Dr. Nagaswamy Demolishes Dravidianism: Part 1
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 พ.ย. 2024
- अब हिंदी बोल के साथ ! bit.ly/HindiNa...
This is part 1 of a 3-part series with Dr. Nagaswamy.
The thesis of Dr. Nagaswamy is as follows:
1. The ancient Tamil classics that comprise the foundation of Tamil culture are based on Vedas, Manu’s Dharmashastra as a code of worldly life. The most important Tamil text claimed by Dravidian chauvinists for separate origins from Vedas is Tirukkural. Yet the 3 books it consists of are in direct correspondence with the structure and content of Dharmashastra.
2. Book 1 of Tirukkural is Aram which is an exact correspondence of Dharma. Book 2 called Porul exactly corresponds to Artha in Manu’s system. And Book3 called Kama is a Tamil version of Manu’s thesis on Kama. The sequence as well as exact structure matches perfectly in both Tamil Tirukkural and Sanskrit Dharmashastras.
3. Dr. Nagaswamy shows point by point that exact correspondence between this foundational Tamil text and certain Sanskrit shastras.
4. For example, there is EXACT correspondence between the Sanskrit shastras practice of Pancha-maha-yajna (five great yajnas) and their Tamil equivalents, in the ceremonial offering of food to: 1) Devas, 2) Rishis, 3) Pitri/ancestors, 4) Atithi/guests, and 5) Bhuta or other living beings. Dr Nagaswamy shows that the exact same Sanskrit verses are translated into Tamil.
The second episode of this interview can be viewed here: • Dr. Nagaswamy Compares...
The third part of this interview can be viewed here: • Dr. Nagaswamy Explains...
To donate to Infinity Foundation’s projects including the continuation of such episodes and the research we do:
इनफिनिटी फ़ौंडेशन की परियोजनाओं को अनुदान देने के लिए व इस प्रकार के एपिसोड और हमारे द्वारा किये जाने वाले शोध को जारी रखने के लिए: infinityfoundat...
To Subscribe to Rajiv Malhotra Official:
राजीव मल्होत्रा ऑफिसियल की सदस्यता लेने के लिए: / @rajivmalhotraofficial
Join Rajiv's discussion (राजीव की चर्चा से जुडें): groups.google....
![ทุกครั้งที่หลับตา (Lucid Dream) - AYLA's [ Official MV ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4i1OBAQyv58/mqdefault.jpg)
Hats off Tamil Culture.. Respect from a Bengali.. We are all one....
Brother, I do not want to talk north or south, but Thamiz people have great regard for Bengalis as Bengalis are the immediate blood brothers and sisters in terms of love for language! Even my girl is a Bengali!
We Tamils love you too 😊 our respectfully Nethaji is from bengal.
We tamils are people who love NETHAJI very much. We love Bengalis very much.☺️☺️☺️
Rahul Ghosh we are also people of Kali Amman or Kali ma. We love Bengalis so much from bottom of my heart.
Indian culture has four limbs that are Tamil (and the other four southern states), Bengali (including Odisha and Assam), Hindi Belt (North and Central India), and Marathi (Gujarat and Maharashtra). Another great limb was Sindh/Punjab that was lost in the past. We also added a few limbs in South East Asia that were again lost in the past.
Yes to Tamil no to Dravidianism. The whole of India, from North to South, from East to West we are all internally unified and connected, no matter how diversified we are. Jai BHARAT.
@Mello Grdd why you guys are so stupid, you mean people in the north never workshipped you guys are totally in a brainwashed propaganda which is ok, You also have to keep in mind there are hundred of temples demolished in north india also Taxila and Nalanda major libraries are burnt, leave about the other libraries. The lies won't let you go anywhere this is all funny, even your tamil ancestors will be embarrassed seeing all this stupidity.
@Mello Grdd dravida means land of the coast that is south India which was coined by sankaracharya, dravida is just a geographical identity and not the cultural one.
I am a kannadiga i know the truth pls do your research and come to a conclusion.
Sanskrit was demolished by British which was spread across the whole subcontinent, that's why all languages
consists of Sanskrit words.
@Mello Grdd I am malayali and im not Dravidian or aryan. I am hindu🙏
I am a malayali and I am a drvidian
If one Great Work that The Modi Goverment has done, it is Recognizing and Awarding Shri Dr. Nagaswamy Ji for His Splendidly Breathtaking Work...
Dr.Nagaswamy is a genius and we should be proud to live in the same time. His wisdom is a treasure for true Tamilians.
Update, not just for Tamil people but for whole Nation and to the world at large. 😇
That is your view. We do not rate him high as we have first hand experience with brilliant archaeologists including Dr. Nagaswamy's mentor who was my father.
@@gowrishankarsrinivasan3852 what
He is a BJP member and Sanskrit scholar
No his a fraud guy, and am tamil...his changing the the unique things of thirukural and , mixing hindu mythologies..🤦🏽♂️
I am so happy to see how well the Tamil culture has preserved ancient Hinduism. I am from Jammu. We Hindus are all one, as Dr Nagaswamy proves. I am sure Thiruvalluvar lived at least a thousand years before Christ. What a joke, the lying missionaries claiming Thiruvalluvar copied the Bible! Lol.
Unless Dravidian myth is rooted out completely thru thorough scholarship from multiple disciplines and retake the narratives to a more correct one, this uphill battle is one of the toughest ones. Congrats to Dr Nagaswamy for drawing parallels to what is almost obvious after it is pointed. The Breaking India forces are in hyperdrive in TN, with the dravidian poison for over 5 decades killing the roots of the civilization and legacy. High time to turn the tide.
The universitis are all pested and corrupted in literature and phylosaphy
Last a hundred years by British christain
missions and Dravida parties.
