Caleb Williams Has Generational Talent, But He’s Far From Perfect | Chicago Bears
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 13 ก.พ. 2024
- Grading The 2023 NFL Draft 1 Year Later (Picks 17-31):
• Grading The 2023 NFL D...
UNDERDOG Fantasy Free $100 Deposit Match: play.underdogfantasy.com/p-fo...
TWITTER: / fballanalysisyt
PATREON: patreon.com/FootballAnalysis
DISCORD:
/ discord
TIKTOK: vm.tiktok.com/ZMe5NbVa7/
Welcome to the Football Analysis TH-cam channel! Subscribe for all NFL related content! Drop a like if you enjoyed the video as all support is very much appreciated! Thanks for watching!
#nfl #nflfootball #football #nfldraft - กีฬา
The most underrated part of scouting a prospect is coaching. There are tons of QBs that had more potential to be better if they played for better teams with competent coaching Staff. Like Alex Smith for example. Played like a playoff caliber QB once he left SF. Then got his spot taken by Mahomes. Now granted he didn't have the potential to beat Mahomes spot but imagine if he got with Reid from the jump?
Coaching is the single most important factor. A great example is Josh Allen. Dude had potential coming into the league but if he was drafted by the Browns I guarantee the dude would be considered a bust rn. Great coaching and letting your players develop in the same offensive scheme is such an important factor in success in the nfl
@@andrewambrusko3651this will forever be an underrated comment.
Actually Smith started playing like a playoff calibre QB in San Francisco once Harbaugh arrived in 2011
Coaching is definitely important… but sometimes people just don’t work out and reach their potential
Alex smith was THE barometer for average qb play with Reid
From a JF1 fan... This is what I was looking for The Good the bad and the ugly not just highlights.. Awesome video
Thank you so much!
can we just acknowledge how good the prod. quality is on this video. the opening music perfectly encapsulates the vibe around caleb: mysterious, intriguing, omniously great but also concerning. wondeful video not only on Caleb as a prospect but the drafting and scouting process as a whole.
Hey Wilson I appreciate that more than you know
I can’t wait to see how this QB class plays out
Me to 😮
Let’s hope it doesn’t end up like the 2021 QB class
It will pan out just like the 2021 class. They're all 1 read or tuck and run. The one QB whose skillset translates best to the pro game is actually BO NIX. BO NIX takes what the defense gives him and uses one play to set up the next in order to set up the big plays which is exactly what a QB needs to do at the pro level. When you look at these QBs like Caleb Williams, Justin Fields, Zach Wilson, Trey Lance, Bryce Young they all play maddenball at the college level dropping bombs on future insurance salesmen in coverage. Then they get to the pro level where you have to throughly set up PLAY ACTION by using your running game, QB run option, counter run plays, Checkdowns, crossing patterns and slant passes, and they all blankly stare down the field like someone who was clocked in the head with a shovel. I'm telling you that BO NIX is this years Stroud
@@brianbelden2449 jj McCarthy is this years stroud to me
@brianbelden2449 now I get what you're saying and bo could be the most "pro-ready" qb - but the draft doesn't work that way, you draft off potential. and, as a patriots fan, I'm wary of players with this label of pro readiness at qb because of mac jones. you need great coaching as mac proved, so why not get the qb with more potential
Im so happy someone covered this. He has talent, it doesnt mean he will succeed.
As always his success will depend on the team he lands on. Teams that are always drafting near the top are not the best places to go, but that's mostly how it works. If it's a team that has a good defense with some good playmakers, then he won't be under pressure. At the same time we have the CJ Stroud comparison that will likely come up, with CJ going to what is considered a bad roster but still thriving.
I agree with your statement completely.
it also depends his ability to hold up to the pressure of an nfl pass rush. I would call that an intangible attribute that no one can see.
Now imagine him behind a Chicago O line in 2024. With Ryan Poles it certainly wont be the 2023 o line, but it also wont be the best in the league.
He's either gonna thrive or crack under that kind of pressure.
In my opinion the greatest QBs make plays, and off balance throws seconds before a 350 pound monster is face to face with them.
Goimg back to what you were saying about the system theyre put into.
People really like to forget that Mahomes not only went in the 10th round, but backed up Alex Smith for 17 weeks. He was put in on his first game to keep their QB1 from getting hurt after clinching the wildcard.
Completely different situation, but people get so blinded by hype.
Personality is also a big key, will he be arrogant or be willing to learn
Exactly. People roast the Bears for passing on Mahomes but he very likely would’ve failed with them because they suck at QB development. Also 8 other teams passed on him so🤷🏾♂️
Literally Justin fields lmao
Caleb to me is what Kyler Murray would have been if he was 6'2" 220. Personality and playstyle included
If you add in good pre snap reads and discipline that's basically aaron rodgers
Caleb is def not 6ft2.
