Joe Rogan, We Need to Talk | Earthling Ed vs Joe Rogan
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ก.ย. 2024
- 🌱 If you find my work valuable, you can become a regular supporter or make a one-off contribution through the following links (thank you!): earthlinged.org... & / earthlinged
💌 Find out more about what I do & sign up for a personal weekly newsletter: earthlinged.org
📚 Download my FREE 122 page e-book: earthlinged.org...
💡 Make the switch to vegan & get all of the support you need: switchtovegan.c...
TODAY'S VIDEO:
Debunking Joe Rogan's hunting arguments from his recent podcast episode, one by one. #JoeRogan
CONNECT:
👉 Find more content on Instagram: / earthlinged
👉 Follow on Facebook: / earthlingedpage
The Disclosure Podcast:
🎙️ iTunes: apple.co/3853BF2
🎙️ Spotify: spoti.fi/37ZtGVS
🎙️ RSS feed: feeds.buzzspro...
My Animal Rights Organisation/Sanctuary:
🎥 Surge: surgeactivism.org
🌳 Surge Animal Sanctuary: surgesanctuary.org
⚡ Unity Diner: (Non-profit Restaurant): unitydiner.co.uk
🎬 Land of Hope and Glory (UK ‘Earthlings’ Documentary): landofhopeandgl...
SOURCES:
phys.org/news/...
www.nationalge...
www.yellowston...
www.thoughtco....
www.theguardia...
www.humanesoci...
www.washington...
extension.psu....
www.biological...
www.fws.gov/re...
Debunking Joe Rogan's hunting arguments from his recent podcast episode, one by one.
Make the switch to vegan & get all of the support you need: switchtovegan.co.uk
Become a supporter of my activism & university touring here (thank you!): www.earthlinged.org/support
FREE 122 page e-book: www.earthlinged.org/ebook
Thank you for explaining this so well!💚
I really can´t buy into veganism
You are amazing Ed. Love from the Netherlands 🇳🇱🇳🇱🇳🇱 ( I'm 46, been vegan since I was 6. So 40 years now. And look at me all alive and shit ) ❤
🌲🌳🦌 📸👨👩✅👍
Would love to see you and him debate
Ed preaching science and setting morals straight. This is something everyone needs to see.
I sadly believe he'd be ruthlessly talked over like most times without being able to get his point across
😂😂😂😂
Troll.@@adamtee3474
My brother Ed Winters.....Your book on how to respond to non vegan excuses and your videos truly opened my eyes and now I am a vegan😄✌️Thank you so much mate❤️❤️
Awesome!
Lmao. Silly
But cool. Youre one of us. 😜
Wait, he wrote a book?
Joe should invite Earthling Ed to a discussion
Joe has got much better at vetting guests so I doubt hed have someone this full of shit on. I guess it would be fun to see him go in there all smug thinking hes got good points and get crushed.
@@ryanwalker8843 man watching this emotionally & hormonally imbalanced grass eater try to spew his "facts" at Joe would be amazing.
I'd want Joe to eat a big fat juicy steak the entire time, slooowly.
I'd be more interested in seeing this guy debate an actual expert who specializes in fish and game regulations who is deeply educated on the subject.
Hard pass. I'd die of boredom.
No this dude would get devoured by Joe...
"It's the type of relationship you have with your food" Yes, I have that relationship with my food. I till, sow, plant, water, feed and care for my plants every day throughout the growing season. And, yes, I enjoy that food so much more than anything I buy in the grocery store, and I didn't murder for it.
I used to be a massive meat eater.
Since I became vegan, I feel physically and mentally healthier.
@@jjohnjJP people don’t realize how bad they feel until they start feeling good. Most vegans have this realization and it’s the best feeling ever.
Jains would disagree with you on the ‘not murdering’ part XD
@@KindlingKatalyst still very different compared to animals who process pain in a very different way than plants
"and I didn't murder animals for it." tftfy
My vegan friends told me to watch this, I’m glad I did.
It's not easy to admit you've changed your mind. Thank you, the world needs more people like you.
You sound like a very humble and compassionate person. Thank you for being open minded and willing to listen ❤️❤️❤️
Hello this is Earthling Ed I'm glad you've watched this. If you have more questions message me
@@kissme1518 It's my view that vegans are far worse for the planet than are hunters. Would you like to have a debate with me about that? Message if you are interested and we can set up a zoom call, or another platform if you like.
@@Rick-the-Swift ok i sent you a link
man this guy's points are as if the earth itself started talking
Made my day! 😂
The earth eats everyone
Yeah if the earth was talking out of its ass
@@tristenkuhn2266 exactly
If everyone listened to this guy Ed. The world would be dead in 5 years
Come on Joe. Don't tell me you're hunting because you're trying to give animals a better death. You're doing it because you like how they taste.
"Would you kill them if they were inedible for humans?" Such questions for some reason get hardly ever asked in such situations.
Forreal 😂😂😂
And because he's a macho tough guy.
exactly ! so sad!
@M Jones Not irrelevant. Philosophy thrives on hypothetical examples, moral arguments in particular.
Killing a bear and getting a picture next to the body is psychopathic. I wonder if he believes his own lies that he’s helping the animals or if it’s just his excuse to make it “acceptable” to non hunters who have a heart.
psychopathic? I don't think you understand what that word means. And if you really believe, than I suppose you think anyone who's ever taken a picture of a nice medium rare steak or beautifully plated roll of sushi or just any meal in general that has meat it in...is a psychopath then?
