The original pinned comment for this video has apparently disappeared. However, I have abrogated it with something better. th-cam.com/video/iqu2zHhlgIY/w-d-xo.html
Learning about Islam made me appreciate my Christian faith a lot more. I can better see now how beautiful is the message of Jesus Christ. I am now a practising Christian. All praise be to God.
The 10 Best Things of Islam: *10* . The certainty that God loves you. *9* . Clear moral guidance and rules that exalt the best of our human nature, as we are made in the image of God, such as - do not kill, - do not steal, - do not lie, - do not commit adultery, and - forgive those who wrong you. *8* . A sanctified institution of marriage; which is the indissoluble union of a man and a woman; in which husband and wife become one flesh, are equal, and are both commanded to love, honor and respect one another. *7* .The promise of eternal life in loving union with God. *6* . A command from God to love your fellow human beings -- i.e. to want them good -- and to live in peace and harmony with them all, irrespective of their sexual orientation, faith, race, gender... *5* . A command from God to even love your enemies, i.e. to want them good! *4* . The certainty that God loves every human being, irrespective of sexual orientation, faith, gender, race... *3* . A command from God for you not to judge others or punish them, but to forgive them; because if anybody deserved punisment, God will punish them, not you. *2* . Beautiful and rich religious rituals which are celebrations of life, are meant to glorify and give thanks to a loving God, and are thus full of joy and are often accompanied with marvellous chants and wonderful music. *1* . A role model Who you can follow with your eyes closed, because He was pure and committed no sin; so in following Him you can make no error. Well, to be precise: these would be the ten best things of Islam if they were actually things of Islam, but they are not. Not at all. None of them is a thing of Islam. But they are all things of Christianity. These are some of the good things of Christianity. Accept Jesus as your Lord and Saviour. In Jesus you will find truth, love, beauty and eternal life.
Can you IMAGINE haveing to make excuses like Muslims do for Muhmmad, about Jesus? Thank God we DON'T HAVE to make excuses because Jesus was PERFECT, God in Flesh.
I was on the debate team in high school. We had to learn how to identify fallacious arguments and tear them apart. Their defenses for legitimate criticisms against Islam or utterly preposterous.
The question is: How to get out of a mental prison? G. I. Gurdjieff said something like: To be able to get out of a prison, your first have to be convinced, that you are in. Otherwise, there will be no desire to escape and you will believe, that your life is normal and free. Therefore I like your presentations, because you open some windows for Muslim people to have a look outside and to see another more real and true world. But still: From there to start making a plan to escape might be a long way. Or one chooses to stay in prison and to calm down ones conscience for the rest of ones life. But what kind of reward can one expect from this???
@@sjappiyah4071 Lmao they're both man made religions full of rubbish. Its only brainwashed people or people desperate to feel that they have a purpose that believe in this garbage. If there really was a God and he wanted to "deliver a message" im sure there is alot more efficient ways to do it than to reveal some book that can be altered/re-interpreted over and over 😂
@@jahedm3 LOL Pathetic, compensating for your insecurities in belief, by projecting your own woes onto God’s communication. Whether you choose to accept his revelation or not does not make it less true lol. Cope harder
@@sjappiyah4071 "Whether you choose to accept his revelation or not does not make it any less true" LMAO what a joke, you can't even prove anything about it to be true 😂 its all blind faith just like every religion and what insecurities are you talking about? I've spoken to alot of christians and they are the same as Muslims where they dont really even know what they believe in. Some even say that its okay to disagree with some parts of the bible and still be a christian LOL
1nemind Isn't it profoundly baffling? Before I began my study of Islam, I just assumed Muslims were pious and much more righteous than Christians. hahahhahah! Imagine my shock when into sura 2 of Qur'an I saw clearly Islam is horrendous. WHY can't Muslims SEE? Satan has blinded them. That's the only answer I could come up with.
*BigBoss* Evidence of Muhammad's atrocities? Typical type of response- challenging me to bring evidence, and posting this challenge in the comments section of the video that contains the exact evidence you challenge me to bring. This happens too frequently... Now, if your comment isn't related to this video, but you're challenging 1nemind and myself to present evidence that Muhammad is a false prophet, they actually have a video on that on their channel. And conveniently for you, that's my next video, from an entirely different angle. So (un)luckily for you, your wish will be granted. I hope you'll join me in about a week or so for a look at the theology Muhammad allegedly revealed from Allah in the Quran. It will not be pretty. Additionally, if your comment is NOT related to this video, I wonder what you have to say in response to the content I've presented above. Also, what do you mean by your "dare" statement? What are you going to do when I post my video on Muhammad as a false prophet and you can't refute it? Are you going to...double dare me? Maybe....double dog dare me??!?! Surely you wouldn't.....triple dare me, would you?!?
Islam Critiqued Look so many things you mentioned in the video I can't recall it all But you're no different from others Honestly..... Typical modern Christians .. Already 60000 books written against holy prophet Muhammad peace be upon him You make no difference And yes I dare you I dare you to read and understand and fully research on our books Like many scientist philosophers And writers I double dare you to read the pornographic verses from your bible to your sister or daughter I triple dare you to speak Arabic language And write it I already know the allegations you're gonna make Common ones So I'm gonna start explaining "And do not approach unlawful sexual intercourse. Indeed, it is ever an immorality and is evil as a way." Holy Qur'an Chapter : 17 Verse : 32 Adultery is prohibited in Islam And even looking at women is also prohibited And shaking hands with them is also prohibited So by your logic and your short view of life Telling me that Pedophilia is allowed in Islam ? My prophet peace be upon him condemns rape “Narrated Wa’il ibn Hujr: “When a woman went out in the time of the Prophet(P) for prayer, a man attacked her and overpowered [raped] her. She shouted and he went off, and when a man came by, she said: That [man] did such and such to me. And when a company of the Emigrants came by, she said: That man did such and such to me. They went and seized the man whom they thought had had intercourse with her and brought him to her. She said: Yes, this is he. Then they brought him to the Apostle of Allah. When he [the Prophet] was about to pass sentence, the man who [actually] had assaulted her stood up and said: Apostle of Allah, I am the man who did it to her. He [the Prophet] said to her: Go away, for Allah has forgiven you. But he told the man some good words [Abu Dawud said: “meaning the man who was seized”], and of the man who had had intercourse with her, he said: “Stone him to death.“ It doesn't mean that the female testimony worth half of that to a man As degerating women What is meant by witness or testimony is something by which the thing testified may be proven and known to be true and correct, so it is information about it. With regard to the witness of two women being equal to the testimony of one man. Allaah has mentioned the wisdom behind specifying the number of two as being that a woman may forget or get confused, so the other woman can remind her, as He said: “…And get two witnesses out of your own men. And if there are not two men (available), then a man and two women, such as you agree for witnesses, so that if one of them (two women) errs, the other can remind her…” [al-Baqarah 2:282 - interpretation of the meaning] With regard to the phrase, “that if one of them (two women) errs”, Ibn Katheer said: “This means, the two women, if one of them forgets the testimony, then ‘the other can remind her’, i.e., she can remind her about the matter concerning which testimony is being given.” (Tafseer Ibn Katheer, part 1, p. 724) Allaah has commanded the testimony of two women so as to be sure that they remember, because the mind and memory of two women takes the place of the mind and memory of one man. (See I’laam al-Muwaqqa’een, part 1, p. 75). This does not mean that a woman does not understand or that she cannot remember things, but she is weaker than man in these aspects - usually. Scientific and specialized studies have shown that men’s minds are more perfect than those of women, and reality and experience bear witness to that And this verse : “And those who accuse chaste women [of adultery] and then do not produce four witnesses - lash them with eighty lashes and do not accept from them testimony ever after. And those are the defiantly disobedient. Except for those who repent thereafter and reform, for indeed Allaah is Forgiving and Merciful.”1 Unfortunately for such people, this fallacy of equivocation has no basis in Islamic jurisdictions and the punishment for rape (which is defined as forced sexual intercourse) is certainly not equivalent to the punishment of adultery. God willing , in what follows we aim to deal with this issue once and for all by breaking it down into several points so as to enable easy understanding. The claim that rape victims require four witnesses to seek justice for their case is untrue and a false lie propagated by those who either do not have any knowledge in Islamic law or want to “prove” a so-called weakness in the hadd laws. Circumstantial evidence is sufficient and the judge can invoke his judgment based upon takzir (his own discretion). If a person makes an allegation of adultery against another person (male or female), only then he or she must produce four witnesses to support such an allegation: “And those who accuse chaste women [of adultery] and then do not produce four witnesses….”2; otherwise, he or she is guilty of slandering, which is a grave offense in Islam. To insist that the raped victim must provide witnesses is akin to inflicting further pain on her. If anyone refutes her claim of innocence, the onus is on him to provide evidence, and she may simply deny the claim by making a solemn oath, thus clearing herself in public. And Taqiya is something the Shia do Not all Shia But the ones in Iran do these guys have manipulated the religion and made so many disgusting stuff and they claim that this is Islam May Allah destroy them That is not the way of Islam We call them "الرافضه " "Ar-rafidah " the rejecters because they rejected the religion and drifted it based on what they desire
Jesus called the Sarmatian woman a Dog is that your example? Jesus called the Jews children of satan is that your example? no wonder the bible produces people like hitter and the likes
@@SlingOfDavid9000 kids cannot tolerate the fact that jesus was better in everything he did and his works and actions are not kept hidden like the works of your stupid stone licker. did you see an imam in a mosque reading muhammed's life. your ignorance is clearly seen. when it is other religion you would attack it without even reading it out of your ignorance but when it is muhammed who is found to be guilty you have to 'research' well to defend about it because you cannot speak in ignorance. but jesus doesnt call the canonite woman a dog for a reason she is a dog jesus is quoting the statement of jews which they were believing in since a long time. but notice here one thing if jesus says she is a dog and says he was just sent to israel according to you why did he healed her and praised her for her faith. jesus clears the myth that the God is just concerned about one tribe. second one is found within gospel of john 8:40-44 we will read from 40 since context is important to both the bible and the stupid book of allah unlike you who thinks context is important only to quran. john 8:40-44 As it is, you are looking for a way to kill me, a man who has told you the truth that I heard from God. Abraham did not do such things. 41 You are doing the works of your own father.” “We are not illegitimate children,” they protested. “The only Father we have is God himself.” 42 Jesus said to them, “If God were your Father, you would love me, for I have come here from God. I have not come on my own; God sent me. 43 Why is my language not clear to you? Because you are unable to hear what I say. 44 You belong to your father, the devil, and you want to carry out your father’s desires. He was a murderer from the beginning, not holding to the truth, for there is no truth in him. When he lies, he speaks his native language, for he is a liar and the father of lies. and dont try to distort history as quran distorted quran. according to non christian historians hitler believed in aryan supremecy that has nothing to do that with christian church. but your profit's calliphate was surely involved to start world war 1 as ottomans are still considered as the calliphate of muhammed till today. now i answered the so called logical fallacies you raised. why did allah called jews and christians as worst of all creatures ? allah also declares war on jews and christians why does he do that ? is your religion confident enough to potray muhammed as he is or you will just lie and distract ?
