Nunez has the most beautiful technique and artistry in this variation! She embodies a stronger more flirtatious kitri. With that said, Osipova is full on fire in this!
В каком месте? Руки не понятно где! В музыку не попадает! Она прекрасная балерина, но эта партия не ее! Настоящая Китри это Мариэлла ,страсть, каждое движение ,как лезвие бритвы! А с музыкой просто слилась
Наталья лучшая! Сгусток страсти и энергии! Скорость! Потрясающая техника! Артистизм! Сметает все на своем пути. Захватывает полностью...)))... Ну, и как тут не вспомнить великолепнейшую Екатерину Максимову- лучшую Китри всех времен!
I think Osipova is over the top and too explosive for ballet, she lacks finesse. On the other hand, Zakharova is very soft for Kitri. That's why Nela is perfect for the role and does the best performance
@Almira Izumchensky So? I don"t like her, I suffer watching her dance. Too much force to pirouettes, needlessly. She is closed and not clean but ballet is en dehors (turn out). She is out of my Pantheón. And I don't care about what some think: millions of flies can be wrong (💩 doesn"t taste good, but they eat it 😄)
@Almira Izumchensky Goodness gracious! Why all the vitriol? Giliberto began his (or her, I’m sorry, I can’t tell by the picture or name) first comment with, “I think . . . “. I did not find it offensive. Lots of people who are well schooled in the art of ballet do not care for Osipova’s style. That’s what makes the world go around. . . different strokes for different folks! Personally, one of my favorite TH-cam videos of Osipova is the 2nd Act of Giselle, with Carlos Acosta. Mmmm, now that is almost perfection.
@@paulagiliberto7386 What is most surprising to me is that how this kind of ballerina could appear here, in Russia. Her performance is gymnastics, anything else but not ballet. I would expect this style anywhere in the world but not here.
Партия Китри не для Захаровой, в ней слишком много зазнайства, словно она снисходит до зрителя, а вообще-то похожа на гимнастку в балетной пачке, оставляет ощущение безжизненности.
@@IvaNovaaaaaaa Sure, I'm sure countless prima ballerinas don't know what they're talking about, yeah? Like Darcey Bussell, who has herself said the same about Marianela, I'm sure she hasn't got a clue.....
All of them are fantastic dancers, with different styles and charming personalities. But for me the interpretative ability and the charisma of Marianela Nunez always add that something special that definetly conquers me.
It was so mesmerising to watch Marianela's perform. It had a certain flair, a elegant but cheeky vibe to the whole performance especially when she looks back and gives a flying kiss with that smile. Natalie spit fire with her moves, she looks she gave it all and she absolutely owned the whole stage, Svetlana was smooth, elegant and looked like she was flying on the stage.
При всей моей любви к великолепной и рождённой для балета Светлане, но Марианела - ребёнок, которого боженька поцеловал в макушку. Она невероятна - техника, артистизм, баланс и идеальное исполнение. Осипова отдельно от всех))) такой огонь 🔥
@@ingkauf6176 Да по биометрии Захарова не подходит... Рост и изящные конечности не позволяют быстро подсобраться в динамичной вариации... Испанка Китри это не амплуа Захаровой... Осипова - отлично!
Marianela Nuñez nos contagia con su perfecto dominio de los movimientos españoles sin escatimar ésa actitud tan especial que tales exigen... Efectivamente Núñez despliega una energía pasional en su interpretación inigualable...
Osipova has the fire, technique, and speed, mesmerizing to watch, but she loses a bit of the artistry of the part. Nunez doesn’t have the speed or fire, but she has the upper body and port de bras for the part. You can really see the flamenco influence.
I would say Osipova showed off technique and speed where it wasnt necessary for the role whereas Nunez had the fire, passion and intensity. Her movements were strong.
This is Osipova/Sarafanov at La Scala. It always makes me smile to watch the toreadors in the background, especially the dark- haired dancer third from the left. The are mesmerized by Osipova's stage presence just as we are, and I don't think it is entirely acting on their part!
Quién dijo que se necesita ligereza,que igual tiene varias definiciones. Yo admiro a cada una ,pero Svetlana lo baila pero lo que menos me parece es una gitana ,Osipova es siempre atropellada en sus movimientos bailé lo que baile. Soy Argentina no opino de Nuñez. Formas de ver,yo soy médico pero tengo una hija bailarina y fuí bailarina.
They are all very good however Marianela Nunez's performance is by far my favorite. Not only her dance performance and ability, even the expression on her face make me enjoy her performance even more.
nunez for the win as she’s a lot sharper and her moves are very controlled than other Kitris while some others you can’t really tell what’s going willst nunez makes everything flow and makes it crystal clear to what’s going on
Marianela is dancing while using the castañuelas, it is magnificent to see her dancing, and it looks like she's enjoying performing the part, she's indeed the best Kitri. Osipova is wonderful and revolutionized, but she looks too focused on the timing.