Christian missionary have started dismantling and defaming Hindustan.
Yes we need to stand up to. Enough is enough
Started? They have been doing it for over 200 years.
@@knowledgeworld9458 Exactly! I never thought about it having myself studied in a missionary school.
Oh funny @Vijay Narain Mishra, First of all, I am a hindu devotee with a passion for history. Nagaswamy born to Sanskrit pundit Ramachandran Sastrigal. He graduated in Sanskrit from the University of Madras and pursued a master's degree in Sanskrit. This same legend who accused Carbon(C14) dating is wrong which calculated the date of IVC, Sumerian, Egyptian, but he will accept Vedic civilization is 1500 BC without any evidence. If anyone asks how u came to the conclusion on Vedic civilization, he told Max Muller told it, the fact is Max Muller never came to India and Muller also declared Tamil, Telugu, Malayalam, Kannada are Dravidian language not related to Sanskrit but Nagaswamy's intellectual mind will not accept Max Muller in it. He also served as director of the archaeology of Tamilnadu, during his tenure, he excavated a site called Alakankulam in 1986 he dig only 11 points even after getting enough evidence he purposely closed the project never sent that evidence to any research. Even today no one knows where are those evidence. If anyone wants to know the history of India never listen to it from a brahmin for them everything starts from Veda's and ends in Ram temple, true they even tried to convert donkey to the horse in Indus valley but luckily the world is awake this time. I apologize if I hurt anyone, If u want to conduct a scientific study u should have an open mind. Think when Gallelio in 1663 said the world was spherical, then Vatican pope gave him the death penalty, but now in 1992, the Pope apologized in public. For the past few decades, there is a study to trace the first language of humans called Nostratic studies or world mother tongue studies by pan world linguistic researchers. According to it, all humans in the world spoke one language at a time, for this study our so-called Sanskrit intellectuals submitted their studies. As recent progress, they were able to crack the roots of the entire Indo-European(Sanskrit comes under it) language into 472 root words but they can't pull it back to 9000 years. The oldest Indo European language is Anatolia once spoken near turkey. Then coming to Tamil go and search for a relation between Indus Valley civilization and Tamil, from Iravatha Mahadevan IAS,"JOURNEY OF CIVILISATION INDUS TO VAIGAI" by Balakrishnan IAS these above two books are based on science and evidence not on any myth. Rakhigarhi is the answer for you guys, 4500-year-old woman DNA proves there is no link with steppes pastorals(Aryan) haplogroup (R1A1), it matches with Ancestral South Indian (ASI), not with Ancestral North Indian(ANI), where this adds up the Indus valley civilization developed flourished without Vedas,Sanskrit,Aryans and without any Vedic religious worship. Also, search about Australian aborigines and Tamils relation.
NOTE: read it with an open mind, passion to truth and without hatred.
@Rajasekar Srinivasan Sorry, to be specific it's one of the 445 Indo-European languages and comes under the Indo-Iranian family. I hope u will accept that revolves around the sun and not vice versa which is also against our texts.
Thirukural is not only for Tamils but a way of life to be read and followed by everyone
Tamil Brahmins have ALWAYS had the best of both worlds of Sanskrit and Tamil... and that surely translates into a super-edge....
Sivaram Hariharan This also fires back. When knowledge is not shared then people end up misinterpreting the knowledge. This is what happened with misinterpretation of several Hindu texts.
We should make sure Sanskrit and Tamil Hindu texts are available and learnt by all.
Who stopped the scriptures?
I seriously do not see any brahmins especially Tamil brahmins stopping learning. It is the so-called Davidian psuedo secular government that wants no mention of scriptures as much as possible in the education system.
TAKSVENKAT How will knowledge be shared and information channels are controlled by west . People whether of north or south have a disease of trusting west . It does not come in hindu mind that people would deliberately do such a thing .
how many tamil brahmins know how to read or speak sanskrit today?
Sufficient enough to keep at least 18% journal contribution to the national samskritic community.
What a marvelous work by Dr.நாகசுவாமி. Superb insight to get a crystal clarity on Sanskrit and Tamil travelled together. These politicians twisted and kept Tamils in dark.
I am Tamil from my childhood we used to pray in Tamil. For Sanskrit people Vedas means Tamil people Thiruvasagam. We don hate sanskrit. Good things comes from Any were we should take it. All Brothers and sisters of india , we should unite. Stop fighting in name of language. U pray in Sanskrit , we Tamils pray in Tamil so only we r treating our language as a holy language. WE ALL ARE INDIAN. we should talk care of our brothers and sisters and our nation.
Ethane Hunt This is understandable. ✌️👍
Ethane Hunt : Namaste 🙏 I agree with your views. Same culture just different languages.
I love the word we are all Indians.My birh & death is Indian.My soul is Indian.I love India.❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
but you said sanskrit is superior , how can we accept it. we tamils have very long tradition we do not need any body for any teachings ok. if you came as immigrant into bharatham ok mind your own business. do not poke your nose.
Yes agreed
Tamil and Bharata (India) are one and the same both with emotions and spirituality. This video throws light on how Tamil scripture and Sanskrit scripture same.
Hope this video clarifies what is wrong with false Dravidian-ism.
i KNEW THIS SINCE A LONG TIME having read many translated sanskrit texts and tamil texts but now confirmed by a great archaeologist ; this is not a surprise at all to me but we knew that the politicians were hellbent to deform this truth that whole BHARAT is a homogeneous and hollistique culture from north to south and from east to west
th-cam.com/video/C0KMXbtoTcg/w-d-xo.html
@நாகராஜ ஐயர்- சேர பாண்டிய நாட்டு அந்தணன் whether Tamils origin is pre vedic or post vedic the present pseudo tamil scholars are all anti vedic
Please talk with scientific evidence and facts don't vomit PERVERTED Sanskrit myths.
