The author of the following article, which really is a wake-up call to all Australians, is Dr (Professor) David Barton,. Dr Barton specialises in general adult and geriatric psychiatry with a particular interest in neuropsychiatry acquired brain injury, and the association between depression and cardiovascular disease. He works in centres in Melbourne and Ballarat
In 1983, as a naïve youth worker and concerned by what I had been reading since the early 1970s about what was happening with Aborigines in Alice Springs, I moved there to see what I could do to help. All told, I spent six years in Central Australia, leaving both depressed and convinced that the situation could never be fixed. …
Unfortunately, much of what passes for Aboriginal ‘culture’ today is an invention of the last 50 years. Fortunately, much authentic Aboriginal culture of the past has vanished. The gruesome initiations, genital mutilation, inflicted cicatrices (Scars), burns, ritual spearing’s, sorcery and payback murders have by and large disappeared. Nevertheless, inter-tribe clan grievances often remain, as can be seen at some football indigenous matches, both on the field and amongst the spectators. Even though these encounters can still become violent, at least those conflicts are mostly played out with a football, not spears and clubs.
Meanwhile, the Aboriginal Industry is chock full of ill-informed, urban myth-makers and illusionists, this caste of urgers and deluded pretenders giving rise to the patronising insistence on the uniqueness of ‘Aboriginal knowledge’ about everything from agriculture and fish farms (a lá Bruce Pascoe), water and fire management (a lá ‘cultural burning’) to Aboriginal ‘art’, ‘fashion’ and even ‘astronomy’, and not to mention Ernie Dingo and Richard Walley’s thoroughly overdone ‘Welcome to Country”. This is mostly snake oil fakery, an effort to convince contemporary Australians that the Aborigines of old were something they clearly never were.
Worse, histories and observational accounts of early Aboriginal life and culture are vanishing from library shelves, replaced by the anti-white post-modern dogma of ‘invasion, colonisation and inter-generational trauma’. It is unusual today to find any history book about Aborigines in a secondary or tertiary institution that is more than fifteen years old. This is cultural censure and erasure happening right under our noses. We are all the poorer for it, black and white alike.
Meanwhile, the recent invention, exaggeration, distortion and misrepresentation of the alleged ‘frontier wars’ serves as a made-to-order replacement ‘history’ intended to raise the status of Aboriginal people and degrade that of settlers. It is yet another bill of goods, a distorting sham, being hawked by a power-grabbing activist elite in whose interest it is to falsify and distort our history. The goal, need it be said, is an attempt to paint a genocidal racism as Australia’s original sin. …
Equality of opportunity is not enough for the power hungry, to whom any perceived inequality in outcome is an opportunity:
Unfortunately, self-determination for many people who today identify as Aboriginal is taken to mean the normal rules - keeping children in school, eschewing clan and domestic violence - aren’t thought to fully apply. This is nowhere more apparent than on the troubled streets of Alice Springs.
‘Self-determination’ means ‘we’ll do what we like and you can pay for it’. Self-determination’ is about colonising and taking control, accepting all that whitefellas have to offer while offering nothing in return. Self-determination is about undermining whitefella institutions, judiciaries, organisations and bureaucracies. Self-determination is about enculturated white people who, on the strength of what may be a mere speck of indigenous DNA, now identify exclusively as Aboriginal, thereby giving themselves an economic and social leg-up. For the activist cadre it always was and always will be about money, power and control, all underlined by the notion that members of one race enjoy a preeminent ascendency over all other Australians.
More examples of ‘self-determination’ can be found in the ban on climbing Ayers Rock (Uluru), Mt Warning (Wollumbin), Mt Gillen, and many Grampians climbs, all for ill-defined or unexplained ‘cultural’ reasons’. After much outcry, consideration is now being given to re-opening the Mt Warning climb, but only for those who pay a fee and are escorted by indigenous guides. More rent-seeking, what a surprise!
