What a perfect way of seeing things and giving opinion , rather than shouting with absolute ZERO knowledge. I would like to address the Republic tv and some other Bengali indian as well as a UPSC YT and other YT channels who are giving their opinions based on twitter university, fix your system. I am glad i watched interviews like this. Everytime I start hating india because of its terrible Media ,i see people and channels like this who are spreading real knowledge.❤
You Bangladeshis wouldn't have realised what had hit you during this interview. He said all those things that Arnab Goswami is saying but in a very sweet and nice way.
This gentleman is very smart and very knowledgeable and he’s full of wisdom It is very rare to see Indian intellectuals talk with reality He should be advising the RAW
It is now known that the US had tried to convince Sheikh Hasina to allow a US military base on a Bangladesh island. When Sheikh Hasina adamantly refused to give the US that demand then the US went the way it usually does and incited the opposition to bring about the ‘regime’ change. It’s okay to say that Bangladesh as a sovereign independent country can choose which direction to turn but the record clearly shows that friendship with the US is short term and lethal.
Whatever dictator Hasina and his son says the Indian media spread them like holy truth.. She is a pathetic liar and we are tired of her drama.. Besides, explain how the US instigated the student protest.. or how the the US convinced Hasina make terrible order to kill 1000+ innocent people and students and shut down internet for five days straight which led to her collapse?? If that's what the US wanted they could impose sanction after the fraud election and the people would overthrow the Dictator anyway 😅😅
Please get your facts right. St. Martin island is only 3sq KM in area and has no preexisting infrastructure for a base. It’s on the continental shelf and hence the water is very shallow and totally unsuitable for large vessels also the composition of the island is coral and it’s brittle in nature, there are approximately 4000 inhabitants who will have to be relocated, the topography of the island is flat and so there is no natural barrier to catastrophic hurricane that this region experience regularly. Moreover the US has multiple large bases in the region to patrol the strait of Malacca and South China Sea. Therefore all these are simply lies by Hasina
@@Nevermind-z1l how about Donald Lu of the US making 3 visits to Bangladesh to get support for the base on the island? Haven’t you learnt from all the previous US interference in so many countries around the world? Get your head out of your arse.
Just your opinion, facts say different story. She engineered three elections, she killed 300 students. Let alone all the corruption and money laundering, the amount of national debt she created is unprecedented. There were no worse dictator than her.
? Who? Bangladesh became Bangladesh 53 years ago and she was in power for 20 years or about 4 terms😂She grew the economy?Yeah idk if you knew this but that what economies do they grow but it sure does have a dildo in this rear when someone with the rationality of hasina is running the economy.I hope becomes the next pm of India and helps its economy like she did to Bangladesh and before you say you don't need it you already have diplomacy blah blah then why did you wish it upon us?
I don’t understand why India should bend over backwards to help Bangladesh. Most Bangladeshis consider India as their number one enemy. I think India should reciprocate in the same manner.
*Enemies in north Nepal , china* *Enemies in south Srilanka, Maldives* *Enemies in east Bangladesh, Myanmar* *Enemies in west Pakistan, Afghanistan* India should ask itself why is that
If you think ‘Most Bangladeshis consider India as their number one enemy’ you should’ve suggested to find the reason behind that. Rather you are suggesting hostility. Man believe it or not, people of Bangladesh and India are not enemies, mass people never were enemy to each other. Try to understand why Bangladeshis feel that way towards India, work on the solution. That will be good for both countries.
@@Anderson-f4t6c we know it's china and Pakistani created Islamic ideology only who is playing all this dirty game.... It was India only not any other country who was stand for srilanka during economic crisis.. it was India only who stand for Maldives during crisis.... It was India only who was there for Bangladesh during 1971.... India was always there whenever our neighbour were in crisis wether it was earthquake, COVID, economic crisis.. every time India helps neighbours..I know people are not realising now but they will realise it very soon as people of afganistan and srilanka realised.
@@ou9htreason is Pakistani created Islamic ideology which madrasas and parties like Jamaat-e-Islami , BNP and other Islamist groups which are continuously spreading hate and propaganda against India
Please do not underestimate Prof, Yunus. He is just not a Nobel Laureate and all theory. He is a doer. He has implemented his theories of microcredit by establishing huge organizations - Grameen Bank, Grameen Telecom, Grameen Health, and Grameen Education. These organizations provided employment to thousands of people and benefited millions of people in rural Bangladesh. He is responsible for the emancipation of the women of Bangladesh, a very conservative Islamic country. His initiatives are being replicated in many other countries. His current initiative is "Social Business". He is promoting it all over the world. As far as his physical ability is concerned, he has taken responsibility for 27 Departments. He is 84. Now, Jamat is not acceptable to the people of Bangladesh, especially the youth. Please do not scare your people.
Politics and governance are different thing, okay let us see how he performs but his initial statements that he has made with regards to India would not go down well with ordinary Indians and also the Indian govt. With regards to his achievements I first thought he must be some genius since he has been awarded the Nobel prize. But then after just digging a little bit deeper found he has cases filed against him in Bangladesh but also the Norwegian Govt was not happy with him. Then saw the documentary from Investigative journalist TOM HEINEMANN on this noble soul called "THE MICRO DEBT" after which got the whole picture about him. He is just a LOAN SHARK who saw business opportunity in fleecing on innocent and poor Bangladeshis that too women by giving them loans on collaterals with high interest rates and made a fortune for himself and diversified into other areas through his DEBT TRAP. There is nothing genius in this to be awarded a Noble prize for. The Chinese too had taken a lesson or two from him and coined their DEBT TRAP DIPLOMACY. Americans keep giving this peace and noble prize of literature to their useful idiots in order to advance the nefarious American foreign policy objectives. He is just a stooge for the Americans popped up into picture through this Noble prize, nothing else. A pretty long term investment that the Americans had made in him which is being used now.
It just baffles me that we allowed a nation called Bangladesh/east Pakistan to be formed in the first place in 1947, if you look at a map. It is sheer idiocy to maintain that kind of border. 4000 kms , are you kidding me , that too India surrounds Bangladesh on three sides, not to mention they almost cut us off from our north east states.