He is more likely Purdy height at most. 6ft - 6ft and a half at most!
@@vitigaymer1053no he isn’t dummy. There’s a photo of him next to CJ at the Heisman ceremony. CJ is 6’3 and Caleb is 1, maybe 1.5 inches shorter. Go look up the pic you bum. Do something useful to backup your comments
@@vitigaymer1053 there's like a weird cutoff around 6'2" where guys are secure enough to give their real height lol. otherwise you should assume guys under that are probably padding their height by 1 to 2 inches
Caleb's height is a mystery but around 6ft ish def not 6'2".
I did the math on the distance of that 51 yard throw Caleb makes from the opposite hash, and the total yards it goes is about 58.6 yards. Super impressive.
Seems low
@@VaanRavi It's not, the camera makes the field seem wider and shorter than it actually is. Remember, 58.3 yards is 175.8 feet. It's pretty damn far.
I don't think it's very impressive for a college QB much less a NFL one. Justin Herbert completed 10+ passes where the ball travelled 55+ yards in the air. That 10 was only during his first 20 games too
@@claytonsutor3953and Justin has 5 it’s horrendous
@@claytonsutor3953you need to look at more football
There’s so many ppl praying that this dude is a bust. Grown men. It’s so sad. I hope Caleb goes to a good situation and succeeds. Unless it’s the Broncos 😅
Ong literally seen someone in this comment section praying on his downfall for no reason 😂
I’m not praying on his downfall but he is the most overrated QB prospect I’ve seen since manziel. He will not succeed because he cannot read a defense and the nfl will be far too fast for him.
Lions fan here, I hope he’s a bust unless Chicago trades for some reason
@@rumbelstiltskin1862 how can a nfl wr be to fast for a qb? You can coach qbs to read defenses, some qbs never even take a snap under center until they go into the league
I don’t want him to be a bust but I think he’s overrated
Unbelievable arm talent and he’s great at moving in the pocket. Only thing I don’t like is sometimes he holds the ball too long, hopefully he fixes that in the league
Agree and I saw every game he played at usc and a few at Oklahoma. That’s his competitiveness but it’s misguided competitiveness. It needs to be broken down and re-directed or he’ll get killed in the pros.
Struggling every time he faced a good D, used to having good time in the pocket, & making plays harder than they need to be at times is what would worry me
Reminds me of a certain Texas A&M QB. Wonder how that guy worked in the pros😂😂
@@joshlewis575Throw in the fact he paint his nails, demands to be made part owner of the team he goes to and issued a list of teams he would and wouldn’t play for and he’s worse than Manziel. He’s a toxic waste dump I wouldn’t want to be anywhere close to.
@@andrewmohrmann3599good thing your not making decisions in a front office
@@arod6079able Good thing my team doesn’t need a sorry ass QB like Caleb
@@andrewmohrmann3599throwing in painted nails like it’s the equivalent of being hooked on nose candy like Johnny Football was I think is a stretch, I will say if I was a team in need of a qb I would rather sit and wait than try and negotiate with the bears
I like how you describe the plays and explain what’s going on and the decision making, like at 1:30 , extremely helpful for someone like me who’s relatively new to watching football!
Thank you so much happy to help!!
Much better than the other channels that only stat watch and don't watch film. Truly a breathe of fresh air.
That second ND INT was part on the WR. If he flattens out, the catch is made. He’s making good reads, just a couple misplaced throws. I can live with that. Everyone throws INTs.
lol 5:40 is that the first time we have ever heard him swear?
yap yap yap bend over
No. But you're right, it doesn't seem to fit with the voice. Urinating Tree is overly cynical. Not this guy.
What worries me about Williams is not what's on tape, but instead it's what's not on tape. TLDR: he's never played the type of quarterback play that he'll have to play in the NFL, without the hype and narratives he'd be labeled as someone that needs to sit for 1-2 seasons before starting.
He only plays from shotgun and %90 of the time it's "go make something happen" rather than a proper structured play. He never has played under center with 3 and 7 step drop backs, so there's none of those quick timing passes that are used all the time in the NFL (think nearly Tua's entire playbook). He also doesn't go through proper 1-2-3-4-checkdown read progressions, again mostly because he's told to run around to make something happen.
Of the old fashion red flags: he's not good under pressure, at all. Also he's very prone to hero ball. He's not good at reading defenses. 6 foot 1 in college is 6-0 in reality or even 5-11.
