Young Scholars Analyse China's Politics, Economy And The Military On SNG Roundtable
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 ก.ค. 2024
- In Stratnewsglobal’s Roundtable series, three young scholars with distinct specialisations on China, analysed and answered questions on a range of issues. Anushka Saxena, a research analyst at the Takshashila Institution in Bengaluru, says that Beijing’s perception of its foreign and domestic situation has darkened.
Xi Jinping himself is warning of “significant challenges”, she pointed out, of “changes unforseen in a century” and that “opportunities for development are concurrent with great risks and challenges.”
In other words, China’s drive to boost domestic consumption and rely less on exports is not happening smoothly. The environment in the South China Sea has become hostile, and the path to technological and scientific progress is being impeded by outside forces.
The anti-corruption campaign has ensnared officials across government departments including the PLA. But the one point which stands out is Xi Jinping’s iron control over the ship of state.
Amit Kumar, also of the Takshashila Institution, focused on the Chinese economy. He argues that the global economic slowdown has impacted on China’s heavily export-oriented industrial base, add to that growing centralization with power being taken away from local authorities and the securitization of development.
Government’s crackdown on the real estate sector has compounded the problem since it contributed from 25% to 33% of GDP. This was done because the authorities wanted to direct capital away from speculative real estate transactions towards the innovation economy.
Suyash Desai who studies China’s PLA from his base in Taiwan, is working on his Mandarin language while also writing a newsletter called the PLA Bulletin. He talked about China’s efforts to intimidate Taiwan through aggressive manoeuvres at sea.
In his view, China is in no position at least for a decade, to be able to mount an invasion of the island. It lacks the capacity in terms of amphibious capability and there’s no telling how things could go if the US intervenes in support of Taiwan.
Tune in for more in this conversation with three young China scholars.
#pla #china #tibet
Join Nitin Gokhale's Strategic Group WhatsApp Channel to get the latest updates from articles on our website and videos on our TH-cam Channel: www.whatsapp.com/channel/0029...
Since many of our well-wishers requested a UPI payment id to contribute and support us, here’s the link, which gives us 100% of what you choose: stratnewsglobal.com/support-us/
You can also click and buy a TH-cam Super Thanks(the heart icon where you liked this video), which directly supports StratNewsGlobal, with 70% of your chosen amount.
Leave your comments, questions, and feedback. Like and share our videos. Subscribe to our TH-cam channel. Click on the 🔔icon to get notified of our latest uploads.
To get instant updates join our telegram circle - t.me/stratnewsglobalbroadcast
If those guys are the best of the youth Indian have then india is in deep trouble lol😂
Exactly! They’re just parroting whatever they read on WSJ or NYT! No original thinking or new insights.
Yes. They should visit China and understand more before taking about China
There's other videos, genius :-)
Sad to say, the Chinese would definitely be relieved if they realise that these people are the foundation/future of India.
@@gtlover2011 lol chinese dont really care about India and why should they when they have USA to wolry about. At best you guys can Compete against Pakistan or Bangladesh but hey bagndesh per capita is higher than yours
As Chinese myself, I have not seen we Chinese gather together like this talk and discuss about India. We don't even care about what happened to India.
But why is India so concerned about China's affairs whereby India has more problems than China. We are not perfect but we are doing much better than India as everyone can see our developments compared to India.
It is not only these people who are talking about China. Not a day I don't see in Indian media reporting about China. All the propaganda, fake and negative news from WION, Hindustan Times, Firstpost, WION, TOI and many more are reporting about China and to bash and smear China. What have they gains for doing that? I can only guess 1 reason. Too jealous, upset and frustrating to see China is way ahead and they are still far to catch up.
BTW. My heartfelt condolences to those hundreds of Hindu devotees that died during the religion stampede.
Indian corporates are sold out on Chinese achievement and so they are least bothered about diversification of their Indian supply chain to improve Indian domestic production. They are focused into gains whether in 5 to 10 years from now and getting their geNext to continue either in India or abroad like if a company in China offers a product at 10 Paise( one rupee is 100 paise) including all logistics until their factory in India, they have not second thoughts about switching over to Chinese production. Indian government is trying to create awareness by being nationalistic to diversify their supply chain due to aftermath of Galway 2020 incident , stapled VISA to Arunachal citizen thus preventing Indians from North East to represent Indian in any global event that happens in any Chinese cities and due to economic woes in neighbourhood like Sri Lanka, Pakistan, Nepal, Bangladesh, Burma due to expensive Chinese loans and predatory Chinese foreign policy to leverage these country's economy to dominate these countries independent political and foreign policy. Indian economy is slowly booming which has penetrated hardly 10% of the 1.5 billion populace. As rest of the populace is slowly opening up their consciousness. Instead of Indian populace to become full depended on Chinese product, India government is try hard to become more independent from Chinese influence in ever sphere.