Australian place names are also rapidly being overwritten with (most likely made-up) Aboriginal names (eg: K’gari, once known as Fraser Island). All of this is about claims to ownership, to ‘sovereignty’. These changes should not be mistaken for deference to Aboriginal culture; it’s no more nor less than an insidious takeover. What we are experiencing here is cultural guerrilla warfare, the picking off one target after the other. Don’t believe it? Look no further than what has happened in New Zealand.
@@GeorgePapadopolous Good people voted NO. The racists who voted yes are mad that they lost and angry that most Australians are decent humans who want aboriginals to be seen and treated as equals.
So, we just forget the fact that AUSTRALIA voted NO to treaty. There is no need to treaty what these people are stating is completely wrong. Go Jacinta.
People don't matter anymore, it's about control, just like the pandemic, it was about how much people would give up and surrender to the Government. We are being had by the very people elected to serve in our best interests.
@Helliconia54 - You'd think so, but Labor in particular would find a way to totally ignore what the majority want, and force it upon us, as various Labor governments throughout the world have also done. Common sense is distinctly absent from within this party - voted in by the majority at the time - so take heed !
Vic is becoming a shit hole. I've been assaulted 3 times walking through the CBD simply because i cover my eyes with the brim of my hat, people assume I'm not looking and try to hip and shoulder me all the time. I've had a home invasion and recently assaulted by an Indian because I told him I would not say sorry to his wife for not stepping off the footpath for his family to pass by me walking the other way. saying "It's polite to walk on the left in Australia" is enough to get you sent to hospital in Victoria now.
True. I voted NO because I could see how the referendum was dividing Australians. I know of many Aboriginal people who also voted NO because they could see the backlash it was going to have and the suffering they would go through by those who legitimately were racist in their opinions. The problem is these people pushing non stop are oblivious to what the aboriginal people really need help with the most. In country SA it isn't uncommon to see children around 5years of age walking around the streets in nappys and nothing else completely unsupervised. Their older siblings turn to theft and begging to feed themselves and their siblings because their parents are drunk, high on drugs, or gambling away their latest centerlink payment in pokies. They get home and there's no food on the table, no clean clothes to wear and the parents fight about everything being hard. Domestic violence is what these kids grow up seeing on a daily basis. No yes vote or council of rich inner city elite will change this at all. Because of the stolen generation the aboriginal people who need the help most won't trust anything brought to them by a government and the money being given to them by government goes to lining the pockets of the very same people who are pushing this yes vote stuff. It's not about helping the communities, it's about beefing up these activists bank accounts and labour is right in the thick of it all because these activists are all through the unions. What labour used to stand for, the rights of working class citizens, is no longer on their agenda.
All I see attending the event are white supremacists. They see themselves as 'superior with privilege', and that the aboriginals require their help... Apparently.
@SecretSquirrrrel that's so right . they are not inacent by a long shot . they weren't back when the supposed stolen generation happened and there not now !
Forensic audit also into the $40billion given annually to the indigenous. The outback and rural indigenous don't see much of that money, so into who's pockets is it going?????
“All those countries that have made a treaty with the indigenous people, well (you know) they’re fine, it’s not a problematic thing”… WELL YES IT IS!!! Ask any of those countries and their general population will recount the issues!!, in fact many leaders from those very countries warned Australia of heading down this path!!! But all said and done… AUSTRALIA HAS SAID NO! This isn’t up for discussion anymore, we’ve held a referendum, the majority of Australians don’t want this, so tuff luck… move on. (Spot a genuine indigenous person in this footage, outside the meeting??🤔🤔)
Absolutely! Look at the mess here in NZ. Certain factions are dragging us back to Stone Age animist beliefs where everything we do must be ticked off by tribal “leaders” based on the Maori world view - for a fee, of course.
I'm pretty sure that we already know what the people said..NO! Labor state and Federal Government needs to be voted out because this proves that we cannot trust this government.