Yes, and also he is weak mentally and I don't think he will be respected as a leader. Say what you will about mental health, but do you really think NFL guys gonna respect a guy who goes crying to his momma when he loses? Idk.
What I do know is that he is going to fumble a lot. He has some of the worst ball security I've ever seen. The way he runs is like he is playing flag football.
Imo he's a 2nd or 3rd round pick disguised as a #1 overall due to hype.
Chicago should draft mhj and trade up for Brock powers. There are plenty of QBs in the draft that have great potential. Pick one of them up instead
@@gazamidori2866bruh explain how he’s “weal mentally”
The throw to Rice early in the video down the left sideline was a 3 step drop then he climbs the pocket and throws. Towards the end of the video he throws a quick slant after a 3 step drop. Yes he does need to learn how to play under center but he does play on time and in structure as well as goes through his progressions. Is it perfect no but hardly anyone is especially coming out of college. Does he leave the pocket yes but he also keeps his eyes downfield looming to make a play. He doesn't bail the pocket to run like many QBs are prone to do. What wasn't included is his release and how quickly he gets rid of the ball which is important on the timing of the passing plays just like that slant
@@mmundle941they have no evidence lmao it’s draft season baby it’s time for false narratives! Remember pre draft Justin Fields was lazy and not a hard worker and CJ Stroud was a poor test taker so he’ll never be good in the NFL!
@@gazamidori2866 SO you decide someone is weak mentally when you don't know him at all. The funny is you say he won't be a leader when there is a long list of USC players that would tell you that you are full of shit. Oh and bad ball security? Seriously. I understand now why you talk on TH-cam and don't have any respect in the football world.
How is there a "Once in a Generation Talent" every year? 🤔
That’s what I’m wondering 🤦♂️
Exactly. People overuse that term.
Talent doesn’t always= success.. so much has to go right
media has gotten out of control
The last “generational” qb was Trevor Lawrence before that was Andrew luck????
great content as always
Thank you!
Bravo..this was very well done!
Thank you!
OK, Caleb is not 6'2" people so please report correct info about the guy. He is listed at 6'1" now so until that is examined more at the combine along with other traits like hand size which believe it or not are both considered important traits of successful QB's in the NFL.
He’ll be 6’0 at the combine.
Not great size…
Late but 6’1 was right
@@embee9936he’s 6’1 217 pounds perfect for an elite qb like Williams with his his arm talent
Love this video format can you do more for some of the other prospects for the upcoming draft?
Absolutely
An interesting video would be to analyze the negatives of Mahomes, Burrow, etc when they were coming out and see if they learned or improved on those things. I think it's ok for players to have negatives coming out of college, as good coaching (like Andy Reid & Mahomes) can make raw talent into brilliance in the NFL
He can have all the 'Mahomes comparisons' as he wants ... yet the one that might be missing is the most important one; he ain't a 'killer' like Mahomes
I see the same talent ... I don't see the same drive ... I don't see him landing on the same coach ... or being gifted the best TE ever and Tyreek to get the early years going.
My point ... It's kinda dumb for people to remotely expect another Mahomes when that kid got so stupidly lucky in almost every regard for him to be successful. Good luck living under this shadow, Caleb
Gronk is the best TE ever
Having DJ Moore, Cole Kmet, and another WR in either the draft or FA with your OC from the McVay tree isn't a bad starting off point
@@ciromorales1421 Nope, that ain't bad either. If they get a good WR2 like Slim in Philly, and if the OC can click like Steichen did with Hurts and their trio of receiving weapons in '22 then bears can have potential. Still isn't likely at all to be 'Mahomes-like' from either Fields or Williams imo, hopefully they'll develop their own mold n name just like Hurts did when he went toe-to-toe with Mahomes during '22 season n SB
@@Umega101 that's the misconception of when people hear these comparisons. They hear Mahomes, Rodgers, and even a bit of Allen like in this video they think that's how successful they will be and will win MVPs and 3 super bowls in 7 years. But it's how they play the position and their game is what's similar not the success. The success depends on a lot of factors such as Williams himself, the players around him currently on what team drafts him, and the coaching he receives
@@Umega101ya it’s the play style, not the overall success or career. He makes plays like Mahomes. He has the ability to make mahomes-like plays. His arm talent is kinda like Rodgers too with the release and arm angles. That’s what people mean
Caleb is fire if he doesn’t have to play hero ball I feel he will be vintage Russell Wilson with a drew Bree’s accuracy
"Hero ball"😂😂 all that is is him not seeing the field. It'll surely continue at the next level because he can't read the defense. Dude is nothing but a black Johnny football
@@joshlewis575 he can’t read defenses 😂😂😂 oh ok…
Thank you video stat guy
Love the video. Even mahomes struggled in college!