This is a self-contradictory comment. I'm seeing a whole lot of (presumably) Chinese people commenting on Indian videos about how Chinese people don't care about Indian videos 🤷♂
They're not particularly great videos (edit: excepting this channel, which is usually good, though this video could have flowed better). Some of the news here is admittedly pretty hysterical but that's the standard for Indian news, you should see how the media covers _Indian_ issues.
Problem's that China is a rising power with an aggressive foreign posture, which includes salami slicing on its neighbours' territory. This has to be dealt with. If you can't see that, you know where the door is.
@@be12 Maybe the Chinese only use TH-cam to see what the world is talking about the Chinese.
Relax bro...ten headed 🐍🐍🐍 as usual
The problem with India is their government focus too much on China instead of their own problems and people.
Sounds like USA🤣
Winne the Pooh bear, we’re not mindless sheep like the typical Chinese . West Taiwan needs to chill out 🤣
My thought exactly.
Not just the govt, the media and the people too. Of course, the media is to blame, they whip up the people's anti-China emotions to a frenzy. What for? Just to sell more newspapers? It is a shame. All that frenzy for naught.
If they spend as much time and energy on India, India will be a great place.
For the Indian readers who want to respond, I can tell you the China side is too busy to worry about India. They are doing trades and building infrastructures, not just at home, but around the world, especially in the Global South countries.
Just like the US.😂
Exactly- too obvious
From $37K to $45K that's the minimum range of profit return every week I thinks it's not a bad one for me, now I have enough to pay bills and take care of my family.
Excuse me for real?,how is that
possible I have struggling
financially, how was that possible?
Thanks to Elizabeth Marie Hawley.
YES!!! That's exactly her name (Elizabeth Maria Hawley) so many people have recommended highly about her and am just starting with her 😊 from Brisbane Australia🇦🇺
I have heard a lot of wonderful things about Elizabeth Maria Hawley on the news but didn't believe it until now. I'm definitely trying her out
Same here, with my current portfolio made from my investments with my personal financial advisor (Elizabeth Maria Hawley) I totally agree with you
The closest these analysts got to China was the one studied in Taiwan. News flash: Many Taiwanese even weren't aware they were Chinese because of their education and the media they read. They probably thought they're Japanese descendants😅.
You need to have at least one analyst that has set foot in China, or better yet, studied there
But Taiwanese speaks and writes in CHINESE LANGUAGE with almost same Confucius thinking and CHINESE CUSTOM too. That’s very very difficult to separate at all. They share similar songs and movie 🎥 stars
I met an Indian in Thailand. He told me proudly that India imported everything from China, implying Chinese economy would collapse without export to India. Then we searched online and found exports to India is 3% of Chinese exports. 😂🎉
Bollywood=Indian😂😂
i dont take indian seriously whenever i met one overseas.
@@masterwong5568😂but subject to Hollywood influence 😢
The quality of the discussion reflects the standard of education in India.
😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂 they can depending on their european/ american masters
🎉Belittling China when Indian airport roof is falling, bridge are collapsing, flood are killing people, air are choking Delhi...
Very surprised with Amit Kumar's analysis and position! We cannot talk on trade and investment as long as this border intrusion continues! Looks like Takshashila Univ seems a bit compromised on China position esp Amit!
"If a conflict starts, we don't know how it will go. Becoz India comes in, Japan comes....". Nothing could be more ludicrous.
Even though the title says round table, the table in the picture looks rectangular to me.
sign of jealousy, as per WHO definition
- You get concerned when the other country is getting well with others
-You obsessively check to see what the other country is doing
-You highlight the other country's problem ,however fake and keep quiet about its achievements
-You talk about other country on daily basis
-You keep talking about you rise and other country's downfall, all day long
Note=there is no cure for jealousy
I watched 20 minutes and had enough of this bullshit. Only negatives on China, particuparly Xi Jingping and PLA.
Xi Jingping is a buffoon, the best thing to happen to the world. lol
xi jingping deserves to be ridiculed. If you are CCP simp i suggest you take the first exit on the right, cuz we like to make fun of Winnie the pooh.