As evidenced by the accomplishments & position of Minister Nampijinpa Price, people of Aboriginal heritage are as capable of achieving a place in the governing body of our nation- of making their voice heard- same as any other citizen in this country: we are ALL Australian citizens; *no one* needs or deserves to have more rights or opportunities, or _special_ rights above any other citizen. This was *_already_* voted on, **&** it was voted down...
It is up to us to vote these state governments out who are pushing treaties, It shows the governments utter contempt for the people of Australia when we voted no. These clowns have to go!
Labor cannot accept "NO", it is hard to pick labor's biggest desire. To have Aborigines govern over all other Australians OR make being Trans compulsory for school children.
A treaty will only further divide, NOT Unite! Moving forward should not be about TREATY, but about TREATING people as we each would like to be treated, all as one, not according to our colour, race, gender or otherwise but by each person's individual actions.
i love how they interview people who no grasp on world history let alone australian history. These people make out that the equivalent of the roman empire was here when the british arrived. the native australians had no concept of nation.
Voice was voted against. By the majority. First nations are well supported financially. The total disrespect for issue voted against. We don't need treaties
Why? It's just a political event. As far as I know you're free to do that Not saying I'm agreeing with them (I don't) but nothing that happened here was illegal
Its not learning more about it! Its about learning more about 'their' version of it! Amazes me the amount of people lining up to loose what they have worked for.
In my experience, they're usually well off and have come from multiple generations of prosperity from the land. They feel guilty and won't give back any of their family's wealth, but expect all Australians to pay for their guilty continued pleasured lifestyle.
They need to see the difference of life between Victoria and Qld aboriginal communities. Totally different because Victoria are city Blackfella not remote Blackfella
@user-pj5ub5cp9k being honest I don't know if Gippsland communities live in squalor like NT and Qld mobs do while being ignored by the activist class.
Hang on this is supposed to be about aboriginal people now I'm not seeing any here . Now I live in South Australia and aboriginals are the same colour as Africans Here, Maybe if they actually got to speak for themselves, they wouldn't need a voice or $40 billion worth of advisors
the state gov snuck their voice in here, only 5% of people who were allowed to vote (race based) did, with some getting in with less than 20 votes, others that won their vote were snubbed so they could have equal gender representation
The problem is, who is an Indigenous person? If you're asking for liberties and taxpayer funds then to have some credibility the Indigenous representatives should look the part, and not like ethnic Europeans grifting.
No, no, no to racial division. People who identify as 'aboriginal' are not united as one as these people seem to think. This brings the question, who benefits and who doesnt??????? Its rooted in racism. We are all Aussies and thats that
![ปฏิเสธไม่ไหว (Crush on you) - LIPTA feat. No One Else [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/NBw1jF342vw/mqdefault.jpg)
Over 60% of Australians, which include Aboriginal People as well, VOTED NO, NO MEANS NO
But that will not stop the activists. I wonder just how much money they get.
💯
The author of the following article, which really is a wake-up call to all Australians, is Dr (Professor) David Barton,. Dr Barton specialises in general adult and geriatric psychiatry with a particular interest in neuropsychiatry acquired brain injury, and the association between depression and cardiovascular disease. He works in centres in Melbourne and Ballarat
In 1983, as a naïve youth worker and concerned by what I had been reading since the early 1970s about what was happening with Aborigines in Alice Springs, I moved there to see what I could do to help. All told, I spent six years in Central Australia, leaving both depressed and convinced that the situation could never be fixed. …
Unfortunately, much of what passes for Aboriginal ‘culture’ today is an invention of the last 50 years.
Fortunately, much authentic Aboriginal culture of the past has vanished. The gruesome initiations, genital mutilation, inflicted cicatrices (Scars), burns, ritual spearing’s, sorcery and payback murders have by and large disappeared.
