I kind of like that Sandpaw changes her opinion on Fireheart even without him saving her life. He leads a charge into Shadowclan camp to rescue kits, drives out a dictator, and brings an entire clan back home. His accomplishments are undeniable and you can’t really try to belittle them (especially when the average warrior’s biggest life accomplishments probably involve bringing home a fat squirrel from the hunting patrol). It shows that Sandpaw can see Fireheart’s worth from how he treats others, not just from things he’s done for her specifically.
I loved that she actually was given the chance to apologize to Fireheart , it was something that it was missing for me, I think the line "you are warrior through and through" will stick in my heart and mind.
Even so, I love that, I just genuinely love how after EACH page she's on, you can just visible see her thinking, watching, admiring or sticking up for Fire
The whole bit with Sandpaw specifically I really like personally. I saw people say her coming around to liking Fireheart feels out of nowhere now but idk, I like it more that it feels like she chose to get to know him and warmed up to him and respecting him as a fellow clanmate due to maturing over the moons, rather than having a "oh maybe he's not so bad" realization just because he saved her during the battle
I know its not very related to the video, but if the novels/comics keep going until TNP i really hope the authors include a scene of Firestar, Cloudtail and maybe BrightHeart too saying their last goodbyes to Princess. Its always bugged me how they dont even mention Princess when the clans leave, or how they never think of her after that. A scene like this could be very cool and impactfull, even if quite sad. It could teach kids how to say Goodbye to someone they know (a very valuable thing to learm, especially early on in life).
1000000% agreed on appreciating more what they added than despairing over anything cut. The sheer amount of characterization and personality OOZING off the pages enraptured me in ways the series hasn’t since I was a kid. I understand why things had to be cut and imo it was more important to establish ITW with its world building than Fire & Ice. And GOD I hope they make more!!!
Cinderkit's face in that one scene absolutely cracked me up, as well as Fireheart's face when he was caught eating prey. The faces in the graphic novel go from goofy to adorable to terrifying and I ADORE it
I was at a Barnes and Noble and saw the Warriors event going on! I didn't know about it beforehand, but the kids section was absolutely SWARMING with children making cat masks. It was so cute to see 😊
I think it could have been stronger if more of fire and ice could have been included, but I still really enjoyed it. I think rising storm will be the easiest to truncate without losing too much, as the most important events are the fire and Yellowfang's death
I feel like people forget that they physically CANNOT show every little detail- that's not possible. Plus, the story is already overly complex and weird so it's just a mess and these two are also new to making this series. I think they did an amazing job and I think they deserve a lot more praise than what most are giving. The original books were confusing and weird and pacing was bad but at least the novel here is showing me something I can understand. I appreciate them for their effort.
I got into Warriors through the old graphic novels. My older brother owned a few, but I also frequented my local library for them. It was at that library another warriors fan recommended to me the main story novels
I am more than thrilled to see how great this graphic novel is! I bought it as soon as I saw it came out! I am just in love with all the personality that it can portray with it's characters! Of course a couple things had to be skipped, but like you said, it still overall gave us an amazing retelling of the first two books! Super excited for the next release, and hoping that the continue further with these!
Genuinely cant get over how much i love the art in the graphic novel. Its so vibrant and expressive! I was having fun just flipping through it to look at the pictures. Its also fun to see how they interpret certain things like the entto the mothermouth. I always just pictured it as a random hole in the cliff but seeing it as an abandoned mine shaft is super cool.
One can assume that Whiteclaw might not actually be dead yet. His death could be postponed and moved to a different part of the timeline, similar to how Swiftpaw’s death may have a different circumstance since he has been apprenticed alongside Cinderpaw and Brackenpaw instead of later.
What I'm guessing is that Whiteclaw's death is postponed, for now. We have no evidence that he's dead yet, from the pages I've seen. So they might wanna put it somewhere else! It could be that they want Graystripe to join Riverclan before Whiteclaw dies?
