No no. We are against Pakistan not against Bangladesh. You need to open up your mind. He was NSA, they he must have some intel. Look at the behaviour of your own people and they are abusing India left and right.
@@harshapatil3497 We Bangladeshi are not blind how India supported Hasina and her illegal work. She has done everything against of our country's people. She has killed more than thousands of people just during in protest. She stolen our all kinds of assets
@@mohammadrafsunjani6571 says the guy in whose country a 60 to 70 year lady was gang raped in a bus, women on the Chittagong beach were beaten for wearing reasonable western clothes, where polygamy and child marriage is way of life, wat else dude.🤣🤣🤣🤣
1. Hasina came to power in 2009. Then, 57 military officers were killed and she didn’t punish the murderer. Because, she was a part of it. 2. In 2013, she killed numerous protesters of Hefajate Islam. 3. In 2014, she arranged a one party election. All opposition party boycott that election. 4. She killed numerous political leaders of opposition in the name of judgement and kept them behind bar. 5. She disappeared numerous political opponents in Aynaghar.(Search it) 6. She arranged a night election. All the votes were given at the night before the scheduled date. 7. She and her Ministers sent money to other country. 8. In every press briefing, she ridicule the citizens of Bangladesh. Every time she said it is my father's country. 9. She again arranged a one party election in 2024. People of Bangladesh were eagerly waiting for a chance to bring her down from power. Students of Bangladesh made that dream true. People of Bangladesh hate India, because India helped her to do all these misdeeds and in return India took benefit from Bangladesh. India is in wrong path. They only support a one person and one party in Bangladesh. They never heard the pulse of the people of Bangladesh. We the Bangladeshi urge India to change their policy.
Also, like adani power, india looks for unevn hidden contracts they done with hasina regim, there is no river water solutions. What a hipocracy. India want to see Bangladesh with their colonial tendency. Independence is not expected for Bangladesh. So, Bangladesh is playing with 🔥. In this lacture he never tell about Bangladesh as a neighbors, they can't change it. They need to realize it❤
We are unfortunate to have neighbours like India who is always play tricks with all its neighbouring countries. Nobody like India because of dishonest Indian officials who always keep one hand inside pocket with hidden agenda.
@@MaTara01 No. Sir Dr.M. Yunus is not equel to USA. This is wrong. USA supporting the people of Bangladesh. But india created Hasina as agent of India in Bangladesh. This is why Bangladeshi people showing anger. 😊
Pankaj Saran is now all of a sudden concerned about the legitimacy of the interim government and what mandate they have when for the past three elections he had nothing to say about the fact that the AL had no mandate due to the fact that they stole the elections. SMH
@@HRC294 No. Election of 2009 was free and fair. But then she started her real game. 1. Hasina came to power in 2009. Then, 57 military officers were killed and she didn’t punish the murderer. Because, she was a part of it. 2. In 2013, she killed numerous protesters of Hefajate Islam. 3. In 2014, she arranged a one party election. All opposition party boycott that election. 4. She killed numerous political leaders of opposition in the name of judgement and kept them behind bar. 5. She disappeared numerous political opponents in Aynaghar.(Search it) 6. She arranged a night election. All the votes were given at the night before the scheduled date. 7. She and her Ministers sent money to other country. 8. In every press briefing, she ridicule the citizens of Bangladesh. Every time she said it is my father's country. 9. She again arranged a one party election in 2024. People of Bangladesh were eagerly waiting for a chance to bring her down from power. Students of Bangladesh made that dream true. People of Bangladesh hate India, because India helped her to do all these misdeeds and in return India took benefit from Bangladesh. India is in wrong path. They only support a one person and one party in Bangladesh. They never heard the pulse of the people of Bangladesh. We the Bangladeshi urge India to change their policy.
@@profbfc You don’t have a credible media, all I see is misinformation from Bangladeshi channels about India and Hasina all over Facebook and TH-cam. That’s why I said just google and find out the truth from international media.
@@profbfc He is speaking about Bangladesh from his experience and probably his contacts in Bangladesh. And it is corroborated from news from international agencies.
@@himadrib4743 yeah fact of sanghis, the fact for world to see is that hasina is in india & she was a puppet of modi... she allowed india to use bangladesh as india's colony... she was lifted, allowed by india to fly over it territory & ultimately living in india is testimony that this guy sharan is all gas... nothing on groud...
@@AjitKumar-lo9yu yeah fact of sanghis, the fact for world to see is that hasina is in india & she was a puppet of modi... she allowed india to use bangladesh as india's colony... she was lifted, allowed by india to fly over it territory & ultimately living in india is testimony that this guy sharan is all gas... nothing on groud...
It's such a great pleasure to see when indians are really concerned, which made me feel so good & also firmly put the idea & strength in mind that my country is in the right direction . Go ahead, bangladesh, go ahead Dr. Younus.
If that's your stance then I think the government of India is doing the right thing. The government of India should keep away from Bangladesh and wait till the people in charge come to their senses. Additionally, the people like you should be given enough time and opportunity to rejoice and ponder. It is one thing to show false bravodo and it's another to face the harsh reality of life. There is a recent e.g. of Maldives and its president Mohamed Muizzu.
Bro, they invested on hasina only, not even on the Awami league😅. Poor Awami league goons. All of them are far from coming back to politics.awami league is dead honestly.
I find it difficult to understand why many Indians like Pankaj Saran think India is a global power. It’s important to acknowledge the significant economic gap between China and India-in terms of GDP, GDP per capita, and overall socioeconomic development. This gap is as vast as the difference between the U.S. and Mexico. Despite this disparity, some continue to dream of India becoming a superpower, a goal that seems not noly overly ambitious but also impossible. For example, the GDP per capita in all Indian states bordering Bangladesh are significantly lower than that of Bangladesh itself. In the 2023 Global Hunger Index, India ranks 111th out of the 125 countries, which means a level of hunger that is serious.Additionally, while India is now the most populous country in the world, it still lacks a permanent seat with veto power in the United Nations. Moreover, after the fall of Sheikh Hasina's government in Bangladesh, India has found itself surrounded by anti-Indian governments in its neighboring countries. If India struggles to assert influence in its own region, how can it hope to project power on a global scale? According to UNICEF, a significant portion of India's population still practices open defecation, contributing to environmental pollution and the spread of diseases. Despite its massive population, India's recent Olympic medal counts lack of gold medals, further reflecting its challenges in excelling on the global stage. Lastly, India ranks highest in both legal and illegal immigration, highlighting the poor quality of life that compels many to seek better opportunities abroad.
Yes, India is behind China but Bangladesh doesn't even come close. Whatever economic transformation Bangladesh has achieved is in large part due to India and Hasina.
Remember one thing,as a nation we don’t have any fault line but you have hundreds. You can disturb us for a while but you can’t break us from each other no matter what you do! That’s not fact in your case!
We will see in another 6 to 12 months. Already your Yunus is seeking for his legitimacy by begging for a meeting with Modi which isn't happening 😂😂😂😂😂 And do u think u running to Pakistan or Americans scares India😂😂😂
@@tameenhaque2285 After reading These Bangladeshsi in the comments sections i cannot understand how they not able follow this logical arguments which are not rhetorical at all and are fact based and reason based. It seem the Bangladeshis have been brain washed, i do not think this brainwashing has happened over the last 1, 2 or 5 years. It seems like a pretty long project since 1971 where politicians, the political parties, the intellectuals, the journalists, the newspaper, the anchors, the news channels, the news analyst experts, the elite, the teachers, the professors, the school, colleges and other institutions having been systematically used to build this anti-India narrative. As they say Rome wasn't built in day so does anti-India narrative and of course a kafir Hindus are the unifying force for all Bangladeshis and Pakistanis.
@@tameenhaque2285Ohh Kanglu don't get so jittery 😂😂.. U r pawn played by the great powers.. that's your aukat. Today it's the USA, yesterday was Us, tomorrow it'll be someone else.. That's ur aukat😅😅. Moreover look at our neighbours Pakistan bankrupt US friend, mayanmar bankrupt China friend, Sri Lanka bankrupt in between US, India, China, Maldives bankrupt China friend. Bangladesh is soon to be bankrupt same in between US, India & China friendship axis!! That's your existence certificate now go & bark..