Because, the then congress leadership didn't have any other choice. The Greater Bengal which had a Muslim majority would have gone to Pakistan. To save at least some part of Bengal for the Hindus, Congress had to demand to divide bengal clubbing together hindu majority districts on one side and Muslim majority districts on the other side. In fact, it was Hindu Mahashava who demanded division of bengal by this religious faultline while Muslim league was demanding Full Bengal to be the part of Pakistan.
@@ds9510I think he means militarily we should have not allowed this division. We could have always pushed the special population to go to there homeland on west like what happened at other places of india
I generally don't like Indian diplomats especially the ones dealing with Pakistan because of their obvious love for peace with Pakistan at the expense terrorism in India. But I have to say I am in awe with this Indian diplomat who has such clarity of thought with regards to the whole gamut of India-Bangladesh relations. I guess the Bangladeshis wouldn't have realised what had hit them in a very nice and sweet way in this interview.
very intellectual and real informative conversations...watching from Portugal as Bangladeshi... Enjoyed a lot...i thought all indian spreads rumour more than real about Bangladesh but it’s not the case here...❤
So no mention of the Jamat and American hand ehh..? BTW, the asset army just woke up and decided to through Hassina out on that perticular date right... The date has no significance..?
Nitin Sir, through ur channel I want to request to Our Govt of India to create specialized think-tank to specific important geopolitical nations to serve India's interest with specialized technocrats.
Saran didn’t talk about what Hasina did last 15 years and what role was India last 15 years . India always play a role as big brother which Bangladeshi people don’t like.
An advice to Nitin Gokhale when you know you have called an expert to your show who is pretty clear in expressing his view then it is very irritating to see when you keep interrupting and disturbing him and his flow of thoughts. We know your also an expert but let the expert guest speak freely and uninterrupted. It was not nice. Thanks
Md Yunus is a microfinance specialist. No political or administrative experience. His Nobel medal is probably doubtful. He will make the country further poor and cash on poor man's financing without losing his image.
Here are my two words on your PM. After just digging a little bit deeper found he has cases filed against him in Bangladesh but also the Norwegian Govt was not happy with him. Then saw the documentary from Investigative journalist TOM HEINEMANN on this noble soul called "THE MICRO DEBT" after which got the whole picture about him. He is just a LOAN SHARK who saw business opportunities in fleecing on innocent and poor Bangladeshis that too women by giving them loans on collaterals with high interest rates and made a fortune for himself and diversified into other areas through his DEBT TRAP. There is nothing genius in this to be awarded a Noble prize for. So this microfinance is no rocket science there are lakhs of such entity here in India. Americans keep giving this peace and noble prize of literature to their useful idiots in order to advance the nefarious American foreign policy objectives. He is just a stooge for the Americans popped up into picture through this Noble prize, nothing else. A pretty long term investment that the Americans had made in him which is being used now.
I believe you guys are one of very rare Indians who acknowledged that Bangladeshi people have their own agency and right to make their decision, all other so called Indian Experts think everything about Bangladesh is geo politics and Bangladeshi people are just audience, no my friend, we dont care about what is going on with India or Pakistan or US, we are owners of our country and we dont want anyone else to make decision for us. Period.
In the very morning of Aug 5, the army of Bangladesh took a decision that they wouldn't able to shoot their own people chest. In terms of the demonstration above 3 million people in the roads of the capital, if army shooted and even instigated somehow, the huge amount of people could die when over thousands of people have been already killed by police and RAB. So, it was a role of Bangladeshi army. They love their country and respect their people's opinion as they evolved and originated from the great liberation war of 1971.
I am a Bangladeshi....And I liked what Mr. Pankaj Saran said.....Very accurate observation and some great advices. Thanks. I really believe that India can help Bangladesh grow. I hope, our Indian brother, sisters will help us to restore democracy, grow together and prosper.....India and Bangladesh would always stay together, I hope. We have the same cultural, history and even appearance. Only our geography is different.
@@mylord3003 EVERYONE is being targetted!!! I have a couple of Hindu friends and acquintances. None of them has been assaulted!!! I am not religious myself. And I am in my fourty. I have seen this 'hindu-muslim' danga propaganda being brought by some selfish groups/institutions, who work for their own agenda of using 'divid-and-rule' technique among all. After a revolution, there will be problems with law and orders. It is normal. In my country, there are some looting. The looters are muslims and the victims are muslims, too. And may be, some hindus, too. Both muslims and hindus are affected by the revolution and it is the nature of the revolution around the world. Unfortunately, some political grounds, miscreants, goons are taking advantage of this and spreading propaganda.....
Dear brother, Bangladesh is not in crisis, Bangladesh has overcomed overcome the crisis, the biggest crisis for Bangladesh is the dictatorship of Sheikh Hasina, and disproportionate interference of India in the every sector of Bangladesh. Now Bangladesh turn about and move forward.
Shut up your illiterate mouth Bangladeshi, the "disproportionate" interference is nothing but your stupidity that has no cure. Stop blaming India for your own inability to govern your own country!
That 'disproportionate interference' is why B'desh grew rapidly economically under Shiekh Hasina... so many infrastructure projects, business opportunities, water concessions and soft loans etc given to B'desh by India... it is fair for India to expect things in return...esp in terms of our security concerns vis-a-vis terrorists sanctuaries, drug and cattle running, space to chinese etc. and also protection to Hindus in B'desh... If the new dispensation goes back to pre-Hasina policy of B'desh towards India, the net loser will be the people of B'desh... its really the call of the new regime in B'desh now...
@@hkpandey1 just an indian explanation, we the people of Bangladesh are not agree with that, because there is no indian aid is visible in Bangladesh,all we are seeing is onle few suppliers credit loan, you can google it,and will learn.
@@hkpandey1Bro check the facts before you talk. India is not even the in the top 10 donar or investor in Bangladesh. The trade deficit between two countries are completely disproportionate. Okay let’s do one thing ‘Stop give and Take’ let’s see who will be crying.