зато почитайте комменты разных там народцев написавших по английски.... По их мнению испанка дескать супер и другие ей в подметки не годятся. Такие иксперды вылезли откуда то Им вообще все равно кого хвалить лишь бы НЕ РУССКИХ
Osipova is all fire. Her "attack" is like she is shot out of a cannon. She is most like Plisetskaya. Osipova is incredible. Zakharova and-Nunez don't have the same "attack". Nunez does something so unique with her arms in the high, turning pors de bras - like whipped creaming whipping up to the air at fast speed! All are more than wonderful.
зато почитайте комменты разных там народцев написавших по английски.... По их мнению испанка дескать супер и другие ей в подметки не годятся. Такие иксперды вылезли откуда то Им вообще все равно кого хвалить лишь бы НЕ РУССКИХ
All are virtuosic. I fully expected Osipova to trample her competition since this was the role that made her, but by gosh! Whereas she was gravity-defying, Nunez was the only one that embodied the Gypsy spirit. Fiery and sultry and a power house! No quarrel w Zakharova’s skills, but all I saw there was Princess Kitri.
Definitely prefer Nunez - embodies a feeling of flirtatious, charismatic energy. The music is energetic, but not out of control. Whoever did the filming for Osipova was off so bad. The way the camera whips around does a disservice to her dancing, makes her look flung around. Still, I feel the orchestration is a little too fast as well to really feel the character is conveying much. I love her energy, but her face is cheesing it up so bad, bless. As for Zakharova, she feels too pulled back from the character and something about her port de bras is awkward. Maybe I'm just not fan of the choreo, ahaha.
Natalia for me! I just love her power and energy. As for Marianela, I LOVE her flair 1:26 and her firebird. For Svetlana, the camera quality did her no justice. Her other variations suit her much better than kitri. I still love her techniques tho. I adore all of them so much!
Natalia Sipova con dulsura,feminidad y expresión artística nadie como ella ya hace mucho tiempo. Gracias por las emociones que el ballet despierta en mí.
Me encantan los saltos de Natalia, la tecnica de svetlana y las expresiones faciales de Marianela, las tres excelentes bailarinas pero en este caso está variación es para Marianela, ella a kitri la hizo suya, cada personaje que interpreta lo hace tan único a su manera👏👏👏
My heart belongs to Nela (I think I say that a lot), but they're all fantastic. Interesting to see just how different the choreography is---pique vs. tombe/inside pirouette on that first turn, whether the connecting step is pas de chat or grand pas de chat. You remember the big choreographic beats like those enormous sisonnes and the millions of sequential pirouettes at the end and want to think they define the variation ("Kitri's Act 1 variation"=enormous sisonnes) but even the two Russians have some interesting differences. Thanks for all of these! And loved Nela blowing a kiss to Basil---like you actually have time for extras in a variation that must feel like you've just been shot out of a canon!
@@francisheperi1127 That's Svetlana Zakharova from the Bolshoi. IIRC she was promoted to principal at 18, and there's footage of her on YT being an astonishing talent in her teens. And ever since!
Marianela did this the best she had power and control and the first girl did amazing too but she rushed it and you couldn’t tell what she was doing in my opinion
Truth be told, Maya Plisetskaya’s Kitri is my favorite. Her speed, technique and just sheer exuberance that comes through on even 60 year old footage is unequalled.
@@Marta44339 l’ex fidanzato Vasiliev in una intervista disse che era instancabile quando faceva le prove, e questo credo si veda nella perfezione della tecnica e nell’ergia che mette quando balla. Il mio sogno sarebbe quello di andarla a vedere dal vivo... adesso la vedo dura, ma chissa’ un giorno....
@@tiziana327 E' vero, anch'io ho letto del suo perfezionismo. Ho visto la Osipova 4 volte a New York, due volte in Giselle,, e anche in "The Bright Stream" e "Firebird" di Ratmansky, sempre bravissima. Un giorno spero di vederla in DQ!
No one does it like Natalia. I’ve watched many different ballerinas do this variation. Those bourrees are the quickest I’ve ever seen. Love this version but I wish the video quality was higher.
osipova’s performance was so engaging. she was so… everywhere, such a flurrying typhoon of fun. i couldn’t tear my eyes from her. i don’t think either of the other two held a candle to her.