Sanskrit didn't even had a script to write till 4 CE note it is CE not BCE, it adopted devanagari script in 4 CE and started writing puranas like Ramayana
Actually Sanskrit copied words from Tamil not the other way around
Thiruvalluvar says all humans are equal (பிறப்பொக்கும் எல்லா உயிர்க்கும் சிறப்பொவ்வா
செய்தொழில் வேற்றுமை யான் - திருக்குறள் 972)
But in manusmriti manu discriminate people based on birth called Varna
Tamil grammar and Sanskrit grammar are totally different like North and South poles they are not the same.
For example some Sanskrit phonetics can Not be even written in Tamil
What a clarity of thought by Dr Nagasamy !
Sir are you a Tamil
CBSE/ICSE should create chapters on cultural and spiritual unity of India with help from Dr. Nagaswamy. Its very important all Indians learn these unifying traits as children.
Hinduism is one. Aryan Dravidian theory is rejected by all scholars.
mana Naga in Hinduism culture is religion and it's a collection of principles. How does it even matter that which is the first, second or last classical language of India?
Saswoti saila suta .
.When it comes to accept superiority of tamil the aryans will show their real face.
Saswoti saila suta Tamils are not Dravidians. Dravidians separated Tamils from Aryans for rulling them.
Senthil ganapathy Why does anyone want the superiority ? is this an effing competition? Even in puranas, shiva is not superior to Vishnu or vice versa. Without shiva, there is no Vishnu, or without Vishnu, there is no significance for shiva. It's not about superiority, it's always about significance.
Senthil ganapathy so sad that you believe in this myth propagated for vote banks. Think of the great sacrifices done by our ancestors for the protection of dharma . But these days nobody cares about dharma and infact everyone has become self centered. Those who consider themselves as masters of human rights are content in staging some protests . But when it really comes to solve the problem why do they fail?? In fact we are doomed cause we have divided ourselves.
I am proud to be part of this movement through TH-cam. When can we recognise our sacred past and when can we live as one community with highest level of value systems?
Thank you Dr. Nagaswamy for your scholarly work. I will surely read your book.
And I hope your great effort will bring my fellow Indians closer, so that India may rise again as one harmonious, diverse, dharmic nation.
Definitely, I will surely read the book as well.
Great🕉🙏🙏🙏
Tamil culture is an important and inseparable part of Bharata culture from the very beginning
No one in my family, including myself, or extended family have ever lived in Tamil Nadu... None of us understand Tamil... But I have always been taught to venerate Sri Thiruvalluvar Ji as Dakshin Vyasa inasmuch as Maharishi Agastya too as Dakshin Vashishtha... I love Tamil Nadu... Their Grand Temples... Simply Fantastic, Flawless, Phenomenal Vedic Chantings and Yagyas...
Maharishi agastya is a person who don't need any adjective
The biggest enemy of the Hindu culture is the Hindus. Being ignorant of the large body of work in different languages. This kind of scholarship is the need of the hour. Fellow citizens in the north of India should seek to learn more about other subculture alien to the cow belt. South in spite of anti-hindi current are aware of Ramayan and Mahabharat. But not many people up north are aware of any non-hindi epics.
thirukkuraL (kuraL) , PHILOSOPHY OF PENINSULAR INDIA. is a compendium of many things pertaining to human values and thought. They are brief and precise, well written without any vagueness or confusion either in meaning or syntax. The verses are direct in their concept and clear in their meaning. The classic kuraL is a book that does not deal with any speculative concepts, as found in the Upanishads . Speculation gives raise to multiple interpretations and the possible conflicts. They ultimately divide the society they intend to enrich. The vagueness and speculative character encourages people with vested interests to meddle with the text by inserting passages.
Tamil culture believes in equality of living beings at birth. Thirukkural 972.
But Sanatana dharam differentiates humans by birth into four divisions, varna, keeping the Brahmins at top.
www.amazon.in/PHILOSOPHY-PENINSULAR-INDIA-THIRUKKURAL-ARAM-VISWESWARAN-ebook/dp/B079NL99RQ/ref=sr_1_1?s=digital-text&ie=UTF8&qid=1520039876&sr=1-1&keywords=visweswaran
@@adhavamuruganjawahar2999 it seems u r among those who called themselves Moolnivasi.
Go and read again... Bt u wont as u blv on idiotic teachings of ur so called leaders and brahmins who r mentally ill and blv on caste base work.
Ohh ..so now mahabharat and ramayana is North Indian story....then say also that Krishna was North Indian black God. .. how stupid u people are.. and what does cow belt means... I think u are heavily influenced by beef eaters..or u urself had forget the roots of ur history ..
@@niteshsrivastava3122 beef eating always common in India especially both in harappan and Vedic period. It's was Buddhist and Jain who initiated veganism around 500BC. Brahmayajna is sacrifice done only by Brahmin. This is section come under dharmasatra. Upto 1950s cow sacrifice by Kashmiri brahmin is common. It was Indian law to ban cow sacrifice. But Kashmiri continued eating meat upto 1987.
www.quora.com/Do-Kashmir-Pandits-eat-meat
Mowgli That’s what makes southern people to become upset about north?!
Dravidian rule should end and tamils rule should raise in tamilnadu. Then tamilnadu will blossom.☺️☺️☺️☺️
Tamil nadu is the second largest economy in India as per RBI. In Human development index its in top 3 as per UNITED NATIONS. It's already blossomed i don't understand why most have hate against performing states.
@@hariprasadsudharsan The Chennai water crisis say otherwise!
@@hariprasadsudharsan they want tamil nadu to develop like bihar. .
