I was at night 2, I quite deliberately decided not to photograph or video any of the performance, I wanted to go back to how it was when I saw so many bands back in the 70's and 80's, thanks for posting this.
I've got floor seats for Madison Square Gardens and I'm thinking about videoing very sparingly or not at all to be honest. There are a ton of people with their phones out for most of the show and I just want to enjoy it without any distractions.
David Gilmour um velhote de 78 anos!? Que coisa mais estúpida, mais absurda. Que falta de respeito, de noção, chamar o David Guilmour de velhote. Só porque ele tem 78 tem que chamá-lo por um nome depreciativo? Ele merece mais respeito.
@@Robsheph hey Rob - from this position, just behind the sound desk, it was super tight, crisp and clear… really top notch quality but the venue has always delivered at any past shows I’ve seen there
This was probably his best vocal performance of this tour but that second solo was not good at all notes that were way off pitch tone was not good and the improvisation was bad
Quanta gente barulhenta nesse show do David Gilmour. É gente berrando, é gente gritando, é gente uivando, furante a música. Quer dizer que quem quer ir a um show como esse, e o único objetivo é ver e ouvir o David e sua banda tocando e cantando as músicas, e ouvir cada detalhe de cada instrumento em cada música, não pode por causa da barulheira da maioria que não está nem aí pra quem quer ver e ouvir. E quem faz esse tipo de coisa, não gosta realmente de Pink Floyd, e de David Gilmour. Pois o Som de Pink Floyd, de David Gilmour, é algo muito mais sério do que apenas ver e ouvir e fazer barulho. Quem ama apenas curte, a cada acorde, a cada nota, a cada harmonia, cada melodia, a cada ritmo, a cada interpretação em canto.
Knowing how much Gilmour and Roger Waters hate (detest?) each other, it's weird to hear Gilmour playing this song, considering Waters wrote the lyrics. I would think it would be uncomfortable for Gilmour to sing those words, knowing they were written by this guy you utterly can't stand. I suppose the song is just something the audience demands, because it's such a huge hit, so it's sort of out of Gilmour's control. Gotta give the crowd what they want, right?! He plays it with real feeling and passion, though, so you've got to give him credit for that. 👍
lol he wrote the music his demo with words Roger changed the words Hence both on copyright credit & it's the guitar solo people want. Has no problem singing loads of Rogers lyrics Time WYWH Breathe & loads more on previous tours.
@@Sean_1970-ED Right, but nowadays, Gilmour and Waters are bitter, bitter enemies. Holy smokes, do they ever despise one another. And lyrics are so personal that I would just think Gilmour would want nothing to do with singing material Waters wrote. I would think it would make Gilmour sick to his stomach. But apparently I'm wrong in this way of thinking. 😃
@@Jim_L Don't think you are wrong just think David & Rick probably regard making the music is most important & David is in record saying when he had to sing Brain Damage / Eclipse on Division Bell tour it was a privilege to sing the lyrics to Dark Side & Roger wrote every lyric he thanks Waters on the live Pulse concert.However he does state he wouldn't touch the final cut & majority of the wall so definitely not keen on those lyrics! I always thought lyrics were important but it was harder to write the music but I don't know to be honest. 🍀✌️👍
@@Sean_1970-ED There was a period -- post Roger Water's era Pink Floyd -- where Gilmour and Waters were quite civil toward one another. Heck, when Waters was doing The Wall tour, he asked Gilmour to play "Comfortably Numb," which Gilmour accepted (you can find it on TH-cam -- it's pretty freakin' amazing). Later, Gilmour then asked Waters to join him in a song or two for a charity benefit Gilmour was a part of, and Waters, too, accepted (this, as well, you can find on TH-cam). But ever since Waters has started speaking out for the rights of Palestinians and condemning Israel, oh, brother -- the sparks between Gilmour and Waters has hit an all-time high! In addition, Gilmour has forbidden Waters to be a part of any Pink Floyd business stuff, which, of course, has upset Waters like there's no tomorrow. It's a sad state of affairs, but it is what it is. Such beautiful music the two once created together; it breaks my heart that it has come to this. 😥
@@Jim_L I was at the 02 that night & the body language wasn't great to be honest & Nick Mason was at the 02 but never played I found that strange he did bang a tambourine for outside the wall! The TH-cam videos the rehearsal I agree seemed ok but I heard David said he loved standing playing that solo & took the opportunity to play Cnumb again on the wall! Because Roger played on David's Palestine charity David agreed to perform at 02 the charity concert on TH-cam. Think they could tolerate each other for a day but even David's lapse Dbell lyrics were written by others particularly Polly on Dbell.. When you think about it they only worked together 17 years out of nearly 60 years A lot of wasted time particularly David as Roger has done more tours etc .🍀✌️👍
I was at night 2, I quite deliberately decided not to photograph or video any of the performance, I wanted to go back to how it was when I saw so many bands back in the 70's and 80's, thanks for posting this.