зато почитайте комменты разных там народцев написавших по английски.... По их мнению испанка дескать супер и другие ей в подметки не годятся. Такие иксперды вылезли откуда то Им вообще все равно кого хвалить лишь бы НЕ РУССКИХ
@@serendipityconsulting570 аргентинка это не национальность а место жительства А так они все латиноамериканцы или испанцы Ну и вкус же у вас Это классический балет а не соревнование по Танго
This Osipova version seems with Sarafanov at La Scala. I loved her early version with Vasiliev at Bolshoi. Her techniques and artistry at that time might not be as mature as La Scala version，but her energy，freshness and vitality was incomparable.
They’re all wonderful in their own right but Marianela Nunez’s form and control are just a wonder to behold. And that she makes what I can only imagine is fantastically difficult look like a breeze as she maintains such a beautiful smile throughout her entire performance brings her to a whole other level of spectacular♥️. Bravo!
Of course each of them is an outstanding dancer! But when I look at Osipova I see Kitri who can dance, other girls for me are ballerinas who play Kitri. Osipova is so full of life!
Can we just celebrate how wonderful it is to have three such extraordinary performances? I won't pick a "best." I'll just echo the other comments: Osipova's power and speed are intoxicating, Zakharova's delicacy is breathtaking, and Marianela's artistry and ability to create a character through her expressions and her steps is everything!
i love osipova, but nuñez wins this one for sure. it’s like she was born to dance this role, her musicality, performance, expressions, acting are amazing, not to mention her outstanding technique (although they are all incredibly talented in this regard)
Natalia is light and airborne. Marianela is connected to the floor on pointe; she also has the most fun. Svetlana disappointed me for some indefinable reason, but she is of course a wonderful dancer. If I were Basilio I'd want to marry Marianela!
As três bailarinas são soberbas, cada qual dentro de seu estilo. No entanto, Marianella Nuñez, talvez pela sua origem latina (Argentina), consegue dar um brilho todo especial ao papel de Kitri. Destaque para a finalização dos giros (2:55), quando Marianella levanta a perna direita e encerra o último giro num movimento muito bonito.
Eu gosto muito da Osipova, principalmente no papel de Odile, porque ela encarna a personagem e é como se ela fosse uma atriz além de uma bailarina. Mas como Kitri, a Nela Nunez será sempre a melhor pra mim. Ela realmente dança com naturalidade e suavidade a personagem, dentro da música, enquanto as outras às vezes parecem estar muito preocupados com a técnica
@@rimbaud2506 Concordo com você. Osipova é perfeita como Odete/Odile e também como Giselle. Sua beleza física e sua enorme força dramática, associadas ao seu talento, são requisitos perfeitos para esses papéis que ela representa divinamente.
okay don't get me wrong, ALL of them are flawless and hve their own styles. but i keep coming back to natalia's performnace. it's like she's a firecracker, a controlled firecracker. she dances as if she's crazed but she's in enough control that her energy doesn't take over. wow she is really freakin good. like you think she's going to screw up with all her energy but no she delivers every time. geez
Enjoyed the video? 🥰 Don't forget to SUBSCRIBE and turn on notifications🔔🩰
This piece shows just how graceful - and yet fierce - women's ballet can be.
Olá. Tá. Bem
Sì, è fantastico! Grazie!
@ Da
@ DanerLineBallet...estoy hackeada
Natalia is so powerful, Marinela is so elegant, Svetlana is so delicate.
Totally agree 😊
I agree
@Maria Tereza Souza Lacerda the first one is the best.
Natalia looks like shes living her best life. Thats what I love about her. There is so much LIFE and PASSION in her dancing.
Светлана - прекрасна, но Китри - не её амплуа.
The clappings in Nunez's performance really elevate the whole thing!!
Osipova sguaiata, Zacharova senza anima.......Nunez perfetta come sempre!
I love when background is reacting with dancer that makes the scene and performance so much more alive and emotionally powerful ♡
Agree. The clapping makes it so much more engaging and fun 🤩
@@rossellarossi9700Захарова бездушна? Чем ты смотрел? Лучше всех Захарова- это балет, Нуньес-просто колоритна, но там не та школа.
Балет -это всетаки танец, а Нуньес исполняет его как гимнастические упражнения. Самое лучшее исполнение у Осиповой
Nunez has the most beautiful technique and artistry in this variation! She embodies a stronger more flirtatious kitri. With that said, Osipova is full on fire in this!
I like the last girl.
Наталья Осипова всё-таки лучшая Китри.❤
В каком месте? Руки не понятно где! В музыку не попадает! Она прекрасная балерина, но эта партия не ее!
Настоящая Китри это Мариэлла ,страсть, каждое движение ,как лезвие бритвы! А с музыкой просто слилась
Marinella
I just enjoy Marianela Nunez's charm and power so much.