@@ou9ht Yes, I hope that happens... then we'll see what your broke ass, debt-ridden govt. can do for your people... also, while your at that, do take back the termites you sent us over the years who're cleaning dishes and washing drains with fake Hindu names and fake aadhar cards in India & living off Indian tax payers money...
First of all India should stop behaving to super power,and start respecting its small neighbours,treat them with dignity,when a nation votes for Hindu fundamentalist government in power,who treats it biggest minority as second class citizens,ask the innocent muslim of up, through out bjp states of India their house are bulldozed with any crime,just because of their religion,that nation has no right to lecture other nations on minorities rights,fix your own house first.
Even if Bangladesh Muslims give half the rights enjoyed by Indian Muslims, Bangladesh Hindus would he very grateful to u. How many Hindu terrorist exist in Bangladesh and committed bomb blast
I have already watched over 50 videos from Indian analysts insights about Bangladesh current unrest. Unfortunately all of them analysed aggressive way and they simply explained things as if they’re representative of Hasina’s Party Awami League. And they don’t even have 20% of knowledge about Bangladesh socio economic condition. Compare to that Mr Pankaj Saran analysis is much better, liberal, and seems he knows socio-economic conditions and public pulse much better than others. But one thing misinterpreted in the video about torture on Hindus. Sheikh Hasina ruled Bangladesh for 15 consecutive years as a dictator and her party Awami League men literally controlled and tortured opposition and mass people. Obviously people had anger on them. Some Hindu Awami League Leaders also there and after Hasina departure, all Awami League people came under attack including Majority Muslims and some Hindu Leaders. Whereas non political Hindus are safe and well, rather in most temple now guarded by mass Bangladeshi Muslim people in absence of police. Also over 1000 people got killed in few week’s long violence in Bangladesh and 99% of them are Muslims, But the way you guys are explaining as if violence intend to Hindus only.
Fantastic comment! Be vigilant about crucial interest of the Nation, don't let anyone hijack this historic n noble people Revolution for that thousands of students and people sacrifice their lives for the betterment this country! Best wishes
If "non political Hindus" are safe then why are temples being burnt down? You guys don't even have minimum intelligence required to form a cogent argument, and give lectures to us?
@@AbdulKalam-yw3zs Unfortunately almost entire Indian maids started propaganda against Bangladesh. They have no sympathy for over 1000 people who got killed and also no respect towards this student revolution. They’re only highlighting some specific points, which completely based on lies.
Coz politically non-aligned Hindu's n Buddhists and atheists have been attacked all over B'desh in the last 4 days n this has been reported by your news outlets😮
The killing violence is not only being done to minorities,whole countries is suffering from that! We formed squad to safeguard the houses,Mandir,mashjid, business organisation! But some how we guys always focus on one thing ! Students are managing the traffic, cleaning the road! The irregularities is seen everywhere as there is vacuum created by the absence of police force! Criminals are robbing houses at the middle of the night, vandalising.So it's not just minority who suffering..it's everyone.But at the same time common people with the students are doing a commendable job to restore stability! With the newly formed advisory panel we are everything will go back to normalcy. So stop just talking about one side. PS: it was good and insightful interview! Thoroughly enjoyed it.and you guys earn my respect. Thank you for the interview
But still hindus attacked by mobs and destroying their horses and temples. By the way only 5% to 9% hindus left now. Hopefully it's not going to be another 1971.
Has there been an engineered and structured regime change facilitated by exogenous forces ? If that was indeed the case , what will be the future thrust from those agencies ? What were their investments expected to lead to as lasting returns ? What will be their overt or covert control over the ensuing regime ? That is a critical question people are avoiding to ask since it is not evident who the possible puppeteers are . One remembers what happened post Arab Spring. So it is crucial to grasp the sort of compact that other political forces will have to enter into with the Islamist groupings whch are now international in their reach and ideological convictions. All other discussions are peripheral. This area will become a key geopolitical theater . That is our worry.
Jamaat never got more than 5 percent vote in any election. This guy clearly has no idea what he is talking about. Based on what is he saying Jamaat has more popularity than BNP.
What he is saying Jamat is more organized, modern , educated compared to BNP, who is an emotional party and don't have an institution of democracy within the party, similar to Awami league.
Talking about Jamat helps their agenda. Helps them to establish the presence of Islamic radicals which will provide them some leverage on establishing that extremists are there.
Its an iran redux where moderate shah/hasina was overthrown by islamists, funded by foreign agencies. Only difference is iran has oil and bangaldesh has nothing. It's not going to end well.
India's problem is they always predeterminently think that I Awami League is their friend. So consecutively three times a l came into power with the only support from India. India has to come out of this mindset. India has to develop a people to people relationship, Institute of a partishan relationship. It should be a Win-Win situation always. Then only it will be sustainable. Again Bangladeshi Hindus also think that they are safe in the hand of Awami League. But this is not true. That's why they always support and do Awami League politics. So when thete is a regime change Hindus become easy target not for their religion but for their political viewpoint and allegiance.
This time done with less violence is he blind and deaf over four thousand students was killed by pro India gavorment of hasina it was done with indias help
Dude how is she pro India, why isn't she pro china. You students were trying to violently overthrow her govt and what were you expecting the Govt and police to do, how should they have responded to the violence. India could have only advised behind closed doors and I am sure the India govt should have done that. As any public statements would have seriously inflamed the atmosphere especially when many Indians work there and Hindu community living there. This would also have serious implications for the Indian govt back home.
In entire discussion one most important factor is ignored ....why and who orchestrated this landslide event. And what is likely play . If it's USA, what is the purpose ? They wish to create unstable territory to keep India & china .