.....Difference between Indian and Chinese ruling political systems ---
India has 19th century corrupt feudalistic parliamentary democracy and China has socialism and capitalism democracy now........Wake up 19th century Indians right now...."Truth is God"- Gandhi ..........China is already in the next leve now...China is 30 years ahead of USA and 150 years ahead of India In everything now (infrastructure development and education)......Chinese GDP growth rate is still 5% which is still very high because Chinese GDP is 5 times more than Indian GDP now it means Chinese GDP growth rate is 5*5%= 25% now but Indian real GDP growth rate is 4-5% only so never trust Indian government Godi Media propaganda GDP growth rate now.... India is heavily depending on China for raw materials and high technology now and India will keep depending on China for the next 50 years to come in future too....
" Indians are bastards"- Henry Kissinger......
bullshit is good staff in india
India still playing the same role it played during opium wars. 😂😂😂😂
Exactly from history books. So will it mature ?
The people of India should wish Mr Xi a long life, if we go by the opinion of Chinese, the PLA should have taken back the territories usurped by India a long time ago.
Why india discuss china in lens of western views of China and they follow the same energy and aura of western interviews that they superior but India isn't superior to China 🤧🤧🤧
Because China's salami slicing low moral expansionist evil nature. This is how we discuss about villans
i bet these so-called experts do not even understand chinese language.
They don't have to understand the language to be a research analyst. But I do find their analysis superficial. They are merely repeating Western propaganda everyone can find on TH-cam.
Young scholars indeed, amateurish talk. It is better for Indians to reduce the talking and start improving India rather than always keep talking negatively about China like Palki Sharma. India needs to do a lot of catching up to be a truly developed country. The infrastructure is 3rd rate as compared to China, the cities are dirty and polluted, slow in modernization and application of new technology.
Excellent job. These Young Scholars are so informative and explain very clearly in simple English their observances. Their extrapolation of scenarios is very helpful to understand.
When you think you know the problems in a country thousands miles away, but you cannot see problems infront of your face
Correction
India is more exports dependent than china, India exports to gdp ratio 21.9 china 19.7 look at the world Bank statistics 2023.
China economy investment dependent. it's 42% of GDP. Does it matter if you have savings 47% of gdp and current account surplus.
These so-called intellectuals need to tell themselves and the world about India's own strategy to decolonize themselves of the exploitative/enslaving west than blabbering about what China's development aspirations are.
The Global Majority already understands and knows what Chinese led developments have done to their own country within their last 40 years journey and the rest of the world through their non-intrusive sharing models. Harping on about the Chinese province of Taiwan and her other autonomous regions is none of India's business.
The panel should listen to Jayant Bhandari if they want to have an accurate discussion about China.
Corruption and drugs destroy and breakup a country..
Enjoyed it - thank you
Very good insight indeed from Indian finest
Indian have been filled by bullshit and they are called finest
When Bharat Grows. China Slows
My foot
look at india import from china ,it skyrocketed after galwan
Who cares
印度跟中国一样都有悠久的历史，中国近代飞速发展的原因就是，中国经历过文化大清洗，彻底清除旧文化旧思想，甚至连儒教尊师孔子的雕像都砸碎，才给国人树立起科学理念，当今中国的基本国策是科学发展观，这就是中国崛起的原因，印度还处于神的笼罩下，想走科学道路要捣毁神庙，这个难度太大了。
God save indian from such youths
😂
A lot of 10 cent we chatters trolling this page eh
Bring on FORCE MAGAZINES Pravin to debate Suyash
They won't 😂😂
Not worth our time
@@nitingokhale184 ok, guess that this program isn't interested in hearing different opinions other than anti -China narrative
Please ask Pravin to show me any comments which is objective and unbiased about China. According to Pravin, there are no issues with China and all bad is with India only.
He is so consistent in peddling Chinese and Pakistani propaganda that he does not even try to appear objective. Like you wont find him talking about Chinese aggression in South China Sea or recently against Philippines.
You will never find any comments on anything where Chinese are aggressor.
Thats why he is just a lackey and does not deserve time on this platform.
@@Wishfulthinker9383 all the more reason for them to debate, isn't that the whole point of discussion/debate
#NoOneChina
india should work harder to alter the living standards of the people, infrastructures, table new laws to make the country stronger at the fundamental level, without which 'obsessive' comparisons to china is meaningless.