Steve Chan no I don’t believe all meat eaters are psychopaths! Most of them couldn’t kill an animal themselves or even watch how their meat is made! I do however believe that trophy hunters are psychopaths which I understand to mean having no feelings and lacking of empathy. Killing these magnificent animals, smiling for a picture next to it’s dead body and taking a ‘trophy’ home is cold and evil behaviour.
caraleepaterson Agree. Because when it comes to people taking pictures with steak, there's most likely a strong sense of cognitive dissonance. That can't really be applied to hunters.
It makes his conscience dormant. Joe brogan goes way out of his way to act all manly and sh*t.
@@TheChillMelodist You definitely can't compare someone taking a picture of food on a plate to someone taking a picture of an animal while smiling that they just murdered... Yes, in a vegan point of view it's the same thing. But most people who follow an omnivorous diet do not have the same disgusting views towards torturing and murdering animals that hunters do. They still have the brainwashed ideas that their meat is somehow made humanely and is required for their health and wellbeing. Don't make that out to be the same. Psychopathic murderers and hunters have A LOT in common in how they self admire the horror they commit while having ZERO sense of guilt for the life of wild animals.
pulling a TRIGGER does not give you a deep connection with the animal you kill
Yes it does
That sounds like something a sociopath would say. If you don't feel a deep connection with an animal who's life you've taken, something might be VERY wrong with you.
Joe uses a bow
Dale Gribble And do you think that animal had love for you as they drew their last breaths?
Dale Gribble I'm sure that animal loves you too...
Yeah, life is hard. Let's put everybody out of their misery
That would be nice, but you're right. We can't kill all animals because we don't know how the other animals think of life. Maybe they aren't developed enough to see life as bad.
It’s like “oh that poor cold squirrel, better shoot him before the snow arrives!” 🤦🏼♀️
@@uptown_rider8078 One day, you will seriously regret writing that comment after you go vegan.
Congrats, you just debunked the entire abortion argument. Thanks!
@@Holy_Athletics Only for sentient cases.
Would actually love to see Earthling Ed on the Joe Rogan show 💪❤️🙏
This is one of the most brilliant refutations of ANYTHING I have ever seen in my life. I’m going to watch it over and over and memorize it so I have these great arguments at my fingertips. Thanks so much for this.
Veganism is a cult and members need to be programmed to regurgitate the doctrine to try and lure other unsuspecting sheeple
Joe's one of those people who thinks they're smarter than what they really are.
As most vegans. Luckily evolution will take care of them. Total feminized incels from all that estrogen dont procreate. Go vegan.
Josef Hlava sure bud
@@josefhlava9575 ok sure you sound really smart
@@ryankay2048 I know. I hate crybabies. Wa, wa, wa, dont eat cow, wa wa.
Josef Hlava we might be crybabies but you will know whose right when the Amazon becomes a desert
Best response to Joe and hunting I’ve ever heard. Excellent points Ed! Please contact Joe’s show and try to go on it!!👍👍
I’ve always been a JR fan, accept when it come to this. You took the words I wish I had right out of my mouth. We’re so blessed to have someone like you to be a voice for our family!
You should go on his podcast.
Rahul Jalundhwala we can hope but we can also sign this! 🤞www.change.org/p/23510694/share_for_starters?just_created=true&tag_selected=entertainment
And get eaten alive in the interview 😂
He's not ready for Joe
@@DistanTThunder2 Ed is clearly ready, the question is will Joe have the testicular fortitude to invite him on? The ball is in his court.
@@justinbisnett In your carnist dreams lmao
I have these vegan conversations with co-workers every now and then and get exhausted at the logical (and moral lol) consistentcies, so watching your videos are refreshing to see information and arguments ALONE be consistent. Im vegan for ethical reasons of course, and it's not nesscarily because I LOOOOOVVVEEE animals, but its because it aligns with my morals and I do care about the harm I cause others. Most are really just trying to be morally consistent
It bothers me that so many hunters do not understand the natural food chain. Thank you so much for pointing this out. Once again, humans screw everything up. I've tried to point this out to people who hunt, but let's face it, those who enjoy hunting care only about their own egos rather than the well-being of animals.
I didn’t know Jon Stewart was a vegan. It makes me love him even more!
Joe's facial expression behind Ed is priceless. What a perfect pause point. You can literally see his little brain imploding... haha
Joe Rogan embodies anti-vegan nonsense
Salad!!!
@@genesisz1 SaLAD
Why are you so angry?
Veganism is nonsense as long as a lower-class individual can't afford it. It's nonsense as long as lower-middle-class athletes build muscle on a weekly basis. Veganism can't support muscle-building if it costs thousands of dollars in food + supps per month. Stop being a fanatic and consider all angles.
@@InvestitudinalKnowledge I only started gaining muscle while vegan. My major source of protein is beans, lentils and whole grains, all of which are much cheaper than meat
My dad was a hunter, so I understand it, yet did not support it. It is better than factory farming, of course. But we are not starving, nor are we true predators. Our bodies are not designed teeth-wise or enzyme -wise, to consume flesh. And we cook it. We don't even eat the animal raw the way all other predators consume their prey. The biggest problem is that we are depriving all the predators of their meals, and that makes them come into cities and farms to find meat. Hunting and animal husbandry seriously disrupt the ecosystems. Forestry (for trees, in cash cropping fashion), is also part of the equation for destruction to ecosystems. (Fishing is of course, part of this problem, esp. the way it is done today.)