There wasnt an event at the Barnes and Noble I went to during vacation (I got the book the day it came out then went again to get The Rise of Scourge and Graystripe's Adventure cause I hadnt read those yet). Anyway, that second day I got the bag and activity sheet in the video, alongside a sneak peak of the next adaptation and those little tattoos that you put on with water! I am still SO confused what you are meant to do with the area with numbers and spots to fill in, but otherwise I LOVE it!
i just wanna know how they're gonna do the dog arc without brightpaw since 1. it's a really important plot point and 2. brightheart is a very popular character
I got the soft cover on sale, but plan to go after the hard cover! The book was so amazing, and I can't wait for more! I'll probably need another book shelf, here's hoping!
Yeah I think that the graphic novel was really good at least the into the wild part, although fire and ice wasn’t remade very well I still think the graphic novel was really good, and the charector designs were amazing! Overall I think it was an amazing book tho
oh man i WISH i knew the hardcover was gonna have such an awesome under jacket cover im so jealous i didnt think to get both versions lol some scattered thoughts i had after reading! the one detail i am actually sad they changed that i think would have still fit the new format was silverstream's banter after she saved him to just her laughing at him... 'can't you drown on your own territory' is such an iconic line to me! im tempted to just marker it in on that page lmao but overall yeah! i think doing a scenes focused approach to the story is really smart even if some stuff is a bit out of sequence or abridged it still gives you the feelings and most important part of the moment; personally would have liked a biiit more yellowfang pages bc firestar looking after her is much more prolonged than that cute little montage and it does cut the moment graypaw was forced to eat two mice bc he was trying to cover for firepaw so he wouldnt get in trouble which always stood out to me as a good scene that shows graypaw is a dedicated friend (though him drawing attention away from ravenpaw when tigerclaw is putting him down during training has a similar effect) I think the into the wild section of the novel is just about PERFECT amount of detail vs snappy, though i do have my concerns about fire and ice / forest of secrets. i think i especially have to commend the rat scene because HOLY shit they managed to make that just as scary as the original books the panel where they are dragging ravenpaw down the ledge goes CRAZY the abridged version of fireheart/graystripe's conflict over silverstream in fire and ice is a bit disappointing bc the drama of that was always so juicy to me but i also understand it didnt fit the tone the graphic novels were setting up; it would be a bit much to throw that in and expect the book to end on a high note of "yay im a warrior cat now :D" and not "well i was fist fighting my friend in the middle of camp but we made up and came to an uneasy understanding" I'd definitely recommend a fan read both versions bc the original fire and ice/forest of secrets definitely had a more anxiety inducing effect on fireheart with him juggling graystripes sneaking out and trying to mentor cinderpaw and his own meetings with princess and knowledge of tigerclaws treachery. as a big princess fan, i do enjoy her being introduced earlier and she is SO adorable in the graphic novel but it is a stark difference from the original because fireheart is grappling with his lack of family in the clan, feeling ostracized for his kittypet origins, and its been so long since he's seen her it really is a BIG moment when he finally meets her again. but i also think thats why it wouldnt work in the graphic novel since its a snappier more comedic pace and its overall Good that they changed it. and i know its been talked about to death but also disappointed by the gorge scene bc i do think its important for leopardstar, graystripe, and sandstorm's character but again i dont think it suited the vibes of the first book so much so i understand why it was cut short (which i why im assuming cinderpelt's accident will is being saved for volume 2) i am fine with them ditching mudfur's prophecy about a needless death though if theres anything warrior cats doesnt need more of its Even More starclan predetermination. just wish onewhisker and morningflower got a teeensy bit more spotlight, tallstar really is the only windclan cat with major speaking lines.
I’ve haven’t been this happy and satisfied with a Warriors book since I was a kid. It’s nice to have something made from passion instead of corporate apathy. I didn’t even notice the cut stuff tbh. I was too busy smiling at the goofy cats.
I adored this book. But dang did it do Fire and Icy kinda dirty. Besides that, this book was as close to perfection as I ever could've hoped for. Lionheart in his first appearance not having a neck is hilarious. And I love Whitestorm's eyebrows.
I see a LOT of people complaining about Graystripe not killing Whiteclaw in the graphic novel, however I quite like this change. I like it because 1. Why in the world would Bluestar give a CLEARLY guilt ridden cat an apprentice especially when she already decided the mentors were going to be new warriors, and 2. If he killed Whiteclaw, Leopardfur would 100% tell the entirety of Riverclan which would make it confusing on why Silverstream *wouldn't* kick his furry butt after she learned his name (and no, warrior cats characters have been known to hold grudges for in-book years. Of course she would still remember that name).
