Not only did a judge have to watch this, lawyers on both sides, including paralegals and law firm assistants (both parties have a lot of money) watched this, multiple times. And there’s no doubt they watched a lot of H3 and Matt’s other videos to build the case all that. I love the thought of some 60 year old seasoned lawyer watching h3’s video about the enema lady and taking notes like “hmm yes this is indeed a satire media and should be represented as such”.
Patrick Cc: lol ikr, imagine them analyzing every word in this and writing it up like it's game-changing evidence. I bet Ethan and Hila never imagined that lawyers and judges would watch this lmao
To think Matt Hoss could've been well respected in the H3 community if he just embraced the meme. He could've gotten quite a following from that, like many others featured in H3's videos.
This case never made it into an actual courtroom. It ended with what's called a summary judgement, essentially a "trial on paper": Ethan and Hila wrote up their case and sent it to the judge, who ruled in their favor. TH-camr Legal Eagle has a video explaining all the steps in a lawsuit, most of which end without ever reaching trial. (Also, this case-- Hosseinzadeh v. Klein-- is mentioned in all of his video descriptions!)
Imaging going to law school getting your law degree becoming a judge and having to watch a middle aged man running and jumping over some walls in pursuit of a paid actress
Leonlx??? that has nothing to do with it... You KNOW that half of them arent used to shit like this, man "I was rock hard and ready to do this but now I know it's fake" Edit: I can't picture Donald Blythe from House of Cards reacting to this, but it's all that's going through my head
I was imagining the judge watching it the entire time. From her mild snark in her written opinion, I have a feeling she has become a fan and has gone back and watched almost all their videos now.
Imagine the Judge watching this, pausing it in the courtroom and saying, "You know, Mr. Klein, you could've just added cabbage and called it Holeslaw."
Callum Griffin Just imagine: "...Spreading my asshole on the street" Echoes throughout a silent courtroom as the video plays on screen for the judge and jury.
Cynthia Valencia especially given how many times he mentions it trough out the series and pretty early on as well. Great Scott productions would’ve been great
Ego is a very disgusting thing. There are people who would be honored to be goofed on by these two guys and if people caught onto the fact the person being goofed on took it well and maybe even made fun of himself, he would have probably had so much more subs views and fans. In a nutshell the guys a fucking idiot.
In retrospect, the thing that strikes me is just how polite and cordial their criticisms are. They never make any vicious personal attacks. The fact that he sued them over this is laughable and I'm glad he fell on his stupid creepy face.
Captain Canada -Completely agree.. this vid actually recommend checking out the plaintiff's channel.. why would he be bothered, much less sue? really doesn't make sense. he had just gotten free publicity/promotion. what a putz that loser is
I really don't think he did it because he was offended. I think he *REALLY* attempted to sue just to extort money from them. If he had been offended about the video, asking them to take it down would have been enough. That's what most people do. But he literally contacted a lawyer and demanded $4,000 in 24 hours or else. And the only other compromise he gave was to force them to promote his channel and upload specific videos(and I think send him the money they made from those videos). Then when he figured out he would likely lose the lawsuit on copyright, he attempted to sue them for two other issues he and his lawyer made up in order to hopefully get something out of it. So it would seem his entire plan was based around the idea that people would not fight against him in a lawsuit. And agree to comply with his demands. I mean, it was completely calculated. Yes he had a lawyer, but the entire situation reeks of a guy that tries to abuse the flawed law system to extort money from people. Whats scary is what if he has done this before? How many people gave into the 'Pay 4,000' or 'promote my channel' demands before he picked a fight with h3h3 and lost?
If I didn't know anything about MattLoss, I would think that he was just trying to make a quick money-grab rather than doing it out of spite. However....
Can you just imagine the deposition? Prosecution: “So, Mr. Klein, when you showed this portion of the clip, you stated ‘carrots in the asshole, Mayo in the mouth’. Is this correct?” Ethan: *Ethan cough sequence of discomfort*
You know, Matt Hoss' video could actually have been genuinely fucking hilarious if he had made it ironically and made the girl do all the crazy parkour while Bold Guy just used the stairs like a normal person.
Turquoise Cheetah instead of just having the old video reinstated, he reuploaded it with 3 ads lol it's a savage move 3x the pay, plus all the people that watched the old one now watch this one too
@@FuckdasketsHOPassass What's wrong with having an American flag in your PFP? Doesn't mean you think being patriotic is a personality trait, which it kind of is.
Literally Figurative It establishes precedent showing that reaction videos such as this one, that utilize clips of other people's works and add criticism and commentary, are indeed fair use. Precedent is everything in our system of law, because judges rely on prior decisions to decide the cases before them.