Nevertheless, inter-tribe clan grievances often remain, as can be seen at some football indigenous matches, both on the field and amongst the spectators. Even though these encounters can still become violent, at least those conflicts are mostly played out with a football, not spears and clubs.
Meanwhile, the Aboriginal Industry is chock full of ill-informed, urban myth-makers and illusionists, this caste of urgers and deluded pretenders giving rise to the patronising insistence on the uniqueness of ‘Aboriginal knowledge’ about everything from agriculture and fish farms (a lá Bruce Pascoe), water and fire management (a lá ‘cultural burning’) to Aboriginal ‘art’, ‘fashion’ and even ‘astronomy’, and not to mention Ernie Dingo and Richard Walley’s thoroughly overdone ‘Welcome to Country”. This is mostly snake oil fakery, an effort to convince contemporary Australians that the Aborigines of old were something they clearly never were.
Worse, histories and observational accounts of early Aboriginal life and culture are vanishing from library shelves, replaced by the anti-white post-modern dogma of ‘invasion, colonisation and inter-generational trauma’. It is unusual today to find any history book about Aborigines in a secondary or tertiary institution that is more than fifteen years old. This is cultural censure and erasure happening right under our noses. We are all the poorer for it, black and white alike.
Meanwhile, the recent invention, exaggeration, distortion and misrepresentation of the alleged ‘frontier wars’ serves as a made-to-order replacement ‘history’ intended to raise the status of Aboriginal people and degrade that of settlers. It is yet another bill of goods, a distorting sham, being hawked by a power-grabbing activist elite in whose interest it is to falsify and distort our history. The goal, need it be said, is an attempt to paint a genocidal racism as Australia’s original sin. …
Equality of opportunity is not enough for the power hungry, to whom any perceived inequality in outcome is an opportunity:
Unfortunately, self-determination for many people who today identify as Aboriginal is taken to mean the normal rules - keeping children in school, eschewing clan and domestic violence - aren’t thought to fully apply.
This is nowhere more apparent than on the troubled streets of Alice Springs.
‘Self-determination’ means ‘we’ll do what we like and you can pay for it’.
Self-determination’ is about colonising and taking control, accepting all that whitefellas have to offer while offering nothing in return.
Self-determination is about undermining whitefella institutions, judiciaries, organisations and bureaucracies.
Self-determination is about enculturated white people who, on the strength of what may be a mere speck of indigenous DNA, now identify exclusively as Aboriginal, thereby giving themselves an economic and social leg-up.
For the activist cadre it always was and always will be about money, power and control, all underlined by the notion that members of one race enjoy a preeminent ascendency over all other Australians.
More examples of ‘self-determination’ can be found in the ban on climbing Ayers Rock (Uluru), Mt Warning (Wollumbin), Mt Gillen, and many Grampians climbs, all for ill-defined or unexplained ‘cultural’ reasons’. After much outcry, consideration is now being given to re-opening the Mt Warning climb, but only for those who pay a fee and are escorted by indigenous guides. More rent-seeking, what a surprise!
Australian place names are also rapidly being overwritten with (most likely made-up) Aboriginal names (eg: K’gari, once known as Fraser Island). All of this is about claims to ownership, to ‘sovereignty’. These changes should not be mistaken for deference to Aboriginal culture; it’s no more nor less than an insidious takeover. What we are experiencing here is cultural guerrilla warfare, the picking off one target after the other. Don’t believe it? Look no further than what has happened in New Zealand.
@@alanc6781still illegal and an be ignored. As our constitution states
I’m sorry government.
We VOTED on this.
The answer was quite clear….
That does not matter to them, at all. They don’t give a shit what we want, they only want what they want.
You shouldn’t be sorry you should be enraged! They’re enforcing communism
Every state in Australia voted ALP.
EAT YOUR CURDS !!!
just shows labor have no respect for the Australian people. we said NO
Labor/liberal. Same, same. Communism. We voted No. treason!