I’ve been steadily introducing my partner to Warrior Cats for a while now, so I’m ABSOLUTELY going to buy this both to get them to read it and because I think it looks awesome :D
I love the comic :D Gorgeous, expressive style and designs (I was soooo happy Yellowfang was drawn grumpy and scrungly as she deserves), and a lot of the changes they made were lovely subtle improvements, taking the future books into account
It's so bonkers getting recommendations for Warrior Cats now just because I watched on video about whether or not Ravenpaw was gay or not (yes, though I already knew this). I only read two books when I was in middle school, which were the very first one, and then the first book of the second series, which I mistakenly *thought* was the second book (oops) but now I'm getting insights and basically live news on what's going on with Warrior Cats (This video was posted only 5 hours ago! Wow!) I don't plan on reading any more Warriors or getting into it but it's so nice to just put on these videos while I work to get a peak into that world. It's also funny because the only reason I'm actually posting videos on youtube is because I animate for the Rain World fandom, which has a *lot* of Warriors animator alumni.
Excellent video, it's always a pleasure to watch your content! I really prefer the Sandpaw from the graphic novel (for the moment): I like that she is sensitive, mature and thoughtful enough to reconsider Fireheart thanks to his daily actions, and not just because he saved her life . We see that Sandpaw begins to reconsider Fireheart on pages 207 and 220. We see that she feels guilty on page 233. There isn't a huge trigger like in the original novels, but I like that natural and progressive side. So I wouldn't say that Sandpaw's questioning comes out of nowhere (but that's just my opinion). Otherwise for the "continuity error" at 11:51 = I thought like you, but Ravenpaw mentions Oakheart on the page before this. So you could say that Graypaw was just trying to explain to Firepaw who Oakheart was.
i love how they kept in subtle hints/references to the fandom's favorite jokes and headcanons! 1. Fireheart's one sided crush on Spottedleaf 2. Greystripe being a goofball idiot 3. the little things Bluestar says that create the Blue-fang head canon ship i wish they'd added a panel about tallstar looking like he recognized Fireheart as jake at first but it fine without over all I LOVED IT i want to see more. i was dissapointed with how tame Crookedstar's jaw was so hopefully they do the next 2 disabled cats in the first arch justice
i got it today for my birthday and it was soooo good and cute. just a delight. made me feel like a kid again. the cute shot of barley saving ravenpaw and ravenpaw being blushy about it... good.
I felt awkward with the concept of attending an in-person event as an almost 30 year-old man so I didn't go, but I do plan to pick up the graphic novel when I have the time. Warriors meant a lot to me as a kid. Wonder how they'll handle Forest of Secrets if they cut out most of the Gray/Silver relationship.
They added princess? Yes!! I always wanted her and Firepaw to be closer when he was still an apprentice, she came out of nowhere in the original arc. Now I got to go to Barnes and Nobel XD Add another book to my ever-growing collection XD
I pre-ordered the Novel and got it just in time. It was absolutely amazing! The artists did well on making all of the characters look well, and a lot of scenes had a comic vibe to them (Ex: The fight with Graypaw and Rusty). I was also able to attend the event the weekend afterword. Unfortunately, there was only one table that wasn't mine that was warriors fans, the rest were just families with their young kids that had little to no idea about the books (Which is fine, but I'd prefer if more fans showed up as well). Although a few details were missed, I think that's fine. Remember guys, adaptations aren't always able to be the exact same! For me, this book is a solid 9/10.
When they get to arc 3 and 4, they will cut out a lot of fluff, so maybe both arcs can be just one arc, the writing also improved, and it can truly shine.
I think a lot of people who have complaints about the new graphic novel are a bit blinded by their nostalgia for the first arc and what they remember it to be, and not actually what the books themselves contain. I LOVE the changes they made in the GN. The story feels more cohesive and the characters get significantly more development as people instead of them just existing to be plot points later on.
I'm so confused about the warrior's stance on the LGBTQ+ community. They have queer illustrators, while denying us anything canonically queer in the series. People will inevitably ban this book, and drop the series if they learn about this. Didn't Kate Carry state that warriors will never have queer characters because the series is published in countries that still criminalize the LGBTQ+ community. Will those same nations not ban this novel then for similar reasons?