¡Olé, olé y olé Marianela! 🇪🇸👍
Marianela siempre primera !!!
she has the "Spanish" fire !
me too
I agree! She has the perfect energy and attitude!
Исполнение Осиповой великолепно. Есть в ней невероятная легкость и волшебство
Херня! Мариэлла лучшая
Osipova has something indescribable...
She is amazing...
I like the last girl.
@@francisheperi1127 That's Svetlana Zakharova
Osipova is wonderful but i think she is too exagerate .... i preferer svetlana and nunez
@@francisheperi1127 х
osipova and Zakharova are great each in their own way
Osipova wonderful dynamic rendition. Nunez kills it with her artistry - she brings the character to life, which is after all the ultimate aim. Bravo!
I like the last girl.
@@francisheperi1127 Zakharova, you have good taste !
I love watching her dance
Nunes’ performance blows the others out of the water. Her technique and musicality, timing and embodiment of the character is AMAZING.
Согласна с вами. Она - лучшая Китри.
I totally agree with you.
I agree - to be fair her was the best quality video but her characterisation really stood out for me
Of course - her hispanic background lends the earthy and "saleroso" strength to her as yet, unchallenged performance.
For me she IS Kitri. No one else is quite the same.
i love marianela nunez 🥺 it’s her latina flair and insane control that sets her apart from the others
Yes! I think she has more expressions, or she looks flirty, happier, more cheeky
She shines in the role and she is Spanish - it shows up so well.
@@annastinehammersdottir1290 She's not Spanish what, she's Argentinian lmfao
@@a.a.2573 close enough lol
@@crunchybubblewrap huh what?
Nobody jumps like Osipova. Nobody floats like Zakharova. But Nela... she *is* Kitri. She's the total package. Everything about her is perfect.
absoultley correct!!!! nice words for that!!!
Na
Да если бы темп был повыше,позы фиксированные.
Для обывателя сойдет. После Основой смотришь ,как в замедленного съёмке.
Согласна. В ней столько страсти и энергии. Она настоящая испанка!
Nunez is perfect for the role, she is persuasive and finishes her arrangement beautifully
Наталья лучшая! Сгусток страсти и энергии! Скорость! Потрясающая техника! Артистизм! Сметает все на своем пути. Захватывает полностью...)))... Ну, и как тут не вспомнить великолепнейшую Екатерину Максимову- лучшую Китри всех времен!
Все очень медленно. Смотрите Плисецкую и Максимову.
Natalia Osipova is 100% kitri super energetic and explosive!!💖Svetlana is delicate and soft more of a Swan Queen or Nikiya!!🩰Bravo to all!!🥳
I think Osipova is over the top and too explosive for ballet, she lacks finesse. On the other hand, Zakharova is very soft for Kitri. That's why Nela is perfect for the role and does the best performance
@Almira Izumchensky So? I don"t like her, I suffer watching her dance. Too much force to pirouettes, needlessly. She is closed and not clean but ballet is en dehors (turn out). She is out of my Pantheón. And I don't care about what some think: millions of flies can be wrong (💩 doesn"t taste good, but they eat it 😄)
@Almira Izumchensky No, but thank you for answer
@Almira Izumchensky Goodness gracious! Why all the vitriol? Giliberto began his (or her, I’m sorry, I can’t tell by the picture or name) first comment with, “I think . . . “. I did not find it offensive. Lots of people who are well schooled in the art of ballet do not care for Osipova’s style. That’s what makes the world go around. . . different strokes for different folks! Personally, one of my favorite TH-cam videos of Osipova is the 2nd Act of Giselle, with Carlos Acosta. Mmmm, now that is almost perfection.
@@paulagiliberto7386 What is most surprising to me is that how this kind of ballerina could appear here, in Russia. Her performance is gymnastics, anything else but not ballet. I would expect this style anywhere in the world but not here.
В танце Осиповой столько жизни, драйва🔥Захарова слишком академична, сдержана
Партия Китри не для Захаровой, в ней слишком много зазнайства, словно она снисходит до зрителя, а вообще-то похожа на гимнастку в балетной пачке, оставляет ощущение безжизненности.
Осипова блестяще!!! Браво!!!👏👏👏
Она очень живая и страстная, но у Захаровой самые красивые ноги!
Marianela Nunez is just perfection.
That's because she put more Flamenco elements into her interpretation, so you can feel the fiery nature of her character.
@@isabelalzateestrada, not only that, her musical sense and technique are exact
Мне тоже Нунез понравилась больше всех.
true, but only for those who do not understand anything in ballet. Zaharova is perfection. Every single moove
@@IvaNovaaaaaaa Sure, I'm sure countless prima ballerinas don't know what they're talking about, yeah? Like Darcey Bussell, who has herself said the same about Marianela, I'm sure she hasn't got a clue.....