@@hariprasadsudharsan Due to AD MK. AD MK is Dravidian for namesake. But it's good overall.
I'm currently reading Rajiv Ji's book Breaking India (at present on the 6th chapter) and then tried to find relevant videos related to that chapter and found this. I'm completely amazed and so overwhelmed by Rajiv Ji's effort for the cause of Dharma. He is doing all this in the true spirit of Yajna (service/sacrifice) as per Vedas. I'm trying to tell as many people about this and trying to spread the word for them to buy the book and read it too. We must be the voice and hands supporting Rajiv ji like an Intellectual Kshatriya as Rajiv ji says for unity and integrity of our great land of Bharat. Also, many many thanks to Dr. Nagaswamy for this life long effort for this service of Dharma which is enlightening us and helping us find our roots and take pride in it. #ArjunaArise #TheTimeIsNow
Love to all Tamils from Assam,Jai Hind 😊🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Loves from tamilnadu 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
every tamil atheist in Tamil Nadu should see this video because they are trying to separate the tamil culture with hindu indian culture ... this video shows how tamil and hindu is one based in Thirukural ... thank you RMji for the great video.
Well. English alphabet starts with 'a'. Does it mean that western culture follows Manu smriti?
such a scholar of tamil and sanskrit is trying to correct the history and unit all indians .dont u believe ur own people then whom us believe mr venkata subramanian. the westerner?
You are going off the subject.Dravidianism was a concept in Tamil Nadu espicially propagated by the Dravidian political parties and they were going on with the theory that Thiruvalluvar's Thiru kural has nothing to do with Sanskrit or the Vedas.This false theory is being demolished by Dr.Nagaswamy.The eminent historian,architect and Sanskrit scholar in conjunction with Rajiv Malhotra has made headway in rejecting the concept of Dravidianism and the Aryan Invasion theory.Both these concepts were introduced with rigour by the British which wished to see a tukde tukde India as the JNU students wanted.The Periyar and the succeeding political leaders including Karunanidhi was harping on this false ideas for a long time.The Christians took advantage of this bogus theory and conversion was going on in full swing.This Dr Nagaswamy refuting saying that Thirukural is exactly an abridgement of Sastras, Manusmriti.
They will learn nothing as it would not serve their purpose of divide and rule. You can take the horse to the pond; you cannot force it to drink. All politicians are hippocrates.
+Venkata Subramanian, Western culture has nothing to do with Manu Smriti! But, the fact remains that a host of Western Scholars have admitted that Sanskrit is the mother of World languages!
Proud of being a Sanatani. Sanatani culture is eternal and the only original culture of Akhand Bharat. 🥰🚩🚩🇮🇳❤❤
A final blow to the afro-dalit project by breaking india forces.
Kashmiri Pandits do the same as Tamilians; we do not eat without laying aside a morsel of food for the birds - but now it is only done during fasting days or pooja days.
Telugu and marathi brahmins do that also my guy. Have to put the north plains in the context of invasions. The hindus of the north faced psychological trauma theougg continuous invasions. They could have forgot some traditions.
Yes it is done even by me, from Karnataka.
Before eating parishinchane is a must.
The British have already done us a lot of damage. They had successfully divided us before using ridiculous theory of Aryan invasion which now stands completely rejected. We need to unite now. We unite as people of one Sanatana Dharma and nothing else.
What British done a damage? they basically united us as a country, may be for their own benefit but India is a single country now. If you want to blame, blame the Fringe group, who denied Veda to all and kept only for them in the name of GOD.
Very aptly said Jagdeesh...they divided us on religion, caste, sub-caste and sowed the seed of upper-caste and lower caste too...time to re-unite and like the other comments mention here, study the vast body of works across the country and draw our opinions....
Nobody denied any learning to anyone Karthikeyan....the society was divided into groups based on their profession and somewhere the inferiority and superiority slabs got created...time to forget about that and embrace these beautiful works!
Karthikeyan S Veda would have 1000 versions if it was distributed then. Now it stands protected
@@bansurishankar What British brought Caste system to India ?? Or was it Manu Dharma initiative? Sad that Why is there such blatant lie spread in a brazen shameless attempt to glorify untruth.
Tamilnadu is a great land and Tamil bretherns are a great people .Tamil literature is one of the best in the world .From people like Rajgopalachari and C.V.Raman to Thiruvallur the Tamilians are respected the world over.Even in these days Tamilians are excelling in their chosen fields around the Globe and I firmly believe they will continue to make big strides and make every Indian proud.
Wow ..amazing..mesmerizing just to hear the scholars talking about the spiritual unity which lies beneath our superficial physical appearances which unfortunately divide us
Amazing
do see his video also on buddhism & hinduism
name of the budhha and dalit agression whole agitation working like slave for mawo
now mawo identy & naxal identy teach us which one is correct or lies
Thank you Rajiv ji for bring Dr.Nagaswamy to the show.. i've learned a lot today.
Very informative. All Tamil Brahmins know and accept what Dr. Nagaswamy is saying.
Santana Dharma and all our Indian languages go hand in hand.
There is lot of corruption in Tamil language alphabets pronunciation etc. there has been a conscious effort to diverge from Sanskrit base due to Dravidian rule in Tamil Nadu.
The thing now is Tamil is not Hindu
But these Dravidian parties will never say Tamil is not Muslim or Christian. People having Hindu names are Christians.
For example A person with name uma shankar or Arumugam which are lord Shiva and Subramanya names will preach Christianity and convert People. This is the level of penetration of the church
Loved every second of this video
So enlightening...
Thank you❤
Love for tamizh & tamil culture from u.p
This is truly fascinating and significant as we work at making sense of our world and restoring a healthy perspective of life.
