How though? They are completely different instruments. The trumpet is a brass instrument. And the alto saxophone is a woodwind instrument that's made of brass. Despite being made of brass, the sound waves of the alto saxophone are more similar to those of a clarinet, as they both have single reeds and conventional woodwind finger keys.
As a sax player, I would say the Trumpet won. Clearer phrases, better consciousness and better sound. Not to say the saxophone was bad, but I think lacks some control, and a little bit too bright mouthpiece/reed combination.
The thing is, me as a trumpet player, i think the trumpet is harder to play than the saxophone, because with the trumpet you actually have to control the position of your lips, and it's just more tiring to play overall. with the saxophone you just have to press the many keys you have and blow into it, does not require a high skill level, just have remember your buttons.
It seems to me that u are a trumpet player and not a sax. The alto sax actually needs more skill than just memorizing keys. It matters if you let your mouth droop low, or if you tighten it, and it matters if you let it squeak or whatever. And there isn't just 3 keys like the trumpet there is a little over 20 on the alto and every one of them cooperates with the tune. Edit: and the sax is very tiring cause of how much air you have to blow into it and how fast.
You are right. But just because the trumpet has only 3 keys, it doesn't mean the fingerings are easy to learn; it can get very confusing because you need to use only 3 keys to play a bunch of notes, the fingering for some notes are going to be the same, which can be quite confusing. Your embrocher(your lip positioning) is important too; if you want to play a higher note you will need to close your lips more. If you want a lower note, you need to open your lips more. I found it quite difficult to learn, and without the right lip positioning, you won't be able to play the higher notes with good sound quality. This also means that trumpet can be quite tiring, was you said with alto saxophones. Your lips will also hurt after playing trumpet for a while due to all the vibration.
Rizzar I play both When it comes to tiring the trumpet is 10 times more tiring Both are great instruments and its so hard to pick which one i like more
The saxophone has the ability to express much more emotion and soul that you just can't do with the trumpet because of how it's made.. which makes the saxophone very tasteful. The trumpet just can't express emotion as fluently.
You are so wrong! Trumpet is much more soulful! The sound is actually produced by the most loving part of the human body - the lips! Trumpet is simply much harder to play! 🙂
@@music_field Naaah, sax keyboard along with embouchure changes just has so much more capability. Trumpet does have a distinct great sound, just not as versatile.
I'm a saxophonist and I know music isn't about competition but the trumpet player did way better and the sax player sounded very sporadic/repetitive and sounded like he was trying to show off and he started playing a bunch of nonsense and it sounded very funny lol but he'll learn over time.
Tbh its like a rock paper scissors battle, saxophones can definetely do more articulation and cool jazz better than trumpets. Our 3 valves can only take us so far.
![[[OFFICIAL MV]] เอิ้นขวัญให้อ้าย- อ๊ะอาย สกุณาพร | ค่ายเพลงเป็นหนึ่ง](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/83x6L3X3qh0/mqdefault.jpg)
i was trying to learn how to distinguish between sax and trumpet and this video helps a lot, thanks
Same here 😂
💀
How though? They are completely different instruments. The trumpet is a brass instrument. And the alto saxophone is a woodwind instrument that's made of brass. Despite being made of brass, the sound waves of the alto saxophone are more similar to those of a clarinet, as they both have single reeds and conventional woodwind finger keys.
@@c.syde65well in Trumpet you don't blow you have to buzz and it takes a while to actually learn to buzz den playing Trumpet
Tambourines won hands down.
yeah
I like the girls in the background
lol
I think they wouldn't have won with the hands down...
@@wohfab Hands down on their tambourines
I see a og floor gang
I don't play either instrument but I love the sound of the sax but I love the trumpet hype man. That guy is awesome.
Which guy?
Did anyone else notice at 0:29 the guy that popped out?
Me
I didn't - but went back to have a look - and it made my day xD
from time machine.. wrong year
It on time too 😯
not a duel, a duet !!!
beautiful
more like duel. duet when they're playing both together one harmony, one melody, one supports the other.
As a sax player, I would say the Trumpet won. Clearer phrases, better consciousness and better sound. Not to say the saxophone was bad, but I think lacks some control, and a little bit too bright mouthpiece/reed combination.
I agree 100% and I also play alto sax because the growl was nice but nun of his rubs were clean
I agree 100% because I play trumpet 😊
I 100% disagree, and I am an alto player. That’s the whole idea of jazz, is too mix up different tones and spike the notes
I play trumpet but man that sax was good but they both did great good job guys
I play sax
for a middle school band thats pretty good. the sax was alright and so was the trumpet. I play trumpet btw so :P.
im gonna play trumpet this year
I'm a trumpet player, but wow that saxophone tho!
I'm a sax player nice trumpet
They're bossing the blues scale lmao. But the sax player really has nice sound
Trumpet player here too
I’m a sax player and the sax won I’m not even biased I think sax played better the trumpet guy was cool too it was a close competition
I love the growl I play alto sax and I do growling on the sax both winners tie , like trumpet and alto sax , really nice:)
I wanna play both
I only play sax my brother plays trumpet
I play the trumpet in my band at school, and it’s great! Whenever you get a chance play an instrument!
I play both.. a the same time
I used to play grandpa's trumpet when I was a kid.
I love the vibrant sound of a Trumpet
You get a growl, and you get a growl, and you get a growl(with random notes in between) 😂😂
Plot Twist Tuba wins
from out of nowhere with a brown note
+JohnPKnuckles lol that brown note is such a good battle strat
XD
Plot twist my minecraft note block won
tru dat
Sax is my favourite instrument but the trumpet was more controlled un like the saxophone
The thing is, me as a trumpet player, i think the trumpet is harder to play than the saxophone, because with the trumpet you actually have to control the position of your lips, and it's just more tiring to play overall. with the saxophone you just have to press the many keys you have and blow into it, does not require a high skill level, just have remember your buttons.