The fact that he sued over THIS is pathetic. This is one of their tamest reactions, damn dude this guy is insecure. He wrote a bunch of self-compliments into the script and got the girl, but he still wasn't feeling good about himself. Thanks for wasting so much time and money on that court case
To be fair, the guy clearly worked really hard on this. He wrote, produced, directed and starred in his own video for millions of people. Also, this video does show pretty much the entire video. The court decision stated this wasn't a "market alternative"; and I am not a lawyer, but I can understand how it could be perceived as an alternative and a violation of his copyright. But I am happy with the decision, that H3H3 aren't bankrupt, and there is precedent for the protection of critical commentary content creators.
Every now and then, I turn off my addblocker(s), and come back and watch this video. It's become a tradition that I will continue for as long as the video is hosted and monetized.
Actually this would’ve fallen under “Civil Case” and the judge is probably a civil judge which means they only deal with lawsuits, legal disputes, land disputes, and other legal matters. Crimes wouldn’t fall in this jurisdiction, so really the judge **at worst** divorce fillings, people trespassing while someone presses charges, or very mild crimes with the main focus being the wanting of compensation by one party. They never really would’ve seen murders or serious gore, maybe the lawyers if they represented a murderer, but never the judge.
Even after all the nice things they said about him at the end about respecting his work, basically giving him free advertising, telling people to watch his vids and he still tried to sue them, what a freaking douche! Over the moon for Ethan and Hila! MATTER OF LAW
Well the modern manner of the justice system is a sword that *no one* can use force on it because its handle is also sharp enough to cut anyone is hand. The difference between the pass and modern justice system manner is that we can see and we can hear if there was a crime or not... The old justice system has this women with blinded eye and balance(form of election) and sword. In 2000 era. the technology allow this same justice *women* to have laser scan eyes (pin pointed problem/solution), laser sword, and digital balance systems. hehe So it`s no more about the hit but the following orders back in good conduct/stabilization.
*court room in middle of presenting this video as evidence* Ethan: Eat the mayonnaise and shove the carrot up your a%# Judge: this is a quintessential example of fair use
Dapbear That's all I could think about too. It's pretty funny too when you think about the fact that lawyers and judges today have to deal with law school and passing the bar, and then they had to deal with stuff like this. It's pretty comical.
Dapbear lol I don't wanna rain on ur parade but it never went to trial or had a jury. This was because it was suck an open and shut case. Only the judge herself watched this
at 6:04 instead of "strong shoulders" she should've said "matter of law" at 6:18 instead of "firm chest" she should've said "Quintissential" at 6:24 instead of "tight butt" she should've said "motion DENIED"
Just seeing how nice they are in the video, even complimenting him at the end, makes the guy who sued them seem even more butt hurt. They were so good natured.
DontCallMeSweetie I totally agree they weren't offensive, didn't call him out for being a total douchebag or point out that this was a lame attempt at ego stroking. I certainly would have oh errr guess I just did. Going get sued!
To be fair, they did get sued for copyright infringement, not for talking shit so what they really said, doesn't matter, nor did it play any role in the trial
i can't believe he sued you for this, this was such a great review on his content, no hate, no downsizing him, just a few banter comments as jokes, this was so layed back that i completely understand why you won the lawsuit.
That's probably the best thing about this. I've watched so much commentary community drama go down & it usually benefits the smaller creator that gets made fun of. Instead of using this as a window to grow his audience, this idiot tries to make a quick buck & sue. Now all he go out of it is millions of people who think (know) that he's a tool. I love it when justice prevails.
If Bold guy just contacted Ethan to do a parody of the video with Ethan as the girl, he would have gotten a lot more success than his pathetic lawsuit could have ever done.
I bet the judge subscribed
Sarah Cosgrove yup 😂😂 nobody can resist papas thickness 🙏 #Papabless
Sarah Cosgrove Matt’s legal team did too haha
Im just replying because sarah cosgrove is pretty
Sarah Cosgrove why did the judge have to watch this?
She’s a legend
knowing the judge watched this is great
Holy shit, yeah 😂 I can imagine the judge cringing so hard
Colby Mello probably just agreed with everything they said tbh
the judge had to hear about Ethans mayonaise fetish
Colby Mello he watched a bunch of h3s videos aparently too
Colby Mello i didn't think of that yet. thanks for this lmao
“He called me a ding goobus your honor.”
i think it was definitely “dang goobus” to be fair
can we get this to top comment fellas?
Efin Barbwedy why did the judge have to watch this?
Efin Barbwedy omg
lets parchment it up yo o m g
Not only did a judge have to watch this, lawyers on both sides, including paralegals and law firm assistants (both parties have a lot of money) watched this, multiple times. And there’s no doubt they watched a lot of H3 and Matt’s other videos to build the case all that. I love the thought of some 60 year old seasoned lawyer watching h3’s video about the enema lady and taking notes like “hmm yes this is indeed a satire media and should be represented as such”.