Excellent video as usual brother. It’s scary isn’t it that Muslims find mo the best example for all mankind. No wonder Islamic counties are in a mess because they follow this wicked narcissist. As you say Jesus Christ is the most excellent example for all and guarantees eternal life for all who accept and trust him. But of course he is, he’s the son of God.😁
Jon Son Did you see the debate hijab did with Jay Smith at speakers corner in London? Same childish behaviour. I saw that first so I’ve not watched the full David Wood & hijab debate because I can’t stomach hijab. Cant stand him.
Christian Prince got him busted! This guy is a joke! He is a stupid liar! After watching his stupid comments I went to his chenal and let him have it! What made me mad is that he was asking for money after the debate! This guy does not realize he got cut lying and is on tape! CP tared him to pieces in his rebuttle video! He even downloaded the debate so they can't lie about what he said!
Excellent!! 💖💖💖💖💖The more we know & learn from your videos, the more our knowledge we gain to protect our loved ones from being duped to embracing Islam! 🤩🤩🤩
Satan is very clever. He caters to the lust of the flesh. Anything Mohammed wanted there was always a so called revelation he would receive to say it was ok to do our have. But because the Muslims do not truly understand the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, they could not possibly understand what Mohammed did was wrong. He is amplified as the most righteous man that ever lived. They don't see Jesus the same as they see Mohammed. So you see how clever Satan is? I am starting to not pity the Muslims anymore because they choose to not seek the truth by questioning Islam.
WOW!!! Minus the Satan part, there are numerous elements in your comment that you'll see in my video demonstrating Muhammad was a false prophet: the ad hoc nature of his revelations, the differences in theology, and differences between him and Jesus. You're spot on here. I think you'll be very pleased with the next video. Good comment.
Islam Critiqued I am so happy to see more people exposing Islam for what it truly is. I just hope people like yourself and the videos that you put up will help open their minds. God willing more and more will come to the truth and accept Jesus Christ as their lord and savior. God bless you my dear and keep on doing what you're doing.
Islam Critiqued another thing I find very interesting as I study Islam and critique it, is the fact that Muslims use the Bible to prove that Muhammad was prophesied, yet they say the Bible and the Torah are corrupted. It makes no sense. Lord have mercy on all of them.
Rima K question begging for sure. Another thing I’ll talk about is Muhammad’s lack of self awareness. Muslim apologists claim FOR HIM that he’s in Deuteronomy 18 and John 14...why didn’t Muhammad say that himself? Why do Muslims have to put words in his mouth?
Islam Critiqued yes, exactly! Muslims today are getting the same kind of "revelations" so to speak, as Muhammad did. They seem to just pull things out of a hat. They just magically appear as prophecies of Muhammad. Looking forward to your future videos.
Basically, the Muslim position is that Quran states the exceptions, which are always Muhammad and/or that context. So it's thou shall not torture & kill unless you are Muhammad and/or you're in his context. But isn't that weird? Isn't it more likely that the Quran states the rule & thus that the Quran approves awful stuff? As a famous atheist said, what did ISIS do that Muhammad didn't? That's the real problem for Islam - Muhammad did horrible things, so either he's not a Muslim or Islam is pretty terrible.
But any man is just a man, no matter that he is a prophet or not, nobody is judge over people beside God, right? Right? Why does someone has to follow a man, love that much a man, obey so much a man, it is JUST A MAN, no matter that some deity supposedly speaks through him, it doesn't matter, and it's NOTHING like that in the Bible. Because WE follow Jesus because we know that He is God, if He woild be just a man - no one would follow Him, and He raised from the dead and we know that by witnesses, and did miracles, He's no mere man. So stupid... Magamad is no final judge, a man is no judge, only God... monotheists...
By the way: following your links, I found something quite interesting, which, in my opinion, confirms the crucifixion of Jesus Christ: Narrated `Abdullah: As if I am looking at the Prophet (ﷺ) while he was speaking about one of the prophets whose people have beaten and wounded him, and he was wiping the blood off his face and saying, "O Lord! Forgive my people as they do not know." حَدَّثَنَا عُمَرُ بْنُ حَفْصٍ، حَدَّثَنَا أَبِي، حَدَّثَنَا الأَعْمَشُ، قَالَ حَدَّثَنِي شَقِيقٌ، قَالَ قَالَ عَبْدُ اللَّهِ كَأَنِّي أَنْظُرُ إِلَى النَّبِيِّ صلى الله عليه وسلم يَحْكِي نَبِيًّا مِنَ الأَنْبِيَاءِ ضَرَبَهُ قَوْمُهُ فَأَدْمَوْهُ، فَهْوَ يَمْسَحُ الدَّمَ عَنْ وَجْهِهِ وَيَقُولُ رَبِّ اغْفِرْ لِقَوْمِي، فَإِنَّهُمْ لاَ يَعْلَمُونَ. Reference: Sahih al-Bukhari 6929 In-book reference: Book 88, Hadith 11 USC-MSA web (English) reference: Vol. 9, Book 84, Hadith 63 (deprecated numbering scheme)
Interesting. The other one is from the kouran that says Isa, whoever that dude is, he's كلمة الله وروح منة، the word of God and from his spirit.... Even though Mohamid had No idea what the spirit is
Every word spoken by "Allah" in the Quran, comes to us out of the mouth of Muhammad himself. Compared to old and new testaments many voices, over thousands of years.
@@The1Bozkurt1 Can anyone prove that the angel Gabriel was talking to Muhammad? No one saw or heard anything. We only have Muhammad's word. If I made those same claims, a doctor would have me committed to a psychiatric unit.
Maybe they mean it was okay for him to do that stuff in that context, but it would not be okay for anyone else in any other context. That is, for example, he could own slaves in that day & age, but nobody else could. Of course, that would make him a useless example - so you still can't save the Quran or Islam.
@@ASMRyouVEGANyetthere is a video about it. Also necrophily is allowed, egypt even has a law for it (limiting it to a certsin timespsn). IS served Yezided their own cooked children.
So glad I discovered you! You give such scholarly information and so calmly it is easy to follow. I appreciate your work, but given Islam's and Mohammed's theology of hate and violence, I am very concerned for your safety. I wish you could have done these videos without showing your face. Please be careful! Many thanks!
Its hard to hear the truth!! The truth is exclusive!! And thats the harsh reality!! But know this, whatever you choose, please know it's only Jesus, that says He's the Way,the Truth,and the Life!!! Take Him!
If one talks bout a "role model", one has to add, for WHOM someone is a role model. Mohammed is quite sure a role model for Islamists. Therefore all Muslims should run away from him when they want to kepp their belief, that Islam is a religion of peace. But for this, the Quran has to be rewritten. Which is impossible. No way out, except open ones heart for Jesus.
There's another best response by Muslims to defend their " best of mankind " prophet for all the atrocities and evil he did.... And that is... " It was suitable / legal / appropriate at that time... " Wow... so much for the best example of mankind...!!!! He's a prophet for God sake! ( as you Muslims claim). So, there's not much to brag about him coz what he did did not comprehend much to today's world.