Sensible Analysis of the situation. The geography of India and Bangladesh can not be changed. Both countries need each other. India should build trust with all parties, not with any individual. However, the way other analysts interpret the situation is far from the reality. Thanks, Pankaj Saran
Now an interim govt headed by Mohd. Yunus is in power... India will obviously deal with the present dispensation..India cannot deal with other forces in Bangladesh...same way India was dealing with the Hasina govt when it was in power
The hindus of Bangladesh usually involves with the politics of Awamileague, BNP and so forth. They get economic benefit, political convenience and show power over the years against opposition and even they involve to torture their fello religious community and others. When their political party are thrown out the government, they face political vandalism. It is the reality of the both sides Awamileague and BNP supporters but Indian media and some people project it like the way of communalism. Though it is political vandalism
Let me correct your opening statement. The country to our east. Bangladesh is celebrating a new birth after the fall of dictorial regime of Sheikh Hasina. Her demise comes after she decided to violently attack students for a peaceful protest killing more than 300 people in 14 days.
India has been seen to only cared about Hasina as India is hosting a leader who had committed horrif8c crimes against his own people. India to handover Hasina to be charched for crimes committed under her watch and on her own orders. Bangladesh in my believe will submit formal request to India to repatriate Hasina to be charged for crimes against humanity. Bangladesh will not ask India for a bail out but instead it will ask to handover Sheikh Hasina.
First time, I heard two Indian talking very logical talking against Bangladesh. Whoever come to power in Bangladesh, should pay attention 'don't put all eggs in one basket'. We should be careful about right of all Bangladeshi (minority or majority). Thank you both of guys.
Our foreign currency is drained out to Modi ji through Hasina & Adani and many other ways. Equation is very simple. I don't understand why your journalists and diplomats struggle to understand this simple equation. Please stop sucking Bangladesh. Enough is enough. Take care.
India should stop treating this revolution as a revolution that led by jamaat-BNP. That hurt us sharp. We need Indian support and India should stop blindly supporting Hasinas family and Awami League
I am glad that the Bangladesh peace process has begun, and maybe the military be work in tandem with BNP, and Jamaat-a-Islam,etc Let us hope that,in a now post -Awami League era, the powers that be could stich together, a cohesive, reliant, resilient and strong government With due respect to Ms.Hasina, I wish she should have resigned before the 2024 elections,and handed power to her second-in-command in the league This stratagem would not only be face-saving for her,and keep her as de jure leader Look, 15 years is a very,very time in politics and Hasina Madam should have taken the call when it sounded.Nobody can stay in politics forever
Hasina's way of thinking is similar to her father's , both were tyrants & mass murderers & Ironically both regimes were thrown out in the same month 😂 . She & modi has destroyed the Ind-BD relationship . An entire generation will now look at Ind as the country which has blindly backed her murderous Regime
You can blame modi for that Blunder , backing a mass murderer & illegal regime . India had good relationship with the dictator/party rather than the people
Hindu fundamentalist (BJP) killing all minorities especially Muslim! In India! Shame on you Indian trying to lecture Bangladesh. INDIAN can see & learn from Bangladesh how to protect minorities when they are in crisis! Thousands of people stand guard together.... Protecting minorities.
India should throw out the criminal who committed genocide a vicious Dictator Shekh Hasina. Or arrest her and send back to Bangladesh. Sheltering her in india is putting india and Bangladesh relationship questionable. India should be friends with Bangladeshi nations interests and well being , not be friends with a criminal who destroyed the democracy in Bangladesh and committed genocide and fled .
That's your internal issue. You don't have proper democratic institutions and power is highly centralized. So, in absence of federal structure whoever is in power will always behave as a dictator.
Some of the policy decision contributed to the fall of Hsina government. For example, not signing Tista water sharing treaty even after assurance of several times from Mr. Modi. Secondly , india's objection on a proposed Tista water management and development project with Bangladesh and China joint venture.
Sir the young society of Bangladesh and the minority religious people and a large Muslim population no longer like BNP Awami League and everyone is asking Dr. Md. Yunus to lead the government for five years and a anti communal person like Dr. Muhammad will be the head of the government of Bangladesh.
this is the first time i saw someone talking so sensible about Bangladesh in india...much respect
What a perfect way of seeing things and giving opinion , rather than shouting with absolute ZERO knowledge. I would like to address the Republic tv and some other Bengali indian as well as a UPSC YT and other YT channels who are giving their opinions based on twitter university, fix your system. I am glad i watched interviews like this. Everytime I start hating india because of its terrible Media ,i see people and channels like this who are spreading real knowledge.❤
Pl use ur real name in your comments. Anonymity can be avoided by serious viewers wanting to state genuine observations.
You Bangladeshis wouldn't have realised what had hit you during this interview. He said all those things that Arnab Goswami is saying but in a very sweet and nice way.
He is a former diplomat, so he knows how to convey his message.
This gentleman is very smart and very knowledgeable and he’s full of wisdom
It is very rare to see Indian intellectuals talk with reality
He should be advising the RAW
It is now known that the US had tried to convince Sheikh Hasina to allow a US military base on a Bangladesh island. When Sheikh Hasina adamantly refused to give the US that demand then the US went the way it usually does and incited the opposition to bring about the ‘regime’ change. It’s okay to say that Bangladesh as a sovereign independent country can choose which direction to turn but the record clearly shows that friendship with the US is short term and lethal.
Whatever dictator Hasina and his son says the Indian media spread them like holy truth.. She is a pathetic liar and we are tired of her drama.. Besides, explain how the US instigated the student protest.. or how the the US convinced Hasina make terrible order to kill 1000+ innocent people and students and shut down internet for five days straight which led to her collapse?? If that's what the US wanted they could impose sanction after the fraud election and the people would overthrow the Dictator anyway 😅😅
Please get your facts right. St. Martin island is only 3sq KM in area and has no preexisting infrastructure for a base. It’s on the continental shelf and hence the water is very shallow and totally unsuitable for large vessels also the composition of the island is coral and it’s brittle in nature, there are approximately 4000 inhabitants who will have to be relocated, the topography of the island is flat and so there is no natural barrier to catastrophic hurricane that this region experience regularly. Moreover the US has multiple large bases in the region to patrol the strait of Malacca and South China Sea. Therefore all these are simply lies by Hasina
@@Nevermind-z1l how about Donald Lu of the US making 3 visits to Bangladesh to get support for the base on the island? Haven’t you learnt from all the previous US interference in so many countries around the world? Get your head out of your arse.