Melissa Gray THIS IS INDEED A SATIRE MEDIA
@@christianleblanc6153 A S A M A T T E R O F L A W
Melissa Gray they probably didn’t know wtf they were talking about when they referenced prank invasion
as a paralegal myself I'd be thrilled to have to do this kind of research
This one comment is funnier that bold guy’s whole video. Great comment tho jokes aside👍
"I'm not saying the guy deserves hate. He's doing his own thing and I respect that"
S U E D
"I want him to have his own show, this shit is so entertaining"
S U E D
"Go check out his channel, he puts a lot of effort into his videos"
S U E D
I fuckin love these comments
S U E D
LMAO.
I can't help but laugh at all of these big wig lawyers watching this video and having to take it seriously lmfao.
Patrick Cc: lol ikr, imagine them analyzing every word in this and writing it up like it's game-changing evidence. I bet Ethan and Hila never imagined that lawyers and judges would watch this lmao
Thats exactly what I was thinking as well.Because I know that must have been a hilarious circumstance
I bet they loved it
The carrot in the ass and mayonnaise in the mouth was quintessential.
lmfao
The judge had to watch this numerous times
Melancholy Dead 😂😂
Melancholy Dead
Best. Job. EVER!
Melancholy Dead what if the judge was already a hila kleiner?
I hope the judge had fun :)
even worse, the judge had to watch the original hoss video numerous times as well without ethan and hila
To think Matt Hoss could've been well respected in the H3 community if he just embraced the meme. He could've gotten quite a following from that, like many others featured in H3's videos.
he would have had to eat some crow for that, and he was too proud to do that
Yeah he's finished on TH-cam
it was Cicero, I think, who said intelligence was the ability to laugh at yourself. I think Cicero would've subscribed to h3h3
But isn't it interesting in the long debate of fair use? This case was truly magnificent.
honestly this video is so tame. This is basically affectionate criticism that concluded with Ethan calling it a "romp". How much better can you get?
lol a court room had to listen to him say "put the mayonnaise in her mouth"
H3h3: "He works hard on his videos, he cares about his videos. We respect him for what he does."
Matt Hoss: *sues them*
Tried to anyway
Kadin Imdad NIGGA GOT D E K L E I N E D
What a nice piece of property
Heather Young
Shut up
Kadin Imdad Still called his work crap though. Doesn't excuse the "sue them for not liking my stuff" but they did initially shit on it.
"I have the right to stretch here"
"And I have the right to come talk to you"
And they have the right to make a video about it
M A T T E R O F L A W
420 likes when i look at this
And Ethan has the right to make fun of them.
bill nye destroys matter
OMG
Cour I'm rock hard
like three years later & i still can’t believe that there was a LAWSUIT over this video
They aren't kidding when they say that it's like a porno without the porn.
RANDOMpercentage it feels like im watching a porno but with the porn cut out
Just "o"
I can't believe an actual court watched Ethan talk about "carrots in the ass, mayonnaise in the mouth" LOL
LOL !!! Yeah, I was thinking the same thing !!!
xD So fucking true.
the judge was probably eating a carrot salad too.
Jamie Hendrickson probably burst out in laughter.
i was thigh 1000 like
This Matt Hoss guy looks like a trigger-happy litigant who immediately activates his lawyers when he is criticised.
Matthew Morrin gotem
matter of law
i agree with your opinion
Matthew Morrin matter of law merch coming soon
DENIED
I wish there was footage of the court proceedings
JustRonhan there has to be right? Aren’t all court cases filmed and in the public record?
I bet its super boring tbh court proceedings usually are.
This case never made it into an actual courtroom. It ended with what's called a summary judgement, essentially a "trial on paper": Ethan and Hila wrote up their case and sent it to the judge, who ruled in their favor.
TH-camr Legal Eagle has a video explaining all the steps in a lawsuit, most of which end without ever reaching trial. (Also, this case-- Hosseinzadeh v. Klein-- is mentioned in all of his video descriptions!)
You mean, the judge making a reaction video of this reaction video. That would have been pretty epic.
Oh the transcripts are public. And they are very fun. Feat. Ethan trying to explain mayonnaise and Carrots to a lawyer.
"SsTRoNGgggg shoulders" - says the woman with arms twice the size of his....
Maisey Wolf lol my first thought when she said that was “but she has better delts than him”???
yoo that's what i noticed too like that girl is pretty buff
His shoulders are weak af. Look at em
Dude you know the judge was rolling watching this
...Whilst adding carrots and mayo to his/her grocery list..🤔
The judge was on Molly?
Thank you.
+Chip Potato Makes even more sense XD
glassjaw 01
This is probably the greatest slap in the face to Matt hoss to re upload this video.