@@victorgomes7585I don't see the Victorian Liberals in favour if this..They have already said it should be no..Why are you talking lies..???
The Yes voters can't take no for an answer and they are hated by the very people they are supporting talk about being dumb
@@johneverett6751 but they are not making a big deal about it either,
Not me
Victoria voted No to the Voice.
that's not a deterrent to the far left
@@justinbiever9165 Spot On
WAKE UP - Your vote doesnt mean anything to Jacinta Allan & her ministers...
Nothing is a deterrent to the left.
And she has the police force to prove it. The proof my friend is already in the pudding!@akhalif68
No means no. No to division and apartheid
@@louise7347 You voted yes for division.
@@GeorgePapadopolous
"You voted yes for division."
No, we voted NO to the racist referendum trying to divide us.
@@GeorgePapadopolous : Aussies voted "NO" to division.
@@buildmotosykletist1987 Racists voted yes for division.
@@GeorgePapadopolous Good people voted NO. The racists who voted yes are mad that they lost and angry that most Australians are decent humans who want aboriginals to be seen and treated as equals.
So, we just forget the fact that AUSTRALIA voted NO to treaty. There is no need to treaty what these people are stating is completely wrong. Go Jacinta.
That’s called third world dictatorship.
We voted "No" . Now you are going to sneak it in.
People don't matter anymore, it's about control, just like the pandemic, it was about how much people would give up and surrender to the Government.
We are being had by the very people elected to serve in our best interests.
yes they are.
@@pacomacaw2456 This shows you how little respect this party has for the people they were elected to serve.
It's all about division and control.
Traitors should be dealt with.
If they do I hope Dutton turns it back to NO !!!!!
this government needs arresting
who does the arresting ?
here lies the problem.
Citizens
Hahaha I like your joke
The voice said NO what don’t these people understand?
NO.
But they are Labour - the working man's friend lol. Really intelligent, just like the morons who vote for them.
NO "treaty" is valid unless voted by the people. We have the right to ignore ANY treaty not passed by the people
@Helliconia54 - You'd think so, but Labor in particular would find a way to totally ignore what the majority want, and force it upon us, as various Labor governments throughout the world have also done. Common sense is distinctly absent from within this party - voted in by the majority at the time - so take heed !
@@daedalus7677 yes your right
A spend of around 450 million dollars on a referendum and a resounding NO appears to count for nothing in the fine state of Victoria it would seem.
There's nothing fine any more about Victoria.
It is Not only Vic, State Premiers are Pushing Treaty without the permission of The People of their States.
Victoria is a the WEF trial state in Victoria. The WEF use indigenous people to take the land off everyone.
@@bettinafullerton6452 except fines.
Vic is becoming a shit hole.
I've been assaulted 3 times walking through the CBD simply because i cover my eyes with the brim of my hat, people assume I'm not looking and try to hip and shoulder me all the time.
I've had a home invasion and recently assaulted by an Indian because I told him I would not say sorry to his wife for not stepping off the footpath for his family to pass by me walking the other way. saying "It's polite to walk on the left in Australia" is enough to get you sent to hospital in Victoria now.
We voted NO
Not me.
@@gavinhellyer9505 We clearly doesn't include you.
And you think Elbow cares what we think?
Australians voted for equality. Not division. These governments need the boot
True. I voted NO because I could see how the referendum was dividing Australians. I know of many Aboriginal people who also voted NO because they could see the backlash it was going to have and the suffering they would go through by those who legitimately were racist in their opinions. The problem is these people pushing non stop are oblivious to what the aboriginal people really need help with the most. In country SA it isn't uncommon to see children around 5years of age walking around the streets in nappys and nothing else completely unsupervised. Their older siblings turn to theft and begging to feed themselves and their siblings because their parents are drunk, high on drugs, or gambling away their latest centerlink payment in pokies. They get home and there's no food on the table, no clean clothes to wear and the parents fight about everything being hard. Domestic violence is what these kids grow up seeing on a daily basis. No yes vote or council of rich inner city elite will change this at all. Because of the stolen generation the aboriginal people who need the help most won't trust anything brought to them by a government and the money being given to them by government goes to lining the pockets of the very same people who are pushing this yes vote stuff. It's not about helping the communities, it's about beefing up these activists bank accounts and labour is right in the thick of it all because these activists are all through the unions. What labour used to stand for, the rights of working class citizens, is no longer on their agenda.