Very balanced view. Full respect.
How nicely they are discussing. Thanks for sharing your views.
As if HASINA is only the dictator Bangladesh has had..There been worst dictators than her..at least she built the economy..
Just your opinion, facts say different story. She engineered three elections, she killed 300 students. Let alone all the corruption and money laundering, the amount of national debt she created is unprecedented. There were no worse dictator than her.
? Who? Bangladesh became Bangladesh 53 years ago and she was in power for 20 years or about 4 terms😂She grew the economy?Yeah idk if you knew this but that what economies do they grow but it sure does have a dildo in this rear when someone with the rationality of hasina is running the economy.I hope becomes the next pm of India and helps its economy like she did to Bangladesh and before you say you don't need it you already have diplomacy blah blah then why did you wish it upon us?
I don’t understand why India should bend over backwards to help Bangladesh. Most Bangladeshis consider India as their number one enemy. I think India should reciprocate in the same manner.
*Enemies in north Nepal , china*
*Enemies in south Srilanka, Maldives*
*Enemies in east Bangladesh, Myanmar*
*Enemies in west Pakistan, Afghanistan*
India should ask itself why is that
If you think ‘Most Bangladeshis consider India as their number one enemy’ you should’ve suggested to find the reason behind that. Rather you are suggesting hostility. Man believe it or not, people of Bangladesh and India are not enemies, mass people never were enemy to each other. Try to understand why Bangladeshis feel that way towards India, work on the solution. That will be good for both countries.
@@Anderson-f4t6c we know it's china and Pakistani created Islamic ideology only who is playing all this dirty game.... It was India only not any other country who was stand for srilanka during economic crisis.. it was India only who stand for Maldives during crisis.... It was India only who was there for Bangladesh during 1971.... India was always there whenever our neighbour were in crisis wether it was earthquake, COVID, economic crisis.. every time India helps neighbours..I know people are not realising now but they will realise it very soon as people of afganistan and srilanka realised.
@@ou9htreason is Pakistani created Islamic ideology which madrasas and parties like Jamaat-e-Islami , BNP and other Islamist groups which are continuously spreading hate and propaganda against India
@@Anderson-f4t6c This is due to these countries being envious of India.
Excellent talk. Thanks
Positive Talk❤
Please do not underestimate Prof, Yunus. He is just not a Nobel Laureate and all theory. He is a doer. He has implemented his theories of microcredit by establishing huge organizations - Grameen Bank, Grameen Telecom, Grameen Health, and Grameen Education. These organizations provided employment to thousands of people and benefited millions of people in rural Bangladesh. He is responsible for the emancipation of the women of Bangladesh, a very conservative Islamic country. His initiatives are being replicated in many other countries. His current initiative is "Social Business". He is promoting it all over the world. As far as his physical ability is concerned, he has taken responsibility for 27 Departments. He is 84. Now, Jamat is not acceptable to the people of Bangladesh, especially the youth. Please do not scare your people.
Politics and governance are different thing, okay let us see how he performs but his initial statements that he has made with regards to India would not go down well with ordinary Indians and also the Indian govt.
With regards to his achievements I first thought he must be some genius since he has been awarded the Nobel prize.
But then after just digging a little bit deeper found he has cases filed against him in Bangladesh but also the Norwegian Govt was not happy with him. Then saw the documentary from Investigative journalist TOM HEINEMANN on this noble soul called "THE MICRO DEBT" after which got the whole picture about him. He is just a LOAN SHARK who saw business opportunity in fleecing on innocent and poor Bangladeshis that too women by giving them loans on collaterals with high interest rates and made a fortune for himself and diversified into other areas through his DEBT TRAP. There is nothing genius in this to be awarded a Noble prize for. The Chinese too had taken a lesson or two from him and coined their DEBT TRAP DIPLOMACY.
Americans keep giving this peace and noble prize of literature to their useful idiots in order to advance the nefarious American foreign policy objectives.
He is just a stooge for the Americans popped up into picture through this Noble prize, nothing else. A pretty long term investment that the Americans had made in him which is being used now.
Excellent conversation 👍🏻
Best 360 degree analysis about the Bangladesh crisis and road ahead. Very pertinent views.
Well thought conversation by indian friends
Very good discussion. Clearly put across by Ambassador Saran. A good change from listening to some Gunner where it is all boom boom and no Jhnan.
Really pure academically perfect and critical interview
where two intelligent minds share their thoughts on
Geopolitical Perspectives
Excellent Analysis
It just baffles me that we allowed a nation called Bangladesh/east Pakistan to be formed in the first place in 1947, if you look at a map. It is sheer idiocy to maintain that kind of border. 4000 kms , are you kidding me , that too India surrounds Bangladesh on three sides, not to mention they almost cut us off from our north east states.
Because, the then congress leadership didn't have any other choice. The Greater Bengal which had a Muslim majority would have gone to Pakistan. To save at least some part of Bengal for the Hindus, Congress had to demand to divide bengal clubbing together hindu majority districts on one side and Muslim majority districts on the other side. In fact, it was Hindu Mahashava who demanded division of bengal by this religious faultline while Muslim league was demanding Full Bengal to be the part of Pakistan.
@@ds9510 - it was all the British divide and rule who did this , else until then people lived largely ok next to each other
@@ds9510I think he means militarily we should have not allowed this division. We could have always pushed the special population to go to there homeland on west like what happened at other places of india
You guys need to do something about your sound. The intro music is 4x times louder than the interview itself.
Very informative and logical discussion.
I generally don't like Indian diplomats especially the ones dealing with Pakistan because of their obvious love for peace with Pakistan at the expense terrorism in India.
But I have to say I am in awe with this Indian diplomat who has such clarity of thought with regards to the whole gamut of India-Bangladesh relations.
I guess the Bangladeshis wouldn't have realised what had hit them in a very nice and sweet way in this interview.
very intellectual and real informative conversations...watching from Portugal as Bangladeshi... Enjoyed a lot...i thought all indian spreads rumour more than real about Bangladesh but it’s not the case here...❤
Good intelligent conversation.