I love love love this graphic novel so much!!! The designs are amazing, and every time I see them rub cheeks (especially Bluestar and Yellowfang omg aww) I feel so happy. I do miss Whiteclaw's death though, and I wish they'd shown the battle by the gorge, I feel it's important for the development of Leopardfur's and Greystripe's stories.
a thing that kind of bugs me about the few people i've seen annoyed that the artstyle it cartoony is that... if it were more realistic... its highly unlikely theyt would be *allowed* to show the fight scenes very much, given the target audiences age. especially tigerstars death. heck, i dont even know how theyre going to go about showing that one even wwith the cartoony style! i personally really love the *tone* of this graphic novel. it recognises the campiness of the story itself, but also takes its readers seriously and doesn't look down on them (*so* important for childrens literature!) i've been following nat and sara for *so* long, since space battle lunchtime (campy space lesbian murder cooking show) . i'll also add that people are upset about brightpaw swiftpaw might want to consider that the way that that litter (cinderpaw and brackenpaw are their littermates!) were split up kind of strangely in the original books. in fact, cinder and bracken are made apprentices before they turn 6 moons, making bluestar join in on brokenstars child warriors. the change was probably to have them all become apprentices at the same time, later, so that that can be avoided, given that this is a chance to correct things that could have been written better
Come on, I can't be the only one who doesn't like buff Silverstream. When I first saw it I hated her design and I thought others would too. But for some reason everyone else seems to like it.
It could be because it’s something new and unique no one has done before with her character, and we don’t have many buff molly’s in the series so that could also be why. Personally I don’t mind buff Silverstream, but I do like the fact they made Leopardstar burly! I’ve always imagined her being bulky, and she was described to have wide shoulders. I can understand why others might not like buff Silvertsteam though. She was always known to be slender!
@@notfurry4259 Yeah I’m fine with Leopardfur. I’ve always imagined her being muscular, although I’ve never imagined her being molly, since it doesn’t really make sense for a wild cat to get that fat. But as I said: I can live with that. But Silverstream? She was explicitly described as slim (at least in the german books but I doubt it would be different in the originals) so why make her that molly? I guess it would make sense for Riverclan cats to be rather muscular in general, since they swim a lot and if you look at real world swimming, they all have a very muscular body. But not that molly.
i actually agree. Based on the book descriptions it seems like Thunderclan and shadowclan cats should be buff and big, while Riverclan and Windclan should be sleek and thin. The books for a long time now have described them this way. When Silverstream is first introduced the author herself focuses on appearance and describes her as a sleek and thin cat. I think people just want to see a female character who is stronger and bigger than a male one although in my opinion this doesn't stay true to the books.
WAIT OMG THE GRAPHIC NOVEL AUTHORS ARE WIVES??? LESBIANS FTW (i am a lesbian dying for any kind of representation within warriors even if it's the authors)
I kind of like that Sandpaw changes her opinion on Fireheart even without him saving her life. He leads a charge into Shadowclan camp to rescue kits, drives out a dictator, and brings an entire clan back home. His accomplishments are undeniable and you can’t really try to belittle them (especially when the average warrior’s biggest life accomplishments probably involve bringing home a fat squirrel from the hunting patrol). It shows that Sandpaw can see Fireheart’s worth from how he treats others, not just from things he’s done for her specifically.
Yeah
I loved that she actually was given the chance to apologize to Fireheart , it was something that it was missing for me, I think the line "you are warrior through and through" will stick in my heart and mind.
Even so, I love that, I just genuinely love how after EACH page she's on, you can just visible see her thinking, watching, admiring or sticking up for Fire
Exactly
The whole bit with Sandpaw specifically I really like personally. I saw people say her coming around to liking Fireheart feels out of nowhere now but idk, I like it more that it feels like she chose to get to know him and warmed up to him and respecting him as a fellow clanmate due to maturing over the moons, rather than having a "oh maybe he's not so bad" realization just because he saved her during the battle
Exactly 💯
I know its not very related to the video, but if the novels/comics keep going until TNP i really hope the authors include a scene of Firestar, Cloudtail and maybe BrightHeart too saying their last goodbyes to Princess. Its always bugged me how they dont even mention Princess when the clans leave, or how they never think of her after that. A scene like this could be very cool and impactfull, even if quite sad. It could teach kids how to say Goodbye to someone they know (a very valuable thing to learm, especially early on in life).