@@scottmorton2053 Absolutely spot on.
Australia voted NO what part of NO do you not understand!!!
Where are all the aboriginals?
Correct! Only the half cast ones and paid off ones.
Funny stuff hey ....
They are there, did you not see them all😂. They are the ones that tick the box on the paperwork to get benefits when not entitled to them.
Couldn’t you see it,the 1% aboriginal blood in them from their great great grandparents.
Yeah all I could see was do gooders & greenies ALL WHITE I might add
wow, i just notice, not one blackfella there
All I see attending the event are white supremacists. They see themselves as 'superior with privilege', and that the aboriginals require their help... Apparently.
there never is!!
Though could all be if their self declared uncheckable paperwork says so.
I was thinking the same thing
Maybe they’re “truth telling” should firstly involve admitting all the horrendous things they do to their children.
Lie telling not truth
🤫🤫🤫
@@MatthewSwift-xc8sn...🤣🤣🤣...What planet do you live on..??
@SecretSquirrrrel that's so right . they are not inacent by a long shot . they weren't back when the supposed stolen generation happened and there not now !
Look at the news this morning with the white mother and her 2 kids come on champ u spoke to early
Victoria, The Wokest Brokest State of Australia.
Now I know why, they do it to themselves.
A $450 Million Dollar NO Means NO!
What about the 40 billion dollars they have wasted…
I'm in country victoria, but there's no way I'd live around large numbers of people. Ignorant and dumb doesn't begin to describe them
Look who they are interviewing. Enough said
this treaty will be with a political party not the Australian people ,,
A National no VOTE meant NO. Bad luck what these YES people want.
Australia voted NO.
Labor out.
Local-State-Federal
No more $ to the indigenous ‘system’.
Forensic audits and investigations into our politicians is desperately needed
Forensic audit also into the $40billion given annually to the indigenous. The outback and rural indigenous don't see much of that money, so into who's pockets is it going?????
GOOD TO SEE YOUR POST UP AGAIN RICKY.
Yes - the audits would be carried out by Labour morons.
We need a petition signed by 1,000’s to oppose this and to honour the vote we already had on the voice.
Go to One Nation’s website, they have LOTS of petitions. Then, tell all your friends to also sign them.
hemp is cheaper.
They have their petition. We voted No.
Labour and Honour is an oxymoron.
Go woke Go broke, i thought we voted No why do they ignore and disrespect the election result.
It’s obvious why, they don’t give a shit about the people, they only care about themselves and what they want.
Because the no vote was a national disgrace.
@@gavinhellyer9505 it's democracy, majority decide not minority.
@@fazall2023 Democracy is over rated. Just ask the imbecile Trump. He doesn't take any notice of votes.
@gavinhellyer9505
It’s called democracy. Get over it
“All those countries that have made a treaty with the indigenous people, well (you know) they’re fine, it’s not a problematic thing”… WELL YES IT IS!!!
Ask any of those countries and their general population will recount the issues!!, in fact many leaders from those very countries warned Australia of heading down this path!!!
But all said and done… AUSTRALIA HAS SAID NO! This isn’t up for discussion anymore, we’ve held a referendum, the majority of Australians don’t want this, so tuff luck… move on.
(Spot a genuine indigenous person in this footage, outside the meeting??🤔🤔)
Absolutely! Look at the mess here in NZ. Certain factions are dragging us back to Stone Age animist beliefs where everything we do must be ticked off by tribal “leaders” based on the Maori world view - for a fee, of course.
