A very interesting take on some popular modules. I ask myself "should I look at these ,in depth,( and spoil it as to wanting to play these as a player) or study them for my personal campaign setting) I am now DMing efforts?" I started on my D&D journey when an older cousin provided a bored 12 year old from the late 70's with a whole new world. Kitteh seems to be playing along with you and your young friend. Endearing! Plus the looks on your faces says it all!
Most are old enough to be way beyond spoilers - but all are worthy a look to for inspiration. As for our cat - I think she should have her own character sheet by now!
The Halls of Tizune Thane! I played that with AD&D 1e back when I got the Best of White Dwarf, maybe 1980 or so? Did it again in 3e twenty years later because it is, as you say, a great low-level scenario.
I loved the walkthrough of your favourite modules 30-11 Took me right back to my teenage years at school with my mates playing the wonderful D&D Looking forward to your 10-1 video Thank you Willy
Against the Cult of the Reptile God is my absolute favorite game module of all time. It has a bit of everything: town adventure, outdoor excursion and dungeon exploration. The snake cult theme in it reminds me of the movie Conan the Barbarian. In fact, the overall theme of CoRG would work very well in a Hyborean Age setting. I often considered expanding the plot of the module to encompass Thulsa Doom and his snake cult religion.
Huge fan of this module. There is some work to be done by the DM to make it all slide together and I usually bring in characters that have already been on at least one adventure. I've played and Dmed it twice and it has always worked out for us. In Contrast I played Assassins Knot once and we did so poorly we had to exit the Lendore Islands. I do want to try to DM it.
Feast of Goblyns was definitely my favorite adventure to run. Another one I’m surprised you might not have touched in this series was Tomb of Annihilation even as a nod.
Maybe if I'd done an honourable mention list... but it still might still not have got in there. Of the 5E WotC ones - granted, its better than most. However, it suffers from many of the issues inherent with those 5E books - railroads that are mostly filler with little substance. A bit less of the railroading in ToA, though!
I think Ravenloft works as a one-off. Or, if enough work is put in to fix things, as an I6/I10 combo. The campaign setting was a mixed bag to me - love some aspects of it, cringe at others. Did have a lot of fun with some of it, though - but again, as one-offs or part of a broader non-Ravenloft campaign.
Hey Ian, why do you call your channel "Willy Muffin"? Also, please make a top 10 module video soon, so we can hear more of your advice on what to buy, because the DriveThruRPG/DM'sGuild sale ends in 6 days.
Well... I am a musician, and play in a band. A while ago, I started tinkering with home recording, for getting at least demos of my songs down and learning about recording processes and techniques. To keep that separate from the stuff the band does, I called that solo recording project "Willy Muffin and the Bootcut Bluejeans" - "Willy" because every other blues, country, and jazz musician seems to be called Willy; "Muffin" for a pinch of mildly rude comedy that chases "Willy"; "and the Bootcut Bluejeans" because naming a solo effort as if it was a group of people tickles my sense of humour, and the guitarist from the band I'm in likes to take the piss for me wearing bootcut jeans. As you can see, the channel is a mixture of all sorts - gaming, music, and anything else that comes to my mind. I set it up originally for music, but it's turned into something for all of my various hobbies and interests. So... that is why the channel is called Willy Muffin. I bet you're glad you asked, now ;)
Hey Willy, I like much of what you say in your videos. E.g. your emphasis that this list is subjective, and e.g. how you said exactly what you meant with the phrase "without further rambling" instead of the cliche "without further ado". :)
@@ronniejdio9411 I'll take a look. We did drop in I guess it was the Finale. As I say I liked the module but then we ended up against the final big bads with no actual history or knowledge and got fried. Maybe better if you work your way through the first two and learn more about them? Still feels like they slip through your hands if they have to be around for the finale which is a pretty plot armoured railroad which I am not keen on.
@Biff Strong I like the idea of being captured ans turned loose in t h e caverns naked and weapons less. I hate it as the finale to this run. I've ran it 3 times anndi think I solved it. I switch the stockade module to the finale and shot can the island one. Whoever survives those first two thenparty has historybwith and can have a giant assault final battle in the module after the sneaking around. Also I like have the blind fire proof slave lord in the final battle he's great. Just gotta drop appearances if him in through the modules
You guys look like you're having a blast! (Cat too.) Thanks for the share!!
Yep, I'm having fun with these 🙂
A very interesting take on some popular modules. I ask myself "should I look at these ,in depth,( and spoil it as to wanting to play these as a player) or study them for my personal campaign setting) I am now DMing efforts?" I started on my D&D journey when an older cousin provided a bored 12 year old from the late 70's with a whole new world. Kitteh seems to be playing along with you and your young friend. Endearing! Plus the looks on your faces says it all!
Most are old enough to be way beyond spoilers - but all are worthy a look to for inspiration.
As for our cat - I think she should have her own character sheet by now!
@@WillyMuffinUK LOL We have 2 ourselves and suspect they observe us wondering what we are doing.
The Halls of Tizune Thane! I played that with AD&D 1e back when I got the Best of White Dwarf, maybe 1980 or so? Did it again in 3e twenty years later because it is, as you say, a great low-level scenario.