@Litwaluz same! That always bugged me too. I also have to imagine that they introduced whitepaw to her grandma at some point
1000000% agreed on appreciating more what they added than despairing over anything cut. The sheer amount of characterization and personality OOZING off the pages enraptured me in ways the series hasn’t since I was a kid. I understand why things had to be cut and imo it was more important to establish ITW with its world building than Fire & Ice. And GOD I hope they make more!!!
Cinderkit's face in that one scene absolutely cracked me up, as well as Fireheart's face when he was caught eating prey. The faces in the graphic novel go from goofy to adorable to terrifying and I ADORE it
I was at a Barnes and Noble and saw the Warriors event going on! I didn't know about it beforehand, but the kids section was absolutely SWARMING with children making cat masks. It was so cute to see 😊
I really love all the blushing these cats do! It's so cute. Also Leopardstar looks so awesome. Big, fierce, and bulky. Just as I've always imagined.
She was described as having wide shoulders once as well!
I think it could have been stronger if more of fire and ice could have been included, but I still really enjoyed it. I think rising storm will be the easiest to truncate without losing too much, as the most important events are the fire and Yellowfang's death
My main complaint is Brightheart is no where to be seen as one of the kits taken it looks like she was replaced with Swiftpaw but it’s odd very odd
I feel like people forget that they physically CANNOT show every little detail- that's not possible. Plus, the story is already overly complex and weird so it's just a mess and these two are also new to making this series. I think they did an amazing job and I think they deserve a lot more praise than what most are giving. The original books were confusing and weird and pacing was bad but at least the novel here is showing me something I can understand. I appreciate them for their effort.
I got into Warriors through the old graphic novels. My older brother owned a few, but I also frequented my local library for them. It was at that library another warriors fan recommended to me the main story novels
I am more than thrilled to see how great this graphic novel is! I bought it as soon as I saw it came out! I am just in love with all the personality that it can portray with it's characters! Of course a couple things had to be skipped, but like you said, it still overall gave us an amazing retelling of the first two books! Super excited for the next release, and hoping that the continue further with these!
Genuinely cant get over how much i love the art in the graphic novel. Its so vibrant and expressive! I was having fun just flipping through it to look at the pictures. Its also fun to see how they interpret certain things like the entto the mothermouth. I always just pictured it as a random hole in the cliff but seeing it as an abandoned mine shaft is super cool.
This new graphic novel got me bac k into reading warrior cats even tho i not read it in years i love this book so much
they still shouldn't have skipped whiteclaws death.
I agree
I know right, I feel like especially with the first few books the plotbeats are so iconic it’s kinda jarring when entire events are removed
One can assume that Whiteclaw might not actually be dead yet. His death could be postponed and moved to a different part of the timeline, similar to how Swiftpaw’s death may have a different circumstance since he has been apprenticed alongside Cinderpaw and Brackenpaw instead of later.
What I'm guessing is that Whiteclaw's death is postponed, for now. We have no evidence that he's dead yet, from the pages I've seen. So they might wanna put it somewhere else! It could be that they want Graystripe to join Riverclan before Whiteclaw dies?
Ain’t worth hating the whole book over.
I need someone to talk about Barley's mustache!! There's no way I'm the only one who saw it.
It made me start reading his lines out loud with a country accent.
There wasnt an event at the Barnes and Noble I went to during vacation (I got the book the day it came out then went again to get The Rise of Scourge and Graystripe's Adventure cause I hadnt read those yet). Anyway, that second day I got the bag and activity sheet in the video, alongside a sneak peak of the next adaptation and those little tattoos that you put on with water! I am still SO confused what you are meant to do with the area with numbers and spots to fill in, but otherwise I LOVE it!
i just wanna know how they're gonna do the dog arc without brightpaw since 1. it's a really important plot point and 2. brightheart is a very popular character
You've made me even more excited than I already was to read this comic!