Beautiful presentation of the cultural and philosophical unity of Bharatha! 🙏
Indians must wake up, and break free from the divisive agenda of the "Breaking India" forces!!
Let's preserve this beautiful, age old tradition that we have inherited! Vande Mātaram 🇮🇳
I am a Kannadiga , who does research on world langugaes and i have good knowledge in Arabic, Chinese , Hindi, Telugu and Kannada , when did reserach on Indian linguistic scripts, the only TWO languages thats stands firm independently is Sanskrit and Tamil . Between the 2, Tamil is older both spoken and written, not to deny in the medevial period Tamil was influenced by sanskrit and begots Kannada, Tulu Brahui , Telugu and latest which is Malayalam which compises the DRAVIDIAN family . Likewise one cant deny the fact Sanskrits langugae birth itself is never without the influence of Tamil , and later the language that got begotten from the influence of Tamil did have the counter influence itself . Egoism is what pulling India down. Hindi which is persian and sanskrit influence tend to lock horns with Tamil. Reason being sasnkrit is so call dead and only live in te alter so hindi takes the position to counter the much ancient Tamil which is purely politics . We have to just accept the fact . Indian soil is the home to such an ancent language but due to egoism much later born languages like chinese and arabic is clamiing that they are older when we have the oldest 2 in hand just that our ego is not willing to accept sanskrit as no 2 . This will just kill us .
Big Question... if Tamil is older than Sanskrit and Hindu religion was developed by Tamilians who once were also residents of Indus Valley and were thrown out by invading Aryans then why were the Hindu scripts not written in Tamil instead of in Sanskrit.
@@pallavisharma8773 who told you that Tamils developed hindu religion?
Ancient Tamil worshipped God, but they are irreligion. They didn't develop any religion . Step out of your brahmin ego, think wise.
Well said my frend
@@krushgo1934 why did you mention anything about being Brahmin. Is this some kind of misplaced ego/complex you have that prompted you?
Now coming to normally discussing the subject.... it is being proved scientifically that IVC existed along Saraswati and so called mythology i.e. itihaas of Indian civilisation also happened around the time the river flowed. Mahabharata happened just before the Saraswati fully disappeared. Since in those times Sanatan Dharm was followed one can derive that the IVC ppl were followers of the same dharma. The word Arya was in use from Ramayana time. So whoever they were.... Aryans or IVC ppl they were in that regions from 17000 years.
Also latest excavation in Tamil Nadu shows that there was a flourishing civilisation around the same time if not older in South India. So nobody pushed anybody down South. Migrations happen all the time. Who knows how many ppl moved up North from South and vice versa in the thousands of years since the IVC.
Check out these videos to get scientific facts:
th-cam.com/video/3tsyzrDg2n4/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/Va0BIqfzpvo/w-d-xo.html
Prakrit languages? Jain and Buddhist scripture? Hebrew? Greek? Various tribes in India?
We Hindus should destroy anything that tries to break our unity in diversity . Thumbs up guys ( especially Tamililan) if u agree 👍
I am reading "Breaking India". Great Book...
Manish verma MO
Impressed with his knowledge and his keen interest on comparative studies.Thankyou So Much Rajiv sir.
Exceptional. The unity of our cultures is clearly elucidated. Actually, division has happened from both sides although it is more emphasized in Tamilnadu now, by the fake Dravida movement which was in fact started by a bunch of non-Tamil commies. But these black shirt wearers who know nothing about anything, have thoroughly corrupted our society and it requires many more factual efforts like this to even engage people into some form of thinking. Look forward to the next parts and more on the same topic.
I understood what I need to study to shape my life on the path of Dharma. Thanks a lot both of you
Thirukkural is a Translation of Vedic education and Upanishads. The Christian missionaries
twisted that and added their lies to confuse and convert the Tamil people who are strong Hindus.
Rajiv Malhotra's work is really fantastic. Pranams to Nagaswamy acharya.. A Hope rising very fast to review our dumped western knowledge with our proud vedic cultural roots ..
Thank you very much sir.
can somebody show this to mk stalin, karuna nidhi brigade please who is thriving on a hoax of dravidanisam.
KUNAL PATEL The thing is they won't. These idiots love being in the delusion they're in.
Dravin ka matalab hota hai
Jal water se otprot Area of
Earth.
Patels, Nishras, Guptas burning... 😂
@@ramduttmishra1978 Dravid comes from the word Travid jis ka matlab hai ki jahan 3 samudri tat milte hain. Yaane Bay of Bengal, Arabian sea and Indian ocean. Aur woh jagah hai south India. Baaki ye dravidism sub bakwass theory hai jisko angrajon ne bunaya tha aur hum hindustani bhi use maan gaye the.
THEY R CORRUPTED BY WEST, MONEY CORRUPTS. PEOPLE WHO TRY TO DIVIDE COUNTRY R TRAITORS WHICH INCLUDE ITALIAN MAFIA THUGS KGB AGENTS
Many thanks Shri Rajiv Malhotra . For me it is revisiting THIRUKKURAL (1st C AD) after my schooling days lessons in late 1950's in Colombo. I bought a copy in Chennai in 1993. Wonderful recap. God bless. Best Wishes from London, UK .
Tamil Culture -An Intergral Part of Sanatana Dharma: Aravindan NeelakandanWATCH: th-cam.com/video/QryC0as2fp0/w-d-xo.html
Together we r called as Great India (Bharat)..proud on our diversified cultures .