Okay, I’m late... but anyways, I thought “Muhammad did it, so it is not sinful.” would be an exaggeration or something. But, nope. Some Muslim ACTUALLY SAID THOSE WORDS, geez.
One and the only cause of fatal level of corruption and cruel apathy in Pakistan and Muslim World is the unholy life (Sirat and Sunnah) of Muhammad. World's top universities must establish a Chair of Muslim Psychopathology Studies. It will be an innovative, interesting and exhaustive discipline of postgraduate studies.
All you're doing is taking modern concerns and superimposing them, anachronistically, on the ancient world. You're then using that anachronistic standard to judge the Bible. This is demonstrably flawed for many reasons. I have related videos on my channel you're welcome to watch. The God of the Bible only approves of two cultures: Eden (Gen 1-2) and Eden restored (Rev 21-22).
"The Spirit of the Lord is upon me, because he has anointed me to proclaim good news to the poor. He has sent me to proclaim liberty to the captives and recovering of sight to the blind, to set at liberty those who are oppressed." Lk 4:18.
Islam Critiqued So all the Christians who had slaves never noticed this verse? How odd. Guess it’s one of those things Christians have to cherry pick to claim moral superiority. Hey, at least no pedophile false prophet...
If you're interested, watch the videos I have on these topics. "Guess it’s one of those things Christians have to cherry pick to claim moral superiority." Honestly, your comment is incredibly narrow-minded. It goes to show how little comprehension of Jesus' mission you have. As I've said, I have videos on these topics. Encouraging you to watch them is a better use of my time than dealing with your childish, pejorative banter. Take care
P.S. the verse I cited above was to illustrate your narrow-minded understanding of Jesus' mission. Not to give you an opportunity for yet another snarky comment. You don't get it, as expected. Christian theology is deep, unlike Islam, another reason a comparison is unwarranted and fallacious. Again, I have plenty of videos on Christianity here.
You probably know this, but brackets mean the word isn't in the Arabic text. It is the translator who is inserting it to "help" you understand the text. Seems Allah is not so good at clear speech. :)
Excellent ❗️only the bold & the brave like your self will expose the nonsense of Quran, Mohamed & Allah the fabricated entity ; good job please continue, all our best wishes & hope this video is viewed by all muslims around the world so that can see how they are taken for a royal ride by their imams.
You begin to resemble that which you worship. The shehada that Muslims recite to enter into Islam existed before Muhammad, translated as saying 'There is no God but Allah'. We have historical evidence of its existence. Muhammad came, and added himself to it, making the phrase 'There is no God but Allah, and Muhammad is his messenger.' The myriad actions that Muhammad takes in the history of Islam are deified: it's a miracle that he sucked on a young boy's tongue! The men rubbed Muhammad's spit on their faces, oh how... miraculous? Indeed, Muhammad is clearly deified by Islam, and when his followers worshiped him he did not stop them from doing so. His lifestyle is never judged, but deemed the perfect lifestyle for Muslims to follow - despite the Qu'ran clearly stating that Jesus was sinless, but Muhammad was not sinless (though not condemned for it). Muslims are told to emulate Muhammad. I think the more they defend Muhammad even in the face of these atrocities, the more they worship him. To claim that anything he did is without fault, and defend these horrid atrocities he performed, since he is the 'perfect lifestyle' to follow. The supposed untouchable sunnah of this slave trader and warlord. Indeed, the race-based slave trade began around Muhammad's time... I would not be surprised if he was one of the major contributing factors to its rise. And you begin to resemble that which you worship. Turn away from sinful man and worship the almighty God. Don't know how? Look to Jesus - even the Qu'ran agrees He is sinless - and see what *He*, who is without sin, had to say. Examine His claims and teachings thoroughly: examine the historicity of them, the validity of our copies of His teachings (indeed, compare the manuscripts of the New Testament and trace them to before Muhammad's time - we indeed have accurate copies of what He said), and the evidence for His resurrection. Then, I think, you will find that Worthy is the Lamb. === Great vid.
As for Aisha , prophet Muhammed consummated the marriage when she was an adult , that's what all Muslims believe that is why Muslim scholars put a clear condition for the consummation of the marriage which is (She can bear the intercourse without any harm to her) whether physicallly or psychologically Muhammed did it , so it is right
4th point , Prophet Muhammed forgave a whole state the pagans of Makkah who not only insulted him but also killed his people and his family but yes few people were ordered to be assassinated but some people had to be killed whether we like it or not and we don't know what is the full story and what these people did to deserve death the fact that they were killed and someone says those women were insulting the prophet does not mean this is the only reason kindly give the source of this jewish woman you are talking about
Here's one woman killed: sunnah.com/abudawud/40/11 Here's the Jewess: hadithcollection.com/abudawud/265-Abu%20Dawud%20Book%2033.%20Prescribed%20Punishments/18278-abu-dawud-book-033-hadith-number-4349.html
It was hilarious to watch your video on Dr. Zakir Naik's interpretation of Hebrew text and spreading misinformation about Judaism(and other religions). When I debate them, I get categorized as an Islamophobe or a hater for not blindly accepting everything and I don't see Islam as perfect. I was born Hindu and Islam is far from perfect just like other religions. Because of learning about Islam I became happily areligious and It would be super interesting to watch your intellectual mind debate someone like Zakir Naik or any Islamic scholar because you've done extensive research. Look at you reading Sahih Bukhari and Quran🙃.
So my issue here would be that there's no comparison, it's apples to oranges. Rather, the more appropriate analogy would be source criticism of the respective primary texts (Bible and Quran). When Christians point out that the Quran contains material from numerous myths that were floating around in 7th century Arabia, Muslims may turn around and allude to some form of the argument that you reference in your comment. This would be flawed on numerous accounts, perhaps the most relevant would be the different understandings of how the text was transmitted from God. It's simply invalid to critique the Christian worldview with Islamic presuppositions. But Muslims do this all the time. Don't be fooled by this. The Christian concept would obviously be that God used people, and those people weren't mindless drones. They read stuff. (Surprise!) And that stuff informed their thinking. And under inspiration they brought these ideas into a coherent theological message. There are numerous examples I could give, but I've spent a good deal of time on the comments section today so I'll try to keep it short but adequate and give you two. The Tree of Life is attested to in other ancient near eastern literature, inscriptions, cylinder seals, and possibly a very close allusion in the Epic of Gilgamesh. There is also much symbolism associated with trees in the ancient world. (If you're interested in specifics, email me and I can direct you to some resources. They are a bit technical). Yet we find this tree language in the inspired Biblical text. It seems the writers were just writing thoughts that were floating around in their times? However, a lot is different. In the Biblical text, the Tree has a special significance, namely, the presence and holiness of God. The theological importance of these two things is critical to understand for Biblical theology. And the theology that goes along with God in Genesis as well as the entire OT, is in many important ways, worlds apart from contemporary pagan theology. Yet, this motif of trees is adapted into the Biblical text. And so we have this Tree of Life, which in Revelation 2 is the presence of God. God dwelling with his people, this is the design from the start, from Eden. That's the message the Tree of Life is communicating- a theological message that is transmitted using language and literary motifs of their time. The literary motifs come and go, but the theology stays. This theme is picked up again in Revelation 22, "Eden Restored". The Tree of Life is there, the presence of God in paradise for eternity. This ancient literary motif wasn't picked up ignorantly by some incoherent babbling prophet. From the start, it had massive theological import- God dwelling with his people (repeated throughout the OT and NT in numerous ways: "the Word became flesh and DWELLED among us"). Also, it's a picture of life. God's presence is associated with life. Second example would be polemics. There are numerous polemics in the Hebrew Bible especially. Ugaritic literature has Baal being the "rider of the clouds". Well, the Hebrews liked that and decided to use it- only it was Yahweh for them! The Lord rides on a swift cloud in Isaiah 19:1, similar in Deuteronomy and the Psalms. The title carried enough theological weight (power over nature) that the Israelites wanted it for Yahweh. Jesus seems to have agreed, in Mark 14:62 Jesus says he will, "...come on the clouds of Heaven!" What the Old Testament writers probably took as a polemic was actually, by divine providence, a very powerful theological point that Jesus himself used as well. So yes the Biblical text does involve extra-biblical material. And this is perfectly in accordance with the Christian concept of theology. And it all comes together in one coherent theological narrative by the providence of God. This is a very brief treatment of these very deep issues. I hope it's adequate as a start to an answer to your question.
Yes, thank you, providing a framework was helpful. I'm very weak on logical arguments. I've been listening to Michael Heiser's podcasts lately, and he lectures in a similar vein -- using scholarly work to understand OT themes from the viewpoint of the people who lived in that time and place. Your 2nd example reminded me of his treatment of Melchizedek (th-cam.com/video/GvpCqgruSvg/w-d-xo.html). I think I've got it -- just because narratives are associated with Scripture, doesn't mean they fill the same function: Biblical apocrypha speaks to time and place, informing our understanding of OT characters, language, and motifs. Qu'ranic hadith is a collection of gossip about Mohammed, some more reliable than others.
Renee Brutvan Literature doesn’t have to be inspired to be useful to the Biblical writers. Simply put. Good on Heiser. He’s one of a rather short list of scholars who put much effort into making academic content available to non-specialists. You’re on the right track.