Excellent arguments Ed, thank you for taking the time to point out Joe Rogans inconsistent arguments for his unnatural killing of others.
Joe simply cannot argue with Ed, i would love to see Ed on Joe’s show though..
I'm vegan and still I can't bear so much truth in this video. Thank you Ed.
Awesome video, Ed! Love your videos and the vegan lifestyle! Keep up the excellent work!
Ed at his most brilliant and articulate! So worth watching, even for the most committed of vegans. I learned so much watching this.
Just learned about you from the comment section of a recent Jimmy Dore show and have subscribed.
Your analysis is absolutely outstanding. It’s incredible how knowledgeable you are and articulate on the subject. I’d love to see you as a guest on Joe’s show! Looking forward to watching more of your videos. ☮️ and 💕from a NYC 🌱 🌱🌱
You’re honestly a genius
Hunters: "let's kill all predators because they're killing the animals we want to eat"
Also hunters: "Oh damn, looks like there's an overpopulation problem so we HAVE to kill those poor deers. Don't blame me, I'm just trying to balance the ecosystem that I helped unbalance."
No it's for population control
For the predators not so they don't die
Joe's alpha-male ego has him under the illusion that he is more intelligent than everyone he meets. He needs a chat with you and if he listens, allow himself to be Ed-ucated
I don't doubt Joe could learn from this guy, but your opinion about him being under an "illusion" and thinking he's more intelligent than "everyone" is wrong. A casual listener of his podcast's can tell you that.
joe is genuinly a chilled guy
He openly states all the time he's not an expert, do you realise how much content there is on the Internet of him talking of course he's gonna say dumb shit alot doing 3 hour podcasts most nights he's just an entertainer. He in no way thinks he's more intelligent than everyone he meets that's just absurd to suggest.
Omg Ed you are my hero! You touch my heart every time you talk with so much knowledge and compassion
You make very good arguments against hunting animals but one issue regarding the reintroduction on predators into natural habitats for the purpose of managing overpopulation is the fact that given the current numbers of deer and other game, these predators will themselves become overpopulated due to the abundance of food. Therefore they will in turn cause an severe decline of deer population, then what happens is these huge numbers of predators such as wolves are inevitability forced to either die out( which a lot of them will), or find other food sources. We see this with bears, coyotes, large cats and other carnivorous predators leaving their natural habitat residential areas. This is already happening in multiple cities around the world where domestic dogs are being killed and eaten out of peoples back yards. Sooner or later they start hunting and killing children and even adults. And this is when all the good intentions and altruistic mindsets( which i am in no way trying to belittle or mock ) amount to nothing facing the sheer violence of nature. Remember the only reason we as a species have continued to survive and thrive is because we developed the tools and weapons to keep those predators from hunting us into extinction.
I think about where Joe says he kills the animal so it does not have to suffer but my mind immediately goes to my ex-boyfriend and when he would come back in the house from hunting a deer, he would have to come back and have us help him track it from the blood that is dripping from the animal that was more than likely causing a lot of pain and then wrapping a belt around its neck to drag it back to the house. I was 24, I grew up with my dad hunting so that was just normal. I never did it, I've never shot a deer or an animal ever in my life. Not even a bird. When people do it like that and they want to track it, that is purely being a predator, trying to outsmart the deer and it makes them feel good about themselves when they're able to find it. It's kind of like a cat when they kill a squirrel and they leave it on the doorstep as a gift to their human. Their natural predators. I almost feel bad for even saying that because my ex-boyfriend is no longer with us, he was killed in an accident where he was drinking and driving and he hit a tree but I have to remember that right is right and wrong is wrong and it doesn't matter who is here and who is not here. If a human were put in the position of the prey and we're being hunted for sport face like in some of the Hollywood movies. I don't think they would ever look at hunting the same way again. That's just my opinion and I'm only 9 minutes into the video
24:40, Joe advocating people to be vegan! 🙏 😄 Great of Ed to point that out 😄🙌
Brilliant as always! So well spoken, sharply logical and calmly delivered. A perfect walk through the mostly week and feeble excuses for hunting that always end up in self contradiction. I have met a few hunters that just shrug and admit that they like the power rush of killing. At least they're honest. I think that the biggest decrease of hunting would occur if suddenly all hunters were released from inferiority complex. No doubt in my mind that the need to exercise absolute power over other beings stems from a deep rooted and numbing feeling of powerlessness and low self worth.
The origins of sadism are a bit more multifaceted than being self-assurance. Never underestimate how simplistic an addiction to an activity that makes you feel good can be. Once something feels good you begin to construct justification for the activity retro-actively. It's the addict mindset. Not to mention amorality playing a role, if you don't care about hurting others you probably won't ever construct a system of morals for yourself either, only egoism.
Beautifully deconstructed and explained as always, thank you Ed for everything you do!
Fun fact: Chimpanzees in Africa have brought 2 different species of colobus monkeys to the brink of extension due to over-hunting.
How dare Ed make the assumption that Joe Rogan does not hunt naturally.... Joe Rogan does not use a rifle or a bow... Joe Rogan chases the deer down and wrestles it, biting its throat till it bleeds to death....😆
I'm a vegetarian on the edge of being vegan, I'm trying to switch over. I find it frustrating how vegans are perceived as weak and feminine, meanwhile, meat eaters are perceived as dominant, masculine and strong. For example, if I tell someone at work i'm a striving vegan, the guys at work laugh and ridicule me for "not being a man and eating meat". I'd like to learn more about how to tackle this...
