Day 13: A Case for The Analog Zettelkasten vs. Digital (Obsidian, Notion, The Brain) PKM Systems
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 12 ม.ค. 2024
- Join the mailing list for info on getting my book "Curators of Wisdom: The Art of Divine Connections - Things Spiritual and Secular - Using the Zettelkasten" as well as the latest information on the community "The Curators' Conclave":
chadrick-mahaffey.ck.page/f80...
On day 13 of my "Talk to Camera" challenge, I make my case for the analog Zettelkasten versus the digital PKM tools out there. If you can relate to me in this, try it and experience it for yourself. What do you have to lose? - บันเทิง
Dear Chadrick, this is the best video I have seen about Zettelkasten (and believe me, I have seen many, many). You have helped me tremendously in choosing the Analog format, especially because I also have ADHD and this is the first time I have seen a video where there is a relationship between Analog system-people with ADHD. Your video is not only inspirational, but a great help! Apps and digital formats are good, great aids, but they are not for everyone! For a person like me with ADHD, the digital format and apps, are truly intellectual suicide!!!! Thank you very much and God bless you!
A, this is the Video you referred to. I must have been blind, while searching for it! I watch later on comment on it.
I relate to this very much. I spend a lot more time thinking about the system than about the thoughts itself. And whenever I write digitally I spend more time thinking about formatting the note and making it look tidy than about what I'm writing, and I feel that after so many notes nothing has really stuck to my brain.
I recently changed to a disc bound notebook where I can move pages around to keep different topics together, and I can see clearly in my brain what I wrote, where it is, and as I write it down I can feel my thoughts flowing with it. When it comes to personal knowledge, writing slowly and having time to to really process the information is not a bug, it's a feature.
Very insightful Chadrick. You really inspire me to further my investigation into the analog route. Subbed.
Thanks Chadrick. Your video is very helpful
I use Obsidian. What I need is to get information from PDFs and access that quickly based on a query or tag.
I never know what I will eventually use it for until I actually need it. The time I would have to spend creating note cards precludes using it as a solution. I cannot query so many highlighted elements and annotations so quickly as Obsidian.
I can port all that information to Scrintal without missing a beat. (Scrintal might be my next move.) So, whatever comes along that is more flexible, more functional is seamless, so long as it supports markdown and its linking feature.
That’s an information retrieval system, not a knowledge management system. This is the error 99% make and thus produce no profound works
Thank you for sharing your perspective and experience as a programmer.
Very good video (and my introduction to your channel - hello!) I've been thinking about the same for a while, and that's also the reason I stopped using emacs after uni: Every time I started it up, I found myself working on emacs rather than working on my projects :) As for the "productiviy tool comparison" videos, it's a cottage farm. Just like the EDC channels. Digital consumerism.
I like your insights on Analog Zettelkasten vs Digital. This video has really helped me decide on how I am going to take the Zettelkasten approach.
I'm glad you found it helpful. Please keep us posted on how it's going. I'd love to hear the lessons you learn along the way so I too can learn more.
tesla or whoever once said 'if i had only 5 minutes to fall a tree, i would spend first 3 sharpening the axe' im writing my own PKM that is it. And yeah it probably was Franklin and not Tesla - my PKM is still being built so i have no idea
Your completely right. I've spent so much time setting up my Obsidian vault and templates. I'm looking at Zettelkasten, but I'm not sure it fits for me. I too work in IT, and I'm not sure I can break things down small enough for a single 6x4 card. I'll keep researching before I decide.
Chadrick,
Just a subtle reminder, in the last couple videos you made your “On Air” light isn’t on. Thank you also for suggesting I look up the definition of “glue man”.
Pete
Thank you! I'll have to remember that. I am writing a checklist that I'll go over before each recording ;)
Thanks for the video, I am on the journey of finding a good PKM tool that suits my needs and as a young person (also a programmer haha), I am constantly trying to learn new things and there are various distractions such as getting stuck or becoming too dependent of some software, and it is very overwhelming to see the tons of information that there is these days and how can I retain all.
I appreciate the advice and experience you share, it helps a lot.
Excuse my bad english.
@@yogurt50003 I'm glad this video has helped. I really hope you find a tool that works for you. If you try to create an analog Zettelkasten, please let me know how it goes. God bless.
Je suis arrivé exactement à la même conclusion.
Tous ces outils, toutes ces applications, sont des objets brillants. Une source de distraction.
Leur but étant qu’on les utilise selon le schéma prévu.
Mais tout disparaît, tout est « dans le cloud ».
Mon smartphone est une source de distraction.
Mon carnet de note ne l’est pas du tout. Écrire me fait du bien et m’apaise.
Et surtout : je me relie. Ce n’est pas un fichier « pour plus tard ». Qui est « jamais » 😂
Je découvre encore le Zettlekasten, le PKM, et j’ai enfin trouvé ce qui me va bien.
Pour info, je suis un ancien informaticien 😉
Bonjour de France. 🇫🇷
Story of my life bro...
And came to the same conclusion....just pick a system and move on, even if it's not perfect.
I am very interested in how your system relates to Biblical studies.