All of them are fantastic dancers, with different styles and charming personalities. But for me the interpretative ability and the charisma of Marianela Nunez always add that something special that definetly conquers me.
It was so mesmerising to watch Marianela's perform. It had a certain flair, a elegant but cheeky vibe to the whole performance especially when she looks back and gives a flying kiss with that smile. Natalie spit fire with her moves, she looks she gave it all and she absolutely owned the whole stage, Svetlana was smooth, elegant and looked like she was flying on the stage.
Захарова скучна, без темперамента, просто хорошо исполняет гимнастические упражнения, демонстрируя возможности своего тела. Скучно!
При всей моей любви к великолепной и рождённой для балета Светлане, но Марианела - ребёнок, которого боженька поцеловал в макушку. Она невероятна - техника, артистизм, баланс и идеальное исполнение. Осипова отдельно от всех))) такой огонь 🔥
Захарова для Китри имеет слишком интеллигентную внешность.
@@ingkauf6176 Да по биометрии Захарова не подходит... Рост и изящные конечности не позволяют быстро подсобраться в динамичной вариации... Испанка Китри это не амплуа Захаровой... Осипова - отлично!
Maria Elevskaya,Марианелла вся зажатая и деревянная
@@ingkauf6176 Партия Китри не для Захаровой, нет огня в танце, а просто хорошая техника гимнастки в балетной пачке.
Наталья Осипова,
с её лёгкостью, задором и темпераментом - воплощённая Китри!
Без сомнения, лучшая в этой партии!
Превосходная наша Наташа. Обожаю ее.
Китри Осиповой неотразима! Легкая, яркая, неудержимая, как огонь!
Marianela Nunez , I loved her dance the most... It's just tooo beautiful 😍
Marianela Nuñez nos contagia con su perfecto dominio de los movimientos españoles sin escatimar ésa actitud tan especial que tales exigen... Efectivamente Núñez despliega una energía pasional en su interpretación inigualable...
Verdad, es única y increible ❤️
Osipova has the fire, technique, and speed, mesmerizing to watch, but she loses a bit of the artistry of the part. Nunez doesn’t have the speed or fire, but she has the upper body and port de bras for the part. You can really see the flamenco influence.
👏👏👏
Osipova lacks control and cleanliness, but no doubt she's the most dynamic
I like the last girl.
I disagree. Nela is the only one that truly embodied the character. When she dances it makes me want to dance with her.
I would say Osipova showed off technique and speed where it wasnt necessary for the role whereas Nunez had the fire, passion and intensity. Her movements were strong.
This is Osipova/Sarafanov at La Scala. It always makes me smile to watch the toreadors in the background, especially the dark- haired dancer third from the left. The are mesmerized by Osipova's stage presence just as we are, and I don't think it is entirely acting on their part!
Ahahah small details make the difference.. nice perspective! Thanks for this comment 👏☺️
Осипова! Браво!
Marianela Nunez totally fits the role, it looks like it was conceived for her from the very first moment!
I love Osipova 🥇 she is the BEST 👏👏👏
I like the last girl.
Безусловно, исполнение Осиповой лучше всех Великолепно! Энергия, яркость, полетность. Животрепещущий огонь.
No lo creo, realmente la que dio gran pasión fue Nuñez pero para gustos colores
Согласна. Осипова - лучшая.
The expressions on their face tells it all! Nunez is in complete control and knows it!
Marianela Nuñez maneja precisión, elegancia ..tiene absoluta presencia sin necesidad de saltos o elasticidad extrema . Hermosa perfección!!!!🇦🇷
Да хороша, но этого мало - нет той легкости как у Захаровой...Как бы замечательно было взять только лучшее у каждой из этих балерин
@@БорисоваИрина-я6в Захаровская лёгкость в этой партии не очень нужна, нужен скорее темперамент, она этим и берет)
Quién dijo que se necesita ligereza,que igual tiene varias definiciones. Yo admiro a cada una ,pero Svetlana lo baila pero lo que menos me parece es una gitana ,Osipova es siempre atropellada en sus movimientos bailé lo que baile. Soy Argentina no opino de Nuñez. Formas de ver,yo soy médico pero tengo una hija bailarina y fuí bailarina.
@@БорисоваИрина-я6в Партия не для Захаровой, здесь нужен темперамент, а у неё гимнастические упражнения в сценическом костюме.
Осипова невероятна!