Agree, wen Albo can explain were 30 billion goes annually 😢 to the indigenous Australians.
Daam, with One million indigenous Australians, that's 50k, each 😔
That's a down right Lie..
to the land councils mostly
@@annabellhaynes7469 you are ill-informed
I'm pretty sure that we already know what the people said..NO! Labor state and Federal Government needs to be voted out because this proves that we cannot trust this government.
Why are they hiding the meeting. Corrupt. once again.
Labor is rushing through before they are kicked out.
Oh we wish!
Exactly what they are doing.
Victoria - The State of Stupid.
The state of WEF
@@billhanna5455Tin hat too tight.
Victoria is not the only state that began a process of treaty.
If it’s done in secrecy then it doesn’t have my support. Jacinta speaks sense.
The money wasted here could've been use to help all needy regardless of cultures
Well said❤
No virtue signalling in that, it's logical.
Thank you Jacinta Price for always speaking out on this subject.
Labor will not be in power next election, in fact I think this current government needs to be dismissed and a new election held.
Treason
As evidenced by the accomplishments & position of Minister Nampijinpa Price, people of Aboriginal heritage are as capable of achieving a place in the governing body of our nation- of making their voice heard- same as any other citizen in this country: we are ALL Australian citizens; *no one* needs or deserves to have more rights or opportunities, or _special_ rights above any other citizen.
This was *_already_* voted on, **&** it was voted down...
Well said.
No means No. Who is instigating this?
Victorian government.
@@simplesimon182 You mean the Australian Goverment, they're all in it - same agenda
How many otherwise innocent Australians will be arrested for breaking a treaty they never agreed to or wanted or voted for.
why not let sky in to cover the event ? still got shit to hide
We VOTED NO TO VOICE
NO MEANS NO!!! That’s it, suck it up, we voted no!!
It is up to us to vote these state governments out who are pushing treaties, It shows the governments utter contempt for the people of Australia when we voted no. These clowns have to go!
Labor cannot accept "NO", it is hard to pick labor's biggest desire. To have Aborigines govern over all other Australians OR make being Trans compulsory for school children.
Jacinta Price is a very rare voice of reason!
300 people wow Victoria will jump on board for sure only 300 , get over it we are all Australians 🇦🇺
They say an open discussion is fine, but if you ask to film the discussion they refuse. That makes sense.
Jacinta for PM!
A treaty will only further divide, NOT Unite! Moving forward should not be about TREATY, but about TREATING people as we each would like to be treated, all as one, not according to our colour, race, gender or otherwise but by each person's individual actions.
Why can't it be filmed? What are you hiding 🤔
No treaty! We are one nation!
i love how they interview people who no grasp on world history let alone australian history. These people make out that the equivalent of the roman empire was here when the british arrived. the native australians had no concept of nation.
Maybe the Roman empire still survives
@@Your-girl_Bonnie5 Maybe you need to open your eyes and get an education.
What part of NO don't you understand.'"
Treaty without the public or media. That is no treaty but a political show.
What was the point of holding the referendum if the Victorian State Government goes ahead and does what it likes anyway....?
It says a lot about the Victorian people.
NO NONSENSE , NO ALBANESE , NO DETRITUS
We voted one Australia
Why do we need a treaty this is so divisive. We are all Australians. This is absolutely ridiculous.
Vote NO evidently doesn't count-
Trust the Victorian ALP, no way.
Some people can't take NO for an answer.
Voice was voted against. By the majority. First nations are well supported financially. The total disrespect for issue voted against. We don't need treaties
This has to be deemed illegal because we took it to a national referendum and the majority voted NO!
Why? It's just a political event. As far as I know you're free to do that
Not saying I'm agreeing with them (I don't) but nothing that happened here was illegal
No means No. There is no No means maybe or yes No is No.
If taxpayers are funding these events then it’s only fair that the media should be able to gain access to report on what is actually being discussed.