So no mention of the Jamat and American hand ehh..?
BTW, the asset army just woke up and decided to through Hassina out on that perticular date right... The date has no significance..?
It’s throw Hasina not through 😂😂
Beurocrats & media are careful not to mention america 😂 you know that hurts post career prospects in US.
Good analysis!
brilliant
If the Indian policy makers and foreign affair ministry share similar views as this guy, we Bangladeshis are in the same page.
Nitin Sir, through ur channel I want to request to Our Govt of India to create specialized think-tank to specific important geopolitical nations to serve India's interest with specialized technocrats.
India does not bother what happens in Bangladesh. Don'tt ry to relate your internal hiccups to India. This is how animosity is created.
Saran's good analysis
Interesting analysis anyhow, rational one for both are professional person! Best wishes
Saran didn’t talk about what Hasina did last 15 years and what role was India last 15 years . India always play a role as big brother which Bangladeshi people don’t like.
Your channel sounds logical
Forget about Bangladesh, worry more about the future of India and its integrity.
Only aaptards and dhongressis think this way.
An advice to Nitin Gokhale when you know you have called an expert to your show who is pretty clear in expressing his view then it is very irritating to see when you keep interrupting and disturbing him and his flow of thoughts. We know your also an expert but let the expert guest speak freely and uninterrupted.
It was not nice. Thanks
Thanks for your advice but too late for me to change. It is a chat/interaction not an interview. Get the difference or keep quiet
@@nitingokhale184 that was crass. Anyway your program and your wish
@@AjitKumar-lo9yuindeed it is my programme. Where is the doubt?
💪🇮🇳💪
Md Yunus is a microfinance specialist. No political or administrative experience. His Nobel medal is probably doubtful. He will make the country further poor and cash on poor man's financing without losing his image.
"no political or administrative experience", "noble medal is probably doubtful"😅😅.. say u are a dumb without saying
Here are my two words on your PM.
After just digging a little bit deeper found he has cases filed against him in Bangladesh but also the Norwegian Govt was not happy with him. Then saw the documentary from Investigative journalist TOM HEINEMANN on this noble soul called "THE MICRO DEBT" after which got the whole picture about him. He is just a LOAN SHARK who saw business opportunities in fleecing on innocent and poor Bangladeshis that too women by giving them loans on collaterals with high interest rates and made a fortune for himself and diversified into other areas through his DEBT TRAP. There is nothing genius in this to be awarded a Noble prize for.
So this microfinance is no rocket science there are lakhs of such entity here in India.
Americans keep giving this peace and noble prize of literature to their useful idiots in order to advance the nefarious American foreign policy objectives.
He is just a stooge for the Americans popped up into picture through this Noble prize, nothing else. A pretty long term investment that the Americans had made in him which is being used now.
I believe you guys are one of very rare Indians who acknowledged that Bangladeshi people have their own agency and right to make their decision, all other so called Indian Experts think everything about Bangladesh is geo politics and Bangladeshi people are just audience, no my friend, we dont care about what is going on with India or Pakistan or US, we are owners of our country and we dont want anyone else to make decision for us. Period.
Even, I affraid to be vanished after a while for writting this comment.
what about the forced disappearance, murder and mayhem committed by this fascist leader.
So US and China are fishing in troubled waters and you’re asking India to be hands off?!
Now 80 y/o grandpa from USA is brought in to run Bangladesh 😂😂😂
Are grandpas not eligible to run a country by any law?
@@teenmastrmay be by law but not by security concerning prospective
Hasina is 76 years old. N professor Yunue runs a big Bank in Bangladesh named Grameen Bank .@@LamheZindageeKe
In the very morning of Aug 5, the army of Bangladesh took a decision that they wouldn't able to shoot their own people chest. In terms of the demonstration above 3 million people in the roads of the capital, if army shooted and even instigated somehow, the huge amount of people could die when over thousands of people have been already killed by police and RAB. So, it was a role of Bangladeshi army. They love their country and respect their people's opinion as they evolved and originated from the great liberation war of 1971.
I am a Bangladeshi....And I liked what Mr. Pankaj Saran said.....Very accurate observation and some great advices. Thanks. I really believe that India can help Bangladesh grow. I hope, our Indian brother, sisters will help us to restore democracy, grow together and prosper.....India and Bangladesh would always stay together, I hope. We have the same cultural, history and even appearance. Only our geography is different.
Hindus are being targetted?
@@mylord3003 EVERYONE is being targetted!!! I have a couple of Hindu friends and acquintances. None of them has been assaulted!!!
I am not religious myself. And I am in my fourty. I have seen this 'hindu-muslim' danga propaganda being brought by some selfish groups/institutions, who work for their own agenda of using 'divid-and-rule' technique among all.
After a revolution, there will be problems with law and orders. It is normal. In my country, there are some looting. The looters are muslims and the victims are muslims, too. And may be, some hindus, too.
Both muslims and hindus are affected by the revolution and it is the nature of the revolution around the world. Unfortunately, some political grounds, miscreants, goons are taking advantage of this and spreading propaganda.....
U r one in a million, may u r progressive tribe increase
Any agreement that was created that benefit one side must be evaluated on the basis of benefiting both sides.
As a Bangladeshi i hope India help Bangladesh for Democracy not supporting killers like hasina think about what people
China will help you for democracy....😅
Dear brother, Bangladesh is not in crisis, Bangladesh has overcomed overcome the crisis, the biggest crisis for Bangladesh is the dictatorship of Sheikh Hasina, and disproportionate interference of India in the every sector of Bangladesh. Now Bangladesh turn about and move forward.
Shut up your illiterate mouth Bangladeshi, the "disproportionate" interference is nothing but your stupidity that has no cure.
Stop blaming India for your own inability to govern your own country!
That 'disproportionate interference' is why B'desh grew rapidly economically under Shiekh Hasina... so many infrastructure projects, business opportunities, water concessions and soft loans etc given to B'desh by India... it is fair for India to expect things in return...esp in terms of our security concerns vis-a-vis terrorists sanctuaries, drug and cattle running, space to chinese etc. and also protection to Hindus in B'desh...
