Decided to listen to this after what was litarilly years of not listening to pency prep. So close to tears. i've always loved them so mich, and this song...
so mcr are my favourite band and i've never actually listened to pencey prep before but i know my friend has bought me heartbreak in stereo for christmas so i thought i might as well listen before i get it. needless to say, i love pencey prep now.
I can't close my eyes I can't shut my eyes to you I can't close my eyes I won't shed a tear for you Not this time No matter how hard I try I break all the ties Heartbreak is forever Land of the lost I found myself in nothing This time Promises broken Find me clutching to you For something Something that you're not Believing in what you say Makes me lie awake at night The truth is not what scares me It's why you have to lie All the time Heartbreak is forever I found myself with nothing to believe in This time The promise is broken finally Clutching you for something All the time I can't close my eyes I can't shut my eyes to you I can't close my eyes I won't shed Not this time Cause heartbreak is forever Heartbreak is forever Heartbreak is forever Heartbreak is forever Heartbreak is forever But nothing lasts forever.
that's so beautiful! i must cry.. there are really just a few songs that makes me cry.. and this one is at the top of this list.. SOO beautiful! *-* i fuckin' love Pencey Prep! --- in 2 weeks i'm going to see mcr live and i will ask Frank about Pencey Prep.. something like 'would you do a Pencey Prep comeback' or something like that^^ btw, sorry for my bad english, i'm german ^.^
@lightningstrike43 As far as I know, "Pencey Prep" definitely is. I've never heard Frank talk about the title of this song, but I expect that would be a reference too.
@ToriElisabeth I wish I did! But I was, like, four when they broke up, so you know... Amazing band though. As much as I ove MCR, shame they didn't stay together. They had potential, and they may or may not have been bigger than MCR eventually. =D
when you see an old comment saying theyre going to see mcr live.....*cries*
unironically one of the greatest songs ever made
The first 40 seconds of this song are so beautiful.
This will always be a classic
Our sweet smol bean has come so far
This always makes me cry
i wish i had of known about Pencey when they were together, this is amazing
Totally thought he said, "I won't shit a tear." instead of, "I won't shed a tear." Oh Frankie... x.x
Decided to listen to this after what was litarilly years of not listening to pency prep. So close to tears. i've always loved them so mich, and this song...
His voice is beautiful. I really want a pency prep cd. This is my favorite pp song
im going to cry everything is just too much
loser
so mcr are my favourite band and i've never actually listened to pencey prep before but i know my friend has bought me heartbreak in stereo for christmas so i thought i might as well listen before i get it.
needless to say, i love pencey prep now.
I can't close my eyes
I can't shut my eyes to you
I can't close my eyes
I won't shed a tear for you
Not this time
No matter how hard I try
I break all the ties
Heartbreak is forever
Land of the lost
I found myself in nothing
This time
Promises broken
Find me clutching to you
For something
Something that you're not
Believing in what you say
Makes me lie awake at night
The truth is not what scares me
It's why you have to lie
All the time
Heartbreak is forever
I found myself with nothing to believe in
This time
The promise is broken finally
Clutching you for something
All the time
I can't close my eyes
I can't shut my eyes to you
I can't close my eyes
I won't shed
Not this time
Cause heartbreak is forever
Heartbreak is forever
Heartbreak is forever
Heartbreak is forever
Heartbreak is forever
But nothing lasts forever.
i miss these days :'(
at least mcr is back together!!!
aww i love this song
that's so beautiful! i must cry..
there are really just a few songs that makes me cry..
and this one is at the top of this list.. SOO beautiful! *-*
i fuckin' love Pencey Prep!
---
in 2 weeks i'm going to see mcr live and i will ask Frank about Pencey Prep.. something like 'would you do a Pencey Prep comeback' or something like that^^
btw, sorry for my bad english, i'm german ^.^
I know this was 12 years ago, but how did it go? What did he say?
i feel personally attacked
I loce this so much, I think I like it more than the version on the album.
Perfectly Beautifull :')
no dislikes(: just as it should be.
pencey prep is the best.
@lightningstrike43 As far as I know, "Pencey Prep" definitely is. I've never heard Frank talk about the title of this song, but I expect that would be a reference too.
Pency prep is the school Holden went to in the catcher and the rye... the secret goldfish I believe is the first chapter
This is now my theme song of my entire life :D
*CRIES* this is so beautiful
Love it thankyou! Will listen to them more :)
aww i love it..
It's so amazing
this song is amazing!
Beautiful
Love U Pencey Prep :D
His voice is so smol awh
Oh Pency
these songs feel so incredibly short when they're like 5 minutes long!
@ToriElisabeth I wish I did! But I was, like, four when they broke up, so you know...
Amazing band though. As much as I ove MCR, shame they didn't stay together. They had potential, and they may or may not have been bigger than MCR eventually. =D
frankie is sweet here, but he's so much better with screamo-- not saying i wont favorite and love till my heart stops though!!!!!!
I wish I could hear Frank sing this again on live.
P.S what's the story behind this song?
i can't help but wonder if the title of this song and the band name are "catcher in the rye" refrences
😭
I like the vocaloid one 😑
Wrong lyrics, great song.