Seriously! People always say "so and so isn't Mahomes".
MAHOMES wasn't Mahomes in college either. It's about play style. I personally see Caleb's play style as primarily a mix of Allen and Rodgers with a little mix of Mahomes and Murray.
Thank you!
Patty had a trash ass coach. Kingsbury is as overrated as a coach as you'll ever see. Imagine not being able to win in the garbage big 12 with arguably the best QB ever. He'll be out of Washington within 3 years. What a fluke
NOTHING IS GUARANTEED but for the folks that dont know CALEB WILLIAMS is absolutely it. I have never seen a QB that has all the tools and mind you even MAHOMES did not show his wears until ANDY REID polished him. CALEB WILLIAMS challenged is the fact that USC and LINCOLN RILEY got to pass happy that I rarely saw an audible but LETS BE REAL CALEB WILLIAMS has inate accuracy superb arm strength and the leadership it takes to be the next GREAT ONE. Not to mention he is sneaky quick and fast on those qb runs. If the Bears do get him they better get a legit headcoach.
Caleb won’t even sniff Stroud’s rookie year success and Stroud inherited what was believed to be a bottom 3 supporting cast and ended up setting records. Caleb will not elevate an offense on that level and I’d be my life on it
He does what Mahomes does but to an extreme. He’ll have to adjust his game big time. He can still do the magician stuff but that extending the play for 20 seconds before finding an open receiver aint gonna cut it in the league. With that being said, I hope whichever team he goes to doesn’t ruin him
I think he did that because he knew he could get away with it.
Da bears will ruin him
Idk man, as a Jets fan I’ve come to realize one thing about QBs: you can’t fix bad decision making
He doesn’t have bad decision making
He doesn't have bad decision making? Other than hero ball his decisions are pretty fine
You play in the same division as Josh Allen
I trust that the Chicago organization will make a well-informed decision regarding the potential drafting of Williams. It will be intriguing to observe his performance in a more competitive environment, which will provide a clearer assessment of his capabilities.
Will there be a video on what u think the falcons should do?
With Williams, the so-called "flashes" are brighter and far more numerous/frequent than those of his peers. His good play greatly outweighs any subpar moments. It is well to remember, too, that he won the Heisman as Sophomore, after not playing his senior year in high school due to Covid.
For fans whose only dose of Williams was his frightful night against Notre Dame (a poor First Half, really, and a one-off anomaly in his charmed career), a note of elucidation:
At N.D. Williams had yet to abandon his dubious decision to play only from the pocket (even when none existed) and eschew running opportunistically this season - a preseason move made presumably with an eye toward his NFL future.
Williams' preemptive moratorium on running was disconcerting - if not disappointing - to observant fans, but didn't seem to hurt SC's offense much in the early going (recall, Williams led the nation in almost every QB passing stat and total for much of this season's first half - and this while playing only two and a half quarters per game, as SC and its top-ranked offense racked up a string of routs scoring 53.2 points per contest).
The new No-Run Williams kept rolling right on through the first two quarters at Colorado, when SC held a 20-point lead against its Week-5 foe at intermission. A day at the office, par for the course.
Then, in an instant, the Wheels fell off.
The Buffaloes were the first ones to crack the code - simply dropping 7 or 8 defenders to flood and choke off the secondary, a tactic which becomes feasible when it's known that a QB won't run. As SC's offense stalled for the first time all season, the Trojans' train-wreck of a defense did its thing as Colorado stormed back, forcing Williams - who a week earlier made his first fourth-quarter appearance since last winter's Cotton Bowl - to play the full game. The clock would eventually save the Trojans - who went scoreless in the final period - as SC scraped by to win 48-41.
The Trojans next opponent, Arizona, now had a template - and indeed the Wilcats' "dollar" defense (eight men deep) neutralized SC's air game. It was at this point - six games into the schedule - that Williams finally realized he'd have to become his old self, at least for one game. Though his natural runner's instincts may have atrophied from long disuse, Williams, returning to form, put his team on his back and Found A Way with his legs - his OT rushing touchdown (No. 3 on the day for Williams) capping a comeback win, 43-41, for a still-unbeaten USC. It would stand as the last of Williams' many clutch showings - dating famously back to his prep days - not to be undermined by his team's defense (to be sure, William's' personal record in Crunch Time isn't spotless, but on balance tends markedly towards success).
After the AU game, fans at last got confirmation that Superman indeed had voluntarily been shelving half of his superpowers, as Williams confounded the press with this remark, accompanied by an emabarrassed giggle and knowing glance toward Lincoln Riley: "I don't really like to run." (This from the man whose legs, chiefly, had carried him from high school higlight reels to the top of the Heisman podium.)