@@IslamCritiqued _"The Christian concept would obviously be that God used people, and those people weren't mindless drones. They read stuff. (Surprise!) And that stuff informed their thinking. And under inspiration they brought these ideas into a coherent theological message."_ That is a really great way to put it. I may steal it. :)
let's deal with your first point .. which is that Islam spread by force Islam spread by choice the Empires of Islam defeated those empires of that time by force they defeated states armies and they weren't like good states or good armies they themselves were expanding empires which took over other people's lands and persecuted them so yes .. fighting them to Spread the Islam is gr8 thing Muhammed did it , so it is right
"the Empires of Islam defeated those empires of that time by force" Yep. 2:256 didn't stop them from expanding the Islamic state by force. I say that in my other video...th-cam.com/video/diAx4OUo01Y/w-d-xo.html "Muhammed did it , so it is right" Hey, I have a video on that topic which you apparently watched since you're commenting on it....and desired to prove my point!
Muhammed didn't struk Aisha in the chest , he just pushed her and it wasn't done in a sinister way read the whole conversation , in fact he said after he pushed her in a very loving way "do you think I will deceive you" Muhammed did it , so it must be right
Your translators say, "struck" overwhelmingly. No matter what he did, struck, pushed, it "caused her pain". you can't scrub that out of the translation. Also, I investigate the "push" claim here. Muhammad could have been using his "demon" doctrine to guilt Aisha into curbing her jealousy caused by having so many wives. Convienient: th-cam.com/video/LSAm6Q2Tn4A/w-d-xo.html "in fact he said after he pushed her in a very loving way" Show me where the narration says that. I wasn't aware that you shove someone to express your love, or that a "loving shove" causes pain.
Islam Critiqued “Aisha reported that Allah's Messenger, may Allah bless him, never beat anyone with his hand, neither a woman nor a servant, but only, in the case when he had been fighting in the cause of Allah …” (Sahih Muslim, Hadith 4296) this Hadith alone shows it’s not the strike your thinking of.
@@kazm9669 _"this Hadith alone shows it’s not the strike your thinking of."_ He didn't "beat" her, he "only" struck her. There, the two hadith are explained without ignoring the clear meaning of either one. So, was it morally acceptable for Mohammad to strike Aisha hard enough to cause pain or not?
Reasoned Answers apologetics videos are you trying to dismiss what Aisha said as she didn’t say strike but beat ? Really? What the hell is wrong with you. There is ample evidence is you look into it, Islam does not allow men to beat women. Only sickos like this uploader will try to deceive people.Regarding whether it was acceptable; the prophets intention wasn’t to hurt her, he didn’t push her to the ground an start stamping on her head, he didn’t push her in a violent way, he applied pressure that caused her. As a result of the push, yes Aisha was in pain but he didn’t intend or it to happen. www.google.co.uk/amp/s/discover-the-truth.com/2013/12/23/refuting-the-allegation-that-muhammed-hit-his-wife-aisha-and-more/amp/ www.letmeturnthetables.com/2011/03/muhammad-beat-aisha.html?m=1
_"It is very sinful to tell lies."_ I agree. Please investigate the claims in this video and then ask the people who taught Islam why _they_ have been lying to you. These are all real stories about Mohammad, accepted as authentic by all Muslim scholars.
@@ReasonedAnswers i guess it is the other way around. U got thw story from Sunni Scholars? My faith is still strong. I don'r believe believe your stories.
@@saifulsijar8395 _" My faith is still strong. I don'r believe believe your stories."_ They aren't "my" stories. The are sahih ahadith. That is, the stories that are obligatory for anyone professing to be a Muslim must agree with. Do you know anything about the religion you profess?
"She was dressed only in a shift" Tabari, Volume 8. There are sources posted in the pinned comment. Please read them before asking me to post them again.
Everything is in Quran and Hadith proves that Muhammad was a great womanizer and loved to have sex with slaves. Wasn’t Maria Quibtiya a slave to Muhammad and they had a son who died in early infancy? And Allah also send a Ayet to stand for Muhammad. It was surah Kawsar .
Ok dude thats your opinion to worship wherever you want but to talk about prophets mouhamed (saw) and said all that against him well l never heard liars lived that long since humans history
I think this guy is Chelsea's Jorginho, critquing Islam. Anyway Jorginho, you are better than that fat guy called David Wood, who does not critique but MOCKS Islam. Critiquing is fine, I believe, but mocking is not. One has to be respectful when critiquing in an academic perspective. Of course, humour can be used without insulting.
i agree with the entire video, and another reason i also reject Islam is because of the fact that the belief itself calls for the death penalty because of apostasy. so i’m good, thanks.
The original pinned comment for this video has apparently disappeared. However, I have abrogated it with something better. th-cam.com/video/iqu2zHhlgIY/w-d-xo.html
Islam Critiqued the merciful. When he abrogates a link, does he not send us a better one?
Learning about Islam made me appreciate my Christian faith a lot more.
I can better see now how beautiful is the message of Jesus Christ.
I am now a practising Christian.
All praise be to God.
Same for me, thanks for sharing that
For me I grew up in a Muslim country but I never felt it in my soul or liked it since a very young age.
@@elvenleaf5589 How come?
The 10 Best Things of Islam:
*10* . The certainty that God loves you.
*9* . Clear moral guidance and rules that exalt the best of our human nature, as we are made in the image of God, such as
- do not kill,
- do not steal,
- do not lie,
- do not commit adultery, and
- forgive those who wrong you.
*8* . A sanctified institution of marriage;
which is the indissoluble union of a man and a woman;
in which husband and wife become one flesh,
are equal, and are both commanded to love, honor and respect one another.
*7* .The promise of eternal life in loving union with God.
*6* . A command from God to love your fellow human beings -- i.e. to want them good -- and to live in peace and harmony with them all, irrespective of their sexual orientation, faith, race, gender...
*5* . A command from God to even love your enemies, i.e. to want them good!
*4* . The certainty that God loves every human being, irrespective of sexual orientation, faith, gender, race...
*3* . A command from God for you not to judge others or punish them, but to forgive them; because if anybody deserved punisment, God will punish them, not you.
*2* . Beautiful and rich religious rituals which are celebrations of life, are meant to glorify and give thanks to a loving God, and are thus full of joy and are often accompanied with marvellous chants and wonderful music.
*1* . A role model Who you can follow with your eyes closed, because He was pure and committed no sin; so in following Him you can make no error.
Well, to be precise: these would be the ten best things of Islam if they were actually things of Islam, but they are not. Not at all.
None of them is a thing of Islam.
But they are all things of Christianity.
These are some of the good things of Christianity.
Accept Jesus as your Lord and Saviour.
In Jesus you will find truth, love, beauty and eternal life.
You had me in the first half not gonna lie lol
Danke!
Can you IMAGINE haveing to make excuses like Muslims do for Muhmmad, about Jesus? Thank God we DON'T HAVE to make excuses because Jesus was PERFECT, God in Flesh.
Warrior Linda Clark you know we would hear about it if Jesus did this kind of stuff!
I am baffled how Muslims pass through schools. If a question is asked , they answer with another question instead of giving the required answer.
I was on the debate team in high school. We had to learn how to identify fallacious arguments and tear them apart. Their defenses for legitimate criticisms against Islam or utterly preposterous.
The question is: How to get out of a mental prison?
G. I. Gurdjieff said something like: To be able to get out of a prison, your first have to be convinced, that you are in.
Otherwise, there will be no desire to escape and you will believe, that your life is normal and free.
Therefore I like your presentations, because you open some windows for Muslim people to have a look outside and to see another more real and true world. But still: From there to start making a plan to escape might be a long way.
Or one chooses to stay in prison and to calm down ones conscience for the rest of ones life.
But what kind of reward can one expect from this???
Oh my god, that sounds very convincing. xD
I really like your analogy
i WHOLEHEARTEDLY choose JESUS.
Jesus is on the koran more than anyone
@@truthfinder466 Jesus in the bible is DIFFERENT from Isa in the Quran
@@sjappiyah4071 Lmao they're both man made religions full of rubbish. Its only brainwashed people or people desperate to feel that they have a purpose that believe in this garbage. If there really was a God and he wanted to "deliver a message" im sure there is alot more efficient ways to do it than to reveal some book that can be altered/re-interpreted over and over 😂
@@jahedm3 LOL Pathetic, compensating for your insecurities in belief, by projecting your own woes onto God’s communication.
Whether you choose to accept his revelation or not does not make it less true lol. Cope harder
@@sjappiyah4071 "Whether you choose to accept his revelation or not does not make it any less true" LMAO what a joke, you can't even prove anything about it to be true 😂 its all blind faith just like every religion and what insecurities are you talking about? I've spoken to alot of christians and they are the same as Muslims where they dont really even know what they believe in. Some even say that its okay to disagree with some parts of the bible and still be a christian LOL
It sounds more like if Muhammad did it, it probably was sinful!
So sad that so many people can be deceived by this false prophet...
Excellent observation! Yet he remains the best example for Muslims to follow according to the verse that he.....I mean Allah revealed.