There is no crisis in bangladesh now. We our working hard to restore the democracy and the rule of laws. All the state Machineries were destroyed , economy was destroyed by taking mega loans to build unproductive mega projects, corruption skyrocketing, inflation skyrocketing, and the consequences are visible now. We are requesting India to understand the pains we gone through the fascist rules of Hasina.
The “rivalry” between Hasina and Yunus has been one-way and one-sided and there has only been one victim. She brought to bear the full power of the state to sate her demented vendetta against him and everyone knows -except apparently Pankaj Saran who god help us was ambassador in BD! - of the two, who was the aggressor and who was the victim.
Currently Yunus is the opportunist and the aggressor, hoisting cases after cases on Hasina and pardoning himself from the various cases that were booked against him by first sacking the chief justice and the prosecutor. I hope the Bangladeshis doesn't consider him to be another prophet.
You don’t know what you’re talking about. The cases against him were laughable. Hasina meanwhile is implicated in the deaths of 100s during the July/August uprising. As for the judiciary, it had been politicized and hollowed out and filled with sycophants and lackeys by Hasina for over a decade, whereas the current CJ is widely recognized to be the country’s top jurist with a global reputation for ability and integrity.
@AjitKumar-lo9yu then 2006 Care taker government under Fakruddin had legitimacy too? Oh, my bad because under him Hasina came to power eh? No question in that.
80 years old Mr.younus conducted 40 highest levels of bilateral meetings in 4 days, this is a world record. I also expressing my gratitude to Modi who didn't let Mr.Younuses hand dirty by shaking hand with him
No benefit crying and lying anymore. You lost Bangladesh to Bangladeshis. There is still time to rebuild the relationship between two countries. The relationship should be built upon fairness. India should leave exploiting mentality behind.
@@MaTara01 Exploitation isn’t just about taking natural resources; it’s about controlling access and influencing economic decisions without direct intervention. India has been exploiting its neighbors through various means, like manipulating transboundary rivers, which affects millions dependent on them downstream. Bangladesh is a prime example-Tangail sarees, originally from Bangladesh, are now being marketed as Indian. The rail corridor was given to India at the cheapest rates, and the Mongla port is essentially handed over, benefiting India more than Bangladesh. If you think this isn’t exploitation, then nationalism might be blinding you to the real power dynamics at play.
You see the hopelessness in his words as if India lost it colony in Bangladesh. Bangladesh is now liberated from Fasist regime and at the same its foreign enbaler.
He served as the Indian High commissioner to Bangladesh during the Hasina regime- played a manifested role in keeping the government in power through voterless national elections. No wonder he will explain about a sanguinary people uprise like this keeping blind eyes. This is by what India distanced itself from the Bangladeshi people on and on.
You all are playing with fire my friend.... Don't push the patience of India or you will regret every bit of it. Don't forgot India is going to be third most powerful country by 2027 economically.
@@SubhaThree-w8w india has been pushing patience of all its neighbours, now pakistan bangladesh nepal bhutan srilanka myanmar maldives afghanistan etc need to form a NATO like alliance against upper caste imperialist emanating from india...
Amb . Saran, you have been a high commissioner of India to Bangladesh for a number of years. Unfortunately , you never learned or wanted to learn about the Bengali culture-distinct from the West Bengal , social and political moorings. You always worked from the selfish India’s perspective and not what the Bangladeshis want. In this interview You have delivered a narrative which is full of falsehood, misleading and evading the truth. In fact from 2009 to 05 august 2024, before Hasina fled to her sanctuary in India, it was literally India , which ran Bangladesh through its stooge Hasina. Though there is adequate skepticism , the 2008 election was generally accepted by the people as fare. But when it comes to the elections of 2014 , 2018 and 2024 , you may duck your head in the sand, but the truth is , if it was not India directly interfering or supporting Hasina nakedly, she would have never won those three elections. The brutal and fascist rule that Hasina ran in the country, would have never happened if she wasn’t emboldened by her conviction that India would support her to the hilt. For instance , the late president Pranab Mukherjee once threatened to send indian troops to Bangladesh , in the event of any threat to Hasina’s life. Was it any of his business ? As high commissioner it was your duty to find out the core reasons for incremental rise of anti India sentiments. You should have also mentioned Hasina’s corrupt practices , laundering of money by herself , her family members and cronies and other crimes against humanity she committed. I remember your attitude towards this country, when i once asked you to pay some attention to the killings of the unarmed and innocent Bangladeshi citizens in the border areas by the BSF. And, you rudely brushed aside my concern, displaying your arrogance.If you are honest , please provide a list of what Bangladesh gained and what India gained out of the so-called “ golden relationship between India and Bangladesh”. No doubt it was diamond for India but for Bangladesh it got only empty promises. Hasina had once infamously declared that “what I have given to India it will never forget”. Let’s see your government make such a bold statement with facts and figures. Mr. Saran , i will advise you to refrain from lecturing us. Bangladeshis are tremendously resilient people and we have throughout our history have successfully surmounted any adversities-manmade or natural.please leave us to our fate. Thanks for reading, if at all you will.
By saying what he said shows his parochial attitude towards Bangladeshi people. India's stooge was Hasina who was an illegal ruler based on 3 farcical elections. If those had been fair, she would have lost all of them. It would be prudent for people like this person not to pretend that he knows all the answers to the current reality. All Indians toe the BJP line of thinking!
Why wouldn't India have a parochial attitude, you came into being because of India, in spite of 50 years of independence you still have been unable to write a proper constitution or able to build a proper institute of repute, you are all flabbergasted by one Yunus who got so called peace prize for being an American stooge, your opposition is constantly fighting among themselves by being either in approval or disapproval of India. Now you expect India to build your infrastructure and capacity and give aid through which you will buy weapons from Pakistan and if we protest or take a preventive action you call it parochial. Seriously dude.
Dude , u better think about ur own country & seven sisters as they r already in fire !!! Poor ass , can't handle own country's unrest , came here to give opinion others on how to be on right path thru history & wisdom .
No one is saying that anyone told Hasina how to govern. What a straw man argument. The beef Bangladeshis have with India is that India backed her to the hilt and thus shielded her from the consequences (electoral defeat) of her misrule.
India was always first to recognize the bogus elections and lobbied strongly with the rest of the international community to have them accepted. This is not controversial.
Why are we blamed for this? Every country in a position of influence will lobby for their choice of government. We have the american congress meeting our opposition leaders. This happens everywhere in the world. This is exactly what Saran is pointing out. You need stronger institutions. Why didn't your opposition parties go out to the world and build loyalties. Politics is dirty. We are not spewing hatred online against the Americans because they met our opposition leaders. There is a certain level of decorum that states need to maintain between them. The amount of hatred I have seen from Bangladeshi society and the gov officials is insane. But Indian officials have only been quiet and mature and not indulging in this microphone diplomacy.
What a joke that Hasina was democratically elected! She was actually an agent of India, and you people have done everything to keep her in power. In 2014, all political parties boycotted the one-sided election, and your external affairs secretary herself visited BD and forced a particular party to join the polls, so that it seems participatory. Since then, Hasina rigged every election, and her only enabler was India. Now, India has gone mad as its agent has been kicked out by the brave Bangladeshis.. We love India and its people.But please don't try to snatch our right to elect our leaders, and don't try to set your agent here again. Also, change your foreign policy, since it is the worst one a nation can have.With this policy, you are setting all neighbours in your confrontation..
Dude were u unable to comprehend that this former ambassador said in this 40 minutes long interview in which he was very carefully choosing his words while expressing himself. How is India going to endorse an election in Bangladesh, if it were to support your opposition then will Hasina not blame India for political interference. How can you absolve china in all this just because ordinary chinese hardly care about you. Was Hasina not playing the Chinese against India and getting the best for her country.
Why wouldn't India have a parochial attitude, you came into being because of India, in spite of 50 years of independence you still have been unable to write a proper constitution or able to build a proper institute of repute, you are all flabbergasted by one Yunus who got so called peace prize for being an American stooge, your opposition is constantly fighting among themselves by being either in approval or disapproval of India. Now you expect India to build your infrastructure and capacity and give aid through which you will buy weapons from Pakistan and if we protest or take a preventive action you call it parochial. Seriously dude.
@@AjitKumar-lo9yu Why does India talk so much about our country? Do we talk about India? We will see the good and bad of our country, there is no need to talk about India.