Ask them why they think that. Then easily debunk the stupid responses they give.
Earthling Ed is so smart, so wise, and so fair minded. I'm largely plant based but not vegan. If anyone could get me all the way there, he'd be the one. Another inspiration is the Netflix series: Our planet. Just watching the miraculous beauty and interconnection of the animal world may get me there too.
Joe’s not saying he is “protecting” the animal from being killed by something else. He is merely pointing out the fact that it is a more humane death to be shot with a gun then freezing to death or being eaten alive by wolves. He has to point this out because the argument from the other side constantly portrays hunting as inhumane and will highlight the suffering of the animal. When put in context with the natural cycle of death for those animals being shot with a gun is a far better way to go than the the alternatives.
And yes not all hunters hunt for conservation reasons but there are a lot that do generally hunt just for the meat it provides and conservation is an added bonus. Hunting and fishing licenses plus all of the extra stamps as well as a tax on guns and ammunition fund a majority of wildlife protection and conservation in the U.S.
You are right about the big horn sheep issue, but you conveniently left out the fact that deer populations are booming due to the agriculture industry. Also, black bears are seeing a rise in cub births and population due to higher access to food around urban areas.
And why is it that humans are no longer part of the “natural cycle” of the ecosystem? Our large brains have made us intelligent but we have forgotten that we are part of the landscape and ecosystem too.
Well said
Your narrative more of sugarcoating, too human centric endorsing hunting.
@@mclarenforever7798 ?? I am a human, and I endorse hunting 👍.
@@quesotaco5103 nothing great about that, get the definition of human understood first, before spinning your fabricated Sciences, endorsing cruelties. Don't try hard.
@@mclarenforever7798 what science did I fabricate? Humans being part of the ecosystem? Humans are one of many species living and interacting on this planet…that is a fact. I’m not saying there isn’t an argument to be had against hunting but neither you or this guy in the video have any good ones. This Earthling Ed guy literally just twisted facts into lies. The reality is that hunting currently generates the most money for North American conservation. If you have a better way to do it then I’m all ears but if you stopped all hunting and fishing tomorrow you would lose funding for almost all major conservation programs and not to mention funding for conserving and maintaining wildlife refuges, state, and national parks. Earthling Ed downplays the importance of the revenue generated from hunting and fishing sales for conservation. Both him and yourself should do more research. It’s not that hard.
All I've Ever wanted was Ed on Joe's podcast
I also doubt that he is just hunting and doesn't eat dairy products or doesn't eat meat when he is eating out
Great Show! This is going to be hard for Hunters because it really illustrates how absolutely wrong they are with any justification for it whatsoever. So there is clearly ZERO altruism in killing animals.
Lovely video as always! So inspiring and educational. Jon Stewart is an amazing individual as well.
Joe Rogan's logic about money from hunting being used for animal conservation is equivalent to allowing paedophiles to do what they do as long as they donate money to child sexual abuse charities!! It holds as much logic!
My wife is a fish and wildlife officer. She says that the money is is used for their salaries. Also for new boats, trucks, snow machines.
You need to take into consideration the managing of population sizes with hunting. If you let a population exceed its population cap (which is normally limited by natural predators but in some cases these are driven away or have a lesser presence), it will be ruinous to both that species due to disease pressure and other such things and to other lifeforms, vegetation and animals alike. Sticking up for biological diversity and a species in general is good but sometimes hunters need to step in to take over the role of the natural predator.
@@shawndarling5855 Forget earthling ed, get this fish on Joe's podcast!!!
@@guycusters3164 I deal with people like earthling Ed. I am in the hunting, fishing, gunsmithing, and taxidermy industry. So every once in a while I have tree huggers like Ed outside my businesses disrupting operations.
@@shawndarling5855 They like to paint a black and white picture but usually fail to take into consideration that killing animals is just a necessary evil. Until we arrive in a morally and ethically perfect state of reality, ofcourse.
I find it quite ironic that someone claims to hunt a bear bear with a bow and arrow to stop it from suffering
Joe Rogan would never have Ed Winters as a guest because Rogan does not want his lame arguments exposed for what they are.
Ed you are so on point. Your wisdom is beautiful. Thank you 💞
"Not to hurt our humble brethren is our first duty to them but to stop there is not enough. We have a higher mission -- to be of service to them whenever they require it." -- St. Francis of Assisi
"Compassion for animals is intimately associated with goodness of character, and it may be confidently asserted that he who is cruel to animals cannot be a good man."
Pietro, 🕊❕❕❕
Please be a guest on Joe Rogan
Joe: "it's wild out there man, animals do horrible things". Yes, if they only saw the raping, the child molesting, the organ trafficking, the forced labour, the genocide we did to each other, they would think of themselves as saints. Human beings playing God is so unbearable. The other day I had a heated conversation with a zoo keeper who pretended to do "conservation" by keeping giraffes in captivity. We are desensitized. I wish we can remember how perfect the earth was given to us and how humble we should be.
I think Joe should just say he loves hunting because he enjoy killing a deer and he doesn't love random animals. At least that is logically consistant
Your final argument about Joe being against factory farming yet not advocating for everyone to be able to hunt was brilliant!