It seems to me that u are a trumpet player and not a sax. The alto sax actually needs more skill than just memorizing keys. It matters if you let your mouth droop low, or if you tighten it, and it matters if you let it squeak or whatever. And there isn't just 3 keys like the trumpet there is a little over 20 on the alto and every one of them cooperates with the tune.
Edit: and the sax is very tiring cause of how much air you have to blow into it and how fast.
You are right. But just because the trumpet has only 3 keys, it doesn't mean the fingerings are easy to learn; it can get very confusing because you need to use only 3 keys to play a bunch of notes, the fingering for some notes are going to be the same, which can be quite confusing. Your embrocher(your lip positioning) is important too; if you want to play a higher note you will need to close your lips more. If you want a lower note, you need to open your lips more. I found it quite difficult to learn, and without the right lip positioning, you won't be able to play the higher notes with good sound quality. This also means that trumpet can be quite tiring, was you said with alto saxophones. Your lips will also hurt after playing trumpet for a while due to all the vibration.
Johnny Is super at a high enough skill level you will have to learn to do different notes using the same fingerings on sax(altissimo)
Rizzar
I play both
When it comes to tiring the trumpet is 10 times more tiring
Both are great instruments and its so hard to pick which one i like more
they both are hard in their own ways, im a trumpet player and i know that both instruments have Embouchure esk skills required to play profeiciently
Can't pick a winner. They were both very good
The guys are really good O_O
Good work guys!
I think this is my favorite thing on TH-cam!
0:29 That one guy in the back xD
love the trumpet, saxophone is okay!
💀
i like this a lot and i am 12 year old and i play trumpet
Michael Bramer Nobody cares
Michael Bramer same
honestly i like the trumpet better, i play trumpet btw but the sax did better
I play sax but I think tie
Aiden Graves Agreed
I like your play.
More from your as you are able ours Hearts.
That sax sure loves the Bb blues scale
I like how on the saxophone you basically turn into a frog when you play it, cause you know how your neck fattens up for a clear sound
Trumpet is excellent but there is just one con… the trumpet is not a saxophone😎
at 0:29 tho bwahahaha that would be me
🎺 won!
HI Rebecca! I wonder if boys are professional musicians now?
Sax won it all.
❤❤
sax owned
Does anyone know the songs played?
its improv
Good
Growling: exists
Saxophonist: I can milk this
The saxophone has the ability to express much more emotion and soul that you just can't do with the trumpet because of how it's made.. which makes the saxophone very tasteful. The trumpet just can't express emotion as fluently.
I agree, it has a very flat sound. The saxophone gives such a rasp that sounds like someone is singing.
Ehh
You are so wrong! Trumpet is much more soulful! The sound is actually produced by the most loving part of the human body - the lips! Trumpet is simply much harder to play! 🙂
@@music_field Naaah, sax keyboard along with embouchure changes just has so much more capability. Trumpet does have a distinct great sound, just not as versatile.
@@k9m42 Let’s agree to disagree!🙂
sorry to say but that sax ate something
Awesome
I'm a saxophonist and I know music isn't about competition but the trumpet player did way better and the sax player sounded very sporadic/repetitive and sounded like he was trying to show off and he started playing a bunch of nonsense and it sounded very funny lol but he'll learn over time.
Where's the full video?
I like sax more because of its blues drive
Saxophone🎷
🎺🎷🎷🎷🎷🎷🎷🎷🎷🎷🎷🎷🎺🎺🎺🎺🎺🎺🎧🎧🎧🎧📯🎙🎙📹📸📸📷🎺🎺🎺🎺🎺🎺🎺🎺🎺🎺🎺🎺🎺🎺🎺🎺🎺🎺🎺🎺🎺🎺🎺♩♩♩♩♩♩🎤🎤🎷🎷🎷🎧🎧🎵🎵🎶🎶🎶🎶
Trumpet Wins
what school is that
Bode Gorge it's new tiver middle School in both Florida
New River
Anyone know this song?
Trumpet still best sound
I’d like to mention that the saxophone is a tenor sax, not alto…both were good tho
Actually all knows that trumpet wons but the trumpet guy is kind 🎺
Sax I lpay alto right now
🎺🎺🎺🎺🎺🎺
I just watched this video cz I cant afford to pay for the sax, so trumpet for now
0:30 lol
I play both. I say both win.
look at the guy in the back at 0:30
Trumpet gave up so I'm going to give it to the saxophone 🎷
can't nothing beat the saxophone
cept accordion 🪗
A trumpet could have one this.
Sneeky Guy AT 0:31
Sax won all the way
like:saxophone
comment: trumpet
Key Vs Peele
sax won all the way and day
🎷🎷🎷🎷🎷
Both very talented, but saxophones go too kazoo on the high notes...
that saxophone woooonn
Saex
the saxophone sounds better
sax won
Also did a TRUMPET JUST FORFIT OVER A SAXOPHONE!? THIS IS DESCRIMINATION TO MY OLDER BROTHER AND TO TRUMPET PLAYERS!
Saxophone is easier to play
Sax won
Based on Comments the saxaphone won.
Tbh its like a rock paper scissors battle, saxophones can definetely do more articulation and cool jazz better than trumpets. Our 3 valves can only take us so far.
Alto? Oh ya and sax wins
That sounded absolutely horrible, that is literally the worst saxophone solo I've ever heard.