Pankaj you are a broker of dictator Hasina. But you know Hasina's place is not possible in Bangladesh right now. At the same time India is the top first enemy in every general person in Bangladesh. I also warn that India is playing with fire.
But India did place all its eggs in the Hasina basket. That’s why they went to the mat to defend her. And yes India will deal with whoever the government in power is, but it’s not happy about it, and that is crystal clear.
How India put eggs in Hasina basket? Was India issuing visas to only Awami League members? If she is the PM, should India deal with Khaleda Zia, who hates India?
Economic Times cares so much about accuracy in their Bangladesh coverage that they can’t even be bothered to spell Hasina or Yunus’s name right. Tells you a lot right there.
Hmmm, and which West Pakistani broker have said this as* hole? The real thing is west Pakistani DNA like you are now having great desire to make Bangladesh Pakistan again 😂
@@shubhajitbiswas9990 Maybe but they are still not out of crisis, maybe the tail end. Give them time they are a smart nation they can manage. Just look at the team at the top, they have the brightest of their lot, surely these young experts brought from all over the world will take Bangladesh forward and very soon. India ought to help them not criticize them.
@@shubhajitbiswas9990 The Hindu claims UpTo 600 people died. Surely India has helped Bangladesh progress in last 15 years but there seems to be some resentment among the people on various issues which is not a big thing among neighbors.
@@xpsmango4146 every things are narrative game. Hasina was dictators . Is yonis elected? Is he was part of the student protest?. No , not directly. How many terrorists are freed from the jail after 5th aug? 50% of now ministers are NGO person ,all funded by USA.
Sir Saran, pl be realistic and neutral.Yours is just anti Bangla desh speculate rhetoric post Hasina.Why such rhetoric was absent during Hasina as Ruler?Because, she was a Vassal of India?
You gave example of Sealed Pakistan border and linked their financial crisis with it. Why dont you think about the border with China?? Thats also sealed and they are way ahead of you 😂😂😂😂
Bloated frogs croaking against the huge neighbour elephant with hunting eagle money... also Begging daily for food energy cotton machine fertilizer oil medicine from elephant... Begging wheat from grizzly bear and begging for money from fiery dragon... Waiting for all players in geopolitical chessboard...
Why doesn't he talk about all the money that was being siphoned out the country? A sitting minster owning 350 plus property in UK. Hasina and her goons were leaches.
To Saran it's a clear message from the people of Bangladesh, Seven Sisters, Kashmir that, ' Kursi ke peti bandh lejiye, Kyo ki mausam bigarne wala hain'. Loud and clear.
It is not Bangladesh who is against Indian dictatorship in South Asia rather it's all the neighbours who do the same. Hate india fearlessly. Then we will have to understand that the problem is not in us. The problem is in India. So stop spreading lies and pripaganda and work on your mistakes to rebuild the future relation.
I feel compelled to express my thoughts on the matter. The true nature of Indian diplomats is evident; if they believe that Bangladesh is heading towards significant difficulties, it may indeed be the correct course of action for us. I encourage everyone to read all the comments.
I generally don't like Indian diplomats especially the ones dealing with Pakistan because of their obvious love for peace with Pakistan at the expense terrorism in India. But I have to say I am in awe with this Indian diplomat who has such clarity of thought and choosing of words with regards to the whole gamut of India-East Pakistan relations. Also with regards to what is really unfolding in East Pakistan. I guess the East Pakistanis wouldn't have realised what had hit them in a very nice and sweet way in this interview.
"Bangladesh historically has always had external forces at work inside the country" Finally, someone admitted it. This external force is mainly RAW. Since independence, RAW involved in Bangladesh politics and they always tried their best to enact India's interest in Bangladesh by any means. Result, in every political assassination, RAW's involvement was obvious. Finally RAW came up to set an pro-indian government in Bangladesh to ensure direct Indian control depriving voters voting right. After topple of Hasina resim, they are still active in Bangladesh to creates unrest politically and economically. All those activities of RAW backfired and only earned hatred from the mass population of Bangladesh
There is nothing uncommon between you East Pakistanis and West Pakistanis which is that there is always a conspiracy against you guys by the Kafir Hindus and Jews.
@1008apocalypse1008 that less than billion busk dues no matter at all, within December 31st you will clear Adani's all deus. After that request Adani to review the agreement and stop selling electricity @Taka 14/KwH. Adani simply plundering in the name of electricity export to Bangladesh
@@Saif1971ify dude that extra money was pocketed by your people who were in govt that is how international deal work. Do not tell me that the Chinese haven't paid any corruption money and u don't have a problem if the Chinese have done that
we are unique in the world. Don’t dare to threat us. We are maybe less in numbers but we will die to defend our country and will raise our Army in our shoulders.
People of Bangladesh know you very well and what happened in 2008 election. India misundstand us last 400 years . What ever you do we just watch . We have faith on Allah and how we finished her with the help of Allah Hasina is an example. She is now like a symbol of victory and fall. Hope Mr Soren personaly read the comment.
We are 95% Bangladeshi anti-Indian, find out why anti-Indian first. Then you will come out of them. If you do not do these things and continue to make the same mistakes as before, then your loss will be great. It's not good to think so much !!
I am from Bangladesh. And I am totally broken to see that how my country has been fallen into failed state. Economy and other stuffs have been destroyed totally
Pankaj is right,external forces working in Bangladesh but only when Hasina is in power and only external forces is Indian Raw. Everyone seen on news on the day hasina fall all Indian police running at the Dhaka airport tarmac got the flight back to India. They was carrying weapons and uniform on.
Regarding trade deficit , it’s true that Bangladesh has huge trade deficits with China . However, china doesn’t impose tariff and non-tariff barriers for Bangladeshi goods , that India does. Unfortunately, India wants uninterrupted flow of their goods to bd ,not other way round.
India as a model country of democracy should work with people of Bangladesh but not any chosen leader! We all are aware of what’s going on in here and who are the players behind! ❤
India's interests and unjust role ignites the fire that forces Bangladesh to play with it. It is unpredictable how the fire might engulf the whole region. Bangladesh might be burned up but the heat wave won't spare the region of interest for other regional and international powers.
Pankaj saran did not highlight Indian role in 2014 election. It is very open how Sujata Sing (Indian foreign seccretary at that time) came to Bangladesh and forced H M Ershad to participate in that election to make the election legitimate. H M Ershad opened it in the media before his exipre.
We are not saying India should interfere in our politics. But we was wanted from India to talk about democracy and human rights. Supporting a dictator for short term benefit doesn’t make sense.
Indian army ko russia ke jaisa aattack karke chaattgaon oe chiken neck ko elephant neck mei change kar lena chayie nahi yo aage jake bohut problem create hone wala hai.
Yes, they will understand peace with India is a dividend and force multiplier for their country and emity with India will only drain their economy from spending on the peoples well being to boosting their defence until unless known beggar Pakistan is funding their projects. But India need not invest any further in this relationship as nothing will change their mind and allegiance to ummah.
His narrative is aligned with his training as a diplomat. Indian involvement started from 2014 onwards. Hasina had no other choice but to dance with the puppeteer, the criminal Hasina received immoral support from Modi even though they knew the last three elections she rigged like a pirate in the high seas. The high commissioner, I am sure, was not comfortable to shove her around by the directives of Delhi. The people of Bangladesh naturally did realize Hasina's compromising attitude towards "Big Brother" India. India heavily relied on RAW, a rotten organization. Like her father, Sk. Mujib, Hasina was involved in conspiracy herself against the people of Bangladesh. Fascist Hasina will remain in a foreign soil but unlike her father, she will not have a final resting place in Bangladesh. KARMA.
So many things he said is factually and fundamentally wrong. I wish I had the patience to be a keyboard warrior and write an essay on the incorrect statements he made. No wonder the anti indian sentiment in Bangladesh is so strong here.
Dude this guy is not politician and he was a former Indian ambassador to East Pakistan and also former Deputy National Security Advisor, the same post that Ajit Doval holds presently except he was deputy. I can understand that the truth can be bitter but certainly it can't blind you from reality. The fact is that you have nothing to counter whatever has been said by this gentleman.
Excellent analysis of the story... But the nehruvian diplomatic conversation does not work with radical mentality beggars either east or west... It works with highly educated skilled societies.
From the comments it seems many in Bangladesh feel that India was asking BNP to not participate in elections. It would be interesting to see if BNP or AL or both decide not to participate in the next elections, will Bangladeshis still blame India for it? And if India engages with a BNP government post elections in which AL doesn't participate, will Bangladeshis be still be complaining? Will such a govt. Legitimate or illegitimate?