Natalia is my favorite ballerina ever! But marianela's kitri steals my heart Everytime
Marianela Nunez😍 the way she spins is the best...it haunts me😌❤️
They are all very good however Marianela Nunez's performance is by far my favorite. Not only her dance performance and ability, even the expression on her face make me enjoy her performance even more.
nunez for the win as she’s a lot sharper and her moves are very controlled than other Kitris while some others you can’t really tell what’s going willst nunez makes everything flow and makes it crystal clear to what’s going on
Осипова Наталья!!!!!👍
Marianela is dancing while using the castañuelas, it is magnificent to see her dancing, and it looks like she's enjoying performing the part, she's indeed the best Kitri. Osipova is wonderful and revolutionized, but she looks too focused on the timing.
Осипова впечатляет. Красавица, харизматичная и темпераментная!
зато почитайте комменты разных там народцев написавших по английски.... По их мнению испанка дескать супер и другие ей в подметки не годятся. Такие иксперды вылезли откуда то Им вообще все равно кого хвалить лишь бы НЕ РУССКИХ
Лучшая Китри - Осипова!
Ever Nela. Everything she does is perfect. No comparison, unique 😍
I like the last girl.
@@francisheperi1127, May be the technique, but not for Kitri
Osipova is all fire. Her "attack" is like she is shot out of a cannon. She is most like Plisetskaya. Osipova is incredible. Zakharova and-Nunez don't have the same "attack". Nunez does something so unique with her arms in the high, turning pors de bras - like whipped creaming whipping up to the air at fast speed! All are more than wonderful.
YEsS TOTALLY AGREED!!
Exactly.....
I like the last girl.
I didn't like Ovispova because of it, it was TOO much in my opinion and she didn't got that strong movements as Nuñez for example
Marianela Núñez, Argentina, ¡maravillosa interpretación y gracia!
What a feast this is. The finest dancers showing distinct variations of a great solo dance, with varying accompaniment. Pure delight!
Glad you enjoyed ❤️
Наталья Осипова как огонь. Движения точные и красивые в такт с музыкой. По моему мнению,она слилась с энергией Китри в одно целое.
Absolutely agree!
зато почитайте комменты разных там народцев написавших по английски.... По их мнению испанка дескать супер и другие ей в подметки не годятся. Такие иксперды вылезли откуда то Им вообще все равно кого хвалить лишь бы НЕ РУССКИХ
@@lanapetersen2287 мы в любом случае останемся при своем мнении 🌹🙂
@@LeoQ77 ну и сидите со своим недалеким мнением
Nunez LIVES the Kitri! Fantastic. My number one! The other two - not for me...
All are virtuosic. I fully expected Osipova to trample her competition since this was the role that made her, but by gosh! Whereas she was gravity-defying, Nunez was the only one that embodied the Gypsy spirit. Fiery and sultry and a power house! No quarrel w Zakharova’s skills, but all I saw there was Princess Kitri.
I like the last girl.
Нуньес не впечатляет. Вы никогда не видели цыган, если пишите такое.
@@francisheperi1127 она хуже всех.
Не зря существует понятие амплуа.В этой роли Осипова лучшая !Блестательно !!!!
all of them are fantastic but for me Nunez is the BEST kitri, her charm is unbeatable
Marianela, es la mezcla perfecta de jolgorio, elegancia y la fuerza que tiene que tener Kitri, una genia!!
Ame la presentación de Natalia osipova se ve llena de energía y carisma
natalia is the queen of the ballet ♥
I like the last girl.
Yes!!!! I love she !!!!
Marianela is my favorite in this variation! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
I prefer Nunez’s artistry in this piece. She pauses and emphasizes at the right moments. Such an elegant dancer.
Osipova rules!!! 👏👏👏
Definitely prefer Nunez - embodies a feeling of flirtatious, charismatic energy. The music is energetic, but not out of control. Whoever did the filming for Osipova was off so bad. The way the camera whips around does a disservice to her dancing, makes her look flung around. Still, I feel the orchestration is a little too fast as well to really feel the character is conveying much. I love her energy, but her face is cheesing it up so bad, bless. As for Zakharova, she feels too pulled back from the character and something about her port de bras is awkward. Maybe I'm just not fan of the choreo, ahaha.
I like the last girl.
@@francisheperi1127 Go Francis !
Natalia for me! I just love her power and energy. As for Marianela, I LOVE her flair 1:26 and her firebird. For Svetlana, the camera quality did her no justice. Her other variations suit her much better than kitri. I still love her techniques tho. I adore all of them so much!
Natalia 🥇... Most energy, joy, expression.
Natalia Sipova con dulsura,feminidad y expresión artística nadie como ella ya hace mucho tiempo. Gracias por las emociones que el ballet despierta en mí.