I came here from Ed's talk with the hunter lady and I was sold on his views.
I was coming here to see if I should start my journey as a vegan.
Well I'm glad I did.
This dude wraps himself in articulation and it fools people into thinking he is actually really intelligent.
He contradicts himself at every corner against Joe.
I'll proceed to eat my meat thankyou very much!
Yes I know how that last sentence sounds 🤣
Thank you for pointing out the #1 thing that dismisses any hunter's point...the fact that they smile in pictures with their prey. THAT's the difference between cultures that truly hunt for food and cultures that hunt because they're simply sociopaths.
I think it's pretty natural for humans to use tools when hunting. It's what we've always done. A hunter-gatherer used a spear, but things progress.
Hunting is the ultimate life experience. I feel truly alive when hunting. I don't think that humans were every meant to live in cities
you’ve gone through so many videos commenting plain shit😂 do something productive with your time.
People formed cities for protection. So it kept us alive. It's nothing to complain about.
@@ltings5806 Don't be such a sour grape. I have 11 online income sources, I have done more with my life than you have with yours
joe: forEWarD FaCIng eYeS!!
me looking at a picture of a panda: hm
Lmao
You could do this with all kinds of herbivore arguments
Laura G for all intents and purposes pandas are carnivores
It IS morally consistent to say that all life should end if suffering is your primary concern.
Bloody brilliantly. Well spoken, clear, articulate, thought-provoking, interesting, and convincing. This is the best response to hunting I’ve ever seen. Phenomenally well done.
Well said 👍🏼
Mark Anthony isn’t it 😄 wish I had his ability
Yeah but it's pretty bias tbh. He's twisting joe's words and it's full of tastefully masked logical fallacies
@@maxwell.l.greene How so?
@@maxwell.l.greene I would be very interested in hearing the fallacies Ed made in this video.
Petition to get Ed on joe’s podcast
👇🏻
Likely to be awkward
I was about to comment this, yes!
@@MrConstantMalachi That's good. Progress has never been comfortable.
Joe isn't afraid of debates, however that isn't what his show is for. His podcasts are more about enjoying a casual, informative conversation, and debates only happen when they arise organically. I love Ed, but Joe's podcast doesn't seem the right platform for him as it would most likely turn into a heated debate (which just isn't what Joe's podcast is for).
S Lee I’m sure they both can keep their cool, Ed had a debate with infowars and manage to keep his composure
Never stop what you’re doing, Ed
😂😂😂😂
What is there to laugh about?@@adamtee3474
Judge: Why did you murder those people?
Joe Rogan: Well they were going to die anyways. So...
I think the point was that deer never die from old age. They get hunted and eaten by humans or other animals. Humans do die from old age.
@@OreoVII No one ever dies from old age. Older people mostly die from diseases.
@@Maidaseu Bro, don't be "that guy". You're splitting hair to create an argument that doesn't even matter.
You know damned well the point was that people usually die from age related shit, and deer die from being viciously murdered by another animal. You know damned well that was the point
@@OreoVII Yes they do, not often but deer do die from old age too and many humans do not die of old age. They die from preventable diseases, accidents, etc. All these are prior to old age.
@@Maidaseu Well, if one dies from old age that happens. Heart disease is different, it is a diseases that takes us before their time. Non-vegans beware!
Hunting is not a sport. In a sport, both sides should know they're in the game.
-Paul Rodriguez
and both sides consent to participate
Karma will play sports with joe
and both sides have an equal chance of winning
The sides are two hunters, the animals arent considered a participant and arent considered sadly
game animals are definitely well aware and well equipped to deal with predators you dunce. Who the hell is paul rodriguez anyway?
Earthling Ed needs to get on Joe Rogans podcast, ASAP.
TH-cam: Dominion 2018
watchdominion.com
I have a feeling it would be pointless. Rogan has his head so far up his ass he would just sound so unintelligent having a conversation with someone as well spoken as Ed. Ed would wipe the floor with him.
@@Kn1ves_0ut I thought the same thing... You probably right. But maybe some of the viewers will see the truth!
@@Kn1ves_0ut this feels really arrogant man, i dont know how much youve watched Joes podcast. But the statement he has his head up his ass i kind of wrong fam. He usually has a open mind. And that it would be point less because hes not as "well spoken" is just dumb, hes not Ben Shapiro, his podcast is about having a good conversation
It wouldn’t be pointless for the millions who watch his podcast and recognize how Joes arguments sounds so illogical.
@Matt Lyle I can't fathom how you can watch this video and come to the conclusion that Ed would be "schooled".
Ultimately this video is about as close to Joe's podcast as he will ever get unfortunately. Joe would never allow someone like Ed on his podcast. Cognitive dissonance is a strong thing, with Joe, and apparently you as well.
I see that Joe does have some interest in animal ethics. I would LOVE to see a podcast with the both of you!
Not those kinds of ethics.
I do t think joe would let him speak
Joe will agree with the last thing that he heard. He is a complete moron. If you beat him at a debate he will prolly have forgotten about it the next week.
Nah he just rationalizes his point for killing em.
Ha! As if that's gonna go down well! 😂😂😂
Ed, you are a Saint. You are relentless and stay calm in the presence of idiocy. I have to take frequent periods away from humans. Been against animal consumption over 40 years. Sometimes, I feel guilty for not engaging hunters more often...but you can't have a debate with someone who doesn't have the ability to understand CHOICES
I don’t have to “take time” away from humans ..... they just get tired of me talking about this and give me space automatically, lolz.