Awesome work with factual and detailed analysis............easy to understand presentation of the origins of the INDIA's bedrock traditional dharma, ethos, values and culture. Hope the amateur wannabe politician Kamal Hasan (a certified atheist with Maoist leanings) reads this valuable book who is hell bent to break Tamil Nadu from India, to create a separate Dravidian identity. Many thanks Dr. Nagaswamy
Great talk by Dr. Nagaswamy. The similarity is amazing. I do not want to bring in politics here but one must note that the word 'Dravida" a Sanskrut term was first used by Sri Adi Shankaracharya while introducing himself prior to start of a debate with Sri Mandana Mishra, in Varanasi. He was giving his location of where he came from(Geographical location) which translates into as a body of land with sea(ocean) on three sides, a peninsula. Sri Shankara was born in present day Kerala in Kaladi, called himself 'Dravida Shishu". I believe when debating Sri Mishra, he was a kid of only 12 or 13 years. He left home and his Mother when he was only 6 years old.
I guess the DMK guys in TN, have to find a new word to define themselves and their doctrine.
It is people like Robert Caldwel who made us aware of the greatness of dravidian languages which are far richer and older than hindi
Robert Caldwell was a typical missionary. He learnt Tamil to proselytize. He was an evangelist. Trusting any evangelist is dangerous, coz they view everything via the Christian lens. We know that the amount of havoc wreaked by Christianity is only next to Islam.
@t s Muthuraman we respect Tamil as much as sanskrit.... Both are sister languages and... Every lang is derived languages
Sir, if possible, please add the link to buy the book mentioned in the discussion inside the description provided. Thanks
Soumya Behera
giri.in/index.php/catalog/product/view/id/36539/key/18cd8e7b62bd82b139ff454b298f1a53
thank you nagaswamy sir for your great work.
This is not Dr. Nagaswamy Ji... This is like Bhagwan Shankara Himself... Beauiful... Lovely... And a Really Grand-Fatherly Explanation... Feeling like I am listening to Voice of the Rishis... He is explaining so affectionately...
Dr. Nagaswamy nailed it. Thank you Sri Rajiv Malhotraji🙏 You both are modern age sage.
Happy to know Akhanda Bharatha (South Asia) had a wonderful Knowledge Management system sustained for 8 millenniums. Namo Rushis. Namo Hindutva. Namo Akhanda Bharatha.
From Hindi belt but I love Thirukkural,
In Madras High Court, there is a statue for "Manu Needhi Cholan" who is known for his uprightness. Unfortunately, even the High Court has changed the name of this King from "Manu Needhi Cholan" to "SAMA Needhi Cholan" for whom a statue is erected inside the Court's premises. The misconception that the word "Manu" relates to religion is nicely exposed by Dr. Nagaswamy. Hope the Madras High Court, understands what Manu Dharma Shastra means and correct the mistake of wrongly naming the great king "MANU NEEDHI CHOLAN".
Ranga Rajan, Replacing the word Manu with Sama, these foolish people are not realizing, that SAMA NEEDHI also are Sanskrit words ??
Just like, if he and his dirty politics-playing coterie were so hung up on Tamizh, he should have/STILL CAN, abandon his own name karunanidhi , give up all the royalties on his cinema compositions, all the wealth they accumulated by abusing the name KARUNANIDHI to loot Innocent masses,, for it's all alien , acchut, untouchable~~
like one of his innumerable wives and children have names like stalin, he can adopt a communist name and convert whole lifetime assets and properties into TAMIZHAGAM ASSETS, over which he has no rights, as it was all earned under the fictitious Sanskrit name KARUNANIDHI . After all, is not communist mindset founded on the basis that everything belongs to everyone. No individual has the right to accumulate wealth in his name and family alone !!??Hypocrites, bigots and SWA-DHARMA HATERS !! These are the greatest destroyers of Tamizh (ORIGINALLY SANSKRIT )PANPAADU.
This is one of the reasons why Dr Subrahmanya Swami keeps reminding all who will hear the story of dmk leader's name and the ETERNAL DEBT he owes to SRI RAMACHANDRA PRABHU OF TRETA YUGA, THE BUiLDER OF RAMA SETU OF THE YORE , with the help of Engineers like Nala & Neela .
Bakula Thompson . I understand your frustration. But we don't care about those who won't be known after their death. Anyways they are already forgotten.
Going on a personal attack does not also add value to what he's to be done to course correct. So let's concentrate on learning these literature and follow them as Thiruvalluvar says, karkka kasadara karpavai katrapin nirka adharkkuth thaga.
Instead of concentrating on what is wrong let's start concentrating on what is right and what needs to be tight. Nallavai seiya allavai theyum
You nailed it, Sir. DK/DMK are THE poisonous seeds. And karunanidhi (why did not he find a suitable alternate name in Tamil..........? only to cheat Tamilians!) and his clan are still trying to divide Tamilians from rest of India as Dravidians-Aryans. The poisonous seeds grew so large and deep rooted that they could not be uprooted in near future. In Tamil Nadu, they have already created great hate for HINDUS in general and BRAHMINS in particular. Some vested interests even have gone to the extent of propagating that THIRUVALLUVAR & THURUKKURAL does not belong to any religion, particulary HINDUISM, which is absurd and baseless.
THIRUKKURAL replicates pure VEDIC teaching of DHARMA as ARATHUPPAL - ARTHA as PORUTPAL- KAMA as KAMATHUPPAL of basic concepts of dharmic human life. After duly full filling these basic principles righteously only one can attain THE MOKSHA - THE LIBERATION.
My humble pranams to Dr. Nagaswamy for his forthright research of the HOLY scripture THIRUKKURAL and breaking the shackles of false propaganda by the Dravidian parties hither to spread and profoundly thank Mr. Rajiv Malhotra ji who brought such a great man to the notice of general public like me.
The learned court has changed the name "Manu Needhi Cholan" into "SAMA Needhi Cholan" because, the justice redered to the Cow was not based on MANU DHARMA, but on EQUALITY OF LIFE among every LIVING BEING as envisaged by THIRUKKURAL, that is SAMA NEEDHI. (SAMA means Equal).