It is and I LOVE it
Not_my_tachanka funny because he gets slapped in the face in this video
With three ads
Imaging going to law school getting your law degree becoming a judge and having to watch a middle aged man running and jumping over some walls in pursuit of a paid actress
Yeah THAT is the bad part. Not watching a middle aged men talk about putting a carrot covered in mayonaise into the ass of said actress.
I’m geeekeddddd
@@Last_Resort991 I have one word for you, QUINTESSENTIAL!
Its Xavier Wulf btw
@@Paul....... hm?
That's incredible to think that legal people had to watch this
"VISUALISE THE CARROT IN HER ASS DUDE"
legal people are just like everyone else
What he's saying is that "legal people" are not the usual audience/demographic of the h3h3 channel.
Leonlx??? that has nothing to do with it... You KNOW that half of them arent used to shit like this, man
"I was rock hard and ready to do this but now I know it's fake"
Edit: I can't picture Donald Blythe from House of Cards reacting to this, but it's all that's going through my head
I was imagining the judge watching it the entire time. From her mild snark in her written opinion, I have a feeling she has become a fan and has gone back and watched almost all their videos now.
QUINTESSENTIAL. MATTER. OF. LAW.
I'm got a full chub
NO DOUBT
DENIED.
Andrew Louviere I just busted the biggest nut
GRANTED
Imagine the Judge watching this, pausing it in the courtroom and saying, "You know, Mr. Klein, you could've just added cabbage and called it Holeslaw."
🤣🤣🤣
Fuck that got me🤣🤣
You should do comedy
😂😂😂
O M H
The only thing I was thinking throughout the video was this being played in court
Everyone was either losing their shit, laughing or cringing
😂💀
Callum Griffin Just imagine: "...Spreading my asshole on the street" Echoes throughout a silent courtroom as the video plays on screen for the judge and jury.
Callum Griffin I'm not into fist-fucking, but thank you for the offer
Ethan on record "I really like mayonnaise...I love mayonnaise."
Imagine the judge trying to watch this video with a straight face.
I hope she is a subscriber now
DeclanGames
😂😂
Nëllia Robertz You just assumed the judge's gender.
REEEEEEEEEEEEEE
Remi King Ethan said himself that the judge is a woman lol
*plot twist* the judge was a subscriber
If she wasn't before she will be now.
Nick gurr Can you imagine the court room when they had to watch this video?
I know the judge can't have a favourite side, but it would be so funny if she was actually a sub
shes a HilaKleiner
Attila Pataki *she the judge was a woman btw
"He's very professional, he cares about what he does."
*S U E D*
Just picture the judge and the lawyers watching this over and over seriously...
D_LOWGAMES Yeah I know.
D_LOWGAMES That's how it got 3m+ views
Have been imagining that for the past year+
D R E A M J O B
I wonder if they laughed at the carrot and mayonnaise jokes
I feel bad for the judge who had to hear nothing but mayo and carrots in the ass throughout this whole video lmao
ChaiSpicedD Dude, it’s a joke.
*QUINTESSENTIAL MATTER OF LAW*
OH BBY SAY IT AGAIN
DENIED
Stefan Steynberg PEWDIEPIE MODERATOR SQUAD LMAOO
bitch you copied my comment
SUE HIM BITCH
It's like if Michael Scott had a TH-cam channel, this is the content he would be putting out.
Even Michael is too self aware for this shit.
Omg michael starting a youtube channel would have been such a great story line!!
Cynthia Valencia especially given how many times he mentions it trough out the series and pretty early on as well. Great Scott productions would’ve been great
really reminds me of threat level midnight
Leave Michael alone
They legitimately gave him a shout-out and he sued them!?
pilotsun he's lost sooooo much money from losing the lawsuit
Ego is a very disgusting thing. There are people who would be honored to be goofed on by these two guys and if people caught onto the fact the person being goofed on took it well and maybe even made fun of himself, he would have probably had so much more subs views and fans.
In a nutshell the guys a fucking idiot.
Michael&Jello *tried to
Nathaniel Racoon be careful he might sue you for your opinion-based sentence, "In a nutshell the guys a fucking idiot."
They might've not been allowed to edit the video
Every time Ethan and Hila say some raunchy shit I just think of the lawyers that have studied for like 6 years and have to watch this seriously....
Jonesy.Jo you're sexy
Thanks you too
Jonesy.Jo open bob
Lol the original video is extra cringe lol
Samantha
woah woah woah, you want to take this to court
In retrospect, the thing that strikes me is just how polite and cordial their criticisms are. They never make any vicious personal attacks. The fact that he sued them over this is laughable and I'm glad he fell on his stupid creepy face.
Captain Canada -Completely agree.. this vid actually recommend checking out the plaintiff's channel.. why would he be bothered, much less sue? really doesn't make sense. he had just gotten free publicity/promotion. what a putz that loser is
I really don't think he did it because he was offended. I think he *REALLY* attempted to sue just to extort money from them.