US - Yunus connection Vs India - Hasina connection is not same. India kept its eyes closed, if not supported the killings, abductions, illegal imprisonment of her political oppositios by Hasina. While there is no such example that US is encouraging Yunus to indulge in such activities. That's why we Bangladeshis blame India for all our miseries that we suffered during Hasina's rule.
Modi never fired a bullet at any protestor at any point of time. I wonder why he would recommend that to Hasina. It's mostly the crooked BD army and US backed bureaucrats
This 2 great jockers are presening a comedy show here with misinterpretation ragding Bangladesh politics. This is totally waste of time for all Bangladeshis.😁😁😁
India should cautiously choose their viewpoint. Because this time it is not ISI backed government in Bangladesh like in 2001. It is USA with Pentagon has significant influence on it! India can't afford to play a proxy war in Bangladesh with USA where a vulnerable porous border exist! India is not united even 90 years ago. US can break into pieces again if India try to stand equal with USA!
Do you agree that sudden fall of Hasina government was fairly avoidable had the otherwise legitimate demand of the students been addressed in right time? After all preservation of 56% of the jobs in public services for special category of the people leaving only 44% for general students is blatantly unjust.
Why should Bangladesh be in big trouble if Bangladesh gets anti India? Nepal was in the grips of India. Now Nepal kicked out India and sided with China. Nepal at one time theathen India with war. So why was Nepal not in trouble for becoming Anti India? Can you explain?
@@Abhinav-ut5zd we are muslims and we fear none but Allah. Also we know about the prophecy of gajwa e hind which will happen probably the way your hindutva regime is operating sooner than later. If I were you, I would be much more careful making arrogant comments about a neighboring country where states of my own country is fighting for freedom, be it in manipur, khalistan, kashmir, assam or arunachal! The day you people think of dismantling our existence will in shaa Allah be the day when the beginning of your end starts.
Hasina, Democratically elected?? If this is ur understanding thn, accept facts lyk- ✅ Monipur is new Afghanistan & ✅ India is being ruled by a religious extremist party BJP.
Bangladesh needs to focus on Bangladeshi interests and not indian interests (Plus it is crucial those in Bangladesh working for indian interests be found and removed from any power they have).
It is worth considering the following-a sort of cross-section of Bangladesh's current landscape from a political and diplomatic standpoint. While it is clear that political motives have played a role in shaping the prevailing narrative, the facts remain largely aligned with the broader realities on the ground.
A good overview of post Hasina Bangladesh from a past Indian High Commissioner from his own perspectives. Ambassador Saran spoken to a select gathering in Dhaka prior to BD election 2024 clearly favouring Hasina’s retaining Power under Bangladesh system of Democray! Now see the outcomes of her three such elections! What legacy she left behind. A series of mega projects burden with astonomical foreign loans beyond paying capacity, a shattered Administration, Corrupt Police system, worst Human Rights Record, bankrupt Banks, low Foreign Exchange Reserves, a thousand dead bodies, a few thousands bullet hit wounded! High Commissioner rightly said a few millions visit India per year. That's people to people connection but that percrption receding past undet Hasina because India supports her continuation with false & fabricated Elections for the third term. India obtained several corridors over Bangladesh to NE States without any visible solution to Teesta & other Rivers, anti dumping on Jute & jute goods, border killings. Perception in Dhaka Hasina gave up without any reciprocal benefit for Bangladesh just to hang on with Indian support. India needed to understand internal dynamics of change without blaming Nobel Laureate Yunus, Jamat or BNP. Delhi should help stabilise situation for her own longterm positive relationship with Dhaka. Hindu community in Bangladesh is much better than Muslims in India under BJP. Let it be our internal issue as good as Muslims are India's. Ambassador M.Shafiullah Mobile no 01817009095
When India is saying something negative about Bangladesh. That's mean Bangladesh are in right path ❤
No no. We are against Pakistan not against Bangladesh. You need to open up your mind. He was NSA, they he must have some intel. Look at the behaviour of your own people and they are abusing India left and right.
@@harshapatil3497 We Bangladeshi are not blind how India supported Hasina and her illegal work. She has done everything against of our country's people. She has killed more than thousands of people just during in protest. She stolen our all kinds of assets
You mean pogroms against Hindus?
Right
Right. Chaw wala moradabad
When your title say Hasina was democratically elected, then I understand that your report is just a joke
Joke is your banana republic to the world who is confusing mobocracy with democracy.😂😂😂😂
@@AjitKumar-lo9yu says the guy who cant get his law on women straight for last god knows how long.
@@mohammadrafsunjani6571 says the guy in whose country a 60 to 70 year lady was gang raped in a bus, women on the Chittagong beach were beaten for wearing reasonable western clothes, where polygamy and child marriage is way of life, wat else dude.🤣🤣🤣🤣
😂🎉😅😊
They knew everything !!
1. Hasina came to power in 2009. Then, 57 military officers were killed and she didn’t punish the murderer. Because, she was a part of it.
2. In 2013, she killed numerous protesters of Hefajate Islam.
3. In 2014, she arranged a one party election. All opposition party boycott that election.
4. She killed numerous political leaders of opposition in the name of judgement and kept them behind bar.
5. She disappeared numerous political opponents in Aynaghar.(Search it)
6. She arranged a night election. All the votes were given at the night before the scheduled date.
7. She and her Ministers sent money to other country.
8. In every press briefing, she ridicule the citizens of Bangladesh. Every time she said it is my father's country.
9. She again arranged a one party election in 2024.
People of Bangladesh were eagerly waiting for a chance to bring her down from power. Students of Bangladesh made that dream true.
People of Bangladesh hate India, because India helped her to do all these misdeeds and in return India took benefit from Bangladesh. India is in wrong path. They only support a one person and one party in Bangladesh. They never heard the pulse of the people of Bangladesh. We the Bangladeshi urge India to change their policy.
Absolutely spotted.
❤️❤️❤️
Also, like adani power, india looks for unevn hidden contracts they done with hasina regim, there is no river water solutions. What a hipocracy. India want to see Bangladesh with their colonial tendency. Independence is not expected for Bangladesh. So, Bangladesh is playing with 🔥. In this lacture he never tell about Bangladesh as a neighbors, they can't change it. They need to realize it❤
We are unfortunate to have neighbours like India who is always play tricks with all its neighbouring countries. Nobody like India because of dishonest Indian officials who always keep one hand inside pocket with hidden agenda.
Clearly you aren't listening to Amb. Saran. If Hasina is equal to India, then Yunus is equal to USA.
@@MaTara01 No. Sir Dr.M. Yunus is not equel to USA. This is wrong. USA supporting the people of Bangladesh. But india created Hasina as agent of India in Bangladesh. This is why Bangladeshi people showing anger. 😊
Pankaj Saran is now all of a sudden concerned about the legitimacy of the interim government and what mandate they have when for the past three elections he had nothing to say about the fact that the AL had no mandate due to the fact that they stole the elections. SMH
2009 was stolen as well?
@@HRC294
No. Election of 2009 was free and fair. But then she started her real game.
1. Hasina came to power in 2009. Then, 57 military officers were killed and she didn’t punish the murderer. Because, she was a part of it.
2. In 2013, she killed numerous protesters of Hefajate Islam.
3. In 2014, she arranged a one party election. All opposition party boycott that election.
4. She killed numerous political leaders of opposition in the name of judgement and kept them behind bar.
5. She disappeared numerous political opponents in Aynaghar.(Search it)
6. She arranged a night election. All the votes were given at the night before the scheduled date.
7. She and her Ministers sent money to other country.
8. In every press briefing, she ridicule the citizens of Bangladesh. Every time she said it is my father's country.
9. She again arranged a one party election in 2024.
People of Bangladesh were eagerly waiting for a chance to bring her down from power. Students of Bangladesh made that dream true.
People of Bangladesh hate India, because India helped her to do all these misdeeds and in return India took benefit from Bangladesh. India is in wrong path. They only support a one person and one party in Bangladesh. They never heard the pulse of the people of Bangladesh. We the Bangladeshi urge India to change their policy.
No. Who said it was? I actually reported on the 2008 election so know a little something about it. But the 2014, 2018 and 2024 elections were.
