The most logical questions not asked are, "Why there was no demarcation of boundary in spite of agreements in vogue for last 2 decades. What progress has been made till date. Not resolving an issue is to wait for it to erupt in future. Why MEA did not achieve it.
Mr Bambawala has been very articulate in putting his points and agreed to many points raised by you as well. The discussion worth listening to. But I must say the point 1 to 10 (the so called), he mentioned has been there for long but non from MEA has ever taken the onus to resolving boundary issue during their entire tenure. The discontinuety in MEA and concern Government depts from time to time and lack of domain expertise in dealing with Chinese authority has been our shortcomings. Thus, the perception of actual line of control has been always shifting and it's accuracy is debatable in all the boundary talks and therefore remains unresolved. The shift in paradigm? we can keep on discussing. I am sure ardent China watchers with factual ground positional knowledge and background from relevant Depts take part in the boundary resolving meeting. We could not get any areas identified as resolved in these years in these talks with China, itself shows how shallow knowledge and preparations we undertake before such meetings and thus come out empty handed. How ever on ground, our troops always differ in their perceived perception of LAC, and confront with the well equipped aggressive opponent.
Mr.. Ameya. let me tell you a fact about china. CHina kills their own citizen for democracy March. learn about tainamen Square masacare . China has installed their big firewall to scrutiny every word what a user type on internet. China has own version of media, Google , Watsup and facebook which help them to control the mind of chinese people by fake story and false number. we killed 54 PLA soldiers of theirs.
It’s interesting to me as American that all the programs emanating from India are so much better in every way than any Western news source. It’s so refreshing to simply absorb in a way the calm and intelligent way that news is both presented and analyzed.
This is most unfortunate. All these years loss of life was not happening and wish it was that way even in this issue. 2.5 Billion people can't be made to hate each other. Let this incident be the last one and no more loss of life. Soldiers have families too. They can't be made to lose life because of incomplete work of politicians. Om Shanti 🙏
Need of the hour for India, is to revisit/change its foreign policies towards China drastically and quickly based on the past experience and the outcome.
This govt has ramped up infrastructure building in Ladakh. This is what irks chinese. Shameful that previous govt neglected building crucial infrastructure in this region.
The principle of boundary agreements should be based on de jure evidence and legitimacy. India has gone wrong by abandoning the de jure principle and accepting the logic of de facto ground position. Agreements should not be made on something which had been altered by force. If principle of force is accepted, then any belligerent can take forcible control. And peace will not return. India has to return to de jure principle for building its relations.
Thank you for telling us in your may video that India Army is well trained, weaponized and deployed. Now, we have never been more confident that the India Army can be easily able to smash Chinese army
Why IAF chief needs to be fired: IAF is run like a sarkaari company which didn't spend a small 700m dollars to buy R77 air to air missiles before launching balakot strike. This increased Chinese confidence that they can defeat India, even though they were preparing for war after doklam humiliation
Major differences between the boundaries with Pakistan is that it was demarcated and agreed as cease fire line in the Karachi Agreement. Boundary with China has major deficit that it has not been accepted ever since China's forcible take over of Tibet. India had accepted Chinese suzerainty over Tibet as autonomous region in Panchseel agreement. If autonomy of Tibet has been rejected by China, then where is the legitimacy for India to continue holding on to Panchsheel agreement? India should send a Demarche to China on Tibet's autonomy.
The answer lies in the hands of India population by boycotting chinese goods as much as possible. Economy and consumer habbit can be the secret wepon of this crisis
Why Current army chief needs to be fired: He blamed nepal of acting at the behest of China despite knowing that 35k Nepalese soldiers are part of Indian army, how demoralising it would be for those soldiers who are fighting on behalf of India
1993 treaty ( RAO) says peace and tranquility... so China moves in and ask us to observe peace and tranquility. So this treaty allows you to capture anyone land in nonviolent way, but only China is taking advantage. We should also move and take over our Kailash Mansarovar and ask China not to use fire power.
If you want peace be prepared war. The word non-violence and peace to be utter by enemy himself and not by our political as well as military leadership of our country. ..Pravin Mhapankar. ..
Sir, One question..Why is always that Indian govt media relations is soo lackluster in putting out statements? Chinese and pakistanis are way ahead in the information warfare game and no wonder global media buys that propaganda.
First recognise Tibet as an autonomous region and also change our stance on hongkong and south china sea otherwise we will always be defensive against china during negotiations.