If he had been offended about the video, asking them to take it down would have been enough. That's what most people do. But he literally contacted a lawyer and demanded $4,000 in 24 hours or else. And the only other compromise he gave was to force them to promote his channel and upload specific videos(and I think send him the money they made from those videos).
Then when he figured out he would likely lose the lawsuit on copyright, he attempted to sue them for two other issues he and his lawyer made up in order to hopefully get something out of it.
So it would seem his entire plan was based around the idea that people would not fight against him in a lawsuit. And agree to comply with his demands.
I mean, it was completely calculated. Yes he had a lawyer, but the entire situation reeks of a guy that tries to abuse the flawed law system to extort money from people.
Whats scary is what if he has done this before? How many people gave into the 'Pay 4,000' or 'promote my channel' demands before he picked a fight with h3h3 and lost?
Stupid? Creepy? You're so sued.
I couldn't agree more.
Your comment is meaner than anything in this entire video.
Ethan: "What happens when he catches her?"
Hila "WHATEVER HE WANTS"
Shadowchao121 DIOO
JOTARO
Dio
I read this comment at the exact time it came in the vid
They fuck, consensually
"And you're looking very Hila, may I say...and that is a compliment..."
-"Okay."
Timestamp?
0:21
Joan Madrigal what a short but very effective and such a big influence in a lot of people lives
filthy frank: 'How would you like to die?'
Hila: 'I'd like it.'
@Shallex 100%
They said such positive things about the guy and he sues them? Man, what's wrong with humanity.
Yeah, they were pretty generous considering how dumb the guy's video was.
He got butthurt and used his big ol powerful bank account.
money
If I didn't know anything about MattLoss, I would think that he was just trying to make a quick money-grab rather than doing it out of spite.
However....
i love the fact that the judge had to watch it with straight face
Mac Vanst 😂😂😂I read this as she asked to fist him🤣🙈🤣
Mac Vanst why would the judge have to watch it with a straight face?
Larry Stotlemyer to be professional
you laugh you lose (the case) challenge
i literally think about that same shit
Can you just imagine the deposition?
Prosecution: “So, Mr. Klein, when you showed this portion of the clip, you stated ‘carrots in the asshole, Mayo in the mouth’. Is this correct?”
Ethan: *Ethan cough sequence of discomfort*
Lol
Some people would use their 3 wishes on some interesting crap but i have to say, one of mine would be to witness this court case
This actually happened lmao, I read the transcript
Quintessential comedy
There is NO DOUBT!!!!!!
*Shaking intensifies*
DISMISSED
that's what I call a matter of law
DENIED
I enjoyed EVERY single ad on this video.
C O N S T A N T V A R I A B L E S i got no ads
I will watch and watch untill I get 3 ads
i turned off ad block for the ads
Weebzurd that's why TH-cam is dying
I watched it all and got no ads
Just imagining a court debating about assplay with carrots and Mayonnaise.
You know, Matt Hoss' video could actually have been genuinely fucking hilarious if he had made it ironically and made the girl do all the crazy parkour while Bold Guy just used the stairs like a normal person.
like a Randy from trailer park boys
Homie won the court case and reuploaded the video. Haha savage of savages.
Ethan was born a savage, hila was born a God
Time to trap up the Ethan Bradbury remix and post it in celebration.
Trap Music NOW. MATTER OF LAW
Trap Music NOW. Yo I love your channel!
Turquoise Cheetah instead of just having the old video reinstated, he reuploaded it with 3 ads lol it's a savage move
3x the pay, plus all the people that watched the old one now watch this one too
this video is even funnier knowing a judge had to watch it
i wonder how they felt about carrots up asses with mayo in the mouth. lmao
That's why I'm watching it 😂😂
Oh absolutely
Why did a judge watch it?
Anthony DiGennaro the guy sued h3h3 for "stealing his video"
Never been so happy to watch an ad.
Static whys everyone going on about the ads?
Dr Sleuth Because Ethan has been screwed by demonetization.
Dr Sleuth because this asshole sued them for this video and cost them tens of thousands of dollars and when you click the ads you make them money 💵💵💵
Becca Dutcher ahhhhhhh okokokok.. Cheers man
Static why not like they are getting ads other places
The re-upload version is so much better. Cause now you get to imagine judges and attorneys watching this :’)
"Please enjoy our creative property"
BURN!
Georg Rockall-Schmidt Didn't expect to see you here.
Holy mother of god it's some guy I don't know.
Georg Rockall-Schmidt everybody lovin' h3h3, keep your vids up too Georg
Georg Rockall-Schmidt
Howdy like ur videos bud.
Georg Rockall-Schmidt your lava lamp makes me hard.