Marianela is the embodiment of classical ballet. No doubt she is The Queen.
Me encantan los saltos de Natalia, la tecnica de svetlana y las expresiones faciales de Marianela, las tres excelentes bailarinas pero en este caso está variación es para Marianela, ella a kitri la hizo suya, cada personaje que interpreta lo hace tan único a su manera👏👏👏
My heart belongs to Nela (I think I say that a lot), but they're all fantastic. Interesting to see just how different the choreography is---pique vs. tombe/inside pirouette on that first turn, whether the connecting step is pas de chat or grand pas de chat. You remember the big choreographic beats like those enormous sisonnes and the millions of sequential pirouettes at the end and want to think they define the variation ("Kitri's Act 1 variation"=enormous sisonnes) but even the two Russians have some interesting differences. Thanks for all of these! And loved Nela blowing a kiss to Basil---like you actually have time for extras in a variation that must feel like you've just been shot out of a canon!
I like the last girl.
@@francisheperi1127 That's Svetlana Zakharova from the Bolshoi. IIRC she was promoted to principal at 18, and there's footage of her on YT being an astonishing talent in her teens. And ever since!
Три лучших исполнителя этой партии ! И всё-таки Марианела огонь 🔥
Albert Azeri,лучших? Осипова,да! Посмотрите Китри в исполнении Екатерины Максимовой
@@ГалинаДримлюга , я имел ввиду, лучших исполнителя нашего времени. А о величии Екатерины Максимовой и не идёт речи ! Легенда !!!
чего это ради она огонь? Обычная балерина знающая свою партию Даже медленнее танцует чем Осипова
@@lanapetersen2287, с того, что я увидел для себя там. У вас свой вкус, у меня свой, и ваша категоричность ну совсем не к месту
@@albertazeri3580 ну дак у таких как ВЫ принцип один: хвалить КОГО УГОДНО лишь бы не российских
Осипова лучше всех!
Marianela did this the best she had power and control and the first girl did amazing too but she rushed it and you couldn’t tell what she was doing in my opinion
Too acurrated
Undoubtedly we all have our favourites but arent we so lucky to be able to watch all these amazing ladies.
I personally prefer Nunez's delivery amongst the 3. The lines just seem cleaner and the energy is just right. This is one of her best.
The clapping for Nunez’s makes it much more festive for me which is why it’s my favorite :D
Natalia is just an other level🔥
Осипова - огонь !!!! Какая энергетика !!! И техника у нее великолепная !!! Она лучшая !!!!
Elles sont toutes magnifiques, mais Svetlana a une élégance sublime unie à une expressivité naturelle que je n'arrive pas à décrire.
I love Osipova's energy and Nuñez' flair!
Nunez is literally the PERFECT Kitri!! 😭❤️
Truth be told, Maya Plisetskaya’s Kitri is my favorite. Her speed, technique and just sheer exuberance that comes through on even 60 year old footage is unequalled.
Nunez is amazing 👸🏼
I like the last girl.
А в Осиповой то побольше испанской страсти ! Браво Наталья ! 👍👏👏👏❤🌺🙋♀️
Вы дикие прыжки воспринимаете как страсть? Это должен быть танец, а не гимнастика
@@user-mori88 Да уж, Наталья Осипова это балерина-гимнастка. Такого в русском балете, кажется еще не было. Во всяком случае, среди прим.
@@galina398,прима-балерина Михайловского театра Анжелина Воронцова в прошлом занималась художественной гимнастикой и что?
Désolée mais pour la passion espagnole, c'est Marianela qui gagne haut la main
Io amo la Osipova.. Questa sequenza è così energetica che lei può esprimere i suoi salti e i suoi giri al nassimo
Anche io l’adoro.... è un uragano non è una ballerina!!!😍😍
@@tiziana327 Anch'io l'adoro. La Osipvoa regna in Don Q.!
@@Marta44339 l’ex fidanzato Vasiliev in una intervista disse che era instancabile quando faceva le prove, e questo credo si veda nella perfezione della tecnica e nell’ergia che mette quando balla. Il mio sogno sarebbe quello di andarla a vedere dal vivo... adesso la vedo dura, ma chissa’ un giorno....
@@tiziana327 E' vero, anch'io ho letto del suo perfezionismo. Ho visto la Osipova 4 volte a New York, due volte in Giselle,, e anche in "The Bright Stream" e "Firebird" di Ratmansky, sempre bravissima. Un giorno spero di vederla in DQ!
Concordo pienamente 👏👏👏
No one does it like Natalia. I’ve watched many different ballerinas do this variation. Those bourrees are the quickest I’ve ever seen. Love this version but I wish the video quality was higher.
osipova’s performance was so engaging. she was so… everywhere, such a flurrying typhoon of fun. i couldn’t tear my eyes from her. i don’t think either of the other two held a candle to her.