SC's next adversary - and the one who would decisively cause Williams to rue his new mindset (and then more or less scrap it, shrewdly, for the season's remainder) - was waiting in South Bend, champing at the bit. (While SC's embattled O-line, coincidentally, awaited its final collapse.)
Whichever team selects Williams (no doubt he's praying it's Not the Bears), it'd behoove them to steer the thoroughbred Talent back toward his natural style - telling him to Take Off when he sees green grass, permitting Superman access to his full complement of powers.
- G. Uribe
TLDR but I know you mention CW’s minimal development due to his team’s limitations. I think that more than anything aligns him with Mahomes, for better or worse😬. He needs to land with a top level coach to ensure success.
@@chetsenior7253was the case for Mahomes and Stroud as well.
Lay off the Adderall my guy 😂. Or did you just snort an 8 ball?
I ain’t reading all that, nice job by his Agent to post this on socials tho.
Holy chatgpt
I think the biggest knock on him is the fragile dudes complaining about him painting his nails 😂
It comes down to the team if he’s on commanders or pats expect a Bryce young 2.0 season for a least two seasons which may lead to him not getting a second chance commander have a good qb in Sam Howell who does a lot of things Caleb can do and look how that went no point in drafting a qb if he’s going to be on the ground 70% of snaps at pats got a good defense which limits time of possession but commanders are the equivalent of usc in the nfl, whatever qb gets drafted there will be labeled a bust despite whatever skill set they have. But on the bears or maybe falcons or Vikings come up the board draft him then he’d get fair opportunity to prove himself.
Agree everyone was hyping bryce as well but look his team and that organization failed him
Best spot is bears commanders don’t have a good oline and will have to trade away picks or players to get him
Thanks Merrill Hoge
Run...they are coming for you.
i hate saying this because i despise comparisons but this is eerily similar to Pat Mahomes coming out of college
Mahomes had a lot of help especially in his early years with Kelce, Hill, O-Line pro bowlers and Andy Reid
How is there no comparison seen between Williams and Murray? It’s so easy to see
Expert analysis Tony
Oh I dont know Jiiiiiiiim
@PhatLvis It would behoove you to have a preemptive moratorium on elucidation.
good vs well bro
Imagine if Bo Nix is the best after 5 years
He won’t be
Bo Nix is fool's goold@@JJ-zr6fu
We’ll it depends where he goes ? It’s going to be a qb that gets drafted into the perfect situation & they’ll say he was the best qb in this class. It all depends where you go
Buddy is gonna be damn near 30 in 5 years lmao
3:15 you said this throw “was absolutely unreal.” 🧐🤔 Looks EXACTLY like the same throw Justin threw to DJ Moore in the game against the Lions when they won where DJ had 2 men trailing him 🤷🏽♂️ Also, the PAC12 ain’t the SEC. He didn’t really play nobody #NotThatImpressed
Everyone knows Justin has upper echelon borderline elite arm talent he’s a baseball player
@@KevonDaDon Facts!
facts
U can not find me a clip of Justin throwing a dart on the money like that on the run 65+ yards on one foot…stop lying and follow Justin to the next team.
Uhmmm, except the throw from Caleb was 20+ yards longer, and tighter coverage lol. Also, he didn’t set his feet. Justin set his before he threw it. Justin’s was not even REMOTELY as impressive.
to all these people in the comments criticising his leadership ability and personality, have you met him? have you talked to his coaches and teammates? ...no?!
unless you're one of the select few with nfl/usc connections, all you can go on the tape and the traits
Nah but i did see him run and cry in his mom's arms like a little b*tch. Don't need to see much else.
Didn't play his bowl game and the backup outplayed anything he did all season against an actual contender. You don't need to personally know him to know he's not the guy. Just a stupid take tbh. With that same logic nobody should say anything about any president ever. But we know that's not the case.
@@savvyb54 1. would you rather he punch a wall in the locker-room because that's "masculine"? it's normal, it's human, and shows that he cares
2. i'm saying leave personality out of the equation and accept that your evaluation as a fan is going to be incomplete. if he interviews poorly, yeah drop him down your board if you're an NFL TEAM
3. pretty much every highly-projected prospect in the CFB era skips their bowl game unless they're in the playoff
4. i evaluate a president on policy first. i'm not an emotional voter but idk why you would bring it up, totally irrelevant
@@savvyb5472 IQ comment
@@savvyb54Are you an nfl scout or a coach? Have you ever met CW personally? Stfu then, you have no idea what you’re talking about. This comment that you made would lead me to believe you are either stupid or 14
and you're in the same boat, and if you think this is bad wait til the Chicago media gets to him lol ask any QB that played here, hope his mom travels well....