If the new dispensation goes back to pre-Hasina policy of B'desh towards India, the net loser will be the people of B'desh... its really the call of the new regime in B'desh now...
@@hkpandey1 just an indian explanation, we the people of Bangladesh are not agree with that, because there is no indian aid is visible in Bangladesh,all we are seeing is onle few suppliers credit loan, you can google it,and will learn.
@@hkpandey1Bro check the facts before you talk. India is not even the in the top 10 donar or investor in Bangladesh. The trade deficit between two countries are completely disproportionate. Okay let’s do one thing ‘Stop give and Take’ let’s see who will be crying.
@@ou9ht Yes, I hope that happens... then we'll see what your broke ass, debt-ridden govt. can do for your people...
also, while your at that, do take back the termites you sent us over the years who're cleaning dishes and washing drains with fake Hindu names and fake aadhar cards in India & living off Indian tax payers money...
Hindus r not being targeted. Stop falling for lies
First of all India should stop behaving to super power,and start respecting its small neighbours,treat them with dignity,when a nation votes for Hindu fundamentalist government in power,who treats it biggest minority as second class citizens,ask the innocent muslim of up, through out bjp states of India their house are bulldozed with any crime,just because of their religion,that nation has no right to lecture other nations on minorities rights,fix your own house first.
What about you, are you big or small
Even if Bangladesh Muslims give half the rights enjoyed by Indian Muslims, Bangladesh Hindus would he very grateful to u.
How many Hindu terrorist exist in Bangladesh and committed bomb blast
I have already watched over 50 videos from Indian analysts insights about Bangladesh current unrest. Unfortunately all of them analysed aggressive way and they simply explained things as if they’re representative of Hasina’s Party Awami League. And they don’t even have 20% of knowledge about Bangladesh socio economic condition. Compare to that Mr Pankaj Saran analysis is much better, liberal, and seems he knows socio-economic conditions and public pulse much better than others.
But one thing misinterpreted in the video about torture on Hindus. Sheikh Hasina ruled Bangladesh for 15 consecutive years as a dictator and her party Awami League men literally controlled and tortured opposition and mass people. Obviously people had anger on them. Some Hindu Awami League Leaders also there and after Hasina departure, all Awami League people came under attack including Majority Muslims and some Hindu Leaders. Whereas non political Hindus are safe and well, rather in most temple now guarded by mass Bangladeshi Muslim people in absence of police.
Also over 1000 people got killed in few week’s long violence in Bangladesh and 99% of them are Muslims, But the way you guys are explaining as if violence intend to Hindus only.
Also Now it's also becoming clear that Awami league paid goon are involved in robbing in local areas.
Fantastic comment! Be vigilant about crucial interest of the Nation, don't let anyone hijack this historic n noble people Revolution for that thousands of students and people sacrifice their lives for the betterment this country! Best wishes
If "non political Hindus" are safe then why are temples being burnt down? You guys don't even have minimum intelligence required to form a cogent argument, and give lectures to us?
@@AbdulKalam-yw3zs Unfortunately almost entire Indian maids started propaganda against Bangladesh. They have no sympathy for over 1000 people who got killed and also no respect towards this student revolution. They’re only highlighting some specific points, which completely based on lies.
Coz politically non-aligned Hindu's n Buddhists and atheists have been attacked all over B'desh in the last 4 days n this has been reported by your news outlets😮
The killing violence is not only being done to minorities,whole countries is suffering from that! We formed squad to safeguard the houses,Mandir,mashjid, business organisation! But some how we guys always focus on one thing ! Students are managing the traffic, cleaning the road! The irregularities is seen everywhere as there is vacuum created by the absence of police force! Criminals are robbing houses at the middle of the night, vandalising.So it's not just minority who suffering..it's everyone.But at the same time common people with the students are doing a commendable job to restore stability! With the newly formed advisory panel we are everything will go back to normalcy. So stop just talking about one side.
PS: it was good and insightful interview! Thoroughly enjoyed it.and you guys earn my respect. Thank you for the interview
But still hindus attacked by mobs and destroying their horses and temples. By the way only 5% to 9% hindus left now. Hopefully it's not going to be another 1971.
Has there been an engineered and structured regime change facilitated by exogenous forces ? If that was indeed the case , what will be the future thrust from those agencies ? What were their investments expected to lead to as lasting returns ? What will be their overt or covert control over the ensuing regime ? That is a critical question people are avoiding to ask since it is not evident who the possible puppeteers are . One remembers what happened post Arab Spring. So it is crucial to grasp the sort of compact that other political forces will have to enter into with the Islamist groupings whch are now international in their reach and ideological convictions. All other discussions are peripheral. This area will become a key geopolitical theater . That is our worry.
The only dictating force playing out in🇧🇩VangaDeysha🇧🇩is⚒️👺☪️👺🪚Hence the culture of Seizure of power by any means is the standard template
Jamaat never got more than 5 percent vote in any election. This guy clearly has no idea what he is talking about. Based on what is he saying Jamaat has more popularity than BNP.
What he is saying Jamat is more organized, modern , educated compared to BNP, who is an emotional party and don't have an institution of democracy within the party, similar to Awami league.
Talking about Jamat helps their agenda. Helps them to establish the presence of Islamic radicals which will provide them some leverage on establishing that extremists are there.
One of the best experts to discuss present Bangladesh situation
Both Mr Saran and Mr Gokhale
as long as India don’t poke its nose to Bangladesh internal matter but friendship
Both country become beneficiaries
Hopefully Bangladeshi government will take all illegal Bangladeshis from our land. They are everywhere now.
What will India gain by poking nose in B'desh affairs😮 you have plenty of things to worry about so we wish all the best to you people
One good realistic discussion which is very rare from India. Take love! ❤
Thanks to mr Pankaj Saran for a balanced assessment on Bangladesh.