Bangladesh is going pakistan ways best wishes to Bangladesh
In your dream brother, Bangladesh is not going to be Pakistan, nor INDIA
Indian propaganda goes on and on and on . . .
Complete lies and propaganda. Economist please fact check his statements, its crazy all these lies!!!
Just google and find out. He spoke with facts.
@@himadrib4743 Google what? He is speaking about bangladesh without even being here, I live here and I am baffled at the lies and misinformation
@@profbfc You don’t have a credible media, all I see is misinformation from Bangladeshi channels about India and Hasina all over Facebook and TH-cam.
That’s why I said just google and find out the truth from international media.
@@profbfc He is speaking about Bangladesh from his experience and probably his contacts in Bangladesh. And it is corroborated from news from international agencies.
@@himadrib4743 yeah fact of sanghis, the fact for world to see is that hasina is in india & she was a puppet of modi... she allowed india to use bangladesh as india's colony... she was lifted, allowed by india to fly over it territory & ultimately living in india is testimony that this guy sharan is all gas... nothing on groud...
This 40 minute long interview is filled with ignorance and nothing else. This is all I can say from a neutral Bangladeshi perspective.
Truth when told straight without any sugar coating is bitter and hard to accept
@@AjitKumar-lo9yu yeah fact of sanghis, the fact for world to see is that hasina is in india & she was a puppet of modi... she allowed india to use bangladesh as india's colony... she was lifted, allowed by india to fly over it territory & ultimately living in india is testimony that this guy sharan is all gas... nothing on groud...
Which part is ignorance?
@@BiswaDas-z4d the whole 40 mins
U r not neutral, you are under bnp jamat or anti Awami League
It's such a great pleasure to see when indians are really concerned, which made me feel so good & also firmly put the idea & strength in mind that my country is in the right direction . Go ahead, bangladesh, go ahead Dr. Younus.
With great pleasure you'll also see the decline of Bangladesh slowly and steadily just like your twin brother Pakistan.
Time will tell which direction Bangladesh will move
If that's your stance then I think the government of India is doing the right thing. The government of India should keep away from Bangladesh and wait till the people in charge come to their senses. Additionally, the people like you should be given enough time and opportunity to rejoice and ponder. It is one thing to show false bravodo and it's another to face the harsh reality of life. There is a recent e.g. of Maldives and its president Mohamed Muizzu.
Why indian south block does not have foreign policy other than sheikh hasina,hasina does not mean whole bd,such a shame😂
Listen to the interview again carefully and you will understand Why.
Shame on you all ..@@AjitKumar-lo9yu
@@sayafshaki6724 They just want to fulfil their agenda at any cost!!
71 pak army breed u
Bro, they invested on hasina only, not even on the Awami league😅. Poor Awami league goons. All of them are far from coming back to politics.awami league is dead honestly.
I find it difficult to understand why many Indians like Pankaj Saran think India is a global power. It’s important to acknowledge the significant economic gap between China and India-in terms of GDP, GDP per capita, and overall socioeconomic development. This gap is as vast as the difference between the U.S. and Mexico. Despite this disparity, some continue to dream of India becoming a superpower, a goal that seems not noly overly ambitious but also impossible.
For example, the GDP per capita in all Indian states bordering Bangladesh are significantly lower than that of Bangladesh itself. In the 2023 Global Hunger Index, India ranks 111th out of the 125 countries, which means a level of hunger that is serious.Additionally, while India is now the most populous country in the world, it still lacks a permanent seat with veto power in the United Nations.
Moreover, after the fall of Sheikh Hasina's government in Bangladesh, India has found itself surrounded by anti-Indian governments in its neighboring countries. If India struggles to assert influence in its own region, how can it hope to project power on a global scale?
According to UNICEF, a significant portion of India's population still practices open defecation, contributing to environmental pollution and the spread of diseases. Despite its massive population, India's recent Olympic medal counts lack of gold medals, further reflecting its challenges in excelling on the global stage.
Lastly, India ranks highest in both legal and illegal immigration, highlighting the poor quality of life that compels many to seek better opportunities abroad.
Good point
Very well said
Folly of India's leaders is that they think it's a big power, but a very poor one, they talk of 3rd biggest economy, but again a poor country
Yes, India is behind China but Bangladesh doesn't even come close. Whatever economic transformation Bangladesh has achieved is in large part due to India and Hasina.
I don’t understand why Bangladeshis are so interested in Indian channels on TH-cam
Remember one thing,as a nation we don’t have any fault line but you have hundreds. You can disturb us for a while but you can’t break us from each other no matter what you do! That’s not fact in your case!
You have been broken twice over since 1947! 😂
Fantastic … that should make you super happy .. Enjoy
You are confusing democratic politics with 'fault lines'. 😅
With such experts, no wonder indian diplomacy failed in all of its neighbours
We will see in another 6 to 12 months. Already your Yunus is seeking for his legitimacy by begging for a meeting with Modi which isn't happening 😂😂😂😂😂
And do u think u running to Pakistan or Americans scares India😂😂😂
@@AjitKumar-lo9yuyou are repeating what funkuj already said.
With this mindset, no wonder you guys gonna get surprise slaps.
@@tameenhaque2285 After reading These Bangladeshsi in the comments sections i cannot understand how they not able follow this logical arguments which are not rhetorical at all and are fact based and reason based.
It seem the Bangladeshis have been brain washed, i do not think this brainwashing has happened over the last 1, 2 or 5 years. It seems like a pretty long project since 1971 where politicians, the political parties, the intellectuals, the journalists, the newspaper, the anchors, the news channels, the news analyst experts, the elite, the teachers, the professors, the school, colleges and other institutions having been systematically used to build this anti-India narrative. As they say Rome wasn't built in day so does anti-India narrative and of course a kafir Hindus are the unifying force for all Bangladeshis and Pakistanis.
@@tameenhaque2285Ohh Kanglu don't get so jittery 😂😂.. U r pawn played by the great powers.. that's your aukat. Today it's the USA, yesterday was Us, tomorrow it'll be someone else.. That's ur aukat😅😅. Moreover look at our neighbours Pakistan bankrupt US friend, mayanmar bankrupt China friend, Sri Lanka bankrupt in between US, India, China, Maldives bankrupt China friend. Bangladesh is soon to be bankrupt same in between US, India & China friendship axis!! That's your existence certificate now go & bark..
India has a bunch of shitty neighbours .. that’s the problem
Poor Mr Saran
Poor Bangladeshis, getting exposed isn't really nice thing
@@AjitKumar-lo9yu
There is no crisis in bangladesh now. We our working hard to restore the democracy and the rule of laws. All the state Machineries were destroyed , economy was destroyed by taking mega loans to build unproductive mega projects, corruption skyrocketing, inflation skyrocketing, and the consequences are visible now. We are requesting India to understand the pains we gone through the fascist rules of Hasina.
I think, I think, I think..... but you don't know
The “rivalry” between Hasina and Yunus has been one-way and one-sided and there has only been one victim. She brought to bear the full power of the state to sate her demented vendetta against him and everyone knows -except apparently Pankaj Saran who god help us was ambassador in BD! - of the two, who was the aggressor and who was the victim.
Currently Yunus is the opportunist and the aggressor, hoisting cases after cases on Hasina and pardoning himself from the various cases that were booked against him by first sacking the chief justice and the prosecutor. I hope the Bangladeshis doesn't consider him to be another prophet.
Yunus is a US puppet, US was against Bangladesh liberation. Hasina knew that his intentions are not good.
You don’t know what you’re talking about. The cases against him were laughable. Hasina meanwhile is implicated in the deaths of 100s during the July/August uprising. As for the judiciary, it had been politicized and hollowed out and filled with sycophants and lackeys by Hasina for over a decade, whereas the current CJ is widely recognized to be the country’s top jurist with a global reputation for ability and integrity.
@@zafarsobhan9191so was your previous chief justice Mr Sinha who stated that Yunus' appointment has no constitutional validity
@AjitKumar-lo9yu then 2006 Care taker government under Fakruddin had legitimacy too?
Oh, my bad because under him Hasina came to power eh?
No question in that.
80 years old Mr.younus conducted 40 highest levels of bilateral meetings in 4 days, this is a world record. I also expressing my gratitude to Modi who didn't let Mr.Younuses hand dirty by shaking hand with him
No benefit crying and lying anymore. You lost Bangladesh to Bangladeshis. There is still time to rebuild the relationship between two countries. The relationship should be built upon fairness. India should leave exploiting mentality behind.