@@RushfanUK yes - I tried as much as I could to just enjoy the whole show with only recording this last track to keep.
Did the same, we went on the penultimate night on the Monday, we just watched the show and like many others just recorded Comfortably numb.
I was on night 2 too. It was great, almost had a heart attack when he left without playing Comfortably Numb 😂
I've got floor seats for Madison Square Gardens and I'm thinking about videoing very sparingly or not at all to be honest. There are a ton of people with their phones out for most of the show and I just want to enjoy it without any distractions.
@@JasonGlisson Memories are made with eyes and ears focussed on the stage, not on a phone screen.
I would imagine Romany Gilmour was on that stage thinking I’ve got just about the coolest Dad on the Planet.
78 now have seen Davigd Gilmour at the Royal albert Hall last time he played,so need to see him again,so emotional seeing this .
His voice has got stronger during the tour, always the best guitarist of course!
Yes and the guitar parts too
2 more weeks and I'll be seen The grandmaster at Hollywood Bowl. Cannot wait 🙏
Truly epic! Gilmore’s greatest gift!
I can’t wait for the live recordings to come out
Not bad for a 78 year old geezer. What a solo.
Incredible right? He’s a year older than my own dad and I just watched in admiration of his skill and talent - it’s inspiring to see
David Gilmour um velhote de 78 anos!? Que coisa mais estúpida, mais absurda. Que falta de respeito, de noção, chamar o David Guilmour de velhote. Só porque ele tem 78 tem que chamá-lo por um nome depreciativo? Ele merece mais respeito.
Heading to Madison Square Garden to see this show on Nov. 9. So stoked!
She’s just loving this moment with her dad
I find it annoying and distracting to be honest, it's not about her.
A few more weeks and it will be my turn in Madison Square Gardens. Cant wait!
@@jonathandempsey6300 that’s gonna be amazing - I love seeing artists at MSG - it’s also a special place
I’ll be there. Also was at RAH.
You and me both. Nov 4 cannot come quick enough.
Looking forward to MSG Nov. 10th!!!
How many gigs is he doing at MSG?
Absolutely Marvelous ❤
We were there on Saturday 12th Oct’.
What a night. Wonderful.
🎶🎸❤️🎸🎶
Rock on!
The Master at work!
Isn’t he just
OMG. Tears.
I was there on night 1, but up in the Rausing Circle above the lasers - they look so much better from below! It still sounded fantastic though😀
3:30 - can I just mention how BRIGHT these lights were. I was at the show on the 9th and my eyes still hurt!
Thank You for sharing. Woaw, what a great solo , the best ever….
Glad you enjoyed it!
Just pure genius
Rock out, Romany!
I was there 🎸👌🏼
Nice video. Great job recording. One wonders if this will David's last performance at this great and historic venue.
Merci beaucoup 🎼⭐️🤩💙
Ce groupe a été créé pour nous merveilleux!!
I grew up with pink floyd❤
Romany is headbanging✌️😎👌😉
Love seeing his daughter jamming to this
So ready for November 5th at Madison Square Garden!!!!
Thank you for this!
Playing some of the right notes. Not bad for 78 but he ain't what he used to be. Still great.
great solo
Great video thanks for putting it out. I think I was pretty close to you K Row 3 Seat 53
No way! Yes we were K, row 10 seats 82&83
@@Kuffdam How was sound quality?
@@Robsheph hey Rob - from this position, just behind the sound desk, it was super tight, crisp and clear… really top notch quality but the venue has always delivered at any past shows I’ve seen there
GOAT
👍❤❤❤❤❤❤👍👍👍❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Semplicemente magnifico
Absolutely
God is back. And we are not disappointed
Oh boy, soooo wonderful to listen to this brilliant man
He fkd up the solo around 7 minutes.
nothing beats the pompei version!