I got the soft cover on sale, but plan to go after the hard cover! The book was so amazing, and I can't wait for more! I'll probably need another book shelf, here's hoping!
Yeah I think that the graphic novel was really good at least the into the wild part, although fire and ice wasn’t remade very well I still think the graphic novel was really good, and the charector designs were amazing! Overall I think it was an amazing book tho
oh man i WISH i knew the hardcover was gonna have such an awesome under jacket cover im so jealous i didnt think to get both versions lol
some scattered thoughts i had after reading!
the one detail i am actually sad they changed that i think would have still fit the new format was silverstream's banter after she saved him to just her laughing at him... 'can't you drown on your own territory' is such an iconic line to me! im tempted to just marker it in on that page lmao
but overall yeah! i think doing a scenes focused approach to the story is really smart even if some stuff is a bit out of sequence or abridged it still gives you the feelings and most important part of the moment; personally would have liked a biiit more yellowfang pages bc firestar looking after her is much more prolonged than that cute little montage and it does cut the moment graypaw was forced to eat two mice bc he was trying to cover for firepaw so he wouldnt get in trouble which always stood out to me as a good scene that shows graypaw is a dedicated friend (though him drawing attention away from ravenpaw when tigerclaw is putting him down during training has a similar effect) I think the into the wild section of the novel is just about PERFECT amount of detail vs snappy, though i do have my concerns about fire and ice / forest of secrets.
i think i especially have to commend the rat scene because HOLY shit they managed to make that just as scary as the original books the panel where they are dragging ravenpaw down the ledge goes CRAZY
the abridged version of fireheart/graystripe's conflict over silverstream in fire and ice is a bit disappointing bc the drama of that was always so juicy to me but i also understand it didnt fit the tone the graphic novels were setting up; it would be a bit much to throw that in and expect the book to end on a high note of "yay im a warrior cat now :D" and not "well i was fist fighting my friend in the middle of camp but we made up and came to an uneasy understanding"
I'd definitely recommend a fan read both versions bc the original fire and ice/forest of secrets definitely had a more anxiety inducing effect on fireheart with him juggling graystripes sneaking out and trying to mentor cinderpaw and his own meetings with princess and knowledge of tigerclaws treachery. as a big princess fan, i do enjoy her being introduced earlier and she is SO adorable in the graphic novel but it is a stark difference from the original because fireheart is grappling with his lack of family in the clan, feeling ostracized for his kittypet origins, and its been so long since he's seen her it really is a BIG moment when he finally meets her again. but i also think thats why it wouldnt work in the graphic novel since its a snappier more comedic pace and its overall Good that they changed it.
and i know its been talked about to death but also disappointed by the gorge scene bc i do think its important for leopardstar, graystripe, and sandstorm's character but again i dont think it suited the vibes of the first book so much so i understand why it was cut short (which i why im assuming cinderpelt's accident will is being saved for volume 2)
i am fine with them ditching mudfur's prophecy about a needless death though if theres anything warrior cats doesnt need more of its Even More starclan predetermination. just wish onewhisker and morningflower got a teeensy bit more spotlight, tallstar really is the only windclan cat with major speaking lines.
I’ve haven’t been this happy and satisfied with a Warriors book since I was a kid. It’s nice to have something made from passion instead of corporate apathy. I didn’t even notice the cut stuff tbh. I was too busy smiling at the goofy cats.
I adored this book. But dang did it do Fire and Icy kinda dirty.
Besides that, this book was as close to perfection as I ever could've hoped for. Lionheart in his first appearance not having a neck is hilarious. And I love Whitestorm's eyebrows.
I see a LOT of people complaining about Graystripe not killing Whiteclaw in the graphic novel, however I quite like this change. I like it because 1. Why in the world would Bluestar give a CLEARLY guilt ridden cat an apprentice especially when she already decided the mentors were going to be new warriors, and 2. If he killed Whiteclaw, Leopardfur would 100% tell the entirety of Riverclan which would make it confusing on why Silverstream *wouldn't* kick his furry butt after she learned his name (and no, warrior cats characters have been known to hold grudges for in-book years. Of course she would still remember that name).