Really, I just think that Palmas' participation in the pirouettes part was lacking.
Merci!
Thank you so much for your support 🙏🩰
Осипова лучшая! Столько задора, энергетики и темперамента нет ни у одной...
зато почитайте комменты разных там народцев написавших по английски.... По их мнению испанка дескать супер и другие ей в подметки не годятся. Такие иксперды вылезли откуда то Им вообще все равно кого хвалить лишь бы НЕ РУССКИХ
@@lanapetersen2287 во-первых, она аргентинка, а во-вторых это вкусовщина, мне из этой подборки тоже больше всех Нуньес понравилась.
@@serendipityconsulting570 аргентинка это не национальность а место жительства А так они все латиноамериканцы или испанцы Ну и вкус же у вас Это классический балет а не соревнование по Танго
@@lanapetersen2287J'adore Natalia, mais ici, désolée, Marianela incarne vraiment le personnage !
@@lanapetersen2287Im an American who likes Osipova best. She is my favorite Ballerina
manianela nunez was by far the best for this variation
I love Nuñez's expressions! So *on pointe*
Thank you for showing the same choreography done by different ballerinas -- it was fun to be able to watch for things ahead of time!
Каждая из них по своему великолепна и красива
Osipova is in the league of her own, Zaharova and Nunez are a tie a notch below. All are just superb.
I like the last girl.
Zakharova is a notch below no one !
Nela is in my opinion a notch below nobody
This Osipova version seems with Sarafanov at La Scala. I loved her early version with Vasiliev at Bolshoi. Her techniques and artistry at that time might not be as mature as La Scala version，but her energy，freshness and vitality was incomparable.
I like the last girl.
Well duh lol, that's Zakharova, she's already a living legend
They’re all wonderful in their own right but Marianela Nunez’s form and control are just a wonder to behold. And that she makes what I can only imagine is fantastically difficult look like a breeze as she maintains such a beautiful smile throughout her entire performance brings her to a whole other level of spectacular♥️. Bravo!
Of course each of them is an outstanding dancer! But when I look at Osipova I see Kitri who can dance, other girls for me are ballerinas who play Kitri. Osipova is so full of life!
She was during her era at Bolshoi, she was really fire and full of energy, in this one she's just trying to emulate her old self, not the same thing
Can we just celebrate how wonderful it is to have three such extraordinary performances? I won't pick a "best." I'll just echo the other comments: Osipova's power and speed are intoxicating, Zakharova's delicacy is breathtaking, and Marianela's artistry and ability to create a character through her expressions and her steps is everything!
Осипова обалдеть какая! Браво! Браво! Браво!
i love osipova, but nuñez wins this one for sure. it’s like she was born to dance this role, her musicality, performance, expressions, acting are amazing, not to mention her outstanding technique (although they are all incredibly talented in this regard)
Marianela is giving life to the character. Not only musicality and technique. Her expressions captivate attention just the same.
Natalia is light and airborne. Marianela is connected to the floor on pointe; she also has the most fun. Svetlana disappointed me for some indefinable reason, but she is of course a wonderful dancer. If I were Basilio I'd want to marry Marianela!
As três bailarinas são soberbas, cada qual dentro de seu estilo. No entanto, Marianella Nuñez, talvez pela sua origem latina (Argentina), consegue dar um brilho todo especial ao papel de Kitri. Destaque para a finalização dos giros (2:55), quando Marianella levanta a perna direita e encerra o último giro num movimento muito bonito.
Eu gosto muito da Osipova, principalmente no papel de Odile, porque ela encarna a personagem e é como se ela fosse uma atriz além de uma bailarina. Mas como Kitri, a Nela Nunez será sempre a melhor pra mim. Ela realmente dança com naturalidade e suavidade a personagem, dentro da música, enquanto as outras às vezes parecem estar muito preocupados com a técnica
@@rimbaud2506 Concordo com você. Osipova é perfeita como Odete/Odile e também como Giselle. Sua beleza física e sua enorme força dramática, associadas ao seu talento, são requisitos perfeitos para esses papéis que ela representa divinamente.
Нуньес - лучшая! Неповторимый испанский колорит.
Markiza,какой испанский колорит. Она скованная,как дерево
okay don't get me wrong, ALL of them are flawless and hve their own styles. but i keep coming back to natalia's performnace. it's like she's a firecracker, a controlled firecracker. she dances as if she's crazed but she's in enough control that her energy doesn't take over. wow she is really freakin good. like you think she's going to screw up with all her energy but no she delivers every time. geez