Spoken like a true cult member.
@EVIL'S DIRTY LITTLE SISTER yeah. The cult members are the ones who have compassion and empathy for others. Really bright, you are. Kinda a case in point situation here, eh?
Vegan Jesus.
I would absolutely LOVE Ed to go on Joe's show and blast him into another dimension, please this has to happen!! 🌿🌱💪👏
I've challenged Ed but believe he's is too afraid to debate me about the dangers vegans pose to themselves and all of society. He seems to prefer to cherry pick famous people's arguments, rather than be exposed by a nobody like myself. However if you or anyone would like to debate me on this topic, please let me know and we can set up a zoom call or something. It could make for great educational purposes.🖐🙂
I hope Joe Rogan watches this.
Fools would never listen to their superiors and change their mind
@@alicia-hd2cs Superiors!?! 😂😂😂
Another vegan smug! Your sense of false moral highground is almost as ridiculous as vegans themselves...
@@vojtechotava1417 please state why
@@alicia-hd2cs I simply can not understand, why somebody should not enjoy his hunt.
It is not only about stalking and killing a prey, it is about a movement in the forest, smell of the fresh air, folowing a road of our ancestors.
It is a highly spiritual experience, yet you are too stuborn to admit that you simply do not get it. I would respect you guys much more if you would just say, exactly like Russell Brand on JRE the other day: "I do not know everything."
This aversion towards hunting is like a rejection of all our history. And I will not participate on this.
Everything you do is just: Killing animals bad. Killing animals bad....
It starts to be really annoying.
@@alicia-hd2cs I do this too. We have a beatiful nature. Hunt is only one part of conection with nature.
You are amazing Ed. Love from the Netherlands 🇳🇱🇳🇱🇳🇱 ( I'm 46, been vegan since I was 6. So 40 years now. And look at me all alive and shit ) ❤
That's great Cat! 40 years for me too. Would you be interested in doing a video interview for a series on long time vegans?
@@Wearephuct-O you are seriously the first person I ever talk to that is vegan as long as me. I like your profile pic. That tells me we think the same about very important things going on now. Very good. 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻 NEVER EVER TAKE THAT VACCIN.
Can you tell me more about that video series? :)
@@Wearephuct-O Do it! Do it! Do it!
But where do you get your protein? 😉🌱
stop lying.. judging from you picture, you are anywherr between 25-30!!
This is the most intelligent anti-hunting argument I've ever seen.
Humans are natural predators, always have been. Unless that is humans are not natural to the environment. In the context of hunting, there are restrictions on how much you can kill. This makes Ed's first point null.
@@doctorscientist3991 we aren't predators, Humans are oportunistic animals, we would eat whatever we could find, it just happenned that we learned a way to effectively kill other beings, our bodys didn't evolve to exclusively hunt like lions or wolfs, if we did we wouldn't have any problem eating a live rat right now, or killing a pig with our own teeth
I Know it can be annoying, all those vegans talking "non sense"... but try it out man, we weren't made for causing so much suffering, we are beings of love, and we should take care of this world and our earth brothers with our inteligence, thank you for reading and i hope you have a great day
@@gabrielrosa1112 Our long violent history really paints a different picture. Our natural inclination is to take care of our own and exploit those who are not, just like any other predator. Maybe we are trying to unlearn this, but as you can see fighting against nature really hasn't been good for the world.
overpopulation, tech/industrial advancement etc. Now I'm not being negative, but we need to see things for what they are.
I was vegan for 5 years, bought into it heavily, tracked nutrition and gripped the ideology with white knuckles. It brought me nothing but suffering in the end. At the end of the day it was me or veganism, one of us was losing.
@@doctorscientist3991 violence and territory defense isn't a predator trait, far from that, these instincts are found in pratically all of the animal kingdom.
Something that we do have is a trait that only we can express, we are the only animals who are able to care about other species... we might hurt them, but we are still learning how to use this power, one day i believe we will have a beneficial symbiotic relationship with every living being on this planet, we have the potential for that :)
I'm sorry that you had a bad experience with veganism, i hope maybe one day you can get back to it in a healthier way :)
@@gabrielrosa1112 Predator: 1.
an animal that naturally preys on others.
You seem to be purposefully forgetting things to fit your worldview. Territory defence is a byproduct of invasion by other humans. Poaching, slavery..
Also, the ability to care for species other than there own has been documented in several species, it obvious now your just speaking outta your ass.
If you happen to come across a way of eating healthier than a vegan wholefoods diet tracked on chronometer, let me know. As far as I can tell that is whats preached as the gold standard. As of now adding in well sourced animal products was almost in instant fix, have literally never felt better. Funny that.
What really cringes me out about hunters is after they have killed their target they sit by the animal and go on and on what a beautiful animal it is. Creepy af.
Who TF hangs heads of dead animals they've killed on their WALL? Oh, that's right, hunters do. Creepy "trophies"
They’re really saying there catching hunting skills are beautiful,an extension of themselves
They're something sexual about it, it seems to me. I hope I'm wrong.
Webtex Web Design There's definitely some "I'm the alpha and on top of the food chain" bs going on and they get some form of thrill out of it. Some people also find hunters attractive. Like there are Instagram pages of "hot conservative girls" who show off guns/rifles and the game they killed with them. So for some hunters, it is sexual. Not all, but some. Big yikes.