This was probably his best vocal performance of this tour but that second solo was not good at all notes that were way off pitch tone was not good and the improvisation was bad
agree!
Brilliant. Cheers.
Fuck the ads
Quanta gente barulhenta nesse show do David Gilmour. É gente berrando, é gente gritando, é gente uivando, furante a música. Quer dizer que quem quer ir a um show como esse, e o único objetivo é ver e ouvir o David e sua banda tocando e cantando as músicas, e ouvir cada detalhe de cada instrumento em cada música, não pode por causa da barulheira da maioria que não está nem aí pra quem quer ver e ouvir. E quem faz esse tipo de coisa, não gosta realmente de Pink Floyd, e de David Gilmour. Pois o Som de Pink Floyd, de David Gilmour, é algo muito mais sério do que apenas ver e ouvir e fazer barulho. Quem ama apenas curte, a cada acorde, a cada nota, a cada harmonia, cada melodia, a cada ritmo, a cada interpretação em canto.
Knowing how much Gilmour and Roger Waters hate (detest?) each other, it's weird to hear Gilmour playing this song, considering Waters wrote the lyrics. I would think it would be uncomfortable for Gilmour to sing those words, knowing they were written by this guy you utterly can't stand. I suppose the song is just something the audience demands, because it's such a huge hit, so it's sort of out of Gilmour's control. Gotta give the crowd what they want, right?! He plays it with real feeling and passion, though, so you've got to give him credit for that. 👍
lol he wrote the music his demo with words Roger changed the words Hence both on copyright credit & it's the guitar solo people want. Has no problem singing loads of Rogers lyrics Time WYWH Breathe & loads more on previous tours.
@@Sean_1970-ED Right, but nowadays, Gilmour and Waters are bitter, bitter enemies. Holy smokes, do they ever despise one another. And lyrics are so personal that I would just think Gilmour would want nothing to do with singing material Waters wrote. I would think it would make Gilmour sick to his stomach. But apparently I'm wrong in this way of thinking. 😃
@@Jim_L Don't think you are wrong just think David & Rick probably regard making the music is most important & David is in record saying when he had to sing Brain Damage / Eclipse on Division Bell tour it was a privilege to sing the lyrics to Dark Side & Roger wrote every lyric he thanks Waters on the live Pulse concert.However he does state he wouldn't touch the final cut & majority of the wall so definitely not keen on those lyrics! I always thought lyrics were important but it was harder to write the music but I don't know to be honest. 🍀✌️👍
@@Sean_1970-ED There was a period -- post Roger Water's era Pink Floyd -- where Gilmour and Waters were quite civil toward one another. Heck, when Waters was doing The Wall tour, he asked Gilmour to play "Comfortably Numb," which Gilmour accepted (you can find it on TH-cam -- it's pretty freakin' amazing). Later, Gilmour then asked Waters to join him in a song or two for a charity benefit Gilmour was a part of, and Waters, too, accepted (this, as well, you can find on TH-cam).
But ever since Waters has started speaking out for the rights of Palestinians and condemning Israel, oh, brother -- the sparks between Gilmour and Waters has hit an all-time high! In addition, Gilmour has forbidden Waters to be a part of any Pink Floyd business stuff, which, of course, has upset Waters like there's no tomorrow.
It's a sad state of affairs, but it is what it is. Such beautiful music the two once created together; it breaks my heart that it has come to this. 😥
@@Jim_L I was at the 02 that night & the body language wasn't great to be honest & Nick Mason was at the 02 but never played I found that strange he did bang a tambourine for outside the wall! The TH-cam videos the rehearsal I agree seemed ok but I heard David said he loved standing playing that solo & took the opportunity to play Cnumb again on the wall! Because Roger played on David's Palestine charity David agreed to perform at 02 the charity concert on TH-cam. Think they could tolerate each other for a day but even David's lapse Dbell lyrics were written by others particularly Polly on Dbell.. When you think about it they only worked together 17 years out of nearly 60 years A lot of wasted time particularly David as Roger has done more tours etc .🍀✌️👍