1nemind Isn't it profoundly baffling? Before I began my study of Islam, I just assumed Muslims were pious and much more righteous than Christians. hahahhahah! Imagine my shock when into sura 2 of Qur'an I saw clearly Islam is horrendous. WHY can't Muslims SEE? Satan has blinded them. That's the only answer I could come up with.
1nemind
Bring your evidence if you're honest I dare you
Both of you
*BigBoss* Evidence of Muhammad's atrocities? Typical type of response- challenging me to bring evidence, and posting this challenge in the comments section of the video that contains the exact evidence you challenge me to bring. This happens too frequently...
Now, if your comment isn't related to this video, but you're challenging 1nemind and myself to present evidence that Muhammad is a false prophet, they actually have a video on that on their channel. And conveniently for you, that's my next video, from an entirely different angle. So (un)luckily for you, your wish will be granted. I hope you'll join me in about a week or so for a look at the theology Muhammad allegedly revealed from Allah in the Quran. It will not be pretty.
Additionally, if your comment is NOT related to this video, I wonder what you have to say in response to the content I've presented above.
Also, what do you mean by your "dare" statement? What are you going to do when I post my video on Muhammad as a false prophet and you can't refute it? Are you going to...double dare me? Maybe....double dog dare me??!?! Surely you wouldn't.....triple dare me, would you?!?
Islam Critiqued
Look so many things you mentioned in the video I can't recall it all
But you're no different from others
Honestly.....
Typical modern Christians ..
Already 60000 books written against holy prophet Muhammad peace be upon him
You make no difference
And yes I dare you
I dare you to read and understand and fully research on our books
Like many scientist philosophers
And writers
I double dare you to read the pornographic verses from your bible to your sister or daughter
I triple dare you to speak Arabic language
And write it
I already know the allegations you're gonna make
Common ones
So I'm gonna start explaining
"And do not approach unlawful sexual intercourse. Indeed, it is ever an immorality and is evil as a way."
Holy Qur'an
Chapter : 17
Verse : 32
Adultery is prohibited in Islam
And even looking at women is also prohibited
And shaking hands with them is also prohibited
So by your logic and your short view of life
Telling me that Pedophilia is allowed in Islam ?
My prophet peace be upon him condemns rape
“Narrated Wa’il ibn Hujr: “When a woman went out in the time of the Prophet(P) for prayer, a man attacked her and overpowered [raped] her. She shouted and he went off, and when a man came by, she said: That [man] did such and such to me. And when a company of the Emigrants came by, she said: That man did such and such to me. They went and seized the man whom they thought had had intercourse with her and brought him to her.
She said: Yes, this is he. Then they brought him to the Apostle of Allah.
When he [the Prophet] was about to pass sentence, the man who [actually] had assaulted her stood up and said: Apostle of Allah, I am the man who did it to her.
He [the Prophet] said to her: Go away, for Allah has forgiven you. But he told the man some good words [Abu Dawud said: “meaning the man who was seized”], and of the man who had had intercourse with her, he said: “Stone him to death.“
It doesn't mean that the female testimony worth half of that to a man
As degerating women
What is meant by witness or testimony is something by which the thing testified may be proven and known to be true and correct, so it is information about it. With regard to the witness of two women being equal to the testimony of one man. Allaah has mentioned the wisdom behind specifying the number of two as being that a woman may forget or get confused, so the other woman can remind her, as He said:
“…And get two witnesses out of your own men. And if there are not two men (available), then a man and two women, such as you agree for witnesses, so that if one of them (two women) errs, the other can remind her…”
[al-Baqarah 2:282 - interpretation of the meaning]
With regard to the phrase, “that if one of them (two women) errs”, Ibn Katheer said: “This means, the two women, if one of them forgets the testimony, then ‘the other can remind her’, i.e., she can remind her about the matter concerning which testimony is being given.” (Tafseer Ibn Katheer, part 1, p. 724)
Allaah has commanded the testimony of two women so as to be sure that they remember, because the mind and memory of two women takes the place of the mind and memory of one man. (See I’laam al-Muwaqqa’een, part 1, p. 75).
This does not mean that a woman does not understand or that she cannot remember things, but she is weaker than man in these aspects - usually. Scientific and specialized studies have shown that men’s minds are more perfect than those of women, and reality and experience bear witness to that
And this verse :
“And those who accuse chaste women [of adultery] and then do not produce four witnesses - lash them with eighty lashes and do not accept from them testimony ever after. And those are the defiantly disobedient. Except for those who repent thereafter and reform, for indeed Allaah is Forgiving and Merciful.”1
Unfortunately for such people, this fallacy of equivocation has no basis in Islamic jurisdictions and the punishment for rape (which is defined as forced sexual intercourse) is certainly not equivalent to the punishment of adultery.
God willing , in what follows we aim to deal with this issue once and for all by breaking it down into several points so as to enable easy understanding.
The claim that rape victims require four witnesses to seek justice for their case is untrue and a false lie propagated by those who either do not have any knowledge in Islamic law or want to “prove” a so-called weakness in the hadd laws. Circumstantial evidence is sufficient and the judge can invoke his judgment based upon takzir (his own discretion).
If a person makes an allegation of adultery against another person (male or female), only then he or she must produce four witnesses to support such an allegation: “And those who accuse chaste women [of adultery] and then do not produce four witnesses….”2; otherwise, he or she is guilty of slandering, which is a grave offense in Islam.
To insist that the raped victim must provide witnesses is akin to inflicting further pain on her. If anyone refutes her claim of innocence, the onus is on him to provide evidence, and she may simply deny the claim by making a solemn oath, thus clearing herself in public.
And Taqiya is something the Shia do
Not all Shia
But the ones in Iran do these guys have manipulated the religion and made so many disgusting stuff and they claim that this is Islam
May Allah destroy them
That is not the way of Islam
We call them "الرافضه "
"Ar-rafidah " the rejecters because they rejected the religion and drifted it based on what they desire
Praise the Lord Jesus Christ for being the perfect example.
Amen.
Amen
Jesus called the Sarmatian woman a Dog is that your example? Jesus called the Jews children of satan is that your example? no wonder the bible produces people like hitter and the likes
He's perfect!
@@SlingOfDavid9000 kids cannot tolerate the fact that jesus was better in everything he did and his works and actions are not kept hidden like the works of your stupid stone licker. did you see an imam in a mosque reading muhammed's life. your ignorance is clearly seen. when it is other religion you would attack it without even reading it out of your ignorance but when it is muhammed who is found to be guilty you have to 'research' well to defend about it because you cannot speak in ignorance. but jesus doesnt call the canonite woman a dog for a reason she is a dog jesus is quoting the statement of jews which they were believing in since a long time. but notice here one thing if jesus says she is a dog and says he was just sent to israel according to you why did he healed her and praised her for her faith. jesus clears the myth that the God is just concerned about one tribe.
second one is found within gospel of john 8:40-44 we will read from 40 since context is important to both the bible and the stupid book of allah unlike you who thinks context is important only to quran.
john 8:40-44
As it is, you are looking for a way to kill me, a man who has told you the truth that I heard from God. Abraham did not do such things. 41 You are doing the works of your own father.”
“We are not illegitimate children,” they protested. “The only Father we have is God himself.”
42 Jesus said to them, “If God were your Father, you would love me, for I have come here from God. I have not come on my own; God sent me. 43 Why is my language not clear to you? Because you are unable to hear what I say. 44 You belong to your father, the devil, and you want to carry out your father’s desires. He was a murderer from the beginning, not holding to the truth, for there is no truth in him. When he lies, he speaks his native language, for he is a liar and the father of lies.
and dont try to distort history as quran distorted quran. according to non christian historians hitler believed in aryan supremecy that has nothing to do that with christian church. but your profit's calliphate was surely involved to start world war 1 as ottomans are still considered as the calliphate of muhammed till today.
now i answered the so called logical fallacies you raised.
why did allah called jews and christians as worst of all creatures ?
allah also declares war on jews and christians why does he do that ?
is your religion confident enough to potray muhammed as he is or you will just lie and distract ?
Excellent video as usual brother. It’s scary isn’t it that Muslims find mo the best example for all mankind. No wonder Islamic counties are in a mess because they follow this wicked narcissist. As you say Jesus Christ is the most excellent example for all and guarantees eternal life for all who accept and trust him. But of course he is, he’s the son of God.😁
Islamic countries consistently rank at the bottom of the list in women's rights, for example. It's no wonder when they follow the example of Muhammad.
@@IslamCritiqued Brother, I asked a Muslim to name one shelter they built with their Zakat! The answer? Total silence!!!
@borrowed tomb I tell him to prove his claim ??? They go silent!
They can dish it out but can't take it
@@IslamCritiqued in bible abraham marry with his sister sarah
@@The1Bozkurt1 I read your statement. It changed nothing. Muhammad is still a raping, murdering, lying pervert.
Anybody watched debate David Wood vs Mohammed Hijab? Yeah he and his fans are proud of Muhammad for doing these vile, demonstrable and evil things
Jon Son Did you see the debate hijab did with Jay Smith at speakers corner in London? Same childish behaviour. I saw that first so I’ve not watched the full David Wood & hijab debate because I can’t stomach hijab. Cant stand him.