@@raykh1086 very wisely thought.
There's nothing there in Bangladesh to exploit! It's a resource poor country, that was the global symbol for poverty a decade or so ago!
Bangladesh will become East Pakistan and thereby heading to, what Henry Kissinger said, an international basket case.
@@MaTara01 Exploitation isn’t just about taking natural resources; it’s about controlling access and influencing economic decisions without direct intervention. India has been exploiting its neighbors through various means, like manipulating transboundary rivers, which affects millions dependent on them downstream. Bangladesh is a prime example-Tangail sarees, originally from Bangladesh, are now being marketed as Indian. The rail corridor was given to India at the cheapest rates, and the Mongla port is essentially handed over, benefiting India more than Bangladesh. If you think this isn’t exploitation, then nationalism might be blinding you to the real power dynamics at play.
@@sashinair1545 dream on
You see the hopelessness in his words as if India lost it colony in Bangladesh. Bangladesh is now liberated from Fasist regime and at the same its foreign enbaler.
Never heard of a colony progressing and prospering at par with the colonialist. Lol😅
He served as the Indian High commissioner to Bangladesh during the Hasina regime- played a manifested role in keeping the government in power through voterless national elections.
No wonder he will explain about a sanguinary people uprise like this keeping blind eyes.
This is by what India distanced itself from the Bangladeshi people on and on.
India is playing with fire 🔥
You all are playing with fire my friend.... Don't push the patience of India or you will regret every bit of it. Don't forgot India is going to be third most powerful country by 2027 economically.
@@SubhaThree-w8w india has been pushing patience of all its neighbours, now pakistan bangladesh nepal bhutan srilanka myanmar maldives afghanistan etc need to form a NATO like alliance against upper caste imperialist emanating from india...
@@bevdo-banno3169First clear IMF loans before forming NATO alliance🤣🤣🤣
Don't worry about India. We will make BANGLADESH as the GAZA of subcontinent. Let TRUMP win and then face the music.
In yout dreams 😂@@avijitbasu5789
Amb . Saran, you have been a high commissioner of India to Bangladesh for a number of years. Unfortunately , you never learned or wanted to learn about the Bengali culture-distinct from the West Bengal , social and political moorings. You always worked from the selfish India’s perspective and not what the Bangladeshis want. In this interview You have delivered a narrative which is full of falsehood, misleading and evading the truth.
In fact from 2009 to 05 august 2024, before Hasina fled to her sanctuary in India, it was literally India , which ran Bangladesh through its stooge Hasina. Though there is adequate skepticism , the 2008 election was generally accepted by the people as fare. But when it comes to the elections of 2014 , 2018 and 2024 , you may duck your head in the sand, but the truth is , if it was not India directly interfering or supporting Hasina nakedly, she would have never won those three elections.
The brutal and fascist rule that Hasina ran in the country, would have never happened if she wasn’t emboldened by her conviction that India would support her to the hilt. For instance , the late president Pranab Mukherjee once threatened to send indian troops to Bangladesh , in the event of any threat to Hasina’s life. Was it any of his business ? As high commissioner it was your duty to find out the core reasons for incremental rise of anti India sentiments. You should have also mentioned Hasina’s corrupt practices , laundering of money by herself , her family members and cronies and other crimes against humanity she committed. I remember your attitude towards this country, when i once asked you to pay some attention to the killings of the unarmed and innocent Bangladeshi citizens in the border areas by the BSF. And, you rudely brushed aside my concern, displaying your arrogance.If you are honest , please provide a list of what Bangladesh gained and what India gained out of the so-called “ golden relationship between India and Bangladesh”. No doubt it was diamond for India but for Bangladesh it got only empty promises. Hasina had once infamously declared that “what I have given to India it will never forget”. Let’s see your government make such a bold statement with facts and figures.
Mr. Saran , i will advise you to refrain from lecturing us. Bangladeshis are tremendously resilient people and we have throughout our history have successfully surmounted any adversities-manmade or natural.please leave us to our fate. Thanks for reading, if at all you will.
This is a true criminal, you have no right to talk about Bangladesh!
By saying what he said shows his parochial attitude towards Bangladeshi people. India's stooge was Hasina who was an illegal ruler based on 3 farcical elections. If those had been fair, she would have lost all of them. It would be prudent for people like this person not to pretend that he knows all the answers to the current reality. All Indians toe the BJP line of thinking!
Why wouldn't India have a parochial attitude, you came into being because of India, in spite of 50 years of independence you still have been unable to write a proper constitution or able to build a proper institute of repute, you are all flabbergasted by one Yunus who got so called peace prize for being an American stooge, your opposition is constantly fighting among themselves by being either in approval or disapproval of India. Now you expect India to build your infrastructure and capacity and give aid through which you will buy weapons from Pakistan and if we protest or take a preventive action you call it parochial. Seriously dude.
Dude , u better think about ur own country & seven sisters as they r already in fire !!! Poor ass , can't handle own country's unrest , came here to give opinion others on how to be on right path thru history & wisdom .
Thousands of Indian soldiers lost lives liberating Bangladesh. Ungrateful bastards. Your coming generations will pay for this Islamic misadventure.
No one is saying that anyone told Hasina how to govern. What a straw man argument. The beef Bangladeshis have with India is that India backed her to the hilt and thus shielded her from the consequences (electoral defeat) of her misrule.
How did India back her?
How India shielded her? Can you elaborate?
India was always first to recognize the bogus elections and lobbied strongly with the rest of the international community to have them accepted. This is not controversial.
Why are we blamed for this? Every country in a position of influence will lobby for their choice of government. We have the american congress meeting our opposition leaders. This happens everywhere in the world. This is exactly what Saran is pointing out. You need stronger institutions. Why didn't your opposition parties go out to the world and build loyalties. Politics is dirty. We are not spewing hatred online against the Americans because they met our opposition leaders. There is a certain level of decorum that states need to maintain between them. The amount of hatred I have seen from Bangladeshi society and the gov officials is insane. But Indian officials have only been quiet and mature and not indulging in this microphone diplomacy.
@@BiswaDas-z4dBy media,In United nation,USA,EU all diplomat backing😂😂😂
What a joke that Hasina was democratically elected! She was actually an agent of India, and you people have done everything to keep her in power.
In 2014, all political parties boycotted the one-sided election, and your external affairs secretary herself visited BD and forced a particular party to join the polls, so that it seems participatory.
Since then, Hasina rigged every election, and her only enabler was India. Now, India has gone mad as its agent has been kicked out by the brave Bangladeshis..
We love India and its people.But please don't try to snatch our right to elect our leaders, and don't try to set your agent here again. Also, change your foreign policy, since it is the worst one a nation can have.With this policy, you are setting all neighbours in your confrontation..
Dude were u unable to comprehend that this former ambassador said in this 40 minutes long interview in which he was very carefully choosing his words while expressing himself.
How is India going to endorse an election in Bangladesh, if it were to support your opposition then will Hasina not blame India for political interference. How can you absolve china in all this just because ordinary chinese hardly care about you. Was Hasina not playing the Chinese against India and getting the best for her country.
Why wouldn't India have a parochial attitude, you came into being because of India, in spite of 50 years of independence you still have been unable to write a proper constitution or able to build a proper institute of repute, you are all flabbergasted by one Yunus who got so called peace prize for being an American stooge, your opposition is constantly fighting among themselves by being either in approval or disapproval of India. Now you expect India to build your infrastructure and capacity and give aid through which you will buy weapons from Pakistan and if we protest or take a preventive action you call it parochial. Seriously dude.
Unush is agent of USA?.
Don't pretend to be big brother,india is just a neighbour country...
Perhaps u forget, Bangladesh is a gift item from India,1971
Of course, Bangladesh should grow up and learn to stand on its own feet instead of asking for loans, electricity, onions etc
@@pramodpradhan3395 you guys are helping us at the end of war,approximately 10 days ago,mind it
@@1008apocalypse1008 so funny,its all about buisness nothing else,and most importantly we are the big market as well..
We gifted u Bangladesh. We liberated u from Pakistan ur tormentor 😂
We want Hasina is next prime minister of India
Pankaj is a lier.
Bangladesh is a peaceful country now.
We are freedom now and we got democracy. Dr. Younus is our best leader.