I like him as a prospect, but I have my concerns just like with any prospect (short of Andrew Luck type of talent). I’ve just read some things that concern me regarding him as a teammate. He made a TON of NIL money, and it’s harder to gel with your entire team (or offense) when you’re making millions and some are making squat. He was in a unique situation in that regard so I guess we will have to see how it plays out. Sounds like he needs to go to a team with a decent offensive line.
He looks good in red and yellow, hopefully those are his colors in the NFL
Caleb Superman Williams !!
Do a video on Drake Maye. I really like him but it seems like Caleb gets hated for some of the same bad habits in Mayes film. Difference is Caleb is a superior talent
Video on Drake Maye will be out soon
6:30 Jalen Milroe shoutout.
He's super hard for college guys to tackle.
Joe Montana was considered small with a mediocre arm and he wasn’t drafted til the 3rd round. But the new coach at the 49ers in 1979 had decision making authority for drafting players, and he knew that these criticisms paled in comparison to other traits he saw in Montana: his instincts, his competitiveness, and his ability to control a game. That new coach, Bill Walsh, already had a reputation as a superb QB position coach and he knew Montana could be developed to acquire the skills needed to succeed and excel in the NFL. Walsh knew a winner when he saw one. Williams has some amazing natural ability. He may not quite have Montana’s legendary competitiveness or ability to control a game, but he’s no slouch in that regard, either. He really wants it bad. I think he’ll succeed.
Yes in the first play he missed seeing a wide open receiver but the fact that he had the presence of mind to throw it away shows maturity.
College prospects aren’t perfect!!?!?🤯🤯🤯
Yes that's exactly what he's pointing out genius. Sorry but Caleb Williams is not the next coming of jesus christ
@@bigchungus2030 whooosh
@@bigchungus2030Work on your sarcasm detection.
There's only one generational talent in this draft and it sure as sh!t isn't Caleb Williams or any of the QBs in this class. Marvin Harrison Jr IS a generational talent and whoever has the first pick would be idiots not to draft him.
Ok Marvin Harrison jr
I found MHJ’s TH-cam burner. Or his biggest glazer not sure which
Fully agree, glad you made this. His indecisiveness in the pocket could be damning at the next level. His arm talent and mobility is clearly pretty Mahomie though, which will save him. I still take him #1 if im the Bears, and grab the best receiver possible to pair him with. Maybe MHJ, Maybe Bowers. They could be competent year 1.
Regardless, I don't trust the Bears to develop any QB even if they do take him.
Yeah they just don't know how to develop a qb, they're cursed.
Yeah but that's all in the past so who cares. It's not like the same qb coach and oc are still around from drafting all those quarterbacks. So that really doesn't matter.
Yes but their OC is the miracle worker who turned Geno freakin Smith into a Pro Bowler.
And he comes from the Shanahan-McVay coaching tree. This is the most un-Bears coaching hire ever vs going for the predictable Greg Roman or Kliff Kingsbury hire.
The bears are cursed at QB until they aren’t. If the cubs can break a 100 year curse the bears can find a QB.
Exactly he has the tools & talent but he still needs to be developed . The problem is the bears don’t do that, bears have to be patient but the fans are going to expect him to come him & win right away especially after getting rid of a qb like Justin fields
I'm glad we're covering this. We are seeing "look at how good he is" against God awful defense and then brush over good defense. Congratulations you have receivers open like rookie on Madden.
He played against both good and bad defenses. Don’t generalize about how particular college conferences play on defense. It’s lazy thinking
@@pjmlegrande I mean he played like dog shit against good defenses. Bro has one good year then his returning year was and embarrassment and people act like they need to trade a team for this average guy?
Your page helped me get back into football. 2020-2022 were sleepy years for me. I like that you talk about good teams being good and talk about good teams being bad. And vice versa. No excuses. Just facts. I respect your content a lot and I hope you continue to blow up dude!
Thank you so much I really appreciate it!! Just trying to positively make an impact!
Trevor Lawrence, the last generational talent was mid AF while bust magnet like Josh Allen and Justin Herbert shocked everyone. Case in point, CJ. These generational talent guys rarely pan out. It’s much better to draft a physical talent and develop him.
Great points. Patrick Mahomes was also considered a “project” and we see how good he is now
So draft Caleb thanks
I view him as Trevor Lawrence if he gets drafted by the bears or Washington.
Only thing that concerns me about him is him being 6 feet tall. I don’t think that will transition well to the NFL.