I pause my adblock and watch this video at least once a month
KC Pelletier twice
many, many times.
Not all heroes wear capes
Same bro
KC Pelletier turn off adblock completely
You Guys were way nicer to him than I expected. I feel dirty for watching his clips.
if you're referring to people who watch porn then you're gonna need a courtroom that can hold millions of teenagers.
and adults
ratinator5 His names MattHossZone, it's a joke account
Dammit I just realized that it was a joke. Lesson learned: don't drink, drive, and youtube comment at the same time.
Watch it with captions
2006: TH-cam
2016: CringeTube
2019: CompanyTube
Spencer Brayman *demonetized*
No, 2016 is KidTube
2020 MyCoronaTube
When nationality is a personality trait
@@FuckdasketsHOPassass What's wrong with having an American flag in your PFP? Doesn't mean you think being patriotic is a personality trait, which it kind of is.
I love how they simply had to reupload it just to fuck with him haha
Patty Boi deserved
Patty Boi 😏😏💀😂😂😂
The funny part is this is gonna get way more views than the original ever did
Fuck yes
MATTER
OF
LAW
FLYINGPIGMEN Oh yeah bb say it again
QUINTESSENTIAL
DENIED
IM FULLY CHUBBED
FLYINGPIGMEN N
No doubt
Where are the 3 mid roll ads I was promised!?
ralphthemoviemaker I know man what the fuck
ralphthemoviemaker with Pepsi
ralphthemoviemaker RALPH!!!
Daddy sepe, is that you?
ralphthemoviemaker Hi my name is Charles Stiles
ethan saying "go check out this guy hes doing some good stuff"
gets sued by him
This video symbolizes a win for the FairUse fight on TH-cam
no it doesn't and please explain how
probably because it was a lawsuit about fair use and it was ruled in favor of the defendant?
Literally Figurative do you even know about the lawsuit?
Literally Figurative It establishes precedent showing that reaction videos such as this one, that utilize clips of other people's works and add criticism and commentary, are indeed fair use. Precedent is everything in our system of law, because judges rely on prior decisions to decide the cases before them.
ya and some people deserve to have it not them two but
got this video open on 10 different tabs getting as many ads as I can
Smash that like button Stab that subscribe button and MASH THE SHIT outta that refresh button.
ADBLOCK OFF MOFOKERS
now I am as well
*1 MI L L I O N L I K E S*
Hamez Cena 10 thats it with my quantum cpu i can get 1trillion tabs open lol
Gustavo Garcia no-one cares because your parents paid for it
D E K L E I N E D
Clearsky ooh i see you are the infamous wraith spirit king breaker
Clearsky H I L A K L E I N E D
S U C C
I couldn't think of a name so I just typed this k S O O K
OH thats good
Matt Hoss: I don't chase girls.
Subtitles: But will chase Ethan to the grave.
It makes me laugh harder that a lawyer probably watched this 100 times
Jack Millen and a judge ❤
Jack Millen they probably subscribed.
And got paid $150+ an hour to do it
The fact that he sued over THIS is pathetic. This is one of their tamest reactions, damn dude this guy is insecure. He wrote a bunch of self-compliments into the script and got the girl, but he still wasn't feeling good about himself. Thanks for wasting so much time and money on that court case
Fanboy lol
To be fair, the guy clearly worked really hard on this. He wrote, produced, directed and starred in his own video for millions of people. Also, this video does show pretty much the entire video. The court decision stated this wasn't a "market alternative"; and I am not a lawyer, but I can understand how it could be perceived as an alternative and a violation of his copyright. But I am happy with the decision, that H3H3 aren't bankrupt, and there is precedent for the protection of critical commentary content creators.
Kyle Wit it's people like you who are stagnating creativity
Subtle Demise Ok
Worked really hard on this? Hahaha. I could produce something ten times better with the greatest ease.
I'm just imagining the judge watching this video in her chambers and just thinking wtf
I was thinking the same thing all through this video.
So much of this
Same she's probably a Hila Kleiner now😂
Kim Johnson HAHAHA YESSS
are u kidding she was laughing her ass of hahaha
Every now and then, I turn off my addblocker(s), and come back and watch this video. It's become a tradition that I will continue for as long as the video is hosted and monetized.
I can't imagine a court having to watch through this video over and over in court.
Shit, I can imagine it, because I'm watching it over and over right now lol
IAmRedJustice Fekkin hell, could barely get through it once. But I made it. I fekkin made it. Just for you, Kleins.
IAmRedJustice to be honest imagining exactly that made it 10x more hilarious.
IAmRedJustice i'm guessing this video and the original had to have been broken down so thoroughly shot for shot they all know it by heart
I wonder if it made anyone laugh!
Wow Ethan, great move, keep it up, proud of you!