MANU DHARMA or NEEDHI is not the same even among human beings, depending upon his birth as a Brahmin, Kshaktriya, Vysya or Sudra. A Sudra would be killed against a murder crime while a Brahmin will go scot free.
But, the Chola King gave death punishment as judgement to his own son for killing a calf of a Cow. He ought to have been called a SAMA NEEDI CHOLAN only.
He was given falsely the "MAnu Needhi Cholan" name by the scheming brahmins of yester years. That mistake was set right by the present HIGH COURT. We all should appreciate it. This Dr.Nagaswamy is trying to market the same lie that was told by his yester year counterparts.
Dr.N.Krishnan,
Dean of Science and
Professor and Head of IT & Engineering
MS University, Tirunelveli.
Ranga Rajan The word Man originates from Manu
Hinduism is a evolved religion unlike others over centuries. Every State has rituals which are similar. Every village has Ayyanar temple in the village boundary and in the same way some gods like Veerabhadra etc etc. Do not divide.
People who think that Aryan & Dravidian theories are real, probably be the same people who think earth is flat.
People who think அறம் and Dharma are same are the one who thinks Ram built a bridge 😂
This concept of Aryan and Dravidian was also FED by the same people (Earth is Flat)...
Hahaha. Have you ever heard of the word "Science"?
Out of this World! ! Really. Thanks Param Aadarniya Dr Nagaswamy and My Heartly Beloved Shri Sir Rajiv Malhotra. Osho.
Hits the head of the nail! Great work, needs to be shared and popularized....
We need people like this to write our education policy
Mera apko koti koti pranam guruji for such wonderful explanations...I am proud of the
Tamil people for preserving their ancestors culture...
Great Malhotraji,More expected from this great man.A saintly person will open eyes of all Tamilians.
Tamils should listen to scholars and not politicians to know about their scriptures and history. Many Tamils get carried away by this thought that they are distinct from the Indian Hindu Culture. As a practicing Tamil-Hindu, I don't find anything to support this claim after reading Tamil scriptures. Even well 'educated' Tamils have hatred towards anything Sanskrit, Hindi and North India. It will take a lot of brain-cleansing to clear up these misconceptions from the Tamils. I appreciate your efforts!
Respect Always from West Bengal..🙏🙏🙏
Loves and respects from tamilnadu🇮🇳
Great video. Very informative.
Long live Dr Nagasamy Sir✌️ Ohm Namah Sivaya🙏🙏🙏🙏
There is a fearful reality we need to be alert to which consists of time, aging and loss. This is a wonderful upload! But I feel it is but the merely scratching the knowledge of Dr Nagaswamy. I think one needs to sit with him and record every word he says on a specific topic. Everyday.
Rajiv Sir good work. I am very much motivated to read thirukkural .being a Tamil I should have read it with the correct meanings.But you need to call People like Nellai Kannan and Solomon Pappaiya to know little more about Thirukkural.
At an age, when people lose all their vitality of life, interest diminishes, depression dwarfs the spirit to live, Dr. Nagaswamy Ji represents to young people like me how to lead a Dharmic, Selfless Life full of Devotion towards Bhagwan... His Dharma has kept Him going even at such an old age... Indeed, Dharmo Rakshati Rakshitah...
Very beautifully explained by two pious men. Hope at least now the Tamil Hindus will realise that there are no divisions like Aryas and Dravidas and both belong to the mighty religion called Sanatan Dharma!
Tirumoolar a Tamil siddhar said Tamil and Sanskrit are two eyes of Eshwaran. Sage Patanjali Danvantri Valmiki all of them sanskrit scholars who lived and died in Tamilnadu and even VedVysar lived in Vyasarpadi in Chennai. Evangelist Robert Cadwell brilliantly divided Indians for his gains and political parties took this advantage
well said
Respect to the great culture and heritage of south india , i am from North .
Very true 100%. This is unbiased study and research. The Contents of Tirukural philosophy came from Vedas & Puranas. Aryan Dravidian theories were used to divide & rule Hindus by Christians and others even today. .
Thirukural is the most comprehensive literature ever written in any language, sir. With due respect to Mr. Nagaswamy's research, his selection of comparing Thirukural is just a few drops of the ocean of knowledge in Thirukural. The Thirukural has lot more from electing a leader to the duty of a leader and duties of citizen too. Wish to see an interview on how Mr. Nagaswamy will attach those to any Sanskrit scriptures too. Thank you.
I am very happy, the truth is getting explained, I pray God it reaches all humans of world, for peace and happiness of all living beings.
Several ancient Indian literature such as Manusmriti, Kautilya's Arthashastra, Kamandaka's Nitisara bear likeness with the second book (Porul), the book on wealth, of the Kural text, while Vatsyayana's Kamasutra shares similarities with Inbam, the third book of the Kural text (the book on love). However, the attitude and approach of Valluvar in expounding the virtues remain entirely different from any of these contemporary works. While the Artha Shastra is based on subtle statecraft, the Porul of the Kural text bases morality and benevolence as its cornerstones. THE SOCIAL HIERARCHIES AND DISCRIMINATION found in Manusmriti are contrasted with Valluvar's concept of universal brotherhood and oneness of humanity. Unlike Kamasutra, which is all about eros and techniques of sexual fulfillment, the Kural text of Inbam remains a poetic appreciation of flowering human love as explicated by the Sangam period's (a Tamil literary era) concept of intimacy, known as Aham in the Tamil literary tradition.
Malini Anbuchelvan the understanding of Manu in your comments relates more to the interpretation of Veda by Max Mueller.
Great video. Always wondered what teachings the Thirukkural hold. Awating the future parts of this dialogue.