I’ve been steadily introducing my partner to Warrior Cats for a while now, so I’m ABSOLUTELY going to buy this both to get them to read it and because I think it looks awesome :D
I love the comic :D Gorgeous, expressive style and designs (I was soooo happy Yellowfang was drawn grumpy and scrungly as she deserves), and a lot of the changes they made were lovely subtle improvements, taking the future books into account
It's so bonkers getting recommendations for Warrior Cats now just because I watched on video about whether or not Ravenpaw was gay or not (yes, though I already knew this). I only read two books when I was in middle school, which were the very first one, and then the first book of the second series, which I mistakenly *thought* was the second book (oops) but now I'm getting insights and basically live news on what's going on with Warrior Cats (This video was posted only 5 hours ago! Wow!) I don't plan on reading any more Warriors or getting into it but it's so nice to just put on these videos while I work to get a peak into that world.
It's also funny because the only reason I'm actually posting videos on youtube is because I animate for the Rain World fandom, which has a *lot* of Warriors animator alumni.
Excellent video, it's always a pleasure to watch your content!
I really prefer the Sandpaw from the graphic novel (for the moment): I like that she is sensitive, mature and thoughtful enough to reconsider Fireheart thanks to his daily actions, and not just because he saved her life . We see that Sandpaw begins to reconsider Fireheart on pages 207 and 220. We see that she feels guilty on page 233. There isn't a huge trigger like in the original novels, but I like that natural and progressive side. So I wouldn't say that Sandpaw's questioning comes out of nowhere (but that's just my opinion).
Otherwise for the "continuity error" at 11:51 = I thought like you, but Ravenpaw mentions Oakheart on the page before this. So you could say that Graypaw was just trying to explain to Firepaw who Oakheart was.
The graphic novel was even better because it was released on my birthday (:
i love how they kept in subtle hints/references to the fandom's favorite jokes and headcanons! 1. Fireheart's one sided crush on Spottedleaf 2. Greystripe being a goofball idiot 3. the little things Bluestar says that create the Blue-fang head canon ship
i wish they'd added a panel about tallstar looking like he recognized Fireheart as jake at first but it fine without
over all I LOVED IT i want to see more. i was dissapointed with how tame Crookedstar's jaw was so hopefully they do the next 2 disabled cats in the first arch justice
i got it today for my birthday and it was soooo good and cute. just a delight. made me feel like a kid again. the cute shot of barley saving ravenpaw and ravenpaw being blushy about it... good.
I felt awkward with the concept of attending an in-person event as an almost 30 year-old man so I didn't go, but I do plan to pick up the graphic novel when I have the time. Warriors meant a lot to me as a kid. Wonder how they'll handle Forest of Secrets if they cut out most of the Gray/Silver relationship.
They added princess? Yes!! I always wanted her and Firepaw to be closer when he was still an apprentice, she came out of nowhere in the original arc. Now I got to go to Barnes and Nobel XD Add another book to my ever-growing collection XD
I pre-ordered the Novel and got it just in time. It was absolutely amazing! The artists did well on making all of the characters look well, and a lot of scenes had a comic vibe to them (Ex: The fight with Graypaw and Rusty). I was also able to attend the event the weekend afterword. Unfortunately, there was only one table that wasn't mine that was warriors fans, the rest were just families with their young kids that had little to no idea about the books (Which is fine, but I'd prefer if more fans showed up as well). Although a few details were missed, I think that's fine. Remember guys, adaptations aren't always able to be the exact same!
For me, this book is a solid 9/10.
As much as I am excited to eventually get the novels for myself, Im so caught up in my own AU that the canon is just SO FOREIGN to me now
Also i didnt know there was a hardcover!! It looks so cool, i might actually try to aee if i can get that copy too lol
I was thinking about getting the book later on but might get it a little sooner with all the prase and look of the parts I did see.
Ayyyooo the first here🤍🤍
I can't watch rhis yet as i wanna read the raphic novel for myself but im glwd you enjoyed the graphic novel
I loved the graphic novel
Cool
The into the wild part of the book was amazing but fire and ice was not thankfully were getting more fire and ice in the second book
SUNNYFALL SUNNYFALL YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS IM SO EARLY THE ERINS DIDNT RELEASE A NEW BOOKS YET WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOH
When they get to arc 3 and 4, they will cut out a lot of fluff, so maybe both arcs can be just one arc, the writing also improved, and it can truly shine.