Arjit Bose *proud of you*
HOSS GOT DEKLEINED
Masterfiend this comment needs to be appreciated more
true
Masterfiend GODEEM
thank you for that man. thank you.
Lmaooo
May this video forever go down as one of the most historic H3 video's of all time
WTF, they were sued for this?!?!
Organizatio and it took nearly 17 months
Organizatio I dont get it either
you dumb boy they won and now its all good
Organizatio matt's just a sensitive bitch
You can be sued for anything.
Congratulations guys for winning the lawsuit and glad to see that you got this video backup
daddy
agreed
Hiii Tommy!!
TommyNC2010 e
aaaaaaayo! look who it is!
Matt Hoss? More like MATT LOSS
Toxic Killa gottem
Toxic Killa
Ha, GOT THEM........
Got them....
I wanna kill myself
Toxic Killa The scarce face looks great with that statement wtff lmao
Got his ass
Toxic Killa bold guy takes an L
I love how Hila's "Yeah" has a trademark in the subtitle.
His parkour looks like its straight out of The Office.
H A R D C O R E P A R K O U R
WOOOOOOOOOOAAAAAAAAAW!!!!!!!!
Dwight Shroot approves
GAINERRR
Nah it wasnt labeled (GONE HARDCORE)
How dare you disrespect my office boys like that:(
Love how they compliment him repeatedly, but he was still salty.
I love the subtitles every time Hila says "Yeah" then it says TM right after it every time.
QUINTESSENTIAL
This is the beginning of a new era. A E S T H E T I C is out, Q U I N T E S S E N T I A L is in.
Simon -PFL the aesthetic meme is normie shit anyways
.... Gamer (aka Lawrence Sonntag).
MATTER OF LAW
Ryley Mcrae DENIED
OMG, the acting is so fucking painful
It is
He is talking about Matt you idiot.
"you're" a fucking idiot
No I like to not say stupid shit and I personally cringe when people are dumb enough to fuck up "your" "you're" or "their" "there" "they're".
Also that's funny that you liked your own comments.
Counter argument: the judge is used to watching far worse (actual crime, death, gore, etc.) so this must have been a relief to watch
No just no
Actually this would’ve fallen under “Civil Case” and the judge is probably a civil judge which means they only deal with lawsuits, legal disputes, land disputes, and other legal matters. Crimes wouldn’t fall in this jurisdiction, so really the judge **at worst** divorce fillings, people trespassing while someone presses charges, or very mild crimes with the main focus being the wanting of compensation by one party. They never really would’ve seen murders or serious gore, maybe the lawyers if they represented a murderer, but never the judge.
@@levelmake7758 Maybe federal judges, right?
@@levelmake7758 judges/lawyers don't necessarily have to work the same field of law their whole careers
The fact that Hila’s “yeahs” are trademarked in the captions... 😂😂
Thank you for showing me this 😂
You helped me unlock a secret part of TH-cam accessible to only the most highly intelligent minds
@Marcell Venglovecz turn on closed captioning and wait for Hila to say "yeah"
Me too but I thought no one would would notice I always have captions they have some funny stuff
Yeah...
I hope Matt Hoss names his child Mad Loss.
i get it
*dies*
Oh shiiiiiiiiiit
As if he's ever gonna get laid in the first place
Lol u cant pick the last name
Too bad they will
Even after all the nice things they said about him at the end about respecting his work, basically giving him free advertising, telling people to watch his vids and he still tried to sue them, what a freaking douche! Over the moon for Ethan and Hila! MATTER OF LAW
Sam Hayes And Matt's behaviour and writing is so creepy. I can't believe that lady went through with it
EXACTLY what I was thinking. Total egocentric idiot.
Matt is a textbook narcissist
The QUINTESSENTIAL narcissist, even.
MattHoss will sue them again sometime in the future for the same shit.
Look at these two kids, never been sued in their lives.
*M A T T E R O F L A W*
FULLY CHUBBED
*F U L L Y E R E C T*
M-A-T-T-E-R O-F L-A-W
Sexiest words ever
*quintessential*
*full chub intensifies*
Hila is always smiling at Ethan ( : 💓
@@jasonallison7681 you better be joking.
They don't take retards to the army. She just seems dull compared to Ethan. She's there to smile.
She's gorgeous with her big eyes
I was about to say that.
@@bub303 because she genuinely loves him.
God I miss the old h3h3
Better times all around.
I have no issues with the podcast but damn it would be nice if did more content under the h3h3production brand.
They literally haven’t made any H3 proper content since the pandemic
Same😭
@@GenerallDRKOr *any* content, really...
I love some good ole quintessential commentary
He should get sued for making Hila cry
Landon Harris this needs more likes. That woman is an angel.