@@chrissierestall5952
An Indian Muslim left Islam after watchin Hijab
th-cam.com/video/v8uqq3CuhtY/w-d-xo.html
"Elijah means God is with us" lol
This liar is pathetic!
@@chrissierestall5952 Mimi Hijabi makes me sick
Christian Prince got him busted! This guy is a joke! He is a stupid liar! After watching his stupid comments I went to his chenal and let him have it! What made me mad is that he was asking for money after the debate! This guy does not realize he got cut lying and is on tape! CP tared him to pieces in his rebuttle video! He even downloaded the debate so they can't lie about what he said!
Excellent!! 💖💖💖💖💖The more we know & learn from your videos, the more our knowledge we gain to protect our loved ones from being duped to embracing Islam! 🤩🤩🤩
I would also recommend this series on the origins of Islam: th-cam.com/video/Gbk_J4XVpA8/w-d-xo.html. Thanks for your comment!
Didn't Allah tell prophet Moses in the book of Exodus what was sin and what wasn't? Looks as if Mohammed broke most of those commandments.
look as if all the Christians broke the laws given to mosses. because your real god Paul told you, who do you follow Jesus or Paul?
@@SlingOfDavid9000non sequitur and fallacious argument
Satan is very clever. He caters to the lust of the flesh. Anything Mohammed wanted there was always a so called revelation he would receive to say it was ok to do our have. But because the Muslims do not truly understand the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, they could not possibly understand what Mohammed did was wrong. He is amplified as the most righteous man that ever lived. They don't see Jesus the same as they see Mohammed. So you see how clever Satan is? I am starting to not pity the Muslims anymore because they choose to not seek the truth by questioning Islam.
WOW!!! Minus the Satan part, there are numerous elements in your comment that you'll see in my video demonstrating Muhammad was a false prophet: the ad hoc nature of his revelations, the differences in theology, and differences between him and Jesus. You're spot on here. I think you'll be very pleased with the next video. Good comment.
Islam Critiqued I am so happy to see more people exposing Islam for what it truly is. I just hope people like yourself and the videos that you put up will help open their minds. God willing more and more will come to the truth and accept Jesus Christ as their lord and savior. God bless you my dear and keep on doing what you're doing.
Islam Critiqued another thing I find very interesting as I study Islam and critique it, is the fact that Muslims use the Bible to prove that Muhammad was prophesied, yet they say the Bible and the Torah are corrupted. It makes no sense. Lord have mercy on all of them.
Rima K question begging for sure. Another thing I’ll talk about is Muhammad’s lack of self awareness. Muslim apologists claim FOR HIM that he’s in Deuteronomy 18 and John 14...why didn’t Muhammad say that himself? Why do Muslims have to put words in his mouth?
Islam Critiqued yes, exactly! Muslims today are getting the same kind of "revelations" so to speak, as Muhammad did. They seem to just pull things out of a hat. They just magically appear as prophecies of Muhammad. Looking forward to your future videos.
Thank you so much for making this video. I hope every Muslim child with a phone watches it.
Basically, the Muslim position is that Quran states the exceptions, which are always Muhammad and/or that context. So it's thou shall not torture & kill unless you are Muhammad and/or you're in his context. But isn't that weird? Isn't it more likely that the Quran states the rule & thus that the Quran approves awful stuff? As a famous atheist said, what did ISIS do that Muhammad didn't? That's the real problem for Islam - Muhammad did horrible things, so either he's not a Muslim or Islam is pretty terrible.
But any man is just a man, no matter that he is a prophet or not, nobody is judge over people beside God, right? Right? Why does someone has to follow a man, love that much a man, obey so much a man, it is JUST A MAN, no matter that some deity supposedly speaks through him, it doesn't matter, and it's NOTHING like that in the Bible. Because WE follow Jesus because we know that He is God, if He woild be just a man - no one would follow Him, and He raised from the dead and we know that by witnesses, and did miracles, He's no mere man. So stupid... Magamad is no final judge, a man is no judge, only God... monotheists...
By the way: following your links, I found something quite interesting, which, in my opinion, confirms the crucifixion of Jesus Christ:
Narrated `Abdullah:
As if I am looking at the Prophet (ﷺ) while he was speaking about one of the prophets whose people have beaten and wounded him, and he was wiping the blood off his face and saying, "O Lord! Forgive my people as they do not know."
حَدَّثَنَا عُمَرُ بْنُ حَفْصٍ، حَدَّثَنَا أَبِي، حَدَّثَنَا الأَعْمَشُ، قَالَ حَدَّثَنِي شَقِيقٌ، قَالَ قَالَ عَبْدُ اللَّهِ كَأَنِّي أَنْظُرُ إِلَى النَّبِيِّ صلى الله عليه وسلم يَحْكِي نَبِيًّا مِنَ الأَنْبِيَاءِ ضَرَبَهُ قَوْمُهُ فَأَدْمَوْهُ، فَهْوَ يَمْسَحُ الدَّمَ عَنْ وَجْهِهِ وَيَقُولُ رَبِّ اغْفِرْ لِقَوْمِي، فَإِنَّهُمْ لاَ يَعْلَمُونَ.
Reference: Sahih al-Bukhari 6929
In-book reference: Book 88, Hadith 11
USC-MSA web (English) reference: Vol. 9, Book 84, Hadith 63
(deprecated numbering scheme)
That's an interesting hadith for sure.
Hey, they like to distort our texts, but then again, I will not go to there level.
That's why I stopped at "interesting". =) It would be pushing the text a bit.
Any context that might help identify the prophet? Unlikely I know as this is from the clear religion.
Interesting. The other one is from the kouran that says Isa, whoever that dude is, he's كلمة الله وروح منة، the word of God and from his spirit.... Even though Mohamid had No idea what the spirit is
Every word spoken by "Allah" in the Quran, comes to us out of the mouth of Muhammad himself. Compared to old and new testaments many voices, over thousands of years.
Gabriel
@@The1Bozkurt1 Can anyone prove that the angel Gabriel was talking to Muhammad? No one saw or heard anything. We only have Muhammad's word. If I made those same claims, a doctor would have me committed to a psychiatric unit.
@@annegreengables6367 Sunan an-Nasa'i 513
@@The1Bozkurt1 Epileptic Prophet series on TH-cam.
@@annegreengables6367 Another weak theory for defeating islam
Thanks for the links, very useful.
That's why I'm here! =)
Maybe they mean it was okay for him to do that stuff in that context, but it would not be okay for anyone else in any other context. That is, for example, he could own slaves in that day & age, but nobody else could. Of course, that would make him a useless example - so you still can't save the Quran or Islam.
It's a tough choice between moohamid and Geoffrey Dahmer. Pillars of mankind.
Honestly, I'm surprised there isn't cannibalism in Islam. It wouldn't surprise me one bit.
@@ASMRyouVEGANyetthere is a video about it. Also necrophily is allowed, egypt even has a law for it (limiting it to a certsin timespsn).
IS served Yezided their own cooked children.
So glad I discovered you! You give such scholarly information and so calmly it is easy to follow. I appreciate your work, but given Islam's and Mohammed's theology of hate and violence, I am very concerned for your safety. I wish you could have done these videos without showing your face. Please be careful! Many thanks!
On the more "scholarly" side of things: th-cam.com/video/7cuTkCGbVlE/w-d-xo.html; th-cam.com/video/Gbk_J4XVpA8/w-d-xo.html
Nice presentation
Applause .
👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
What a prophet! What a god, Allah! What a book, Quran! What a religion, Islam!
Can't tell if serious or joking 😂
@@ASMRyouVEGANyet Open eyes of the heart and see.
Hello. I would like the Hadith source about the ordered assasination of the man without genitals. Never heard this one before. Thanks!
Hadith are in the pinned comment. Check there! Thanks
Its hard to hear the truth!! The truth is exclusive!! And thats the harsh reality!! But know this, whatever you choose, please know it's only Jesus, that says He's the Way,the Truth,and the Life!!! Take Him!
Most excellent upload 🙌
I choose Jesus !! Amen !!
You can rightly accuse ISIS of doing all sorts of horrible deeds, but you can't accuse ISIS of not following Muhammad
No wonder they come attacking our Lord Jesus, trying all they can with a wife an child story. Thank you again for all the work you do !!
YES THANKYOU!! YOU’RE AMAZING!!
Yet muslims call him 'mercy to mankind'.laughable.
How is Muhammad exemplar in any sense? It is beyond me that any Muslim can think he is an role model.
If one talks bout a "role model", one has to add, for WHOM someone is a role model.
Mohammed is quite sure a role model for Islamists.
Therefore all Muslims should run away from him when they want to kepp their belief, that Islam is a religion of peace.
But for this, the Quran has to be rewritten. Which is impossible. No way out, except open ones heart for Jesus.
There's another best response by Muslims to defend their " best of mankind " prophet for all the atrocities and evil he did.... And that is... " It was suitable / legal / appropriate at that time... " Wow... so much for the best example of mankind...!!!! He's a prophet for God sake! ( as you Muslims claim). So, there's not much to brag about him coz what he did did not comprehend much to today's world.