Truth is bitter, if you have substance then say it. Don't try to whitewash lame one word narrative. I didn't find any of his analysis off the mark.
@@AjitKumar-lo9yu Why does India talk so much about our country? Do we talk about India? We will see the good and bad of our country, there is no need to talk about India.
Pankaj you are a broker of dictator Hasina. But you know Hasina's place is not possible in Bangladesh right now. At the same time India is the top first enemy in every general person in Bangladesh. I also warn that India is playing with fire.
As a brave gober bhakt sanghi mee support sheik haseena saar 😂😂😂
But India did place all its eggs in the Hasina basket. That’s why they went to the mat to defend her. And yes India will deal with whoever the government in power is, but it’s not happy about it, and that is crystal clear.
How India put eggs in Hasina basket? Was India issuing visas to only Awami League members? If she is the PM, should India deal with Khaleda Zia, who hates India?
The Bangladesh Army handed her over to India. Why did they? Blame them!
Ok. You are right. Happy?
Now create jobs 😊 and listen to this interview again
Economic Times cares so much about accuracy in their Bangladesh coverage that they can’t even be bothered to spell Hasina or Yunus’s name right. Tells you a lot right there.
Yes - that's because nobody gives a damn about bangladesh.
@@intercalz yet kept crying since 5 aug? clown pojeet😂😂
When India saying something wrong regarding Bangladesh that means Bangladesh is on Right Track Now. Hmm POOR INDIA!!!!!!!
Hmmm, and which West Pakistani broker have said this as* hole? The real thing is west Pakistani DNA like you are now having great desire to make Bangladesh Pakistan again 😂
This individual exemplifies the profession of a lawyer who is standing up for a convicted murderer.
lol...couldn't agree more 😂
Still better than professional undergarment thieves.
We want to play with fire.Don't threaten us.
What an arrogant title, narrative and take on Bangladesh.
India wants Bangladesh need no choice, just follow them.
It seems more of a crisis for India, rather than Bangladesh
15hr electricity shutdown shows everything.
@@shubhajitbiswas9990 Maybe but they are still not out of crisis, maybe the tail end. Give them time they are a smart nation they can manage. Just look at the team at the top, they have the brightest of their lot, surely these young experts brought from all over the world will take Bangladesh forward and very soon. India ought to help them not criticize them.
@@xpsmango4146 no one can help any nation. When us is involved.
We all wish good for bd.
Can you tell how many people died after 5th aug
@@shubhajitbiswas9990 The Hindu claims UpTo 600 people died. Surely India has helped Bangladesh progress in last 15 years but there seems to be some resentment among the people on various issues which is not a big thing among neighbors.
@@xpsmango4146 every things are narrative game.
Hasina was dictators .
Is yonis elected?
Is he was part of the student protest?.
No , not directly.
How many terrorists are freed from the jail after 5th aug?
50% of now ministers are NGO person ,all funded by USA.
Stupid question of course every single person of Bangladesh are behind ouster Dictator Haseena but in headline we call it students public.
Sir Saran, pl be realistic and neutral.Yours is just anti Bangla desh speculate rhetoric post Hasina.Why such rhetoric was absent during Hasina as Ruler?Because, she was a Vassal of India?
Truth is bitter dude
You gave example of Sealed Pakistan border and linked their financial crisis with it. Why dont you think about the border with China?? Thats also sealed and they are way ahead of you 😂😂😂😂
When you say foreign institutions then I would say Indian institutions will be at the top.
The Dictator Hasina should be punished.
Propaganda lol
Did you (Indian) think Hasina was the democratic leader?
Bloated frogs croaking against the huge neighbour elephant with hunting eagle money... also Begging daily for food energy cotton machine fertilizer oil medicine from elephant... Begging wheat from grizzly bear and begging for money from fiery dragon... Waiting for all players in geopolitical chessboard...
Why doesn't he talk about all the money that was being siphoned out the country? A sitting minster owning 350 plus property in UK. Hasina and her goons were leaches.
Tu kabhi nehi sudhrega.
To Saran it's a clear message from the people of Bangladesh, Seven Sisters, Kashmir that, ' Kursi ke peti bandh lejiye, Kyo ki mausam bigarne wala hain'.
Loud and clear.
@@kh.rafiqueabdullah799Pakistan had similar thoughts about Kashmir. 😅
@@1008apocalypse1008 WAR at the horizon dear. Keep your eyes open. 😁😁😁
It is not Bangladesh who is against Indian dictatorship in South Asia rather it's all the neighbours who do the same. Hate india fearlessly. Then we will have to understand that the problem is not in us. The problem is in India. So stop spreading lies and pripaganda and work on your mistakes to rebuild the future relation.
We have the best of the relations with Bhutan, Srilanka, Maldives, Myanmar, even Afghanistan, Nepal are our brothers so don't bother about it.
Sri Lanka, Maldives, Bhutan are all surviving on handouts from India.
We are proud. We are a Muslim majority country
Shameless country
I feel compelled to express my thoughts on the matter. The true nature of Indian diplomats is evident; if they believe that Bangladesh is heading towards significant difficulties, it may indeed be the correct course of action for us. I encourage everyone to read all the comments.
Insightful conversation 👏👏
lmao pojeet
Why don't you want to learn ? We know why you did that and trying to do again and again.
It was India who was playing for decades and now America.
I generally don't like Indian diplomats especially the ones dealing with Pakistan because of their obvious love for peace with Pakistan at the expense terrorism in India.
But I have to say I am in awe with this Indian diplomat who has such clarity of thought and choosing of words with regards to the whole gamut of India-East Pakistan relations. Also with regards to what is really unfolding in East Pakistan.
I guess the East Pakistanis wouldn't have realised what had hit them in a very nice and sweet way in this interview.
What a lier!!!
Bangladesh now well prepared not counting India
😂😂😂😂
"Bangladesh historically has always had external forces at work inside the country" Finally, someone admitted it. This external force is mainly RAW. Since independence, RAW involved in Bangladesh politics and they always tried their best to enact India's interest in Bangladesh by any means. Result, in every political assassination, RAW's involvement was obvious. Finally RAW came up to set an pro-indian government in Bangladesh to ensure direct Indian control depriving voters voting right. After topple of Hasina resim, they are still active in Bangladesh to creates unrest politically and economically. All those activities of RAW backfired and only earned hatred from the mass population of Bangladesh
There is nothing uncommon between you East Pakistanis and West Pakistanis which is that there is always a conspiracy against you guys by the Kafir Hindus and Jews.
Ok brother please repay the loans and clear electricity dues. 😅
@1008apocalypse1008 that less than billion busk dues no matter at all, within December 31st you will clear Adani's all deus. After that request Adani to review the agreement and stop selling electricity @Taka 14/KwH. Adani simply plundering in the name of electricity export to Bangladesh
@@Saif1971ify dude that extra money was pocketed by your people who were in govt that is how international deal work. Do not tell me that the Chinese haven't paid any corruption money and u don't have a problem if the Chinese have done that
@@Saif1971ify 20 percent of Bangladesh electricity comes from India. 😂
we are unique in the world. Don’t dare to threat us. We are maybe less in numbers but we will die to defend our country and will raise our Army in our shoulders.
It is important for India to be generous to its neighbours
It is important for neighbors to be grateful instead of throwing tantrums.
Why interfering into Bangladeshi afairs? Let the people of Bangladesh to decide. They are wise people.
Best wishes from Pakistan
People of Bangladesh know you very well and what happened in 2008 election. India misundstand us last 400 years . What ever you do we just watch . We have faith on Allah and how we finished her with the help of Allah Hasina is an example. She is now like a symbol of victory and fall. Hope Mr Soren personaly read the comment.
Red alert India
Red alert bharat.
Cry baby
red alert Muslim Umah
We are 95% Bangladeshi anti-Indian, find out why anti-Indian first. Then you will come out of them. If you do not do these things and continue to make the same mistakes as before, then your loss will be great. It's not good to think so much !!
I am from Bangladesh. And I am totally broken to see that how my country has been fallen into failed state. Economy and other stuffs have been destroyed totally
Pankaj is right,external forces working in Bangladesh but only when Hasina is in power and only external forces is Indian Raw. Everyone seen on news on the day hasina fall all Indian police running at the Dhaka airport tarmac got the flight back to India. They was carrying weapons and uniform on.