It is most excellent 🙂
I loved the walkthrough of your favourite modules 30-11
Took me right back to my teenage years at school with my mates playing the wonderful D&D
Looking forward to your 10-1 video
Thank you Willy
Thank-you!
Funny seeing the cat observing your game in the background of the video. :D
That's one of my miniatures cases she likes to sit on. Apparently, it doubles up as a good cat-cushion, too!
Against the Cult of the Reptile God is my absolute favorite game module of all time. It has a bit of everything: town adventure, outdoor excursion and dungeon exploration. The snake cult theme in it reminds me of the movie Conan the Barbarian. In fact, the overall theme of CoRG would work very well in a Hyborean Age setting. I often considered expanding the plot of the module to encompass Thulsa Doom and his snake cult religion.
No doubt, it is a bloody good one.
Huge fan of this module. There is some work to be done by the DM to make it all slide together and I usually bring in characters that have already been on at least one adventure. I've played and Dmed it twice and it has always worked out for us.
In Contrast I played Assassins Knot once and we did so poorly we had to exit the Lendore Islands. I do want to try to DM it.
29 "WTF is this" ... I remember that feeling well with Castle Greyhawk! lol
Horrible, wasn't it!
I liked the cover.
Feast of Goblyns was definitely my favorite adventure to run. Another one I’m surprised you might not have touched in this series was Tomb of Annihilation even as a nod.
Maybe if I'd done an honourable mention list... but it still might still not have got in there. Of the 5E WotC ones - granted, its better than most. However, it suffers from many of the issues inherent with those 5E books - railroads that are mostly filler with little substance. A bit less of the railroading in ToA, though!
Love Tegel Manor. What a map !!! Oh Mi God. So Much Fun.
Keep an eye out for a Tegel Manor review comig soon!
@@WillyMuffinUK Sold
fyi someone summoned a cat :() Very interesting video, thankyou.
RPGs are always better when the familiar is there ;)
@@WillyMuffinUK, the cat plays the Cheshire Cat NPC when you play EX1 Dungeonland, innit?
yup Guns Of Navaronne, Dirty Dozen thats the D&D equivalent war mission , some sort of commando raid. behind enemy lines.
I Like Ravenloft but not an acolyte of the world? follow ups? Campaign?
I think Ravenloft works as a one-off. Or, if enough work is put in to fix things, as an I6/I10 combo. The campaign setting was a mixed bag to me - love some aspects of it, cringe at others. Did have a lot of fun with some of it, though - but again, as one-offs or part of a broader non-Ravenloft campaign.
Hey Ian, why do you call your channel "Willy Muffin"?
Also, please make a top 10 module video soon, so we can hear more of your advice on what to buy, because the DriveThruRPG/DM'sGuild sale ends in 6 days.
Well...
I am a musician, and play in a band. A while ago, I started tinkering with home recording, for getting at least demos of my songs down and learning about recording processes and techniques. To keep that separate from the stuff the band does, I called that solo recording project "Willy Muffin and the Bootcut Bluejeans" - "Willy" because every other blues, country, and jazz musician seems to be called Willy; "Muffin" for a pinch of mildly rude comedy that chases "Willy"; "and the Bootcut Bluejeans" because naming a solo effort as if it was a group of people tickles my sense of humour, and the guitarist from the band I'm in likes to take the piss for me wearing bootcut jeans.
As you can see, the channel is a mixture of all sorts - gaming, music, and anything else that comes to my mind. I set it up originally for music, but it's turned into something for all of my various hobbies and interests.
So... that is why the channel is called Willy Muffin. I bet you're glad you asked, now ;)
As for the Top 10, the general framing is done - I just need to finish off editing the audio. So hopefully, within the next couple of days.
@@WillyMuffinUK, that makes sense now. :D Thanks for explaining. :D
Hey Willy, I like much of what you say in your videos. E.g. your emphasis that this list is subjective, and e.g. how you said exactly what you meant with the phrase "without further rambling" instead of the cliche "without further ado". :)
Thank-you!
@@WillyMuffinUK, you're welcome :)
Love Reptile God, We had way more success with this than say Assassins' Knot.
Hate the Slave Lord Series. Didn't mind the scenario where you are dropped in the dungeon with nothing but it was an eventual TPK.
Ho Hum.
Sounds like a bad experience. I've never experienced a TPK with it before.
Hated the finale of the slave lords module. Loved attack and slave pots adventures. Good stuff
@@ronniejdio9411 I'll take a look. We did drop in I guess it was the Finale. As I say I liked the module but then we ended up against the final big bads with no actual history or knowledge and got fried. Maybe better if you work your way through the first two and learn more about them? Still feels like they slip through your hands if they have to be around for the finale which is a pretty plot armoured railroad which I am not keen on.
@Biff Strong I like the idea of being captured ans turned loose in t h e caverns naked and weapons less. I hate it as the finale to this run. I've ran it 3 times anndi think I solved it. I switch the stockade module to the finale and shot can the island one. Whoever survives those first two thenparty has historybwith and can have a giant assault final battle in the module after the sneaking around. Also I like have the blind fire proof slave lord in the final battle he's great. Just gotta drop appearances if him in through the modules
Gygax is pronounced Guy Gax not Guy Jax.
Yes, and Malcomson is spelled Malcomson not Malcolmson - so I say we're even.