Best example for mankind....in 7th century Arabia. hahaha
Okay, I’m late... but anyways, I thought “Muhammad did it, so it is not sinful.” would be an exaggeration or something. But, nope. Some Muslim ACTUALLY SAID THOSE WORDS, geez.
I'm glad I found your channel
Welcome!
You are so brilliant😍😍😍😍
Thank you so much !
One and the only cause of fatal level of corruption and cruel apathy in Pakistan and Muslim World is the unholy life (Sirat and Sunnah) of Muhammad.
World's top universities must establish a Chair of Muslim Psychopathology Studies. It will be an innovative, interesting and exhaustive discipline of postgraduate studies.
Blasting video! You’re a sir! -)
To be fair, Jesus never said “don’t own slaves.”
That would have been among the MOST moral things he could have said in his time on earth.
All you're doing is taking modern concerns and superimposing them, anachronistically, on the ancient world. You're then using that anachronistic standard to judge the Bible. This is demonstrably flawed for many reasons. I have related videos on my channel you're welcome to watch. The God of the Bible only approves of two cultures: Eden (Gen 1-2) and Eden restored (Rev 21-22).
"The Spirit of the Lord is upon me, because he has anointed me to proclaim good news to the poor. He has sent me to proclaim liberty to the captives and recovering of sight to the blind, to set at liberty those who are oppressed." Lk 4:18.
Islam Critiqued So all the Christians who had slaves never noticed this verse?
How odd.
Guess it’s one of those things Christians have to cherry pick to claim moral superiority.
Hey, at least no pedophile false prophet...
If you're interested, watch the videos I have on these topics. "Guess it’s one of those things Christians have to cherry pick to claim moral superiority." Honestly, your comment is incredibly narrow-minded. It goes to show how little comprehension of Jesus' mission you have. As I've said, I have videos on these topics. Encouraging you to watch them is a better use of my time than dealing with your childish, pejorative banter. Take care
P.S. the verse I cited above was to illustrate your narrow-minded understanding of Jesus' mission. Not to give you an opportunity for yet another snarky comment. You don't get it, as expected. Christian theology is deep, unlike Islam, another reason a comparison is unwarranted and fallacious. Again, I have plenty of videos on Christianity here.
100%true ❤
Jesus is diffinitely better than Allah
Infinitely better, in fact.
It's a nice video. Jesus is sweet and worth following.
Too good for words.
But.. But😕🥺hEs ThE GreAtest ExaMpLe tO ManKinD
If Qur'an put Muhammad in the bracket many times and several tropics, so 'Muhammad' probably not one person
You probably know this, but brackets mean the word isn't in the Arabic text. It is the translator who is inserting it to "help" you understand the text. Seems Allah is not so good at clear speech. :)
The wickedness of this man it's almost an allegory,I can barely believe such wickedness
Ever heard of the "If everybody jumped off the cliff, would you do it" delemma? I wonder what Muhummad's answer to that is...
He tried multiple times
But “Jibril” stopped him...too bad.
Brilliant..
Excellent ❗️only the bold & the brave like your self will expose the nonsense of Quran, Mohamed & Allah the fabricated entity ; good job please continue, all our best wishes & hope this video is viewed by all muslims around the world so that can see how they are taken for a royal ride by their imams.
Thanks for your comment!
Brilliant
Then the Imams send assassins.
He broke pretty much ALL of the 10 commandments. He didn't manage to do anything to his own parents because they were already dead.
the next point that the prophet ambushed villages are not clear , kindly provide your sources
th-cam.com/video/ifypJPNZ-hI/w-d-xo.html
You begin to resemble that which you worship.
The shehada that Muslims recite to enter into Islam existed before Muhammad, translated as saying 'There is no God but Allah'. We have historical evidence of its existence.
Muhammad came, and added himself to it, making the phrase 'There is no God but Allah, and Muhammad is his messenger.'
The myriad actions that Muhammad takes in the history of Islam are deified: it's a miracle that he sucked on a young boy's tongue! The men rubbed Muhammad's spit on their faces, oh how... miraculous?
Indeed, Muhammad is clearly deified by Islam, and when his followers worshiped him he did not stop them from doing so.
His lifestyle is never judged, but deemed the perfect lifestyle for Muslims to follow - despite the Qu'ran clearly stating that Jesus was sinless, but Muhammad was not sinless (though not condemned for it).
Muslims are told to emulate Muhammad.
I think the more they defend Muhammad even in the face of these atrocities, the more they worship him. To claim that anything he did is without fault, and defend these horrid atrocities he performed, since he is the 'perfect lifestyle' to follow. The supposed untouchable sunnah of this slave trader and warlord. Indeed, the race-based slave trade began around Muhammad's time... I would not be surprised if he was one of the major contributing factors to its rise.
And you begin to resemble that which you worship.
Turn away from sinful man and worship the almighty God.
Don't know how? Look to Jesus - even the Qu'ran agrees He is sinless - and see what *He*, who is without sin, had to say.
Examine His claims and teachings thoroughly: examine the historicity of them, the validity of our copies of His teachings (indeed, compare the manuscripts of the New Testament and trace them to before Muhammad's time - we indeed have accurate copies of what He said), and the evidence for His resurrection.
Then, I think, you will find that Worthy is the Lamb.
===
Great vid.
Weak simply means it’s weak at supporting the SIN they so desperately hold on to.
yes more please more
Would you be able to give us these sources?
See pinned comment from my most recent video. Download the Word Doc there.
@@IslamCritiqued thank you! I just saw it now, the doc is amazing! It can definitely become an app! Thank you for the effort
I put a lot of time into it...hope it helps someone!
@@IslamCritiqued It will help many Christians to help many Muslims. Thank you for your effort. God bless
As for Aisha , prophet Muhammed consummated the marriage when she was an adult , that's what all Muslims believe that is why Muslim scholars put a clear condition for the consummation of the marriage which is (She can bear the intercourse without any harm to her) whether physicallly or psychologically
Muhammed did it , so it is right
"Muhammed consummated the marriage when she was an adult" prove it.
_"As for Aisha , prophet Muhammed consummated the marriage when she was an adult "_ When is the last time you met a nine-year-old "adult"?
8 months and we are still waiting for the proof...
@andrew_veale 4 years and we are still waiting 😂
@@xtb3215STILL waiting 😂
Question:
What was the name of Jewish woman whom Momo ordered to be str4.ngled to deff???
Adopted son? He has no son that was married, as all his son died when they were really young.
ADOPTED SON. ADOPTED. And yes, sons dying sounds like punishment from Allah.
Apostate ptophet should connect
3:55
4th point , Prophet Muhammed forgave a whole state
the pagans of Makkah who not only insulted him but also killed his people and his family
but yes few people were ordered to be assassinated
but some people had to be killed whether we like it or not
and we don't know what is the full story and what these people did to deserve death
the fact that they were killed and someone says those women were insulting the prophet
does not mean this is the only reason
kindly give the source of this jewish woman you are talking about
Here's one woman killed: sunnah.com/abudawud/40/11
Here's the Jewess: hadithcollection.com/abudawud/265-Abu%20Dawud%20Book%2033.%20Prescribed%20Punishments/18278-abu-dawud-book-033-hadith-number-4349.html
there is nothing more disgusting than your filthy fake prophet muhomo
The non-Muslims are all ignorant as their own ancestors.
It was hilarious to watch your video on Dr. Zakir Naik's interpretation of Hebrew text and spreading misinformation about Judaism(and other religions). When I debate them, I get categorized as an Islamophobe or a hater for not blindly accepting everything and I don't see Islam as perfect. I was born Hindu and Islam is far from perfect just like other religions. Because of learning about Islam I became happily areligious and It would be super interesting to watch your intellectual mind debate someone like Zakir Naik or any Islamic scholar because you've done extensive research. Look at you reading Sahih Bukhari and Quran🙃.
in bible abraham marry with his sister sarah
First, gross. Second, how would you counter the argument that weak hadith can correspond to apocrypha?
Renee Brutvan could you be more specific as to how this argument goes and what the implications are?
So my issue here would be that there's no comparison, it's apples to oranges. Rather, the more appropriate analogy would be source criticism of the respective primary texts (Bible and Quran). When Christians point out that the Quran contains material from numerous myths that were floating around in 7th century Arabia, Muslims may turn around and allude to some form of the argument that you reference in your comment. This would be flawed on numerous accounts, perhaps the most relevant would be the different understandings of how the text was transmitted from God. It's simply invalid to critique the Christian worldview with Islamic presuppositions. But Muslims do this all the time. Don't be fooled by this. The Christian concept would obviously be that God used people, and those people weren't mindless drones. They read stuff. (Surprise!) And that stuff informed their thinking. And under inspiration they brought these ideas into a coherent theological message.
There are numerous examples I could give, but I've spent a good deal of time on the comments section today so I'll try to keep it short but adequate and give you two.