Why are you burning. We Bangladeshis are very happy.
We are free from Indian exploitation. Allah hu Akbar
Regarding trade deficit , it’s true that Bangladesh has huge trade deficits with China . However, china doesn’t impose tariff and non-tariff barriers for Bangladeshi goods , that India does. Unfortunately, India wants uninterrupted flow of their goods to bd ,not other way round.
India as a model country of democracy should work with people of Bangladesh but not any chosen leader! We all are aware of what’s going on in here and who are the players behind! ❤
Muslims across the world can't live in a democracy. They need a US backed dictator.
India's interests and unjust role ignites the fire that forces Bangladesh to play with it. It is unpredictable how the fire might engulf the whole region. Bangladesh might be burned up but the heat wave won't spare the region of interest for other regional and international powers.
Pankaj saran did not highlight Indian role in 2014 election. It is very open how Sujata Sing (Indian foreign seccretary at that time) came to Bangladesh and forced H M Ershad to participate in that election to make the election legitimate. H M Ershad opened it in the media before his exipre.
We are not saying India should interfere in our politics. But we was wanted from India to talk about democracy and human rights. Supporting a dictator for short term benefit doesn’t make sense.
External forces like raw always controlled Bangladesh. And now they are kicked out. India is only worried about that 😂😂😢😅
we want to sheikh hasina as the prime minister of india 🎉
Indian army ko russia ke jaisa aattack karke chaattgaon oe chiken neck ko elephant neck mei change kar lena chayie nahi yo aage jake bohut problem create hone wala hai.
Yes, they will understand peace with India is a dividend and force multiplier for their country and emity with India will only drain their economy from spending on the peoples well being to boosting their defence until unless known beggar Pakistan is funding their projects.
But India need not invest any further in this relationship as nothing will change their mind and allegiance to ummah.
All these are internal matters of Bangladesh, these two guys talking nonsense.
Do not watch who is forcing you, watch Pakistani news you East Pakistani
Absolutely, India is also a nation of free will.
His narrative is aligned with his training as a diplomat. Indian involvement started from 2014 onwards. Hasina had no other choice but to dance with the puppeteer, the criminal Hasina received immoral support from Modi even though they knew the last three elections she rigged like a pirate in the high seas. The high commissioner, I am sure, was not comfortable to shove her around by the directives of Delhi. The people of Bangladesh naturally did realize Hasina's compromising attitude towards "Big Brother" India. India heavily relied on RAW, a rotten organization. Like her father, Sk. Mujib, Hasina was involved in conspiracy herself against the people of Bangladesh. Fascist Hasina will remain in a foreign soil but unlike her father, she will not have a final resting place in Bangladesh. KARMA.
So many things he said is factually and fundamentally wrong. I wish I had the patience to be a keyboard warrior and write an essay on the incorrect statements he made. No wonder the anti indian sentiment in Bangladesh is so strong here.
Dude this guy is not politician and he was a former Indian ambassador to East Pakistan and also former Deputy National Security Advisor, the same post that Ajit Doval holds presently except he was deputy. I can understand that the truth can be bitter but certainly it can't blind you from reality.
The fact is that you have nothing to counter whatever has been said by this gentleman.
Excellent analysis of the story... But the nehruvian diplomatic conversation does not work with radical mentality beggars either east or west... It works with highly educated skilled societies.
Awami charters run for their lives 😂😂
From the comments it seems many in Bangladesh feel that India was asking BNP to not participate in elections. It would be interesting to see if BNP or AL or both decide not to participate in the next elections, will Bangladeshis still blame India for it? And if India engages with a BNP government post elections in which AL doesn't participate, will Bangladeshis be still be complaining? Will such a govt. Legitimate or illegitimate?
Last 15 years how democratic India supports (blindly) supportsto monster unpopular Hasina. Where (was)voice, vote,etc of Bangladeshi people s.
Bangladesh now in right path. Stop Indian conspiracy.
Stop doing dadagiri with Bangladesh. India's dadagiri is mainly responsible for present condition of Bangladesh.
External forces are now analyzing Bangladesh internal politics. He is just a male Veena Sikhri.
US - Yunus connection Vs India - Hasina connection is not same. India kept its eyes closed, if not supported the killings, abductions, illegal imprisonment of her political oppositios by Hasina. While there is no such example that US is encouraging Yunus to indulge in such activities. That's why we Bangladeshis blame India for all our miseries that we suffered during Hasina's rule.
Modi never fired a bullet at any protestor at any point of time. I wonder why he would recommend that to Hasina. It's mostly the crooked BD army and US backed bureaucrats
Beware, India is splitting into many pieces. Remember you heard it here first.
Complete propaganda & lies
This 2 great jockers are presening a comedy show here with misinterpretation ragding Bangladesh politics. This is totally waste of time for all Bangladeshis.😁😁😁
India should cautiously choose their viewpoint. Because this time it is not ISI backed government in Bangladesh like in 2001. It is USA with Pentagon has significant influence on it! India can't afford to play a proxy war in Bangladesh with USA where a vulnerable porous border exist! India is not united even 90 years ago. US can break into pieces again if India try to stand equal with USA!
Do you agree that sudden fall of Hasina government was fairly avoidable had the otherwise legitimate demand of the students been addressed in right time?
After all preservation of 56% of the jobs in public services for special category of the people leaving only 44% for general students is blatantly unjust.
Why should Bangladesh be in big trouble if Bangladesh gets anti India?
Nepal was in the grips of India.
Now Nepal kicked out India and sided with China.
Nepal at one time theathen India with war.
So why was Nepal not in trouble for becoming Anti India?
Can you explain?
Bangladesh is Playing with fire? such arrogant statement. but he can only show such arrogance there.
Bangladesh is about to get dismantled. Watch out
@@Abhinav-ut5zd we are muslims and we fear none but Allah. Also we know about the prophecy of gajwa e hind which will happen probably the way your hindutva regime is operating sooner than later. If I were you, I would be much more careful making arrogant comments about a neighboring country where states of my own country is fighting for freedom, be it in manipur, khalistan, kashmir, assam or arunachal! The day you people think of dismantling our existence will in shaa Allah be the day when the beginning of your end starts.
Not only playing with fire, the country is on 🔥... completely divided on political, sectarian lines
@@Abhinav-ut5zd
@@BiswaDas-z4d Cry more man
Hasina, Democratically elected?? If this is ur understanding thn, accept facts lyk-
✅ Monipur is new Afghanistan &
✅ India is being ruled by a religious extremist party BJP.
US is hegemonic superpower. What is India? Compare Yunus-US and Haseena- India is ludicrous!
Bangladesh needs to focus on Bangladeshi interests and not indian interests (Plus it is crucial those in Bangladesh working for indian interests be found and removed from any power they have).
India should change their bad intention about Bangladesh.
"Democratically elected" 😂😂
It is worth considering the following-a sort of cross-section of Bangladesh's current landscape from a political and diplomatic standpoint. While it is clear that political motives have played a role in shaping the prevailing narrative, the facts remain largely aligned with the broader realities on the ground.
However, truth is Hasina fled.
A good overview of post Hasina Bangladesh from a past Indian High Commissioner from his own perspectives. Ambassador Saran spoken to a select gathering in Dhaka prior to BD election 2024 clearly favouring Hasina’s retaining Power under Bangladesh system of Democray! Now see the outcomes of her three such elections! What legacy she left behind. A series of mega projects burden with astonomical foreign loans beyond paying capacity, a shattered Administration, Corrupt Police system, worst Human Rights Record, bankrupt Banks, low Foreign Exchange Reserves, a thousand dead bodies, a few thousands bullet hit wounded! High Commissioner rightly said a few millions visit India per year. That's people to people connection but that percrption receding past undet Hasina because India supports her continuation with false & fabricated Elections for the third term. India obtained several corridors over Bangladesh to NE States without any visible solution to Teesta & other Rivers, anti dumping on Jute & jute goods, border killings. Perception in Dhaka Hasina gave up without any reciprocal benefit for Bangladesh just to hang on with Indian support. India needed to understand internal dynamics of change without blaming Nobel Laureate Yunus, Jamat or BNP. Delhi should help stabilise situation for her own longterm positive relationship with Dhaka.
Hindu community in Bangladesh is much better than Muslims in India under BJP. Let it be our internal issue as good as Muslims are India's.
Ambassador M.Shafiullah
Mobile no 01817009095