Why should the oppositions opinion be taken into consideration when deciding about China ? Opposition's opinion is there for all to see on twitter and other public platforms. The current government have been elected by our people with overwhelming majority. Thats all the backing they need.
During this long stand off and pressure tactics did China is trying to build up their massive deployment of forces for a full scale war? Or they try to involve Russia in this scenario as forth coming 'RIC' meeting held in Russia as Rissia is host country in this meet?
Dear Mr. Nitin ji : As per your performance as journalist on India and China current conflict.Total failed in information. Kindly improve your correct information.
thinking.... what would have happen if those who loss there life for securing the our border with china went on this way. and acted with cool calm and rationally?
What India did with Pakistan Kashmiri king signed accession treaty with India not with Pakistan when it comes to baluchistan you guy cite treaty but when it comes to Kashmir you selectively chose what narrative suit you
According to Mr. Bambawala why there is different attitude of indian policy is that according to him between india pakistan border there are ppl living along side "so india have a aggressive policy there with include daily mortar fire" and border with china its has no populated area so according to him india should restrain & think with cool mind Hahaha Bhai agay bharo aur attack karo china ko darty kun ho ??? There is no body living in that area! it will btwn ur army and PLA daroo mat shabash
@Long John Silver all Tibet, Taiwan, south china sea, Sikkim, Arunachal Pradesh belongs to china but coronavirus doesn't belong to china. nice try from 50 cent ccp army
Indian gov and people should realize that india cannot expand territorially but can lose a lot of it; if it keeps following the path it is on. It will be better for them to move on and achieve peace with all neighbours. You can play games and feed lies to public but that will only hurt more. False and propaganda based narratives can only take you so far.
Listen to Modi's response and feel some shame as your prime minister is begging on its knees that we don't want confrontation. To pulwama ke baad confrontation kis kutty ne ke thi, isy modi ne ke thi, phir jb abhenandan ko aalo diya to early hours mein Indians social media pr keh rhy thy ke ye to IAF ka pilot he nahe hai. IAF mein kisi ke moustaches nhe hai, Phir meine bola ' Beta jb Aalu jaata hai to mouchein nikal ati hain '. 4 hours ke baad jb Indian airforce ne accept Kia to tum logo ke annkhen khulein. Ab bhe time hai aankhein khol lo warna aik aur aalu janay wala hai tumharay andar. Now Indian government has time to show some balls if they have any. Give respect and take respect 😎😎😎
China is the real expansionist regime...2/3 of China is autonomous region including Tibet, Shenziang, Outer Mongolia, Manchuria etc are not part of mainland China.. World has been blind to real nature of Chinese state. India should pursue if necessary its own perception of boundary on the same principle which china follows. A low intensity war probably will be the best answer if you want China to seriously agree on boundary.
Once again a fantastic interview. As an Australian please allow me to thank you for your good work.
I have full confidence on India Army to protect India
Thankyou sir for such profound knowledge on current India-China stand-off.
🇮🇳Jai Hind🇮🇳
🇮🇳Jai Hind Ki Sena🇮🇳
The most logical questions not asked are, "Why there was no demarcation of boundary in spite of agreements in vogue for last 2 decades. What progress has been made till date. Not resolving an issue is to wait for it to erupt in future. Why MEA did not achieve it.
Mr Bambawala has been very articulate in putting his points and agreed to many points raised by you as well. The discussion worth listening to. But I must say the point 1 to 10 (the so called), he mentioned has been there for long but non from MEA has ever taken the onus to resolving boundary issue during their entire tenure. The discontinuety in MEA and concern Government depts from time to time and lack of domain expertise in dealing with Chinese authority has been our shortcomings. Thus, the perception of actual line of control has been always shifting and it's accuracy is debatable in all the boundary talks and therefore remains unresolved. The shift in paradigm? we can keep on discussing. I am sure ardent China watchers with factual ground positional knowledge and background from relevant Depts take part in the boundary resolving meeting. We could not get any areas identified as resolved in these years in these talks with China, itself shows how shallow knowledge and preparations we undertake before such meetings and thus come out empty handed. How ever on ground, our troops always differ in their perceived perception of LAC, and confront with the well equipped aggressive opponent.
After PLA killing 20 Indian solders, if India tries to "deals" with such situations.. then i have no words to say more to such politicans..
@john doe It is like corona virus death numbers. Only a moron would believe Chinese numbers
Mr.. Ameya. let me tell you a fact about china. CHina kills their own citizen for democracy March. learn about tainamen Square masacare . China has installed their big firewall to scrutiny every word what a user type on internet. China has own version of media, Google , Watsup and facebook which help them to control the mind of chinese people by fake story and false number. we killed 54 PLA soldiers of theirs.
