volume of the greatest sins ALMOST TOTAL power has been given to the devil. Recalling Pope Leo XIII had a vision and overheard a conversation between God and the devil, Satan! We have reached the climax of that power handed to Satan and through his minions (the freemasons who report to the AC Charles) has caused mankind's massacre of the unborn to be so great that these deaths exceed ALL THE WARS PUT TOGETHER....
You cannot avoid “open schism” when the pope is worshipping pagan idols. We cannot be one Church worshipping one God when the pope is worshipping a false god.
How was he worshiping an idol? From what I remember he was sitting there and watching some ritual.
@@pavelrazamazov2672
After the ceremony in the Vatican Garden where he sat there while people offered latria to a false god, which is evil enough, he participated in a tree planting ceremony, shoveling the dirt himself, planting a tree with pagan tokens hanging from it. Then, he had the abomination processed into St. Peter’s Basilica, placed it over St. Peter’s bones, said prayers to it, and held some abomination of a Mass where he accepted an offering to it.
You don’t nearly have the full story if you only saw the first ceremony in the Vatican Gardens. The pope fully participated in pagan worship, allowed altars to be set up to the abomination in various churches in Rome, and had prayers published to the Andean earth goddess by name, which I will not use here.
I will ask again, how can we have unity in worship of the one true God as the one true Church, when we have a pope who worships idols? This is only the most grievous of his many sins, heresies and apostasies. This “pope” seeks unity at the expense of the faith and unites himself with pagans and heretics. Schism is the lesser evil when we have such a pope, and it is already upon us. We cannot be united in apostasy. We must call the pontiff back to the faith, and if he will not come, we must abandon him and hold to the gospel given us by the apostles and reject any new gospel, even if it should come to us from an angel. Such is the teaching of St. Paul.
We live in a hard time when we must make a hard choice. We cannot be obedient to an apostate, even should he sit in the chair of Peter. The devil mocks us by forcing this choice upon us, this choice between obedience to the ancient faith, and to the man proclaimed by the Church as pontiff. The times are, indeed, evil.
@@pavelrazamazov2672 really "oh no Jesus I wasn't doing that I was just watching" I have no respect for any man sitting back and watching an assault or a rape or what ever and I am just a man I am not the Vicor of Christ who accepted being the head of the Church Jesus started to protect the Deposit of Faith .Pray for the Pope and all Church leaders
Sadly, Madre Pasqualina the Gate Keeper let one slip through. In the final years when such protection would have been invaluable. Justin Bea.
Vigano needs to address his critics and not ignore them.
We can’t be unified with apostasy
Do you have a son named Kevin that's a Priest?
He's the only one.
who gave Argentina the money ?
Luke 12:51 52 & 53
The end doesn't justify the means. Usery was forbidden by the Church. Then the church found out they were missing a bet and changed the law, so they could charge interest.
Fr Murr, you should view Jordon Peterson's interview with Joe Rogan... as he states that it is fascinating to see how the conversations make their own themes, and have an arc and conclusions. Your conversation was perfect, and had the theme it should have.... no need to try impose too much on them.
lI ove and appreciate these in depth conversations where there is never enough time to get to the bottom of things and to get round everything. But I do have one point of contention with you both, and respectfully ask, please excuse my frankness, why do you both continue to tiptoe round Bergoglio and all his blatant heresies - for, blatant they are, to believing Catholics! I think in your heart of hearts you know this too. E.g. the Creed itself gets us to declare that we reject the 'devil, and all his works, and all his empty promises.' The belief in Hell, and the belief in our freedom to go there if we want to, is a fundamental of our Faith. Bergoglio's manipulative game of saying, well, yes, it's there, but I believe it's empty, is a spiteful trick against simple Catholics! By saying this he first of all teases us and insults us by implying we are horrible uncaring people for thinking anyone would have to go to hell, and then he says this because he believes he himself is more generous than God!!! He puts himself above God by saying this. And no-one with a few brave exceptions, has the courage to call him out on it. I hope you are not upset by my thoughts, but, I think we should start airing these things, or we will never clear this up and many will be hurt and lost. Of course I've given you a 'like! The programmes is great and I really appreciate your insights, which are very enlightening. Thank you and bless you!
what he is doing is contrary to that
Robert, you are being naive. Vigano is right.
Usury was, is and will always be a sin.
For BerGOGlio, "Peace," means "surrender to RuZZia," BerGOGlio´s fellow-Communists! Thanks, but, "NO THANKS!!"
USSR ended in 1991. Russian government today isn’t Communist.
@@dlw3425 You are a fool! It is still Communist. Changing names of countries does not mean changing nature or Ideology! LOOK at what evil Genocide POOtin, is doing! He is like Stalin!