Its an iran redux where moderate shah/hasina was overthrown by islamists, funded by foreign agencies. Only difference is iran has oil and bangaldesh has nothing. It's not going to end well.
India's problem is they always predeterminently think that I Awami League is their friend. So consecutively three times a l came into power with the only support from India. India has to come out of this mindset. India has to develop a people to people relationship, Institute of a partishan relationship. It should be a Win-Win situation always. Then only it will be sustainable.
Again Bangladeshi Hindus also think that they are safe in the hand of Awami League. But this is not true. That's why they always support and do Awami League politics. So when thete is a regime change Hindus become easy target not for their religion but for their political viewpoint and allegiance.
This time done with less violence is he blind and deaf over four thousand students was killed by pro India gavorment of hasina it was done with indias help
Dude how is she pro India, why isn't she pro china. You students were trying to violently overthrow her govt and what were you expecting the Govt and police to do, how should they have responded to the violence.
India could have only advised behind closed doors and I am sure the India govt should have done that. As any public statements would have seriously inflamed the atmosphere especially when many Indians work there and Hindu community living there. This would also have serious implications for the Indian govt back home.
Can u remember what happened in gujrat?
Nope😁
In entire discussion one most important factor is ignored ....why and who orchestrated this landslide event. And what is likely play . If it's USA, what is the purpose ? They wish to create unstable territory to keep India & china .
Sensible Analysis of the situation. The geography of India and Bangladesh can not be changed. Both countries need each other. India should build trust with all parties, not with any individual. However, the way other analysts interpret the situation is far from the reality. Thanks, Pankaj Saran
Now an interim govt headed by Mohd. Yunus is in power... India will obviously deal with the present dispensation..India cannot deal with other forces in Bangladesh...same way India was dealing with the Hasina govt when it was in power
Bailing out Bangladesh 😅
The hindus of Bangladesh usually involves with the politics of Awamileague, BNP and so forth. They get economic benefit, political convenience and show power over the years against opposition and even they involve to torture their fello religious community and others. When their political party are thrown out the government, they face political vandalism. It is the reality of the both sides Awamileague and BNP supporters but Indian media and some people project it like the way of communalism. Though it is political vandalism
Weak Bhatat
Too much Talk
No Rrsult
Let me correct your opening statement. The country to our east. Bangladesh is celebrating a new birth after the fall of dictorial regime of Sheikh Hasina. Her demise comes after she decided to violently attack students for a peaceful protest killing more than 300 people in 14 days.
India has been seen to only cared about Hasina as India is hosting a leader who had committed horrif8c crimes against his own people. India to handover Hasina to be charched for crimes committed under her watch and on her own orders. Bangladesh in my believe will submit formal request to India to repatriate Hasina to be charged for crimes against humanity. Bangladesh will not ask India for a bail out but instead it will ask to handover Sheikh Hasina.
First time, I heard two Indian talking very logical talking against Bangladesh. Whoever come to power in Bangladesh, should pay attention 'don't put all eggs in one basket'. We should be careful about right of all Bangladeshi (minority or majority). Thank you both of guys.
What first time? You watch trash on TH-cam all day and blame all Indians lol?
Our foreign currency is drained out to Modi ji through Hasina & Adani and many other ways.
Equation is very simple.
I don't understand why your journalists and diplomats struggle to understand this simple equation.
Please stop sucking Bangladesh.
Enough is enough. Take care.
Plz comment on the Awami league and Hindus being targeted and massacred
Its you indiang always come to Bangladesh to make the Balance, imbalance
Why don’t you talk about your Modi’s Hindu Radicals
India should stop treating this revolution as a revolution that led by jamaat-BNP. That hurt us sharp. We need Indian support and India should stop blindly supporting Hasinas family and Awami League
We very well know this is not a revolution but a Chaos brought in students who were instigated by the BNP and Jamaat.
I am glad that the Bangladesh peace process has begun, and
maybe the military be work in tandem with BNP, and Jamaat-a-Islam,etc
Let us hope that,in a now post -Awami League era, the powers that be could stich together, a cohesive, reliant, resilient and strong government
With due respect to Ms.Hasina, I wish she should have resigned before the 2024 elections,and handed power to her second-in-command in the league
This stratagem would not only be face-saving for her,and keep her as de jure leader
Look, 15 years is a very,very time in politics and Hasina Madam should have taken the call when it sounded.Nobody can stay in politics forever
Hasina's way of thinking is similar to her father's , both were tyrants & mass murderers & Ironically both regimes were thrown out in the same month 😂 . She & modi has destroyed the Ind-BD relationship . An entire generation will now look at Ind as the country which has blindly backed her murderous Regime
The crux of the matter is that all the investment done by india in bangladesh stands SUNK.
You can blame modi for that Blunder , backing a mass murderer & illegal regime . India had good relationship with the dictator/party rather than the people
Jai Hind. India cannot do anything. Let Yunus govern the Umat with his Jamaat allies.
Hindu fundamentalist (BJP) killing all minorities especially Muslim! In India! Shame on you Indian trying to lecture Bangladesh. INDIAN can see & learn from Bangladesh how to protect minorities when they are in crisis! Thousands of people stand guard together.... Protecting minorities.
India should throw out the criminal who committed genocide a vicious Dictator Shekh Hasina. Or arrest her and send back to Bangladesh. Sheltering her in india is putting india and Bangladesh relationship questionable. India should be friends with Bangladeshi nations interests and well being , not be friends with a criminal who destroyed the democracy in Bangladesh and committed genocide and fled .
That's your internal issue. You don't have proper democratic institutions and power is highly centralized. So, in absence of federal structure whoever is in power will always behave as a dictator.
Some of the policy decision contributed to the fall of Hsina government. For example, not signing Tista water sharing treaty even after assurance of several times from Mr. Modi. Secondly , india's objection on a proposed Tista water management and development project with Bangladesh and China joint venture.
Sir the young society of Bangladesh and the minority religious people and a large Muslim population no longer like BNP Awami League and everyone is asking Dr. Md. Yunus to lead the government for five years and a anti communal person like Dr. Muhammad will be the head of the government of Bangladesh.