Compared to vegans who enslaved animals, kill animals that try to eat their vegetables, fill the planet with chemicals.....
Vegans aren't supposed to kill sentient beings but Ed just straight up murdered Joe Rogan
It was humane slaughter, so it's okay
Tom If only......😂
Yes Ed is my fav Vegan TH-camr!
I don't know if I'd call Joe Rogan sentient
Great comments here. Good job, Ed
Great response Ed.
You’ve got good arguments there. I was pro-hunting because of Joe Rogan. You’ve changed my mind!
How did this change ur mind?
@@TigranHakobyan-jh8ue Because its brilliant? Ethical? On point?
@@bobmenat3361 what a tosser
I’m sorry you were lied to, John. Thank you for making the switch. Women + animals + the world appreciate you!!
@@tonystone3397 because he actually educated himself, instead of insulting someone
Is that guilt of truth, making you feel threatened by any chance?
Time to learn some truth, turn off the main stream lying media and educate yourself
Plant based diets are the best for everyone and everything
Dude this has to be best debunking of thr hunting argument I've seen on youtube yet. I hope you know the difference you are making Ed. Keep up the great work!! GO VEGAN!😀👍
Hunting is the best thing that can happen to an ecosystem. Thanks to hunting regulations, natural territories are being preserved from deforestation and from the construction industry. It´s because of the money that hunters pay, those lands are being preserved.
@@readysoldier6799 maybe you should watch the video....
@@readysoldier6799 You didn't hear a damn thing he said did you? Pull your head out.
Ready Soldier Ummm... watch the video.
@@readysoldier6799 Well, another special person who doesn't watch the content, but chooses to show how stupid they can be. You lose. Try again.
I'm so impressed by how educated, well spoken, smart and compassionate Earthling Ed is.
He sounds like a complete moron actually and he only appeals to the most gullible people.
Yea but unfortunately his education is wrong
Hes calculated and conniving and has no education in animal ag whatsoever. Hes an amateur film maker by education.
@@evilsbrowndog4068 He's doing great things in the world 😀, making a difference. What are you doing?
@@AndreaAvila78 enjoying meat and dairy as i see fit along with 8 billion others.
I just absolutely love your work. I have been vegan going on 5 years but was raised by adopted family, who are back woods hunters, so I have struggled to stand my point. I've almost let them wear me down back into eating meat but thanks to you, I have really been able to re-establish my view point on my ethics. much appreciated
There's a huge difference between people who live in the bush and hunt and people who live in the city who think meat comes from cellophane covered packages.
It's hard to argue that these people don't live much closer to the hunter gatherers that we used to be.
You need to go on the Joe Rogan podcast.
agreed, but with another expert.
Here is a petition! Who knows if Joe will acknowledge it but we can at least try! 🤞www.change.org/p/23510694/share_for_starters?just_created=true&tag_selected=entertainment
hes too girly
@@noobstarr4798 You're so manly, how do you do it.
@@christianalmli9085 by not being like you
NEVER STOP BEING A VOICE FOR THE ANIMALS AND OUR PLANET! MUCH LOVE FROM CALI.
❤️💪👏🌱🌿🌎😘🇬🇧
@@angelagallagher8136 🥓🥓🥓🥓🍔🍔🍔🍔🍔🥓🥓🥓
@@Bray3k 🖕🖕🏻🖕🏼🖕🏽🖕🏾🖕🏿
@@user-oe4wv6kv4r shut up
You vegans think you can take away meat with a snap of a finger lol
Ed strikes a nice balance as a spokesperson for veganism. He sticks to his guns and he always combats ignorance but he doesn't do so in an overly aggressive way and so he's still appealing to neutral people and is good at winning them over and not pushing them away.
Not like a lot of vegans then, unfortunately
As a vegetarian I'm disappointed that anyone takes this guy seriously. in an actual debate when he's not ranting into a camera he would be destroyed.
@@acush7327 I guess you haven't seen any of the numerous videos where he debates people??
@@acush7327 Why? What do you have against him?
agreed mate
THIS IS WHAT WE’VE BEEN WAITING FOR
As a child, I’d go along as an observer of the hunt with my dad. I would make noise and scare away the deer before he could shoot them. 😂
However, I still remember the ones he got and seeing them get butchered in front of me🙁
🕊❕❕❕
Watching animals get killed and butchered as a child is what made me go vegan as an adult. I wasn't allowed to make that choice as a child.
So If an elk can feed Joe's Rogan for a year, ("one animal's death equals a year of my meals"), I guess he hunts once a year only, Right?
Right 😏
He'd also starve as there is no way enough calories in the body of 1 elk to feed him and his family for a year...right 🤔
Uh huh. And then he'd also have to advocate, hard, against hunting because he knows it's mathematically impossible for everybody to live like that without eradicating all other life on earth.
Isabelle Zablocki he talks about eating donuts, fast food, street tacos, steaks from steakhouses, etc. Joe is virtue signaling and lying
good thing there are 8 billion moose wandering about :3
Yeah, and I wonder...Did he eat the bear?
Wow, I was confused about the arguments for hunting since becoming vegetarian and now vegan, but this helped me so much, now I am better prepared to have discussions on the topic with non vegans. Thank you!!!