Good points by Gautamji
I don't know why but chinese are claimimg my kidney, they are saying this belongs to us since ancient time...
It’s interesting to me as American that all the programs emanating from India are so much better in every way than any Western news source. It’s so refreshing to simply absorb in a way the calm and intelligent way that news is both presented and analyzed.
This is most unfortunate. All these years loss of life was not happening and wish it was that way even in this issue. 2.5 Billion people can't be made to hate each other. Let this incident be the last one and no more loss of life. Soldiers have families too. They can't be made to lose life because of incomplete work of politicians. Om Shanti 🙏
Our Ambassadors always talk peace which is not the language everyone understands. Values don't protect us always.
Very profound words coming from the Ambassador 👍👍
Start by using words like LAC with Tibet. Not China.
Need of the hour for India, is to revisit/change its foreign policies towards China drastically and quickly based on the past experience and the outcome.
India please start making more and more products. #Vocal4local
I feel for patriots like Nitin A. Gokhale
It is not china but india whose provoketive action created this situation.
Please get Vijay Gokhale to discuss on this very topic
This govt has ramped up infrastructure building in Ladakh. This is what irks chinese.
Shameful that previous govt neglected building crucial infrastructure in this region.
The principle of boundary agreements should be based on de jure evidence and legitimacy.
India has gone wrong by abandoning the de jure principle and accepting the logic of de facto ground position.
Agreements should not be made on something which had been altered by force. If principle of force is accepted, then any belligerent can take forcible control. And peace will not return.
India has to return to de jure principle for building its relations.
Thank you for telling us in your may video that India Army is well trained, weaponized and deployed. Now, we have never been more confident that the India Army can be easily able to smash Chinese army
Why IAF chief needs to be fired: IAF is run like a sarkaari company which didn't spend a small 700m dollars to buy R77 air to air missiles before launching balakot strike. This increased Chinese confidence that they can defeat India, even though they were preparing for war after doklam humiliation
Very insightful! Thank you
China is always right and India is wrong.
There is one way to deal with them, give it back to them ...
Why, can you explain, India was not prepared for the sneak attack? How is it Indian soldiers weren't ready for possible attack?
Our diplomats are so eloquent. How did Mani Shankar Iyer get into the IFS?
Major differences between the boundaries with Pakistan is that it was demarcated and agreed as cease fire line in the Karachi Agreement.
Boundary with China has major deficit that it has not been accepted ever since China's forcible take over of Tibet.
India had accepted Chinese suzerainty over Tibet as autonomous region in Panchseel agreement.
If autonomy of Tibet has been rejected by China, then where is the legitimacy for India to continue holding on to Panchsheel agreement?
India should send a Demarche to China on Tibet's autonomy.
Can anyone share the agreements or protocols, whatever is signed between IN and CN? Let's have a good check and see who violates the agreements?
Sir hindi me b bola kariye ....kabhi kabhi
The answer lies in the hands of India population by boycotting chinese goods as much as possible. Economy and consumer habbit can be the secret wepon of this crisis
Master class!
Why Current army chief needs to be fired: He blamed nepal of acting at the behest of China despite knowing that 35k Nepalese soldiers are part of Indian army, how demoralising it would be for those soldiers who are fighting on behalf of India
Sir , He said about Nepal and not about nepalese! Nepalese soldier in india has nothing to do with Nepal . Its just a race and identity
china had broken all agreement and its time india act on it firmly.. india should instruct its soldiers to use firearms in self defense.
1993 treaty ( RAO) says peace and tranquility... so China moves in and ask us to observe peace and tranquility.
So this treaty allows you to capture anyone land in nonviolent way, but only China is taking advantage. We should also move and take over our Kailash Mansarovar and ask China not to use fire power.
Cool heads and deep mind 👌👌👌
If you want peace be prepared war. The word non-violence and peace to be utter by enemy himself and not by our political as well as military leadership of our country. ..Pravin Mhapankar. ..
Friends, please share this video and the link to this channel with all your friends and family.
Sir, One question..Why is always that Indian govt media relations is soo lackluster in putting out statements? Chinese and pakistanis are way ahead in the information warfare game and no wonder global media buys that propaganda.
Agreement ,!!!!!!!!
What u did with Kashmir was that fare and didnt u broke agreement unilaterally.