The Tree of Life is attested to in other ancient near eastern literature, inscriptions, cylinder seals, and possibly a very close allusion in the Epic of Gilgamesh. There is also much symbolism associated with trees in the ancient world. (If you're interested in specifics, email me and I can direct you to some resources. They are a bit technical). Yet we find this tree language in the inspired Biblical text. It seems the writers were just writing thoughts that were floating around in their times? However, a lot is different. In the Biblical text, the Tree has a special significance, namely, the presence and holiness of God. The theological importance of these two things is critical to understand for Biblical theology. And the theology that goes along with God in Genesis as well as the entire OT, is in many important ways, worlds apart from contemporary pagan theology. Yet, this motif of trees is adapted into the Biblical text. And so we have this Tree of Life, which in Revelation 2 is the presence of God. God dwelling with his people, this is the design from the start, from Eden. That's the message the Tree of Life is communicating- a theological message that is transmitted using language and literary motifs of their time. The literary motifs come and go, but the theology stays. This theme is picked up again in Revelation 22, "Eden Restored". The Tree of Life is there, the presence of God in paradise for eternity. This ancient literary motif wasn't picked up ignorantly by some incoherent babbling prophet. From the start, it had massive theological import- God dwelling with his people (repeated throughout the OT and NT in numerous ways: "the Word became flesh and DWELLED among us"). Also, it's a picture of life. God's presence is associated with life.
Second example would be polemics. There are numerous polemics in the Hebrew Bible especially. Ugaritic literature has Baal being the "rider of the clouds". Well, the Hebrews liked that and decided to use it- only it was Yahweh for them! The Lord rides on a swift cloud in Isaiah 19:1, similar in Deuteronomy and the Psalms. The title carried enough theological weight (power over nature) that the Israelites wanted it for Yahweh. Jesus seems to have agreed, in Mark 14:62 Jesus says he will, "...come on the clouds of Heaven!" What the Old Testament writers probably took as a polemic was actually, by divine providence, a very powerful theological point that Jesus himself used as well.
So yes the Biblical text does involve extra-biblical material. And this is perfectly in accordance with the Christian concept of theology. And it all comes together in one coherent theological narrative by the providence of God. This is a very brief treatment of these very deep issues. I hope it's adequate as a start to an answer to your question.
Yes, thank you, providing a framework was helpful. I'm very weak on logical arguments. I've been listening to Michael Heiser's podcasts lately, and he lectures in a similar vein -- using scholarly work to understand OT themes from the viewpoint of the people who lived in that time and place. Your 2nd example reminded me of his treatment of Melchizedek (th-cam.com/video/GvpCqgruSvg/w-d-xo.html). I think I've got it -- just because narratives are associated with Scripture, doesn't mean they fill the same function: Biblical apocrypha speaks to time and place, informing our understanding of OT characters, language, and motifs. Qu'ranic hadith is a collection of gossip about Mohammed, some more reliable than others.
Renee Brutvan Literature doesn’t have to be inspired to be useful to the Biblical writers. Simply put.
Good on Heiser. He’s one of a rather short list of scholars who put much effort into making academic content available to non-specialists. You’re on the right track.
@@IslamCritiqued _"The Christian concept would obviously be that God used people, and those people weren't mindless drones. They read stuff. (Surprise!) And that stuff informed their thinking. And under inspiration they brought these ideas into a coherent theological message."_ That is a really great way to put it. I may steal it. :)
let's deal with your first point .. which is that Islam spread by force
Islam spread by choice
the Empires of Islam defeated those empires of that time by force
they defeated states
armies
and they weren't like good states or good armies
they themselves were expanding empires which took over other people's lands and persecuted them
so yes .. fighting them to Spread the Islam is gr8 thing
Muhammed did it , so it is right
"the Empires of Islam defeated those empires of that time by force" Yep. 2:256 didn't stop them from expanding the Islamic state by force. I say that in my other video...th-cam.com/video/diAx4OUo01Y/w-d-xo.html
"Muhammed did it , so it is right" Hey, I have a video on that topic which you apparently watched since you're commenting on it....and desired to prove my point!
Muhammed didn't struk Aisha in the chest , he just pushed her and it wasn't done in a sinister way
read the whole conversation , in fact he said after he pushed her in a very loving way "do you think I will deceive you"
Muhammed did it , so it must be right
Your translators say, "struck" overwhelmingly. No matter what he did, struck, pushed, it "caused her pain". you can't scrub that out of the translation.
Also, I investigate the "push" claim here. Muhammad could have been using his "demon" doctrine to guilt Aisha into curbing her jealousy caused by having so many wives. Convienient: th-cam.com/video/LSAm6Q2Tn4A/w-d-xo.html
"in fact he said after he pushed her in a very loving way" Show me where the narration says that. I wasn't aware that you shove someone to express your love, or that a "loving shove" causes pain.
Islam Critiqued
“Aisha reported that Allah's Messenger, may Allah bless him, never beat anyone with his hand, neither a woman nor a servant, but only, in the case when he had been fighting in the cause of Allah …” (Sahih Muslim, Hadith 4296) this Hadith alone shows it’s not the strike your thinking of.
Were you there to witness this?
@@kazm9669 _"this Hadith alone shows it’s not the strike your thinking of."_ He didn't "beat" her, he "only" struck her. There, the two hadith are explained without ignoring the clear meaning of either one. So, was it morally acceptable for Mohammad to strike Aisha hard enough to cause pain or not?
Reasoned Answers apologetics videos are you trying to dismiss what Aisha said as she didn’t say strike but beat ? Really? What the hell is wrong with you. There is ample evidence is you look into it, Islam does not allow men to beat women. Only sickos like this uploader will try to deceive people.Regarding whether it was acceptable; the prophets intention wasn’t to hurt her, he didn’t push her to the ground an start stamping on her head, he didn’t push her in a violent way, he applied pressure that caused her. As a result of the push, yes Aisha was in pain but he didn’t intend or it to happen.
www.google.co.uk/amp/s/discover-the-truth.com/2013/12/23/refuting-the-allegation-that-muhammed-hit-his-wife-aisha-and-more/amp/
www.letmeturnthetables.com/2011/03/muhammad-beat-aisha.html?m=1
It is very sinful to tell lies. How Christian allows this? What have Prophet Muhammad done to tou guys?
He started an ideology that enslaves people, rapes women and children, advances the religion by the sword...etc.
_"It is very sinful to tell lies."_ I agree. Please investigate the claims in this video and then ask the people who taught Islam why _they_ have been lying to you. These are all real stories about Mohammad, accepted as authentic by all Muslim scholars.
@@ReasonedAnswers i guess it is the other way around. U got thw story from Sunni Scholars? My faith is still strong. I don'r believe believe your stories.
@@saifulsijar8395 _" My faith is still strong. I don'r believe believe your stories."_ They aren't "my" stories. The are sahih ahadith. That is, the stories that are obligatory for anyone professing to be a Muslim must agree with. Do you know anything about the religion you profess?
He still doesn’t get that these are ISLAMIC books! The denial is strong.
no Muhammed didn't see the wife of his adopted son
kindly provide an authentic Hadith for that if you have one ?
"She was dressed only in a shift" Tabari, Volume 8. There are sources posted in the pinned comment. Please read them before asking me to post them again.
you lack knowledge of the science of hadith yet you authenticate hadith, strange!
No, actually. I refer to YOUR scholars. Muslims LOVE their scholars, until they authenticate things they don't like about Muhammad.
Islam Critiqued give me the isnad/chain of narration I don't have the book Mr. pastor .
Why is it that I have more books than most Muslims? I will not do the work for you. I cite my sources. Do your own research.
@@IslamCritiqued No they did not! why don't you have evidence from Musnad Imam Ahmad? do not you have the book?
@@Vibez_KCome back when you actually have something to say.
Where did you get all these lies about Muhammad??? From non Muslims?
Not a single non-Muslim source cited. Only Islamic sources. Watch the video.
Everything is in Quran and Hadith proves that Muhammad was a great womanizer and loved to have sex with slaves. Wasn’t Maria Quibtiya a slave to Muhammad and they had a son who died in early infancy? And Allah also send a Ayet to stand for Muhammad. It was surah Kawsar .
Ok dude thats your opinion to worship wherever you want but to talk about prophets mouhamed (saw) and said all that against him well l never heard liars lived that long since humans history
"you want but to talk about prophets mouhamed...." just repeating what your sources say.
And you too should tell people that noyhing in the bible siad worship jesus
_"Ok dude thats your opinion"_ Actually its the "opinion" of the most authoritative hadith collectors there are.
in bible abraham marry with his sister sarah
moses kill man
No Jew or Christian copycat Abraham. It is just Abdools who copycat Mohammed.
@@thinkingperson2122 I didn't say there are Christians and Jews trying to imitate Abraham.
@@thinkingperson2122 according to this man's logic ,,,i trying to say marrying with sister is not sin because abraham did it
I think this guy is Chelsea's Jorginho, critquing Islam. Anyway Jorginho, you are better than that fat guy called David Wood, who does not critique but MOCKS Islam. Critiquing is fine, I believe, but mocking is not. One has to be respectful when critiquing in an academic perspective. Of course, humour can be used without insulting.
i agree with the entire video, and another reason i also reject Islam is because of the fact that the belief itself calls for the death penalty because of apostasy. so i’m good, thanks.