Indian culture has four limbs that are
Tamil (and the other four southern states),
Bengali (including Odisha and Assam),
Hindi Belt (North and Central India),
Marathi (Gujarat and Maharashtra).
Another great limb was Sindh/Punjab that was lost in the past. We also added a few limbs in South East Asia that were also llost in the past.
Nitin Singh : True! Thats why shankaracharya established the char dham yatra to these four parts of India I take it as an integration of South, North, East and West.
A great video, wonderful presentation by Dr. and a great contribution by Mr.Rajiv to put things in right perspective.
My Saashtaang Pranam to Bhagwan Thiruvalluvar... And to Shri. Dr. Nagaswamy Ji... And to Shri Rajiv JI...
Namaskar sir 🙏 i request you that mention some text image of important point in video so i can right note same as you add in this video. I'm prepared many notes for my family and friends who not understand english language. Dhanyawad 🙏
Mr Nagaswamy sir i want t purchase your book "Tamil Nadu the land of the Veda". I checked and mailed your site but it bounces back. Can you or Rajivji give a link about where to find it? Would be useful
You would be better off contacting Rajivji through Facebook because it is more interactive than the comment section here. Not only Rajiv, but his followers, his website administrators will help you in contacting Dr. Nagaswamy, purchasing his books. Here's the link. Good luck.
facebook.com/RajivMalhotra.Official/
Sir thanks a lot for the reply. I will try to do so.
Ramanathan Ramakrishnan you can buy it from the website of Tamil Arts Academy.
I personally went to his house in Besant Nagar, Chennai and purchased the books. His daughter lives next door and you can call her and get an appointment and purchase the books. I strongly suggest to buy bulk copies of the book and give it as a gift in Marriages, birthday and other occasions.
Send a mail to nagaswamy@
tamilartsacademy.com
I'm a Tamil and it absolutely doesn't prove anything.
Thiruvalluvar, the author of the book is widely accepted as a Jain preacher. We unanimously celebrate this book because it wasn't written with a god of particular religion in mind. Nor does this advocate for Casteism. This success of this book is in its agnostic tone.
None of his statements are shocking, controversial, revealing or "destroying". In fact, his research supports present day Dravidianism, which basically comes down to " we will teach only our language in schools".
So, let us learn in our own language and we're all happy?
Also for your info, there is a statue of the author of this book right at the southern tip. The height of the statue is 133 ft, the total no verses in the book.
Thank you for confirming my observations and thoughts when enquiring about the astonishing similarities in Indian culture in all different regions.
Lots of love and appreciation.
மிக்க நன்றி 🙏
Dear sir
Namaskaram.
I have seen many of your videos and enjoyed them to the fullest and benefited a lot in knowing our roots.
My humble request to you is to interview noted scholar Dr.SAR .Prasnna Venkatachariar. Popularly known as Chaturvedi Swamy.
Your work will not be complete without his interview.
He is widely popular among scientists all over the world attending many science conferences as main speaker.
But, he is not at all recognised in our country.
He knows 6 languages of India and English.
You can easily meet him in usa or Canada during his trip.
I am eagerly awaiting your interview with him.
Thanks
Regards.
As Vallabhbhai Patel, V P Menon contribution to united India; You could try to unite Hindu across India . It will become Greatest achievement and ever live in history if you do it - looking at your contribution you have potential to do it. And Note, every state is different - especially in tamil nadu, never approach with sanskrit impose in mind - always will fail and video like this will move you out of tamil nadu making it even more harder to achieve. Good luck! Save India from conversion.
A great revelation... hope the pseudo people spreading hatred watch and learn from this
From mischief to meditation
Why I do not see many North Indian viewers comments .. most of it is from South Indian comments ?
Manu divided by people ,but
Tirukural is expose unity
Thiruvalluvar is basically srivaishnava. He actually lived In right now we call mylapore.
I request all Tamilians to be against this divide within the Hindu community. At the end of the day we are both Hindus and there are bigger problems to address than that and you know it too.
Rajiv Ji is enlightened I can see in his face . Dr Nagaswamy is a legend
My abundance respects to Dr Nagaswamy.
*Hats off, Great Title.
What a wonderful way to go*
Thank you Rajiv ji for making this video and because of you we were able to take such important knowledge for a gem of our nation Dr. R. Nagaswamy. Rajiv ji & Dr. Swamy both of your's contribution towards Sanatan Dharma is commendable. Thanks a lot again for sharing such divine information.
Priy bhartiyon Yuvaa mere mitron.. kyun abb hum Inn Foreign Elements Kae dwara Prey ,shikar banen... Baar Baar. Ab hum Sab Milkar Jaagen. Aur Saadhana kee Aur Agamya Tapasya .. kae Is MahaYagya mein Hum Sabhi Milkar Phir sae Shaamik hon. aur Saahas Kae kadam .. aur Challlanggg laen Vaapis sae. Hum Jaagen!! Phir sae mere Bhai behno. . .Mere Hindu Puraan Sahyatriyon.. . . My Beloved Respectful Fellow Travellers... Awake .! And Walk And Run!! For Our Bhartiya Revival Kraanti.!!! Taking The Mashal in Our Hands. . .Jaagen Hum bhartiyta Hindu culture Jo jagayen. Not political Hindutv... Balki They did Right Hindu. . . By Reading and Reviving Our Bhartiya texts and Shastra by Dr Nagaswamy and With sir Rajeev . . Let Us Revive OurBhartiya Sanskriti Again. . .Namo Namo Bharatambe. . .
Wisdom is a realised experience. The persons who know many languages personify the universality of beautiful coexistence and know the importance of sharing the wisdom from one civilization and culture to other. Evolution need such spport and india must be proud its shared heritage and life style.