Fuck that. Guy. I do parkour and I am extremely disappointed in him. Ethan is a god
Landon Harris *Hanged
Faolan Van Garrett Ha yeah he’s the worst
Well the modern manner of the justice system is a sword that *no one* can use force on it because its handle is also sharp enough to cut anyone is hand.
The difference between the pass and modern justice system manner is that we can see and we can hear if there was a crime or not...
The old justice system has this women with blinded eye and balance(form of election) and sword.
In 2000 era. the technology allow this same justice *women* to have laser scan eyes (pin pointed problem/solution), laser sword, and digital balance systems.
hehe So it`s no more about the hit but the following orders back in good conduct/stabilization.
*D E N I E D*
*M A T T E R O F L A W*
Q U I N T E S S E N T I A L
P U S S Y
England is My city
*Y O U A R E O N E*
*D E K L E I N E D*
And here it is, 2022, I'm not just a lawyer but a law professor, and I had to watch this for a copyright article I'm writing. Yeah, go ahead. Laugh.
I can't imagine a judge deeply analyzing h3 videos for a lawsuit lol
Gabriel S MATTER OF LAW
"As to the legal merits of the argument regarding carrots and mayonnaise, it is this Court's opinion that..."
...for years
Hahaha, right. There were a few parts that must have really stood out in the judges mind. Never mind the original "Bold" video.
It made reading the boring settlement .pdf very entertaining to put it in that serious context!
Keep in mind a judge watched this video.
fug lmaooo
well at least we get the
*MATTER OF LAW*
"Carrots in the ass"
Watched it with honour
3 years later, this is still such a great video to come back to to remember this big win for youtubers as a whole.
*court room in middle of presenting this video as evidence*
Ethan: Eat the mayonnaise and shove the carrot up your a%#
Judge: this is a quintessential example of fair use
Dapbear LOLOL
Dapbear That's all I could think about too. It's pretty funny too when you think about the fact that lawyers and judges today have to deal with law school and passing the bar, and then they had to deal with stuff like this. It's pretty comical.
I'm done, getting outta here before I get a heart attack 😂
Dapbear lol I don't wanna rain on ur parade but it never went to trial or had a jury. This was because it was suck an open and shut case. Only the judge herself watched this
😂😂😂
at 6:04 instead of "strong shoulders" she should've said "matter of law"
at 6:18 instead of "firm chest" she should've said "Quintissential"
at 6:24 instead of "tight butt" she should've said "motion DENIED"
great idea
Ethanila needs to read this.
I came reading that
YASSSS
Noah Carpenter omg
Just seeing how nice they are in the video, even complimenting him at the end, makes the guy who sued them seem even more butt hurt. They were so good natured.
DontCallMeSweetie I thought the same thing. Seemed like a huge waste of money to sue over this.
DontCallMeSweetie I totally agree they weren't offensive, didn't call him out for being a total douchebag or point out that this was a lame attempt at ego stroking. I certainly would have oh errr guess I just did. Going get sued!
Tom Cap he probably got a pro bono lawyer or something because no way he could afford this law suit
Sweetie
To be fair, they did get sued for copyright infringement, not for talking shit so what they really said, doesn't matter, nor did it play any role in the trial
i can't believe he sued you for this, this was such a great review on his content, no hate, no downsizing him, just a few banter comments as jokes, this was so layed back that i completely understand why you won the lawsuit.
they were actually being pretty nice compared to some of their other vids. he definitely should not have sued
Toby Stapleton ikr litterally at the end saying he seems like a nice guy and stuff. 😂😂
Right? They were actually being really nice towards him.
Yeah.. Matt was defiantly the one who ended up with the carrot in his ass
That matt guy clearly lives in a fantasy world i'm not surprised he sued and thinks he's in the right
Toby Stapleton yeah like i imagine the comment section in his vids has far worse commentary than this. They praised him too :S
they really got sued over this?? they plugged his channel and said that they respect him as a creator wtf
Maga Mujica Yeah but did you see the video? The dude is obviously a selfcentered twat. He's that friend that can't take a joke.
Spencer Lewis what's sad is he tries to hide how he can't take a joke behind "protecting artists rights"
That's probably the best thing about this. I've watched so much commentary community drama go down & it usually benefits the smaller creator that gets made fun of. Instead of using this as a window to grow his audience, this idiot tries to make a quick buck & sue. Now all he go out of it is millions of people who think (know) that he's a tool. I love it when justice prevails.
Yeah. Ethan can be hard on some People but this looks almost as an advertising for the dude's work.
Maga Mujica I
I still can't believe this whole lawsuit was over this video. Matt must really hate mayonnaise...
NoSkillScrub and he grabbed my arm. Got distracted waay to easily get the material we could make our own stand. Stab everyone you ever cared about
If Bold guy just contacted Ethan to do a parody of the video with Ethan as the girl, he would have gotten a lot more success than his pathetic lawsuit could have ever done.