I've never seen such a brilliant and intelligent speaker and thinker like Ed, he can make you look like a fool if you believe in something that's toxic and against nature
I remember my own thought process when I made the decision to move to a vegan lifestyle. I had just sworn off factory farm derived products and I was still deciding if hunting or fishing my own meats was still on the table. I went back and forth with various arguments but kept landing on 2 questions that would not move.
1. Do I need to consume meat or fish to survive?
No, there are vegans everywhere these days and have been around for years and they're both strong and healthy, just like anyone else.
2. Should I be a part of the life and death of an animal when I lead an existence far removed and insulated from the natural world where my own life is almost never at stake (or at the very least almost never under threat of being ended by a wild animal)?
This was a question I had to answer for myself and I didn't like the idea of going out into the wild to go kill things to eat, especially given how I didn't need to. (so no, duh)
Given those 2 answers, it was then the only logical conclusion that I attempt to embrace a vegan lifestyle.
That day was about 2 months ago as of this moment and I feel like changing my diet and lifestyle has been a positive experience in almost every aspect. I feel healthier now than I have in years and I hope to stick with this change for the long run.
We now hunt and shoot wild animals with a DSLR camera and telephoto lens. Our trophies are awesome photos. Leave no trace. 👍
Do you mind if I share this comment with some people?
@@uselessgarbagehandler go for it, I hope it helps
Yesssss man!! Awesome connection and congrats!
Thanks for choosing compassion and sharing your story!
Joe has meat sponsors. Don’t think he doesn’t get everything Earthling Ed is saying. Joe is protecting his money.
He doesn't need to protect anything, he just uses some of his arguments because he can't be bothered just saying fuck off with your morals.
Because no one has the right to dictate that shit when it comes to animals, unless they are tortured.
Which we have seen being introduced over the last couple of decades or so.
Hunting is done as always, just newer weapons have been introduced.
Vegans have a hard time grasping this because you live in the bubble of what you have been told from a one dimensional view.
And also, if you think any differently, well, you are not vegan.
@marcus24000
Mono crops and a deficient diet are not the future, wake up!!
Exactly, isn't that why it's so hard to change people? Animal industry has paid them off? Look at school cafeterías or ag gag laws to prevent filming in slaughter houses and farms.
@@marcusserrao
What, are you reading from blogs from 2010. That's the same shit I used to drivel. 🤣🤣🤣 Get up to speed.
Disagree. I do not like these arguments by Ed, and by Joe. They are both bad arguments.
BUT this one is even worse.
Joe has "F**k You" money.
Joe regularly tells people to "F**k You".
Good lord I am so done with eating animals.
Me too sister
I'm not
@Jacquelyn Hammerton. Good!!!!Do it!!!!The animals need you!!!!
me too sis
I'm so happy for you! :)
You opened my eyes man. Excellent and true points...and I'm not even a vegetarian. Trapping is to me even more sinister....and I doubt Joe has done a tour of a slaughterhouse...that's way more destructive than what happens in the wild.
I'm not a vegan, or even a vegetarian, I have even hunted before. I found this interesting and thought provoking. Nothing Joe Rogan has ever said has made me say that. Well done.
You should go vegan for climate, enviromental and ethical reasons :)
I'm very impressed with your open minded willingness to even watch this video, good on you mate!!... perhaps as you continue to explore your own values and the current state of our world, you'll find yourself moving over to the plant based diet world... keep curious :)
@@biosphere1053 so I shouldn’t eat meat?
@@Cameron_Greaves or buy diary products (if you value vegan principles)
@@biosphere1053 dairy*
Joe Rogan is the gatekeeper for meatbros
Atkinsdotal Ketovores
real gatekeeper by having so many people on that he disagrees with.
yeah he is !!
Inviting Ed to the podcast is like being hunted by a vegan
Ed will slaughter Joe Rogan...humanely of course
An Apex Vegan prEDator
:)
yeah, I'd love to watch that
Sounds nice compare to being hunted by some carnivoure.
@@Changeling9au well that pun
You state the obvious so well as usual. There really is no excuse for hunting
Except there is. Always has, always will.
I will soon get a hunting card, nothing will not make it non-justieable as hunting is the same as a bear or a lion hunting.
I'm vegan and my dad is a hunter. In a couple of days we'll be in a car together for eight hours. Wish me luck! And thank you for all the good arguments!
be prepared for cognitive dissonance
@@xb5741 Hunting is the only thing that stands between an ecosystem and the construction industry.
Would be interesting if you played this video back to him.
Good luck!
Shifting perspectives only takes a second, even if he disagrees. It's about planting a seed 🌱🧡
@@musicworship4520 gross
I wish deerwatching was more common. It's beautiful when they're unafraid.
It’s very common where I live. We see and watch deer everyday in our backyards 🙂
They're always afraid
They don't even know they are being hunted untill the last moment when the gun goes off and its already hit and dying
@@ATD1990 Yep, that's what I told the judge after I shot those kids in their sleep. They literally didn't know what hit them. No suffering. That's supposed to negate the loss of life. But for some unimaginable reason, they didn't see it that way. Apparently somebody's life itself has value or something. Ridiculous. Please explain your view, maybe it'll help me build my case. If you kill them quickly and painlessly, it's practically the same as kissing them on the forehead. It's a mercy. Am I wrong?
@@wolfafterdark human beings and animals are two different things. Its by law murder for killing an innocent human. Its not murder when killing an animal for food and other uses. Just because you don't like something dosent mean its wrong.