First recognise Tibet as an autonomous region and also change our stance on hongkong and south china sea otherwise we will always be defensive against china during negotiations.
हमारी सीमा तिब्बत के साथ है । ये बीच में चीन कहां से आ गया । इन से बातचीत बंद करो और दलाई लामा से बातचीत शुरू करो । ताइवान से बातचीत शुरू करो ।
Don’t ask Americans for help because we are not a match for China either
Why should the oppositions opinion be taken into consideration when deciding about China ? Opposition's opinion is there for all to see on twitter and other public platforms. The current government have been elected by our people with overwhelming majority. Thats all the backing they need.
He looked numb, too cold blooded, to vague! Weak person to be sent at ambassadors. S jai shankar is dynamic and firm in his stands.
During this long stand off and pressure tactics did China is trying to build up their massive deployment of forces for a full scale war? Or they try to involve Russia in this scenario as forth coming 'RIC' meeting held in Russia as Rissia is host country in this meet?
What kind of strategic thinker are you when you don’t have optimism and don’t see the sun shining - and shamefully wait for the sun to come out
Do you think this is a bollywood movie?
Dear Mr. Nitin ji : As per your performance as journalist on India and China current conflict.Total failed in information. Kindly improve your correct information.
thinking....
what would have happen if those who loss there life for securing the our border with china went on this way. and acted with cool calm and rationally?
Why are u worried now Indians?
U did with Pakistan
What India did with Pakistan Kashmiri king signed accession treaty with India not with Pakistan when it comes to baluchistan you guy cite treaty but when it comes to Kashmir you selectively chose what narrative suit you
Kya bukwash hai perception of boundary ...but bullying China must paid price for such action.
learn about Damaski island capture by Chinese from Russia to understand land grab technique of yellow peril china PLA>
According to Mr. Bambawala why there is different attitude of indian policy is that according to him between india pakistan border there are ppl living along side "so india have a aggressive policy there with include daily mortar fire" and border with china its has no populated area so according to him india should restrain & think with cool mind Hahaha
Bhai agay bharo aur attack karo china ko darty kun ho ??? There is no body living in that area! it will btwn ur army and PLA daroo mat shabash
Is Aksi Chin area ours or not?
@Long John Silver Sure budy infinity and beyond... All is India's to take..
@Long John Silver all Tibet, Taiwan, south china sea, Sikkim, Arunachal Pradesh belongs to china but coronavirus doesn't belong to china. nice try from 50 cent ccp army
*Wolf Warrior* now claims Galwan is there area. Lol, halwa hai kya. 😂
Please also make some videos in Marathi & Hindi
कृपया मराठी आणि हिन्दी मधे पण ध्वनी चित्रफीत बनवा, म्हणजे आजून जास्त लोकांना हे बधता येईल.
agreement is for weak nations. strong nation break agreement all the time. if India thinks its a strong nation let it break agreement with Pakistan.
who disliked this video ..a Chinese guy?
Why are you frequently promoting and spreading hatred ? You lack of broadcasting materials?
Modi and BJP govt supports one China policy and accepts Tibet as part of China. It is at this point India is breaking and failing.
Indian gov and people should realize that india cannot expand territorially but can lose a lot of it; if it keeps following the path it is on. It will be better for them to move on and achieve peace with all neighbours. You can play games and feed lies to public but that will only hurt more. False and propaganda based narratives can only take you so far.
Listen to Modi's response and feel some shame as your prime minister is begging on its knees that we don't want confrontation.
To pulwama ke baad confrontation kis kutty ne ke thi, isy modi ne ke thi, phir jb abhenandan ko aalo diya to early hours mein Indians social media pr keh rhy thy ke ye to IAF ka pilot he nahe hai. IAF mein kisi ke moustaches nhe hai, Phir meine bola ' Beta jb Aalu jaata hai to mouchein nikal ati hain '. 4 hours ke baad jb Indian airforce ne accept Kia to tum logo ke annkhen khulein. Ab bhe time hai aankhein khol lo warna aik aur aalu janay wala hai tumharay andar.
Now Indian government has time to show some balls if they have any.
Give respect and take respect 😎😎😎
China is the real expansionist regime...2/3 of China is autonomous region including Tibet, Shenziang, Outer Mongolia, Manchuria etc are not part of mainland China.. World has been blind to real nature of Chinese state. India should pursue if necessary its own perception of boundary on the same principle which china follows. A low intensity war probably will be the best answer if you want China to seriously agree on boundary.
Part of Godi media