This dude never misses
Appreciate you
Happy Valentine’s Day!
Thanks Jake you too 🥳
As a Giants fan, we need to pick up a quarterback in this draft. Perhaps not one of the top 2 or 3 prospects, but somebody who along with Devito to put pressure on DJ. Who I fully believe isn’t the quarterback for the franchise and we need to move on from, instead of wasting yet another year. Yet we only have ourselves to blame after giving him the extension last offseason.
The only chance he has to be “The next Patrick Mahomes” is if a good team trades up for him. Even then that team would give up so much to do it, it’ll hurt his chances of success.
You know the Bears' #1 pick is through the Panthers right? They could've easily been 10-7 this season if it wasn't for three historical collapses against the Broncos, Lions, and Browns (two teams of which were in the playoffs).
So that team plus the upcoming draft and free agency should be good enough to at least make the playoffs, even if they do roll with Fields. Even more so with Williams. Not to mention hugely upgrading their offensive staff.
@@disthymia6929 But they weren’t 10-7. If they could’ve easily gone 10-7 why didn’t they? I’m not a Bears hater. I just think Mahomes benefited from going to a team with a solid roster and good head coach that had winning seasons every year for the past five years before he even got there. If the Bears have failed so far to develop Fields, I don’t have faith that they’ll develop Williams (who’s a spoiled brat and a diva) any better.
@@YourExGranPappiIf you’re Chicago, would you draft him or keep Justin?
@@DondreDashard Draft him and trade Justin. I don’t expect Williams to fail in Chicago. I hope for their sake he’s solid. I just think you can’t expect any player to be “The next Mahomes.” No one even expected Mahomes to be this good or he wouldn’t have fallen to ten. We’ve seen what Fields can do, and it’s not much. Plus maybe I’m wrong and Williams ends up being amazing. Just bet on the upside and hope for the best.
Bro looks like he plays like Josh Allen more than anyone else always looking for the home run play #GoBILLS
On that first int vs notre dame, the problem wasn't his choice to throw, he over threw it badly. That would have been a good throw if he didn't just flick it out there to avoid being sacked. He legit could have thrown a competition there. But he like many of his highlight throws are erratic.
Here’s my issue with the bears drafting him; any QB that has had moderate success in the NFL is better than any incoming rookie until that rookie has proven otherwise. We’ve seen so many QB’s come into the league and fail. I think it’s a very poor decisions by the bears to pick Williams over Justin, because it is inherently a risk. I think they could immensely benefit by trading off the pick and reaping the rewards of a couple 1st round draft picks. As a Falcons fan I hope they trade him to use though.
Basic by ur logic Texans never should have draft cj stroud bc they had Davis mills and he had some success plus fields never got success
@@gamothelegend7712 it’s a tough call. My worry is Caleb Williams work ethic/mental state, especially at the qb position
@@NathanMoon-tz2jp there are no reports about Caleb’s work ethic or attitude/ character
@@NathanMoon-tz2jp how you gonna worry about something when 0 negative reports about it have come up 😂 creating your oen narrative is crazy
That’s what they said about Bryce and Lawrence.
This is not at all a shot against FA (who is only referring to others’ opinions) but “generational talent” has to be used 100x less frequently. It’s lost its meeting and most people who were hyped as such are not. Conversely, iirc, Mahomes wasn’t a generational talent until he played in the nfl. Nobody was taking him #1 overall.
Andy Reid's GM and scout team thought Mahomes was the greatest player they'd ever seen. Sean Payton said Mahomes reminded him of Farve. Caleb isn't the first QB to receive big praise before playing in the NFL.
Put this guy with Bill or Andy and you will have 8 or nine Super Bowl appearances with seven or eight wins.
The ending is exactly why the Bears need to draft him. We are not the worst team in the NFL, we have a good WR and TE, with a mid but improving O-line
Im hoping he listens to criticism so he can grow I hope he don't just put up good numbers and don't win it feels like it will unless he listens
As a Trojan fan, you can guess how I feel about Caleb and his talent. Fight on forever.
I think he didn't hit that dig route in the middle of the field because he's pretty short and couldn't get it over #93 that was waiting to swatt it
5:53 he looks like he’s trying hard not to lose. The same guy who cries with his mom in the stands before the tv broadcast is over can make it look like he’s trying hard not to lose. Shocker. This is hero ball?
I hate the generational talent talk, a lot of it comes down to team situation coming into the league and usually its not good if you’re a top pick. Look what happened to t lawrence and burrow.
Commenting for the algorithm.
:]
GOAT
On that UCLA play…first ask the wr why he sat down on his route directly behind the ref, forcing Caleb to move left to find an open window…then too late.