Warriors is finally getting the rewrite it deserves
I cant even read the ones whith nightpelt in it my cat I named nightpelt got shot cause he was dieing
The art is very nice
I think a lot of people who have complaints about the new graphic novel are a bit blinded by their nostalgia for the first arc and what they remember it to be, and not actually what the books themselves contain. I LOVE the changes they made in the GN. The story feels more cohesive and the characters get significantly more development as people instead of them just existing to be plot points later on.
I'm so confused about the warrior's stance on the LGBTQ+ community. They have queer illustrators, while denying us anything canonically queer in the series. People will inevitably ban this book, and drop the series if they learn about this. Didn't Kate Carry state that warriors will never have queer characters because the series is published in countries that still criminalize the LGBTQ+ community. Will those same nations not ban this novel then for similar reasons?
I love love love this graphic novel so much!!! The designs are amazing, and every time I see them rub cheeks (especially Bluestar and Yellowfang omg aww) I feel so happy.
I do miss Whiteclaw's death though, and I wish they'd shown the battle by the gorge, I feel it's important for the development of Leopardfur's and Greystripe's stories.
a thing that kind of bugs me about the few people i've seen annoyed that the artstyle it cartoony is that... if it were more realistic... its highly unlikely theyt would be *allowed* to show the fight scenes very much, given the target audiences age. especially tigerstars death. heck, i dont even know how theyre going to go about showing that one even wwith the cartoony style!
i personally really love the *tone* of this graphic novel. it recognises the campiness of the story itself, but also takes its readers seriously and doesn't look down on them (*so* important for childrens literature!)
i've been following nat and sara for *so* long, since space battle lunchtime (campy space lesbian murder cooking show)
.
i'll also add that people are upset about brightpaw swiftpaw might want to consider that the way that that litter (cinderpaw and brackenpaw are their littermates!) were split up kind of strangely in the original books. in fact, cinder and bracken are made apprentices before they turn 6 moons, making bluestar join in on brokenstars child warriors. the change was probably to have them all become apprentices at the same time, later, so that that can be avoided, given that this is a chance to correct things that could have been written better
11 minutes 🎉
I can't fin a PDF! And my mom won't let me buy it! TWT
Im pretty annoyed by many of the cuts. Leaving out Brightkit and Brindleface in particular
i think brindleface was in it she just didn't have any speaking lines
Come on, I can't be the only one who doesn't like buff Silverstream. When I first saw it I hated her design and I thought others would too. But for some reason everyone else seems to like it.
It could be because it’s something new and unique no one has done before with her character, and we don’t have many buff molly’s in the series so that could also be why. Personally I don’t mind buff Silverstream, but I do like the fact they made Leopardstar burly! I’ve always imagined her being bulky, and she was described to have wide shoulders.
I can understand why others might not like buff Silvertsteam though. She was always known to be slender!
@@notfurry4259 Yeah I’m fine with Leopardfur. I’ve always imagined her being muscular, although I’ve never imagined her being molly, since it doesn’t really make sense for a wild cat to get that fat. But as I said: I can live with that. But Silverstream? She was explicitly described as slim (at least in the german books but I doubt it would be different in the originals) so why make her that molly? I guess it would make sense for Riverclan cats to be rather muscular in general, since they swim a lot and if you look at real world swimming, they all have a very muscular body. But not that molly.
i actually agree. Based on the book descriptions it seems like Thunderclan and shadowclan cats should be buff and big, while Riverclan and Windclan should be sleek and thin. The books for a long time now have described them this way. When Silverstream is first introduced the author herself focuses on appearance and describes her as a sleek and thin cat. I think people just want to see a female character who is stronger and bigger than a male one although in my opinion this doesn't stay true to the books.
Yes. You’re the only one. Buff Silverstream is funny and unique.
@@Grant-do9ce huh? RiverClan has always been described as fat and bulky, never slim.
Idk, for me cats in this novel just look obese. I absolutely don't like this design choice. WCAnimated did this job MUCH BETTER
WAIT OMG THE GRAPHIC NOVEL AUTHORS ARE WIVES??? LESBIANS FTW (i am a lesbian dying for any kind of representation within warriors even if it's the authors)