BEGONE CCP TROLL
@@wassuphomies263stupid ppl
62,....lagatar. .ghuspaith...Corona kal main jaberdst khooni jharap galwan main...Bus..bahut ho gaya
Ab china ki shakal lalo lal hagi..
Conversation kerte rahiya...per badla....
If they have any brain they would get together and plan a strategy to save India instead of wasting time talking about China.
Poor of Poor having laugh show
Ready for Uyger consentration camps? Rewards for umma in China😅😅😅
China experts 😂😂😂haahahaj freaking Smeelly PawjEet😂😂
Dirty bat eaters, 🤣
India China problem is rising out LAC issue It is not India China border but It is Tibet India border historically, culturally and geographical Tibet is India's leverage if India waits too long on LAC there will be never a tranquility on the border Tibet is bufferzone
Keep dreaming your sweet dreams.
@@padmawangyal8572 China and British Indias border
@@user-uy9zm8sf2y Hullo? Is this Mongol China?
As long as Indian government wants to claim the borderlines created by British Colonizer, the border problem between China and India won't be solved. And as long as India can't solve the border problem, India can't never commit itself into the economic development, since the borderline is too close to the capital of India not vise versa. So the Chinese can destabilize the India very easy with some some border conflicts. Remember the following words by a wise man...
Anywhere in the world, if there is a border dispute, it is usually the result of a line drawn by an Englishman; if it is an internal dispute, it is usually the US fueling it. Difference in implementation of divide and conquer strategy.
@@directxxxx71 The British are long gone. The dispute is now between India and China. Or perhaps India and Mongolia? Or all the other kingdoms that conquered "China".
How many Indian dead in this hot weather??
Who are these clowns
Global Hunger Index Rate 2023(Total 125 nations):
1. China: Below 25
2. SriLanka:61
3. Nepal: 69
4. Bangladesh: 81
4. Pakistan: 102
5. India: 111
India has a sever hunger problem. Fix your problems before pointing fingers at others. Also India and Nepal must peacefully work for the return of Bihari migrants from Terai, Nepal to India which is their rightful home. These Bihari should be proud of being Indians.
These folks mass migrated into Terai, Nepal during the great famines of India like in Bihar, UP, Madras, Bay of Bengal and so on taking advantage of open borders. Its been Nepal biggest headaches since their arrival. In fact the only headache. Only indigenous "Tharu" are native in Terai, Nepal with their own distinct culture.
Indians should act on it before Nepalese hate against them goes full blown. Indians doesn't know Indians are not native to Nepal and have maintained sovereignty before there was India as a nation. Even the British couldn't colonize them.
lol this is tragic.
Good day, Miss Saxena! You seem quite tense. Please take a deep breath and talk in a calm, collected voice. It will benefit both you and your viewers.
India😂😂😂 never as freedom people...
Up to now still under western influence.
Many indian CEO in western because no chance in India it self.
different With China, many Chinese expert, scholar back to China for develop their country 😊
For every Indian that is in the west, There are 5 chinese. Good luck living in your delusional land and speaking to your echo chamber. Reality is given the chance 90% of the chinese population will migrate to the west. They are only in china because of fear of winnie the pooh.
Lol. These guys r funny.
Next Uygers in the making😅😅😅
All the loser CCP trolls here saying how they don't care about India, yet they come hopping here to watch the video and comment eagerly. Someone is very worried , lol.
Topic roundtable China...so they watch but they can't understand what's going on
You’re so delusional. All you guys do is talk about China. Compare yourselves to China. Stop talking about China. China does not spend the kind of energy, that India does with China, talking about India.
Worried about what...? Actually yes, very worried
Your streets cities filled with shits , dirty food , bad air , scammers , beggars ， filthy rivers..
@@nigeltang8738 BEGONE CCP TROLL.
Redirect water away from heaven. There are no good people there Just redirect water to heaven. There are no good people there
I think this is like performance art. Performaner is happy but has no impact. since nobody cares India's opinion.
you care enough to comment on this post.
In this talk show.....look like. ...Somalian tv show they are discussing about American economy. Haha. So foolish.
Paid CCP Troll or donkey reseller to free uygers in China?
anyone of these China experts even been to China once? 🤣
我这么觉得这几个青年才俊说话都说不清楚，语无伦次，颠三倒四，逻辑混乱？
Non west,non middle east crusader, like Hindu, Buddhist, Asian,, should cooperative despite some issues unsettling,,, for good