HA! The media is as corrupt as the pollies.
This is disgusting. Our government is not following through with what we democratically voted for.
We already said no. I assume this is a power and money grab. And provides no benefits to all Australians.
Its not learning more about it!
Its about learning more about 'their' version of it!
Amazes me the amount of people lining up to loose what they have worked for.
In my experience, they're usually well off and have come from multiple generations of prosperity from the land. They feel guilty and won't give back any of their family's wealth, but expect all Australians to pay for their guilty continued pleasured lifestyle.
So the people of Australia have no say again
government should be held accountable for going against the wishes of the people
I was just wondering whose paying for it????
YOU ARE.
Don't these people see the Division in Treaty.
They don’t care, they’re already wealthy, it won’t affect them
NO
The people they interviewed smelt like Labor cronies
The USA stopped making treaties with native Americans in 1871. Why go back to 19th century policies in Australian in the 21st century?
They sound like the CFMEU type of organisations
These divisive Labor governments have to go !
Omg i cannot believe these people.
Why do these people insist on separating us we are one we should all be treated the same
Can the Australian people have these politicians arrested and put on trial?
If there was an INDEPENDENT GG Elbow would be out on his RRRRs. But no, we have a Labour appointed GG. Wonder why?
I don't remember voting 'yes'.... This ridiculous govt. has to go...
Labor doesn't represent the Australian people they only represent the w.e.f.
This is going against over 60% of Australian NO voters that won the referendum in 2023.
And Elbow cares?
They need to see the difference of life between Victoria and Qld aboriginal communities. Totally different because Victoria are city Blackfella not remote Blackfella
@@dlbeck2023 Nonsense. There are Indigenous Australian communities in Gippsland.
@user-pj5ub5cp9k yes but are they remote like Qld and NT aboriginal communities?
@@dlbeck2023 What's the difference?
@user-pj5ub5cp9k being honest I don't know if Gippsland communities live in squalor like NT and Qld mobs do while being ignored by the activist class.
Much much longer travel for amenities!!
@@GeorgePapadopolous
Hang on this is supposed to be about aboriginal people now I'm not seeing any here . Now I live in South Australia and aboriginals are the same colour as Africans Here, Maybe if they actually got to speak for themselves, they wouldn't need a voice or $40 billion worth of advisors
the state gov snuck their voice in here, only 5% of people who were allowed to vote (race based) did, with some getting in with less than 20 votes, others that won their vote were snubbed so they could have equal gender representation
@@nickbilske8140 This just goes to show the filth that is the Labour Party.
Jacinta price is the voice we should listen to. One day she we will be a strong PM and bring all Australians together.
I agree, she has commonsense, fairness and is a leader.❤
Or trojan horse
No means NO
are we at war to have a treaty?
They don't know what the word even means - They are fools.
The problem is, who is an Indigenous person? If you're asking for liberties and taxpayer funds then to have some credibility the Indigenous representatives should look the part, and not like ethnic Europeans grifting.
We should be celebrating that we have politicians like Jacinta representing us and we are able to work as one. Not separating everyone.
No, no, no to racial division. People who identify as 'aboriginal' are not united as one as these people seem to think. This brings the question, who benefits and who doesnt??????? Its rooted in racism. We are all Aussies and thats that
Jacinta Price for our uniting Mandela PM! Australia is dire need for a uniting force like MP Price.
Secret Secrets Business.
These meetings should be under public scrutiny if there nothing to hide!!!😡😬
2.50minute guy what a muppet
We voted NO,why have a referendum if your going to do it anyway,what a total waste of money
So 300 selected lefties say "YES"....
Love Jacinta Price.
Referendum said No.
No means No!!
Pure evil
Being the only country without treaty just means the only country treating people as equal.
Vicco has loads of cash surplus to pay for this... oh er wait maybe not.
Sneakiest, most deceptive government ever. NO MEANS NO.