As a Bears fan, I find it delightfully ironic that Caleb reminds me most of Aaron Rodgers.
Interesting. Rogers is Williams’ favorite QB
Doesn't matter. Even if he isn't mahomes he's certainly better than fields
wanna bet
Last generational QB was Andrew Luck he was perfect QB if Luck went to a better team he wouldve be in the GOAT Convo.
The best comp for him is Fran Tarkenton
Can't wait to see this guy in a Bears uniform
Yuck
@@angelshadowofficial9218 You must be a Packers fan
As a lions fan I don’t want to see him twice a year
Tbh I think Caleb is the best QB in this draft but I don't think he is a generational talent. He's a weaker prospect than Trevor Lawrence was and I see him being a good QB in the league but not top 5.
You didn't want to see Justin either. He torches the lions.
Pray that the Broncos Raiders or Patriots give away their entire draft to get him
@@Philtrationand as a bears fan you also aren’t used to winning so we don’t blame you for incompetence
It’s gonna be real fun having Kirk Cousins, Jordan Love, and now probably Caleb Williams all in our division…
Ugh with this phrase. I remember Trevor Lawrence being called generational talent just three years ago. TL was good last year, but hardly the best QB in the last 20 years. Now Caleb Williams is a generational talent even though he apparently cannot even play consistently at the college level. Apparently 'generational talent' does not mean much. Let's come up with some new cliches to overuse on people.
Trevor Lawrence is Mid. Had one good season and then collapsed. He’ll be like Alex Smith
DJ LAGWAY IS COMING!!!🔥
When was the last time the qb taken as a number 1 overall turned out to be that guy?
Burrow
@@KevonDaDon I guess
@@jasonbrown5342Cmon Burrow is that guy. He’ll win a few.
@@DondreDashard gotta be on the field
@@jasonbrown5342 Fair point. Availability is the best ability. But he’s definitely a winner.
1:57 to hit his receiver Caleb would have to throw through the ref thats in the worst place possible.
If anyone is doubting Caleb, go back and watch his CFB debut in OU Texas and those doubts should be erased pretty quick
JF is gone already.Theres no way Poles is passing on this guy.Hes a smart business like guy.Hes running the place like hes in a real production facility.I trust the decisions an believe the easy bears loses will end.
Bears need him
What will hold Caleb back is his intangibles. People compare him to mahomes but I see him as more of a Aaron Rodgers. For how many plays he makes and have a 93 TD to 14 INT in 3 years is absurd.
He won’t save a dysfunctional organization, but in the right hands. There’s a great chance he’ll be an all time great
I agree, he's too emotionally unstable to be Mahomes
Every Qb misses guys even mahomes
Yeah, but not every series 🙄
Bro this music is so moody
Let us not forget about Matt Leinart, now.
How is this in any way relevant in evaluating Williams’ NFL potential? Foolish consistencies are the hobgoblins of small minds, it is said.
The one thing I have been wondering is why people haven’t been talking about and concerned with his mental capacity. He seems to be immature from the videos I’ve seen on him, made a list of the only teams he’ll play for and says he wants to be part owner of the team, and acts like a child when things don’t go his way. To me, that isn’t someone I would want being the face of my franchise. And why is everyone saying that the Bears are going to take him? The Bears aren’t on his list of teams he would play for so what if he pulls an Eli Manning? I dont know man…. It seems like to me that there’s things that these “football experts” aren’t saying for some reason. There were many other players before Caleb that had the same mental aptitude that people talked about all the time…
His camp specifically said that wanting to be "part owner" is fake and that he is not "anti-Chicago" according to Cowherd. Next time, do research
@@chonk4334 lol ok chunk. I spend a lot of time watching stuff and excuse me the “part owner” part got past me. You still haven’t defended the other stuff I said so apparently what I’ve seen is true lol. Not to mention seeing his demeanor during games and press conferences. Just because that part isn’t true, doesn’t mean everything else I’ve said isn’t. Still wouldn’t want a guy like him running my team
@@robertjohnston6976 Why are we questioning his character when we don't even know him personally is the real question lol
A lot of these comments sound like they want the kid to fail. You for sure have to be thorough when evaluating these College QB’s and pointing out their weaknesses/strengths and things they need to work on for the next level, and Caleb for sure has things to work on. But in a lot of these comments and their evaluations of him. They seemingly want him to fail rather than hoping he gets better to do well in the NFL. Good video as always F.A 🫡🔥
Thank you so much!
my opinion on caleb williams has arrived
DAK 2
🐻 ⬇️
Caleb Williams plays too much Hero Ball and he should work on just taking the checkdown at times instead of trying to be Mahomes